Skip to main content
Loading video...

Rate My Shelf - Keep or Cull - Board Games - Episode I

Transcript 17:06

thank you hi everyone I'm Luke Hector and you're watching the broken meeple this is a YouTube channel about board games where I give reviews top tens and my honest opinions regardless of the consequences so I'm trying something a little bit different on the channel a little bit of alternative content for you you may remember back in lockdown around 2020 I did this massive series called uh oh I think it was called uh rate your shelf or all by myself or something and basically I went through every single shelf in my collection here are the room and downstairs and basically in fact I didn't even think I had the downstairs Shelf at that point it shows how much the collection has grown but I went through each one and basically talked about the games and it was a very quick series I did one a day for the entirety of a month it damn near killed me to do it it was hard to keep up that momentum but hey we were in lockdown it was covid it's not like I could do much else so I wanted to try something similar to that but I don't want to do that whole one a day thing because that will legitimately kill me if I try it now so I figured what I'll do is I'll go through each shelf in my collection through this series as time goes on you know not like in a short while you know just space it out and what I'll do is I'll talk about the games that are on that shelf but also give an opinion as to whether these games are going to be key Keepers I I'm gonna keep them until at the end of time at this rate or if they're potentially Cults and when I say Carl's I don't mean I'm going to sell it off the next day you know because the stuff that's in my collection is kind of here to stay for the most part but I am in a situation where I'm now in a kind of one in one

out uh you know affair with my games that if a big game comes in it's going to take up space on the Shelf something else has to give because I need to make room for it and I have no intention of buying more shelves so it's not that the game's gonna get sold but it means that it's at risk of being sold like this is a game that could get replaced if I find something that will do a similar thing take a similar box scratch a certain itch but do it better it varies from moment to moment so without further Ado let's take on with the first shelf this is downstairs top left corner and this is very much a days of Wonder theme shelf and this is kind of something I do with my shelves they're kind of organized 90 by publisher uh with a few times they're scattered around but mostly I try to keep publishers in the similar area so this is a days of Wonder Shelf with four games that I have had here most of which for a very long time most are quite a few years since their releases but one brand new one so why don't we try that one first because that's pretty easy going heat uh yeah you've been living in the cave if you have not heard of this game by now this has been hyped up like crazy it's been buzzed about it's been getting great reviews and to be fair I'm one of them I was very skeptical about this getting loads of really high reviews I reviewed it played it and at first I wasn't bowled over by it I thought like this is decent but where is this hype coming from the game takes a bit long with a lot of players and it still does it is kind of a floor of the game but I did after more plays started to see oh yeah I like these new modules you can throw in and it is a nice simple game and the

solo mode in this is fantastic very easy to control AI cars which means you can always play a six player game of this even if you don't have six people and frankly I'd rather play this myself with five AI cars than then play with six actual human players if it's human players I'd like to cap it at four really and use two AI cars because it only takes that one person who's a bit slow on the uptake in order to get this game and to be honest it's not like it's a complicated game but that heat mechanic of putting the cards in your engine and taking them out again seems to trip up a few new Gamers but this is still a really cool vincenter traits gorgeous artwork all the you know two boards all the pieces a nice insert all the cards are sleeved it's just a fantastic production for what you get and it's one of the best racing games out there I mean it deserves a lot of the awards it gets although not all of them you want to check out where I think it drops the ball go check out my recent podcast episode with the golden geek Awards where this apparently won the most thematic game and everybody's okay with this did I miss something no way was this supposed to be the most romantic game when there was stuff like frostpunk and oath sworn and various other ones in the running it's like how that doesn't make any sense but I digress but he really cool game only got it at the end of last year this one's a keeper for me it's a keeper it's gonna stick around this is definitely filling a hole with you know racing games where I need a nice Gateway level racing game I've already got snow tails and I've got downforce although downforce is more about the betting aspect although I

still like the racing part and snow Tales is you know just a different style of racing game and I've still got flan Rouge although hard to tell if flam Rouge will stay the test of time with this in the collection but I have to say but this is definitely a keeper all right so let's move on to Cleopatra and the Society of Architects now this is a pretty oldish game and it had a new version I think mojito Studios tried this big one and I did get it on Kickstarter and sold it because it just wasn't a very good production from the hype like the not the height the the price it was asking for it was crazy it asked for it had all these massive plastic pieces I had this giant box the artwork was decent enough and it was a decent Deluxe production but it was just too much it made it fiddly the setup it made it a chore to get that out of the box it was you know Mass table presence and I just kind of thought not a big fan and some of the rules tweaks I was kind of like not sure if I'm a fan of these either so it just didn't quite work for me it was disappointing and I thought you know what this version I think was better than it so I kept this version however I've not played this in a very long time because as much as the game is simple you're basically just getting cards and resources and it's a bit like the canopy game where you've got the different Columns of cards some are face up Summer face down and you choose which column you want and there may be good cards in it there may be bad cards in it but you gotta decide which ones you want the main thing that really draws me to this though is not the plastic pieces it's the corruption mechanic you play certain cards and if they're more powerful they get you corruption it's

secrets and a little pyramid you can try and get rid of it during the game but at the end of the game Whoever has the most corruption is fed to the crocodiles and they don't score their points I love games that do this High Society is another great example the auction game if you spent the most money you lose and the next player wins that mechanic is just something I adore it's a great it's a great little hidden thing that might just trip some players up at the end of the game and it adds a nice bit of tension brilliant as long as everybody knows it's a thing this one however has not been played for a while mainly because it is still a bit of a chore to set up I mean for a game that's got really easy rules I've got to deal with these paper pyramids I've got these all these cards and you know the insert is not bad I mean there's the tray there but then I've got to deal with this multi-part board and these plastic pieces and this like covering layer is a nightmare to get back in the Box because these Mosaic pieces don't stay where they're meant to be you have to line up these plastic pieces ideally like in exactly the right order and it just makes it a pain but I do like the game it is nice and simple but I have not got it to the table in a long time because of that setup and put down chore and that's a big deal for games for me it's it's good fun and I do stand by that I think this is the better version compared to the new one the and the another factor is is that if I did sell this one there's no way I'd ever get it again because it was hard enough trying to find a copy of this when it was at a print trying to get it now pretty much impossible however that being said I think this one is a potential car it's a

potential car you know and not to say that I want to sell it anytime soon but you know if I'm not going to get it played is there a reason for me to have it and set up and take down is a problem that is something I really want to try and curb from a lot of games I've got so it's solid I do really enjoy it but it is a potential cold part although probably lower down on the coal pile like you know something's gonna have to come out to be similar to this before I really want to get rid of it I think other games will go before this one but to say it's a keeper for life um I'm not sure about that one dear Patrick and the Society of Architects wish it was just called Cleopatra frankly alrighty let's look at a look at five tribes five tribes is a great uh Mancala mechanic game so you have these uh squares on on the like in a grid and your idea with this in fact it's I've even pinned mine up because not only does it have the two expansions in it Sultans and the color it's also got oh yes five tribes folded space in sir because folded space inserts for the win frankly this is basically the inserts I live by everything in a nice you know convenient boxes like that that just allow for Speedy setup and this one's a very nice simple insert but you've essentially check out these grids with the meatballs on it and you're putting these colored meeples down in order to trigger their various abilities depending what color there are so the board is just littered and I've got a special back brick here I don't know where I got this from I think I got this from a random artscow.com promotion they were doing in

America but yep all these meeples all over the place this thing is a colorful joy to behold on the board it's a really cool puzzle and very very enjoyable and I have yet to try out the solo mode I've heard for this I don't know if I've got it in the Box I don't think I do but there's a solo mode for this and I've still yet to try it let me know in the comments if you've tried it you can give me some insight with this one the problem is getting it to the table because the expansions do add a bit of complexity to it and as much as I love The Sultans one in particular a complexity doesn't help for teaching new players the other problem is time length this is a game which at two players which is another count I get games to the table with very often is fantastic this is two players is brilliant but it free and for its diminishing returns because the chaos Factory what's on that grid gets problematic but also the downtime gets ridiculous because if you get anybody remotely AP in this game the game just grinds to Halt constantly as you're waiting for them to concentrate go well I could do that and that would do that and that would get me these oh but I'm not doing that all right well I could do this and that would get me that you know where they basically are a combination of the sloth from zootopia and Rado and when you get that as a combination in this game oh God it hurts yeah so playing this with four is not something I want to do three is acceptable two is brilliant but then I don't get twos to the table so unless that solo mode is really good free is kind of the way I want to play it but I did play this two-player um uh did I do it last year I think last year I did yeah I played a two player at a bacon

and had a really good time a really good solid two player game a new friend of mine has five tribes and really enjoys it as well so I can play it with her if need be you know so it's it's really a sound game and probably one that I think is still a keeper because it's it is just great find that man color puzzle is really engaging and really cool and makes some really good decisions with those Genies as well the Gins you know those are the special powers I love grabbing a bunch of to them the expansions you get another try The Sultans add little objectives you can complete all really good but man playing this with a lot of players it's a tough one but there isn't really any other game that does this as well as this does you know because the rules themselves aren't necessarily complicated it's just the amount of decisions and options you have that trips up of other people so it's really probably one of the heaviest games that days of Wonder have done and kudos to them they stepped outside of their comfort zone and they did a sound job it's a keeper for me all right now on a similar vein lastly yamatai yamatai is a game that is severely underrated not a lot of people give this one props despite the fact that the cover is one of the most gorgeous covers I've ever seen in my life you good looking hot okay yes art doesn't necessarily make the game great what does make this game great though is the fact that this has probably easier rules than five tribes in order to teach it it's still like as colorful as all get out because the board is just absolute like absolutely gorgeous board

but also we've got blimey ah this one's clearly been set on its side a bit this doesn't have an insert the pieces are everywhere oh this is a disaster but I'll sort this out later but you've got these really cool character tiles that you can grab with special abilities everybody's got their own you know different you know all this like colored wooden boats that you sail around you've got these giant pieces for palaces and that when this gets going on the table it is just Beauty personified is lovely but essentially with this one is that you are sailing these boats around the islands and as you envelop the islands you're putting buildings down on the islands and triggering powers and getting points so it's very mechanical the theme is pretty much not there I mean why are you sailing like different multi-colored boats on it it's another color puzzle much like five tribes which also means much like five tribes colorblind people stay away because both of these games do not work with colorblind people but it's again a very nice simple game I mean this is the rule book the rule book is literally they're set up there's two pages there's third page and game end that's all the rules there is and yeah there's some good decisions there's a lot of cool bonuses there's a little bit of interaction because you are well indirect interaction where people are sort of getting in each other's way or licking stuff on the islands before they can but I love the fact that you've got all these different characters that you can use so you know you can grab you know these to help you on they're worth points as well but I mean you can double value if you'll press these tokens when

opponents do this you can take some of their stuff you can perform more transactions but the other thing I really like with this I wonder if I can find an example is these you've got a turn order sequence where the these tiles come out and they're in different orders as the game goes on but they give you an initiative order but they also give you a like a really cool bonus for the turret the more the higher the initiative which means you're going later and around the better the bonus so you've got to make this cool decision every term with do I want to go first before another player and but then am I willing to take or do I want a really cool bonus you know and that is just a really nice mechanic again I would like to see this kind of initiative bonus system been used in more Euro games but nobody talks about this nobody it's like just died a painful death you know you can't get it anymore I'm not even sure if it's on retail anymore but this is really cool and on par for me with five tries I think I would give the slight Edge to five tribes but this is still one that I think is great and it's from Bruno cafala as well it's the same great designer doing both games but nobody ever really talks about this one this one for me is a keeper I still you know I really need to get to this to the table again actually I haven't played this in a long time and that's probably going to a recurring thing with my collection because when you've got 250 old games you can't exactly play them all the time but this is one where I whenever I look at it I go man I'd like to get this out again and it works with more players better than five tribes does because yeah you get a little bit of down time at times but this one goes at a quicker Pace than five tribes does

when you have the four players in it so this one caters for multiplayer better so this one probably gets more plays than five tribes does and it has that Advantage but yeah it's beautiful it's great it's got great little decisions and the rule set is simple part of me really wants to learn this and get it to the table again maybe I've got time to do that before handycon this weekend we shall see but yeah it's a keeper for me so there you go four games on my first shelf you know you can see that three of them are definitely gonna stick around for a while one of them might be in danger of getting replaced but again like I said these are not right I'm gonna call it then everybody start saying can I buy off you that's not the case this is just to say that if new games come in and I need to space these are the ones that could be in danger of being replaced Cleopatra in the society architect might sit on my shelf for a long time to come but I gotta be able to say right if this game comes in and it's good enough can I replace this game because I'm looking around at my shelf and I can see a few examples where that would certainly be the case but you'll have to look at more episodes to come to find out more so that's it for me on this episode of the broken people if you like what you see then please thumb up this video on YouTube but also let me know your comments about any of these games what your thoughts on five tribes yamatai heat and Cleopatra you know good and bad I'd like to know what you have to say particularly with the five tribe solo mode somebody give me a heads up on that one but until next time you can check out more content on the channel including the recent review I did for revive big hyped up Euro game did they deserve all that hype you'll have to

watch the review to find out but until next time remember regardless of whether you want to keep or call any of your games they're still only games take care and bye for now foreign

Progress saved