Skip to main content
Loading video...

Vikings, Picture Perfect, Quest for El Dorado Reviews - Chairman of the Board

Transcript 10:57

hey everybody today I'll be taking a look at three more family weight style board games here the games are going to be the Quest for El Dorado we have Vikings and we're also going to take a look at picture perfect now before I get started on my thoughts on these games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor keyienda dot Co dot UK who are my go to online retailer when it comes to acquiring board games here in the UK and if you use my link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get five percent off your first order okay so let's start here with the Quest for El Dorado so this is a two to four player game that takes around an hour to play um at least according to the box but personal experience I've had many games that have run quicker than that so this is a deck building and racing game hybrid as you are trying to Traverse this modular board here in order to reach El Dorado before the other players do and as with deck building games you are trying to manage your hands of cards use them efficiently and buy new ones from the market to get better and better as the game goes on and all these cards are going to associate to these different terrains all the different hexes within the map here so for example in order to travel through this thick kind of bush here you're going to have to use these machetes to cut your way through and you're going to start with pretty basic cards as with most deck builders but you can invest in better and better ones to get faster and faster and of course you and the other players are sharing Roots at times so therefore you might be stood in the way they might have to go around you and that kind of thing so there's a good bit of attention here to try and get to places quicker

than the other players do now if you watch my content regularly you might have noticed that I tend to not play many deck building games I've always thought that there's a bit too much going on in them and you have to keep investing and getting more and more content to keep it interesting and that kind of style of model all that that buying model doesn't interest me too much but and that kind of ties into my initial thoughts of this one because when I first played this one I was a little bit underwhelmed because I wasn't quite sure what to expect and it turned out to be a very family friendly accessible game and I thought you know maybe I wanted a bit more meat on the bones here more things to explore but when I knew what I was getting into and I accepted that's what the game was and that's what it was trying to be I've tended to enjoy it more and more and I especially think a big part of that is because it does not outstate its welcome at all you know you want race games to be relatively Punchy and relatively quick to bring out that feeling of the race and I think this game does that well and you have to accept that there is some swinginess in the luck here like for example I've had many games of this where I'm stuck on a certain spot I just need a single um you know a single car to let me get past this water and I don't draw it for several turns while my other opponents are flying through the map because they've drawn the right cards at the right times now generally that'll balance out but sometimes you're too far behind and you can't make up the ground but you have to get people be prepared to roll with these punches and accept that that might play a part and The more I've accepted that the more and more I've enjoyed it so this is actually climbed to the front of my favorite deck building style games because it's all self-contained you don't need to keep

buying new stuff and it's like a nice little Charming design here by the good doctor Ryan knits here so I actually think for a for a gateway deck building racing game hybrid this is a really cool option and it's again that I don't really ever feel like turning down I might not always request it but I've always had a good time when it gets to the actual table so that is the Quest for El Dorado the next game we're talking about here is a picture perfect now this is a two to four player game that takes around 45 minutes to play now if you watched my 2022 Chairman's Choice Awards you might be aware that this game won the category for the most unique game of the year and because the concept of this game is absolutely fascinating as each player has their own basic little diorama here centered around this dining table and you're gonna have a bunch of these different character standees and the idea is that you want to be taking the perfect group photograph based on the wants and needs of all these characters because at the start of the game each player each of these characters is going to have their own little personal sleeve here and you gotta randomly distribute these cards into those sleeves which will show what those characters want so for example this character might say well I want to be stood next to this gentleman and I want to be stood next to the table some might say I want to be stood away from the table or I want to be stood behind the table or I want this character's face to be covered up and all these different things you're trying to map out to try and reach as many of them as possible to get the most points so a very cool unique concept which has to be given full props because you know generally speaking most mechanisms and

ideas and board games are rehashed now because there are so many games coming out this game managed to break through and try something completely different which gets my full full respect I like this idea of the memory in the game because you know generally speaking I don't have a great memory I don't find memorizing things particularly fun but this game manages to make it fun which is a bit of an anomaly for me and I think I think a big part of that is because of the real tangible nature of the game and because each of the characters are quite distinct and unique so they do have uh you know a good character and that can help you you know retain information a bit better so I do like that because you know because you only have a small fraction of the information available to you at any time and once it goes on to the next round you're gonna have to remember what these characters wanted um you can regain that information back but generally that's not going to happen now despite me loving the concept of this game and finding it a lot of fun I do think this game has a lot of rough edges and I think there's certainly some things that could have been ironed out in terms of the design process like for example because of the cars being distributed at the beginning of the game randomly sometimes their wants and needs are contradicting with each other so some might say well I want to be stood next to the table but in the same sleeve you have one that says I want to be stood away from the table which obviously can't happen so you're gonna have to give up one um so you can't score maximum points and that's that's a small criticism um but I also think that there were a few too many mechanisms added into the design process so for example each round there's an event most of those events are really simple like swapping sleeves with each other that kind of thing but

sometimes they add in this auction mechanism where you are spending these items on your table to to bid for information I think that is completely extra it did not need to be there it did not did not help with the game experience at all it made it fiddly and convoluted for the sake of it so I definitely think I would remove that part of the game completely and when I personally play this game we always take those events out of the deck because again it's too much for this style of gameplay and it takes away from the core experience but on top of that I think the game is great it's a really good fun experience and um you know I thought it would run dry pretty quickly but it didn't and I really enjoyed this one still so that's Picture Perfect a fantastic little family game here and the final game I'm talking about today is Vikings by Michael keisling so this is an older game and takes around an hour to play accommodates two to four players and it's a tall placement drafting Style game as you are drafting these tiles which are these different items I suppose I'm putting them onto your own little player board here which is essentially this little axes and you have to build them from left to right and also when you drafted these tiles from this really cool kind of bidding wheel here you they go hand in hand with a particular meeple color and all these different little Viking meeples have their own strengths and have to go in these particular rows on the islands on your player board so for example the black Viking meeples will help fight off these ships that come and attack you and if you fight them off successfully then you can get victory points or you can get more income

um you've got the red ones here which give you straight up victory points you've got the green ones which give you points based on the ones below it and you have the yellow ones which will give you more income during the income phases and you have the blue ones which will give you um basically the ability to feed your workers at the end of the game because if you don't focus on that you're going to end up risking losing a lot of points I love the fact that when you draft these things they go hand in hand with each other and if you can't place them immediately they go straight into the storage area meaning that you have to collect these gray nipples these gray Vikings to ship them off to the islands later so you want to be efficient there and if you're not being too efficient you want to be making sure you're investing in these gray kind of botsman here these boatsman which is a really cool mechanism I like the way that the the wheel here rotates based on what other people are taking so for example if there's only say one type of meeple available like you're desperate for a black people to fight off the threat then you're gonna have to spend a fair amount of money to do so but the more and more these cheaper tiles get bought up as soon as a new one becomes the cheapest one it will rotate surround making everything else cheaper so it does have that kind of passive play interaction there and it's certainly another wrinkle of the game that you need to consider because money in this game is super super tight just a very cohesive game here I love the way everything works I love that get that dual drafting mechanism I like the way you're compensated by spending the most money because if you spend more money than anybody else at any time you get to take one of these bonus tiles which are really useful tools which will kind of increase the yield if you're certain

Vikings Etc just a wonderful game you know I talk kind of Ad nauseam really about games being out of print and why that's a shame I think if I was to ask for a game to be reprinted I think Vikings might be right at the top of that totem pole because I think with the right kind of release and the right marketing this game could be as big as a game like Cascadia I think this game's a better game than Cascadia and I really like that game but um but yeah for some reason this game isn't being played it's not out there already available and it should be because it takes so many boxes and it appeals to so many different people you know I could teach this for somebody who's relatively new to gaming and they'd have a great time or I could play this one with you know three other really salty experience coming eurogamers and they're also going to have a really good time with it because the game experience is that rich and it is that enjoyable without being complicated without being confusing or anything like that at all and that kind of different dynamic in terms of the tire placement is is different to anything else out there because you can't just put things where you want you have to construct these islands in particular orientations and depending on the availability of these tiles that's really going to change the flow of the gameplay so this one is going from strength to strength for me personally you know this was kind of creeping into the bottom of my top 100 but the more I play it it's getting higher and higher on that list and I think it might be breaching the top 50 now so that's how much I think of this relatively simple tile placement game just an absolute Delight to play and this one if you find a copy out there in the world I really Advocate you pick this one up because it

is an absolute Gem of a game so that is Vikings so there we have it that's my thoughts on these three games hopefully you've enjoyed the video and if you have please hit like And subscribe to my channel and for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye

Progress saved