Oath: New Foundations - Clockwork Adversaries - Pre-Development Preview
Transcript
hi everyone welcome back to box of delights and welcome to this demonstration of oath it's not actually a demonstration of oath I'm just want to do a little discussion about the New Foundations expansion which has just launched on Kickstarter um Liz Davidson from beond salente and myself are working on the solo two-player Co-op expansion for New Foundations so New Foundations is going to add a whole bunch of new stuff to the base game plus a separate expansion okay an independent expansion that's crowdfunding at the same time which will add it's called Clockwork adversaries at the moment but the idea is that these Clockwork adversaries can be layered into your two plus games uh solo games and potentially Co-op now I'm saying potentially because the kickstarter has launched very very early in the development cycle this is not going to be available until the latter end of 2025 Okay so we've got a long design and development stage so I'm working on the design of the clock expansion which my roomate at this stage for Liz and I is to include solo two player and potentially Co-op all right so we're going to that's what we're looking at so that's our ultimate aim but like I say what will ultimately make the cut comes down to how successful it
is that's our remate at this stage but like I say it's very early stages in development but we wanted to be able to show you something at least and that something in the moment is a module of the two-player solo and Co-op design and that module is basically this order deck the order deck is something that we're going to be using to control the actions of an automated opponent now let me make one thing clear this is just a single module all right this is a small part of what makes up this expansion for the co-op for the solo we know that we need to introduce new victory conditions we've been playing with new victory conditions we've been looking at things called uh one of our one of our base scenarios and Liz may have already talked about this in his in her video in lizz's video demo so I'm going to leave a link to that video go and have a look and I know Liz is publishing a designer Dory that talks about some of the things that we were looking at when we were doing our initial design sketch one of those things was called queen of Shadows queen of Shadows is in the co-op game so queen of Shadows was for the co-op us as players playing against the game against an imagined opponent called queen of Shadows who's making stuff happen in the world of oath that's pushing Back Against The Soloist or players playing cooperatively and in the world of Shadows we had Shadow sights we had Shadow relics relics that you had to carry and carried then had a burden so
it was hard for you to carry these shadow relics we had Shadow denisons even different denisons that would when you explored down into the underworld of a Shadow's sight these denisons would appear and hurt you but you could bribe them persuade them to come onto your side and then you could use them in your multiplayer game this is part of the chronicle to be more attacking cards more interactive um with other players so so we had all these different ideas now all these different ideas got taken apart now one of the things you'll see in New Foundations for example is overlays on sites now that kind of conflicted with her idea about what shadow sites um would look like so we've kind of abandoned the shadow sites not totally um but that's what happens in design and development things you you have a 100 ideas and only only a handful of them make it through to the final product but just know I guess the ultimate of what I'm trying to say is Queen of Shadows comprised lots of different modules different lots of different ideas impacting all those different elements of the game one of those modules was the order deck and that's the thing that we wanted to demo to you how does an automated opponent choose its actions now in essence it's going to try and act like a regular player right it's going to take more than one action on its turn it's going to be limited by Supply now for our order deck that just means the number of actions it's can take it can take is limited but we don't want to be completely random right there's there's there's two
ends of the spectrum when doing an automated opponent you can make a fully intelligent controlled deterministic logically driven opponent that has a 100 different or a thousand different logical if then lse statements to make it behave like a human if it's got a large decision space you need a large computer to make Intelligent Decisions we all know this right so that's one end of the spectrum but that that's not feasible all right it is feasible but we're not including a computer in our components list for this expansion um or an app or anything else okay this is this is a paper and pencil this is a cardboard um opponent so further down that line you get to the opposite end which is completely random do random stuff and anything you do is just purely random all right now you're going to be on that sliding scale somewhere where in that scale are you going to be now that decision comes down to lots of things do you want expansive flow charts like gmts coin games that try to drive all that logic or do you want a simple Aloma deck where it's just laying down random actions to interfere with your game right where on the scale do you want it to be we want it to be somewhere a little bit different um a little bit off that SK off that line a little bit we've got a random automa deck kind of acting like a random opponent was when an opponent plays the game you you can't predict what they're going to do totally right so this feels like an opponent's behaving randomly
stuff's happening that's beyond your control right and that's what an automa deck does and that's part of what makes an automa deck work but at the same time we wanted a key project in initiative make this thing simple short and sweet right we want to focus on our turn not the's turn perfect we're going to do that but at the same time we want wanted our Toma to be responsive to the game State what am I trying to do what's my opponent trying to do what sites are out here what denisons are at sites how much money is in each of these Banks we wanted our deck to be responsive to that game State we wanted our automa to execute the effects of Dennison for example when played discard all halfth and Order cards it sites in your regions that's what Dazzle does we well we want the automa to do that too and it will do okay so everything becomes meaningful the actions that you take impact what the automa does that's what the order deck is about and that's the in in Innovative part when I designed the automa deck what you'll see is there's two sets of actions right there's there's a left hand side and a right hand side on the surface when an automa oath player takes its actions it's going to do three things right three things if it can but on the right hand side here is a
boosted action this is the inative part and this action is an additional action so it could do up to six things and these are just regular actions right it's going to it's just the icons you see are just regular oath icons so for example we've got a search icon that's just a search okay A muster icon that's just a muster and they'll do those actions in the same way as a player would no special rules now we do have some new icons we've got three new icons we've got the reap icon which is kind of like a sunrise or Sunset it may get moved about it was originally the end of a turn and it's now gone to the top of a turn we got a moon and a star now the moon and the star they don't really do anything themselves all they do is direct you to an overlay on the automa Players Board so you can place this down it basically replaces their actions okay with a moon action and a star action and the idea is that you with clock Advent adversaries you can have many different types of opponents and each of those opponents each adversary will have his own style of play and its style of play will to some extent be directed by the the actions it chooses to take um so it's just like a wild card really so the wild card here the star Wild Card means go over here what's it going to do it's going to gain a favor it's going to look for favor some might look for Secrets some might exchange favor for secrets so
it's kind of a way that it trades way does it like to manage its resources so you're going to see trade type actions here so actually for this overlay here it says and gain a favor and if it's got three favor um discard them and trade them in for Secrets right so it's cashing them in different designed adversaries will have different logic and moon moon is going to be a bit more mood directed and I'll come back to this in a minute but I think Moody Moon uh the their current mood reflects the type of things that going they're going to do so if they see the moon action what are they going to do well it depends on what their current mood is so at the moment the oathkeeper goal is oathkeeper of devotion which means they're going to be looking for the darkest secret which means that when the moon comes up given the mood they're going to go and try and gain secrets and gain the darkest secret Banner all right so it gives them a little bit of direction too the mood itself these are the mood cards again it's a way of getting an automated opponent to respond to the game state the mood will change depending on what they're trying to do what Their opponent's trying to do um we're still developing the rules around that and trying some different ideas but at the moment it's really simple so for the demo if they hold the oathkeeper title or you serper
then they're holding on to it but they're going to defend against anything that you're trying to do so if a new vision gets revealed they're going to switch their mood to match that vision and try and stop you getting your vision while they're holding oathkeeper if they don't hold the oathkeeper their mood just switches to the oath oathkeeper goal so it's a little bit reactive to what's going on uh what we're playing with actually is ideas of just altering the mood so it's a little bit more layered right what they want what what their opponents want but obviously trying to do that for solo one opponent two opponents three opponents is going to take a little bit more development remember we're very early in the design stage we're not even in the development stage yeah we're right down in the fun part of doing the design and figuring out design anyway that's how mood works but the other thing is the mood and why you see suit icons here I already told you that boosted actions happen in response to the suits their access to Suits so what that means is at the moment they're yellow they have access to an Arcane suits right if they play any advisors so they can play play advisor just the same as we can play advisors those advisor have suits if they play advisors like here they might play this Beast advisor sorry sorry Discord advisor now they have access to the Arcane and the Discord suits Discord suits those mean with they've got access
to those suits it means they've got access to these boosted actions right suddenly they can do more stuff but also their mood does that so given that um they're holding the darkest secret as their mood right that's influenced the types of things they want to do they're responding to the state of the game it also means they have um access to boosting actions that have these three suits okay each one will have a different set of suits that directs the type of actions they're trying to do so it's a nice simple method they do the stuff on the card but extra stuff in response to Suits they have access to and suits that are driven by their mood and the reason why suits work is because suits have flavor so for example if they have access to lots of alcane Suits or they're in an alcane type mood then the types of actions that they take will be about gaining Secrets Discord suit will give them access to searching and playing advisors and actually gaining favor The Nomad suits will give them access to more traveling type actions okay getting about moving around the map as well as playing advisors attacking advisors every suit and you'll figure this out when you start playing and when the game comes um every suit kind of actually I'm saying that but you'll have access on tabletop simulator you'll have access to print and play but at the
moment just this little module all right now remember this module it's not a complete game all right it does one little small thing but it can't live and Bre is a full game it'll be like you know trying to make the heart run without a body but it it's just it's just showing you one small part of how the the order deck will will work I think you've got that point by now right so it's not a complete endtoend game it's a one small small little module and you can have you can try out just to get a feel for how simple it will be to run an automated opponent but also how responsive they are to the game state so for example let's you know I've already told you that suits have themes that means you have some agency over the aoma right what you're doing is also significant to what the automa is doing not just in the visions that you choose or the or the oath keeper goal but also the denisons you're playing because when you play a Denison to a site and what's important in the multiplayer game it's not just a Denison for you it's a Denison for other players to make use of right they can come in here and use those denisons as well they can control these sites so if you lay denisons down be aware that that's going to power up the automa when or the servant we're calling him the servant right now so if the servant has access to those suits then they're going to be potentially boosting up their actions and being able
to do more stuff on their turn likewise you can control and limit what the automa is able to do what the servant's able to do by controlling the number of favors in each of these suits in the favor banks by limiting the secrets they have so to boost an action to take an action they're going to have to play a secret onto a boosted suit so for example um Aron boy okay Aron boy s right so they've gone over here they've taken control of Aon boy if they want to use the suit here the Beast to trigger a boosted action like this muster here for example then they're gonna have to place a secret from their board on here and it's if if they've taken the action okay if they don't have secrets they'll use their favor and if they can't do a favor they'll just do a trade so they'd use a secret to do a trade all right or or a favor to do a trade right so Dennis will give access to actions make sense she's responding to the game State and that's really important when you're playing the game to understand um that when you play Denis you're powering up other players in this case the servant player so that's how that works and what it means is that because
these actions are not just driven by if then else type logic she's not completely focused she's not single-minded you know the oathkeeper title here is dark of secret but that doesn't mean she isn't going to try and win some sights it doesn't mean she's not going to go for people's favor it doesn't mean she's not going to trade or campaign or do these other things these supporting actions all it means is her her mood gets a little bit of a shift towards the oathkeeper of devotion and the Dennis that are coming out the advisers that she has access to will influence the type of action that she'll be taking okay that's it so that's how the order deck works now if you want to go and see the order deck in action like I say go and check out lizz's video Liz will do one Turn showing you exactly how it works but I guess I could show you too why don't we have a little go why don't we just see what H happens here so I've decided that I'm the chancellor it looks like I've set up this way um if if you want to set up a game inantly when the print and play comes out or the TTS comes out um if you've got oath set up what I would suggest you do is just set up a basic game if you want to reset your world deck you can do as well just grab nine random cards of each suit shuffle them all up get yourself
eight sites turn the top one of each region face up Place one Denison at each site face up which obviously gives the chancellor access to three sites at the beginning of the game three zenis at the beginning of the game if any of those are advisor only shuffle them back in just do it again right so you get three sits three face up denisons aultimate player just goes to the first site that she can closest to the Cradle set yourself a random oath keeper goal or use the one that's in the world deck and then set her starting moood to match all right okay cool all right we start with a couple of cards in this card pile just because I'm playing solo here you can use the order deck solo you can use it in two plus player obviously in a two plus player game the it's going to work on its own as a standalone module it's going to work better because in a two plus player game you've got human opponents you know fighting each other for victory with the automa just kind of getting in the way and acting as that chaotic interference in the solo game we're going to need much more supporting uh components to go with this all right so there's going to be supporting goals scenarios different things that may be invading and influencing the game that The Soloist or the or indeed a co-op team of players may be playing so it does work better in a two two plus but if you want to set up
and play it solo feel free right it just might not give you um much of a challenge okay we're going to uh give ourselves some advisors oh from uh bottom of the deck it's amazing how many simple rules you get wrong right so let's see one we grab T right we'll put those over there discard these let's quickly take my turn I we're just we're just going to go ahead and must for one Supply travel over here for two Supply let's have a peek at what that is oh circle of command um I need to burn a secret to recover that so let's do that one Supply recover this Relic Circ of command's interesting cuz it says players cannot take Target or take your banners or your other re relics so so at this point I mean this is important right and this is why when you're building AI I say AI it's it's no it's not very long the the scale of artificial intelligence right with if Dums at this end and and and clever that end a cardboard opponent is right down this end AI is in Mis Noma we say it all the time we in the board game world but there is no artificial
intelligence it's not that complex all right but here's an example Circ command we could build logic into an a opponent that says right o coper devotion needs the B of the darkest secret how am I going to get it well I know now with me holding circlet of command they can't take it they can't take it the only way to get to a banner is to get to this Relic now to build that logic into an AI opponent is going to I mean this is just one exception okay I mean you could say well have your Tim ignore relics well that's no good because what's the point of holding this Relic right I want everything to be integral to a solo game or a co-op game or a multiplayer game hold with involving an automa as it is a regular oath game I want to play Oath I want to play oh I don't want to play a version where some of the rules don't work okay because it just breaks everything I want the circle of command to be the circle of command and to build logic into an AI that says I want a banner but I can't get a banner if they've got the the circle it is it's just it's too much right you don't want to have to pause that logic every time you play the ai's turn because you're going to be taking your turn and then half an hour to take the AI opponent's turn right so AI missa let's not do it but in this model they will Target The Relic even though they need the banner because when they flip their card and it says they're going to campaign for a
relic or recover a relic they're going to take the C of command despite the fact that darkest secret is a banner all right they're not doing it smartly they're doing it incidentally and incidentally they're making a smart decision but what's clever about this system is not the fact that it wants to take you know the the it randomly chooses the recover action the point is that these and their act ACC to these suits means he's more likely the servant is more likely to want to take the recover action in order to recover relics because of the suits recover is a suit that's linked to Arcane and halfth we've got Arcane here we've got Arcane in their mood they're more likely to take a boost and take the recover action right there's one right there that says if they've got access to arcane they're going to try and recover which means they're going to Target my circlet so it's not purely random it's driven by the game state but it is absolutely incidental it's not AI to any stretch of the imagination but it's still doing smart stuff okay so this is how um this is how things work oath oath is so complex I mean and it's and it's opaque what you do why you do it is opaque and it's and
that's one of the reasons why multiplayer people struggle with this game um because they they they don't know what to do but we can suggest what an automated opponent should want to do through directing it using our order deck and the boosted actions idea right and suits are reflective of the game State and the types of things it wants to do right it's a neat solution I think it's a neat solution to a very complicated problem that is otherwise impossible to solve without the computer okay have we finished our turn yet I don't think we have Let's uh let's play tense down here grab a favor and let's um let's search uh we can search up here no reason why not if we search up here we're giving her access to less cards so that's something a player might want to do uh not ideal I was hoping for a nomad but I didn't get one I might take this okay all right end of my turn perfect um what are we on 6 12 15 + one I think we're up here okay my turn is not important you want to see what this guy does okay so on their turn they're going to flip a card and some cards are going to be Moon some are going to be star am I going to be going after my objective am I going to be
um going after resources all right so let's see let's see what she does it's a moon okay so the first thing they do is reap this is like the sunset or the sunrise action uh discard a card from the world deck they're going to clock the way through and this is really just a balancing mechanism if you're playing solo you do these if you're playing multiplayer you ignore these but in the solo you've kind of got a scale things back up for the fact that going through the world deck is a little bit slower um and then they're going to grab a favor and they're going to grab it from there's a priority order suits they're going to grab it from Nomad next they're going to do this Moon action now the moon action remember it's a moody moon now it looks complicated but all you're doing is saying Moon do this bit it looks complicated but they're only doing one of these things okay and it's going to be reflective of their current mood so the current mood is holds darkest secret okay so they're actually IGN ignoring all this stuff and they're only doing this which is gain a secret and then recover the darkest secret now we know they can't recover the darkest secret because I've got the circle of command and any time they can't perform an action they're just going to take a favor instead so Moon gives them a secret and a favor okay that's that's that simple this is what the moon's doing so it's directing them towards the things that are going to
help them get their goal now obviously as we develop more characters more adversaries they're all going to have their own different style and their own different attacks so for example for Star they're going to be trying to gather favor turn them into secrets and then turn secrets into an ability to take away your advisor so this is kind of a very attacking adversary but other ones may have other effects so for example this star here likes to go searching okay um you may find an adversary who wants to be the chancellor who will replace the chancellor who doesn't want to search wants to keep the world deck thick but instead is going to be maybe mustering lots of War bands okay so different characters for different adversaries that's the plan okay all right now what they're going to do so first thing they're going to do and these actions and these sequences have been created they're not just random they've been created by U playing games observing games kind of like training a neural net you just fire games at it and you say well what sequence of actions does a player normally do okay now before they've got access to lots of Suits they're just doing these but then as the game develops and they're getting access to more and more suits this develops and they get to do more and more stuff okay so as the game develops like I said this their turn gets a little bit bigger as
they get access to more things let's see then they're going to search the world deck if they've got less than three visions they have okay cool is there capacity to play Dennis in a site no there isn't there's already one here so this site is actually a maximum capacity so instead she's going to play one of these as a face down advisor okay which one is just random in order for us again to make an intelligent decision we'd have to have revealed what cards she's chosen so she's placed it as a face down advisor next action does she have access to the Beast uh suit no she doesn't doesn't own any or rule any sites that have got Beast Dennis she doesn't have a beast adviser she doesn't have a mood that wants to do Beast like things so at the moment she's not mustering okay she's going to skip down to the next one which is she's going to search again so she's still SE seeking Vision she's going to search the discard there's only one card here so we have already had some agency over what she's done right we've said we wanted a search here so that she had less cards to search from so she's going to grab this again as a face down advisor next what she going to do well she does have access to a an Arcane suit there's one right here at a site so she's going to place a secret on this card and in response to that she's going to gain a secret beautiful these are
reflecting different things that she could be doing on her turn all right it's just a quick way to whis through a turn make stuff happen get back to my turn I'm not do you notice I'm not having to make decisions for her I'm not having to do that I'm just saying can she do it or can't she um let's just do it grab a secret put one here done right next option um so this so already she's done an extra thing because she had access to a Dennis in at her site Arcane one right this is um the advisor icon she's going to now play the card that she searched for grab it okay this has to be played at a site she can't play at her site her site's full so she's just going to discard it it's Marshall culture um and it's Sue order so it's compensation she's going to take a secret and a favor from order okay that's the culmination of playing and discarding um an advisor effectively all aism okay does she have access to the order suits she doesn't she hasn't played any advisor she's used up this Arcane that Arcane one's used just like the regular game so if we had another action here that was boosted by arcan she couldn't use it because it's already got a token on so the this turn it's been all about Gathering resources that's what she's been focused on this is what this card has done for her card number 11 it's been all about just trying to gather up resources that's it the turn's done right so she gets a secret back all right job done now it's
back to me so you can see it's really straightforward really simple but driven by the game State given by the things she can and can't do the suits she has access to and the types of things she wants to do all right if you've got any questions leave them below well I could say look out for further developments not sure if we'll have them during the campaign but there's a Discord server there's obviously the kickstarter page there's forums like on Board Game Geek there's places where you can go and ask lots of questions the best way place to be is in the Discord because what will happen is the you know the TTS module will get updated um throughout the whole development process so say we're very early we're not even in development right now we're in design stage uh but once development starts it may very well be that you can become a play tester you can try this stuff out about get involved and see how the development of the product is going if you want to back it early if you've got confidence and faith in leader and what Cole is doing with the expansion what I am doing with the solo what Liz is doing with the solo and the co-op jump in now be a part of it and get involved either way if you go on to the leader Discord you can watch the design and development of this expansion progress and it's an exciting wonderful project to be involved in and I'm really excited about being able to
explore all the different ways that oath can deliver uh to me particularly a solo game and a co-op game you know Liz and I want this to be the kind of game that we will enjoy playing all right so not everyone's going to be happy for sure you can't ever please everybody um I must we must do something about um reducing the number of Secrets they have access to don't about that and every time I play I'm thinking about how we can tweak things uh but yeah I mean having access to Arcane early does does do that yeah anyway stop stop thinking development Ricky get on with it yeah we want this to be Liz and I want this to be the kind of game that we enjoy playing um and if you enjoy playing the kind of games we like playing um you know Liz likes Co-op and solo I'm a big solo person so this is going to be the kind of game that we will want to play as solo and and hopefully deliver a new kind of experience because we don't want it to just be churning out the same old you know solo games you've seen before we want it to feel unlike anything you've played before o is already like that so we we're already kind of riding on the shoulders of giants here but we want this to be a new kind of solo experience and have some innovation in like the the boosted actions type stuff right this is stuff that we're giving you for the first time as a soloist there it is it so that's o uh the the expansion is called New Foundation the the solo Co-op two plus player automated opponent Clockwork adversaries
will s is funding alongside it will be available as a separate expansion it will integrate you you don't need New Foundations to play if you get New Foundations it will integrate okay at least that's the objective we um I say New Foundations is also in early development right now so you know there's a lot of work to do still over the next 12 months of building this thing um go and look at what is doing he'll be publishing all sorts of designer Diaries already has actually designer Diaries and like I said you can keep an eye on progress on the Discord server all right I think that's all I wanted to tell you so I need to get back to it enjoy the campaign enjoy your gaming we'll see you next time