Skip to main content
Loading video...

Top 10 RPGs To Play Instead Of Dungeons & Dragons

Transcript 15:11

unless you've been rolling a critical fail on your history checks for your entire life you've heard of dungeons and dragons whether it's via long-running youtube shows like critical role that's so bad it's bad jeremy irons movie or those mop haired twerps from stranger things d and d squats large in the tabletop rpg landscape like a dragon slumbering over its precious gold and i am duty bound to say the dnd is very good or else luke and laurie will bring their d d party around to my house and i don't know cast imaginary fireballs at me the dorks i'm kidding of course d d is wonderful an engine fueled by imagination social interaction and consequences a shining pillar of how compelling genuinely emotional and therapeutic gaming can be the only criticism i throw at it is that from the outside it might appear like the only game in town not so if you're looking for an alternative to d's fantasy setting it's not in considerable amount of rules complexity or simply a palette cleanser after washing goblin blood from your boots for the sixth time this month have a look at these and make a wallet saving throw with disadvantage i'm adam from no roles bard and here are our top 10 rpgs you should play instead of dungeons and dragons and while you're here why not subscribe to no rolls bard if you've seen our content and haven't subscribed first of all thank you for seeing our content but also if you do just click that button for free it does help us out a lot so why not go and do it expelliarmus is that d d ah it number ten ten candles could not do it at number ten could i lads though just based on personal preference i'd actually rank this much higher it is after all the only rpg i've ever run for other players so it's got a special place in

my heart so what is ten candles it's a survival horror rpg set in a dark world where the sun no longer shines and something is lurking in the shadows it's a one-shot system which means it creates stories designed to be finished in a single sitting so right there's a leg up on calendar consuming dnd campaigns it's also wonderfully simple all players sit around a circle of 10 candles hey that's the name of the game at the beginning all these candles are lit and are the only light in the room when players want to do something that requires skill or luck they roll a number of d6s equal to the number of currently lit candles a d6 is a die with six sides which most people know is default dice if even one of these dice is a six you succeed and get to tell the story of how you succeeded however if you fail your role if you get no sixes a candle is extinguished you lose a die and the dm tells you how you fail so as the game goes along it gets harder and harder and you fail more and more often as the shadows creep further and further in the light of hope literally fading until the last candle is blown out you're left in total darkness and everyone is dead horror gaming at its most atmospheric number nine fiasco anyone who's ever played d and d might think that every rpg requires a dm or a dungeon master not so and fiasco is a prime example of that another one-shot system like 10 candles fiasco markets itself as a coen brothers crime movie that you build yourself a collection of desperate crimson sleazy opportunists conjuring a scheme that will inevitably

collapse into betrayal bungling and death there are loads of scenarios to play one on a doomed spaceship the salem witch trials at the zoo each setting coming with a host of different relationships mcguffins and plot twists players sit in a circle roll dice to define their relationships with their two neighbors maybe my connection to the person on my right is where estranged siblings who want to get even with the city but my connection to the person on my left is that we're a pair of animal smugglers trying to pay off our debt to the zoo once everyone has a pair of relationships the game plays out as a series of improvised scenes plans and schemes mounting on top of each other until they fall apart it's super simple super fast paced with almost no rules admin after the setup and often drop dead hilarious number eight call of cthulhu back to horror games we go and one of the most recognizable brands in all of spooky dudes with outdated attitudes the cthulhu mythos where the big gods play there's loads of different call of cthulhu campaigns available from ones like masks of nihilathatep that can run for years or teeny two-handers that can be breezed through in a single session it's similar in dna to dnd exploring a game world most of the time investigating some spooky business you have lots of different skills and when you do something the dm tells you to roll dice based on one of these skills and then they'll narrate the consequences but it's got one real juicy mechanic sanity ah yes it's always sanity people just go mental for sanity mechanics in

lovecraft games whenever you encounter something in a call of cthulhu game that's spooky which by the way is all of the time you can lose sanity if you lose too much in a single game day your character can go temporarily insane the game gives you a randomly generated compulsion which then completely changes how you're role playing uh oh looks like you've seen too many spoops mckenzie's and now you want to start some fires how's this going to affect the investigation bad irex number seven alice is missing absolutely fascinating game this the elevator pitch is an rpg about finding a missing girl told entirely in silence entirely by a whatsapp life is strange meets twin peaks locked inside your phone like fiasco there's no dm rather a facilitator who runs the setup but then plays alongside you so you learn which version of alice you're looking for there's a bunch of different alices in the box take one of five available characters come up with a unique secret your character has a unique drive maybe you're the peacekeeper of the group for example and finally leave the room to record a voicemail that your character has left on alice's phone then 90 minutes starts using an official time of video the designers have put on youtube with a full and brilliant soundtrack and all players stop talking taking to their phones to uncover the mystery together in a group chat every 10 minutes clue cards will be revealed that draw the story closer and closer to its conclusion and sometimes sometimes it ends badly it could be pretty affecting stuff and the game provides a lot of support for its players letting them outline content they'd rather not role-play around

before the game even starts as well as providing an x-car to stop the game if it's getting too real because it can be a deeply moving game locked away from each other despite being in the same room trapped in your phones with only your suspicions your fears and the timer ticking down and down until you eventually find alice one way or another and then right at the end you play the voicemail you recorded for her at the start of the game what a genius concept number six fate at their simplest rpgs are games about telling a story the fate series of games are more than any other rpgs games about telling a movie and it does it by being completely open-ended most rpgs come armed with a setting for characters to explore fantasy spookum space fate gives you none of that players build a setting and characters from scratch with their dm with the help of aspects each setting and character are defined by aspects or traits and they can be anything you want there's a high concept which is a broad descriptor of your character like the last survivor of a once great house they must have a trouble aspect which is something that could complicate their story like framed for murder and on the run and then three other aspects which can be anything things they're good at a rivalry with another character a secret as long as and this is the rule book talking you don't make them boring that's fate's whole deal big action weird characters right now let's go want to do something say what is then roll four dice with pluses and minuses on them and add them together with something else which will tell you

if you've failed succeeded with a cast had a regular success or best of all succeeded with style which allows for some badass narration of how cool your character looks right now as is even more likely when you do something related to one of your aspects it's such a focused system makes you constantly put your character at the forefront of the story when everyone's pinging off each other it can make for something truly cinematic number five no thank you evil for this talk of stats conflict and cthulhu has led you to think that most rpgs are aimed solely adults then well yes you're right to be honest but there are some wonderful rpgs out there designed for kids to play with their families leading the pack is no thank you evil a game explicitly designed for kids the setup is ridiculously easy you define your character by saying blank is a blank who blanks maybe pat is a postman who can fly wheels calhoun is a car who is also a sheriff jeff bezos is a businessman who should stay in space stuff like that kids are encouraged to draw their character they can also come up with a companion and they'll start the game with stats in the following skills tough fast smart and best of all awesome they start with a certain amount of tokens in each they can spend to do fun stuff in the game the game is run by a guide aka the dm and appropriately no thank you evil is a fantastically simple system for people running games for the first time the game comes with a map of the land of storia divided into four different broadly thematic lands and those lands are based on the first choice players make which is

how do you leave your house want some traditional fantasy head into the closet and visit dragon snot falls or head under the bed to check out boo lagoon and other spooky places behind the bookshelf for more storybook locales or out the window for a more action movie type adventure it's utterly charming number four blades in the dark blades in the dark rules to simplify almost too much it's ocean's eleven meets dishonored sign me the up the world of the game is a criminal city called duskval a wretched hive of scum and villainy that's also sheltering behind a perimeter shield of lightning powered by demon blood because the sun broke and now the dark world is full of ghosts i have made none of that up sign me up more players role play as a member of a crew taking down scores to build their standing in the city characters like lurks the stealth bastards slides the smooth talking bastards or whispers the bastards who talk to ghosts because there are loads of ghosts and if all that isn't cool enough the game also has a flashback system that makes the scores work you know that bit in a heist movie where something goes wrong but it turns out to be all part of the plan all along blades in the dark has that if you run into trouble your character can trigger a flashback where you outline something that you did in the past which now helps you out of the pickle you find yourself in oh no this hulking bodyguard just chucked me off the roof thank god i bribed that stained mattress peddler to leave a bunch of stained mattresses on the street all part of the stinky plan number three

worldwide wrestling i mean we've got to mention it right for those of you who are new to the channel first of all hello aren't you lovely second this channel is partly founded by wrestling fans we have another channel called parts fun known and on that channel there's a series called cbw where we play a version of this rpg worldwide wrestling it's wonderful it uses a game engine called powered by the apocalypse which a lot of other games have used to dictate how stuff happens and how characters are connected games like monster of the week which is like x-files meets buffy monster hearts which is all about horny teenage monsters and of course worldwide wrestling all about a wrestling promotion and the lives of the wrestlers within create a wrestler from various types jobber monster hardcore high flyer cowabunga then whenever you want to do something hit a move cut promo play to the crowd you roll two six sided dice and then add or take away points based on your skills a final result of 10 or more means you do the thing seven to nine means you partially do it but there's a consequence six or less and you fail you build feuds with other players other people around the table can commentate on your matches you can build momentum by doing cool stuff which gives you chips you can cash in to improve your dice it's a robust system made with obvious love for the wrestling biz it's also profoundly and wonderfully stupid just like wrestling and also the second silliest game on this list but adam what's the silliest why that would be number two honey heist to be honest this entry is really more about an rpg designer called grant howard he's designed a whole bunch of super simple

rpgs with his gimmick being that the rules for each one take up only one side of a4 he does the lord's work he's made games like sexy battle wizards in which you are sexy battle wizards jason statham's big vacation which is exactly what it sounds like but best of all honey heist you are a bunch of bears you are planning a heist can i make it any more obvious every player chooses a type of criminal they are hack a driver muscle but also what type of bear polar bears are good at swimming black bears are good at climbing honey badges excel at checks notes carnage honey badger don't give a it just takes what it wants the dm sets up the heist by rolling for what you're stealing the opposition you're up against and what the second act twist will be and then off you go bears each bear has two stats criminal because they're criminals and bear because they're bears when you want to do a bear related thing roll one six sided die on your bear stat for all other things roll on criminal at the start of the game each player is equal parts criminal and bear however if things go bad you can lose a point in one stat and gain it in the other if you ever go full criminal you betray your own team if you ever go full bear you go completely feral and probably berserk because you're a bear rpgs don't have to come with thick bibles of law with hundreds of qualifications on which dice to roll when sometimes it's as simple as being bears and stealing a thing grant howard is brilliant and number one golden sky stories and now to end with something lovely golden sky stories is a japanese rpg set in a small japanese town in

which players play henggai magical animals that can take human form and literally the entire game is about using your animal powers to help the villagers overcome emotional problems think films like my neighbor totoro delightful after some of the stuff we talked about this might seem impossibly tame and hey play the type of game you want to play but give it a chance and golden sky wins you over entirely with its charms see there's a whole subset of japanese manga and anime called iashke which translates as healing which are just about people living their lives without too much bad stuff happening with the intended effect on the audience being a simple soothing experience there's an ash k show called after school dice club and it's about people playing board games and it's brilliant and golden sky stories is all about this calm you don't even roll dice in the game instead you spend wonder points to use animal powers these powers can be influencing other people's dreams like a cuddly inception you can calm people down fly you can spend feelings points to complete skill checks you can boost the number of these points you get each turn by increasing your friendship with each other or by awarding each other dream points for doing things that other players really liked yes it's twee yes of course it is but not everything has to be boom booms in conflict for the right group it might just be the most heartwarming game you've ever played and that's our list do you have an rpg that you really love tell us about it in the comments let's get a huge list of wonderful tabletop rpgs going and hey if you like this video share it around and subscribe to no rolls bard for more great board game content get on board

Progress saved