Skip to main content
Loading video...

Is this the best version of Codenames? - Codenames: Critical Role Adventures - Board Game Review

Transcript 11:09

Hello everyone, this is Senna.

And this is Johannes.

And you're watching Board Gaming Ramblings.

And today we are giving you a review of Codenames: Critical Role Adventures. This is a review copy, so thank you so much for that. This is also Codenames.

Mhm.

We know Codenames, but we're still going to do a little overview because it's a bit different. I am going to think that you know Codenames. If you don't, I'm going to tell you how it works. Um,

it's usually played in teams, Codenames. One person is going to be the code giver. He's going to say a word and a number, and that is supposed to give the other players on that team the knowledge of knowing which of these words to to guess that they think they want to know because they're going to have a card that's going to show you which words they want you to guess. That is the same thing you're doing here. But in this game, it's a fully cooperative game, so there's no teams, only one.

Yeah.

a There's a team-based game. There's only one team. You are going to have characters with special abilities. There's not going to be like each player has a character. Every team, which is the one team, is going to have three characters that you play with throughout the campaign. There's a few to choose from. There's a few that they are kind of recommending in the beginning, and then you are doing the Codenames thing. So the first time you play, it's going to be mostly Codenames because it's a campaign game, so it's going to change. You're going to get experience points and level up, get abilities, you're going to get items, all of these things to make guessing easier because as it is a co-op game, it is made to be harder. You also get this cute little GM screen because it is based on Critical Role: Dungeons and Dragons role-playing game thing. We don't know a lot about that, but we know that it is a series that's also known animated series and probably a cereal based on

Probably.

Not like the cereal like a serial killer, but the cereal like the food.

me.

And that is the overview.

Yeah.

It's one of the better overviews I've ever done.

I applaud you.

Yes, thank you. You didn't actually applaud me. Thank you so much. Let's talk about this game.

Yeah, I like that it's a a fully cooperative Codenames. We played Codenames Duet before and that's also cooperative, but it's only for two people.

Yes, still one team, one team.

One team. And in this game as you are have like an RPG inspired thing, one player is the game master, so that alternates from round to round.

Yes, you don't have to alternate from round to round, the game is kind of like saying that you should. There is a story in this little storybook. There is also this cute little thing that if you think the people are not doing what you want, you can hold this in front of your face. Uh there is a story. It is I I enjoy how they've done it.

Yeah.

Because it is okay, but it is fluff. But it is fun. Like we laughed a few times. It is thematic, like it is like a fantasy Dungeons & Dragons kind of thing. I'm very happy they did it to this extent because less it would have feel like if it's just like set up the game and play, it would have feel like why is it the campaign? And if it was four pages of reading every time, I'd be like I just want to play Codenames. So for me, it was like a perfect amount of story, not too much and the story it's well written, but I don't come into this game to get like a great epic narrative.

I agree. If you have listened to Critical Role, you might recognize some of these characters that you can play with. I thought the character abilities that you can unlock is fun and it makes also decision with the base mechanism from Codenames more interesting, also more complex. But but it's leveling up and getting these abilities and getting more health points to your character and like balancing which characters are going to get XP. I like that mechanism.

We haven't seen anything of Critical Role. I don't know if you've seen like anything.

listened to like one podcast.

I I don't I've seen maybe a minute of it. Like it's not my thing, but my cousin, which we played this with, he have seen like a lot of it. So, we it was really important for us to bring somebody in to to see like how well they implemented the theme, and he knew the characters. He said like it did the abilities made sense to the characters and all of that. So, we can't really speak to that, but he was very impressed with it as a game. It is harder than normal Gloomhaven.

Um and I think it's that's okay because it's fully co-op. But but we did struggle to get we we actually lost.

We didn't lose.

Yes.

Because you can't lose more than I think four times before you you you lose the whole campaign. We get got to the end, but we didn't we didn't win the whole thing.

And and it's more difficult also because some of the missions are have a little different rule set and they're more difficult that way, but it also is like a different ballpark of words. They're more like fantasy based. So, so sometimes it was a little hard because it felt like many things were in the same category.

Yeah.

I think that if you have no reference to fantasy,

Yes.

doesn't need to be role-playing games, but like the fantasy in either books or video games or board games or stuff like that, it is going to be harder to play the game. There is also as my cousin said, there are Easter eggs, there are in jokes and all of that. I think that it will add to the game if you play it with a group who has only played who has watched and and viewed and listened to and used their senses to explore and experience critical role, but I don't think it's needed. I think but I think though if you are like a family who's just like getting into board games, don't know anything about or if you're just a game group who doesn't have any inclination toward like if you hate Lord of the Rings, you don't like any of that, it's going to be a harder game.

Yeah, but we changed up some words because we were like, "Oh, we don't have a relation to that. We don't understand that." or something. And and that was fine, too. So, I like that they put these very specific critical role things in here as well.

Oh, yeah, because if if if it was like too little critical role, it wouldn't have been it would been just like pasted on there. And if it was too much, you would alienate a Of course, they're going to sell this. People going to see it to love Critical Role, and they're going to be people who buy it and also the people who like Codenames. If you're not one of those groups, I don't think it's going to be like drawing you in from like seeing it on the shelf because those are the two things it is. It's Codenames and Critical Role. And the game is pretty quick.

Yeah, each session has taken us like 15 to 30 minutes to complete like a game of this, but it's like like one of those games where I just like, "Okay, I want to go again." Especially if we lose, I really want to try again. But it's yeah, as we said, we didn't reach the end of the

No. the

We we did reach the end. We just didn't win at the end.

Um so, it's a yeah, you will you will most likely be playing some scenarios again.

I also like we we we touched on this, but I also like that the missions are different.

Yeah.

Like it's not This time it might be like, "Oh, it's a boss mission. You're supposed to do this." And then you're actually supposed to find like the black, which you're not supposed to in normal Codenames. There's also a new color, the blue one, which might have different thing happen to it. So, that's like another one where you kind of want the other players to to to to get it. And then there are eight yellow ones that you like get experience and you need to take. Sometimes you will have to do like In the beginning it might be like the first scenario might be like five or four. And then it might be like eight and do this and this, and it gets harder and harder. I really like the variability in that.

Yeah, and there's like two negative things other than you instantly die. And there's just like one you take damage for guessing that, but the other one also makes you lose time. And that's like a very interesting mechanism in this game because you have usually too little time. So it makes makes you want to take some chances in the guessing.

Are you ready to do some final thoughts?

Yes. I really like this game. I think Codenames in itself is is a is a cool game. I I like it. I don't play it as much. I don't like the teams thing sometimes. I think it's like I want to be in on the fun at all times. So I like this more than I would see myself if I would play any version of Codenames, I would want to play this.

Yeah.

I'm not into a lot of D&D, but I'm I'm like the fantasy genre. So this suits me very well and I think that it was fun with the mechanisms added to the base concept and also the little campaigny stuff that also is there to like tie everything together. So I'm super pleased with the with this concept and I'm excited to see if they will make more kind of like this with other like concepts because yeah, Codenames are is is all over the all over the place right now. I'm going to land this on an 8.5. I think it's like super super good.

I like Codenames. I think Codenames is a good game. It's not a game that I I have other kind of word games like hard to get for example that I like more. And I think Codenames for me, I really enjoyed Codenames when I got to play it with six people. Because with four you only have one clue giver and one guesser, which means you have no one to discuss with. And this basically takes that and just takes away the one team where you're just So that tension Oh, I hope the other team you lose that tension of oh, you got my team now you like you give the other players points, but that is you get that here as well, but in like another way. I don't usually like co-op games. I like this a lot. I I agree with you if I am to sit down and play Codenames. I don't know when I will do that again, but it would be to play this one.

I'd like to do this again.

I really enjoyed it. It would be fun to see the other characters because it is like it gets more complicated the more you play because you have to be like okay, but when we play there we can use the ability and now we have to roll the die or we took the damage, but then we get to do this and we get to mark this with the things and now we know that this is not that and it it's it's a step up from Codenames, but since it's a co-op game it's not like a hidden information or if one team forgets to use the special ability, all of those things doesn't matter too much. Um for me I think Codenames would be like a 6.5 maybe.

Oh, yeah. Same here.

this one for me lands on a 7.5. It is a lot of fun. It it would be my preferred way of playing Codenames. Just know that those things like it might not be the perfect first Codenames if you are not hugely into fantasy or critical role.

Yes.

And that's going to be the end of the video, but it's not the end for you because you have to

subscribe.

Yes, it's 100% free and it helps us more than you think. Thank you so much for watching. I'm Johannes and you've been watching Board Gaming Ramblings and bye-bye.

Progress saved