Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Broken Meeple Show - Episode 52 - Can Bad Rulebooks Kill A Game?

Transcript 53:13

you're listening to the broken meeple show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's luke hector best known for the broken meeple youtube channel and i'm an everyday gamer just like you and i'll be talking about reviews top 10s and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as i have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game hi everybody welcome to another podcast episode episode 52. you're probably wondering why i'm wearing my headset today i don't think it's going to make a lot of difference but suffice to say my neighbors moved out recently are two very nice neighbors very quiet and without kids sadly the people who have moved in have yet to say hello to me and have two kids and apparently they're very very noisy so it does mean i'm having to sort of really dodge when i can do recordings of videos but i'm also wearing these now because i'm trying to drain out the noise which i hope won't get picked up by this microphone and it's just purely for my own sanity yeah i am definitely a pets person put it that way you know i've always said it's like if i can ever meet miss wright you know i want to meet miss wright who's like a geeky girl it doesn't have to be in the board games because there's something geeky that they like and preferably don't want kids which means that they can be crazy cat lady for all i care in fact i would actually like it if they were a crazy cat lady because then we'd have lots of cats and cats are lovely and cute and

fluffy so i'll be totally down with that or even if she had two dogs like i said just pets so she hasn't got a pet tarantula i'd be pretty much happy with that really but yeah so you know hopefully it won't get picked up on the microphone but we'll just have to uh shall we say roll with it on top of that i'm having to record this with a bit of a headache so hopefully we'll get through this episode of one piece with my sanity still intact but you know he'd be a blogger right so how's things been well generally not too bad i mean we're getting into the summer now and views are a little bit on the low side when it comes to a lot of videos takes a long time for them to get up to speed but then most people are off on holiday they're doing stuff in the sun and so you've got to expect these kind of things with uh like the summer time uh but there's you know generally been alright i've certainly been getting on with a lot of pretty big size reviews i mean the yeah merchants of dark robe was a big review perseverance believe me that took me a long time i mean for the viewership i almost wish i hadn't done the video in a sense it's just it was such a mission to get through that game both episodes give it the beans and do a mega review on it but uh it's there if you wanted to know about the latest mine clash one if i did that the top 10 games of five players has been fun and recently i did a collaboration with ninja geek games for top 10 six player games which hasn't been as popular as i hoped it would be but you know it'd be nice to get more onto there but there's a lot of content coming up soon guys i mean i literally have on the on the ren that i've rendered already i've got the sniper elite review i've got the gutenberg

review i've got the viticulture world review and i'm almost i'm halfway to editing the beyond the base game outer rim unfinished business review so yeah there's like four videos on route for that alone you've got this podcast i've got a live stream with solo playthroughs on tuesday evening gmt seven o'clock uh where we're going to talk about top 10 games we've cooled on so that's another collaboration top ten and i've also got an idea for well i say i've got an idea i was inspired i think that's a bit more accurate by a viewer who basically said um you know if you're looking for like other content like other ones to do or say have you considered that well it was basically that they don't tend to watch reviews like reviews for single games which i can understand i mean that's kind of a thing but they suggested the idea of that the best way to put it is if you like x style reviews because there's not a lot of them out there you know dice tower did it very briefly but they were like very short and years ago but and you know times have changed but not a lot of people do like if you like say ticket to ride you're like this and the video would basically say well this is what ticket to ride is and my thoughts on it and then it would dissect the game into several different categories both theme and mechanics and it would essentially very quickly suggest other titles it's not going to be fancy it would just be me in front of the camera in the study you know my nice setup probably very few video clips if any you know but they generally try to be quick videos say

i hate to say low times because i always exceed them but we'll say no more than 10 minutes max you know these will be shortish videos and i thought you know what maybe that's something i can look into because my channel well one thing i mean this will link onto something i'll chat more in detail in a minute but this is definitely a more consumer focused channel so i certainly would like to put out more content that is consumer focused and i feel that such a thing probably would be consumer focused you have to say like right did you like playing cluedo as a kid well here's a bucket load of stuff that you can play that's similar to cludo see what you feel you know light medium and heavy games in fact i reckon that could be quite cool i could get those out reasonably quickly i think they'd be useful there's plenty of options as to if you like this do this or whatever and i think they're they're important enough that they wouldn't just simply be a podcast segment so i'm thinking about that one that could be an interesting experiment to try and probably more successful than the live review thing i was doing which yes has been panned not panned canned that's it yes there was some decent feedback for it or mixed feedback but i was like yeah this ain't working for me it's just not working so the live reviews had to stop but yeah we'll see how things go with that in terms of what i'm talking about like focus on at the moment i need to make a big push for the uh patreon that i have because there it seems the board game industry is going very corporate at the moment and by corporate i mean that it's very the publishers are definitely looking

more at the pound sign that the bottom line then they are i think consumer uh like consumer focus and that it's just the impression i'm getting because i'm having trouble with like like some publishers are recently unfollowed me for reasons i don't even know i mean the most recent one i had was uh i know stonemaire unfollowed me a little while about but then haven't said anything good about three or four of their latest games that's kind of a thing uh but then leather games leader games the ones who do root they unfollowed me on twitter recently and i know i probably shouldn't really care because twitter is twitter i don't really care about that but i you know i it's just weird because i mean i would like to know what what's the deal why you know why was it done but obviously no reason i'm obviously not going to go back to them and say oy why'd you do it because that's not exactly ethical but it's just like why i've i've literally i've taught the praises of fort yes i'm not a big fan of root but i've not really spoken about it at all i even did two playthroughs of the app and said the app was really good i've done nothing on twitter apart from talk about the lord of the rings journeys in middle earth which is on the table uh underneath this laptop and that so yeah just kind of think out of the blue but the phoenix publishers are starting to do this now and not just to me but to small creators in general and so i need to make a big push to people to say look hashtag supports more creators get behind the smaller creators they're the ones who are going to talk to you probably without bias because they're not getting review copies of games all the time they're just talking about something they're passionate about they're not

forced to they're not i'm not i don't want to say the word paid but they're not like uh pressured to do certain things because of the relationships they have with the with the big publishers and that you know i there's loads of really great channels out there that are done by just person around the street who likes to talk about games most a lot of them i've had on my show and there's going to be more in the future i mean i i mentioned solo playthroughs tuesday uh all aboard gamer er we're going to do something in mid-july uh forget i don't think we've settled on a list yet do you mind oh i think they might have wanted to do top 10 heavy games that might be what we're doing with them so that should be quite cool i might be wrong on the topic but we're definitely doing all aboard gamer and um another little podcast uh who which includes actually an old school friend of mine um uh becky who as i went to school with but so long ago i can barely remember back then but it's like ah cool beans uh they do a little uh local podcast called who's turners anyway and yeah good name actually but they you know they had paul grogan from gaming rules on recently for a good uh podcast topic and so they you know we've chatted informally about like oh you know do you want to do something let's do something either a top 10 on my channel or do something on your podcast either way and we haven't done anything yet but it's definitely something i think hopefully both parties are keen on and we'll try and do something with that but all i'm saying is definitely get behind some smaller creators and show them some love because as i say a lot of the publishers can't or won't

and the i would certainly say i need i need to boost the patreon drive a little bit more so i do have a patreon uh that you know that i do use but the and the patreons work great i mean i i owe my patreons so much at the moment because they are the reason this channel keeps going because i get some review copies of games and i'm now getting into the habit of saying on every single video i get a review copy for a thank you to the person who gives me it not to mention for disclosure purposes because obviously some people want to know a lot of the stuff i get though isn't a review copy it's paid for out of effectively patreon funds or my own cash and if i didn't have a patreon that this channel wouldn't function because it's it just about or barely covers its overheads for a year and you know so other stuff has to come out of my pocket i mean i've just recently bought a c-stand which is the thing that slicker drips uses to do overhead playthroughs yeah spoiler alert i'm looking into the idea of doing play-through videos in the future and i thought well slicker drips does a pretty good setup so i thought i'd ask tom you know to advise me on what sort of equipment he uses and that c-stand is the one that he does so i now need to find a good camcorder to put on the thing and that's where i'm a little bit held up at the moment trying to find a cheap well and a cost-effective yet suitable 4k camcorder that can go on a c stand go above do low light nice and easy and do some

playthroughs now i'm not talking live stream yet that will come a bit later let's just baby steps let's get the first bit done first then worry about a live streaming format because you you need multiple cameras you need all sorts of stuff for live streaming i mean just take a look at slicker drips and gaming rules for a kickoff you know and and so you need all that equipment and i just don't yet have that but yeah i i figured i'd give that one a shot but where was i what was i talking about oh yeah so with the patreon side of things they i i can't thank my patreons enough every single one of them whether it's whether they're putting in one dollar two dollars five dollars ten dollars possibly even more sometimes i mean i'd rather have i'd rather have a thousand people give me a dollar a month than a hundred people give me ten dollars a month because you know money is tight at the moment the world market has gone to part especially the uk market and it's you know i don't want to ask people to put themselves in financial risk to support me so you know a dollar is nothing you know dollars nothing you know you wouldn't even miss that but obviously 10 might be a bit different but the patreon funds it goes to like paying for the adobe subscription it pays for the motion array subscription which is where i get a lot of my overlays and like intros and stuff like that and like music files are used it pays for like you know youtube um subscriptions so i can post things up and not have to worry about them like bombarding me with ads all the time or something which could get which used to get really annoying it pays for

review copies it pays for equipment so camera batteries i have to update every now and again the tripods the stand this microphone the laptop everything you know had to be funded by the help of patreons and my own cache and even review copies now because publishers are starting to shy away from anybody who's willing to talk um like i say a word honestly people who are willing to talk negative about reviews as well as positive they're shying away from and that's happening with a few mind now some publishers love the fact i do that but some don't and it's clear to see which ones don't and obviously they want to preserve their profit line which makes sense i mean you're a publisher you're a business i'm not holding it against them it's just that's the way it is at the moment and so you have to effectively think well that means review copies of less which means i have to rely on my own money and patreon in order to get some stuff out like i mentioned what games i mentioned there sniper elite viticulture world the outer rim expansion and uh gutenberg now in the case of those four i was quite fortunate kienda were very nice to support me with the outer rim expansion uh portal were very nice to support me with the gutenberg game uh viticulture world i spent on my own money though and libertalia before that so everything from stonemart i've had to get myself uh perseverance i paid for you know that big one merchant's the dark road i paid for uh what else was there there was another one i got done this week uh mention gutenberg sniper elite uh viticulture sniper elite sniper elite i paid for

that wasn't a review copy either so a lot of these games a lot of this content that i'm doing particularly if it's the hotness games i got offend off and so does so does every small creator to the most part you know some get some of you guys but some people don't get any because they could be so small that a publisher will literally just gloss by them and so that's why i say you need to support these creators and that's why i like to support those creators as well i may not be able to like give them physical cash or like every single one but you know giving them shout outs sharing their content you know supporting what they do having them on the show to say look you know we're going to do a top 10 list why don't you tell us about who you are go subscribe to them you know any every little bit helps to get you know some exposure to them and so you know if you can consider even just a dollar a month for the patreon it all goes a long way and i would certainly appreciate it but you know if you can't you can't as long as you're watching the videos i'm also happy you know sharing them you know share them out on social media because you know get get them out say like you know someone says done a review make it a discussion topic you know those sort of things work on facebook groups and twitter so but by the way i'm grateful that everybody who supports the show whether you're a distributor a publisher uh joe blogs around the corner on the patreon or even just uh somebody sitting on their chair office chair right now listening to the show as a podcast i oh you're in the car seat i'm totally i i am so grateful to you lot it's unreal because i don't know how it would survive otherwise so you know this has

taken up too much of my life to just have it suddenly crash and burn so uh yeah so hashtag support small creators is definitely something to think about right uh well that was a bit of a long intro right why don't we actually get on with something you actually want to hear about like games so let's start off with some basic news first i haven't got to basically the show there is going to be a shelf review so a game that i've uh had on the shelf called diamonds i'm going to talk about later uh i've got a discussion topic on rule books but for now let's just do a little bit of news there isn't a water there isn't a what i've played segment today because i haven't really played anything that isn't already getting a review video at some point uh although on the side i have played some to carry on i played that with some friends of mine on friday and as i mentioned underneath i'm going through the spreading war campaign for lords of rings journalism middle earth so that's been good fun but why don't we get on some news so in slightly weird news bruno cafala bernica fala we love him as a game designer he's designed some fantastic games he has no word of a lie that i swear he's one of my favorite designers but well and one of those games that he designed that i really love was seven wonders duel so seven wonders i already love the game someone just is great seven months duel takes seven wonders makes it good for two players and changes up some of the rules makes it a little bit more complex but it's one of my favorite two-player if not my favorite two-player only game that is in existence but now apparently he's teaming up with marc andre who did splendor splendor as

i keep singing the praises of it's just such a classic 30 minute four player engine builder game that just works so smoothly well apparently they're teaming up to do splendor duel yeah a two-player implementation of splendor now on the one hand splendor is a great game i'm down for something else that uses that splendor mechanic on the other hand two-player splendor is already pretty good in seven wonders case the seven wonders two-player variant i found to be atrocious and a lot of people did as well here though two-player splendor is just fine it's a very simple engine builder game that's lightning fast so what exactly are you changing you've got to add in new mechanics here and so if you're going to create something that's more complicated than splendor which i think is pretty much going to happen by default how simple splendor is this one i'm a little bit in a little bit concerned by like did we need this re-implementation of a two-player version of splendor how much more complex is it going to be but that being said splendor is a good game and bruno kafala is a genius so uh i'm not going to you know write it off just now i am i mean it says here retain some of the gameplay mechanisms while being a bit more complex dynamic interactive rich tense and mean i mean could blimey that's a lot of uh um things although features a main board shared by both opponents and card powers and free victory conditions this is really going down the same road as seven wonders duel isn't it and if that's the case

that could be actually something really fun so i'm keen to give this one a look i'm just kind of surprised it exists right although i'm not surprised this one exists so i'm just gonna say it first right i'm not the biggest fan of roland bright's i know that there's not many roland rights i like okay i've already said about games constantly being like oh you know why is why have we got to have a role and write for everything like why does every big game need to have a roll and right you know can't we just leave it as the big game okay so we've got that but i this one i can see why they might have done the wrong right but i oh god this gets the award for the most what's the i'm trying to think of the word i use the most unassuming uninspiring generic role and write that i can think of and as also i would say the cover is partial nightmare fuel so uh just gonna for those of you on the video side of things i will say the name of the game don't worry but three two one joan of arc all the ons drawn right and how many of you just screamed at the screen about the like the horror that is this cover this cover is atrocious it uses the same sort of pretty bad artwork that all the odds had but this lady is wearing what looks like a castle as clothing because the clothing

actually looks like brick walls but oh my god this looks horrible but look at the rest of the cover it's literally just a white background a very faded village in the background it's this it's the same sort of orleans like art um like art style but man this looks uninspiring joan of arc orleon's drawing right as they call it not much detail about it i mean you you know you draft tiles yeah you pull tiles out of a bag and you take turns drafting them and taking actions that correspond to those tiles that's pretty much it debate it doesn't sound like anything amazing but oh my word i mean i'm not the biggest sound of all leon so yes granted i'll take that you know take it with a grain of salt but i'm not exactly caring about this because it's a roll of robert i just saw that cover and i just couldn't help but laugh because i was thinking are you serious if you saw that on the shelf would you pick it up would you grab this off the shelf if you saw a game called drone joan of arc drawing right with that picture no as i this can't be i thought it was being trolled at first but i mean a shorter version of all the odds is not necessarily a bad thing in my perspective but yeah if you're into this genre then oh well you got another one on the reach you know but i'm curious does anybody who's a fan of is there anybody who's a fan of all the ons interested in a roll and right version that would be something to know but this one i'm curious about in a good

way now i mentioned about the box cover for joan of arc this one just takes the case it's literally just a black cover there's nothing there they haven't actually put a picture there yet it's kind of like a work in progress picture or at least i hope for the love of all things holy that it is because otherwise i'm going to laugh my head off yeah it's a placeholder image right so okay we'll go with that but this is the target d boldness box dye bonus back so you know the bonus box explaining what the language you're in this is an expansion for target turkey is a brilliant two-player only game which i have not played in years because it's a two-player only game but it's in my collection it's got the expansion in it and i still hold fire that this is one of the best two-player games that cosmos has put out it's really really good uh designed by andreas steiger now with this one this is apparently a 10th anniversary of target blimey 10 years old i mean it just goes to show culture the news not always a good thing but they're basically bringing out this bonus box now there's not a lot of content in this game so i hope they're going to make it cheap it's basically got wooden tokens to replace the good tiles in the base game so it's a bit of a component upgrade more than anything else two modules of some extra edge cards some new action cards and things like that so it's like okay not the most lucrative amount of content and you can combine this with the expansion which is all well and good but here's the bit that really got my interest here rules for a solo mode okay

a solo mode for target now seven with the stool love the game but it is two player only asmode then did the print and play or response production uh repost production to be more accurate um did the print and play uh solo rules i have done a playthrough of those rules on the channel i'm pretty certain at some point i did a play through so have a look on the channel for that but it is a brilliant implementation of a solo rules for the physical board game of seven understood yes you can play on the app but i'm talking getting the physical game out with the components and playing against an interesting unique ai system with a card deck it's a brilliant little thing now target if target can introduce a similarly great mode that isn't too complicated but can simulate a second player to a decent extent i will be all over this like glue because i will definitely be down for playing muslim or target especially when i don't have to worry about the fact that i can't get a second player at the you know at moments notice so i am definitely curious to see how they're going to do a solo mode for target i mean it's got to be doable i can imagine it's going to be an autumn deck which dictates which edge cards the meeples will go on and then based on that you'll do your game and then they'll take certain cards based on what they're after hopefully not too complicated that's the only way i can see a solo mode working but i am totally down for this uh well i don't really i don't even care about the rest of the box frankly just give me a print and play of those solo rules and i

will be perfectly happy but yeah it's on the way so if you're a target fan but you always fancy playing it solo because you can't always play it two players uh you could be in with some luck i think all of this is 2022 it does say 2022 on the on the cover so you know let's just hope it stays that way okay right i'm going to take a big swig of my drink sweet apple and blackcurrant squash because it is hot not quite heat wave temperatures anymore thank god but it's still bad right we're gonna do a shelf review so uh well spoiler alert there's the rating there for some people but you know i'm actually thinking i might increase that rating so hear me out this is diamonds diamonds is a trick taking game done by stronghold games this is a second edition and this is the copy i have at the moment the diamonds well actually first off the background trick taking if you're not familiar with what trick taking is it's basically if you've ever played trumps or hearts or anything with a classic deck of cards it's where you play a particular card uh let's say a ace of diamonds or whatever and other players then have to follow suit so they play diamond card diamond card diamond card whoever plays the highest card in that suit wins the trick if you haven't got a diamond to hand like you haven't got the suit that was played you have to follow suit with something else but you won't win the trick now very simple and trump's was basically that but one suit dominated other suits

with hearts it was a case that you scored points but you didn't want to score points you were trying to get as low as possible but you could shoot the moon for something crazy which almost never happens i've done it once where you try and win all the tricks so that everybody else suffers except for you diamonds plays on that trick taking aspect so if that's basically what the mechanic is i really like trick taking games um i'd certainly be more of resurgence in my liking for them in the last few years possibly because of my own nostalgia but even so i enjoy a trick-taking game i think it's probably because they are being used in much more interesting ways now i mean you've got the crew and you've got brian borrow and uh even well as much as i hate to say it leader games you know um arc which i haven't backed but i'll try on retail release that apparently uses a trick taking mechanic in that one and so yeah that they're being used in more interesting ways diamonds feels like a classic game so what you're doing diamonds is you basically are playing cards of the different suits so diamonds hearts spades and everything but there's up to 15 of each suit which is a bit more than usual and i know bring that picture back up there we go and so you're just playing these as normal and you play and you follow suit and you try and win the trick okay where's the difference here the difference is that you are trying to collect these diamonds these little diamond little gemstones behind your screen they're in your safe essentially now these diamonds will score you points at the end of the

game based on whether they're in your vault or in front of your vault so there you can have them stolen off you if they're not in your vault now what happens is you play several rounds and in each round you're dealt out all the cards you're then allowed to pass one two or three to a neighbor depending on the first player and so you play a normal trick taking game so i'll play a free of hearts and you follow with a heart heart heart but whoever wins the trick gets to perform a special power based on the suit that was used so with this uh so for example if you play all the hearts so if you play hearts and you win the heart trick you get to put a diamond from your showroom into your vault a diamond suit might allow you to stick a diamond directly into your vault so there's very simple little rules with how they work but that's essentially what you do you play through the whole round play several tricks and you're you know manipulating these diamonds and trying to get hold of a bunch of them the reason this works so well though is because it's such an easy teach in person and i'm not doing the best job of it at the moment but the idea that you basically just play a normal trick-taking game but then you have these powers for you know a diamond allows you to put it straight into your vault the heart allows you to put it in your showroom the spade allows you to put it from your showroom into your vault the club allows you to steal one from another player it's you know just very simple little powers but it's more than that as well as winning them throughout the round

what you do at the very end of the round is you collect up all the cards from in front of every player whoever has the most cards from a specific suit you they get to do the action again and even better is there's a shoot in the moon mechanic that if you don't win any tricks you get to do two of the diamond actions like like as a compensation which can actually be just as good as winning a bunch of heart and spade actions frankly because you've got to win multiple of those in order to get the diamonds it's like yeah but putting two behind my screen you know if you're not having a good round you can aim for that and get some decent compensation it's pretty cool as a mechanic now you know simple rules really easy to play definitely works with anybody who's played a trick taking game before in their lives uh this is like the first edition version of the game second edition i think tweets some rules will just improve the graphic design a little bit so you know this format is a lot better so let me just blow up that picture and leave it there for a bit um things are not wanting to play ball with me at the moment in terms of my laptop there we go but what i like about this game is not only those special powers are really sweet but it's simple and you can tailor the length of this game to how much you like the game says go on for six rounds do not do that ever it takes too long it can go up to six players with too many players it's a little bit chaotic i quite like this with three or four players i think that works best but i would say stick to four rounds max

three rounds is decent four ounces probably ample five and six you're just going through the motions again it's unnecessary so you can get this done in a decent amount of time say an hour tops three quarters of an hour tops if you just tailor the rounds of it if you play this with a lot of players and play six rounds you will not be done in an hour it's not going to happen but yeah the game was dirt cheap i bought it at essen of all places for 10 euro that's pretty good that must have been on some kind of sale but even so it's not that expensive to buy this game and it just feels like a classic trick taking game you know if someone has played only trumps or hearts and they're like oh but i don't want to get into anything too complicated this is basically what they've been playing for life with just a couple of extra special powers thrown in that's literally it it's just a very cool simple game and you know i think it kind of sparked my resurgence of getting back into some of these trick taking games you know this is definitely a much more classic normal style of trick taking game as compared to something like the crew or brian boro as i mentioned which are a lot more um like a lot more sort of involved but then also it's different from games like nyet or what was it called the goblin king or dwarf king that bruno fergus did i haven't actually played that one but it was basically chaotic powers but there's other trick takens i've gone for in fact tournament and camelot is on the shelf downstairs i've yet to play it but that seems pretty cool the idea that you're playing a trick taking game to like survive a combat true and it's like

okay interesting so you lose life based on the trick special powers it's like hmm i'm interested to try that one at some point so yeah diamonds has just been a pretty solid hit i've rated it a seven out of ten now i'm tempted to raise that to an eight because i do enjoy this game quite a bit but i don't always bring it out so seven eight i'm curious where hold up i mean it is definitely one of my favorite uh in that respect because it does do a lot of it i mean yes i'd rather play the crew yeah or maybe some more like intricate trick taking game but fox in the forest is another one but certainly i think there's i don't know i'm gonna leave it at seven for now seven or eight but this definitely gets the seal of endorsement uh from me i think it's solid anybody who's into the genre or if you just want a simple card game that you would be able to teach to non-gamers i think this is a pretty decent one to go so diamonds off the shelf on you know so off-the-shelf review of diamonds which remains on my shelf uh from since the day i bought it actually right okay right let's talk about the discussion topic now while i've still got a voice so i was trying to debate what to talk about this time i need to do a another patreon post to ask people for keywords in fact yeah on the subject with that i can't i haven't got the time to do like lots of advanced videos and like patreon only stuff you know paul grogan's got a bit more time in his hands for that but what i tend to do is

i can to get people involved so you know if you're on a lower tier you get to ask questions for me to do on q and a's at your leisure you don't have to wait for me to prompt you i also ask for podcast discussion topics again you don't have to wait for prompting i you know you can just message you can start a message or you can respond to one of my posts when i call up i need to set another one of those up actually and if you're on a higher tier you actually get to vote and suggest ideas for top 10 lists both collaborations and otherwise so you know just you basically get you you get involved in what i put out content-wise and if this new idea of mine takes off then well well we'll add that as a part of the tier that you can advise me on what game you would like to see on those ones that'd be pretty sweet but let's tackle this discussion topic which actually i'm borrowing from gaming rules uh like forum so gaming rules has a uh a bgg forum board game geek forum um i definitely recommend people sign up to that because there's some cool little discussion topics that are in there he also puts uh stuff out that's for discussion on the videos and ideas and so there's a general question that came up in here uh from miss monica here uh has a rule book or a game in total ever defeated you so that you don't play the game now that's i'm not sure that's the best wording but basically what this is getting at is has a rule book ever destroyed your appreciation of a game like can you think oh the game's got

some great components it's got some great mechanics it's got everything but then you're slightly defeated because the rule book you hear is pretty bad or like yeah or when you get for the rule book the fact that it's such a chore to learn uh maybe a chord of teaching app becomes a killer for the game i have to say this is actually more prominent than you think because for me that actually is a big deal especially with these big games like for example over there on the corner of the table i have carnival zombie the second edition now this is a pretty big box game about terror defense from zombies i've never played the first edition i have no idea how the game plays apart from like what mechanics are in it i've the rule books i'm looking at them and i'm thinking there's a lot to absorb here am i gonna have the time and effort to like get through this rule book and i mention rule books on every review i do because you know i think it's important a lot of people who review games actually don't talk about the rule book which shocks me to like no end because i get that it's subjective you know people are going to absorb rules in different ways they learn games by different ways and some people understand complex rules more than others but i think you still need your personal opinion on the rule books in a review because at the end of the day like practice what i preach a rule book can destroy an experience for me particularly it involves a lot of effort so i mean taking some heavy games recently i mean they're going to have the most thickest rule books but you

expect that for a heavy game but it can still go a little bit far so you know one game in particular uh defense at crookeon 3 i believe it was yeah defensive program free i review i gave it a sort of like first impressions review back in uh yes back in january and one of the biggest problems i had with it was that it was basically like it had five rule books in it five rule books one for each race one solo and i think there was one other account member but there's maybe there was a six but there were certainly at least five rule books i can't handle that i'm sorry i just can't it was too much asking people to have to read an entire rulebook to themselves and then try and understand them all yourself it just took this one way out of my comfort zone but then uh recently on the perseverance review i made a big deal about the rules being complicated in that one and certainly more people have agreed then disagreed certainly the big fans have come out uh in their you know to say their negative comments on that subject but you know perseverance has a rule book for each game plus a solo rule book plus a chronicles rule book and they're very long rule books with a lot of rules in them it became a bit of a chore to learn this game and get it played to the extent where it was worthy for a review to the point where i wish i didn't even have to well i didn't have to review it i paid every on my own cash

but a lot of people wanted to know if this two episode thing worked you know so i thought all right let's do a review man it was a lot of effort for it and it got to the point where i said look you know what i don't want this game anymore because i can't deal with this amount of rules all the time and it's not just a case of you know oh the rules of complex because i've got games on my shelf where the rules are complex you know i mean come on do you think any of the soda games behind me have simple rules there's plenty enough to do but there's a couple of other factors to consider firstly how much are you going to remember these rules so when i learn a heavy game like arc nova for example or even spirit island to an extent i remember most of the rules from a game to a game because they are either intuitive or they thematically make sense and so in art nova a lot of the rules i explain tend to relate to the theme and theme is a big draw for me in games because it makes teaching the game easier perseverance has a really cool setting i wouldn't say it has the easiest theme to teach with the rules though uh you know tricarion that i played recently that's another thing because yes it's got a really cool thematic setting but it's not that you can teach the rules to it easily particularly when you're starting to deal with things like trick links and the performance cards and the fact that the tricks don't actually mean anything it's just the title and what yield they give you it's like you know it you struggle to get past that but then i can play a game

with kaverner and fields of isle and teach you most of it by thematic inclusions i made a big deal about preda porter on my shelf behind me you could explain most of predaporter by theme alone it's that good and even the little surgeries behind me you know the kanban and the gallerist and this boa well maybe not this board to an extent but vinos maybe viticulture all of these games have solid themes that make teaching the heavy complex rules a lot simpler and it makes a big difference so with that said carnival zombie might work i need to tackle the rules to it but yeah big heavy games they are they can be problematic with the rule books and i'm getting into this mindset where like life's too short time is precious and i can't be dealing with these ridiculously overcomplicated rulebooks in plentiful quantities just for a single game i got enough games i need to get played and reviewed without having to devote my life to this one game it just doesn't work in that respect now in those circumstances it's not that the game is terrible or the rule book is terrible because i don't think the perseverance rulebook is bad i don't think that a lot of these other heavy game rulebooks are bad but there's a lot of stuff in there but if you do have a game for example that has a terrible rulebook like one that you just will not go near because it's written so poorly then yeah i probably won't even go near your game period and who can forget the most infamous of this batman city chronicles i think this is

the one yep the the the monolith game which you know was essentially adapting their conan game and you know theme wise i should be on this like glue it's batman it's awesome a miniatures game of batman going up against uh like enemies and yeah and doing like a skirmish game it should be great it also has one of the worst rule books in human existence and given that the conan rulebook was already like horrific in terms of its rule but you'd think it would be some clue to them that they needed to sort this out but no their rule books were so bad that i could not legitimately play the game right each time and i thought well i am not going to teach this where the rule book is so confusing i can't refer back to it again so i'm done you know not going to play them now i hear paul grogan's doing work on possibly the batman rule book so that will be amazing if that's the case because then finally you might actually be able to play the wretched game but yeah i mean it makes a difference to have your rule books correct and so publishers really need to start paying more attention to this kind of thing i don't get how these horrible rule books get past quality control you should make that the forefront of anything you are planning for in your play testing give it a blind play test to a different people who don't know you who don't know the game try and get them to learn it and if they can't learn the game from your rule book then perhaps maybe hire

an editor you know it's not a big like surprising revelation here to be able to hire a rules editor more publishers need to do this and it works wonders for your game okay rule books you know people can forgive a bad component people can forgive a quirky mechanic they don't like people cannot forgive bad rule books they will just destroy your game if they are written poorly now with a lot of other rule books serving the style of rule book makes a difference for me and certainly when i get a new game to review or certainly when i get a new game to play i look at the rule book and depending how it's laid out that's going to have an impact as well because i'll be like okay so this looks pretty good it's laid out nicely the fonts big there's not a huge amount of pages great mainly i'm looking for pictorial examples so i certainly do not like when uh rule books are just a wall of text because that gets on my nose because i feel like i'm just reading a technical manual but if i can see that there's a lot of pictures explaining everything i'm good and i mean i you know i gave wonderland's war a seven out of ten okay i think it's overrated but i still gave it props for what it did good and the rule book was one of them the rule book in wonderland's war was very good it had probably went a bit over the top in terms of pictorial representation in places but i could see exactly what it was referring to and i didn't have any problems playing the game at that

point brilliant if you've got app integration even better i mean you know i'm playing journeys in middle earth i haven't played it in a while so i thought oh i'm gonna have to read a bunch of rule books and oh as i read them down here i've got to you know the rules reference and uh spreading war here so you know expansions don't have that bigger rule book for these so that's an easy one to include in fact most of it's just rinse repeat but there are some things that i've forgotten since the last time i played it so you know i forgot oh what does that keyword exactly mean oh is that right oh what what's the exact definition of resetting a skill deck you know and then other little bits like oh does this happen at that point you know and these rule references are great for me to find that because i can find the rule and just get on with the game i don't have to read the entire rule rulebook to learn it but all i pretty much did was i got the stuff out and followed the app the app gets you into it and so something like manchester madness and xcom for example that take you through the game and handle a lot of the admin and bookkeeping make a wonderful difference you know if i hear that it's something like manchester madness where there's app integration it's instantly gonna like perk up my spirits for your game because i know that the app is gonna handle a lot of the rules problems and make it a lot easier to learn now of course you could have a bad app as well or something that doesn't really help with the rules and that is a potential factor but there's not many occasions where i've had that issue it

must be said i mentioned briefly earlier that you know your ability to teach a game is going to be influenced by this so it's all right saying oh well it's not the most complex of rule books or even if it is a complex rule book how easy is it to teach the rules though i honestly don't have that much trouble teaching art nova yeah there's a fair amount to get across but because i can use theme to describe a lot of stuff that happens in it and because a lot of the rules are fairly intuitive it's it works wonders for being able to teach it because arc nova is a heavy game but it's not heavy because there's 50 million rules it's heavy because the stuff you were doing in the game requires fort whereas as i mentioned perseverance earlier yeah the stuff you're doing in the game is heavy although i'd argue actually that it's only mid weight in some respects i don't know it's still technically heavy i guess but there's a lot of rules a lot of different things going on a lot of little interactions like if this happens do this if this happens to this that makes it an absolute chore to teach because there's the there's the question of time span between games who's playing perseverance every single day at the moment i would envy them for how much time they have on their hands that would be insane but you know if i put down perseverance after playing it once it could be months before i play it again because it's so long and involved you know compared to getting everything else out and so how am i gonna remember all those rules i'm gonna have to relearn them all over again they won't stick in my head but there's a bunch of games on my shelf here where even though i haven't played

it for a while i wouldn't need to learn that many rules again because they they stick they're not so fiddly they work with the theme they're more intuitive uh the ryan lockett games i haven't played empires of the void in a while i guarantee you though when i get out again i might have to skim the rule book once briefly to check on a couple of things but i could pretty much teach empires of the void too right now if that was the case obviously a simple two-player game a simple filler and that requires nothing to teach i mean splendor obviously is not going to be a problem seven wonders some wonders architects uh i think baron park alice's garden you know small games have small rule books therefore they're always a good thing i mean if you if you over complicate a small game you've kind of failed really because that's not what it should be but but then there's you know some rule books for smallish games that i'm not the biggest fan of it imperium i've got downstairs i i still love the game i think it's an excellent solo deck building game for me i don't like to play it with other players because it's too long but the rule book in that from osprey games is not particularly great is it uh it could use a rules rewrite you know not just in the look you know with more pictorial examples but just to make it more clearer and so that does put me off bringing imperium out i still think the game's great and i want to play imperium but i know there's going to be that learning curve i'm going to have to jump into that hurdle robertson crusoe is another one um a lot of people say that they put robertson crusoe down and then don't pick it up again because it's a bit of a bug bear to learn and teach again

the new version coming out with the tutorial could really solve that problem but it's a factor it it's something that people care about so you know my voice is starting to go a little bit so i think i might wrap things up there a little bit earlier than usual but just that's basically what i'm saying the question of can a bad rule book or complex rulebook kill your enjoyment of a game i think the answer is wholeheartedly yes you know people don't want to have to put that much effort to learning the game constantly over and over again because publishers should be making these games accessible to as many people as possible and they should be getting their rule books right they should be proof read they should be blind play tested they should be edited by a proper rules editor for language and everything they should really be putting more effort into the rule book than how fancy your miniature looks or whether you've made something out of bakelite or you know plastic acrylic or whatever it's like get your rule books done right first because that's the bit i am definitely going to be commenting on in all my reviews and it's definitely going to be one of those things where it gets marked heavily because you know your game can be the most beautiful most fun thing in the world but if your game is a chore to learn and a chore to play you have killed my enjoyment hands down so yeah be interested to know your thoughts do rule books kill the experience for you what's your example of the worst rule book you found i mean i people have asked me this this is like you know top 10 worst rule books i

wouldn't be able to remember top 10 worst rule books for me and as i say it's very subjective as to whether a rule book is that bad for you so i don't think that would work as a list but i've you know i've mentioned a couple there you know batman is obviously one of the worst rule books i've ever seen i don't tend to get along with the rule books for something like key flower and those key games richard breese because those rule books tend to be a little bit on the uh text heavy i really didn't like the rulebook for botoku uh but toku i thought was just laid out in a weird way with sidebars that contained specific rules you needed to know uh stroganoff had a weird rule in it that meant that you you know it was hidden off the side in a note box but it was quite essential to the game imperium's got a pretty terrible rule book so there's a lot of examples of bad rule books but i wouldn't be able to do a list of them but i'd be curious what's the worst rule book you've come across and i don't want to know the best rulebook because hopefully all games should have the best rulebook but what's the worst uh one you've come across let me know in the comments so that's it for me i'll see you on the next broken meeple video or podcast uh remember check out all the video content i'm releasing this week if you can please subscribe to the patreon failing that come and watch the top 10 live stream with me and so the playthroughs uh greg on tuesday evening gmt 7 pm because that's i think it's going to be a fun list i need to actually get round to drafting that list somewhat pronto but that's going to be pretty cool and of course i'll see what happens with regards to that c stand and if i can get it working i'm certainly going to need

to think of a decent camcorder for it and also the idea of that new if you like game x you're like this type segment you know so there's a lot of stuff on my mind all i got to do is just try not to be too deterred or bummed out by you know corporate board game industry stuff and popularity and you know where the more you talk positive about something the more publishers will be behind your back i mean you know i've seen gr i've seen some major stuff lately of like you know publishers like share content out because they're going oh they love this so much thank you thank you thank you yeah i bet you wouldn't be sharing it if it was an average review would you i bet you would not be sharing it if it had cons in it of course they wouldn't because it's bad for business but that's the way it is my channel is very consumer focused it's not corporate focused it's going to hurt me in some respects and i need to try and not let it get to me and just continue doing what i do which is enjoying talking about board games and focus more on the small creators front as well as as i said being more consumer focused at the end of the day because somebody's got you so i'll see on the next broken people video if you like what you see please consider thumbing up the video subscribing to the patreon if you can or subscribe to the channel and remember comment on what your worst rule book you have found is until next time you can check out more content on the channel including the recent review i did for perseverance go check out that mega review but you can also check out the top 10 six player games i did with mark month from nietzsche ninja geek games

from the last collaboration i did support small creators take care and remember as always everyone it's only a game bye for now love you all

Progress saved