Skip to main content
Loading video...

Hall of Fame: Stratego, L'Attaque & the Big Four

Transcript 26:28

secret deployment grid-based movement bluffing and deduction memory and Capture the Flag despite this system being one of the most dominant throughout the 20th century it doesn't have a name Gamers have a shared language for the games they love deck builders area control roll them right no such jargon for this family of tactical grid-based military-themed games we could name the system after its most prominent iteration the Stratego mechanism in a similar manner to the way we describe certain dice games as using the Yahtzee mechanism but looks like an injustice since stratigo was far from the first and certainly not the most Innovative entry in the genre the gungeon mechanism feels more apt referencing the likely progenitor of the system but it's a totally unfamiliar reference for Western audiences perhaps we need a mechanical term but there are many ingredients in this particular recipe what's the standout feature secret deployment is Central to the gameplay but widely used in other war games and strategic board games which share few other features I'm on a bit of a loss deduction battle games deductive Jewel has a pleasing alliteration I'm Adam Porter I design games and I review them on this channel if you like what I do please subscribe comment and share the video in my game design Hall of Fame series I pick out games that I love which have undeniably proven themselves as Titans

in the industry Sushi go viticulture King Domino carcazon everdale and Stratego undoubtedly qualifies though it wasn't this iteration of the system that I first fell in love with some of my fondest gaming memories are of sitting down for lengthy sessions of Dover Patrol with my dad Dover Patrol was his childhood favorite and of course with Decades of practice he was unbeatable the core of the mechanism will be instantly familiar to fans of Stratego two players secretly line up their pieces on opposite sides of a grid you can see the value of your own Force but you don't know the value of your opponent's pieces which face away from you when two pieces meet back to back you can declare an attack and the values are revealed with the lowest scoring piece eliminated from the game the goal is to progress through the enemy ranks and capture their flag bag the origins of this iconic game system are unclear a German literary journal Monet's hefta described a Japanese war game known as gunjin Shoki or military chess in 1905.

the game was subsequently published in Finland in 1906 and described as having been invented during the recent Japanese war most likely the sino-japanese war of 1894 and enjoyed by soldiers and officers alike ganjin shogi is remarkably similar to later titles latak and Stratego with the most notable difference being the requirement for a third player to act as Arbiter declaring the outcome of any conflict without revealing the identity of the pieces patents were filed in 1907 in London by Julie Berg and 1909 in France by Herman's Eden it was Eden's version which achieved commercial success in Europe under the title latak however the origins of latak are disputed because Eden's state asserts that she invented the game in the 1880s which if accurate May predate the Japanese war game another variant boots and she or land battle chess is widely played across China and it has the trappings of an ancient game though it actually appears to be a relatively new invention having appeared somewhere around the mid-1900s Eden's latak was brought to the United Kingdom by Gibson's games in the 1920s and it attracted three direct sequels Dover Patrol Aviation and try tactics all apparently developed by Harry Gibson these games were marketed as Gibson's big four or War without tears Stratego first appeared in 1946 late to the party

by about half a century an almost identical to Herman's Eden's litak there were Dutchman Jacques Johann mogendorff claimed to be the Creator stratigo was licensed to some Heavy Hitters in the industry Milton Bradley Hasbro and jumbo which still retains the ownership of the brand in 2023 this Stratego branded version dominated the market in the west pushing through to become one of the most recognizable iconic board games of the last century many modern board games have utilized the core game system over the last few decades and of course there have been a wide variety of Stratego branded re-implementations including TV and film tie-ins simplified versions a complex historical simulation and a collectible version with variable unit abilities meanwhile in Japan gunjin shogi is still widely played with many different variants incorporating most of the various Evolutions that we've seen in the Gibson series and the Stratego range so variable boards variable abilities and variable Army distribution in China Lut sanchi is still a mainstream classic and the Philippines has its own beloved version too the game of generals very few modern board games have benefited from this degree of cross-pollination across continents older games like parchesi and backgammon perhaps but Stratego feels Fresher a stepping stone between traditional abstract games and

modern strategic titles so what is it about this system that makes it so engaging and does it hold up after over a century on the market well the one thing that deductive dual games achieve better than any other to my mind at least is the ability to lay traps for your opponent there are a few gaming moments as satisfying as convincing your opponent that your low-valued piece is actually a prize to be won guarding it and moving it across the grid with your opponent's piece in Pursuit only to reveal that they were chasing a decoy even better if you can manipulate them into attacking a mine eliminating one of their most powerful pieces because they thought they had located your commander or your flag the aspect of the game which feels a little more dated is the pacing the setup takes considerable time with players considering many options and for the first portion of the game the board is so cramped there's little that the players can do apart from carrying out arbitrary attacks to eliminate the front line and start to drive a wedge through the opposing Force it's in the mid game that the game becomes more tactical and deductive but you often have to grind a little bit before you get there the older games in the family don't adhere to one of the core tenets of modern game design the game should be fun from the very first turn that said I'm quite happy to give these older games a pass they were way ahead of their time and outclassed their competitors enormously latak was brought to the UK only a decade or so later than

snakes and ladders so let's get into the details what are the differences between latak and its more famous imitator stratigo well honestly there are very few meaningful differences the games feature playing pieces with similar names and abilities though the distribution is ever so slightly altered the attack uses a grid nine squares wide 10 squares deep and Stratego uses a slightly less cramped 10 by 10 grid though the two Central Lakes are larger than the Three Lakes featured in latak in some editions the ranking is reversed so that the lower numbers beat the higher numbers and that's about it for the differences everything else is identical the highest powered piece the commander defeats all others except for the lowest powered piece the Spy which can defeat the commander the eight Scouts value two can move any distance in an uninterrupted straight line and a frequently sacrificed to reveal the value of an opponent's piece mines remain static after initial deployment and defeat any piece which attacks them except for the sappers valued three which are the only piece that can eliminate a mine a the game is won when one player attacks their opponent's flag one substantial change in latak from the earlier gunjin shogi is the requirement to reveal the two pieces involved in a battle in the Japanese game and later Eastern adaptations a third player acts as Arbiter checking the pieces involved in a battle and declaring the winner but

taking no other part in gameplay hence neither winner or loser learns the identity of the opposing piece so they can progressively deduce the value of the opposing pieces based on the outcome of successive conflicts was reworked in 1996 by Roger Hayworth and packaged as a tie-in for a popular British TV series sharp starring Sean Bean Sharp's attack uses a larger board with a central River with more Crossing points than the earlier game the spy and Scout abilities are remixed in this later game the special agent is similar to the tax spy except that instead of only defeating the commander it defeats the highest valued piece in play so if the 10 has already been defeated by a mine here called a readout or by another Commander the special agent can now defeat the 9 8 7 and so on depending on which pieces remain on the board in Sharp's attack it's the special agent which can move any number of spaces not the scouts leaving the highest valued pieces vulnerable to a sudden attack from a distance in Sharp's attack the scouts valued two are not defeated when they attack a higher valued piece they are however defeated if they attack an equivalent piece or if they're attacked by a higher value piece themselves they don't benefit from the ability to move long distances as in the earlier game since that ability has transferred to the special agent but we're way ahead of ourselves Sharp's attack is actually the fifth latex sequel from Gibson's games the aforementioned Dover Patrol was the

first direct sequel published around the same time it's a game of comparable Simplicity to latak with a slightly larger board with no inaccessible spaces there is however a harbor wall which you cannot move through limiting access to the base where each player's flag is located and the goal of the game is not just to capture the enemy flag but also to carry it back to your own base and once collected it can be passed between adjacent playing pieces if a piece is defeated while carrying the flag the attacker takes control of the flag and to win the game you must have both flags on your own base this of course results in a longer game than the attack but the rulebook does list four short variant goals the basic rules are the same as the attack movements are orthogonal never diagonal and attacks are optional in Dover Patrol the mines activate as soon as you move alongside them as opposed to the attack where they only activate if they're attacked mine sweepers act like the sappers of the earlier game these are the only pieces which can defeat a mine mine layers are floating mines they can move but never attack they can only be sunk by a destroyer which is valued for submarines are similar to The commanders from the attack in that they defeat all pieces except for the low-valued motor torpedo boats which defeat them the flying boat is unaffected by mines and it can ignore the harbor wall as such it's largely used to capture the flag which sits on the base behind the wall the flying boat

can jump over a mine moving two spaces but in doing so it reveals its identity the second sequel Aviation released in 1925 live and sometimes labeled Battle of Britain is a step up in complexity from the attack and over Patrol the board in aviation is the same size as that used for Dover Patrol but there are two additional pieces per player each side of the board features two Aerodrome spaces and the goal is to land a Troop Carrier in your opponent's Aerodrome to win the game in most circumstances troop carriers cannot be eliminated if they're defeated in a battle they're simply returned to the owner's Aerodrome troop carriers are unusual in that they're the only pieces which are allowed to move diagonally anti-aircraft guns function like mines in latak except that they can move rather like the mine layers in Dover Patrol they are however limited to moving within their own half of the board an anti-aircraft guns are primarily used in conjunction with searchlights now when a Searchlight Attacks An opposing piece and there's a gun within range it can shoot the opposing piece down and the guns have ranges of three four or five spaces is and the spaces between them and the target must not be obstructed so this is the first example of a line of sight mechanism that I'm aware of predating any other games listed as featuring line of sight on the board game geek database by almost two decades but I'm not a war game historian so I can't vouch for the accuracy of the BGG database

searchlights can only be destroyed by reconnaissance planes and observation balloons function like static searchlights and can be destroyed by reconnaissance planes and bombers with Aviation the system has become complex enough that it's pretty tough to memorize the different interactions between the playing pieces but the system is about to get more complex still 1925 also saw the release of a third sequel try tactics an amalgamation of latak Dover Patrol and Aviation featuring land sea and air units the board is now considerably larger featuring a 12 by 12 grid with a substantial portion representing the sea rivers and lakes and each player having 56 pieces compared to 36 in the TAC 40 in Dover Patrol and 42 in aviation the aim of the game is to either move infantry onto the opponent's headquarters or move a ship onto their Naval Base infantry and Naval units are not restricted to moving over land and sea any piece could move anywhere but a piece attacked when moving out of its element for example a ship moving across land will automatically be defeated a ship can only move on to an opponent's Naval Base by moving down the river and whilst on the river a ship can defeat any land piece with the exception of heavy artillery searchlights function like an attack Scouts in that they can move any distance in a straight line and while they can reveal the identity of the other pieces they never defeat them at this point the system of interactions

is really complex and it requires a table to check the outcome of Any Given encounter and even this doesn't give the ultimate answer because some outcomes are altered depending on whether the attacking pieces are on land or at sea or attacking across the coastline or from the river the fourth sequel by Gibson's games the fantasy themed swords and Wizardry came 55 years later the goal of the game is to reveal your opponent's princess who starts on one of the castles in their side of the board but the question is which one in this game when you win an attack your pieces moved into the space vacated by the defeated piece however this doesn't happen if you survive a conflict as defender or if you attack with a Siege catapult in swords and Wizardry the pieces are not numbered as in try tactics an attack table is consulted to determine the outcome of any conflict the king is strong against humans but it's weak against Monsters the hero is strong against Monsters but overcome by military forces The Peasants are the least powerful pieces but as in most of these games they're able to defeat some of the most powerful pieces the king and the hero the princess is unable to attack and will be rescued if attacked by any piece except peasants or monsters and the dragon can jump over a piece obstructing its way and it can fly over the lake the ogre is the least powerful monster piece but its value is enhanced while in a forest and The Siege catapult can be used in two ways it can attack the piece directly in front of IT consulting the attack table or attack a

piece two spaces in front of it revealing the piece but never defeating it if a Siege catapult attacks a piece on a castle the defender is always eliminated unless that piece is the princess pieces on the castle can otherwise only be defeated if the opponent completely surrounds the castle with their own pieces in this game the wizard is awarded the ability of latex scouts or Sharps attacks special agents in that it can move any distance conflicts with Wizards are resolved with the role of a die on a five or a six the wizard defeats any piece a three or a four defeats all non-monster pieces a two defeats peasants and a one results in the Wizard being eliminated if two wizards are in Conflict the highest roller wins now with all these interactions the game becomes difficult to learn and it's not surprising that the simplest of the family Stratego has become the Evergreen title in the series after exploring all the various sequels Stratego and its near identical twin will attack feel beautifully streamlined but there does exist an even more streamlined adaptation released in the same year as swords of Wizardry the generals does away with conflict tables and it doesn't require a third player as Arbiter the grid is smaller eight by nine and each player has only 21 pieces 15 less than in the attack the game has two different win conditions either capture your opponent's flag or move your own flag to your opponent's back row the generals is similar to Stratego

in that it features a numeric ranking system with the lowest ranked piece the private able to defeat the most powerful piece the agent the generals however doesn't feature any other special pieces no pieces can move more than a single space there are no Minds no sappers and the flag can be moved freely attacks are made by moving into the opponent's space from any direction front back or side to side when you attack you mark the space being competed over with an attack marker then both battling pieces are removed and pressed onto an electronic Arbiter to find out the results of the conflict the identities are not revealed and the winner is positioned in the marked space the fact that the values remain hidden even after a battle is resolved as with the early Asian Games in the genre increases the deductive element of the game system in winning or losing a battle the player has gained some information about their opponent's piece what it might be but they can't be sure the generals is developed from safronio H pastler's 1972 design the game of generals the dominant example of the deductive dual family in the Philippines and inevitably stratigo had its own electronic implementation just two years later using a system remarkably similar to the generals one final classic title worthy of discussion is lutsan chi or Chinese Land Battle chess of Unknown Origin but probably arising in the

mid-20th century this game has undoubtedly been stirred into the mix somewhere along the way contributing to the cross-pollination and evolution of the genre and it has some fascinating twists on the western games most notably in the manner in which the different grid locations are open up new strategic opportunities for the players now you'll notice that I've marked the pieces to make it easier to play in Land Battle chess pieces can move up down left or right as in the other games that I've described but certain spaces allow you to move diagonally and if you're positioned on a circular campsite you cannot be attacked and a railroad surrounds the outside of the board along which pieces can move as far as they wish so long as their progress is unobstructed and without going around a corner only the engineers can break this Rule and travel around corners each player's flag is positioned on one of their two headquarters at the start of the game and the goal is to locate and attack the flag belonging to your opponent in one variant rule set if your commander is defeated you must reveal the location of your flag to the other player the game features static Minds which can only be defeated by engineers and grenades and movable pieces which defeat all other pieces but they are themselves dominated in the process so they're often moved on to the campsites where they can remain undetonated until they're needed in another variant if you attack the wrong headquarters the one without the flag your pieces forced to remain on that space and the intention

is that the game should involve a third player who determines the outcome of the conflicts for where this isn't possible players do frequently play without an Arbiter revealing their pieces after a conflict in a similar manner to Stratego some even prefer to play with all pieces revealed from the outset transforming the game into a perfect information strategy game like chess there's a popular four player version available where players form teams sitting opposite each other and work together to capture both of the opposing team's Flags stratigo has also experimented with four-player editions the most recent being Stratego conquest by Jim and Lucy Kiefer and Nick Hayes the first notable thing about Conquest is the cleverly engineered game pieces designed such that they can only be seen straight on and they aren't easily viewed from the side unlike other games in this video Conquest doesn't use a grid instead players select their starting positions on a disordered map into an order on your turn you can move one unit to an adjacent Zone if it contains an enemy unit a battle occurs these are resolved in the conventional manner the lowest rank the Spy Master can defeat the highest rank the king mines are called cursed lands and function in the usual way and the Sorceress is the equivalent of the sapper the only piece which can defeat a cursed land and Scouts value 2 can move across any number of unoccupied zones you can move one additional piece on your turn per City Zone that you occupy and if if you're the only player

in a territory you take the corresponding territory token to indicate that it's under your control and the number of territories you controlled halved determines the number of action cards that you can draw on your turn you select one of these to play and discard the rest and these cards have a variety of effects allowing you to bring a random unit onto the board or swap the locations of existing units look at opponents units or take additional moves when your flag has been captured you continue to play and you're able to regain your flag by capturing the flag of the opponent who previously captured yours the goal is to be the last player remaining with an uncaptured flag there are several modern games which don't carry the Stratego branding but utilize very similar mechanisms in Shadows in Kyoto when you attack Only The Defenders pieces revealed win or lose the attacker's piece remains hidden the goal is to capture both your opponent's pieces with a red dot indicating that they carry secret intelligence but you also so win if your opponent captures three of your four pieces without a DOT or if you manage to move one of your red dotted pieces to the opposite end of the board moves are determined by playing cards from a hand of locations and tactics allowing you to swap positions of your pawns move long distances or push back opposing pieces and the advanced game features asymmetric powers and a catch-up mechanism whereby you gain a special one-off ability whenever one of your important pieces is captured shadows and Kyoto is a much quicker game

than most in the genre adopting the same approach as other modern iterations fewer pieces and card driven turns there are opportunities here for a degree of bluffing and some nice combos to pull off with the tactics cards but it does feel insubstantial when compared to the weightier early games in the genre there are a few other modern games which I'd love to try but I haven't yet had a chance in kanitzia's Lord of the Rings the confrontation the two armies are entirely asymmetric with unique abilities on each piece for example many of the fellowship pieces have the ability to retreat from a battle additional cards can be played to determine the amount outcome of conflicts including cards which boost the strength value of a piece the end game conditions are asymmetric too the fellowship wins if Frodo enters Mordor the Sauron player wins if three of his pieces are in the Shire or if Frodo is defeated in the card game thunder and lightning previously known as hero and Zeus players play cards into rows and columns to bring them into conflict with their opponents when a card is eliminated all other cards in the column are move forward to fill the Gap in volto each playing piece can move in a different way like chess but the identities of the pieces are hidden so if you identify and capture your opponent's king piece here called the candidate you win but you also win if you manipulate your opponent into inadvertently capturing both your ladies in tactiki you can move your playing pieces such that they stack on top of each other and where such a column

enters into a conflict the uppermost piece battles first and then the next level of the column and so on until one player's column is entirely eliminated confusion Espionage and deception in the Cold War pulls a Hanabi well since this is an Adam in Wales video pulls a picoko and flips the mechanism on its head in this game you can see the movement capabilities of your opponent's pieces but you can't see the abilities of your own you have to deduce these as you play despite the massive number of variations on this core mechanism as the most prominent iteration it's Stratego that sits in my game design Hall of Fame as a placeholder for The Wider family of deductive dual games are there any other hidden gems in the genre which I haven't considered but I really ought to try let me know in the comments and if you enjoyed this video you might like my deep dive into the world of abstract strategy games or perhaps you'd like to see a similar exploration of the Carcassonne game system featuring many of its sequels and variants follow the links

Progress saved