NEW expansion for Finspan | Sharks & Reefs
Transcript
We're exploring new areas of the ocean with the Sharks and Reefs expansion for Finspansion.
Thank you for joining us at Tantrum House Studio D. I'm Melissa Delp.
And I'm Kevin Delp. Sharks and Reefs is an expansion to Finspansion, a Finspansion. An action selection game, engine building game for one to five players that's all about fish.
Now the expansion is designed by Michael O'Connell and developed by David Gordon and Elizabeth Hargrave. It's published by Stonemaier Games and they sent us this review copy. In this video we'll give a quick overview of how the expansion changes the game and then share our thoughts. Sharks and Reefs does not change the main gameplay of Finspansion. On your turn, you'll still use one of your divers to choose an action, either adding a fish to your board or diving in one of the three dive sites. The coral reef overlay is one of the biggest changes. The overlay covers the original twilight zone section on your player board. When you dive in a column, you can pay the indicated cost for that dive site to add one of the coral that matches the reef. [clears throat] You don't need to have a fish in that zone to place a coral.
For the blue site, you have to discard an egg. For the purple site, discard a young. And for the green site, discard a card. At the end of the game, each coral is worth a point and each full reef is worth a certain amount of extra points. But coral is also useful during the game. New reef fish have a coral requirement for placement and some fish provide an additional reward if a certain amount of coral is present in their column. The expansion also introduces some new rewards and abilities. Some allow you to play a fish for free or to let any fish in your ocean consume a shorter fish from your hand. Sharks can scatter schools. With this ability, you have the option to break up a school into four young that you place in four different spaces. New reef fish have requirements related to how many coral are in the column.
That was a quick look at the new things the expansion adds. We'll go into some more details as we talk about our opinions.
And we're separating this into our four C's, our thoughts about components, our critiques, our commendations, and finally, our conclusions. So here's a look at the new components the expansion brings. There's a coral overlay board for each player and three types of coral tokens, one for each dive site, blue, purple, and green. These are different colors and shapes. There's also a new board that tracks the achievements and rounds with updated scoring and three new double-sided achievement tiles. There are new player aid cards with the additional icons and info for this expansion. Now you will still need to use the original player aids to have all of the rules and icons, but I know that I am always excited about a good player aid, so I'm super glad that they added a new one.
There's a new score pad, five new starter cards for fish, and 75 new fish cards, many with new requirements, rewards, and actions. The expansion also has a plastic insert to hold cards and tokens. Here are a few critiques. My first small critique is I wish that the coral tokens that both sides of them had that screen printed on it. It just made it would have made it feel a little nicer. I I know. You're like flipping them all over to get them to the the nice printed side.
Yeah. Uh one thing that was a little confusing for some of our players were the requirements that are on some of the new fish. So some of the reef fish have to have a certain number of coral in their column. And if some players were kind of confusing that with a cost, you don't need to spend the coral to place the fish. You just have to have that many. So kind of like the requirement for which zone it goes in. It's kind of like that. Um one thing they are printed in different sections of the card, so if if you kind of tell people, "Hey, this area is cost and this area is just what you need to have." Hopefully that'll help them keep those things separate in their mind. I think yeah, there was definitely the first game I was like, "Oh, I have to spend this?" Or I might have spent it, I don't remember.
But uh another small critique, I I think at the higher player counts, it's easier for the players to fill up their coral reefs on on the different um sections. I don't know if it's because the players are going down that column more that happens that people are just happen to get cards or there's and there's more cards that give coral.
yeah. I mean, in some of our games several players had cards that gave everyone coral when activated or when played, so it felt like they were flowing a little bit more.
And I think that matters because some of the end game there's some cards that give end game bonuses to add a certain color reef to your board, you don't really need that card if you know, your reef's already full. Right, because once they're full, there is no benefit that you get for gaining additional ones, so yeah. I don't think it'll be as much of an issue in a lower count game.
Let's move to our commendations. I like that there are more fish in the game, so in a five player game, um we found before we had the expansion that we would go through the whole we usually went through the whole deck and we had to like reshuffle the cards, but now that there's 75 more fish, we played a five player game and didn't have to reshuffle. So I think that's a benefit uh to the game cuz in this game you have personal discard piles and sometimes you're like, "I really want to pull this fish back in there." And then all of the sudden at the end of the game they all get pushed back together. It could feel bad, especially near the end of the game if you were saving something. But I like that there's 70 75 new fish. So I like the flexibility of the new bonus reward where you can break up your schools into young. You actually get one more, so a school is normally three young make it, but you can break it up into four and that gives [clears throat] you more flexibility, especially when um paying young is one of the cost to put I think the purple column of the the coral reef. So it just gives you a little bit more to think about and ways to um you know, strategize. Also, another cool thing is sometimes players could go down a column one column a lot. This game helps players want to go down the three different columns because each coral reef sort of does different things and you sort of need to get more points or you
will try to get more points if you go down the different things to get put coral on those on the different coral in in the different columns. So it sort of in a sense forces people to go down the different columns.
Makes them diversify a little bit more. Yeah, I think that the coral and having to pay different things [clears throat] like the eggs and the young and the cards does mix up the strategy a little bit. You could kind [clears throat] of feel like in the base game I have my mindset of, "Oh, this is when I want to start making schools and this is what I'm using my resources for." And now there's another way to spend them. And for me, I would start delaying schools unless I had that thing where I could break them up because I need them to pay for fish or pay for coral. So it just swapped the strategy a little bit and freshened up the game for me. One more commendation is I like that this game doesn't add too much to basically change the base game. It's This is already a nice streamlined game in the Span universe and I like that this adds a little bit and not a whole lot to make it sort of overwhelming. And it doesn't overwhelm at all. Adds just the right amount in my book. Okay.
Let's move on to our conclusions. So I agree with Kevin that the expansion doesn't add too much new complexity to the game. It is still a streamlined version of all of the Spans. So I think if you already enjoy Finspansion, this will be a great expansion to add in for a little bit more variety and a little bit different strategy with the coral and the reefs. If you don't like Finspansion, I don't think this is going to change your mind because it's not changing the game that much. Maybe if your only concern was that the complexity was too low, this does bump it up a little bit, so that could change your opinion on it, but it is still the game of Finspansion.
I think it'd be good and helpful for people to know sort of where the different Span games fall for us. Okay. Our ranking.
Our ranking. There was originally Wingspan that sort of started the whole Spanverse. I know we were calling this.
Uh then Wormspan came out, which is the dragons one, and then Finspansion. I would put at my uh top, my favorite one is Wormspan. Uh just because uh it has that engine building component to it. Uh it's, you know, it's got the dragons which are cool. I'm just a sucker for for that. And I would also say the game itself is not hard to explain. I mean, all you're doing is um one of those one of those actions or you're walking down the path. Um so it's easy to comprehend now that there's a lot of strategy involved and it's the heaviest of the three. Yeah, I would agree with that that it has the probably the most strategy, the heaviest, and I do think the action of walking from left to right is a little easier to understand than the the Wingspan where you're going the opposite way. Uh so, next for me is actually Fins Span. I am the opposite side. This is super streamlined. It's easy for me to play with people who don't want a super long game which Wingspan is going to take a lot longer.
This you can actually play four or five players in an hour. Um if everyone knows what they're doing, you can, you know, go through it pretty quickly cuz you only really have two choices. You're either going to play a card or you're going to be walking down one of the columns, diving Mhm. down the columns.
And this doesn't add that much time to it at all. And then, last for me actually now is Wingspan. I I think it's thematically the birds are the coolest of them all, but I'm thinking more gameplay-wise. That's what I'm ranking them uh currently, yeah.
And we would mainly play Wingspan with the base game or maybe the first expansion. We personally have not delved into a lot of
[clears throat]
the extra expansions that probably would change some of the strategy and up the complexity potentially. Yep. So, that's our ranking. Well, at least mine. Yeah, I I I
agree with that. The bird feeder in Wingspan adds a little bit too much randomness for me. So, I enjoy In the other games, it's easier to get the resources that I need. So, what would be your ranking? Have you played the different span games? Which are your favorite? Are you excited about this expansion? Let us know in the comments.
Please like and subscribe.