AEG Fires COO Ryan Dancey After AI Game Design Comments! Tiny Towns, Cubitos, and Flip 7 Mentioned
Transcript
Ohoy there YouTube. I'm back again today for another episode of Bower Rides the News where I take a look at a different tabletop gaming news story put in my eyeholes and put in your eyeholes at the same time. We got ourselves a huge one here as the chief operating officer at AEG says artificial intelligence could have designed his company's games. This was two days ago. And now, uh, the top story on Reddit is AEG and Ryan Dancy, their chief operating officer, part ways after comments about AI replacing designers yesterday. Uh, this one's from Floral Alyssa. So, we're going to see exactly what he said. We're going to see exactly what they said. But before we get into that, I think it's important to remember just how great AEG is as a company. Like banger after banger after banger. You know, you look at the top rated games of all time. They have number 57, 181. So, Cascadia, Warchest, Istanbul, Space Base, Calico, The Guild, The Guild of Merchant Explores, so good.
Love letter, Dead Reckoning, Ready Set. That's so fantastic. Let's go to Japan, Cupos, Tiny Towns, Thunderstone Quest. It just list goes on and on and on and on and on. They have fantastic games. Some of the best well-designed games in the entire world. And they've been doing that since I got in the hobby over a decade plus ago. So, very well ran in my opinion. Like, just so let's get into this. The chief operating officer at AEG says AI could have designed their games. So, we start with a quote from Richard Simpson, and he says, "Baffles me why people would think AI should be included in any serious business when it's like the office four-year-old." And Ryan Dancy, the COO at Alerac, responded by saying, "Because three years ago, it was essentially nothing but a curiosity. Now, it's useful, but in limited cases. In a year or two, it will be as useful as any new hire. A year or two after that, it will be as useful as an experienced employee. in any field for a few dollars day and cost. 15 years ago, the best humans could beat any computer playing chess. 10 years ago, a human checking the work of the best chess playing computer could beat the best human. Today, the best humans cannot beat a chess playing computer. That is what is happening with AI except the time frame is months, not years. So starting off with this, nothing I would say that is terribly offensive or crazy or going to lose your job, right? I think that's a very like I agree. Moving on.
I have zero reason to believe that an AI couldn't come up with tiny towns or flip seven or cubidos. Uh and that was quote so quote unquote come up with tiny towns or flip seven or cubidos. I could prompt any of several AIs right now and get ideas for games as good as those. The gaming industry doesn't exist because humans create otherwise unattainable ideas. It exists because many many previous games exist feed into the mind of designers who produce new variants on those themes. Yeah. And I mean, if you want to look at one of the the most recent example we have of that in the board game world is is is you know Dominion and think about what Dominion is if you played that and then think about how there have just been hundreds of games since then and pretty much just taken that basic idea and and spun it out numerous different ways.
Okay. So yeah, I get what he's saying here. People then apply risk capital against those ideas to see if there's a product market fit. Sometimes there is and sometimes there is not. In fact, much more often than not. Extremely occasionally, twice in my lifetime, Dungeons and Dragons and Magic the Gathering, a human has produced an all new form of gaming entertainment. Those moments are so rare and incandescent that they echo across decades. Game publishing isn't an industry of unique special ideas. It is an industry about execution, marketing, and attention to details. All things AIS are great at. And that is it. So that is the message sent. And I'm gonna guess that the part that really like calling out specific games.
Why would you call out specific games? Like I I just just And I know why. I know why. Because the next argument to this would be, you know, all right, let's talk about what Tiny Towns or Flip 7 actually is gameplay-wise. Like Flip 7 is not a complex game, right? Um, but still naming specific games, I don't feel like that was a good play. Uh, okay. Let's check out what the comments are. Having designed a few games for AEG, I can say this hurts to read. And having published 100 plus games on my own, I can say he's way off base. AI could toss out ideas, but so can anyone. That doesn't mean it's a good game. The best game comes from lots of hard work after that initial idea. So, I'm just curious. Uh, Warp Tour. Yeah, what's up?
Um, I didn't know if we could figure out who that that was, like like what games they designed. Deserving of way more up votes. Ideas are in abundance. Uh, if you want to spit out warm bowls of nothing, LLMs can help you all day. If you want to create something a little beyond flip seven, something people refer to as art, not so much. This is the take of a man who buys the ideas and hard work of other people, not the take of a man who has had those ideas or put in that hard work. Buys the ideas and hard works of other people. Like I you put it in a negative connotation like they're trying to sell it. Okay. Anyhow, so that was the quote and now we go to the next post which is the blue sky. Today I want to share that Ryan Dancing and AEG and this is John Zincer who is like the head dog at AEG uh you know like AEG was formed in the early 1990s and has been continuously owned and operated by president and CEO John Zinser. So like this was the buck stops here. Today I want to share that Ryan Dancy and AEG have parted ways. This is not an easy post to write. Ryan has been a significant significant part of AEG's story and I am personally grateful for the years of work, passion, and intensity he brought to the company. We have built a lot together. As AEG moves on to its next chapter, leadership, alignment, and clarity matter more than ever. This transition reflects that reality. Our
commitment to our designers, partners, retailers, and players remains unchanged. We will continue building great games through collaboration, creativity, and trust. Okay. And then we also have Ryan Dancy's response and we have an article about it from Board Game Wire, which has some more information as well. So, this is from Ryan Dances. This morning, John Zitzer and I talked about the aftermath of my post yesterday about the ability of AI to create ideas for games. He's decided that it's time for me to move on to new adventures. Sorry to have things end like this. I've enjoyed my 10 years at AEG. I wish the team there the best in their future endeavors. I believe we're at a civilizational turning point. that who we are and how we are is going to change on the order of what happened during the agricultural and industrial revolutions and its pastime we started talking about it and not being afraid to discuss the topic talking about AI being honest about what it can and cannot do and thinking about the implications is something we have to begin to do in a widespread way humans have a unique creative spark that differentiates us and makes us special and we should celebrate that specialness as we experience this epic change. For the record, I do not believe that AI will replace the work talented game designers/developers do, nor do I think it is appropriate to use AI to replace the role of designers and developers in the publication of tabletop games.
During my time at AEG, I developed and implemented policies and contracts that reflect those views. It's important to me that you know what I believe and what I don't believe on this particular topic despite what you may have read elsewhere in particular. I think it's a smart idea to mention uh that that part about the in the contracts like yeah we put stuff in here actually you know uh so that's something we were looking at for and by the way this is from uh Marky X on X. He does some great board game stuff on there. So word game wire. One more article. Tabletop veteran Ryan Dancy loses Alak COO job after saying AI can generate game ideas as good as some of his company's game designs.
Ryan Dancy, a more than 30-year veteran of the tabletop gaming industry, has lost his COO job at publisher Alderok Entertainment Group. This is by Mike Ditimus. True, by the way, a day after saying AI could generate game ideas as good as his company's titles Tiny Towns and Cubidos. Dancy said Alderak COO John Zincer told him it was time to move on to new adventures in the aftermath of his LinkedIn post discussing the use of AI in board game design which quickly attracted a flurry of negative comments from tabletop designers. Yeah, AEG business partners and bodies such as the tabletop game designers association as well as board gamers across social media. Much of the eyeire was directed at Dancy's response to a post comment which argued that AI wouldn't come up with tiny towns or flip sevens or cubidos because it doesn't understand the human element of fun. I want to take a pause here and say this as someone who has looked into like trying to design a game help with the help of chat GBT. I think there is absolutely a lot you could do with AI, especially to come up with different ideas that you could potentially weed out. Like what he said about how, you know, games come together from people's, you know, shared experiences of like trying all these different games and then figuring like trying to pinpoint the fun and then add to it or change it. Like that's Yeah.
So, I get it. I get what he's saying and I don't necessarily disagree. On its own though, no. I think the game would probably suck because I don't think they would have a way to play test it yet. Anyh who, I just want to say that because if you haven't tried, it's it's kind of fun to try and be like, "All right, here I want to make this deck building game." And then like, yeah, it's fascinating. Any who, the gaming industry doesn't exist because humans create otherwise unattainable ideas. It exists because many, many previous games feed into the mind. Oh, that's exactly what I was just talking about. Uh, so they're just quoting some stuff from the article. Game publishing isn't an industry of unique special ideas and is it's Oh yeah, this is he's literally just posting the exact post. I want to be clear where I stand. For 30 plus years, AEG has worked with human designers to bring games to life. That creative partnership, the collaboration, the shared spark is what makes tabletop specials. That is not changing. Several hours later, Zinser confirmed in a Facebook post that Dancy and AG had parted ways after more than a decade.
Zincer said, "This is not an easy post yet. The stuff we read, I expect Ryan will have much success in what he builds next." Okay, here we go. Asorgan the extra stuff. The Tide, in my opinion, is only running one. No. Dancy, however, provide an extensive response to Board Game Wire's questions, including denying that he believed AI could come up with Tiny Towns or Flip 7 or Q videos. Instead, emphasizing that he was speaking about the technology being able to produce ideas rather than completed designs. He told Board Game Wire, quote, "I am not saying that AI could turn over a finished game design ready for publication. I'm not even saying that an AI could produce work ripe enough to be pitched to a publisher. But the idea that it could not be used to generate ideas on the level as those embodied by those three games is already demonstrabably false in my opinion. Yeah, that's that's exactly what I was just saying. Like if you just ask me to pitch out like give me three or four ideas, I'll sip through them myself be like, "Oh, that would be fun to add a bidding mechanism here." Right.
like like give me some unique big bidding concepts that that might make this feel different but unique like and make sure it's going to still work with the player reference card that we have you know like that's the kind of stuff we're like that's a legit conversation that that you have with the chat GPT when you do this kind of stuff this language come up with is pretty not specific and I understand people who chose to take it as the most extreme level even though that was not my intent I could have done a better job of being more explicit about the level of work I think an AI can do yeah a thousand% and not name drop some of your games, right? I think that could have used like an extra paragraph there of like like let's for instance take a look at a popular game design and like what actually is the like what makes it so special here and it's like oh it's it's you know what I'm saying? Dancy added that he had contacted Tiny Town's designer Peter McFersonson and Cubido's creator John Declair in the wake of his comments discussing their game saying quote among other things I told him I don't think AI is capable of doing your jobs. I would much rather work with you than a robot.
I think you're both top tier designers that I feel privileged to work with. And I apologize if you found anything in my remarks to be hurtful. Oh gosh. Tried. Oh, I don't have a working relationship with Flip 7 designer Eric Olsson, but I would say the same to him if I did. That was quote. Commenting on his suggestion suggestion in the LinkedIn post that all current board game design is based on designers taking existing games and producing variants on those themes. Dancy said quote everything we do as humans is derived from experience. All art is derived. We all stand on the shoulders of every generation that went before us. Specifically, I wrote the gaming industry doesn't exist because humans create otherwise unattainable ideas. It exists because Yeah. Yeah. We talked about that. I stand by that statement. It seems axiomatic to me. The game industry is overflowing with great ideas for games. We don't lack for ideas. The hard part is deciding which great ideas could be commercialized and how to do that. The incredible skill that someone like Pete or John brings is knowing how to evolve a good idea, a good idea into a great game. True. No AI at AEG. Dancy also told Board Game Wire that AEG's leadership team made a policy decision quote unquote several years ago not to use generative AI in its products or its quote creative pipeline. He said, "I support that decision. It was a consensus. I believe then and I believe now that it's not appropriate to use AI in those ways in tabletop games. Since then, I've been responsible for developing and adding language to our boilerplate contracts with people who freelance for AEG, who develop for AEG, and who create artwork for AG, which specifically specifically prohibits them
from using generative AI in their work without permission, which AEG does not provide. And that specifies pretty harsh penalties for failure to comply with those policies. quote, "I fully support the inclusion of that language in our contracts. I took the initiative to write that language and I took the initiative to enforce its inclusion." We have already had push back from creative workers who don't like the harsh penalties. We've had push back from people who want to water down their affirmative responsibility to ensure that they and anyone they're working with or subcontracting work to adheres to this policy. quote, "This tide is, in my opinion, only running one way, and AEG is going to have to fight hard to hold its position. Sick." Let me know in the comments what that sick means. I've never known. I nearly flunked out of high school. He continued, "I am not championing the use of generative AI in the gaming industry. Design, develop, or illustrate games. I believe we must talk about the real abilities of this technology honestly so that we can think about the impacts it will have on our lives. Making decisions to use it, how to use it, how to restrict it, and how to enforce those decisions is something that every publisher in the industry should already have done and should be revisiting on a regular basis. The time for these conversations is now, not next year, now. Dancy also quoted in his response to Board Game Wire an essay he says he read last week titled something big is happening specifically this section quote I'm writing this for people in my life who don't work with AI my family my friends the people I care
about who keep ask me so what's the deal with AI that's kind of what I was just trying to do earlier like it's amazing uh and I'm I'm a dummy with it and getting an answer that doesn't do justice to what actually is happening I keep giving them the flight version the cocktail party version because the honest version sounds like I've lost my mind. Yeah. And for a while, I told myself that was a good enough reason to keep what's truly happening to myself. But the gap between what I've been saying and what is actually happening has gotten far too big. The people I care about deserve to hear what is coming, even if it sounds crazy. This is what I tell my kids all the time. Think about whenever you're impressed with AI. Whenever you're like, "Oh, wow. That was really nice. That was really clever what you did there. That was awesome." Think about what the richest billionaires scientists working with AI to make trillions. like what they have and it's like okay I'm on step six. What's step one look like? Dancy told Board Game Wire, I believe I am in touch with enough of this tech and have done enough research to feel the same as author Matt Schumer. I feel like I have an obligation to discuss this technology as widely and honestly as possible. If I do not, I'm going I'm doing harm to those I care about. Yeah, I'm Yang Gang. All I was huge into Andrew Yang who was talking about, you know, the industrial revolution five to six years ago. God, six years ago and we're just now uh okay, I'm sorry if I'm having this conversation makes people uncomfortable.
I know that there are people who want it to go away or believe it's unfixably tainted by the unethical circumstances of its birth. I know that there are people who want to have a fight about this and I want to use proxies if they have to, which is what I feel has happened in this particular case. But I still feel compelled to speak. If I do not, I will go insane. I am incredibly sad that this episode resulted resulted in my separation from AEG, a company I have worked with for more than 10 years, and I'm really frustrated and hurt that it's happening because of something people think I said, not something I actually said. Wider issue. Wingspan designer Elizabeth Hargrave, the co-founder of nonprofit sport organization, the Tabletop Game Designers Association, dismissed NY's suggestion that AI could generate ideas for games such as Tiny Town Cubits, Cubitos. She told Board GameWame Wire, quote, "I absolutely do not think AI could be prompted to come up with even the basic idea for those games, let alone a fully fleshed out rule set for them. For fun, I've prompted several different options for ideas for wigs cards, and not one of them has given me an actionable idea. I had a friend who ran a rule book lit through AI for proofreading, and it hallucinated that people need to shot bingo. Apparently, that's AI's concept of board games right now." Okay. Um, sounds like they weren't using strict restrictions, right? Like that's the thing that apparently is being like you have to have like a huge list of restrictions to keep it on its rails. Uh, or it does stupid stuff. She added, "Designers do pull from existing games, but when it's done well, it's
because those existing mechanisms serve some original idea, and then they're remixed so thoroughly with other mechanisms and with the subject matter that it feels new. Sandable has pieces of Takaido and Tetris and many Thailand games, but it wasn't a prompt of I'm going to remix these games. It was what would work well in service of this idea that I have that requires understanding how games actually feel when you play them and anticipating how different pieces can fit together. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Like that's like it'll be like here's four ideas that you think are great. Like those all kind of suck like and then if you're like give me Yeah, I get this. Hargrave said that TD TTGda board has been discussing use of AI in board game design, adding that it was a conversation we need to have with our membership. She said, "We're working on a model contract to offer to our members right now and that will offer a clause that designers can request that will require publishers not to use AI in their final product. A lot of contracts ask us to certify that a board game design is our own and not plagiarize.
It's my opinion that using AI in a final product goes against that because it uses a machine that's built entirely on plagiarism. Harrave add it. I do see people using AI for things like generating a bunch of placeholder names and a prototype. They're often clunky options, but they do the job when you know everything will change 50 times before you're done anyway. I'm not aware of anyone who has successfully actually gotten good original ideas for mechanisms from AI. What I wish we were talking about is how AI could be built to help designers run models of their games repeatedly to catch weird edge cases or broken strategies. Yeah, like that's that's huge. I wish someone would build that tool instead of the language models that just focused on advanced autocomplete. Excuse me. This would never replace actual play testing with humans for psychology and actual fun, but it might save me some repetitions. Yes, I disagree with that for for some games. I will say that like I feel like especially like an abstract strategy game. Um I feel like certain games, but yeah, for most games I think just that human aspects could be really hard to simulate in the play testing unless you have extreme conditions. Dancy's exit from Alderak comes three years after he publicly a Oh, previous apology. So, we're moving on. Dan's exit from Alderak comes three years after he publicly apologized for saying that male board game designers vastly outnumber women because female are females because quote females are socialized in the west to avoid situations where they're subjected
to fairly harsh criticism of their abilities and creative ideas. Ow. Ah, that's one of those quotes that you really you really hope like that's not my quote, is it? Good. Um, no. I'm gonna guess there's a lot less female game designers because for a long time it was a big boys club, right? Like the And it's still unfortunately is to a certain extent even though it's totally changing like rapidly, especially with Walmart, Target, like more consistently family game nights having, you know, like King of Tokyo, Splendor, you know, some like that that sort of stuff. Uh yeah, that's that's not a great quote. Previous apology. Dancy's exit from Alvarac. Oh yeah. He had made those comments on Twitter in response to a thread from Elizabeth Horrae who uh designed Wingspan by the way Mary poses who had presented data criticizing the structural issues in board gaming which had been so few women nominated for the Spiel prize widely considered the biggest award in board gaming. Okay.
I wonder I I I'm curious how long that goes back because like because they were nominated to spiel this back when it was a big boys club. So yeah, those numbers are going to be heavily skewed um back then. I'm curious D but we got to keep on trucking. We got so we got so much post open. Dancy's comments in the thread include him saying males are socialized to take the punches and keep moving forward. Getting across the gap is how you turn someone into a real game designer who gets paid for their work and who makes designs that are attractive to publishers.
Let's break this down bit by bit so I don't get in trouble. I agree with the first part. Males are socialized to take the punches and keep moving forward. I worked in early childhood education for a decade. I saw a lot of parents. I saw a lot of different parenting styles and yes, they just it's just way way way more prevalent. Uh getting so moving to the next part, getting across the gap is how you turn someone into a real game designer who gets paid for their work and who makes designs that are attractive to publishers. I have talked to many game designers and most of their game designs don't get published. Like most of them have like a it's like you know like for every X number there's one that gets published and that changes based on who you are and how many great games you put out. Um but X is larger than the one. Okay.
Anywh who, his apology for these comments, which has since been deleted from Twitter, remains visible via board game geek fair on the situation. In addition to saying that post doesn't reflect my views, and it certainly and I'm not trying to to agree with him, by the way. I'm just trying to understand his thought process, which you know is that from an early age, you know, boys are taught you got to get through this. You got to get through this crap. Put your shoulder down, man up, right? And in game design, you're going to get a lot of closed doors, a lot of failures, a lot of bad play tests. And he's drawing the connection that because this is how in our society, boys are raised more prevalently like this, this is why they tend to be better game designers. At least is what I'm reading from that.
Let me know what you think about that basic concept in the comments below. Um, no followup. Oh, sorry. In addition to saying that post doesn't reflect my views and it certainly doesn't reflect the views of the company I work for, Dancy outlined concrete steps. He said AEG would be taking quote to do better in this regard and calling on readers to check back with me in a year and hold me accountable. When Board Game Wire contacted Dancy on the anniversary of the apology for an update, he said quote when I'm ready to speak more on this topic and I'll do it on X as a follow-up to that original post. Well, yeah. Would you like to revisit your apology about being sexist? No, thank you. I'll post on Twitter when I get around to that.
That exchange just makes me laugh. Anyway, Dancy's career in the tabletop space dates back more than 30 years when he was part of the team developing the Legend of the Five Rings trading card game. Uh, in 1997, he helped negotiate Wizard of the Coast takeover, the bankruptcy threatened Dungeons and Dragons publisher TSR, becoming head of DND following the deal. Wow. He was a key part of Wizards decision to encourage fan contributions from the D&D community, which led to a creation of the open gaming license, an agreement the game the company controversially attempted to rewrite in 2023. I so I I gotta say I love the fact that this is like really spotlighting like this is a really well done thorough article here. Kudos. Dancy also previously worked as chief marketing officer for CCP games, the Icelandic video game producer of space sandbox MMO Eve Online following its acquisition of role playing games and book publisher Whitewolf Publishing in 2006. Fascinating. He was also the CEO of Goblin Works, the company behind development of massively multiplayer online games based on Piso's Pathfinder RPG between 2011 and 2015. That title raised about 1.4 million across the Kickstarter campaign, but after Dansancy left for quote unquote personal reasons.
All but three of the company's staff were almost immediately laid off with then Piso CEO Lisa Stevens saying delays in getting the games to market coupled with some anticipated funding falling through have left us about 75% short of the money we need to finish the game. Ow. In 2004, Dancy resigned from the board of tabletop gaming trade association Gamma uh who who does the big trade convention and they also uh run Origins as well. after revealing he had accessed the confidential email communications of the Gamma board of directors prior to his election. Okay, so he cheated in the election. It sounds like after access and then Dancy told Board Game Wire yesterday that he did not have any specific plans for the future following his departure from AEG.
Sounds like if he wants to work, there will be someone who is pro AI that runs a company that will be will be there. Uh we had some other stuff too, but honestly that's it. I feel like we got we got the we we bit the most of that apple. So the top response on this him getting fired is well that was quick. Had to be. You can't poop on your own company's designers like that. Yeah, like naming specific games like no. Oh yeah, he definitely deserved it. I'm just used to companies taking enough time to get their PR story in line before taking action. Uh next most popular comment below says think he may have already been on his way out. From what I'm learning, the guy had a reputation. He's the one who made the statement about women being bad designers, right? If anything, it speaks of the company that didn't push him out.
So there, so that's like we just wrote the actual quote he said versus that. And that's like that's why you got to be extra careful. Like that's so someone coming from someone who's not extra careful. Okay, but there you go. That's you're caught up on what's going on with AEG. If you enjoy this board game news coverage, also there's a podcast version of it. If you don't want to see it, you just want to hear it. Uh, and if you enjoy the content, please be sure to click on that subscribe button down below or consider supporting the Patreon for a dollar a month because it really does help me out an awful lot. Have yourselves a good one. Bye-bye.