Blood Rage: Valhalla & Road to Helheim - TCbH Review
Transcript
More than 10 years ago, a former RateMyMini website turned aspiring publisher, CoolMiniOrNot, released Blood Rage, a seminal entry in the hybrid scene. Editor Jack just hopping in here to say that it was 10 years ago this month, October 2016, where we launched the initial iteration of the Cardboard Herald review blog with a review of Blood Rage. Thanks for being along for the ride. Taking Eurogame design principles and applying them, adapting them for more American-style conflict and themes. From there, CoolMiniOrNot underwent foreign buyouts, name changes, massive Kickstarters, even employing Blood Rage designer Eric M. Lang as director of game design for a time. But, the last several years have been pretty rugged for old CMON, as they were now known, where by most accounts, they were robbing Peter to pay Paul in a sort of Cardbordean Ponzi scheme where they were taking the profits of one crowdfunding campaign to pay for the production of the game promised in the prior, leading to the sale of many of their properties, including Lang's mythic trilogy of Blood Rage, Rising Sun, and Ankh to Tycoon Games, aka Starling Games, aka Tabletop Tycoon, aka Game Salute, which is no stranger to controversy, either. But, part of this deal is that Blood Rage, my old bay spicy Vikings here, in addition to being available once again through this new publisher, also gets a direct
sequel, which is Blood Rage: Valhalla, which brings us to today. So, let's take a look at this new game and see really what it is and how it stands up to one of my favorite combative area control games of all time. In simple terms, Valhalla, like the original, is a game where players summon and spread Vikings and various mythological creatures throughout a board, initiating combat to claim the spoils of locations, and hopefully gain glory, aka points, through a myriad of effects. With a conclusive impact to a specific region at the end of each round, where surviving warriors are also shepherded to their glorious death for points. But, here's where the familiarity starts to split. That end of round region, well, instead of blowing up due to Ragnarok, here at the beginning of the round, a new Norse god parks themselves, offering a special effect if claimed through a standard conflict, but only the player with the most remaining figures are spirited to the feasting halls of Valhalla for points. And instead of one region each round, the gods stay, granting their contestable boons and ultimate judgment.
So, by the final round, you're dealing with three gods and their three judgments on the board. And how do you interact with the game? Well, it's still your standard action, spending rage, augmented by, or rather greatly influenced by cards drafted at the beginning of each round, but rather than being stock sets of round one, two, and three cards, they're now defined by combining sets from each of the randomly chosen gods arriving this game, along with shuffling in random monsters, essentially the hero units based on player count. This alone is the biggest, cleverest, and coolest change of this whole ordeal that affects things at a structural level. And at first, I was pretty skeptical, a big part of the original Blood Rage was the arc, where during the first era, you'd get cards that you'd look at and you go like, "This is okay, I guess." But, then by era three, you're drafting cards that WERE LIKE, "HOLY MOLY, THIS changes everything." So, how do you still preserve this sort of arc without having dedicated era cards?
Well, this game does a couple things. First off, you have all the cards that are made up of specific gods based off of which gods are going to arrive in the game. And because of that, because they all have their themes and little sub strategies, you can see them weave together and build upon one another as you get more and more cards for interesting and creative little combos. One card on its own isn't that much, but as you lean into specific strategies, you start seeing cumulative effects. From Heimdall's heavy interaction with quest to Thor's brutal combat efficiency, which all of this is cool on its own and it codifies concepts of the OG, but also god agnostic monster units, once paid for as an upgrade onto your clan sheet, are now free to put in play.
Not just the first time, but also every subsequent summon even after they die, but are released back to your pool. So, you really get this sense of investment and snowballing catastrophe that each player is building to. But, it goes beyond that, too. There is some regulation to keep the greater flexibility in check that I really like here. In the OG, each region could only have so many units, though if you declared a pillage, players in adjacent regions could one by one fill up vacant slots to their hearts' content. Here, there's no regional limit, but when a region is contested, all players, including the one calling the contest, can only send in one unit. Similarly, monsters feel vastly more interesting.
With many monsters and cards in general scaling their effects based on round, but gone are the days of a full surprise attack. Playing a monster to your upgrade sheet is an action, your full turn, and the monster doesn't automatically come out. That'd be a summon action on a future turn, allowing players to prepare and anticipate, which in turn makes the really dynamic abilities feel more fair. Heck, even quests now temporarily take up a spot on your player board. An interesting move that I'm certain is primarily to balance out the fact that your upgrades are now more flexible in general.
No more specific slots for given types, just limited by the overall space or upgrades, and of course how much room you want to keep open for questing. On the whole, a few games in, I'm really pleased with Valhalla. It feels more considered, more deliberate. For the most part, abilities are generally more dynamic, and the versatility and variability of the different gods that could be implemented in a game really adds an interesting layer to the whole thing. Bolstered by the Road to Helheim expansion, which adds a bunch more gods and monsters, and for the most part is an easy automatic recommend. If you like one, you'll probably like the other. But one thing I have to emphasize though, is that this is not just a straight upgrade. The original had a poppy, bloodthirsty, devil-may-care attitude.
Your troops were slinging all over the board, and often you could capitalize on death as much as victory in battle. Valhalla is just a little bit more reserved, calculated. There are still some battle tricks that you can do, and a handful of gods that lean into death, like Hel, who has a tribute mechanic on her cards. When your dudes die, you can discard a card to activate all your tribute rewards on upgrades. But it is less reckless than the original, and with the addition of gods, so too increases the complexity. Not to mention that there's going to be more to learn with every combo of gods that you try. Player count and production are a consideration here, too. With the former being that this is three to five players, as opposed to the original's two to four, though expandable beyond that. Some diehards would say two-player Blood Rage wasn't that good, but honestly, I always thought it made for an interesting duel. But again, the more methodical play here makes sense that it wouldn't flow as good at two.
Production, well, it looks fantastic, but some people are going to hate the colored minis for players. Personally, I like them as a non-painter. And the paper materials from the box to the cards feels distinctly thinner to me than the original Bloodrage production. I can't speak to the new Tycoon version of Bloodrage proper, but at least in Valhalla, I feel like some pennies were pinched to put as much towards the minis as could be. Bloodrage Valhalla is, well, it's just great. For me, I think it it really captures my favorite moments, the concepts, and the oeuvre of the original, while still addressing some things, smoothing some things out, introducing others, and making for a stronger game. It feels complex, but not necessarily complicated, and it earns the complexity it does have by smoothing out as much as it can in the periphery.
Now, the lack of a two-player mode is a genuine drawback for me because a substantial amount of my gaming is done with my wife, and a good brawly two-player game is always in high demand, but I feel like the tradeoffs here are pretty substantial. If I have one concern, it's that with so many monsters and so many gods, it's easy to imagine that in 10, 20, 30 plays in, or hundreds or thousands of plays by the community, certain combinations of gods, certain monsters could really prove dominant. That said, how the game is designed around drafting and communal involvement and interaction with the gods, and not to mention that pretty much no unit in this game is unassailable, I think that it sets itself up pretty well for self-balancing and combo-tastic exploitation feels really rewarding and fun [snorts] rather than frustrating. Now, I'm not ready to pitch my beloved just yet. I am the type of guy where I need things to simmer. I need to ruminate on this. I need to get on the backside of those 10 to 20 plays to really see how this bears out, but my instinct is that if push came to shove and I could only keep one of these, Valhalla would win out and prove to be my spicier Vikings. That's our review, but let me know, what is your favorite sequel to a game and did it
eclipse the original? Put it in the comments below and as always, thanks for watching. Thanks for supporting. Thanks for doing all the things that help us grow. Your likes, comments, subscribes, your checking out our Patreon and of course sharing these videos across the interwebs do a tremendous amount to help support us. But above all else, thanks for being such a great community. You know that I've been Jack for The Cardboard Herald.