Brass Pittsburgh: A New Take on the #1 Game of All Time
Transcript
The wait is finally over and brass Pittsburgh has launched the crowdfunding campaign that is uh this is the next iteration of brass and we're today going to talk to you very briefly about brass but more significantly about the differences that we've seen in Pittsburgh compared to mostly compared to Birmingham. Uh but to to summarize that um I think after having played this uh as Birmingham sort of felt like a more developed version of brass I think this too feels like an even further developed game and better for it.
Sure. And we'll we'll talk about all that, but we want to bring you up to speed. If you've never played brass, you don't really know what all the excitement is about Pittsburgh. This is a brand new game using basically the brass rules. There are some new things that are added into the game that we'll talk about. Uh, but it does bring us over to Pittsburgh, the whole Pittsburgh area, really kind of the eastern half of the United States
centered around Pittsburgh, which is a big steel production, big oil production area or whatever. But brass itself, this is a network building economic game where you're going to be kind of building out trains onto the board, connecting all of these different cities together, building industries to these cities, producing goods, selling goods, selling a lot of economic stuff you're doing. But what really makes brass innovative is this card system.
And I want to talk about this because if you don't get why people love brass, I think the way you use cards is a big reason that people love it. Yeah, it's a very simple game. I mean, I think the depth of brass has always been in the decisions that you're making and not not in the mechanics of the game because on your turn, you're generally speaking going to be taking two actions. Each action driven by one of the cards that you play. And the cards are either going to be city cards that allow you to do things in those cities, or you've got some industry cards that let you do specific industry building actions in any city you want. But there are some rules to follow there. But there's just a handful of actions you take. But no matter what action you're taking, you're always discarding a card because sometimes you'll just discard a card to abstractly do another action.
And all of those actions are carried out on the board like David said, either in these specific cities or regarding these specific industries. And you'll see that every city can hold different types of industries. So as you're playing the game and you're building things out into these cities, you're placing your tiles on these spaces. But a key thing to understand about brass is that you're never going to have a pile of resources in front of you like you might have in other games. You have money, which is the main thing that you're managing moneywise. But all of the resources that you need to pay for your buildings, have to come from the board, either from these markets that you see spread out here or from other players. Because as you build these buildings, like I build a coal building, it's going to come into play with three coal. That is now available for other people to use as long as there are trains connecting it to where they want to use it. So there's this interesting system here where you're building your own network because as you expand your network, it expands some of your options to build, but other people are able to use your network to add your goods to kind of build their own thing. It's a really dynamic system where I think the the state of the board is constantly changing and your options are constantly expanding.
Yeah. And it's tied very much to what you're trying to do in the game because all of those tiles that you're taking from your player board, which is robust uh and putting it out here on the uh the main board are ultimately trying to get flipped. And when you flip these, it's when resources have been taken from them in many cases. Uh in other cases, it's when you sell those buildings, you're going to flip them. These are the main ways you're going to be scoring points. And that happens at the end of era one and the end of era 2. And that's what we'll use to segue into some of the differences between Pittsburgh and Birmingham. Because while this one does have an era 1 and era 2, some big differences include the fact that this game doesn't have any canals.
Yeah,
this is this is just trains. So it's another era. It's another geographic location. There are no canals here. And in in Birmingham and in earlier brass, there was arrow one which was all canals and then you removed those canals and then you went to trains and then the connections on the boards would be like, "Oh, there's new connections that are only trains that I couldn't use in arrow one." In this one, it's all train tracks. It's all the same trains, but you're going to be putting out these light train links and potentially some heavier train links, but you don't have just willy-nilly access to those. Yeah, it is. It is it's a completely different feel when it comes to what's resetting between the different eras because you remember you still take all the light trains off the board in between the eras just like you take the canals, but you're not replacing them with trains.
You're still using these same trains in era 2, but you have access to these heavy trains and you're going to start the game with one of them. You have to unlock more of these heavy trains by progressing through your playerboard, which you're going to see looks very different than the player boards in Brass Birmingham. But these heavy trains go on the board just like any other link. They give you some kind of bonus, but they stay. And that is king because if you have a really good spot secured on the board, you might want to use it with a heavy train in order to make sure that nobody takes that for the rest of the game. Each one of these trains give you powers. There's some that give you resources. There's some that let you put resources specifically on those trains that no one else can use. There's one that doubles your points. And there's a really cool one, the switch one, that actually lets you take that heavy train and swap out an opponent's train. So, if they're really holding on to a space that you really want because it's worth a lot of points, you can now do that.
It's different. It's interesting. And it ties the trains more into your playerboard because you still have to progress up these different columns in order to gain access to those trains in the first place. Yeah, those trains are interesting because the other thing they do is at the beginning of era 2, the ones that have stayed out, if you're fortunate enough or good enough rather to get more than that starting heavy train out on the board, that's just that much more of your network that you have out on the board for the next era because when all the trains wipe, you're really just left with the buildings you put out there. And even then, a lot of the starting buildings are going to go away. So, the map is going to sort of clean up quite a bit. I will say though, one difference between this and Birmingham is I think this map cleans up a little less than it did in Birmingham. Obviously in Birmingham, no links stayed whatsoever. All the canals went away, so no links are going to stay, but the buildings I think you're going to be able to get maybe a little less of the buildings out in this game than you might have gotten out in Birmingham.
Yeah, but you can get more trains. So that's that's the the other side of that coin. And there's one more thing you're putting out on the board that kind of counts as a link. But this is going to bring us back to another major difference with Pittsburgh. We have a new resource. Well, actually, we have four new resources. And you'll see we've got the coal and the iron like we had before. But we also have coke and steel, which I found out coke is not a drink. It was used in the oil manufacturing process.
But we also have a very special resource, which is oil. And this oil is kind of going to take the place of what beer did in Birmingham. You're going to be producing this oil and you're going to use it when you sell your buildings. But unlike Birmingham, there's not a building you can build in order to produce the oil. The oil is kind of already out there in the form of these oil fields. And you'll see these new links that are not tracks. They're like oil links. You will have pipelines in the game. And you start with one of these pipelines that you can place out. And when you do, you'll be flipping these tiles over and these will be producing oil for you. But again, anyone can use this oil. This isn't like a special oil. So you don't get that free transport. You still have to transport it through your networks, but people will be taking this oil from you to sell their buildings, but every time they do, it's going to pass through your pipeline and give you some kind of benefit. So that's a completely new idea that you actually have some links now that give you bonuses when people use them.
Yeah. And when you put those pipelines out there, those are also going to remain out there from era 1 to era 2. So those pipelines, you know, earlier games didn't give you anything when things passed through any links. These do. So strategic placement of these pipelines. And you're all going to start with one. But again, as you move up your playerboard in that first era, you might focus on moving up those particular columns so that you can get more of those pipelines out
and hopefully get some of those bonuses as people use them.
Now, what's cool, they actually give you like a second little pipeline. It's a broken pipeline. If you haven't upgraded to a point where you've unlocked more pipelines, but you want to secure a spot, you can place a broken pipeline down and still flip the tile, get the benefit benefits for flipping the tile, and then later you can replace your broken pipeline with one of your own. Nobody else can take that spot. So, you're basically claiming a spot even though you don't have one available, but when you do get available, you switch it out and this one comes back to you and you can use it to secure another spot. So, it's kind of a cyclical thing you can do. It's almost like a two-step process to building these pipes.
And yeah, that oil is going to be used like beer when generally you're selling the buildings or the industries that you've put out on the board. A couple notes on the other resource types though. Coke, steel, all of these come into play with all of the things that you're generally building. Uh, as you can see down here, there's a little chart here. It's going to cost iron and coal for the pipelines and the normal trains. Cost two steel for the heavy trains. That's something you're gonna want to pay attention to because even though you start with a heavy train, it's not so simple to just go out there and build a heavy train link. Now, with that said, one other interesting thing here is we've got Cornelius Vanderbilt, which didn't really exist. Uh, this function didn't exist in Birmingham. You can always just go to him and spend money to get these resources if you're not connected because obviously generally speaking you need to be connected to some of these resources before you're able to pull from them.
But he now this is not cheap but you it's not cheap at all.
You can go to him and spend seven or $10 to get some of these resources that you need to get some of those things out in a pinch. And this emphasizes the tightness of money in this game. It's always been sort of a tight situation. This is a game where you're going to be likely taking out loans. Uh in this game, when you take out a loan, you're going to move your income marker back, uh but get what? 30ucks,
$30. So, it can be a lot a lot. But you take income after every single round, after every player at the table has taken their turn, everyone gets income based on your income marker where it is. And everyone starts at zero, but you can move that income marker quite a bit through a variety of different things on it down. If you take too many loans, you're paying during the income phase.
You can also take it down. So going to the negatives and taking uh income where you're actually paying can hurt significantly and you can even go bankrupt in which case you lose an insane amount.
40 points. But I I do want to talk about just for a brief second the impact of having these new resources. I mean it gives you a lot more to think about. A lot of these buildings are requiring the new steel and the new coke resource as well. Especially some of like the smelting plants that provide iron and steel require coke. So you have to find a way to get them. You can upgrade some of your coal plants into coke plants to you know produce coke. But just like in Brass Birmingham and past brass games, there is an element of waiting and saying, "Do I want to upgrade my coal into the coke to Parad Coke and risk other people using it or do I want to wait and hope that somebody else buys this coke to build like an iron and steel plant and then I can skip the coke process and just take their iron and steel off their board?" I mean, that was a big factor in timing when it came to the previous Brad games, but I think that timing factor is even more emphasized now for multiple reasons.
Yes.
For one, more resources means you'll need to time more. But the other one is these markets actually being printed on the board and so spread out. In the past games, there were different places you could connect to, like the coal market connected in multiple different cities. people can build those iron works and you could connect to that to buy, but it was generally one market. Yeah, you bought and sold from that same market no matter where you were on the board. Now, we have these very, very specific markets. So, timing matters. You have a little bit more control when you are producing goods and trying to sell them to the market. You might not be connected. This market might be empty, but if you're not connected to it, you're not selling to it, which could be good or bad based on whether you want the money now or whether you actually want to use your resources. that whole aspect of the game was not there in the in the previous ones.
Yeah. And another area where timing is very crucial is these new premium sales tiles
deals. So when you're selling and taking the selling action and taking some of those tiles that you've built out there and flipping them, uh, a lot of those are going to give you the opportunity to have these little stars on them. And if you flip enough in one sale action to get anywhere from five to
seven, I think
seven stars,
you can actually get this bonus. This is sort of a first person to do this gets this bonus, flips the tile, shuts that down. So the interesting dynamic here is like do you sell when you can or do you wait and wait and then sell and jump on this? You have to pay attention to whether other players are going to do the same. Now, the dynamic that's working against that is all the locations that you're selling at also have kind of first two bonuses as well. So, if you're the first person to sell goods, you're going to get six points. And then you flip that over, no one else is going to get those. So, you could take those opportunities or you could wait to get these bigger sort of premium sales.
Yeah, that's a balance. And also, there's an action efficiency to that as well. The longer you wait, the more you can sell with one action, the better it is. But you are going to notice that there are less spaces to sell in this game. There are only four spaces to sell. And this one right here, this token, that's kind of a wild that lets you sell your kerosene and manufacturing. The first person to sell this gets $12. But then this tile becomes dead. You cannot sell there. And then now we only have three markets where I think in Birmingham there was markets more surrounding the board. And each market had individual Yeah. I like could sell two things there. But now we've kind of got these things spread out. And then there's one that lets you sell your automobiles and trains, which that might help you get these premium deals, but man, they are hard to build because you really have to work your way up to those.
Yeah. No one's going to be doing that early on in the game. Now, a lot of the things that we've talked about that add sort of not complexity, but more depth to the game are balanced out by some things that make things more flexible. Like we said, Vanderbilt makes things more flexible because it gives you the option to do things when you thought maybe otherwise couldn't. But also the way wilds work in this game is very different. In Birmingham, there were wild cards and you would take one of your actions to discard a card and two more to take two of those wild cards. In this game, there's whiskey. And what this also brings in is sort of a geographical or a positional rather uh strategy to this because there are normal actions that you would otherwise take that might grab you some whiskey around the board. When you build a link or when you build a particular train, your heavy train that you start with, when you build it, you get a whiskey.
The beautiful thing about whiskey is once you have that and you can just basically store whiskey tokens, you can spend those to make cards that you play purely wild.
Yeah. which is nice. Yes.
I mean, it gives you a level of flexibility. It also gives you a level of unpredictability because in a previous one, if you wanted to get somewhere, like you wanted to get to Philadelphia and you had nothing in your hand that let you get to Philadelphia. Okay, let me take an action to discard to get some wilds. And everyone around the tables, oh, I wonder, you know, now he has those wilds. In this, it could be like, I don't think you have any way of getting there. We're down to our last two cards. I'm confident that you can't get there. Oh, but you have whiskey. So, now I'm worried that you could go anywhere. It's effectively like as soon as someone gets their first whiskey, it's like they have a wild in their hand at any time, no space on the board is safe or guaranteed for you to take. Even if you know those cards are out of the game because there's this whole distribution of like you can look at it and say, "Okay, well, in a three-player game, there's only two Philadelphia cards and they're both been played, so but you know, I'll use my whiskey to get there anyway."
Whiskey can also be used to kind of boost the value of your deal to like meet these stars. Personally, I mean that that can be huge. I think they're just so much better used as wild. Like it's hard to turn down that flexibility.
It depends, right? Like if you have six stars in your sale,
sure
and you have a few whiskey, spending one of those to get to the seven.
Yeah, probably worth it.
Are you going to hold up that much whiskey? I don't know. It's a It's a valuable resource. Technically, I think that adds like a sixth resource to the game. Although whiskey is treated
very differently, but
it is. Yeah, it feels like a different than a resource. It does, but it does add more competitiveness. Like David said, some of these spots out here give you whiskey. And also, we kind of brushed over this, but when you flip these different oil fields, they'll come down here. And each one of these has some different bonuses. So, there is kind of a race. If people are flipping these and you notice this one gives whiskey, and it hasn't been discovered yet. I want to go to I want to try to get to a undiscovered one. Maybe that's the whiskey one. That might really help me out.
Yeah. So, overall, like I said earlier, this is just a more developed version of the game. So, if you're a fan of brass
Yeah. We can't imagine that you're not going to be a fan of this. Ryan has more experience playing brass than I do. I would say you think this is based on your experience the best version so far.
I do. I mean I I honestly do. I thought when when Brass Birmingham introduced that beer mechanic, it just added such a new dynamic to the game. We're seeing that again. The oil changes up that formula, these new resources and the new player boards are designed in a really smart way. They require more things, but we have some buildings in here that give you extra abilities. We have buildings that give you free sales actions, that give you oil when you make them, that give you like if you build your locomotive industry, you get points for every heavy train you've put on the board, which is crazy. So, there's just a lot more you can do. And if you're actually looking at the playerboard right now, you'll see arrows pointing in all these different directions. It's not so simple as just like
going straight up.
You're sometimes you're curving over, you're skipping things, and it's a really cool uh thing that they've done with the playerboard.
Yeah, I think this is the way I like to put it. If you're sitting down with a pe b bunch of people who've played brass Birmingham in the past and you're teaching this every time you get to a new thing where you're like well and then this one has this like the trains on the playerboard the options to cut over to other columns when you're going up these columns all of the different things that we've talked about all of those are going to elicit a reaction that's like oh cool
yeah very
very I can't imagine anyone hearing about any of the new things and going oh like it it's only like a or interesting yet it doesn't like change the game, right? It doesn't make it This is not a different game. This feels like brass. This feels like brass, but it feels like the version of brass that you might want to play, especially if you've played brass for a very long time. I think it's just the next step.
It's been almost 10 years since brass has come out.
Doesn't feel like it, but yes, it's been a while. So, like people have been playing Brass Birmingham. I know there's people that will always want to play Langenshshire because it's the uh you know the original whatever this might not be, you know, as tight of a game as those are, but for me, I like the amount of flexibility. I like I found myself using Vanderbuilt a lot more than I thought I was, even though at the beginning of the game, those prices seem daunting. Later, you're like, I really need that steel. $10 doesn't feel too bad at the moment.
Yeah. And I would say, too, for those of you who are feeling like, oh, that flexibility, is it like uh dumbing down the game? Not at all. Not at all. This is
you need so many more resources to do things.
If anything, there is much more to consider when you're playing this game. I think by adding that stuff that you need to consider and that depth, they've just simply balanced that out by giving you some flexibility in some respects. And honestly, for a gamer like me, it just makes it more fun to have that flexibility because it gives you more elements of glue to piece together what you're wanting to try to do. you don't run into as many of those situations where like you just can't do this. I mean, if you got the money,
yeah, you
you can I don't know that I would advise it, but it is a possibility here.
Yeah, I think for all those reasons, like you said, for me, this is the the pinnacle of of brass. They they really didn't they didn't add too much. They didn't change the core feel of the gameplay. They didn't change a lot of the core decisions. They just gave you more decisions to make, more to do, and I think honestly more fun to be had at the table.
Yeah. And if you have any more questions about the game or if you just want to talk about brass in general, please get down in the comments below. Until next time, make sure everyone has fun at the table and we'll see you then.