Skip to main content
Loading video...
Transcript 16:56

I received review copies of Quoridor and Quarto from the distributor. So, thanks to Asmodee Board Games UK. Move stacks of pebbles, dropping one off at each space along the way in an attempt to make a row of four pebbles of your color. Place or slide wooden stars in an attempt to form a perfect square in your color of any size. So, a pair of wooden abstract games from Gigamic's long-running prestigious modern classics line. And that's the hook.

I'm Adam Porter, a game designer and occasional reviewer, and I use published games as case studies to explore the connection between product design, player experience, and commercial success. So, once again, this won't be a typical YouTube review. Rather than simply asking whether these games are good, I'll be using a series of product design tools to explore who they're for, where they sit in the market, and why they succeed or fail to entertain. If you're interested in these frameworks, I discuss them in much greater detail in my Adam in Wales game design books, which are available now on Amazon. See the link in the video description. Quoridor is a two-player abstract strategy game from Romain Fraga and Didier Lannoy Blanchard. A design duo unfamiliar to me, so I'm assuming they're relative newcomers. Quarto is also a two-player abstract strategy game. This time from Fabrice Puleo, another relatively new game designer from France. In Quoridor, two pebbles of a neutral color are placed in each corner of the board. On your turn, you place a pebble of your own color on top of one stack, and then move that stack across a series of adjacent spaces, dropping off pebbles from the bottom of the stack as you go. And the first player to create a line of four pebbles of their own color, as viewed from above, wins the game.

In Quarto, on your turn, you either place a star onto the board or move a star to an adjacent space, potentially pushing another star which is in its way. You can even push stars off the board. If a player ever creates a square of any size with stars of their own color, then they win the game immediately. The starting point with any product is the box cover. Frequently, the first contact a potential customer has with the product. For the last decade or so, Gigamic's presentation of these games has been consistent. A white box with the game's components up front and center. Back when I was a child, board games frequently used this approach. We would see a family grinning as they leaned over a game in progress, The Game of Life or Go for Broke. But this aesthetic has long since fallen away in favor of stunning art pieces which evoke the narrative or setting of a game. But of course, with abstract strategy games, there is no narrative or setting. So many opt for the traditional game components as cover art route. Gigamic's modern classics range are designed as beautiful wooden sculptures as much as they are engaging games, and the boxes highlight that. But they even go a step further, angling the laid out components and muting the board colors so that the components and their shadows stand out starkly against a blank backdrop.

Somehow, they manage to make piles of wood look intriguing and enticing rather than dry or mathematical. Each game in the range is also sold in a miniature portable edition, which is a great option if you're short on shelf space or if you wish to play the games while traveling. Gigamic know that table presence is one of their key selling points, and they exploit that with every new game. Naming an abstract game is always a challenge, and Gigamic tend to default to titles beginning with Q. Quarto, Quantik, Quoridor, though Pylos and Squadro buck the trend. Awalé is an ancient Mancala variant, hence the name Quawale. It's not so hard to derive the origin of the game Quoridor. The pieces are star-shaped and they move like comets. So switch the C to a Q, and there you've got it. I don't think anyone's buying these games based on the title, so it probably doesn't matter what they're called. but the convention of starting with a Q is a useful brand identifier, placing the games within a larger family.

Onboarding describes the journey from first discovering a game to purchasing a copy, learning the rules, playing for the first time, and ultimately becoming a repeat player. Every step in that journey is an opportunity for a game to either win people over or lose them. So, the onboarding process for both games here is very smooth. There are no complex or unintuitive rules. The rule books are short and simple, with Quoridor coming in at around 200 words, and Quomet just a little longer at around 300. This is a clear indication of the procedural simplicity of these games. Their depth does not come from layered mechanisms, but from the emergent complexity of player choices and interactions. Gigamic's abstract games feature some of the cleanest rule sets in the abstract strategy genre. No unintuitive edge cases, no exceptions, no scoring complications. Setup and teardown are, of course, extremely fast.

You'll be up and playing in seconds, and the game can be packed away just as quickly. And that's assuming that you want to pack it away at all. Part of the charm of this range of games is the aesthetic appeal as physical items to leave out on a coffee table or a sideboard. My ladder engagement model looks at five things that tend to keep players engaged in a game: theme, interaction, feedback, tension, and meaningful choices. Now, very few games score highly in every category, but they don't need to. The goal is to top the ladder with a score of 10 or above. So, for thematic immersion, both games score zero out of three. Quoridor is, of course, entirely theme-less, and the star-shaped pieces in Quomet give it a visual identity, but they could hardly be considered a setting or a theme. Abstract strategy games are often among the most interactive that exist, especially those which feature a race to achieve an objective and win. Every move will either progress your own chances of winning or reduce your opponent's. So, in Quoridor, you consistently cover your opponent's pieces with your own or break down stacks which your opponent has created. In Quarto, you push your opponent's pieces out of the way, disrupting their plans. So, both games score a full three points. Tension in these games does not come from surprises. There are no random reveals or hidden information. Instead, the enjoyable tension is derived from the uncertainty of your opponent's decisions. Will they spot what I'm trying to do and block me? Will they make a mistake? What are they planning?

Am I missing something? So, both games score three points. Feedback describes the ways in which a game responds to players' inputs, rewards, bonuses, and in-game scoring. And there isn't a lot of this in either game. You either win or you lose. The game doesn't hold your hand or pat you on the back along the way. There is no extrinsic feedback. There is, however, intrinsic feedback from manipulating the lovely tactile pieces. It's not as strong as flicking a disc in Crokinole or balancing cards in Rhino Hero, but there is pleasure to be had in the clicking of Quoridor's pebbles as they're stacked on top of each other. I think Quarto could have scored a point, too, if the pieces were able to be pushed smoothly as in the abstract game Abalone, but alas, that isn't possible.

So, I'm scoring Quoridor one and Quarto zero for feedback. Of course, any decent abstract strategy game offers up a wealth of meaningful decisions, and these are present in abundance here. You'll have the opportunity to plan ahead, to explore different strategies, to learn from mistakes, and to master the game over many plays. These are games where skill overwhelmingly determines the outcome. I'm going to deduct a point from Quoridor, though, for the rather high likelihood of a game ending in a tie. That's never a desirable end to a fiercely fought battle of the mind. And while ties are commonplace in the abstract strategy genre, I believe the perfect example wouldn't enable such an outcome. In Quoridor, draws are not possible, and one potential source of a tie is specifically dealt with in the rules. If your move causes both colors to simultaneously form a square, then your opponent wins. So, the total for engagement is nine, which is really strong, but it's just short of the top of my engagement ladder. Abstract games always have to work extra hard to overcome their lack of theme.

The DICE model is a product design tool for isolating the elements of a game which are fundamental but unremarkable, the elements which drive a positive player experience, and the elements which drive sales. So, D stands for default. These are the unremarkable aspects of a game, the basic fundamentals which are essential to know, but nobody's shouting about them. Quoridor and Quarto are both boxed wooden abstract games for two players, playable in around 15 minutes. These elements will be useful for a distributor or a retailer to understand when arranging their catalog of games, but they're hardly likely to motivate a player to race to the checkout. I is for invisible. These are the elements of the game which drive the system but tend to go entirely unnoticed. So, I find the classification of abstract strategy games fascinating.

Quoridor and Quarto, along with all the other games currently in the Gigamic Modern Classics range, are bounded games. That is to say, they're played within a fixed grid, rather than a free-form playing space or variable grid, as in Hive or Okay Play. Quoridor and Quarto both utilize a race mechanism to determine the winner. Players simply win, lose, or draw. We do not evaluate the final playing space to score points as in abstract games like Othello or Blokus. And again, this is a common trait to all the games currently in Gigamic's range of abstracts. Both Quarali and Quoridor feature a dynamic playing space. That is to say, when a piece is placed, it does not remain static as in games like Connect Four or Cathedral. It can be moved on later turns. And most of the games in Gigamic's Modern Classics range are also dynamic. But there are two exceptions here, Quarto and Quantik. So in both of those games, once a piece is placed, it remains static for the rest of the game. Now these traits matter to me when trying to identify similarities between titles and where novelty truly lies. But they'll go entirely unnoticed by most players. Pushing back against such constraints often results in designers devising creative or innovative new mechanisms.

C is for core. These are the elements which do get noticed. Players appreciate them. They may even comment on these aspects of the game. So for both games, I would highlight the end game condition of connecting four pieces. This is such a well-worn mechanism and a staple of the abstract strategy genre that it's unlikely to form the hook of a product, but it is the mechanism that players always seem to enjoy. E is the player's edge. Every successful game needs something that people can immediately talk about. This is often the key hook for the game's marketing. So far, Quoridor and Quarali have sounded very similar. They're bounded, dynamic, race games with a connect mechanism. But they don't actually feel all that similar to play. And that's because of their edge. So for Quarali, it's the Mancala-like movement mechanism. Not all that novel in and of itself, but very unusual and satisfying when combined with a connect four end game condition. For Quoridor, there are two aspects to the edge. Firstly, the use of a push mechanism to create connected pieces, and secondly, the requirement to create a square of matching pieces rather than the more traditional straight line.

Meta hooks is a framework that I've developed to analyze why players are drawn to a game, and it breaks a hook into four domains: mechanical, experiential, thematic, and aesthetic. M stands for the mechanical hook. This hook must only describe the game's mechanisms, not the theme, not the presentation. And both games have a strong mechanical hook. Mancala meets Connect Four, or push pieces to create squares. E is for an experiential hook. And this type of hook focuses on the player experience, how they interact with the game and with each other, and the emotions that they feel while playing. In both games, the experiential hook is essentially the same. Every move strengthens your own position while potentially creating opportunities for your opponent, forcing you to think several turns ahead. In fact, that describes almost every abstract strategy game, so it doesn't really help as a hook at all.

T is for a thematic hook. A hook which describes the narrative of the game, the setting, characters, or story. And of course, neither of these games has a theme. But when designing an abstract game, I do think it's helpful and fun to imagine what the most appropriate theme could be, even if it's a real stretch. So, Quoridor is a case in point. The choice to use star-shaped pieces does not truly constitute a theme, but it did inspire the choice of name for the game. And the two together, the shape and the title, do indicate to players something about how the game plays. I.e., these star-shaped pieces are going to be moving around the board. If we had to come up with a theme for Quawali, what would it be? Uh maybe something about laying stones along an ancient pathway, invoking Stonehenge or other ancient mystical formations.

A is for an aesthetic hook. So, this hook describes the presentation of the game, how it looks, the unique components, table presence, or tactility. So, in Qawale, smooth wooden pebbles are stacked and distributed across a beautifully sculpted board, creating a constantly evolving landscape of layered patterns. That's a lovely hook, and it probably generates equally as much interest from players as the clever mechanisms. In Quoridor, wooden stars glide across an elegant board, creating satisfying geometric patterns. There's one other type of hook which the meta hooks framework doesn't consider, and that's contextual hooks. I haven't included these in my model because typically they're outside the control of a designer, relying on some broader context for the game. A contextual hook might be the latest game from the designer of Scythe, the seventh sequel to Everdell, sold 1 million copies worldwide, or the game they tried to ban. The contextual hook for both games here is simple. They're the latest additions to Gigamic's modern classics range, a catalog that already includes Quarto, Quoridor, Pylos, and several other highly regarded abstract games.

Gigamic has built a reputation for publishing abstract games with remarkably clean rule sets. The final product design tool that I'm going to use to assess the game is my idea execution matrix. Evergreen bestsellers tend to occupy the red section at the top right of the matrix. Fantastic ideas flawlessly executed, while underperforming games linger in the blue section to the bottom left. The idea of combining Mancala with Connect Four is a solid one. It feels innovative within the constraints of the accessible grid-based abstracts favored by Gigamic. So, my personal feeling is that the idea of creating squares by pushing stars around a grid is a little less easy to communicate, so I've marked it down a little. Nonetheless, both ideas are extremely simple to grasp and they prove to be an engaging experience.

The execution of the ideas is also very strong. The presentation in both games is outstanding, of course, but Quoridor is more visually striking and I do think Quirkle would have benefited from a physical construction which allowed pieces to directly push other pieces without needing to pick them up and physically reposition them. With regards to the rule sets, Quoridor is marked down slightly because of the proportionately high rate of tied outcomes. It would have been fantastic if a solution had been found to prevent this. This leaves Quoridor in the yellow section of the grid, an excellent place to be suggesting strong commercial appeal, and Quirkle slightly lower in the green section. Still very strong, but perhaps not among the highest echelons of the Gigamic Modern Classics range. So, both games succeed for the same reason. They take a single, elegant idea and execute it with restraint. If you're looking for deep strategic play without complicated rules, either would make an excellent addition to your collection. Of the two, Quoridor is the one that I expect to revisit more often, but both comfortably earn their place within Gigamic's Modern Classics range. If you're interested in the product design tools used throughout this review, you'll find them explored in much greater detail in my Admin & Wales game design books, especially my Board Game Designer Journal and Admin & Wales Product Design. All of my books are available on Amazon worldwide, so check out the links in the description to this video.

Progress saved