TCbH Podcast - Desert Island Games
Transcript
hello and welcome to the cardbo heral podcast I am Eric joined as always by my lovely effervescent co-host Jack scholarly do you see the pencil that makes me scholarly you do the mechanic big pencil yep I could have that oh jeez go with the big Razer for your yep exactly all right we're in good shape we're in good shape um hello Jack how are you doing on this fine Sunday evening doing good the logistics of us recording continues to be a not insignificant uh process with us on different coasts and different work schedules uh even if we were in the same community and that is challenging but it's a Sunday night and I get to hang out with one of my best buds so you know I'm feeling good well hello welcome in to this podcast to all of our listeners um this week I've been enjoying I've have been super happy with how many of the games that we played at that asthma day uh Creator event have made their way to board game arena C drafting the cosmos has made it and that was the one that I out of all the games there was the most excited for so I've gotten to
play that it's still super fun I think that game is is really up my alley I'm going to have to play it some more and maybe see about getting it some plays in person at some point or another um but how does it translate the the sort of physicality of the game because like one of the things that caught my eye is just how much of a toy Factor it had like sure I know mechanically that can translate no problem but the the presence it's almost like gizmos or something where a big part of it is that tactile look and you just kind of want to get in there do you still feel it's as inviting and uh kind of encouraging uh playing it digitally oh no no no I think this is a game that in person from from what I remember I mean at this point it's been it's been a handful of months since I played it in person for about 20 minutes um at most if that but it's I think it definitely still is a very good in-person game in a way that I think board game arena is a great way to get your fix but it definitely isn't the same thing that we played where you're like moving these little hungry Hungry Hippo style balls around to make elements um but it still just is a interesting game for what it is
like I just think that it is up my alley in terms of weird decision spaces that you keep finding yourself in where it's like well how many you play it solo uh it doesn't have solo on board game arena right now so okay uh went through the tutorial played a few games against other people uh just random random people who had tables open um and had a great time with it um yeah so I played that um which was rad just cuz it's been it's been a little bit since we played it at uh P so I kind of forgot what the uh I forgot a few different aspects of the rules but it ended up being yeah um I'm still excited for that game to to fully release and for me to find a copy of it somewhere did we talk about Yokohama last week I don't believe think we talked we did not talk about Yokohama have you played Yokohama I have not played Yokohama let me tell you about Yokohama so Yokohama was a game dour like a very popular game when it originally came out I want to say 2016 yes I'm looking it up here uh and it was a TMG did you did you did you have that answer already pulled up when you rhetorically asked yourself the
question no no I I I was looking it up as I uh was uh guessing on that but I know uh the time frame because I went to Dice Tower conon 2017 and that's where I first played it and it was one of the new hotness games uh at that convention along with ethnos the first time that I played that and it was at that point one of the more complex worker placement games that I'd played uh it just has some legistic uh pathing stuff that's going on where you're setting up workers but not activating them until you have your your president of your company moving around um and like TMG games it's finding its way into reprint um tacy menstral went uh under uh though it was a very beloved uh company that was trying some really interesting stuff we now have Harvest uh which we on the channel were huge fans of uh and then uh Yokohama just had a reprint um with uh with I want to say it's synapsis games uh that uh released a new version yes um unlike Harvest they did almost nothing mechanically uh but the visuals are really outstanding the components are really nice and there's a couple really subtle mechanical
differences but it's still a really good game it really didn't need much um I would have preferred kind of like a Yokohama second edition especially with how much of a glow up that Harvest had uh but um it nonetheless uh it's really nice I I found a a cheap copy surprisingly cheap because the kickstarter uh delivery for this new version was within the last 6 months or so oh wow so I don't know I don't know what that says about synapsis games uh but uh yeah uh I went ahead and pick that up it's still a great game still just really solid economic Euro uh set in 19th century Japan once uh Japan opened up to Western trade cool yeah I this is not exactly the same but it is a worker placement uh that I played as well uh set in Japan maybe set in Japan I'm at this point yeah it's set in Japan White Castle oh I was going say castle yes I got that played uh earlier today the solo version of it um as well um I just I think that worker placement is just that's my jam and it's I have I haven't played White Castle in in a little bit I I forget the last
time I played I know I played it solo like right around when we first moved here and I think I might have played it solo again between now and then but every time I play it I'm always just reminded of oh wow this game's amazing yeah it's well obviously that that was uh one of the best games and this Channel's favorite game uh not last year but the year before and man the the economy of decisions um that you're making and I can imagine that for some people that is like just too brain burny and I am someone who kind of gets overwhelmed by too much information but something about how White Castle organizes strategy and giving you just a little bit of a nudge and kind of seeing where this can result in just a couple turns um it it's less like uh the the kind of development and strategy of like someone who outlines a story um and more like uh George R Martin famously talked about how he was a gardener with his plot developments where he left a little seeds that he could pick up on and sometimes they would kind of Wither and sometimes you know he'd be able to Blossom them and so instead of having this like concrete outline of what needed to happen he was a gardener and that Rings true to me with how the White
Castle works I still feel like you know turn six or seven is still reaping the rewards of a couple early decisions but I wasn't locked into those exactly like continually pivoting is so good it's so good it's so good it's so good and the solo is great too yeah and I think that that's a really that makes it such a solid contention for like if I had to pick five games only for it to be like on that list it's it's at least it makes it worthy of being in the discussion is what I would say worthy of being in the discussion um as if maybe I too had written in this notebook in front of me uh a list of games that if I had only five say Desert Island games um what they would be I when you first sent the text of like oh what about desert island games I don't know if I texted you that I made the confusion but I read it as Forbidden Island games and I was I was really confused for B cuz I was like Forbidden Island there's only three games what do you mean five Forbidden Island games hey you're behind the times ma' we're up to four we got Island Desert Sky and jungle I haven't played the latter two when did Jungle come out uh I knew about sky like two years ago and while Sky jungle is not going to
give me the answer I just I I was Googling just jungle that's yeah forbidden sky was not particularly well received but jungle is supposed to be good we could do a podcast on those two board game series I feel like is a is a topic we'll loop back to that we'll put a pin in that we will We Will We Will reass reassess that um when the time comes but citizens of the audio board game verse if you want a cardboard Herald Review of Forbidden Jungle then we will go out and get a copy of Forbidden Jungle to who play this game maybe maybe we can find some way of doing like some you know like solo playthrough of the game too maybe do do a I mean we could also just do like podcast like do a podcast on Forbidden Island do a podcast on Forbidden Desert where we just play the game and talk about it while we're playing it um I have no clue how a lot of Matt Le uh in one in one consecutive uh series of podcasts maybe that's we'll see save that for the least so you don't think you don't think Matt Leck deserves deserves his flowers is what I'm hearing you want to tear him down right now actually uh he is a former guest on the cardboard Herald and when I talked to him I asked him something about like
what does he do when he gets a cold uh I was very interested in the relationship of like pandemic and him uh but we did talk about all kinds of stuff what does he do what does he do no no no what does he do I can't remember this was like six years ago it it was my friend uh Sarah and mo i they were the most obsessive um pandemic players I know they like log all their results in a notebook that has like a Sanctified place in their house and they play on the hardest difficulty and then play house rules to make it even more difficult they're insane with their pmic but uh I said hey I'm interviewing Matt Le and we're mainly talking about board games but if there's anything you want me to ask uh I will ask one question on your behalf um and I can't even remember it at this point because I've been doing this forever um seems like but that's not the topic for today so why why don't you talk about what the pitch is so the pitch is you are stranded on a desert island for I don't an unspecified amount of time I think it can be we can we could also maybe this will be a different level of games we would bring but one year 5 years forever and you can only bring five games to entertain yourself for the entire time you were on this desert island what five games do you bring and this was you suggested it but I also was
going to suggest it at some point or another because uh my wall while we were running our I just ran a half marathon and my sister sent us questions to answer while we ran each Mile and one of the questions she had for me was or for for the group I was running with was uh you're stranded on a desert island for one year you're allowed to bring one book one movie one album and those are the only forms of entertainment you have for the entire year and my first question was can I substitute the album for a board game and they said yes I don't know about like ditching music but I guess you only get a few minutes of uh entertainment out of aing I figured album is depending on what album you choose unless you choose like a very long album you're getting sub one hour of of content there right and I figured that was the one I could probably convince us to swap out that is good run Tech uh and uh something that people who don't do a lot of distance running or cycling or you know like some other activity where you just kind of lock in and you go for a long distance they might not realize that the wandering mind having something kind of creative to focus on really distracts you from
the exhaustion in fact this ties back to the cardboard Herald because the very Genesis of cardboard Herald was on a run um here on brotherhood Trail in Juno uh where I was thinking about creative things that I wanted to do for other reasons and I was listening to other podcasts and I was thinking about what I would like to see in a podcast or a written review type of thing and I during the Run had thought about it for about half an hour and then hit record and then recorded as I was running on the way back just like some quick notes on what I wanted this to be because I didn't want to uh like let that wandering mind just release all that information um so yeah good good Tech I thought you I thought you were going to say you just started recording the first podcast and I was going to say that audio must have been really good I think the 100th episode uh because there's this whole backlog of interviews when this was just like an audio only podcast thing before we even had like video channel content um I think I put that in the 100th episode yeah yeah this shows this shows about how much of the channel lore have been privy to I mean for being as old as it is there's only I mean it's not that big of a channel so like
it's not many people know much about the channel lore for as much Channel lore and history there is to discover um but anyway uh so did you when you were organizing your desert island list did you put any additional parameters on it Beyond just what you've shared so I I don't think I put any additional parameters in terms of what the games have to be um I I think my presumption is there will be at minimum three other people who are willing to play board games I think giving yourself that that ability to say up to four players you can play more player I I think you can bring games that can play more players and you can also bring games that are only solo but right the assumption is you have if you would like them there are three other players that are will play with you at your request that way it's not like you can only bring solo games or you can't bring games that are that much um oh gez uh pencil falling dangerous situations hazards of podcasting um so I uh thought the same thing you know I don't know if there's going to be other players there or not but um I did think about this maybe in a slight aew version of the original
premises um or premise uh and that's you know like there's a lot of paranoia going around there's a lot of you know like who knows what's happening and uh so there was almost this like prepper aspect to me you know and so I was thinking about well I can't just bring with me all the games that have the most content or the biggest games so I did apply just a couple um parameters to mine one of those uh being that I didn't know how many players there were going to be so it might be just me might be other people I don't know who's going to see me on this island so every one of the games I picked can be played solo uh and the second thing was I wanted it to almost be like it could fit in a bugout bag like all the games have to be able to to fit into let's say a carryon uh for an airplane or something something something about that size uh so that way that gives me limitations and more than anything that gives me reasons to talk about different games than I normally talk about there's going to be some overlap if you know the cardboard ha lore uh enough to know some of the favorite games uh you'll you'll see some of the faves come up but uh yeah that that gave me a reason to kind of uh search for some different stuff so uh um Eric what uh
tell me either about what some of the considerations you made when making your list or go ahead and start it out with uh the top of your list yeah so I think the considerations I had going into this were I want them to be games that it will be very difficult to have the same experience with um or at least games that I feel like I I I wanted to have a little bit of a spectrum of games that are easy and like chill and games that are like crunchy my my goal was to have a little bit of something throughout the Spectrum um variety so with that I had some games that I I went back and forth on a few where it was either games that are similar or games that were in the same genre but I might have elected a game that was a little bit lighter um just to make sure I'm I'm I'm hitting all parts of the board gaming Spectrum so for me first consideration was making sure I had games for all emotional states when I want a game that's really easy and light and when I want a game that is challenging um so I'll start off with one that I think there's a chance I would say if I had to put a percentage on it like 80 to 90% chance is also on your list because when
I think of one game that I would want to play Forever it's Spirit Island yeah it's so thematic that's also on my list that is my one I thought it was I thought it would be it just is yeah we can go back game we can go back and forth on this plays great solo uh plays great with other players tons to to witness and even when you're seeing the same uh cards the same Powers the same uh Spirits uh like you're playing The Same Spirit the combination of spirits always makes for Unique game States and the game State itself is going to impact what cards are most worthwhile for you to uh pick it just has so much um reactivity to it um there's so much to pull out of that game it's it's unbelievable um and because it's not a campaign game um you don't necessarily reach an end and go like well I'm retreading the same water if I play this over again I I think that's actually something that works in its favor as compared to like I was like do I want to do I want a Gloom Haven on here yeah I feel like I don't I don't have Gloom Haven on my list either and it's probably for reasons where it's just there is a finite point where I
feel like it is you can still get enjoyment out of Gloom Haven but you you aren't going to get the same novel reaction of discovering the story like the main overarching story for the first time as your first play through right and that is super reasonable to say like well you know I'm only there for a year or five years you know how long was how long was your Gloom Haven campaign yeah well if you if you can limit yourself to one one session a week for however long that'll take you how long the other thing about uh Gloom Haven and frost Haven is yeah you do retire characters but you're essentially doing the same thing over and over again I guess part of it is the like participating with a party and if you're on the island and you're you know locked in with your other residents then maybe that that means something but uh I don't know I feel uh that every game of spirit Island feels more unique and um puzzly than every game of say something like Gloom Haven and frost Haven even though I really love those games or Adventure tactics or even sleeping gods or you know some of these other um great Campaign games now uh since you went
ahead and shared one of yours uh so some of the things that I thought about um and spirit island is one of mine as well um is I wanted diverse genres so like you I wanted kind of like a versatility in games um variable Avenues to explore the games uh in some way you know like either change Up characters or kind of variable strategies within or um different levels of challenge something that gives it a little bit more consideration other than just the joy of playing it again and again uh and then strong components in aesthetic you know one of the things I love about board games is I like the tactile nature of them I like the visuals I really want if I only have five games I want them to be something that you know like I I I get a kick out of so uh my one of my small box considerations uh was River Valley glassw Works a recent allplay title um has just a great Central uh literal River uh mechanism that you pull gems from or or glass stones uh that feel really great they look really great uh and it has the vibe of something like Azul or Sada uh so that kind of ties into that abstract
strategy um mode but it's also very easy to teach and it's very friendly and inviting and the the visuals are uh topnotch so uh I was like yeah you know if I'm going to have one of these games it has solo has lots of different levels of solo it's got a good amount of content and really stuffs into that small box let's go with River Valley Glass Works yeah totally and I I think that makes sense I guess when I was planning out mine I didn't really just I was thinking like you took this as like prepper like oh the world is destroyed I thought oh this is like a Mr Beast challenge where I get to bring things and it's fun and they'll transport it for me so this will be an interesting version of our list pull off the face mask and I'm Mr Beast and you have a chance to win like $10 million H welcome to board game Island here know nothing about Mr Beast five of your friends didn't he win a dune Imperium tournament he did yeah no he's very into board games he's he's I think he won a dune Imperium tournament he won some I'm pretty sure it's Dune Imperium uh I think you have that spot on um um yeah he actually is like really he organized it and then also won it but not in a way that's sad or
underhanded I think he just was like I love this board game I want to play this board game I have essentially unlimited money I'm going to throw a tournament for this board game and therefore I'm really good at this game because of how much I play it he won the tournament and I'm glad that you mentioned Dune Imperium um I went back and forth a few times with it because I I love June Imperium I consider it one of my one of my top five games depending on the day um I went back and forth on Dune Imperium and clink also by Paul dennan because clink was like clink for me is a comfort game because it's just it kind of got it didn't it got my wife into board games it is just a really much simpler to understand deck builder SL worker placement type thing it's not really worker placement but it's you have a you have a meele that you move around the board using your cards and I think Clank with the expansions again just for trying to hit all levels of complexity because I I think June Imperium is not as difficult to Spirit
Island but I think that it is in the ballpark at least for in terms of like my how I internally rank these games so I chose clink as in one of my other games um as opposed to Imperium despite the fact that I think that I enjoy Dune Imperium more but it just will occupy the same space of oh I am I am really going to need to like Focus to play this game whereas clink you can tune out a little bit in in some ways where it's like you know you're you're kind of building an engine at some point or another you're just like well this is what I have I'm not going to really like try to optimize this I'm going to take my three movement and move further into the the dungeon Clank the board game does not have Jason mimoa in it does that change your opinion when you mention it like that it also doesn't have Timmy yeah so Timmy c big Timmy C the our non Oscar winner y well um I think another game that does not have uh Timothy Shalom or Jason mimoa in it which is unless you discover the the secret Easter egg yeah it's the White Castle we talked about it earlier now I'm going to leave it to
people out there to find you know the all their it's just it's so good to see a board game not have Timothy sham and Jason mimo and the White Castle is so brave for for not including those two in their board game and they we talked about the White Castle earlier and I did not anticipate us talking about it because we uh while we do some of our individual prep work we usually don't uh like convene and plan out what the games are that we played in advance but I sure wrote it down over here oh I guess I'm sailing the rest of the list I okay know how visual that was but I did write down the White Castle um again really strong solo I I'm still in this weird matcha Zone you have you entered the matcha Zone yet I haven't I haven't got my hands on the matcha Zone okay when you're up here for your wedding um or I guess wedding celebration uh this uh coming year um we'll we'll play some matcha and see how you feel in the matcha Zone it on one hand is a lot more of what I love about the White Castle and on the other hand it kind of takes away from what is like so almost like fetishistically pure about the White Castle but I can have it with me and choose not to play it or choose to play
with it uh and that gives me that extra layer and the White Castle is I think right now um for the size of box that it is which is I I considered that uh uh Lighter Side of medium uh box and I I feel like it's just one of the best worker placement uh values per box size that you can get out there I still might like a grica and viticulture slightly more Harvest is also really up there but uh if it's just up to me the White Castle is just it's so good it's so good and solo is good we talked about that earlier yeah SOLO is good I I think White Castle is a great option to bring I mean it just is it's a great game we it's really fun multiplayer in a way that is in my mind different than the solo mode like the enjoyment I get out of the solo mode is more uh more anticipating the machine you're playing against versus like the multiplayer you're trying to anticipate them but I feel like you are more trying to optimize like how do I avoid getting blocked by them in a way that you know the multiplayer just doesn't quite have and but it's good because they are different the solo modes are different
than and it's dice worker placement but done in a way where you're not getting screwed over by the dice yeah because you roll the dice and it's a shared pool which is such a cool thing I mean I I love the Voyages of Marco Polo or rather I love Marco Polo 2 uh which I think is the much better game uh but both of those are dice worker placement but you're still using your personal Dice and ringing what you can out of that here it's the contention between the dice that are out there and sometimes you want the lower dice or the higher Dice and sometimes you want to go second sometimes you don't there's a lot of cool things that happen uh with such a a small frame work in that but uh we we've gushed our White Castle hearts out so let's let's hear another Poll for you so this one is going towards the uh I like having a ton of content and I like having a ton of options to play and I think you know exactly which game this is it is Imperium or Horizon and I think that the The Good the thing that really boosts Imperium here with this hypothetical is it is it is for people and in theory it's the same for people so I only have to go through the nightmare that is teaching this game once and then I can just play it
multiplayer forever or one year or five years you can be on the island with four people including yourself you can break out and Imperium and say hey do you guys want to play this and then everyone looks at it and goes oh that looks like a lot and then you're left to your own devices and can play solo as many people find the best version of Imperium that is true and then problem solved I think that it for me that's a great I either case either case is great for me yeah it's either I can go ham on all the different variations in the solo mode playing through the different difficulty levels or maybe I actually can play multiplayer for more than two games with one person uh which is currently my high score do you have all of the sets at this point all three of them yeah yeah yeah what is what is your favorite faction to play from each of the sets oo this is also really good audio to questions that I didn't prepare you for yeah no this is great listen we'll I'll talk about it I think that in theory playing against other people the waga do Empire feels very nice from Imperium Horizons where it's you're interacting
with trade routes more which means you're interacting with the other players at the table in a way that is somewhat positive and it seems like a lot of their abilities allow you to do that but then they have like the weird packed with bada which just gives you like a little bit of friction that you have to deal with every time in a way that is fun um in terms of solo I think that the oh I like the Chin Dynasty cuz you have to bounce back and forth between confu ISM and legalism in a way that is I find rewards skill which if I'm going to be uh playing solo mode uh is nice it's nice to feel like what I'm doing is really really impactful uh I also that was the first uh dast that was the first thing that I played as so for me I feel like it's uh I have a little bit of sentimentality towards them um okay yeah yeah yeah I I I would play Imperium with you if we were on a desert island we we I don't know if that's true well I mean then you'd still be happy right still be happy this is true that is the outcome that I'm hoping for
um I really want to see you bring Imperium Horizons to like a public Meetup yeah and the full intent is to show that you know you're happy to be here you're here to be social but then you're just off in your corner playing that by yourself would be totally fine too photo of a shark in the in the middle of a school of fish just completely empty space around him while everybody else is hanging out could be fun yeah could be good I like it we're at a desert island the confessionals For That season of Survivor are going to be rad and it's like yeah that guy just he brought a he didn't he hasn't justess been asking him to come to the challenges and he's just over there playing Imperium Horizons nobody knows what it is he won't explain it he says he gets scared well my uh next game is another small box game uh and I wanted to go for what was the small box game like the smallest box that I'd still really want to bring um get a lot of content out of out of it has a solo mode plays well multiplayer you know like there there are a lot of things that I I considered you know like I could go as far down as like a button shy game or a pack of cards but I thought a pack of cards was a little I was thinking you know regicide could be an option but then you just kind of because you have a deck of cards that was a consideration but I am nothing if not joyous to talk about some
newer uh stuff and some stuff that doesn't uh get on a lot of people's Radars so I picked boblins belly oh yeah yeah yeah you just did a review on that it looks really interesting yeah it's in a little square box it has a completely unhinged visual aesthetic I think it's actually a spin-off of a um other series uh drop dungeon and and drop space I want to say uh yeah that's correct yeah yeah and uh so um it just has this look where everything is cubes uh in a completely goofy way uh and it takes what terraforming Mars does of having like the the three types of Cubes depending on their placement on your Tableau represent a different type of currency it does that except it's just one Cube for everything there is a second Cube for like the antagonistic trolls uh but otherwise you just have this Goblin Cube and that Goblin could be a basic Goblin or any other type of goblin it's actually a really good small engine building game that is cute it's fun it's silly uh has some really smart things and I I I found myself in a position recently to be talking about engine building games where uh I hear a
lot of discourse online where people are like I want an engine building game where you actually get your engine going and then get to experience your engine uh and I disagree with that you know like I I find the act of building the engine is the really satisfying part uh you know like really making challenging decisions and sacrifices to kind of get that going but then when you're just performing at ultimate levels of efficiency it becomes much more boring because you've already done what you need to do and if the game continues too much longer then it's just like well this is more performative at this point um so one thing that I think boblins Rebellion does really well that other broader more uh grander in scope engine building games could do is uh a lot of the tools that you have collapse as you use them a certain number of times so you're constantly having to feed new things into the engine not just resources but the infrastructure itself which is really cool idea um and when you get things exchanging at a good rate it feels like you consistently have more capabilities but nonetheless you don't ever reach a level of like automation that takes away the the fun of the game yeah totally uh two two notes one uh the games are Dungeon Drop and drop Drive
are the are the games that it is it is uh vaguely tied to and two a thing that I uh having read like board game design Theory um that I sometimes board game design theory is uh not the most accurate uh or maybe it's a bit outdated as games and tastes have changed but one thing that I agree with is always ending the game one turn for for engine building games end it one turn before the engine would be complete so that players always are like making choices to build their engine and it sounds like with boblins Rebellion it is uh you did the thumbs up again I didn't even have my thumb up it was like over by my cheek this is so off topic we were FaceTiming some friends of ours today and we did this and it caused a raincloud to happen and a I was very confused how it happened cuz I forgot that iOS just does that now um yeah I guess yeah it's that for they're they're predicting everything for us for for the audio listeners Jack gave a thumbs up and he got the little bubble thumbs up um but yeah don't give them a carrot make them come to the channel for context audio listeners forget what I said forget all of it no more um but
yeah I think that like again not I haven't played bins Rebellion um but it does sound like it gives you a really interesting reason why you can't just put the engine on autopilot and you still have to make like very you have to make choices every round and those choices seem meaningful in a way that you know you have an engine builder that just goes right that's much less fun at the end of it at least I also like that you you said I found myself in a situation where I was talking about engine building to start that to start that talk about engine building as if you didn't purposefully put yourself in that situation recording a review yeah found myself in a situation how could I possibly have foreseen this to to get into how the sausage is made uh whenever I'm working on a review uh largely they are scripted um the the things that are labeled as like mini reviews or seem more conversational than they probably are I do some unscripted stuff but if it's just tcbh review chances are I scripted it and I spent a lot of time thinking about like what it is that I want to say uh and rarely am I trying to explain the entirety of a game um because I think most people who are
looking up a review for a game can sus out the majority of what they need to know about uh most of it if you give just a little bit of context some commenters would uh take issue with that because they want me to explain a lot more of the game but I guess that's for other channels um but I do try to think about like what are the three prevailing positive or negative thoughts that I have about this game um the things that were neat or interesting or novel uh that are worth discussing like if I were to be hanging out with Eric independent of recording anything and I was like hey dude have you checked out this game well it it's this type of game but you know what it really does um and so uh in this review of life of the Amazonia it's a game that I really like but I I kept on thinking about like as I played it several times each time I got to the point where like my engine was as good as it was going to be and I still had a bunch of turns left and so like the first hour and a half of that game is like oh feel so good and then it was just getting it done um Spirit island has a lot of the same accusations that people lay on it you know you get to the point where you see that you've won the game and then it's a
round or two as you perform the ending but I find that much more satisfying because you're still having to make interesting decisions whereas the the end of life of Amazonia which is a good game I do like that game still has this weird feeling of the the best parts of the game were behind you and now you're just grasping as many animals as quickly as you can to to drain the pool yeah and I think with Spirit Island the biggest difference is in in my mind I can see I can see where that argument's going where it's like you know you know you've won why why is the game not over yet but it feels a lot more oh yeah I did it I get to do the last few actions to prove that I did it it's and also like if you see that you have already done it you can just choose to end it like you can just see like okay cool well we've won if you want to like in in a way that's different because you know it's first of all it's Cooperative you can just you can say okay well we can verify prove that we have won the game we don't need to go through all of this and hopefully people don't uh take that to a non uh official ending we're getting a little off topic so I'm going to ring it back in or yeah I'm going to ring it back in yeah you did bobin's Rebellion it's up to me now um I the fourth game I have on my list and
this kind of it it's good because we just talked about this game quite a bit last week I even put in the thumbnail um is Sushi go like I just think that that is a very good for me this is easy I am not going to really think about it too much this is I'm kind of turning my brain off and we're having a fun kind of social time and at the same time if we do want to take it very seriously it's a game that that highly encourages social interaction of oh what is everybody else grabbing like I need to make sure that I'm I I I see what the maky rolls are doing around me in a way that uh I think works I could see the argument of doing Seven Wonders here instead but I think I mean Seven Wonders with the with the expansions leaders and there's there's an argument that that is the better game to bring here and it's probably just because Sushi go was on my mind because we talked about it so much last week and I do love Seven Wonders and in in theory I probably should choose Seven Wonders but I wrote down Sushi go so we're sticking with sushi and I think Sushi go party is is fun and more the I'm looking for the lowest level I have to think
game uh-huh that I would still want to play many many times okay so if I were moving across the country as you recently did uh Sushi go might be one of those games where I'm like oh I want this game to have like a really light game in case I'm going to public meetups yeah you know like I'm going to a pub night or something like I at my regular public meet up a lot of the games that we play or oink games or you know smaller party games or or social games Sushi go works perfect for that I don't really see it as a desert island game personally because you know like there's only so much you're going to get out of sushi go after 5 years and you know like that that wasn't a consideration for me but it is a nice small game and you could probably do something
or something like that I don't know I don't plan on actually being on a desert island I plan on being on a Mr Beast Island okay they me give me food and money and also uh uh friends to and and Jimmy comes out and goes I'm playing as Timothy shalam on a desert island I think uh he should use his vast sums of money to hire Timothy shalam to be the like Local Host so like you know this is sponsored by Mr Beast but uh Timothy shalam is performing as Mr Beast on the island um Timothy sham dresses up as well dress up as Mr Beast he just dresses in a suit so it's not that crazy um I that would be very fun to have Timothy shamay play Mr Beast while Mr Beast plays in a in a Dun Imperium tournament on a desert island as like the concept of a video wait is this a board game podcast or is this a award-winning script writing podcast because we got gold on our hand gold okay my my my last game on here let let me double check uh because uh we have digressed so much uh yes my last game uh I went for one of
medium siiz game I'm assuming Spirit island with expansion content is large I have that kind of Consolidated to a a a Franken box but I got all in one box uh and then we had boblins Rebellion we had River Valley Glassworks both of small games and then in the medium territory we already talked about the White Castle and just a little bit bigger than that is terraforming Mars Aries Expedition which we've about um and you could accuse AR's expedition of having some of these like challenges with um uh engine building games where you get to the point where it's like oh I'm the god emperor of Mars at this point I just need to take a few more action phases and we're done yeah but that always feels to me like maybe the last you know like two rounds of the game instead of the last uh you know several turns that you're uh performing things um and it's just so varied there's so much in that little box uh especially if you have the expansions which fit inside of the Box uh great components uh visuals not so great but you hey the original terraforming Mars wasn't exactly a looker either uh and uh I can ring a lot out of that solo um the okay Cooperative mode uh that's in the uh base game or the slightly better but
still okay Cooperative mode in the expansion or just competitive which is great I love that game and it fits within my scheme of having an array of different sizes of game yeah that makes sense I think that I I heavily considered it just because dun sorry terraforming Mars is just such that both the base game and Aries Expedition are games that I frequently want to play like I is going to be tough for me to be in a situation where I don't want to play either of those games and I think AR's Expedition Sushi go Sushi go was you know what you chose and said so you know when you put you like when you put would I rather play in a vacu would I rather play Aries Expedition or sushi go Sushi go wins every time I did I did say that that is that is exactly what I said with my list I was choosing an array I was choosing an array of games from turn my brain off to full brain power full more than 10% of my brain which is a nonsense thing but I still will use it for this example I was like I would like to use only 10% of my game when I play this and I also I kind of had this I didn't put this at the front so now it might seem like I'm backtracking I had a little bit of a mind when I was making this that the
people I was on the island with aren't board gamers and so I wanted games at like every step to get them into board gaming even though none of my other games have Tableau building or like I pick and pass a card mechanisms in them but I see okay I I had that in my mind too cuz we just talked about Gateway Games and I was it was in the back of my mind I'm not going to say it was the end all be I mean it it wasn't that much in the back of your mind considering one of the games that you were choosing was Imperium Horizons and like I I do not see the logistical path between Sushi go and being like well now that you got this covered here's Imperium Horizon in my mind Spirit island is most difficult most brain is functioning game and then small step below is Imperium Horizons okay at the earlier end of it we have sushi go and Clank with the expansions and now you're number five and my number five and I went back and forth on this because I really wanted to include harmonies because I like it a lot at this exact moment uhhuh I haven't sat with it for very long so possible I get bored of it at the moment we talked about it a
lot and so I went to choose I I chose a different game that I'm choosing because I've had such fun experiences playing it and I feel like every time I play it I get a story of what's Happening as we build out the board slowly and again this is a game that is one that I feel like I can play with anybody and hopefully ease them into Imperium Horizons and that game is kassan with all of the expansions you can take out what's up including the Catapult I'd say yeah sure we we don't have to play with catapult we don't have to play with the Catapult but it's at least an option but I just feel like anytime I play kassan it is light we build a fun story with how we build out the map and I think that it would get very I can see it becoming repetitive which is one of the reasons why I went back and forth on having this on my list versus harmonies versus Cascadia and I was trying to get games that all occupied that like half Step Above Sushi go where it is games that are not the most difficult in the world but are still pretty light and
give you interesting choices and I feel like you build like little you build U-turn City you build Mega City every time and you you build things that have like fun names that you've created the name for and it's not logical but it's like you know it's a very social thing that brings you to a point where you are talking about the other players at the table and trying to scheme around with how how is Jack going to try to connect his farmer to my field and it it I think just invites a lot more of interaction with the other players at the table in a way that is light-hearted and fun and it's just it's it's a great game and I think lighthearted and fun I say a a great way of inviting uh like Mutiny and uh cannibalism possibly uh like dangerous things are happening on that island after you know like someone is learning because in your island people are just learning these games and you're taking them through a journey I don't think you're going to have to worry about having other players when you get to emperium because the moment someone plays carcasson and they're like oh this is a such a fun nice game isn't it nice to just like put our things out and then someone else realizes oh I could just make your
Castle impossible to build I don't even have to be in it I'm just going and put this here and now you'll never get to finish that and you could say goodbye to that worker it's just gone forever your Cathedral it's there in sham exactly your field all Barren exact eviscerated and never mind the idea of getting your farmer into someone else's zone or your Castle be like oh you did a lot of work on this Castle I'm nudge myself a little bit closer and and you know what it can be our Castle weird that is going to uh break a lot of hearts and possibly break a lot of skulls with the lack of food and uh overexposure to Sunshine on your desert island see but I feel like in those moments when you have like these huge huge villain turns in carcassone it it invites monologuing in a way that's really fun for a desert island you know perfect you know that thing that famously has a lot of people talking back and forth instead you can just have one person doing a villain monologue to the other people you know that fun thing that happens all the time I think we just discovered some new board game shorts possibilities that we can put on to YouTube which is like your villainous monologuing as you are about to do something really skull dous in
carcasson it's interesting that castle you've built the walls seem sturdy the city finances seem to be blooming it's a shame that field it's connected to has a little opening for my castle and the only way you'll be able to complete this is joining our cities H I'm so here for this and loving this like dramatic production that's happening right now I am kind of worried about the chord wrapping around Eric as he twists his there's there's some concerning implications of the 360 that's uh happening right now so that uh while he completes his heel turn get it heel turn um while he unwinds himself that's our five that that's our five each which I guess ultimately ended up at nine right yeah our our nine total games um my five just to recap were Spirit Island uh Imperium Horizons sh Sushi go clink and carcasson um I feel like I got a nice little spread all all things considered you got a nice wide array of much effort you put in and then also you know varying varying forms of content in there with the different expansions for
carcasson and Clank as well as Spirit Island obviously um yeah and these lists are really here to give us a ways of thinking about our collections in in different lights than just simply what our favorite games are um and sometimes you end up with some of your favorite games still at the top um but uh you know as uh this podcast goes on if you want to hear more lists out of us uh or other ideas for discussions definitely let us know uh wrapping up my list um for my small boox games I had boblins rebellion and River Valley Glassworks for my medium-size games I had the White Castle and terraforming Mars Aries Expedition and for my large game I had Spirit Island and uh similarly I think it's a good spread I think the well reasoned and different perspectives on how we approached this very broad topic um I just think you're going to be you're going to miss not having sushi go I think so think you're going to really really feel that absence well you know it was a it was a strong sixth uh you know it could have been there it was a contender um like Marlin Brando in at the waterfront could have been a contend a contender um we have one audience um
list here that I think would be interesting to discuss now that we have decided upon ours um just to pull it up and chat about it and kind of our thoughts on why we would or why we wouldn't bring a game and I think for for some of these it is I I think we were thinking of different islands in in a way so from Blue SE Pearl uh the comment is my criteria are variety replayability and escapism taking a pack of cards off the list as that would be cheating and I we agreed um but incredibly versatile I and this is sorry this is a tangent within within the customer or the uh uh uh audience uh comment um boy customer if I could just bring if I could bring a dice set we would be set I'd be playing so much Dungeons and Dragons we'd be we'd be playing a Dungeons and Dragons campaign set on an island boy that's a good call hours of fun but I think that that's that's out of the purview of of this question back to back to the comment um uh here are my selections goal I have the first edition that plays up to 12 nice bluffing snack siiz game monikers good solid party game that creates wonderful inside jokes and provides levity in a stressful
environment could be really fun on a desert island to have some levity uh spirit Island which we're in agreement with lots of way to play my main concern is that it might suffer the fate of pandemic during the p mic do you really want to play unrelenting gaze of the sun on a beach I would substitute terraforming Mars is what it says I disagree Spirit island is inherently triumphant that is our Island and we are the keepers of the island until we are rescued so if there are any Invaders that come to the island without the intent to rescue us we must repel them so it gives us training um and uh dark irony you don't dismiss dark irony uh betrayal at at the house on the hill uh emergent storytelling with 50 to 100 scenarios I think they're including widows walk on that and then Ticket to Ride rails and sails or botney a simple game about traveling the world while stuck on a beach um I think this is a solid list I think the in my mind when I'm thinking I kind of put the stipulation on myself that it would be limited to or not limited to but like you would have four players total which monikers if you have like a whole Island full of people monikers is great I I think that's a great game for creating
those inside jokes and and giving you some sort of creativity um in terms of trying to figure out how to best mime mime forth uh many of the suggestions um yeah loses points for having a rival uh as if we're Rivals uh uh special edition with the moniker shut up and sit down uh hilarity box or whatever it is now unless until monikers is coming to the true best board game channel on the internet uh what would some of the prompts be what would please tell me what some of the prompts would be for card hey hey I'm not I'm not selling this right here right now you know giving away these ideas for other Chumps like uh you know uh shut up and sit down Dice Tower for them to steal our ideas as they've been doing nonstop since before this podcast even existed um no uh monikers is a great idea uh there's a lot of good social games that uh could have gone on here um it's just you know know like when it when it really comes down to it I really want those strategy games and I'll get the social element or we could play you know like charades or you know we don't need we don't need we don't need a board game to play charades yeah exactly exactly skull I think is great I love skull um I think
that's a solid bluffing game I think my my thoughts on it are the like status quo would change a lot so there's a lot of adapting to what other people are doing I I would worry with it becoming stale just in terms of there isn't there isn't an element of Randomness in a way like you're not bluffing based on a deck of cards and like you can't necessarily learn the best probabilities of what's going to be coming out here uh in a way that I feel like you would start missing out on after a bit the first year that coup came out I probably played at least 50 probably upwards towards a 100 games of coup uh and let me tell you as good of a game as coup is and I could totally play that right now you start going I'm done with coup I I don't need more coup I'm good on the coup uh and I think that uh skulls might suffer the same fate um especially because a single game of skull is over at about 10 minutes which is a perfect amount of time for skull but then you usually want to play it maybe a couple times while you're having drinks or whatever and then move on to something else or or maybe that's the night uh it's very much an activity
to do while you're doing something else I'm thinking of this list personally as like this is one of the chief forms of entertainment that we have here this is a one of our only luxuries that we have on this island so I I wanted more meat on the bones yeah totally um and then I think my last not necessarily my last thought another thought I have on this is betray at house on the hill um I think the emergent storytelling is really fun I hadn't really necessarily considered that but that is also a game that has a lot of you make your own story as you play it of like who are these characters that we're playing as what are they doing and then you also then end up with one of the many different endings you might have and that is what it is um I think that the fact that there are like limited 50 to 100 with widows walk I'm pretty sure that's the number gets up to with that expansion um that it is I don't think it's limited in the same way that Gloom Haven is because even if you play the same scenario you know you kind of got there in a different way most of the time at the same time I just don't like playing it like I I I don't really love betrayal like I it
it is very good for what it is or and when it came out like it's an important moment in board gaming history but I don't I don't really I don't really want to play it I was going to say that it the enjoyment I get out of betray house on the hill is the storytelling aspect of it you're not making many strategic choices in this game it's it's more you have to make up the story as you go along and that to me is the fun part about it and I can feel I I feel like there are other games that do that part of this better um at the same time if your friend group likes betrayal at house on the hill yeah totally bring this game this is a great game if if your friend group is the type that is going to be like Fool sned on the weird absurdest improv comedy that comes out of playing a game of betrayal at house on the hill uh then that's a great game to bring with you um especially if you guys are okay with like you might end up replaying one of the 50 to 100 scenarios um I think it can be a great came on a desert island depending on who else is on the island with you and then my my last thought is you don't have sushi go so zero out of 10 yeah exactly no Timothy Shalom no Jason mimoa no Mr Beast no sushi go like what is this list what is this list what are you what are you looking for
here and also and also another thought no drop hter I can't believe that they would include drop hter on their list of games that they would have to play for an entire year do you know how strong your hand muscles would get you'd be able to like uh build a boat get off that Island exactly exclus hand mus drop well we want to hear from everyone about what their uh personal desert island list is and uh get creative what are the parameters that you would put on it what do you think of our list and also you know ultimately even if we're dunking on some other games here the right games are the games for you and that's what we as a community and we as the cardboard Herald are all about is making sure that people find the games that are going to resonate the most with them and so where can people go to drop us a line Eric find us at uh on YouTube uh at the cardboard Herald uh you can also find us on Spotify under the card board Herald or go to the cardboard Herald or just cardboard herald.com just cardboard herald.com cardboard herald.com uh and you can also email us at cardboard Herald gmail.com if you want to uh message us there uh that's a great way of reaching out to us and we look forward to that I think on both
Spotify and well definitely YouTube and Spotify you can leave comments for us there and we will always take a look at those and respond to those uh in the best way that we can um let us know I kind of want to hear other people's desert islands because now that I've put my list out there I'm obviously a bit self-conscious about my list cuz why would I not be no no it's a perfect list it's perfect and I want to hear people dunk on me for my choices tell me tell me why tell me why some of these games are are not the best and also dunk on Jack too if you're going to dunk on me also dunk on Jack it's very important his ego does not get that big perfect list perfect list there is not a single flaw in it yeah objective we're done like board game content creation is done I just want it yeah all all email all email shut up and sit down in the Dice Tower and Rodney yeah exactly I'll let them all know it's time to time to shut it down turn the servers off thank you all for listening as this is going to be the final cardboard heral podcast apparently as I've just found out three seconds ago that all I got this oh sorry I got this breaking news breaking news uh there is a really hideous new version of quacks of qulin Saw that's dropping so we'll
we'll have at least some more content to talk about the coming year you know podcast isn't cancelled you can tune in next week probably on Sundays when it'll come out Sunday at noon eastern time uh almost certainly sometimes it's Monday occasionally it's been Tuesday but usually Sunday Monday or Tuesday uh the next episode will be coming out thanks to this new edition of quacks of qued Linberg that has just been announced thank you for tuning in I have been Eric with the cardboard Herald podcast along with Jack that's me and tell us if you have some topics because quax is not going to be the topic we we don't want to just dunk on it what Jack I just promise the audience well no you promised that because of quacks but you know like are we going to fill an entire episode with speculation on just like cover art do you think people actually make content that's speculation based off of trailers and cover art and you know like movie posters and that kind of stuff yeah come on that that wouldn't be loow hanging fruit that people would turn to immediately it would be really good for our audio podcast to talk about the bo game cover thank you for tuning in thanks everyone later bye
h