Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Week In Review - June 1, 2026

Transcript 40:39

Hey, hey, hey.

Hey, what's up y'all? Welcome to the upstairs the loft. I I still have yet to come up with a good name for this, but here we are. Uh let's talk some games today. I was ju it was just brought to my attention some Monday morning drama. Not board game related, but apparently Lego related, brick and mini fig, whatever. Whatever. Anyway, uh not a lot of gaming this weekend. The only gaming that I actually did this weekend was something I can't tell you all about. I can tell you that it is a uh Brian Bourne Mueller trick-taking game that we play tested that is under NDA. So there you go. We play tested that a lot. So there's that. All right.

I mean, right? But we are going to talk about the last two, three weeks honestly of games because we haven't done this in a little bit. And we had that that whole board game convention that I hosted not too long ago. And by not too long ago, I mean it ended a week ago today. And my birthday is a week ago or a week from today. What? Whatever. Doesn't matter. Right. So, let's get into it. Treasure ship of Jang Ha. Uh, designed by Hisashi Hayashi and published by a publisher that apparently is pissing off a lot of people, Harvest Valley. Now, uh I I've talked about this a couple times on the show. Uh not going to go deep deep into this, but um it was loaned to me from Jay Bernardo of Cardboard East. Jay, I will be sending that out to you tomorrow. So, thank you again for the your borrowing of your game. But it is a I don't it it's kind of an amalgamation of mechanisms that are broken up into essentially three distinct parts to where you are uh doing the diplomacy phase in which you are giving some uh diplomatic relation people some diplomats I guess that would be uh some resources is to get stuff for your trips. So, because it models after the seven treasure fleets

of Jangha historically, I want to say it was the 15th, 16th century, 14th, 15th century uh China. And so, you you choose uh whichever of these actions that's going to allow you to give some resources to get some other better stuff that you will need on your trip. But the hook there is you can only do each o or have diplomatic relations with each diplomat once throughout the game. And that's going to dictate the choosing order for the next phase. The next phase is uh there are three or four different legs of each of the treasure fleets that goes out. And depending on which diplomatic uh diplomat you have a relationship with this round dictates the order in which you choose to be the captain or the leader of that leg and which chooses which action you're going to take on each leg. So after that's decided, then you actually go out onto the main board and you put down ships.

You take actions. You you get resources. it becomes a very in that regard. It becomes a very generic I think is a fair term uh euro in that uh whoever is the captain of that leg you're going to have anywhere you're going to place anywhere between three and technically six ships out. one of which you get to take the actions for and all the others the other players get to choose one of those maybe a second to take uh actions from. It's all stuff that you've all seen before when it comes to yours that part of it. But the way it all kind of intertwines makes for a really really pleasant play. My real only gripe about the game is if you play all seven rounds plus the extra eighth diplomatic phase, you can pretty much complete most everything that you wanted to complete in the game. And so therefore, if we all get almost everything done that we want to get done, why did we bother playing the game? because it then artificially bunches people back up at the end.

So, not super keen on that. Now, I'm not a developer. I'm not a designer and I have the utmost respect of Hisashi's designs. However, this one goes one round too long. So, what we've kind of messed around with is the idea of chopping off one of the one of the fleets. So instead of it being seven rounds, it's six rounds. Um, and what we kind of have settled on for a house rule is we just cut the first one off. So we only do six. Makes for a more interesting game in our opinion. Your mileage may vary. So yeah, Treasure Fleet of Jan Ho, I would say good, not great. That's what that's where I fall on that one. All right. All right.

Uh, so there's that. Uh, hold on. Stop. Go away. Go away. Not now. There we go. All right. The next two we're going to kind of talk about together. And that's Fa Swamp and Ki. This is uh designed by the Oster Tig brothers um and published at least Ki way back in the day. Fifific spiel and fractal zugos. I'm butchering that. I have no doubt. Uh, two tomatoes 999 games cranio crowd d or crowd games I guess here for fyas swamp and ki again is the original version of what fyas swamp becomes. So, Kai is that old school uh knife fight in a phone booth type game that has really interesting decisions, but it certainly has that old school runaway leader fall away trailer problem that some of the older games, if you want to call it a problem, it's a feature, not a bug in my opinion. Uh but but Kyi is the cleaner of the two. FA they both feel like they are designed.

They are descriptive and appropriate designs for their time. That is damning with faint praise on the latter and a compliment for the former I would say. ulong tea this morning. So, KYI is clean. It's relatively simple and all you're doing is over the course of a bunch of a number of rounds. I think it's eight rounds on this one is you have actions in which you can uh choose any of these basic actions to it's a it's a board in which there are a bunch of islands. You're going to be building huts on these islands. You're going to be fishing uh rolling dice to be able to fish. That is one of the divisive things. I'll come back to that.

and basically then selling the fish that you've caught to some of the players huts, your own or others. It's a relatively simple game where the depth or and the the interest is both in the action selection as well as I would say the timing of when you take certain actions. One of the hooks in this game is every time you take an action, you have to add a coin or a dollar or whatever you want to call it onto the action. If you have to basically match the current bid to take the action. If it's zero, then you don't have to put anything, but the the the game puts one on for you. And then if somebody wants to take that action, whether it's you or someone else, on a subsequent turn, they have to take a coin from their supply and add it to there. And then if somebody that's annoying, if somebody else wants to take that action, you or someone else, you have to add two coins then. So on and so forth. Mechanically very simple. It's a game a little bit of brinksmanship as well as uh capitalizing on the actions of others. Again, it is a very old school design that works really, really well. And it it can be really, really mean. You can sink other people's boats, but you don't have many.

You only have three or four of them. And so, it can be used when timed right. You lose points. They lose the ability to do extra stuff. Now, those dice that I mentioned, when you go fishing, excuse me, uh you're rolling weighted dice. The first die it's you get five successes or I think it's five out of six uh are successes. Then the second one that you could roll depending on the number of fishing village or huts you have uh or boats but six one have a dozen the other uh has like four of six and then three of six and then two of six. So, it's diminishing returns, but it's a press your luck aspect as opposed to uh in the newer version of the game. It adds a bunch of other kindler gentler things to it that honestly don't appeal to me. Fya's swamp, like I said, is very much a design for those that found Kai Vi a little too tight and a little too punishing, which is fine for those that enjoy such things. It just adds fluff to a game that just didn't need it. And I think the universal feeling of those of us that played it, we played both in successive weeks to be able to compare them back and forth or compare the two is Fa Swamp is perfectly fine and if I

didn't have Ki, I might enjoy it more than I do. But if I had my brothers and I do, then I will not I have no interest in ever playing Fa Swamp again because Kaii exists. However, the problem is Ki is really hard to get and it's out of way out of print and it's relatively expensive to get a copy. So that's where Fya Swamp comes in. It's just an inferior game is the problem. It's not a bad game. It's just not as good as Kyi. So, there's that.

All right, that's enough on both of those, I would argue. Uh, let's go ahead and talk about one of the more popular games out there that for the longest time I really did not enjoy. That's Great Western Trail. So, Great Western Trail falls into that bucket of games much like the Terrammystica family, much like Tigris and Euphrates, much like Twilight Struggle, that there is such a large experiential gap between players that have played it a number of times and players that haven't. that it becomes non-competitive.

There's nothing wrong with that whatsoever. There are a number of y'all out there that thoroughly enjoy getting good at these games. That's commendable. That's great. I'm not one of those. Uh highlevel play comes with more plays. Duh. I mean, food chain magnate is another one that kind of falls into this bucket. However, so as well as Great Western Trail, like there are certain, oh, a building strategy and a specific strategy within that to where you do these things based on where these buildings ended up, yada yada yada. So, I I I've always kind of been turned off of Great Western Trail. Uh, back on the first edition, that was the last time I played it. I haven't I hadn't played it uh since the second edition came out. I hadn't played it since any of the iterations of Great Western Trail had been played. Hadn't played it since because I was kind of just turned off. Like I'm never going to play a game enough to be able to get to that level. So therefore, not really my cup of tea. Great for those that enjoy it. However, well, a number of the patrons had asked, "Hey, can we go ahead and stream it again with the second edition?" I was like, "Yeah, sure. Just because I don't I'm not super keen on a game doesn't mean we're not going to stream it." Okay, cool.

So, we did and I loved it. It was a really, really good time. And yeah, we just I mean, Kyle smoked us the first game, but he has the most experience between all of us. So, we played the very vanilla base game of Great Western Trail. I'm just going to assume you all know the mechanisms and how Great Western Trail uh plays. Uh you're tracing a path. You're moving up. It's a action selection game where you're stopping on buildings on the way up to uh Kansas City. And then in Kansas City, you have a hand of cards. It's not really a deck builder. It's a sort of action selection deck builder.

deck shedding thinning game. Uh when you get to Kansas City, you turn in your cards. You then can put out stations. You're moving along a train track. Has nothing to do with trains. Uh mechanically very very simple. Yet yet Alexander Fister killed it with this design and they have since come out with the expansion railway rails to the north. Rails of the North, Northern Rail stuff. Then what? Argentina, uh, New Zealand. There might be one other I'm forgetting. I haven't played either of those. We did also on our second play play with the Northern Railway expansion. And that was a lot of fun. that it it it gave a little bit of breath uh as well as a little bit of depth and a new new toy to play with. Uh that expands what you can do on the rails. Uh instead of it just being a very simple, okay, I'm going to put a disc here and it unlocks something on my player board.

Cool. The end. uh to a whole new board up there that does really interesting stuff and gives you things like goals kind of like pathways that you can choose. And I really really enjoyed that. So just goes to show that just because you don't like a game the first time or two you don't you played it, maybe revisit it years down the road because a your tastes may change. They they almost assuredly will change and and for whatever reason, maybe it just hits different. Now, am I ever going to get good at Great Western Trail? Nah, I'm still going to be a Neoight that gets smoked by any competent player. And I'm okay with that in this game because what it is I'm trying to do in the game, you might be more efficient and you might do it way way better than I do, but I can still enjoy. Hey, I'm I'm doing well for my level and I'm okay with that. Now, if you're playing two-player, that might be less fun, but uh as a as a four-player experience, I thoroughly enjoyed it. So, Great Western Trail and Rails to the North. We're gonna go with that, but I'm not sure it's right.

Somebody can correct me down in the comments. All right. So, before I jump into the next one, let me go ahead and take a look at the comments. Uh, let's see. Any chance we get another playthrough of Railways of Los? Maybe I can't promise that is third in line at the earliest for 18xx games. 1817 uh and I believe it's 71, the Old Prince. I think it's 71, but the Old Prince and then we'll see after those. All right. Uh apparently El Paso is the new streamlined one. Great Western Trail needed streamlining. Mark. Okay. All right. And jump to the beat says, "I was going to say that Fyos Swamp was the more available than Kaii. However, there's a solid print and play for Kaii."

Okay, cool. Personally, I think Ki is the far superior game to Fa Swamp, but it's also meaner and tighter. So, choose your poison accordingly. I would say on that. All right. Uh there's something magical about a game that's still fun when you're not in the lead and you can do something cool and feel satisfied. There's there's validity to that. Like uh I can't think of it off the top of my head, but any game where you're you're building something in and of it your own. And even if you're not doing, and it's not necessarily got to be a heads down game, meaning what the other players do don't affect you, but they can still affect you. They can still impact you, but you can still be proud of, hey, I did this thing. This looks cool. I I had fun doing that, even if you smoked me.

Get your fun where you find fun, right? So, that's cool. All right. I dig that. All right, so now let's go ahead and switch gears a little bit and let's go into some heavier games. We'll go really heavy themewise and we'll start off talking about I believe this one was Amabel Holland. I know it's Holland spiel. It is Emmael Holland and Holland Spiel couple years ago uh produced a game called Doubt is our product. Now, Kyle and I played this uh for the patron only. So, hey, news flash. If you do that, you get access to bonus content. And we'll talk more about that later in this stream because there's more of that coming tonight. But our patrons get bonus streams. Whether we're testing out a game, learning a game, it's a lot less finished product and a lot more fumbling through. and it's just a sneak peek behind seeing how the sausage is made while also being able to see some games that may or may not get public release on the channel.

So, one of those was Doubt is our product. Doubt is our product is a very heavy theme. It is it pits two players two-player game. There may be a solo, I don't think so, but two-player game that pits the te tobacco industry versus the world at large. So, one player is trying to get people hooked in using all the tools at your disposal to get people hooked and trying to make money. The other player is fighting a very very long hard uphill battle against the tobacco industry.

Now, that's either done one of two things. I don't really need to tell you about the game. I'm going to, but I don't need to because you're either, "Oh, hell no. Uh-uh." And that's a valid response. I'm I'm totally supportive of that. I get that there is other the I like there's no oh h no this feels like it's going to be you're either hell no or okay I'm here for that let's tell me more I happen to fall in the ladder of that camp of those two camps I should say now That's not to say that it is an endorsement or anything of what the tobacco industry has done to promoting cancer around the world.

Um, it is very much a pretty cynical look, but also pretty true look into the fight that the world at large has mostly US- centered, but um, has taken on how difficult it's been to fight big tobacco. And Annabelle grew up in a house of smokers. I grew up in a house of smokers. So I get it. I I used to dip when I was 5 years old. Let that sink in. Product of the 70s and 80s. Uh I quit on my sixth birthday. I told that story during the uh during the the patrononly live stream.

But yeah, product of their of our times because I mean you see shows like Madmen, you see stuff like Piquey Blinders and all that, right? Anyway, so one player plays as the tobacco industry whose goal is to make money. The other side is fighting the tobacco industry and over the course of a turn on the tobacco play industry players turn they must play a card, they must buy a card um and some other other steps. If there is ever a time you cannot do a thing, the tobacco industry player loses.

So the other player is doing everything in their power to in interrupt this string of actions that the tobacco player is playing is is trying to take. I found it very compelling. I felt it felt it was very asymmetric and it also as Amabel Holland is want to do makes quite the impactful statement I think and if you're not completely turned off by the theme I think it's pretty interesting gameplay in there as well. It feels it's big tobacco. You can almost like shrug off this little upstart world of trying to fight back at you.

They don't matter until they do. And if you're the world at large trying to fight big tobacco, you feel this insurmountable mountain that you're just trying to just be a gnat on a rhino's butt trying to annoy and interrupt and mess with. And it's really hardgoing until it's not. And so if the theme resonates one way or the other, and if that sounds interesting to you, highly recommend checking it out. You will see it on the channel, I'm going to say in the next few weeks publicly. Uh I'm okay with that. Kyle and I will do a two-player publicly uh for everybody. And it's not it's certainly not a game for everybody by any stretch. In fact, um I was talking to someone about it and they were like, "Yeah, I lost my I lost my my dad to to smoking. That's a hard stop for me." I respect that. I get that totally 100%.

But I see both sides of it. And for me, it falls back to the whole art should make you feel something. Whether it pisses you off, whether it makes you happy, whether it makes you cry, whether it makes you sad, whatever the case may be. If art is making you feel something, then it's succeeding on some level. So there you go. Okay. Anyway, so that's doubt is our product coming to a heavy cardboard stream near you in the next couple of weeks. All right, one more. And I would argue the number two game of Heavycon, that's Grenville.

Uh so we're going to talk a little bit quite a bit about Grenville here. Uh, if you are a patron, you get to see Grrenville tonight, 7ish on stream learning game for everyone that isn't me. So, Grrenville, uh, designed by Rudy Preszinski and published by him, Rudy 3 Publishing. Now, I a little bit of background on this first is I had missed this Kickstarter. completely never heard of this game. Apparently Rudy was emailing me, had the wrong email address, so that's why we we missed each other. But nonetheless, I only heard about Grenville through a patron of mine was like, "Hey, Edward, there's this game that Roto says you should play."

Okay. So, I go look up Richard's uh stream where he talks about it and he specifically said, "Yeah, this is a game that heavy Cardboard, this is right up Heavy Cardboard's alley." I was like, "Poor K." So, I went investigated it. Um, I would like to reference that whole artwork art or I'm sorry, art should make you feel something. And

the art in this game is a fever dream. I really dislike the artwork in Grrenville and I really like the game, so I'm okay with it. So there. So it certainly makes me feel something. It's reminiscent of cons from Splatter if you've ever encountered that game. And it's just it's just not my art my art style. I'm not saying it's bad. I'm saying I don't like it. All right. Anyway, so I went and investigated the game. It looked really interesting. It sounded interesting, but there really wasn't a lot of info out there for it. Well, I had heard that copies were starting to get delivered a couple weeks ago, and wouldn't you know, somebody in our group, hi Paul, uh had a copy. And I was like, "All right, cool." So, let me borrow it. And we did a pre-play of it.

Three players. It was fine. The rule book job security. Job security. And the player aid job security. So, we played it at three players and it was perfectly crumbulent. It was fine. Free players is not where this game sings or or less for that matter. Uh I haven't played it at two. I have no interest in playing this at two. I really don't have a lot of interest playing this at three. But then HeavyCon rolled around and my goal at HeavyCon for game playing was to get at least one game of Granville played five players because I wanted to see cuz I felt like this is a game that is going to probably be best at four maybe even five and checks out. Pretty pretty pretty great game. Really enjoyed it. So Grrenville at its core is a citybuer with a rondelle. That's really all it is. So everybody, all the players, there's a custommade rondell. When I mean custommade, there are, I don't know, I want to say maybe 20, 25 spots around this track for a rondelle in which players can take actions on.

It's custom in that it's set up before the game. There are four spots. the two markets and the two building spots that are locked always every game. They're in the four corners. Then there are some other actions that are always in the game, but where they are can either be random or not. And then there are the pink/purple tiles of which there are 14 plus, let's say, of those. You choose seven in a game randomly or otherwise. Mix it all up. Put them out in any order that you want to put them out in. Give me one second. B. All right. So, tonight's gonna be four players. That was Derek just letting me know he can't make it tonight cuz work.

Anyway, so you have these whatever bunch of tiles. You set them up in a rondelle. On your turn, a player moves any number of spaces forward on the rondelle, including the space that they're on, meaning they move all the way around the rondelle, which is fine. But every time you pass go, i.e. you hit the beginning of the rondelle, you have to pay taxes and wages, but other than that, you can take any action on the board. There are some exceptions that spots get blocked by other players when they've locked up certain things. doesn't matter. But you're taking actions all in the uh purpose of scoring points. And the majority of the points that you're going to score come from predominantly three things really two things. One, planting trees and beautifying the town of Grenavville, as well as expanding the town of Grrenville. Grenavville is a series of plots or or uh platters if you will. So it's has a core center tile that has some municipal buildings on it.

Then there are small platters that take up the second ring or the first ring if you will. And then there are bigger platters that make up the outer uh ring that are connected to the inner ring which is connected to the center via roads. So it's a very circular town and you are adding these platters. You are building roads. You are then all in the purpose of building buildings specifically residential houses. You're building municipal buildings while also building retail buildings so that you're able to build residential buildings. So that the cards you have in your hand, which at any given time will be zero through three, these are residents that are moving into the town of Grrenville. And these are worth a considerable amount of points and money. And you can only they move in when there is a house for sale and you meet all the criteria which may be certain res I'm sorry certain businesses and municipal buildings which may be within a certain tile distance food chain magnate.

So you're you're scoring points by building out the town of Grrenville and moving residents in effectively. Sounds pretty simple and mechanically it's pretty simple but the ways you can go about doing that and the parasitic symbiotic it's definitely not a co-op but there is so coopetition in building buildings and then maybe finishing them and being the one to finish them especially when it comes to residences. So, as much as I dislike the artwork in Granville, the graphic design is pretty great.

So, okay. The key to me is artwork and graphic design should work together. Even though the artwork looks like a fever dream, and it's very much not my cup of tea, it works within the context of the game. And dare I say it's kitschy or quaint or almost cozy. It fits and it doesn't get in the way of the graphic design. Now the graphic design does not make sense until you have it explained to you. Then it makes sense and it works. So it's it's a pretty impressive package that comes put together here. Now, my one real gripe with the game is has nothing really to do with the game and it just has to do with something on the box and that is it says it plays two to six players. No, it doesn't.

It plays two to five. You can get the six player components separately. Don't tell me it plays six players on the box then. That's a no. No. Other than that, it's pretty great game. You're going to want to see this. So, that now rolls into what do we got coming up for y'all this week? All right, for the patrons alone, so if you go there and you support the channel at the $5 and up level or higher, you get access to the Slack community. You get SL access to all the bonus content that I do that is for the patrons only, including tonight's learning game of Grinville.

Now, I taught the game four times at HeavyCon. I played it once, didn't I? They play it twice. Once or twice, doesn't matter. Taught it a bunch and then ran the games. But, uh, tonight it's going to be a four-player Grenville for the patrons only. Tomorrow night is a public stream of the new version of Medi, also known as Medici by some. On Wednesday, we are going to either host a fiveplayer Granville or depending on how tonight goes and who's available on Wednesday or on Wednesday we're going to do Shackleton Bass uh Fabio Liano's Ode to Moon Colonization. Uh we're going to do that with the expansion. So, depending on how tonight goes, one of those two. And then on Friday, we're busting out a uh what was it that John said? A like a a funny game that's really really mean. And that's Santiago. We streamed that apparently like six years ago. I have no recollection of it. So, we're going to bust that out on Friday. That's going to be five player. Medici is going to be six player. and Shackleton will be four. Gravville will be five, depending on which one we stream, and then tonight will be four.

So, there you go. That's that's a rundown on the last handful of games or so that I It's not all of them, but it's a it's a pick and choose between the games that I've been playing. So, treasure ship of Janggha, uh, Kyi and Fya Swamp, that is also Great Western Trail, data is our product, and Granville. So, thanks for hanging out. Hopefully you enjoyed it. I'm working on the depth on the camera here, so hopefully this one's a little bit better. And, uh, let me know what you think of the studio up here. Um, and and whether or not you're you're digging the look up here or not. like feedback, help me out. Um, this is a learning process with all of this here. So, anyway, that's a wrap. I will be back in six hours or so for y'all with y'all with the patrons with those people.

Please like, subscribe, consider the Patreon, all that fun stuff. And I will see y'all tonight for the patrons tomorrow. Everybody else, Metachi, y'all take care. See y'all later. Bye.

Yeah.

Progress saved