Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 169: Torill Elvira Mortensen on Transgressive Play

Transcript 1:07:31

it's adbreak time the Beyond solitire podcast is proudly sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and as usual they're up to some amazing things they recently concluded a successful campaign on backer kit for eyeball to eyeball a lar about the Cuban Missile Crisis late pledges should be available soon also just a quick plug for myself if you want to support the show and help keep it going uh please do go to patreon.com beond soliter which pays for all of my hosting and subscriptions associated with the podcast and channel uh thank you so much for listening and let's get on with the show hey Gamers this is Liz Davidson from beond soliter and this week of the pot we have a very special guest this is Dr tural mortson uh she is Professor of digital media and Communications in the faculty of social sciences at Nord University how you doing today I'm doing very well thank you very much and thank you m much for having me here yeah I'm super excited to have you on uh because your work sensors around something that I actually think is very worth talking about um which is dark play so for people who have not heard the term dark play before um what does that encompass well um dark play is a it's say it's actually a term that shna out of New York University established about play that goes counter to to your expectations that plays with your expectations and often in very unpleasant uh manners uh

it can play with your fear or with your discomfort or with the in other in different ways play with the idea of playing so it can Encompass like a wide range of things I think I think when people say dark they think it definitely means bad but it sounds like this could also just mean mildly uncomfortable yeah it doesn't have to be bad it doesn't it it is it is something that um it is something that people like to to think about the idea of dark that it necess is uh is something that is morally bad and that is one of the issues why we started looking at it in the first place because uh people think about certain types of play as morally bad but this is these are types of play that challenge the Norms that challenge your idea what play is supposed to be uh challenge what you think uh society would expect from playfulness how did you become interested in this topic is gaming something that you were into for a long time or did you get into gaming because you had philosophical interests that were met by what was happening in the world of games um I was kind of both it I I started looking at gaming uh back in the 1990s uh wrote my first scholarly article on it in 96 I think it was uh published uh then I was writing about uh multi-user dungeons the text based

multi-user games and there not many people know about them anymore uh they were like the um written version of World of Warcraft really and uh yeah yeah it's say definitely if you have never heard I think there are muds still existing and uh definitely something that would be fun to look into uh the wonderful thing about muds is that you don't really need so much uh server space or so much knowhow in order to edit them so it's so there a lot of people making their own games and um I started looking into both at how the games were structured and what kind of people were playing and what kind of people were making games so that was my my PhD was about that but I started this because H and it was about uh it that was a very I guess philosophical reason because I had I'm a media scholar I come out of a very traditional media ER Direction and I used to teach uh and and I still teach uh uh journalism and public relations that is uh that is what I have been teaching most of most of my life so the reason I then started to look at games was that I I saw that the computer was going to change how we think about communication it was going to change how we structure it how we how we read how we communicate with each other how we search for information how we navigate in this uh entire communic communicative

structure and I had this hypothesis you can say uh that uh the compu computer games would be at The Cutting Edge of this change and if in order to understand what was going to happen we had to understand how computer games were driving the development of the personal computer and to a very large extent the computer have been driving that because you don't you don't buy a new expensive fancy computer in order to be able to use word better no that's true yeah I actually remember we got our very first family computer sometime in the the 90s it was an IBM and the first thing I did was play some kind of game on it yeah yeah it's not like you go oh yes I can write on it that is not the that is not the big Revelation and um um and and so I I started following up that Trend uh the first game I looked at was a um what we call a serious game it was an educational game uh you know to teach boys about sex uh sadly that there was a Norwegian government that uh that designed it the Ministry of Health uh it was never actually published because so we then we got a a Christian Democratic prime minister and he was like no we are not going to make it more interesting

for boys to have sex so can make it more interesting to them but you know well actually I I that was one of the one of these opportunities that I missed I should have told them I should have written an article that said if you publish this game it is so boring they will never want to have sex

again that's hilarious um all right so um when you were gaming in the 90s is that something that were also doing recreationally well I um I did start out uh playing around uh we we bought a computer in order to both my husband and I were working on master thesises and um at that point it it did actually make a difference if you were if you if you could write in a more efficient manner so we did buy a we did buy a computer in order to finish our thesis and it was a huge investment at the time it was like wow uh but we bought it we bought a used uh and it had it came with a whole bunch of of games so we started uh playing around with that of course and um that was basically it I've not looked back since amazing so you talked about your PhD being about like what kinds of people were playing games early on what did you discover about who was playing games in the early years and then how has that changed between that and now well it wasn't really about who were playing exctly who were playing games it was more about how they were using the game how they were interacting with it and how they uh uh understood themselves in relationship to the to the text of the game and it has it has changed

surprisingly little uh that first group of people who were who were both I because it was it was an amateur game I could I could talk to both the um designers and the people who were playing and the people who were designing and playing they were typical they were Typical Gamer nerds and they came from all sides of uh of the all directions they were you know a lot of them were were students at the University of High School uh some of them were uh had had dropped out and did other things some of them one of them was like this child genius Prodigy at like one of the really high level universities in the United States and uh and then here I was a like an aging G researcher at already a grown woman and almost too old for people's concept concept of who would play games at the time and uh wanted to talk to them I wanted to understand what was going on wanted to understand their relationship to to play and um there was a lot going on with a thesis uh it was one of the first um examples of uh doing digital ethnography in games uh and uh it's still one of the one of the ones that kind of pulled out as a foundational description of how digital ethnography is done and um so it was

methodologically a really challenging and interesting um thesis it uh I was looking into a type of um communicative space that people didn't know anything about I had to I had to start a scratch and explain to explain to everybody what a mod was the moment I was going to tell them anything about my work and there was so many yeah go ahead no I that actually leaves me the question too of were I I sort of feel like at least where I come from academically which is classics there is now a rising movement of reception studies and looking at archo gaming and games about the ancient world but at the time even that I was finishing my PhD in 2014 that was not a common thing and I don't feel that my advisers would have looked on that with respect or even interest you know um was it did you feel like you were doing something that was considered academically viable at the time and were other people interested in your work or did you kind of have to push against the tide well uh I was very lucky with my supervisor uh it my supervisor was Espen oret and he is uh kind of like the person in game studies uh and he was at that time he if you want to argue with someone in game studies everybody are trying to take him down at the same time he was a guy who did the really new and interesting stuff particularly back in the 90s

2000 he was really really nice to have a supervisor like that that was both challenging and at The Cutting Edge so I was definitely understood by my supervisor even if we totally disagreed on so many levels and we still do and we are very good friends so so it's not like it's I'm not I'm not uh it's it wasn't without friction but it was a very constructive friction uh and and it was never a question about whether or not this was a worthy topic because it definitely was part of both the big project he worked on and his own kind of idea about the need to to study this as an academic uh uh as an academic Direction at the same time I was working in a very traditional um media Department uh it was one of the biggest uh and most established and respected U journalism educations in Norway I was uh within that structure I was uh building designing starting up a education in public uh relations and Communications so this was talking about games was was really not something anybody expected that you should do so I I have always lived kind of a schizophrenic life I have the things that I teach and I have the things that I research so occasionally they overlap and more and more now I can I can talk a lot more about my experiences from uh

social media studies and from game studies and from uh online culture cyber culture and pulled that into a more traditional media studies context but a lot of that comes from the work that me and a few others who come out of media studies have been doing in order to introduce this to that kind of yeah that kind of a tradition and what do you think the fact that um you've been working at Norwegian universities like what kind of impact has being from Europe had do you think on your study of video games like when you were doing uh the work early on were you talking to people uh in Norway or were you talking to people from all over the place and you know how's your access and reach changed over the years as well um the designers for the game that I I studied uh at first it was called the dragons realm uh the designers were in Australia and uh a lot of the players were either in austral australa or in the United States with a few in Europe and when I was going to do my interviews for the thesis I traveled to visit uh the respondents who were in uh the states most of them were on the west coast but also some on the east coast of of the United States so I spent some time traveling around and H I was this weird woman that showed up and said hi I'm from the internet can I interview you I mean I've got away with that for

some time now I'm sure it worked out f it wasn't it wasn't quite that uh accepted in 1999 and 2000 I'll tell you that's fantastic uh so I mean I suppose with the internet getting to where it is now I mean do you still travel for aspects of your study or do you sort of conduct a lot of interviews online now if you're if you're talking to people about games um I do travel so but right now I am um looking more into the actual structure and use of games so I'm not I'm not doing that much of interviews but I have I I was when I was studying World of Warcraft uh we we had a we had a researches European researchers Guild in NOA Warcraft and uh I was like I was the Guild Master of that Guild and um and so we did a lot of research on World of Warcraft and we we were part of starting that kind of own trend of of doing World of Warcraft research and one of the things I did was that I played with a guild that I had a had meetups so I went and and met with them and these were since I since this at that point um servers were um sections by section by by regions m and I played on a European

server these were European players but uh in this case this Meetup was in was in Amsterdam and so I went and and met them and interviewed them all in Amsterdam and they were from all over they were all over Europe and I later on I have been um playing with and interacting with and talking to players from yeah most of the world and um been meeting people when I've been traveling I've been um on I've been on on sabatical and different places in the world and I've been talking about games and I've been talking with people who have played games and designed games uh yeah there there's quite a bit of travel involved but um it's right now I'm looking at different things I'm not talking so much with individuals fair enough fair enough so how did you get from just sort of studying gaming culture sounds like a bit more generally to dark play what led you in that direction yeah um uh games have had a very bad reputation for and it still has but uh back in back between 2000 2010 and particularly after 2011 when uh there was this horrendous shooting at UTA in Norway um uh the terrorist who was a white supremacist uh he claimed this was this

was never substantiated but he claimed that he had used World of Warcraft to practice how to how to shoot people oh God and uh and so of course there was a lot of push back toward against that um all of us Norwegian games researchers anybody would had do anything to do with games had to go in different ways we were invited in in different types of media to talk about the dangers of uh of games and since we had been doing a lot of work on specifically on world on World of Warcraft we were basically chased down by the by the by the media all over in order to talk about this connection between between uh in this case World of Warcraft and murders killing terrorism and and we of course were perfectly aware that you do not become a terrorist by playing a game uh there's at the time I was TR I was tracking down um a research by from CIA and from FBI to see uh what they wrote about the people who became Shooters who became violent and their conclusions was mostly that uh people who be who became violent if they played games they would mostly play them because they wanted to look at and kind of play around fetishized weapons that it was not so much about playing so actual players people who

enjoyed and played games they were not the ones who went on to become these shooters and um and so for a while there these the discussion around games was very very hard very difficult to handle and uh and very very serious because we over and over again had to have this conversation about uh would people become Killers H people wanted to restrict uh games for the the children they were terrified that if anybody played games the that's thing they would do was to pick up an assault rifle and go out there and um and we had to have this conversation over over again and say that no that is not how it happens uh radicalization is not something that automatically happens when you pick up a a controller U it is it is a different process it's a different um thing that goes there but it was very difficult because designers were at that time talking about games being addictive being games being addictive was for games designers and still is in a way for game designers a very positive thing because it meant that people would buy them and play them uh but at the same at same time by using that language they kind of forced uh both a both a um a a a um a the ID that that I accessed there something like game addiction existed and they forced the idea that games were

dangerous and at the same time you know there's a lot of violence a lot of that violence is both uh particularly in the games from that period are both racist and they are misogynistic so a lot of so it was very very hard to say no these games are not dangerous because the games themselves were kind of displaying a lot of negative traits so we decided that okay we know these things about games we know that that that it's no automatic correlation between games and violence H but it's really hard to talk about it because we do not have a language that explains why this kind of uh horrendous negative looking play is actually playful it's not it's not about killing it is about playing what is it in these games that is about playing and not about violence and that is why we started looking at at dark play that's why we started out with with the U Anthology that was on was on on the dark side of gameplay and kind of the the turbs dark play came into play that was uh uh me Christina jurgenson yunas Lindero a few others uh your other European and um specifically Nordic game Scholars who who started talking about this so we and then we opened up and and wrote this first Anthology about about dark play

and what we wanted to to do was to create a language where we can talk about difficult gameplay gameplay that people would react negatively to if they did not have a context and and create a an academic language that would permit the analyzis of this type of play so how do you come to an agreement about something like that you know the the the actual Anthology um dark play which by the way I recommend um it's expensive because it's an academic book but you know uh but it covers it covers everything from you know games that are essentially abusive to the people playing them to you know how we handle player agency and killing children in games um to games that are you know that that have a lot of sexual content to people might find objectionable so how did you decide what fell under the umbrella uh of dark play or how are you deciding that W well uh when when you when you talk about a cultural object there is no there is no point where you say well this is the truth and this is not the truth it it will always be in degrees uh the the main way we went into that was by by looking for the kind of play that would be understood as controversial things that people where

people would uh either feel that this was horrific that it was terrifying or it was offensive in different ways or you were offended as a player it was different ways of of um looking at at play that went started to go beyond your boundaries and uh went into a playfulness that was not necessarily expect it when the play took you out of this uh innocent childishness in a way that we tend to ascribe to play and into this uh into this more challenging activity that a lot of adult players yeah although what interesting is that when you talk about dark play in the most General sense I kind of feel like that's something that kids do naturally and actually that essay about children you know turning things to have child blocks into something bad like who who didn't play The Sims as a kid and like you know take the steps out of the pool yeah it's ch children at a certain age are psychopaths so when they they haven't necessarily developed empathy and understanding for of uh how to feel for others and uh it is something we we develop as we as we mature so of course children will play anything it's like yeah yeah I mean you know I mean I think that games have an inherent meanness in them a lot of the time just because people do

consider that fun it is not so much about the meanness and this is where we started come into a book that you actually asked me about it was the the Paradox of transgression in games that I wrote with Christine yinson um this is where you start to come into the question of breaking nor Ms and uh stretching boundaries and we have in uh most of the time in society we live within very very strict boundaries that are things we can and things we cannot do and we are most of the time we are perfectly aware of where those boundaries are uh culture culture shock is typically where you certainly are in a situation where those boundaries are somewhere you did would not expect them uh the boundaries you expected people would respect are not respected they are expecting you to respect other boundaries than you cared about um you see that a lot particularly right now a lot of Americans are coming to Europe and discover that there are different boundaries in Europe uh a lot of Europeans are having a lot of American visitors and also discover that no we they we might think we are very culturally close but we are not this is typically the kind of boundary breaking experience that uh that we have a lot in everyday life this kind of boundary breaking experience when we have it as a culture shock is very frustrating it's can be

very painful and it can at some at some point totally ruin the experience it that is what uh what we in the book call a profound transgression it is when is something is so transgressive that you cannot stand it it's uh it's so totally beyond your comfort zone that the only way to to deal with this is to pull yourself out of the situation leave it flee it call the police in order to have them end it somehow just it has to stop and um but it play those boundaries are different because in play you have a dual a a dual awareness of uh who you are you are both aware that now I am I am getting closer to a boundary and you are aware it doesn't matter because I'm just playing so you have that knowledge that you are in a in a kind of a space where you can permit yourself to to break now norms and go counter to Norms at the same time as you are aware that these Norms are there and so in a game you can act towards and and perform transgressive acts killing someone for for instance is a profoundly transgressive act if you are in real life that is that is yeah that's like an

absolute stop but if you are in a game it can actually be quite fun because you know there are no people being harmed as I per as I perform these acts I can I can play around with being dangerous without actually being dangerous I can pretend I'm horrible but I don't need to be horrible in order to have that experience uh it's also why a lot of people for instance do gender swap gender swapping in games they might might want to live the fantasy of being either a strong male or attractive female and so they they live that they play around with that other fantasy and since they are perfectly everybody are perfectly aware that you don't become a woman by playing a woman it's not a problem it's something you can you can do without without having any real life repercussions and that awareness that that dual awareness of the existing Norm that you are breaking the transgression you are performing and the awareness that this transgression is not is not the problem in this context is permissible uh I think that is a lot of the reason why we think games are so fun and particularly horrible games and particularly being bad in them I I love to manipulate people in games it's my it's the best thing yeah you know I definitely have my limits but I also did get all the dric artifacts in Skyrim so we know that I'm willing to do something bad

right but um I I find it really interesting that you put it this way because you know actually in the the Paradox of play you mentioned that there's something called the fallacy of play which is like this concept that games are all non-serious they're fun and they don't really have external consequences and you know I think especially when we talk about things like serious games or games that are grounded in history um it's hard sometimes to talk seriously about games because there's the immediate backup of it's just a game it's just a game yeah so how do you kind of square that Circle of well the transgression is fun because nobody's really getting hurt and you know there it's the circle of play how do you get from there to like how how do we talk about this in a serious way that's meaningful um without I guess kind of overplaying what people in the game doing and that is that is where the we find that this uh comparison to Art is so is so fruitful uh we are all we all agree that art is important art is something that is necessarily part of life it is something that should that people should be able to experience and it is something that brings you out of your everyday life and into a different type of experience and this experience we agree it is both serious and important at the same time art is art art is its own thing it is separate from from other life and you can push boundaries in art in ways that you

cannot push them in real life if you one of one of my one of the examples I like to use is um uh is when uh Ula and abovich they had they were they created this uh event at a exhibition in bolog in when was this in the 60s 70s something like that where they both it was a it was big art exhibition and they and everybody who entered that exhibition had to go through a portal and they stood this was a man in a woman they stood at each side of that portal completely naked so in order to enter the exhibition you had to kind of sneak between and they were un really uncomfortably close you had to sneak between a man and a woman a naked man and a naked woman you had to make the decision am I going to face the man am I going to face the woman and you had to make the decision of actually performing this very very transgressive act uh this both changed your understanding of nudity of uh your desire to to be part of of a an art experience uh the meaning of what art is at the same time it didn't really change anything because you had walked past two naked women and two no sorry two naked people and nobody had gone up in Flames

so so it was this it it it was this this uh very transformative but at the same time completely safe experience and uh transgression in games is like this it can be very very uh it can be very very transformative because it can U one of the people we we interviewed for instance uh she started out she wanted to play uh Grand Theft Auto because she had uh H she had heard so much about it and um but she didn't expect it to be particularly transgressive but uh so she just started playing and at first didn't didn't react but then she started noticing um uh the uh the pretty strong ethnic twist in Grand Theft Auto uh she was starting to see how they were going how they were displaying black communities how they were displaying um different levels of crime and uh and I don't remember exactly which city this was supposed to be but you know the grand Tech Auto series goes through different American cities and display uh some some some kind know approximate simulation of crime yeah and this was a this was a black woman playing and the more she played the more she had a problem with playing so she knew that she was doing

something that was not dangerous or difficult at all and in the beginning she felt it was a simply you know a kind of a pleasurable transgression she felt naughty she felt felt like she was doing something that was a little bit bad but not so much but the accumulative uh realization of how this was put together uh then at the end became such a problem for her that it became a profound transgression she could not finish even for research she could not finish the game and she stopped and she said no this is this is at this point this is unplayable to me because I I am now seeing all these little connections and that is what things that that the transgressive experiences do to you they open your eyes to boundaries they open your eyes to your own boundaries and to the boundaries of others and if you can start to perceive those boundaries in a safe context that is of course a lot more interesting than perceiving it anywhere else so that is how we have like this we both talk about the fallacy of play we say that play doesn't have to be fun it doesn't even have to be pleasant we spend some time talking about play that is just painful and uh at the same time it can be uh permissive it can give you the

opportunity to try out things that you otherwise would not feel safe to experiment with how do you separate your own ethical and personal boundaries um from your work when you're talking about these kinds of games like one thing I noticed is that some of the essays in the dark Playbook you know they talk about things that are pretty you know normal like Grand Theft Auto you know my brother and I played San Andreas when we were kids I'm pretty sure my parents wouldn't have bought the game if they knew what was in it at the time but you know uh but you've also got people who are talking about things like kusters Revenge which is you know an old game about you know approaching and sexually assaulting a native woman um or something like rap play which is you know a game that's exactly what it sounds like how do you talk about those things in an academic context how do you study those uh in a way that I mean I don't think you can be objective so how do you talk about it yeah this is this is of course a complicated right now I also have I have two PhD students one of them is uh studying um conspiracy theories the other is uh cons studying uh incels and men's rights activists and how do you talk about that in a way where you do not pull your kind of put your own ER moral judgment on top

of it right and and this is this is the point where you have to you have to be open about who you are as a researcher uh if you look at if you look at the the things I've written you will see that I I use me and I when I talk about my research and I and I do not use a third person to talk about myself because I am I am this person I I have these I have these limitations but I also have these opportunities uh I it is my eyes that look at the games and it is uh my background that is important in order to understand what is happening and you asked me at the beginning what what is different between being European and an American G scholar for instance uh one of the things is that uh we are particularly European scholars my age we are thoroughly schooled in how what class means uh so talking looking at this we we see other things where an American Scholar will not see class as a as an issue as something that needs to be to be studied I have had uh Publications published in the United States before they before they could publish they told me you cannot use class you have to use uh ethnicity or or or gender in order to to demonstrate unequalness or unequal situations nobody will understand Clause as say something that is unequal this is some years ago I think there's more

discussion about clause in the United States now but like 15 years ago it was not it was not like that and um so so one one of the things that I bring into this is uh Is this different understanding of how Society is not equal and it's not just because we are of different ethnicities speak different language it's also because Society um is is uh put together and function unequally for so different people see different things and the things I see come from my background they come from my being me being a a scholar in a Nordic country with very little violence so for instance um and we and who are where we are very permissive about nudity and sex uh so for me the fact that American shows have a warning about uh violence and suicide uh and sex no sorry about suicide and sex but not about violence that is that is very upside down it's like oh you can kill as many people as you like but do not show a nipple and that to is a very strange and different and difficult thing um and so coming being able coming into this from this background I do not think that I that I'm delivering the entire truth I never think that my truth is the entire truth and by using I and me when I write

about it I make it very clear that this research that is about the things that I have observed someone else who goes into this using their subjective experiences looking at this they will see something different they will have a different experience they will draw different con conclusions they will have a different analysis even if we see if you supposedly look at exactly the same thing I think that is one of the fundamental things about doing difficult research or transgressive and provocative research you have to be open that but to that not being the end of the project interesting when you are doing this research um you know if you're talking about transgressive Games first I guess I would ask how do you gather information about how people are responding to those games and what's considered a legitimate way to do that and then also to what extent do you think that researchers need to play those games themselves this is this is a huge gap studies debate uh if you go with espinos he will say you'll have to play and you have to play at a very high level you can't write about raiding if you do not raate if you can't write about the professional play if you cannot play at that level I think that is a little bit

too much at the same time um games are a system that you do not that is not a casual in order to understand the system you cannot just start to play and not and not have any background ER you need to be able to see what kind of game you are within what kind of affordances do you have in this game what kind of limitations do you have in this game and you have to be able to see through these and see how these affordances limitations create the communicative situation you are in and this is where I think games and uh and digital media generally social media in spe in particular uh can learn so much from each other because social media develops the way it does based on the affordances and the limitations it has each platform has different affordances and Li limitations and so you and so you will get a different permissive um culture on the different on the different platforms and in games this becomes very very clear where you may think they don't these limitations do not exist in social media or you might you may think that there are only affordances in games it becomes very clear that there are both limitations and affordances and and in order to be a in

order to understand what is going on within this context you have to be able to understand the this the this specific part of uh of uh the platform and you cannot have that uh that experience without playing uh you can you can study players you can kind of uh put players in a room and see how they interact while they play uh that will not be a game study that will be a player study uh you can you can study every screen a lot of screenshots from a game and see this is the story that is being told uh that will then be a textual analysis of what happens in a game and it will be more akin to a literature study than a than a game study but in in order to to study the game as game uh then you have to play the game and understand the context that has been played in it makes sense do you feel that your own boundaries and interests as a player have been pushed into darker places because of the research that you do no um I am um I'm a kind of person who who when I do something when I do something for a long time I become very curious about it and I want to explore it uh and to a level where I understand it I I like to push my own boundaries of

uh knowledge and understanding of society as far as possible and the more I go in in a direction uh the more explicit this becomes uh over the last few years since the since the pandemic I'm actually doing something very very different from dark play right now I'm I am looking at how people play in knitting communities so I'm looking at play on rivalry and how women at my age play which is a very different type play and nobody will will actually think of it as a dark play although there's quite a bit of cheating I'll say that but by by starting to do this kind of research I have been spending a lot of time online in in these knitting communities and I have been knitting and uh I am currently maniacally knitting and at a level where I have never knit before it's I have I yeah the things I currently produce are very different from what I have what I've done before because I have both uh be I both became interested in knitting and that made me study these communities and the study of these communities made me want to understand both about more about what both what what kind of limitations do you have when you knit and what kind of kind of affordances you have and how you can translate that uh through digital

media into different types of play oh that's awesome so we spent most of this interview kind of talking about play as a place where nobody gets hurt as a relatively safe place to explore but I I think you probably do have some opinions about this because you read a couple of articles about gamergate you've got a student who's talking about incels I feel like these topics are really hard to discuss because there's realworld anger and push back for perceived invasions of transgressive gaming spaces so how do you reconcile wanting to respect the play experience even if highly transgressive um with kind of the real life reactivity that can result from talking about it the thing is that I movements like gate and other and other reactions like that also the violence of uh the in no way and things like that they do not they do not start and end with a play it is not the game that put PE people in these positions they just use the game as a way to to express or manage or handle the feelings they have about the POS positions they are in and so uh I do not find it to be problematic when people use a game in a problematic manner

because the because that is something there is some other reason that makes them use the game like this uh if you are if you if you're feeling powerless in your real life if you feel like nothing can change and you're angry and you want to lash out at someone and uh and you use your game as that place where you left out and where you where you act out aggressively uh that is just a different Arena it's just a different place where you where you take this out it's just a it is just a different um opportunity to rid yourself of some of your frustration or your fear or or anger um with my I'm right now discussing with my PhD student who studies misogyny that um uh an important part of research in context like this is to is a compassionate research is research that is empathic and that and that puts it it doesn't it doesn't necessarily mean you should put yourself in another shoes because you can't but it means that you need to accept that not everything you disagree with is bad so you can disagree with something but still try to understand it you can disagree with something and still try to look at how is it put put together what is uh what is going on with it where does it come from what does it

relate to uh it was super interesting to see a lot of the gamergate language how it related to the how it was related to to both um holigan cultures typical the type of aggression you will find in in other play spaces and at the same time related to to some a lot of the online um uh r the far right disc discourses that were going on at the same time so you saw all of these cultural um all this cultural overlap and the game just became an object in this very complex ecosystem of different cultural o overlaps and if you do not if you're not willing to to look at what is actually going on with the other person then you blind yourself as a researcher and you do not and you do see that the things that you react to as a moral person might be connected to something very very different that Society needs to understand and handle and react to do you ever think that there's a point at which research can be too permissive or is it open- mind all the way no matter what well well um that's a very funny there a very funny article about um a player called Twix who uh goes in and

provokes players as hard as possible he's basically uh he's basically this researcher is basically using all the exploits in order to win and he keeps winning he just ruins everything for everybody and he is he's using what he calls gar finkling it's a technique where you where you play or you do you do research that puts people in really complicated and and uncomfortable positions and he does this continuously to the point where he where he ruins the experience for everybody who plays while he plays people get really upset they get really angry they attack him uh even his own Co is even those on his own side want to kill him so it's guess it because it really becomes a problem um do I think that's a good idea he does he does explore some boundaries for instance he descri he he describes the distinction between um uh what is a cultural agreement and what is a hard law okay he describes the for instance he since he uses all these exploits continuously and people get angry with him uh he he demonstrates that are two there are two different types of rules in this game it is the rules that are coded into the game and it's rules that are that are created by the society within which he

plays H that isn't that is a very interesting uh observation and it is really interesting to see that that players uh negotiate these these rules and these Norms among themselves he demonstrates that beautifully at the same time I think after the first 10 threats he had established that he was doing something that people didn't like he did not have to go from one server to the next in order to establish that no people do not like when you play like this uh yeah I think I think sometimes you can you can kind of dial it a little bit back and um and think about do I really have to be this mean in order to learn this uh and um yeah there were there are boundaries and we have ethical boards and thank God I also think about this in terms of what to place so one of my personal interests because I am I have a Classics background um is games about Rome and how the ancient world is presented in games and you know I was looking on Steam for some possible interesting things to play and I don't remember the title I don't know if I want to too but a game came up that was about purchasing slaves in the Roman Empire teaching them how to have sex in a way that you found gratifying and then selling them off and I remember just being like so viscerally like just upset

conceptually by that how do you approach something like that respectfully like you know we talk about profound transgressions but there are people who will say that nothing is a profound transgression for them but like that's I feel like that's Pretty Outside the norm of what most people would play in a video game so you know at what point is something worthy of study when do you decide something's worth engaging with and then if it's really gross like that frankly is gross like how do you do how do you do it honestly for this I would probably see if some Japanese Scholars had done anything on it because they have very different boundaries on these things from us um but um how would I approach something like that I would uh I would try to um I would try to to see what is actually going on and what and how people are changing um the opport altering what people do what they do here um there are examples of for instance um one of my one of my friends and colleagues he has been studying how modding Skyrim in order to be able to kill the children or modding Skyrim so that uh so that it becomes a um a Utopia for the Nords who are then the master the people um very unpleasant culturally unpleasant and and

transgressive mods uh but at the same time if we do not look at it uh who will Who will understand what is going on if we say that oh no I'm feeling I am morally so offended by this I cannot do this research Society is paying me to do this research I am I am in a very privileged position because I'm willing to do these things because I'm willing to go into into and ask these difficult questions that people may not want me to ask um just saying that this is important this need we need to understand this once I once I think that this is true once I think that this is actually something Society needs to know about I have an obligation to society this a society that uh that pays me that feeds me that hires me in order and and I need to I need to go in there and do these things um luckily we have free will so I I don't have to go necessarily in in a dark Direction all the time one of my one of my colleagues she she came into into um game studies for a long time she then she moved back out of it but because she had before that she had been um uh she had been doing research on children's experiences of grief and death she was crying every day at work

it was horrible for her she came home and was totally emotionally wrong out she could not touch it afterwards for a very very long time for her to come into the uh the The Gamers Guild and be able to play with us and and research play and research something where she did not come home and cry every day that was a gift but she had still put herself in that position in order to understand what was going on in order to understand this thing which is so heart-wrenching she put herself in the position of being exposed to Children's grief over and over and over again for years and that is that really for to me that is a profound transgression I don't not think I would have been able to do that but if someone want me to look if some if some if for some reason I really have to look at uh digital people being sexually abused in order to understand what's going on that is a lot easier for me than children's grief interesting uh this actually this leades me two different questions so let's ask the more technical one first which is just so the other thing I've noticed is that you know if you're looking at transgressive stuff do you ever find that it's I guess weird for people to know that you've been looking at or playing something that is considered so transgressive like you know I was this is innocent I was just playing batro the other day on Steam but

because steam is hooked to my Discord somebody messaged me and they're like oh I see that you're playing batro hahhaa um so how do you even play anything anymore and not feel like watched doing it and therefore like there's an extra layer of transgression like observational grossness uh and then you know it's sort of like finding somebody else at the dirty picture show or something right like if you both saw each other then you're both accountable for what was on that screen so like how so how does that aspect of it work you know in academic study yeah yeah well first of all if somebody uh knows enough about the game to catch you at playing the game that means they have played the game so then we are both at that then we are both at that show but um but at the same time if I just if I went into this just because I wanted to play a dirty game then I could play that dirty game and never tell anybody about it I didn't have to research it if it if it bothered me uh to tell someone that I had this uh that I had had this uh fascination with I don't know AOG games I would not have to tell I I would not have to write about write an article about it I could just do it on my own time and that would be it when I go into the in in order to do this in research uh I know I do it uh with a lot of

preparation I will have I created a methodology for doing the study I will have a plan for how to collect the information I need I will have research questions that I plan to ask from this material I will have a theory that backs me up and that backs up the hypothesis I go into the study with and which will then be part of what I either disprove or confirm through my observations and through my play and that gives that uh let lets me take a step back and creates this uh this distance uh that we also write about in in the the the Paradox of transgression this observation this this distance of the observator the person who stands outside and and looks in and it is a it is a distance that you that you need to be able def finded as a scholar if you don't then you will not be able to do an analysis this also leads to question of you know especially it sounds like you know studying children's grief oh my God god like people have to choose right what they consider is academically important and worth the study you if you wanted to find something upsetting or if you wanted to find something gross I mean it's you could just find that like it's not it's not hard so how do you choose which media is actually worthy of academic attention versus something that

just exists because people exist in in many forms well I think that everything that exists because people is exists is interesting so it's more about choosing exactly what I will focus on yeah it's more about limiting it's not about finding the important stu stuff it's about limiting what can I actually study here and now and um the other thing I am I'm I'm a person that becomes a nerd whenever I start doing something but I'm also a person who is incredibly curious and and so I think almost everything I touch is interesting I think almost every person I meet and talk to are interesting it is uh the the world is so full of exciting knowledge that we can find and that we can uncover I don't think I will ever find my boundary on that I think life is such an incredibly interesting playground for all of us but uh as long as I can ask questions I will probably keep doing it I love it that's actually a great stopping point for serious questions just a couple sopes Before I Let You Go one uh what are you playing right now that is bringing you Joy I know you're knitting but are there any other G make happy right now I'm actually I'm actually mostly playing a very small um very small games on U on the tablet uh the most uh uh the game I'm

playing the most is a very simple like a little uh platform games running back and forth It's called Kingdom I am at a kingdom two crowns at the moment and I and it's uh it's so funny and it's so relaxing and it's so both easy but with just enough of challenge that it has that it has this enough Edge that it is interesting to play but I have played it now so long that I use it to fall asleep I will I will play it just before going to bed and then I'm gone so so I am actually looking for for something else to to pick up and and uh and uh look at and try to understand I'm also playing around with a lot of different apps uh um I one of the things I since I since I teach communication one of the things I need to do is to look at all these different apps for gamification of everything um so I'm looking for at Wellness apps and and stuff like that and um so yeah my my play is currently uh very light and I I'm not I'm not diving into any of the big games so um I have um I I don't feel the same kind of uh curiosity about them as I did

some years ago but um I'm pretty certain that it will come back and I'll be I'll find that game that I really wanted to look at everybody is clearly looking at disco elium right now I that is one game I I going to have to look into yeah I uh actually still that was on my to playlist as well and then if people want to find you and follow your work uh where do you like to be found well um it's probably just Google me on Google Scholar there is no there's no particular there's no particular outlet outside of I I used to have a Blog I started a Blog in that uh that was one of the first academic blogs in the world and I even got a prize for being a the best European Tech blog at some point uh but that is very that is very not active I am occasionally posting call for papers but I that is it so you probably not find me there I'm not active on X anymore it was something that uh um yeah there was a after a while I did not enjoy the the the discussions on on that platform um I have a group of friends on on Facebook that I that I still talk to and they all are very impressed with my knitting skills so that's a gratification

but yeah uh probably the best thing is to to look up my my academic writings that's that's where most of my stuff is perfect I'll put your University page in the in the show notes uh but everybody out there I can be found anywhere as Beyond Solitaire if you're looking uh J thank you so much for for coming on the show this has been a great conversation I really appreciate the time thank you for for your wonderful questions and for letting me talk for so long all right everybody there uh please like subscribe ask questions and most of all Happ a Ging

Progress saved