Beyond Solitaire Podcast 171: Geoff Engelstein on Kurt Vonnegut's Lost Board Game
Transcript
it's adbreak time I'm proud to announce that the Beyond soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University Center for Learning through games and simulations this week want to remind y all that CGS continues to offer classes in partnership with Gen Con and the next one starts on October 14th veteran instructor aloy Lanta will be teaching when Worlds meet mechanics turning fiction into games I know this class is going to be amazing and you should absolutely sign up for it also if you want to support this podcast please visit patreon.com beon soliter and help me keep the lights on but for now let's get on with the show hey Gamers this Liz DAV from Beyond solitier and this week I'm on the Pod with special returning guest Jeff engelstein he is a game designer and educator and we're going to talk some awesome stuff today how you doing Jeff I'm doing okay thanks for having me on so there are a million things that we could talk about because you do so many things but this episode I want to devote to your new interest uh which is finding unpublished games by people who are famous for other things and then bringing them to light so let's go ahead and start with Kurt vonet we had a really good Kurt vonet party at Gen Con but for those who weren't there uh what's the what's the short version uh well um it's it's sort of been an interesting hobby of of finding this stuff so I'm sure we'll get get into a little bit of H some of the craziness that's happened but yeah so in the 1950s um Kurt vaget uh had published his first novel and he was not doing um
it was critically well received but financially was not paying that well and he had two little kids and a third on the way and so he decided that he needed to do something else to supplement his income or perhaps even replace writing and so he decided to design a board game which was a just terrible terrible plan uh as any of you have designed board games know not the most lucrative of professions um but uh that's that's what he desided so he designed this game called GHQ and um tried to get it published and no one was interested in it and and he ended up shelving it and went back to writing and shortly thereafter cat's cradle came out which is his first uh there's a few other books in there but that was the first big one that really kind of settled things for him financially and he was fine from there on out um and obviously became you know one of America's Premier writers of any type um even though he's often classified as a science fiction writer um and uh so I had read that anecdote more than a decade ago at this point in some biography or just article about vaget and of course it you know Peak my interest it's like oh he he designed a board game and I tried to find out something about it and uh I uh did up some uh just did some searching on the internet and poking around and I found nothing about it uh and um ultimately I uh learned that all his papers he had passed away at this point he died in like 2007 something like that
all his papers were at Indiana University um and I reached out to to them to see if they had anything they said they could not advise what they you know any any information about it unless I had permission from the family so I had to like find out who was managing the estate I spoke to him and you know so the whole process took a while but ultimately I did get the papers um uh the the there was a whole carton labeled board game materials as part of his uh uh his stuff and so um they uh they scanned all the materials and there was even some um later we found some some game pieces because it wasn't you know it was it's all his paper so a lot of stuff was mixed in with other stuff so it's kind of other stuff has come up over time um and uh yeah found out that he you know got the details about it and kind of cobbled together a set and tried it and it wasn't terrible it was actually a a pretty decent game um but it was interesting from a number of levels I mean first it's a um you just the fact that vonet designed this and that he was you know uh in the very beginning part of his career so it's just kind of an interested s of a sliding doors moment you know if this game had become popular where you know what would have happened um but also it's a it's a war game it's a two-player semi-abstract war game so it's uh just red versus blue and you have a headquarters you're trying to capture the enemy headquarters but the other pieces are infantry and armor and paratroopers and artillery so it's it's
very much drawing from his experiences World War II um and of course for any of you who have read slaughter house 5 and some of his other novels you know he was uh while he was in World War II he he was really clearly traumatized by it and um you know he was captured by the Germans was held uh prisoner in Dresden was there um during the Allied bombings of the city and then um had to help with you know help cleaning it up and dealing with the dead bodies and everything it was just you know a very difficult for him as well you know obviously and many many other people um and that ultimately those experiences made it in slauer house five so the fact that when he s sat down to design a game he's like oh I'll I'll design a war game you know and it's not in any way ironic or anything so that's that's kind of interesting so uh anyway so yeah since the game was good and um you know it had some interesting historical aspects to it we I said you know let's let's try to bring it to life um and um we put together a deal uh with the family and also with Barnes & Noble um so in the United States this is going to be available basically exclusively through Barnes & Noble um in October and um uh should be up for pre-sale by the time this airs if you'd like to to order a copy uh and um also at the vaget Museum and Library Museum in Indianapolis will also be selling copies of it and we're working on various deals other places so uh so
that's kind of the the origin of it I mean it was you know just just sort of poking and poking and poking and poking and just being persistent and eventually it uh uh was able to uncover all these materials so did you have any intentions regarding this game when you started poking around or did you do this just out of pure curiosity it was just out of pure curiosity yeah it wasn't until I got my hands on and started playing it I was like oh you know maybe maybe it's something it's worthwhile I mean if I had played it and it was absolutely terrible or if the G the rules weren't even really finished or whatever you know I mean I S I would have let it lie but you know like I said it's got some interesting aspects to it what made you so determined to see this particular board game that you were willing to track down the library talk to the family go back to the library Etc I think it's just sort of a general character flaw of mine uh I don't take hints that the universe is trying to give to me uh so it was just kind of you know persistence and you know I was just interest you know just the Curiosity of it you know we we have a saying in our family you know when when things get kind of crazy or we try to do something and it's like it's we go want to go somewhere and all a sudden it starts a blizzard starts or whatever we're like you know at certain point we will just turn other say well this has turned into a quest now you know it's it's now it's it's the the obstacles have made us even more determined to to do it and I I think
this just entered into Quest territory at a at a certain point well you got to love a good quest uh the other kind of question that that that popped up as you telling about this is you mentioned there's an entire box of just board game materials with more things popping up so what kind of stuff goes into a whole box of board game materials it doesn't sound like you just found like a neat little game like with the rules attached Tada so what did you find we found there was a lot so um there was about five or six different versions of the rules um there was a lot of handwritten notes of his trying to work through different Mech mechanisms and scribbles and stuff like that um there were the letters that he wrote to Publishers his pitch letters there were the rejection letters back from the Publishers there was patent applications he tried to um apply for a patent for this or at least he looked into it um it's unclear if he actually really filed to to try to get it or or not but he certainly talked to some lawyers about it so there's just a lot of that other kind of Correspondence um there was um a um one of the Publishers like got a got a prototype and sent him a list of rules questions and so he kind of responded to that so there was a lot of different stuff it's interesting you know I mean it was a I I guess now if you were looking at someone you'd have to get into their email and see stuff that was sent you know which it's interesting that you know we had physical copies but also you know he made copies of stuff he was sending to other people so um you know like I said a letter that he sent back
to the publisher he typed it and and made a copy of or either retyped it again I don't think they were really copy machines back then so maybe had carpon copies or something like that so um so there was a lot in there there was also some pieces um that we found later he um he cut them all out of wood with a jigsaw um so his prototype sets uh you know were also kind of floating around somewhere so so we got those as well so yeah I you know it it wasn't like files and files and files and files of stuff but you know it was a good 60 to 70 Pages worth of materials that we we went through that is fascinating so you know the game that's being released through Barnes & Noble is a complete playable game which set of rules did you use for that game and how did you determine what to do when there were ambiguities I mean you're designer yourself um you know what kind of arbitration I guess went into getting the game into the form were going to have it in um the rules one of the first things that I tried to do was figure out which rules were kind of the order of the rules because none of them were data they all had years on them they all said 1956 uh but they were all the same year right so this all happened over the course of a single year that he that he developed this and tried to sell it and then you know ultimately it was 1957 when he got the rejections back but all rules were done in 56 so the years there was no they weren't dated so just kind
of from Context Clues um you know some of the late some of the rules were a little bit more detailed had had better illustrations even though they all the illustrations were handdrawn they just looked a little more polished um so that was kind of interesting it was a little bit like a uh you know a treasure hunt or you know a little of a detective game of like okay so yeah this this paragraph was in here and so we can kind of tell that this must have come after this so we did a lot of that um and then for for ambiguities I mean there was there was some contradictory version so uh we um uh we tried to you know I I tried to take the rules that I thought were best um and uh or or made the game a little more interesting um he vacillated on a couple of different rules back and forth in different versions so I felt like you know we kind of take a pick at which way we landed um and then when we were playing there were some rules that just weren't in there at all um and uh so which we recognized as we were doing some testing so you know we just kind of made a judgment call about what we felt you know just thematically made the most sense like there's pieces like there's a rule that you can't move you know a piece cannot be in a a space that's under bombardment from enemy artillery for example right but there are some pieces tanks and mobile artillery that can move two spaces well almost every piece just moves one space it's know if I mentioned but it's on an 8 by8 checkerboard kind configuration just so
you can kind of picture it in your mind um and um you know but it didn't say for the pieces I can move two spaces could I move could I Dash through an enemy bombardment and go to the other side or you know did it kind of create like a wall that I I was considered to enter each space so so for for gameplay reasons and just you know kind of thematic reasons we we decided to rule that it would you could not move into even if you're mov two spaces you couldn't move at any point Enter a square that was under an artillery apartment so um so but generally it was you know we didn't have huge changes to make now honestly I did not approach it as a real developer I kind of approached it more as a historian I guess than a developer right I was not looking at it and saying okay you know he's just submitted this game to Jeff's publishing company and now I'm going to you know bring this to the next level and make it be what I want to be right I mean I wanted it to be an expression of his vision so maybe some rules that you know I thought maybe could have been a little better or whatever you know we decided to you know we're just going to leave it the way that Kurt had it he thought it was done he sent it out to Publishers right so he he thought it was finished um so I decided to just kind of respect that and put it out more as a um historical thing there's there's nothing that's so egregious that I would want to put out like a a vonet version and you know a
more modern updated version or something like that so it wasn't there wasn't anything that that was terrible when you say we we were doing things we decided Who falls under that umbrella of we well it's partially the Royal Wii I mean it was mostly me but I played with my kids I played with some other people you know I I kind of bounc some ideas off different people but there was no one person um we've the in the very very beginning when we're first talking about this we've gone through a couple different cycles of trying to publish this um I was working with Steven bonor of stronghold games at the time it's back in like 2012 something like that 2013 um so we were going to publish it under stronghold and that we were not able to put a deal together at that time um and now then when the the pieces kind of fell back into place again recently about three years ago no pun intended um then uh you know I decided to publish it myself under my own G so so so he was also involved in some of the play tests and things like that so you just said 2012 2013 how long have you been working on this project I've been working on this for about yeah over about 10 over 10 years was when I first heard about it and when I first made contact when I first made contact with the family was like 2013 something like that it's been a long time coming so that I mention the quest yeah no that's a good Quest it's like it's like a Trojan War approaching Quest y um okay so here's my question then um
so one thing that you mentioned earlier was that Kurt vonette felt that he was done that the game was done and so you wanted to kind of leave things in place but he was also submitting to Publishers what do we know I guess about board game publishing at that time like if it had been accepted do we know anything about whether the game would have been developed and what kind of play testing it received I actually don't know about that aspect of of history of board game publishing um we're pretty sure based on his correspondence and just discussions with the family and stuff like that that he just play tested himself with his kids and the neighborhood kids and F you know his friends and family play testing and now when we talk to um you know when we talk to people at designers when I'm talking you know they I always say like don't just test with friends and family right you got to go to just blind play test and third parties or whatever and there's no evidence that he did that um so uh it's it's unclear what happened it's also you know obviously at least one of the Publishers tried to play it and had some rules questions so they messed around with it a little bit but um you know it's not you know I I don't know how what level of play testing and development they did um you know I I think back then probably not that much play testing or development was really done on that level I I feel like it was a little bit more of a kind of an oour period in a sense for these you know
more sophisticated games um you know I think that maybe you know the sub subtext perhaps of your question is like would it have been popular maybe if it had been published right you know what would it yeah or more like would it have been a different game than what we're going to get to see yeah I mean I I don't it's it's impossible to answer that I I don't think it would have been that different um but I you know I think that there was definitely innovation in the game there was there was some stuff that I had not seen before in games from the 1950s or early 1960s so I thought think that that was you know very interesting um you know it's and I I I looked into the Publishers that we know that he sent it to and the types of games that they were doing and this was a very different Beast than other stuff they were doing which I think was part of the problem is there weren't really Publishers doing war games of this type that were a little bit more technical um you know a lot of the you know there were plenty of World War II games but they were AED kids and a lot of little plastic soldiers and you know it was more it wasn't as sophisticated I guess as as you could say as this game is so that leads me to another question I know very little about gaming of the 1950s um what what did the landscape look like at that time and then what do we know if anything about kvon get's engagement with the popular games of his
time um there wasn't that much on the war game landscape like in the early 50s um there were some of these I have to check on the dates there was the American Heritage games which may have come out in the early 50s or maybe early 60s I could be wrong about that but I do know for a fact that um this there in 1957 so so this is 56 was and he was working on this right 57 uh so it was was when the Publishers finally rejected it so I mean if it gotten accepted it would have come out saying 58 right so in 1957 and 58 three games were published um one was um tactics two from Charles Roberts um so tactics one had come out before that but it was very limited run I I possible vaget had seen it but I'm not sure um but tactics 2 is considered one of the foundational war games of uh you know of our time it's you know it's played on a square grid not a hex grid um but it's got a lot of different counters they have you know number different they can move different distances and different combat things I think it was the one of the first CRTs combat results tables um different terrain and stuff like that and you could move every single unit each turn um it was a you know it had a lot of the features that we saw in um see in modern war games and eventually you know Charles Roberts you know turned into Avalon Hill it next came after tactics
he was Gettysburg and kind of Off to the Races so that one came out in 57 um right around that same time we also have uh risk risk was released in 1958 um so that's also right around that time and obviously you know a major military simulation of sorts you know but certainly a military game and a war game and one that you know achieved popular success more than tactics 2 did um and then the third game that also came out like in 58 was diplomacy um by Alan cam camer I forget I forget his last name I apologize but um and diplomacy also very you know sophisticated game you know so really all I mean people aren't still playing tactics too but they're certainly playing its descendants and risk is still played and diplomacy is still played you know here's here's three games that came out within 12 months of each other that really defined the era and set the foundation in a lot of ways for Modern War gaming and and just you know gaming in general so um you know if it had come out in that kind of time period I think it's entirely possible that um it would have uh you know done pretty well or you know there was certainly something in the air you know around those years around military simulations maybe it was far enough away from World War II you know I guess it was the Korean War was happening around then it wasn't quite Vietnam yet when you know those feelings about the military and US involvement in war
changed um so you know I I I think it may have done uh pretty well but you know all those games came out after he designed it um but you know whatever inspired those designers may have also you know partly inspired him it's a cool way to look at it and then just out of curiosity how did the publishing deal with Barnes & Noble come about and what is the balance between you know this game is going to be popular and people are going to buy it and this is a literary project we just want to be part of um one when when I decided you know I wanted to to publish this game and kind of get it out there into the world you know you know it's I wasn't sure if it was really you know if it was just released if it didn't have vet's named attached to it right and it was just released I I don't know how well it would do it's a very different game than what's out on the market sure um and you know later we can get into the details of how it works if you're interested but um it's uh you know I it's it's not going to be the next arcs or whatever right it's not going to you know it's it's not ADV ing the state of design in 2024 um and you know I I didn't want to just like sell it so I didn't you know just selling through normal channels I felt would be challenging um
and and honestly not something that I was particularly interested in you know I wasn't looking to start a business of being a publisher I've never published a game before and I could have got maybe try to get another publisher involved but you know we were kind of you know I I kind of put this this deal together so I reached out to Barnes & Noble it seemed like a natural fit because of the literary aspects of it um I don't know if it's still up there but I mean in in in the olden days of Barnes Noble you know they used to have all these big wooden woodprint uh cutout uh figures of famous authors that would decorate the stores yeah I haven't seen this in a while but I know exactly what you're talking about yeah and one of them is caronut uh so he was all kind of like a semi-official mascot of the store in a way and with them being so such a big proponent of games and modern games and that's kind of a big part of their strategies is to sell games also it just and this one like you said it kind of straddles like it's a game but it's also historical document you know so it just seemed like a slam dunk that Barnes & no would be interested in and ultimately I we were able to put a deal together and they've been very enthusiastic about it and you know we're you know they're putting a lot of marketing muscle behind it so so hopefully um it will appeal both to game players as well as people interested in his work and you know kind of how this how this comes out um so in the game to try to you know fulfill that promise we have
um there's a in addition to the game itself and the rules there's also a separate 24 page historical commentary booklet and in that we include I I included a lot of uh uh you know the notes so out of those 70 pages we extracted a bunch of his notes and and photographs of some of the original play materials along with some annotations I'm a little you know I I love the minutia so like we like part of the running theme of all this stuff is like how some of these individual little rules the way he explained it changed in the different versions and what that means and stuff like that so it's it's kind of a close reading of the rules and so you can see some of his handwritten notes and diagrams and stuff like that as part of it so we very much tried to put it in it bring out the hisory historical nature of you know his design process as well as put it in the context of his larger career even though this was early on just from a life standpoint you know this was a very eventful time period for him um his um so you know I I we we wanted to make sure that people understood that and and so that people even if they never played the game would get some interesting information out of it just from be able to see it so I me sometimes one of the push backs I get is you know people like oh you're you know you're you're exploiting him by you know publishing this now um and you know it's it's you should just let by gon be by gon and you know you know he shouldn't bring this out and I you know I I I
understand under certain circumstances that that applies and his feelings I you know recently there was a controversy with um like Harper Lee who wrote To Kill a Mockingbird where you know it was an unfinished manuscript which was her sequel to te Killa Mockingbird was discovered and uh but Harper Lee didn't didn't think it was good enough to publish right she she didn't you know that's why it wasn't published so I can understand in that circumstance that people being unhappy about that coming out being published and then when it came out to much fanfare a lot of people read it were like oh this isn't very good you know and and other people were like well yeah you know she knew it wasn't good that's why she didn't want it to see the light of day you know and so it's kind of tarnishing the Legacy and I think there was another one recently maybe Gabrielle Garcia Marquez I I don't remember but there was another instance of that and it happens sometimes and it's really interesting historically but you know for Scholars perhaps to see these unpublished works but just to publish it as like a finished work is not I don't think makes you know is unfair to the authors a lot of times there's a reason why they didn't want it to come out this I think is different because it's he as I said he thought it was done right he's got a bunch of pitch letters you know he's there's there's one we include in there you know of his pitching and he's like you know this is done this is ready to go I've played it a thousand times I think it's you know it's ready to go to a wider audience right so so this is
just giving it the exposure that he wanted it to have anyway this is not something that he worked on it thought it was terrible and shoved it in a box so um so you know that was that was part of our motivation as well I'm personally super excited about it both as a historian and as a gamer uh but then you know thinking about this game as a historical object so when you have the playable game with the rule set to learn the game from how much of the aesthetic is original to vonet and then what artistic choices did y'all make as a team publishing it and then for the text of the rules are we looking at vag's words edited or or did you write a rule set that would be comprehensible to a current gamer but like but did you do he wrote his an Old English yes the anent time rules we rewrote the rules I I we wrote the rules um and you know whether people feel they're better or worse I will leave up to them because in in the historical commentary book that you can see you can see his you know what we think is the is his most recent version of the rules so you can kind of compare and contrast uh the way we express it um but um yeah we we rewrote the rules but we tried to keep as much as possible the aesthetic that we thought he might want uh you know and and not just the aesthetic that he might want but we also tried to make it look like it had been published in the 1960s um at least in terms of the board and the pieces and the cover I mean the
rules look modern um as I mentioned um but um for example the shap of the pieces right he actually Drew pictures he actually Drew like engineering drawings of of some of the pieces and we have uh photographs of some of the pieces he cut out of wood so the first version of the pieces were very pointy and not very sturdy so I think that the later versions they're they're a lot simpler shapewise um which I'm not sure if it's because he decided they were too sturdy or too too too dangerous but or if it's just because he was cutting out with a jigsaw and it was just going to be easier for him to cut triangles and these fancy little Chevron shapes and stuff like that but it regardless we we the shapes of the pieces we generally kept to what he wanted we did tweak things a teeny bit the headquarters he just had as a plain Square we made it a star um and the other thing that we did was also for kind of consistency and uh comp playability and comprehensibility so you know I think back in the 50s you know I remember even like you know there there's been very you know over the the decades obviously countless chess variants or chess like games of which I would kind of put this one in that category chess pieces you know one of the things you just expected to do as a player is memorize what the pieces do in the way that they move there's no hints on a chess piece you know uh for a standard chess thing or what it is or I
had this old TSR game called the fourth dimension where you could move you know was like played on sort of a circular is chess board and you could move pieces that were fancy alien shaped pieces but you just had a little reference card or had to memorize how the pieces moved right um we don't want I don't I feel like that's players don't want that anymore and I think we've learned that that's you know not as preferable um so we very clearly kept some very consistent things there there's two main classes of pieces infantry and artillery and all the Infantry pieces have a white triangle on them and all the artillery pieces have a white rectangle on them um so that um uh that that clearly differentiates which category they're in and also uh as mentioned some pieces move faster so just about every single piece moves one space the pieces that move two space we we put two black circles on them um and the piece and and the artillery can fire either two spaces or three spaces and so we put either two little stars or three little stars on the on those artillery pieces so that just at a glance you can see what it is you know they all have different shapes as well you know the mobile artillery and the heavy artillery and the regular artillery and you know they all but but they also have little screened iconography on them which was not common at all in the 50s and the 60s um but um you know we felt the modern player would appreciate it makes it a lot easier to jump in and see what you're doing and right away focus on the strategy of the game and not have to worry about hey
which which piece was this one again and get surprised when your opponent all a sudden captures you and you didn't realize um so that was that was a big thing that we did um but so to to try to keep it the same but the other thing which we really struggled with was the cover of what to make it look like so um I I drove so the the art direction of the game was done by Bill Bricker um who's a longtime um artist for illustrator for stronghold games and i' I've worked with him on a number of other projects so and I know he's a huge fun of to get found so I was excited to involve him on this project but I was driving him crazy because I'm very bad at expressing stuff artistically about what I'm looking for uh and he just went through thing after thing of thing so initially so we wanted to do a couple of things we want initially when we were sitting that look at it we're like we want it to be have kind of a classic look we don't want it to be a celebration of war or battle because that's not his legacy right he was not you know this game set aside the rest of his career even stuff he was writing contemporaneously with this was not you know proar and any stretch of the imagination the um uh the he was writing a book called um Sirens of Titan as he was working on this game I believe uh it's a little unclear but it was published like in 59 so with the exact you know when he was
working on polishing but it's in that same time frame right so of Titan for those of you have not read that um is a it's a very weird book like a lot of his stuff it's it's his first first first book in 55 or 54 was was player piano which is a more Normal book um but when you get to Sirens of Titan which is a second book it's a lot he's already kind of you know much more surreal and um and more vonat like uh but um you know one of the premises is that there's a big uh Martian Army on Mars of humans hum humans live on Mars and they're want to attack Earth um but the Martian Army it turns out is just you know and a lot of it is from the point of view of people in the Mars the army of Mars and the army of Mars is a joke it's a terrible thing none of the officers know what they're doing there's no purpose to it this whole thing is the whole Army gets sacrificed and the whole purpose of the army was much like Watchmen uh is is by attacking earth that it's going to help Earth's People Unite and find common ground and come together that's sort of person who sets up the AR the Mars Army to attack that's what they do but you know it's the Army is very much made fun of through the whole thing right it's you know it's treated very ironically um it's not like Battlefield Earth or War of the Worlds or you know something where it's about the the military um so the first thing we did with the covers you know we didn't want to you know we didn't want to just glorify a battle we didn't just want a battle scene or a war scene a picture of a big tank or something like that um so we tried more
Stark covers just like white or or just you know with a couple of faded backgrounds uh vonet also was very famously had Doodles in his books he has like these handdrawn illustrations of stuff that he did including some bombs with like skulls on them and some other things that he did and so we kind of adopted some of that type of iconography and put it in um and it just didn't quite look right we tried a lot of different things different color schemes it wasn't right um so then I told Bill I was like well let's maybe we go back and make it look like it's from the from the 50s and 60s like it came out at that time rather than you know being um uh you know a modern interpretation of what the cover would be and so we trotted out some of the old we looked at some of the old 3M game covers like acquire employ and feudal and Faxon five for those of you that are familiar with some of those older I have a copy of fax and five actually nice they have a real distinct look to the cover Twix was in that series too right uh and um so we we we did a scene Bill did a scene of two generals like leaning over a map pushing pieces around um and it was in that 60s style and he captured it's beautiful it just looked beautiful as a 3M you immediately looked at it like oh my God that's a 3M game cover for a game that you know never came out but maybe it could have if the cards had fallen differently but again it just wasn't quite right it still didn't didn't quite
capture something um and so we're trying a bunch of different things and then at one point I was just talking to Eno tul um and just mentioned to him that we were working on this and just to see pick his brain see if he had any any thoughts on it and he's he's like you know he says if I was gonna do this he says uh he said I'd love to work on it but I'm super busy because he's already got always got 8,000 different projects if you don't know you know he's a very famous board game illustrator and cover designer he's done some awesome stuff um but um he sent me an image of a of an old book cover from the 60s like a pulp fictiony kind of a book with just like that looked like it was made out of paper cutouts and stuff like that he's like this is what I would like it to look like and uh this is what I think it should look like if I was doing it and I looked at it it was like instant like oh my God yes this is this is like the key to unlock this and so so we played with that a little bit and ultimately we brought on Ryan goldsbury um to to um to finish up the cover he is he's got a real 60s mod style to his work he's done the cover for covers for like burel Bros and uh you know uh other other games but it's always um if you know that work it's very angular very like spy versus spy from Mad Magazine right that's kind of his look and so it's sort of 60s Vibe um but it's also kind of edgy and and a little more modern looking and I you know he just and he
and Bill working together on that just HED out of the park so I just totally love the cover um and where we ended up on that so but again the intent was make it look as if it was an artifact that had dropped out of a time capsule from the 60s right that's that's was the look that we were going for and I think we ultimately you know were able to to kind of nail that probably a way longer explanation of what you're looking for no I actually really enjoy I I enjoyed that very much so before we move on for vaget I do want to ask one more thing I don't know how long I answer this trigger though so you mentioned um you know a game about war kind of being a bit in congruous with his written work how do you feel differently about vonette and about and about his body of work having spent so much time with the game that he made I think that he like all of us was a very complex and not you know multi-dimensional human being that changed throughout his life you know I think he had this very traumatic experience in World War II but I'm sure that when he came back it was very much um you know it was a victorious war and you know veterans were celebrated and you know I don't think he he had maybe not this he's just kind of suppressed it maybe you know I think it took him and and it took him decades to really write about it and in fact in in
slaughterhouse 5 when when he's either in the book or or I think you know writing about the book he said that you know he it took him like 10 to 20 years to write it just because he said he started to write it a zillion times he started to write about his experiences in World War II a ton of times and process that and he was just unable to until he had become a accomplished enough writer that he figured out how to tackle it right you know that the central metaphor although it's not treated as a metaphor in slaughterhouse fight but the central metaphor in that book is that he's become unstuck in time you know that he just is constantly as he goes through his life he shifts he jumps into the past he jumps into the future and he's you know just he's he's a time traveler that's unstuck in time is the way it's phrased there and it's you know it's treated as reality in the book but obviously it's a metaphor for you know dealing with trauma that just all a sudden thrust itself at you and you're there right all you know you're just you're just in the supermarket and then all of a sudden you're back on the battlefield right and the way that that can those thoughts can intrude on you so I I think it just took him time to process it and maybe this game was part of that maybe this was part of his denial of of what it was it's difficult to say um you know he certainly was treating it unironically he played a lot with his kids you know it was it was you know a fun family game
was was what he was trying to put together he wasn't trying to put together a gritty realistic indictment of War as in experienced On The Ground by soldiers so uh you know it's uh I I think that from that perspective it just it just showed me you know that people evolve and change um it also gave me the opportunity to go back and reread a lot of his older stuff that I hadn't read in a long time and even some new stuff that I had never read because I wanted to really read all the things he wrote right around this time period and understand them better to be able to put it into more context so that was um that was really fun and interesting for me to get to do that's awesome and so I I was planning to come here eventually you know that your your quest didn't actually stop with Kurt vonet you are now on another Quest well yeah this we'll see if this one happens I'm I have I'm still in the quest stage of pounding on the were to try to get some answers we'll see if anything happens or maybe somebody else is doing it but yeah a a friend called me um a couple months ago now um uh that um he's been working on a book about Stephen sanheim uh the um uh the song writer did you obviously did a lot of super famous musicals um from uh you know Sweeny Todd and to the woods and all kinds of stuff uh and um he uh so so he was hely into puzzles
sonheim did did lots of puzzles and famously did like treasure hunts for his friends and stuff like that and um uh my friend uh Barry Joseph is working is going to be publishing a book um I haven't seen a pu yet but I think it's coming out next year called matching Minds with sonheim which is a biography of sonheim specifically kind of focusing on this playful aspect of him with um you know with puzzles and games um and so he just called me one day out of the blue and said hey you know I was wondering I have a sort of an interesting proposition for you sonheim in his 20s designed a board game um that he tried to get published and was never published and it was lost in a house fire um and you know I he said I'd heard about this game it was called stardom and you know it was kind of based on the hwood stars and it never really went anywhere um you know what but he says that his sonheim just died a few years ago and there was an estate auction an online auction for his his estate and he said at the estate auction all of the game materials for stardom that were thought lost in a fire were found and they were all posted on the internet they were all scanned and posted on the internet as part of this auction and um he said got all the rules what I'd like to do is have you on I do a podcast I'd like to have you come on and we can read the rules together I've
already read them but I'd like you to read the rules cold and kind of give me your commentary as you're reading them and discuss what it is I was like I was like so you mean like you know so it's is weird it's kind of like the vonet thing and he said vonet thing what are you talking about why what do you he had no idea of this other project because it was interesting it was so analogous to it and also this game was designed right around the same time it was like 1955 1956 was the same time son design this game and Tred didn't get published which is weird also um although he was younger than vonet at the time he was in his 20s I think vonet was like 30 um anyway so so I checked it out and uh you know it it was interesting um and you know I'm trying to see if I can get the rights to publish that I've sent a couple of emails off to the estate it was originally up for auction it was part of the auction and then like the day before the auction it was pulled out of the auction oh so it didn't sell it we there's no it was not sold or it was sold privately I don't know so I've been reaching out to try to get more details and see what's going on uh but you know we did have you know it was posted and so we know all the materials so we know what the game was about um so it's uh uh it's called so as mentioned it's called stardom and the story is that he um sanheim either went to Hollywood or something he was inspired by a map he saw to the to the Holly the stars homes he got one of
those famous Hollywood mes to the stars homes in the 1950s and decided that that would kind of be a basis for a game so this is the game idea that he came up with so uh it's um so there's a map of the uh the board is just a map and apparently he got his mother his mother drew the map and colored it in for him because she was like an artist or something although it wasn't that great but anyway she his M his mom made the map and you you play a Starlet that has just arrived in Hollywood and um you uh have to advance through the different levels of stardom to try to reach the ultimate level level four or level five or something like that and the way that you go up to each level is you have to visit a house of a Hollywood star a female star all of the people in this the game are women you have to you have to visit the the the woman and I guess sleep with her and then you go to the next level and and um and then you got a you get a new Target of who you have to see but so basically you draw a card and it tells you the home of the person that you have to visit but first you have to visit like two or three other people's houses first and then go there and if the other players can guess which house you're going to then they can like knock you down a l um because it's a scandal they reveal that you've actually got a relationship with this person and it's a scandal and so you have to go back down a level and
ultimately you're trying to sleep with Norma Desmond who is the um from Sunset Boulevard uh the the main character who's the only fictional character in the whole game every other star listed on this board is an actual like was a real person at the time oh my God so it's like yeah that's so a giant lawsuit yeah so and there's a bunch of cards there's there's these rumor cards and certain points you can draw rumor card and it'll say like you know such and such a person throws a terrible party and you know you have to go back whatever it's all these current Hollywood rumors so I mean right off the bat all the names would have to be changed I mean I think it could be published just you know as historical thing just these were the names he had in there but yeah none of these people gave their permission obviously um but the other really interesting part about is so you got the C the casting couch Dynamics except it's sleeping with women instead of sleeping with men um but also the characters the players at each time you go up a level the game the original game came with um all these various accessories and when you went up a level each level had a specific accessory that the players had to wear so like a a tiara or a necklace or a bracelet or earrings or a boa right so you gradually like dress up in dress and then when the players pass each other on the board you also have to say something caddy to that person as you go by about a party you attended or
something like that they give some examples in the rules and even when the game starts you're supposed to say something you know kind of uh in in that vein there's a there's a very strong drag culture Vibe thing as part of it and it's very specifically in rules that it says like you know it you know you uses the he pronoun throughout the rules so it's clear in the rules that the the expectation is that a group of men would get together and play this game where they play a Starlet trying to sleep her way to the top with other women and they're dressing up as women and talking to each other as drag queens while they're playing this game now I think it's really so it's interesting particularly interesting because so Steven's onim decades after this would come out as as gay but you know here he set up a situation when he's like 22 or 23 right where he can invite his friends over to the house and say hey let's play this game and all dress up like women you know and do that in a way that's kind of socially acceptable right there's a concept in game design called the magic circle um which I'm not sure if you or your listeners has heard of but it was originally proposed by hazinga who was a Dutch Anthropologist in the 1920s and then it was popularized in the 90s by um Eric Zimmerman and another person whose
name is escaped me that wrote this book rules of play um and the basic idea is that when you start to play a game you enter a realm that's separate from The Real World right that that you you I mean at a very basic level you're adopting rules that you will abide by you know you will you know take your turn when it's your turn if you're playing Hanabi you're not allowed to speak right there's there's things you do because the rules say you have to do it and you are all agreeing as players that these are the rules of contact that we're going to do and that can be a very very powerful thing it can get people to do stuff that they normally wouldn't do right there's religion there's Cults there's a lot of other applications of this all of which hazinga discusses he he believes that like religion and and play and games are very related in lot of ways um but um and that's one of the things for example you know the Game Cards Against Humanity for example right it's got these horrible things written on cards and part of the fun of the game and I'm doing air quotes here right part of the fun of the game is that I can I can have Grandma over right and Grandma will re have will say this horrible thing that's on this card out loud to all of us which grandma and none of you would ever ever say in a million years but the rules say that you have to read the card out loud right and you can't choose whether not you're going to read it because if somebody else gives it you know some somebody else puts it in the pile if you're the judge you pick it up
the rules say you have to read the card out loud and people do it because that's the rules right so you can use for good and for evil this concept of the magic circle and so sonheim whether consciously or sub consciously is setting up an environment where he can explore his own sexuality with his friends with other people but in a safe way because oh you know worst case it's like oh you know now we're just screwing around we're just playing pretend you know it's not it's it's in the game it's the game is there those are the rules right I mean he wrote the rules but it doesn't matter once you know the rules have sort of this mystical ability themselves so I think that's really just from perhaps even more than the banet stuff right just in terms of his own psychology and his own journey I think is really really interesting um just a lot of it and and he fully intended like this dressup part to be part of it we also have his letters where he was pitching the game to Publishers and he says you know he says he says the the accessories that are in there you know they don't have to be like an actual boa and tiara you know they could be like made out of cardboard or card stock or something right but he he specifically you know he says you know that's part of it is the dressing up part of it is part of the whole experience that he wants to try to get across so um so he intended that to be part of the game and not just like his home brew thing uh and and also like I
said thought it was finished and in fact you know when he sent out he also said to Publishers he's like it could be you could it could be a whole line of games because we could do one stars and then we could do one about authors one about poets you know he listed all these other artistic things where I guess you could sleep your way up to the the top of the Poetry food chain that's that's G to go great oh yeah this thing's just a me too nightmare but uh so how did he pitch this like so it sounds to me like you know vonette was going for a fun family game I played this with the kids I play this with the neighborhood kids you know everyone loves it how did sonheim Pitch this like what go back and reread I'd like to be to reread the letters now I kind of just read it on the Fly we're doing it but um you know he was pitching it as you know kind of like it's campy it's you know adults getting together and you know C more of an adult thing with some family and you have a couple of drinks and you know have another couple over and you just kind of do this kind of just like a parlor game for life exactly definitely in the Parlor game vein yes it was very very different but like I said this was also this is like 1955 so it's like right around the same time frame and obviously you know when it was much more you know serious to be you know exploring homosexuality was a lot more in the 1950s than it is today so um so it's just interesting from that standpoint now the flip side of that game versus the vona game is it doesn't appear to be a very good game you know it's a rolling move uh you have to land
roll to land exactly on certain spaces you can get knockdown levels and the game would probably go on for a really long time although I think it's more about the experience of playing than actually winning you that game if I was going to do that game if I could find get somebody to respond to my emails uh that one I would definitely include like in as designed rules as well as here's here's a more modern gamer take of this if you want to you know try something a little bit more entertaining oh so that would be like a whole bigger project in a way then perhaps yeah and I'd have to see it and try it I mean I didn't I haven't actually played that one so maybe it's better than I think but it just it it seems to fall into all the the classic 50s just roll and move tropes you know lose a turn go back a level have to roll exactly the right number like I said all all those kind of things just are are in there so we want to include some way to mitigate it but I mean part of the fun of it it's not you're not you know you're not going to play that game for a strategic experience I mean it's just it's a goof Fest right so you're gonna want to play up that stuff but I think you'd want to make it tighter just to make it end faster and just take take away some of the rough edges Fair that's fair so you know you've got these two projects now the vonet project and the Sim project do you have other projects of this nature like going is this like a thing you want to do now I would love to do this as a thing I I don't know the sonim thing just kind of dropped into my
lap as I mentioned you know I I was not looking to do it specifically so uh you know I I've kind of kept my eyes open at this point of trying to see you know think about what other are artists might or other you know famous people might have dabbled in game design that just you know people that seem likely suspects but so far you know I don't have any other candidates so it's just sort of a a random thing at this point but if anybody knows chance if any listeners know of any you know any famous people that designed games before they were famous that never became published you know hey drop me a line fantastic I I kind of hope this continues and we can do another episode later because this was fascinating um so just some kind of softy questions to end off the interview so you've been playing all kinds of stuff that is in various stages of completeness it sounds like recently uh but what games have you been playing for fun um I well probably the most recent thing I I was up just at this SD histon East um and uh while I did some play testing there uh you know I did have an opportunity to play um an uh 1914 something 1914 by Maurice suckling oh crisis 1914 I think crisis 1914 yeah so I played that that was pretty that was fun uh enjoyed that um and um uh also F
you know this is a much heavier war game but the Napoleonic Wars um the mar Clin game uh from years ago so there was a big game of that so I enjoyed that so um but really I mean I you know I'm I'm kind of a grazer you know I'll play a game a lot of games once and then move on and something else and you know so it's I I just kind of play a game suck the life force out of it and then move on leaving withered husk behind me I mean fair enough it's how it's How all games should be played right and then sure and then uh if people want to follow your work online uh where can you be found um yeah best bet is uh so I'm on uh blue sky and Twitter or X I'm gonna keep calling it Twitter G englin so that's GN gel s n um also on substack I have a game Tech uh blog called uh which if you look at game Tech G te K is how that's spelled um so that's an occasional um posting I I try to do like once every two weeks um sometimes do more sometimes do less uh it's always free I I specifically keep it free because I feel if people pay for it I will um even though very kind people have offered to pay for it uh to for Content I I would feel much more obligated to actually do something on a regular schedule which I don't want to be bubbled into so it's just as a mood strikes me kind of a thing but uh that that's also a way to keep in touch with with what I've been
doing fair enough Jeff thank you so much for coming on and talking to us about your quest this was awesome hey Liz thanks so much for having me it was a blast all right uh so so hopefully by the time this comes out I'll be able to put a link in for pre-order at Barnes & Noble um so check the show notes everybody I can be found anywhere online is beyond soliter and everybody out there thank you so much uh please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming