Broken Meeple Podcast - Episode 128 - Was I Too Generous?
Transcript
Hi everyone. Everyone, Luke Hector here recording podcast 128. It's uh a little dark in here, but I don't think that'll be too bad. It should be all right. I got some uh window light there, and if necessary, I'll go turn the light on. But uh yeah, this is 128, February the 8th, and this is a big uh penultimate day for me because uh I pretty much have had the easiest couple of months of my life in terms of work stress sort of. I mean, I basically wound down my notice period for my last job, and that ended on the end of January. And whenever you're in the notice period for work, it's typically a an easier ride, shall we say, compared to, you know, full-on work. And then, especially during January when there's not a lot of work for corporate tax accountants anyway.
But then I also took a week off break between leaving on the 30th of Jan and starting my new job tomorrow. Yes, I I start tomorrow. Was they originally sort of wanted like second, but now I need a week break. I've been up north to visit my brother, hence there's not been that much uh video content lately. And yeah, that was a good visit. It was nice to go visit him and my sister-in-law. But I needed a break between jobs and I start tomorrow. New job, similar role, few tweaks, but uh yeah, new place, new culture, new um people. It's it's scary. Um it always is scary to start a new job because you never know if it's like jumping out of the frying pan into the fire, you know, in terms of why you're moving jobs. And you know, I no reason to believe that right now. You know, I mean, you know, they've been very nice people and I'm looking forward to it, you know, in terms of like this could be a really good fun place to work, but a job's a job. Work is work. You don't wake up in the morning going I get to go to work today. It's like no, it it doesn't. you do it to pay your bills.
And I'm just hoping that this will be a decent job that's challenging enough, but not too stressful, not boring, and not going to, you know, basically not going to stress me out like crazy like, you know, sometimes in the previous one did. So, yeah, it's it's it's a it's it's a scary prospect, but uh you know, people have been very supportive. You know, they're wishing me luck in that. So, you know, by all means, thanks for that. You don't have to you don't have to get it in the comments down below if you don't want to. So, it's it's I'm not asking for uh you know, supportive comments on that front, but you know, it's just yeah, I've enjoyed a bit of a break, but now it's hard focus mode in the office a lot. The long commute to Southampton, the horrible M27 road works, uh you know, early morning get ups, you know, it's it's it's beginning again. Yeah, we're back. Uh playtime's over. It's time to be serious. But that also goes for the channel because obviously I took a bit of a break from video content while visiting my family.
So there hasn't been a huge amount of video stuff at the moment, but certainly we've now finally started getting the top 50 of all time done. Um, you know, I released the 50 to 41 yesterday. Uh, not as many views as I would have liked for its first incarnation, only two and a bit thousand, but you know what? Hopefully that will build up over time. And to be fair, the top 50 generally ends up being in very much a curve. So it starts off fairly low and mediocre in terms of engagement and then once you get to the top 25 it really does heat up then. So I'm expecting the 20 to 11 and the 10 to one to be a lot more lucrative or something. Whereas the other three I suspect will get views just not anywhere near as many. But by all means if you are just unaware that it's come out then by all means uh get on it. Get on it and please watch it. Uh there's some cool games in there. Uh 27187 subs. You know plus 130 in the last 28 days. That's not a bad shout, honestly. You know, if I could maintain that for life, you know, I'd be pretty happy with that ratio. Uh because it just means getting on, but obviously be nice to see more. Your channel is 12 years old. Oh man, do I feel old. Feel so old at 41 to be uh told that my channel is 12 years old. So that means I I mean, this is when I started YouTube. I did Blogspot before then. So, in terms of reviewing content, I'm probably something like 15 years old in that regard. But 12 years old since I started doing a YouTube channel. Oh my god, that is so old. I feel so old.
Like, he chose poorly. I really do feel like that. As much as I've tried intermittent fasting in the last month and going to the gym a lot, it's made a bit of a difference. I've certainly burned off all the excess um Christmas weight, but still a bit to go. still pudgy face, still bit of a dad bod stomach, even though I'm not a dad, you know. So, there's still plenty of work to do throughout the next month or two, I reckon. I reckon I'll I'll keep this up for February. See how I get on by the end of February and then maybe throughout some of March, uh, mitigating it a little bit. I won't be quite as hardcore maybe this month and next month as I was in January. But, yeah, you know, as much as I can to try and thin thin the body out, shall we say. Uh, but yeah, so, you know, as I said, not a lot of content. I've done the 50 to 41 and I released a review for Valheim. That's pretty much it. Yeah. I mean, I released I released Valheim shortly after the last podcast. Uh, you know, 2,000 views.
Was hoping for a bit more, but then Valheim's not going to be a widely known distributed game yet. So, that's probably early days. Uh, you know, good to see some uh good, you know, some half decent views for others. Although, again, they've sort of capped. I mean, you know, White Castle Duel only 1500, Epona only, 1300. Uh, Citrus a thousand, but that's a fairly un unheard of game. Blooming Cells expansion for Windmill Valley, you know, so 1,400 there. So, I mean, yeah, views for the top 10 to 25, great. And in a lot of stuff like beforehand, really great. But I guess maybe we're just in a lull period for people watching YouTube at the moment. Or maybe that these games aren't just that well heard of. I mean, that's why you don't see a lot of reviewers doing these. I mean, how many reviewers have done the Blooming Cells expansion, Citrus, and Apona? You know, not that many. And, you know, they know it. They know it won't get that many views, and so they haven't bothered doing any content for it. But, uh, yeah, I say we'll build up. We'll build up.
Obviously, it was a slow week because I've been away visiting family. Time to get back to work. So, 50 to 41 is out. Uh, 40 to 31 is in the editing room. In fact, it's about 3/4 of the way finished. So, that shouldn't take too long before that comes out. Uh, 30 to 21 is recorded. It just hasn't started on the editing process, and I haven't even recorded the other two yet. So, I mean, this is basically going to be something that takes place over the next month, I would say. Yeah, give me a month to release all five of them. I think it'll be fine. In terms of talking about games that fell off the list, I'll make bolt that on to the 10 to one. Maybe I'll do a sick video or maybe I'll make that a podcast episode. Um, cuz I do need more topics. So yeah, that's something to look forward in the future. But yeah, otherwise, yep, scary prospects of starting a new job and getting back into the channel, but other than that, uh some repetitive strain injury on my right thumb. That's what comes from, uh doing a lot of keyboard work and browsing on your phone and stuff. So I got to watch that from a physio's perspective. But yeah, generally that's life at the moment. So uh nothing else.
Still living the bachelor life as always. Okay. Right. So, uh, we're going to talk quickly about a couple of, uh, small games, uh, that I've recently played and got into the collection, um, uh, just before I get on the main topic. So, first off, uh, we're going to talk about a game called fishing or fishing or whatever it is. Basically, these are a couple of tricktaking games that I've recently acquired because, if you know me and my channel, I like trick taking games. So, I've definitely been getting into a few of these. In fact, I think um you know, I've played a bunch of them, but I haven't necessarily done a lot in recent months, apart from, you know, January and December. So, I'm actually now getting to the point where I feel like I can do a top 10 trick taking games list and actually talk about 10 that I absolutely adore as opposed to just uh oh, here's a few that I love and here's a few that are meh. Now, I reckon I can talk about 10 bloody good ones. Um so, hopefully I'll maybe do that top 10 list uh maybe during or after the top 50 is done. Maybe I'll make that the first top 10 list. Okay. So, fishing fishing from Freedom and Freeze. Uh, so Real Grand Games, Freedom and Free, this is definitely, you know, if you know his games, they do have a very unique style.
He's one of the more unique um game designers I think out there. Whether he does a Euro or a small little card game, it's always going to be very different. He likes to push the envelope a little bit as to what we expect from a Euro game. And fair credit because I think we need more of those in the industry. So, even though I don't tend to go mad for Freedom Freeze games, uh cuz I mean if we look at his stuff, yep, bless God bless the Germans for giving us some cool stuff. Uh yeah, I mean it's very hit and miss. So, notable games. Fearsome floors, fine. Power grid, hate its guts. Figlia, it's all right. 504 crashed and burned, but fair play. You tried something very different. I applaud you for your innovation. Fabled Fruit, it's a little overrated. Fast sloths, that was an interesting little game. Same with Fume.
Was that a card? No, so not card game, but yeah, Fume I thought was all right. Fancy Feathers, not bad. I mean, let's say that they're sort of like fine, not bad, you know, but nothing's really sort of like stood out like crazy. And this is his notable game. So, there's a few that not mentioned. Yeah, Friday. Friday is fantastic. That's a really good um solo game. Uh any others just from the first sort of page? because I'm not going to go through all of these. But yeah, let's try one more page and then I promise I'll stop. Power grid. Power grid. Power grid. Power grid. Power grid. Power grid. Hate. Hate. Hate. Hate. Hate. Hate. Hate. Terror. N. So, I mean, as I say, it's it's hit and miss, but I like that he tries something a little bit different. And you know, even if you don't necessarily always succeed in winning me over with a game, I like the fact you try something new. And I applaud you for that. Fishing is definitely trying something new though with a trick taking thing because it's essentially trick taking mixed with pseudo deck building. I think you could say the idea with this is that you play several rounds of tricks in the normal fashion. Play a card, follow suit. I'm not going to explain how trick taking works. If you don't know how trick taking works, then look it up. But I think most gamers listening to this channel know how a trick- taking game works hopefully. But the idea is is that it's the standard rules. Play a card, follow suit, highest card wins the trick, right? You start off with a bunch of basic cards in certain suits and they go up to like I think value 10 or something, you know, like not particularly high. And the idea is is that they don't have any special abilities and they're basic cards. So you play through a round and you take note of all the tricks you've won and you get a point for every trick you win.
But then what happens is there's a deck of cards in the middle of the table that have all these different funky cards. So, they're either cards that are ranked above 10, a trump suit of uh fish, which are trump everything else, special cards like these boy markers here, or the zero cards which have like extra effects like nicking cards from the trick and stuff like that, you know. So, these are in the mix. But the idea is like, you know, even just the basic 11 and 13 in this picture here, they come from the special deck. But what happens is each round there's a hand size and you take all your tricks and you win them and you put them on your net card here, right? Then you you shuffle them all together and put them on your boat card, which is effectively your deck. If you have less than the hand size for the round, your remaining cards that make up your effective hand for the next round is made up of cards from the special deck.
So the worse you do in a round, the more special cards you get for the next one. And obviously, if you win a bucket load of tricks, you might find that you won't get any special cards because your deck hand size is so many tricks. But people are winning tricks. So the cards that you've got, including some of the specials, could be going to other players. And some of the specials will nick cards out of a trick. Like you could play a really good 14 card that wins the trick, but somebody plays the zero that nicks a card from the trick before you win it. And it's like, ah, damn, there goes my 14. It's, you know, the cards go back and forth, and it's a such a clever idea. I I mean, do I love it? No. I mean, I like it a lot. I think this is one that's going to have to grow on me a little bit. My problem is that it's a bit long. I think you play about eight rounds in this game or something.
And I think the rounds can take a little bit of time and eight rounds is maybe just a couple of rounds too many. Like maybe it should have capped at six rounds. Uh what's it got down here? So here's the components. You know, the cards are pretty basic looking. Uh stupid. Your privacy nonsense. Get off the screen. Right. Um 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8. Yeah. So eight rounds. I I just think eight rounds is maybe a little bit too long. That's my own that's my gripe with the game that is a bit long, but it's a very clever little uh trick taker because you've got the familiar rules in there. The special effects on these cards are not complicated. They're pretty easy to deal with, but you got to be prepared that they're there. And because you've seen the cards appear and you've seen where they go to, you can remember if you've got a good memory like which players have got those cards and did they draw their entire deck for the next round? Maybe there's a chance they didn't get those cards. Uh, but then it's it's you know, and you might think, well, do I want to win a bunch of tricks this round, or do I, you know, I could win this trick, but if I win the trick, I'm just winning a point and some basic cards. I feel like maybe I want to lose this trick so that I have better cards for the next round. There's a lot of interesting little tweaks that you can do with the uh your thinking process here. And it just made for I think I played it once at Handycon. Um, uh, someone showed it to me there and you know, and I I played it and I thought, "Oh yeah, I want to try this game more."
And it was at I think it was like hard to find. I think you could only get it I don't know if it was Essen or like overseas, but at the time you couldn't get it. Now you can. So I bought it from uh, you the Firestorm Games. Was it Firestorm Games? I think it was. Yeah. That that come to Handycon and you bought it from them, you know, for fairly cheap. What was it about like 10 quid tops? I mean, yeah, 9 10 quid. I mean, it wasn't expensive. Um, and yeah, I've I played it a couple of times while I was there and it's like, yeah, you know, this one will grow on me. You know, I I do think it's a bit long, especially when you get a lot of players in, but you kind of want a fair amount of players in because you want a bit of nut jobs with the with the cards. You know, it works fine at three. It works decent at five. It's just a bit more chaotic. I think maybe four is a sweet spot. You know, you get the best of both worlds. But yeah, it's just simple rules, but a cool concept. You know, it's another one of these trick takers or another one of these games that tries to do something different with a genre that's already got a lot of examples in it. And when you do that and you hit then you it works even better with me. I mentioned looking at Freedom of Free's other games that uh you know, some of those ones push the envelope and didn't work. Well, this one pushes the envelope and does work. So, if you get a chance to try this and you're a trick taking fan, by all means do. It's a interesting little game. All right. And then moving on to another trick taker uh that I've recently acquired. Also, I think I also got a handy con actually. I think I just bought a couple of small games off cuz I wanted to buy something. I just wanted to buy some games. This is LZ L UZ. I
don't know what the hell the LZ is meant to um uh represent. Uh and she went to the cathedral. Blah blah blah. Nice color windows, whatever. I mean, the theme in both of these games is non-existent. And you can argue the fishing one's got a little bit of theme with some of the special cards, but that's about it. This this ain't got theme. It's just an excuse for pretty pictures, but this is from Yellow Games. I think it came out last year. I remember this one getting a lot of buzz at the UK Games Expo. Like, you know, people have sort of gone, "Oh, yeah. This is a really great game. You got to try it." And then by the time I was done with the expo and Drander Games and that, and I decided to go have a look, I couldn't find any copies to buy and I couldn't really get into a game to play it. So, I just left it be and didn't really care. So, at Handycon, I saw this again. I thought, oh yeah, this is one I heard about. So, I bought it and just decided, yeah, you know what? Let's try at hand. And this is a trick taker that is kind of borrowing a little bit of notes from Hanabi and Tribes of the Wind and stuff like that. So, you've got these beautiful looking cards and they are really nice, you know, nice colorful cards. I've seen better. I've seen better, but they're still pretty nice. Um, and I've definitely sleeved these. And as a little note on the sleeving front, I think this is French tarot size. So you're going to need specific sleeves to fit them ideally. Uh because it is yellow games, French, therefore French tarot. Yeah, it's going to be that kind of size. But this is a little game um interesting little game where basically if I show this now, you don't get stands in here. Someone else has done this. But what you do is you draw your hand of cards for the round and you then bid
like um in turn order how using these beads how many tricks you think you're going to win. Okay, how many tricks you think you're going to win. The blue is like a safety bead. You won't get as many points if you succeed, but it kind of gives you a plus one um I'm not sure if it's a minus one as well, but like a plus one safety buffer. Um you won't get as many points and the points go up each round. So that is one slight flaw of the game. I think they should be equal uh numbers. I find that giving loads of points to the p to the fourth round kind of undermines the point of the first couple of rounds. You know, I'd be interested to know your thoughts on that. But the idea is is as you can see, you're holding the cards the wrong way. You look at the cards from the back. So, when you get your initial hand of cards, you look at all the values and you see what they are. And then you put this uh placer card to show whether you've organized it in ascending or descending order. and then pass the hand to the player on your left. They then don't look at the numbers. They put the cards, as you can see here, with their backs facing away, grouped up into the suits.
And the way this works is that you can see everybody else's cards, but not your own. And some are not even in the round. So, you don't even have perfect information. So, you're bidding on how many tricks you think you can win um based on your new hand and what you see out there. So yeah, I think I got the order slightly messed up. You don't bid on the number of tricks you win when you get your initial hand. You do it after you've got your hand from your player to your right. So, you know, before you start the round. So, that's an interesting little quirk in itself, but it means that you're sort of thinking, right, I can see that from everything that's up to eight in value, I can see there's a bunch of seven and eights out there for these colors, which means the ones I've got are going to be low value. I don't think I'm going to win many tricks this round. But then you might not see the eight. And you're like, well, they've got some high values there. But I do have a couple of blues.
Is that one of these blues an eight? I don't know. I'm a little bit worried. And during the round, you'll get a chance to think, well, they've played their six and seven. Is this an eight? I could win the trick, but I don't know if I want to. And it's like, h there's, you know, based on how many tricks you think you're going to win. And it's, you know, there's a little bit of guessing in it, but you can make some, you know, logical decisions, particularly when you get to the end of the round, you realize, ah, yeah, this definitely must be lower than this and stuff like that. Those cards went up to 12. It depends how many players you've got. But it's a nice looking game. The cards are very nice. They're very pretty to look at. It's very easy to tell the suits apart because the iconography is very clear as to what the suit differentiation is. So, even if you're color blind, it won't uh matter. uh you know, you can see the back of the cards have got the suit differentiation very clear, so it's very easy to see which um cards people have got. But yeah, I'm finding this one quite interesting as well. I mean, uh do I like it as much as fishing?
Um I think fishing is a bit more clever and a little bit more entertaining, but this one is shorter. You only play three rounds, I think, in this one. um four tops. And I think that makes the game a little bit quicker and a bit more of a sort of filler. Whereas fishing isn't really a filler. You're playing fishing as a short game of the night, but in no way is it a filler. You won't get eight rounds done in 30 minutes. It just ain't going to happen. But you could get L done in less than 30 minutes pretty easily. You should be able to anyway. So yeah, I've enjoyed this one as well. It's a you know, you got to get used to holding the cards though. That's the thing cuz you have got this placeholder card that you shove on either side and you've got to be comfortable with fanning your cards. If you're not good at fanning your cards in your hand, like in one hand, it could be a little bit fiddly for you to sort of micromanage the cards because obviously everybody needs to see what cards you've got. You can't make it like hidden or anything.
So, you know, be be comfortable with that. Be good at What the hell? Slag in LWD. What language is this? Slagin lude 999 games. Somebody tell me what language this is. Does it say slag? I need to know what language this is. Brilliant name. Oh, seriously. Is this Is this German? Is this German or Dutch or what? I need to know what slag in lude is. Somebody in the comments tell me what language that is. Uh because I don't think it's going to translate either way. But I need to know that that's a weird name for a game. I mean, I would have picked this up ages ago as a trick taker game if it was called slagging lude when I saw it in a shop as opposed to LZ. But, uh, yeah, that's that's just weird. I just find it quite funny. But, yeah, pretty looking game.
Small box filler, nice little clever thing. Again, a nice solid trick taker. Both of these are going to have to get more plays before I can say whether they're going to stay in the collection or uh, you know, get ranked highly or lowly or something. I'm not doing full videos for these obviously, but uh yeah, that's why I'm talking about them on the podcast and that's kind of what the podcast is good for actually. Talking about the little games that I can't really spend the time and effort to do a full video for. But uh yeah, these are pretty neat little trick takers so far. So, by all means, suggest any others that you think I'd like. Bear in mind, you have seen reviews of ones that I already have done, so by all means, if I've done a video, don't suggest it. Uh Nikosu Dice would be a good example of that. But yeah, there's a bunch on my shelf. I've got things like net and tricky badger and diamonds and uh and obviously the crew. So yeah, there's a bunch of trick takers that I've got that I like. But I say if you know any good little ones that have got these little clever mechanics and aren't just basic trick takers, then yeah, by all means suggest them because they're cheap, cheerful. Oh yeah, four Northwood. I've got that as well, so don't need to suggest that one. Um, but yeah, so yeah, two pretty good little trick takers I found for a total of less than £20. Got to say, I mean, when you spending 70 quid on a big euro and you play it a few times and you realize, nope, this Euro is not for me or it's just the same old same old or it's just too long, too punishing, whatever. And then you can pay 20 bucks and get yourself a couple of little card games that, you know,
barely take up any space and give you more fun. It just goes to show that, you know, the price point of a game shouldn't dictate how good it is. All right. Okay. Let's get on with the meat of this episode, though. So, I did a podcast recently. Go figure. What you think I do? It was called uh was it Can I Forgive These Games? And it got some interesting feedback. I'm going to take some coffee while I'm at it. So, hang on. Oh, that is still hot. These these Contigo mugs I use. I use these every time I go to like cafe Nero and other coffee shops and that and I bring them to conventions for a tenor. These are damn good mugs. I mean they are big. They hold a lot of liquid. You can drink from them easily. They stay sealed. Um and they really do keep the heat in. I mean wow. This is still piping hot. And I poured this probably a good 30 40 minutes ago or something which granted it's a thermos type flask. It's meant to last hours, but I have managed to occasionally leave this in my car, not realizing I still had half a mug left.
Come back after several hours and it's still hot or still warm to drink. And it's like, wow. You know, I do love these. A side plug there. But uh yeah, so I did this podcast and shall we say uh it got mixed reception for the most part. People liked it and enjoyed it and got the deal. I mean, it wasn't me trying to be super serious. It was me just uh having an excuse to sort of let some uh venting out and talk about a bunch of games that truthfully I do hate. But I was willing to forgive and forget a bunch of them and sort of go, you know what, maybe I was a bit harsh. These are better. They've been improved. And there were some that actually did meet that mark. You know, these were ones that I've rated like a one or a two. Like they've just made me angry to play them. And it's like maybe I was being a bit too harsh. People enjoyed it. Some people didn't. Some people didn't quite get the the idea of the episode or thought I was just being harsh for harsh sake. It's like no, you know, and obviously there were going to be people that love those games to death. That would have ated my guts as well. I mean, the the amount of people that were sort of coming back saying, "How do you how do you do not like Barrage? I love Barrage." Look, if you love Barrage, go right ahead. But that that game seriously just has no redeeming features for me. I don't get why. It's actually No, that's harsh. I do get why people like it. Yeah, I'm not blind to that fact, but it does everything that is just there to make me mad. It's like anything from its look, its component quality, its length, its punishing gameplay, its mediocre mechanics. Uh it
it just everything about it is just designed to annoy me. So, it's not a game I'm going to be forgiving that one anytime soon. But, you know, fair enough. I was like, okay, fine. um you know not a you know most people liked it but there were a few that were like okay well you know I gotta give props to um a viewer who's very vocal on my channel in terms of you know good praise and giving ideas and feedback if I can find him. So, here we go. Comment here. So, thank you for the comment, Rendell. I I know you in real life, but that is your YouTube name. I do hate the fact that YouTube messes around with the usernames on these, right? So, excellent stuff as always. When you were talking about a board game, loop, remember not to hold back and say what you really think. Yep. Yep. That's always the case. But you could maybe do the opposite in the next podcast and discuss if your nines and tens are still worthy. Maybe. Not a bad idea is what I said to that. And uh yeah, that's not a bad idea at all.
Actually, this is me playing devil's advocate because I've basically done a podcast where I've taken a bunch of games I hate and gone, can I forgive these games? And obviously, it uh, you know, involves me hating on a lot of games, but doing it in reverse, taking a bunch of games I rated a 10 and then deciding if I was too generous, if I was um too much of a well, shall we say IGN about it. Yeah, fight me. IGN is one of the worst things to be put on media in terms of reviewing anything. They are just a bunch of lying, misleading little ah whatever. I got to keep this family friendly. But yeah, if if you like IGN, what's wrong with you? But yeah, I just thought, yeah, maybe there was a few reviews I rated a 10 that I was a little bit too generous on. That does happen.
So, I figured, you know what, let's do the devil's advocate approach. If you're going to be harsh on a bunch of games, then now's the time to, you know, give some criticisms to, you know, some of the ones that you rated really highly. Now, granted, most of these, I think, are going to be justified in my mind because the disparity between a game I don't like at all and meh, mediocre, boring, or whatever, but it's fine, is a lot smaller a gap than the gap between mediocre and I love it to bits. like you've got to you don't have to put in the too much effort to get between a ranking of a one and a ranking of a five in my mind because they're not exactly good ratings anyway. Although five I will still play an average game. I just don't particularly seek it out. You know, when you get down to four, three, twos, you know, that's when I actively don't want to play the games. But yeah, there's only so much disparity. When you're going from 5 6 7 8 9 10 though, it's harder. It's a bigger curve, you know? It's a butt harder uh slope to climb. So, you know, the difference between a game that I would rate a 10 and a game that I would rate a six even is insanely high. You know, these are games that I actively want to own, spend money on, pimp up, get to the table as often as possible, you know. So, there's a big difference. So, a lot of these games I don't think are going to be ones where I'm going to say, "Yeah, you know what? I was a bit too generous on these." But I had a look. you know, you won't be able to see it on my screen, but I have got screenshots of all the games I have rated a 10, and there
aren't that many. Trust me, tens I do not give out willy-nilly. Um, but I've had a look at some of them and it's like most of these I would still keep as a 10. There are a few though, which I think maybe I was a bit too lovey on and they could even include recent stuff. So, uh, by all means, let's see if we can balance the books a bit, play devil's advocate, and say, you know what, if you're going to do it one way, got to do it the other. So, okay, let's crack on and get some games on here. So, obviously you can't see the Yeah, you can't see the screenshots I've got, but I'm not going to go through every single one I've rated a 10 cuz even though there aren't that many, it would still take me forever to do them, but let's go through a few that could be in contention. So, hang on. Let me get to uh Right. So, I don't want uh YouTube comments. I want Board Game Geek. Here we go. So, we're going to go through a few. Uh, so first one I can think of is Seven Wonders. In fact, Seven Wonders and Seven Wonders Duel are games that I have rated a 10. Now, I'm still, I think, going to stick with a 10 for Seven Wonders Duel. Definitely. Seven Wonders Duel is a fantastic twoplayer game. I only really want to play it with Pantheon. I don't think the second expansion was any good, but honestly, I will still play duel with the base set, you know? I just think it's improved with Pantheon. But this is such a good game. Now, this one really I think is something that I think justifies a 10 for me or something. It's not that hard to learn, particularly if you have played seven wonders before. It's a
really good tense back and forth. It can really lead to some good tactical play and it's a very clever system. So, I definitely like playing this on board game arena and I like playing it in person. So, you know, this is definitely one I would go for attempt. Seven Wonders. Seven Wonders is where things get a little interesting. And when I say I mean one thing I will caveat is that I'm not necessarily saying when I reviewed it I was too generous to give it a 10 although there may be a few on this uh list that I might give that reasoning to. But it's also did it stand the test of time? Like does it still warrant a 10 now? You know as you know just like the other week when I was doing do these games still warrant a one. Well Seven Wonders I still think is a really really solid game. I mean, the only gripes I have with it, like I would much prefer to play it with expansions, but that's just because I've played it a bunch of times. You know, it's certainly got my money's worth out of it. Uh, the base set is still really, really good fun.
You can argue that the science is a little bit overpowered in the game, and certainly if you let one person get it all, then you're kind of asking for it. But, you know, if you're aware of that small fact, I don't think that's enough to drop it from a 10 to a nine. I still think that this one is a game that is deserving of its evergreen status. It's a great drafting game. Other games have tried to mimic it and never come anywhere close to like meeting its uh simp, you know, simplicity and caliber. Even though I don't call this a gateway game by any means cuz it's uh definitely not a gateway game with the amount of iconography you've got to teach people. But there's a problem when you get Can I just say people when you're putting photos up on Board Game Geek? I'm interested in looking at the game, not random bloke who's playing the game.
Okay, that is why I don't take pictures of people when I'm playing games at conventions. I take pictures of the game. Like, I can't see the game here. I can't see anything on the table. All I can see is five people I've never met in my life. It's like, I'm not interested in that. Show me the game. But I digress. Rant over. Um, this is meant to be a positive list. So, yeah. You know, I still think it's a great drafting game. Really good fun. I I'm sticking with the 10 on this one. You know, even to this day, I think it's still worthy of a 10. I mean, even at most worse, it would be a high nine, but it's still for me, I think, still up there. All right, let's have another look. Uh, okay. Um, let's have a look at uh uh let's have a look at Architects of the West Kingdom.
So, this is, in fact, I'm going to look at two of these actually. I'm going to look at Architects of the West Kingdom and I'm also going to look at Vic Counts of the West Kingdom because both of these I gave a 10. I didn't particularly like Paladins. Uh so I only gave that one like a six actually. Well, or did I ah is that one of the ones that I gave like an eight when I first played it and then realized ah that was a mistake and gave it like a five or a six afterwards. So yeah, that was probably one of those. But architects and VI counts I gave a 10. H was I a little bit generous with those? I I mean I do enjoy both of them a lot, but both of them have not been played in a while. I think these are starting to sway a little bit in the test of time. The problem is is that expansion bloat didn't help. Uh the first expansion of architects is great.
I definitely recommend it. Um the second one is a bit too much bloat on top. Like it doesn't really add enough. That's great to justify the extra um teaching load and everything, which is annoying cuz I've got the play map which has the uh extra bits on top. So, I basically have to sort of use it as dead space on the board, but it's a solid game nonetheless. You know, the idea that this is a typical worker placement of get resources and build buildings, you know, that stuff is simple, but you got a lot of different buildings with a lot of different effects as you can see here. Uh the artwork is really good. You know, I like Mo's um artwork. It's a unique style, but it's a style that I get into. The slight problem with it is that, you know, some of the gameplay is dictated by the townhouse as to whether or whatever it is, the town center where people can arrest each other. Now, I like that mechanic and it's one of my favorite aspects, but new players to the game might not know how to work it correctly and so they either just keep arresting for the sake of it or they don't do it enough. You know, they don't keep people in check. But, you know, again, that's a relatively small gripe, but is it still worthy of a 10? I mean, is it really that much of a benchmark game? Um, I I think I'm still willing to justify it on this one. Maybe at best it could be a nine. Um, worse, sorry, it could be a nine. I certainly don't think it's worthy of falling from a distinction level rating, but you know, that that is one potential issue. I don't like the second expansion that
much. I do think that hurts it a I mean, the second expansion is great if you're a solo player, cuz the solo mode they put into the second expansion was pretty solid, but the new mechanics, not so much. But the game is still good fun. It takes not a long time to play. I mean, you can I've played a six player game of this in 90 minutes once. I mean, that's bloody good going for a six player euro worker placement game. So, it's definitely got a lot of good stuff going for it. um you know people can argue that you know manipulating the sort of low virtue and black market is a bit too powerful. Well I mean you still have to get your virtue up later. So there's still an element of that but yeah this is one of those games where if you stay in high highest virtue all the time it may hurt you slightly. Um whereas if you're willing to bend the books a little bit uh a little bit during the game and then rise yourself up a bit higher then you know that can pay dividends. But I think, you know, it's definitely gone down for me over time. I think this is definitely like, you know, no longer quite a 10. Um, in my books, I think this has dropped to a nine. Um, you know, it was in danger of dropping to an eight at one point, but I think it's now settling on a nine. And definitely I want to play it with the first expansion pretty much all the time really, but I rarely want to play with the second one. It's still a solid worker placement game. And you know 10 is meant to be you know one thing to stress is 10 is not a perfect game.
Okay? It never is. Even my favorite game ever is not a perfect game. Every game has flaws. And if you don't believe that your game has flaws then you're in a pipe. You're in a dream world here. So uh but the 10 is meant to be a benchmark rating. So when I consider the genre direct um director the genre publisher designer um mechanic theme this is the type of game that I would say right I'm going to be comparing other games to can you do it as well and I I think Architect still meets that benchmark target because there is some cool unique twist to this one to make it what is effectively a simple get resources and build buildings type worker placement game much like what something like Stone Age in that was and making it that much more interesting. So, I think this one still justifies the 10. I'm not so sure though that VO counts did. I think this could be the one where I was like, ah, maybe a 10 was a bit generous. Um, because I do really enjoy Vic Counts.
You know, it is a really solid game. Um, because I love the sort of conveyor belt thing with the workers, sorry, with the apprentices or whatever they're called in this one, the villagers. And I like the sort of rondelle mechanic with moving your knight around and doing all the different actions. It is a solid game, but expansion bloat really did hurt this. And this is definitely one of the mistakes I think I made when I reviewed the expansions. I gave them quite a high rating because I thought, "Oh, these are good fun. They're adding, you know, cool new things to the game." But over time, I've actually got to the point now where I don't want to use the expansions because the expansions do add a lot of bloat to a game that's not exactly uh you know you know bare bones as it is. And they get fiddly at times with some of the stuff in it. Like the the purple villagers, the ones that have like endgame scoring and that just don't seem that interesting. The king's favor stuff again not that great. Mainly the expansions helped to balance a little bit, you know, with uh the manuscripts and the castle, which was um you know, you can argue the castle was a little bit overpowered and the manuscripts weren't as powerful before. Buildings have been balanced a little bit as well.
So, there are things from the expansions that I will use in the game because they are small modules that you can throw in, but you know, like the treasure chests and stuff like that. You know, there was just a few little additional modules that I don't know were just a bit too fiddly for their own good. out saying that the uh uh what do you call it? The asymmetric cards that you can put in your original deck like those hero cards, they're really good. I like those. So, I like to use them a lot. You can hear a dog barking. Sorry about that. Um but yeah, the you know, I think there's elements from the expansions that are good. But yeah, they did add a lot of bloat and I think I was too generous with those. With this game, I also do think I was maybe a bit too generous at a 10. I mean, it's it's certainly potentially a nine. Maybe it could be an eight. I mean, it's not been played in a while. I enjoy it when it gets played, but the expansions have hurt it and, you know, it hasn't hit the table as much as other, you know, V uh AR, you know, the Tigris games are hitting the table more than the West Kingdom stuff now. And this is one of the ones that have suffered more. It is still a solid game, but especially in its like base game only form, you have got to admit that the uh four different sort of paths to victory are not entirely balanced. I mean, you don't really use uh the trade one, the money bag symbol as a path to victory. It's more of a means to an end. Uh with the expansions, you can kind of focus a lot more on it, but not so much in the base game. Buildings are good, but not easy to do. and the expansion did balance
them a little bit more as well. It's a lot of people sort of do the castle and the manuscripts and the castle usually if somebody does it well will do pretty damn well at it. So it's a little bit hard to gauge what the actual ranking for this one probably should have been. Maybe sort of kept up at a nine. Uh so you not say nine is not a bad rating. It's still a seal of distinction game. So, I think the question is really, is this worthy of the seal of distinction I gave it in the first place? And I want to say yes, but I think maybe a 10 is going far. You know, like I think I still would have given this a nine at the time, but to call this a benchmark to say that I'm comparing other games to this, not so much. It's a very enjoyable game, but 10 was generous. I think, you know, this is the one that's definitely, I think, suffered more as time has gone on. All right, let's have a look at others. Uh, I mean, let's say I've got Abyss. Abyss is generally a game that I really like. Is it worthy of a 10? You do want to play it with a decent amount of players, and you do want to ideally use the expansions because the expansions do a great job with this game. you know, would I rate it a 10 if I was ranking just the base game on its own? That might be saying something, you know? I mean, in fact, I'm not entirely sure if I did rank the original base game a 10. I think the game's now a 10 for me with the other stuff included.
But 10, I think, would be generous for this game if I was ranking just the base game because the base game does have problems. Um, you know, it it's best with more players. it doesn't work as well with less players because you want the um I don't want to say those words are something the depths uh going into the depths or whatever to get more um ally cards isn't as interesting with less players. It really does want a full count four ideally. So you know three is fine but you really want four. Two doesn't work with this game I don't think. Um the heroes there's only so many of them. Some were a bit better than others. Uh the locations again had that similar thing. But the main problem that the base set of Abyss has is that monster track. That monster track there on the right is just garbage. It's a garbage mechanic in the original one.
You know, you level it up, but it doesn't level up very far before somebody claims all the rewards on it. And it just wasn't very good. I mean, this monster token is at the bottom of the track. So, well, top, bottom, whatever. goes down, but it never usually gets further than the key before somebody takes the award. And there's not enough monsters in the deck for it to get all the way down before somebody just says, "Yeah, I want it." So that that mechanic was pretty bad. So this is a game that I really do like and rate a 10 now with two expansions thrown in. If I don't know if I ranked it a 10 originally, but would I rank it a 10 base set now? No, it wouldn't be. it would probably be possibly a nine, maybe even only an eight out of 10. The expansions really did help this game to make it a lot better. But and you know, it hasn't been played in a little while, but I still really enjoy it. Um, you know, does that mean it will fall out of my top 10? We shall see. But it's uh, you know, it's still a really great game. I still love it. But, you know, 10 for the base game, no, that wouldn't have happened. If I rate, if I was ranking it now, it wouldn't get a 10 as a base set. you know, it needed help.
Okay, let's talk about another one. Um, Arknova. I mean, Arknova, I love this game. I play it on BGA. I play it on in plays. I don't even know why I've logged plays here. I think I must have been logged into the wrong um account when I was looking at stuff, but I still love this game. I still think it's 10. There's not much I can really say. Um, it's just fantastic. I love it as a tableau game, you know. I'm going to compare it to other tableau games. I love it as the uh typewriter mechanic game. I'm going to compare it to others. And Sanctuary did try to get compared to this one. Yes, it was meant to be its own game, but let's face it, it was basically Art Nova Light. And Sanctuary, if you watch my review, I only gave a five out of 10 to It's a fairly meh game. It tried to do something, you know, lighter with it and it didn't work. It took a lot of the great stuff from this game and removed it and diluted it too much. So, you know, that one was a pale comparison, but Arc Nova still gets the plays. It's still a great game. This is a 10. I'm still keeping it as a 10. It's happening. Um, okay. Uh, what else we got? Um, uh, Art Society. Art Society. Uh, that is one I think I was a bit generous with this one. It It is a great game. I still really like it. Um, it's, you know, really solid. uh play tile placement game where you've got these paintings you grab by a sort of closed bidding
system to get the paintings and put them on your board. You want to get uh certain paintings next to each other, but there are some that you don't want next to each other. Um I think somebody's committed a fauxar or two on this board, for example. But it's, you know, it's not Tetris. You know, you're putting rectangles and squares on, so it's a bit easier to deal with the whole spatial awareness thing. But I love the fact that when you are doing the bidding on this game for the paintings, you can choose which ones go into the bidding mix and it looks gorgeous as well, doesn't it? But, you know, you choose which paintings go on. But when you're choosing a painting, you've got to decide between multiple things like what type of frame does it have? What type is it? How big is it? Um how much am I how big a bidding amount am I going to put in for this? you know, so and also the one that's left over increases on the track and they get ranked, as you can see here, based on how many victory points each one is worth. So, you're going to want certain colors to level up more than others. It's such a clever game. I rated it a 10. Um, maybe that was a little bit too generous cuz I still really love it. It's still in my collection and, you know, I I can't remember if I've talked about it yet on my top 50 or not. I don't know. But um yeah, it's it's a really great game. 10 might have been going a bit far though.
Like a nine definitely. I mean, I do think this is a really solid game that definitely, you know, they're bringing out a new version of it with a revised insert. I mean, the insert was fine, but they're bringing out a better insert. They're upping the sort of component quality and that even though it was still pretty decent, and bringing out an expansion for it. So yes, I am pretty sure that Mighty Boards will get in touch with me uh when that uh gets to more fruition. I look forward to covering both at some point, you know, the changes from both editions and what the expansion entails. So I still really love this. A 10 was too far, though. I mean, would I class this as a benchmark game? It's quite unique in its own way, so it's hard to know what I would compare this to. You can't really compare it to other Polyomino games to an extent because it doesn't use all the polyominos. It's just squares and rectangles. So, it's a little bit hard to say what game you compare it to. A bidding game, a tile placement game.
It's hard to say, but it is a really great game and I do love playing it. But maybe it was better to have capped it at nine. You know, benchmark levels probably not. A nine though, definitely. I still think it's worthy of that nine out of 10 rating. Just maybe a 10 was a little bit too um bit too high emotional for that one. Okay, let's see what else we got. Uh, Citadels. Uh, well, Citadels. Citadels I still really like as a game. I still think Citadels is great. Do I think it's worthy of a 10? Um, I mean, I still love the game. I I suppose now it would be a nine, but it's an evergreen for me at this point. it. You know, it's a role selection game. One of the earliest role selection games. One of the first board games of the new of like post 2000 board games I've ever played. You know, I played Citadels pretty much at university when I was at university at the time of its original release. It's a game I love, but in its original form, it did have problems with uh the length of the game and uh you know, player count balance and stuff. The revised version did you know fix it. They brought in expansions to add more characters for a bit more variety. They shortened the length of the game, which was a good thing. Um, component quality was improved as well from the artwork.
So, I still really love it. I I mean, I suppose I suppose I still could give this a 10 because when I think of RO selection games, this is one of the benchmark role selection games that there is. And there have been others that I have played. Uh, what's the what is it? Ratus? You know, that's a role selection game. And I've played that one, but I'd much rather play Citadels, honestly. in uh Mission Red Planet is another one which has got a similar feel to Citadels, but I'd rather play Citadel. So, Citadels, I think, still probably does justify that 10 out of 10 rating for me. Uh yeah, at worst it'd be a nine, but this is my go-to roll selection game, so not going to change there. Okay, let's find uh let's see. I can't go over every single game, so let's find let's find one that I'm a little bit more on. Um, well, people got on my case recently about Emberart, about Emberart being a 10 out of 10. I still think that this is a game that should be considered the benchmark. Now, is it one that I want to play over and over again? No. But that's not what the rating is getting at. This is a game that has for me replaced stuff like Lords of Water Deep and that it's just such a buttery smooth worker placement game that you know is gorgeous production, really cheap to buy, you know, simple to teach. Even from the rule book, it was easy for me to learn this one. I literally taught it on the same day I read it from the rule book.
Um, has a little bit of variety with the heroes and how you can sort of go about with your dragon companion. But yes, let's be honest, there's not a ton of different paths to victory in this game. And it does have one flaw with it, which is the flame track. Now, the flame track for me has not broken the game like some people say, but there is a potential issue with it. Um, if I can see on there, the flame track here at the top basically is a points uh differential at the end of the game. Um, and when you do certain things, the more lucrative stuff burns you and you go higher up the track. And the disparity between you and the lowest marker will obviously depend on you. and the lower markers will depend how many points they get. Now, people think that you can max out the track and just remain there because there's no penalty for maxing out the track. Um, I would admit that is a potential flaw of the game. However, that has not created a situation where somebody has exploited it and still won the game in the games I have played.
They've come close, not going to lie, they've come close, but I've usually been the one with 20 points at the end of the game as a result of being lower on the flame track and I've won, you know, those games. So, you know, I do think it can be a potential issue, but if you know how to play the game well, you can get around it. But I always say though, if you put if you really are bummed out about that, here's a house rule. Every time you increase on the burn track and you don't have um sorry, every time you increase on the burn track and you're at the maximum point, say you lose a worker, you lose one of the tokens every time you do it. That's enough of a deterrent to not want to spam it all the time, you know, because you're reducing your effectiveness in one of the critical phases of the game. Put that house rule in and see how you get on that. There you go. Fixed. But it's never caused that much of a problem for me. I might just introduce that into my games uh just as a little extra incentive. But it's still buttery smooth, really gorgeous, really cheap, really easy to teach and play. It can outstand its welcome a little bit, you know, but with four players, but generally with three or less, it's uh still pretty good. No solo mode, don't really care. Not every game needs one.
It It's just a really solid game. I still think it's deserving of the 10. I think it ticks a lot of boxes. Now, again, do I want to play it over and over again? No. But am I happy to play it when it gets suggested? Yes. It fills that niche for me nicely is it's kind of on the same I mean it's it's not as sorry now uh this one is better than the alternative which is River of Gold. Um which I don't think is behind my head. I think it's in my bag at the moment but River of Gold is h sorry bit my lip um River of Gold is a you know easy uh lightweight Euro and that for me kind of replaced something like Lords of Water Deep and stuff like that as well. So, these two games are filling that niche quite nicely. And I I think this one still deserves a 10.
You know, I considered whether I mean, it's not like it was a um it's not like I would say this is the highest 10 ever. I still think maybe that this was like brushing a 10. So, you could argue maybe this could go down to a nine, but I don't think like the flaws of this game are enough to stop the fact that this can be a benchmark level game. So, I'm still sticking to my guns with this one. Okay, what else we got? Uh, something that's probably not a 10 anymore. Let's uh play a bit more devil's advocate here. Um, that one already done V counts. Uh, ah, here's a couple. Yeah. Yeah, these ones could drop. All right, let's talk about these ones. Um, let's go back to thing. So, first off, Street Masters. I think I might have been on a bit of a Sentinels in the Multiverse fix, which I still think is a 10. That is not dropping. Um, but Street Masters, I gave it a 10.
Maybe that was a bit generous. Um, it is quite a bloated game. You know, there's a lot of content for it and it's a bit hard trying to sift what it is you want, you know, and how easy it is and that. The rules are not the best written. You know, there's definitely elements of, you know, some FAQ nonsense going on. The component quality is only so so. I like the cards and the card artwork definitely fits the theme, but the components and what this sort of stuff looks like is pretty basic. It doesn't, you know, the miniatures are only so so unless you take the time to paint like some of these people do. It represents its theme brilliantly. You know, it does feel like Street Fighter mixed with Double Dragon mixed with Streets of Rage, you know, that kind of thing. So, you know, especially for those who have painted it, it is a really good fun game to play solo or two-player. I do think it's pretty much a solo or two-player game for me. But yeah, 10 out of 10. No, no, no, no. I did. Someone's playing on an Arkham Horror playmat. That's an interesting mat to use. But, you know, it's a fun game. It hasn't come off the shelf in a while, though, because of the amount of content in it and trying to relearn the rules and stuff each time.
It's got some problems and the reprint uh that was done uh by the other publishers I didn't overly help. You know, in fact, I actually think the new version that was done by Steam Forge Games wasn't as good as the original big box set that I have. So much so that I actually got rid of the new version and kept the old one. You because I think the old one was better. So, it's definitely I don't think worthy of a 10. like this one would be a nine, possibly even an eight actually. It's, you know, I still really enjoy it, but it's not coming off the shelf. It does have some problems, and those problems are definitely enough to take it out of the 10 out of 10 category. So, probably a bit generous with this one. Still really, still really great fun, but it's not getting played anywhere near as much as it should for a 10. Okay. Uh D. And the other one I want to discuss that's definitely I think a bit too generous is a game called Tribes of the Wind. I think I rode a high with this one because of how innovative it is. It's a very innovative game. It's basically taking the Hannabi mechanic and introducing it into a light euro. But I gave this one a 10 cuz I was definitely riding a high for how good fun it I was having with the games I was playing. how gorgeous it looks, how simple it is. You know, there's a lot of good stuff about this game. 10 out of 10, though. I think maybe I was riding the innovation front a bit too much, you know, because it is definitely unique. But the game's not
flawless. Player countwise, this game does not work above three players. I mean, you can play it with four, but it's pointless to play it with four because even more than something like Seven Wonders, this game does not care enough about having more players. It just adds too much length to the game. Five players is a waste of time. They put five on this game to sell more copies. That's all they did. It's not worth doing. Four player again is still, I think, too much. This setup with free is ideal, though. And even the two-player version is pretty sweet. Actually, the two-player version uses the middle cards as kind of like a dummy hand, and that works really well. So, for two and three players, I can wholeheartedly recommend this game. For four or five, though, that's a lot of player counts to be giving a 10 out of 10 to, you know, it should have been good at all player counts to really warrant that. But then also, the game does have some balance issues. Uh the the cards, the objective cards, some are definitely a bit easier than others. the powers that you can unlock with the asymmetric characters. There are definitely some powers that are better than others. Uh the uh the objectives cards themselves, I think there's a say a luck of the draw element with, you know, which one you started the game with and which ones you end up with because if you have one at the start of the game that's worth a ton of points, you know, that one is infinitely better to have at the start of the game than one that's only worth about six or seven. you know, it's it's you kind of want, you know, some much better objectives to begin with. And it's just,
as I say, and like I say, the mechanics of the game are simple, but at the end of the day, you're placing colored tiles down and moving stuff around and, you know, doing a little bit of resource management. It it's like it does have some niggling problems. So, I would still probably at least give this one a nine. I think for me though, it might have even dropped to an eight at this point. Uh, it's still a game I really enjoy. I still think it's pretty innovative, but it does have some problems and I'm not sure it's standing the test of time as much because there's not a huge amount of differentiation in the past to victory. It's very much a tactical game. You can't say, "Right, this game I'm going to focus highly on this." It's like, you kind of have to judge everything at the time, which is one thing I do like about it. I do like tactical games, but it does mean that the variety suffers a bit. And that's one thing I think this game does have a problem with. the variety in the game just isn't quite there. But I do think, yeah, 10 was too generous. Um, I would, if I was ranking this game now, I would certainly praise it. I still think it's underrated. I think you should definitely give this one a try if you want a really interesting two to three player game that's quite easy and light.
But a 10 out of 10, no, no, no, no, no, no. I rode a high with this one. Rated it too high. This one wasn't uh correct. Uh, okay. Anything else before I end because we're already up to the hour mark. Uh, anything else? I mean, I'm just going to skim a few quickly. I'm not even going to do the images. I'm just going to uh go back to normal here and just shout out a few. I already mentioned Sentinels in the Multiverse. No, that is staying as a 10. That is a benchmark co-op game. I love it. It's amazing. Um, Pursuit of Happiness and Pulsar 2849. Uh, they recently got talked about on the 50 to 41. Yeah, they have gone down for me. They would probably be nine out of tens now. Uh they're definitely very fun games, but would I rank them a 10 if I rated them again? Maybe not. Uh but they are pretty damn good. Um there is that. Uh Valley of the Kings. Yeah. Rain at a 10. I don't know. It takes a long time when you play it with high player counts and it the starter cards were not particularly overly well balanced. You needed the afterlife expansion to Was it Afterlife or one of the others? I can't remember which one it was. No. Last Rights. Yeah, as I look behind me at it, Last Rights really did fix the starter cards. Um, it doesn't really have a solo mode that I would go mad for. So, it's really a two to three player game. I still think it's one of the best deck builders there is. Uh, 10 out of 10 might be a bit much. I'd probably say a nine at this point. Um, let's see. Uh,
uh, South Tigris games. I was it wayfarers of the South Tigris. I still think that's a I mean it I really do love that game though and like I say some of it is personal enjoyment. It's not just simply detaching my enjoyment of the game. But is Wayf Farers of the South Tigris a benchmark? Possibly. I' I'd still say that's worthy of the 10. It really does a good job. it has one or two minor um issues with the cards not going away, but then you do have a way of mitigating that and you could house rule some easy mechanic in there to wipe a few cards uh every now and again. So, I mean it's it's something that you could fix, but I think it's still worthy. Spirit Island, that is definitely still a 10. I think that is definitely a very unique benchmark co-op heavy co-op game. you know, you want a really thinky co-op game that's thematic, you know, and interesting and works at all player counts. It's Yeah, that is definitely worthy of a 10. Uh, what else we got?
Seti, I did say that that was brushing a 10. I still think it is a 10, but you could argue maybe that should have been a nine. Um, as I say, it's not bad if they become a nine. It's just that I, you know, if I rank them now, would they be the same? Uh, Hijgemany still a 10. Uh, let's see. The Hannah Makoji, is that a 10? Hannah Makoji, that two-player game from Emperor S4. And the expansions do add a bit more variety to it, and it's only got so much variety in its base box. It would easily be a nine. Would it be a hat? I don't know. I think it'd still be a 10. It definitely is out of the two-player games I've played, a benchmark two-player game. Now, does that mean it's one that I play a lot at the moment? No, because it's a two-player only game. I rarely get those to the table. So, will it be in my top 50 or my top 100? Probably not. But I'd still probably rate it a 10 because it's such a good benchmark two-player game. They just don't get played much. Maybe it would need to drop a rating for that. I feel like giving it an 8 out of 10 would be harsh, though. I think it is that good. You know, Geishers Road and a couple of others tried to do similar things with it and they didn't do as well. So, I think this one is still deserving of at least a nine, if not a 10. Um, but yeah, so there's a bunch there. So, and I'm not going to go into everything I ranked a 10 because otherwise I'd be spoiling most of the top 50, I suspect. But, you know, it depends how many people watch this and then that. But yeah, I mean the the idea
is is that, you know, there's going to be games that I probably were too harsh on more so the games I was too generous on because I'm definitely more critical of board games. You know, I will certainly be picking at them more. I'm more consumer focused. I'm, you know, careful with my money. You know, if I'm going to be spending a lot of money on a game, you better justify it. which is why I'm actually waning off Speak Easy at the moment. You know, I would still like somebody to put it in front of me and play it, but it's starting to appear more in the UK now. You can sort of pre-order it, but it's pre-ordering at £125. I'm sorry, that is a lot to spend on a game for a gamble. And this would be a game that would require a ton of investment in time and hours to play.
And the more I see it online, the more I'm waning off it because the flaws that are being mentioned with this game, you know, people mentioning, you know, people who just love it to bits and won't say any flaws are living in a dream world. There's clearly flaws with this game because the ones that I see that are doing pros and cons say this is what I like about it. Here's some problems. These are legit problems with the game, chaps. I mean, there are some issues in this game. It's just a case of whether they are issues as much for you as others. But it's also like a massive table hog. I mean, for a solo game, speak easy wants the entire like gigs and table to itself for a solo game. That's a little bit ridiculous. Even Frost Punk doesn't. Actually, Frost Punk Matt tower those four boards. Actually, Frost Punk does take a lot of that for solo, but that is a much more I mean, that's a big fanatic game that's got that presence. Speak easy does not have to do that. It, you know, it's hard to say, but yeah. I mean, I've seen speak easy just sprawl over tables and it's kind of ridiculous. But, you know, I'm just less keen on it the more I hear about it. But, u you know, there's definitely games that I've been critical on, very critical on, and maybe gone, "Yeah, you know what? Maybe maybe I can reward some aspects of this game, especially when you're saying a game is like a one or a two out of 10. That is pretty low down." But when I get a game that is a 10 out of 10 and a benchmark level, usually it worse. I mean, I'm trying to play devil's advocate as much as I can, but worse, it's probably just still going to be a nine. You know, it's
it's unlikely that if I give a seal of distinction to something that I rate a 10 that it would suddenly not get a seal of distinction from me. I could argue maybe that Tribes of the Wind that I was talking about is probably the biggest contender for that. A game which I ranked the 10 probably might have only even given a seal of approval as opposed to distinction. You know, there's not many of those games in existence. Usually, they're going to be okay. So, if I don't think it's a benchmark title, I'm still gonna think it's a damn good title. You the, you know, maybe it would be interesting to look at the ones I rank a nine out of 10 and see if they actually don't deserve a seal of distinction, but again, that just sounds like I'm being too harsh on those games, you know, because they are still, you know, good ones. Although, the disparity between an eight and a nine is probably high. I would say the disparity between a nine and a 10 is a small gap compared to the disparity between an eight and a nine because with those two ratings I'm trying to distinguish whether I give it a seal of approval or a seal of distinction and those two are very different in terms of uh you know grading. You know if you see a box out there like Galactic Cruise or something like that with my or um Ager's Dream or something with my gold uh seal of distinction sticker on it, there's a reason I gave it a seal of distinction.
you know that it means a lot from me who generally ranks games lower than other people. Um so in fact somebody uh oh I'm trying to remember can I find the comment actually just before I sign off. This made my day. This absolutely made my day and if I can find the comment I'm going to shout it out now because this is the sort of stuff I like to read. I was coming into this this morning and I was like all right I'm tired. I had a late night you know job starting tomorrow. thinking about that sort of stuff and I was thinking right all right come on let's get the podcast done it needs to be done still contemplating whether this podcast should be monthly honestly you know would it really kill me if I did this monthly rather than fortnightly we'll have to see but let me just know your thoughts on that but um especially as they're usually an hour long anyway at least I would make them long podcasts you know maybe I'd make them an hour and a half in the future if I did it monthly so I had a nice long podcast to listen to but I was doing I was looking at MV uh the board game MV And I did a video for that one ages ago.
Uh, and on this one, uh, somebody put a comment on it today and I'm definitely going to shout this out. Where the hell's the video? Damn it. I'm going to find it. All video reviews 39. There's a lot of video reviews for this D. Somewhere here there is the Broken Mele review. Here we go. Heart of the Silk Road review. Should you buy Oh, this was the time when I was saying should you buy this game? you know that that is a title which is so cliche but somebody put a comment this morning uh just known as beast of leisure not familiar but yeah dude you are becoming a rare thing a reviewer I actually trust to critique a game properly there seems to be fewer and fewer reviewers willing to stick their neck out and say unflattering things about games I appreciate you for not being an industry shill thank you maybe using the word shill is a bit uh um much to say you know especially when describing anyone else, but you know, just get a comment like that just to say that, you know, the stuff you do is really nice. You know, I'm not saying I need to be flooded with this stuff, but I read that this morning before I got onto this podcast and it just made my day, you know, to get comments like that every now and again, you know, really does make all this effort worth it, you know, and I don't need them every second, you know. I still enjoy what I do. I still enjoy doing this, but you know, you have to put up with a few trolls and haters every now and again doing it the way I do things. It's nice to get it the other way round at times as well. So, yeah, that made my day. So, thanks, Beast, for that. That was just a very nice comment to read. Anyway, I'm going to sign off this podcast and get it edited and sorted. So, thank you for
listening. Hopefully, this reverse topic worked for you. I don't know, but I thought it was an interesting idea, so I thought I'd give it a try. But um certainly going to ask the patreons I think for some more topic ideas before the next one in the Fortnite because I'm definitely going to need more to talk about. Uh take care everybody. Uh thanks for listening. Share it on social media. You know, thumb it up. And uh the podcast should now be working on the RSS feed now. Um I fixed that problem. Um for whatever reason, Soundcloud.net didn't fully process the tracks. So even though I uploaded them, they didn't fully process, which means they didn't link out to other sources. So I've corrected that. You should now find podcast 126 and 127. They might be in the wrong order because of when I uploaded them. There was other problems, but you know, they are there. So, you should have had those fed to you now.
This one should feed to you. I'm going to keep double-checking that they fully process. So, we should avoid that problem. So, if you're on Spotify or Apple and other providers, you should be getting all the podcasts now. So, thank you for listening and thank you for bringing that to my attention. I'll see you on the next Broken Mele show. Take care and enjoy the rest of your Sunday. Wish me luck tomorrow, guys. Bye-bye.