Skip to main content
Loading video...

I Love Board Games That Make Me MAD

Transcript 32:13

Guys, I have a terrible confession to make. A while back, I bought a board game with a reputation for ending real friendships. Not just a quaint Sunday morning and coral actually ended friendships. People refusing to speak to each other for years. Christmas gifts never sent. Weddings never attended. The game was the unceremonial start of a generational blood feud. My reaction when I read about this, yeah, I should probably own that game. And look, I'm not talking about acting mad. I'm talking about feeling mad. There's a massive difference between the two, which we'll come back to later, because this is my concern. A lot of people treat the feeling of being mad in games like this shameful thing, like if you feel it, you're being a sore loser or taking things way too seriously. You'll hear, "Relax is just a game." And I think that's backwards. When a game can explore and create uncomfortable emotions, whether intentionally or not, that's an excellent sign. It means the game broke through my emotional barrier and made me care about these little meeples and tokens. It's a sign that the design is impactful. So, today I want to discuss a few games that should be avoided in anger management class. Games that make you feel things you probably shouldn't feel about cardboard. And somehow I'm going to convince you this is all a perfectly reasonable way to spend a Friday night. Let's start off with the classic diplomacy. The betrayal mad. Diplomacy is infamous for a reason.

There are documented cases of people refusing to speak to each other for years after a single game. It's like if Risk and a divorce lawyer had a baby, and that baby only smiles when someone else starts to cry. The setup is clear. It's from 1901. Europe is about to explode into World War I, and you're controlling one of the seven great powers. Your goal is simple. Capture 18 supply centers and dominate Europe, but you just can't conquer Europe alone. The game is designed so you need allies to make any significant progress. It's mandatory to coordinate with other players, to form tres, to plan joint attacks by supporting one another. Otherwise, you're going to sit in a corner of the map, sad and lonely. But diplomacy doesn't only force cooperation. It forces betrayal. Because diplomacy has no dice, no cards, no luck, no hidden information. It's just seven players writing down commands in secret, then acting on those orders simultaneously. Which means the most effective way to gain an advantage is often to deceive.

Picture this. It's 11:30 p.m. on a Friday night. You've been at this table for six stressful hours. You're playing as Austria Hungary and you formed a pack of non-aggression with the Russian player. Over the many hours, this pact has blossomed into a true alliance with passing notes and hushed whispers. Together, you've been systematically dismantling the Turkish and German coalition. You've been at this so long that someone ordered pizza 2 hours ago and Russia paid for your slice. You owe them $4 and your complete loyalty. Now Turkey has been nearly eliminated by your joint efforts. And now your pieces are perfectly positioned. One more coordinated push and the second oppositional army of Germany will fall.

And then you can split your supply centers with your best friend right down the middle. You can see victory foreman. Then you submit your orders for fall 1909. The moderator reads them aloud. Everything is going smoothly and as expected until it's Russia's turn. Russia moves all of their troops into your territories instead of Germany's. There's like two seconds where your brain hasn't fully caught up yet. Then you see it. They've been planning this the whole time for that perfect coordinated backstab. Those past three turns where you thought you were working together. They were setting up for this one single moment. Those whispered conversations from 2 hours ago suggesting that you move your armies out of your main territories. It left Budapest, Romania, and Vienna completely clear for the taken. It's been planned this entire game. And while you were bragging about how great your partnership was, they were counting the territories and sharpening the knife.

That feeling you get in that moment. That's what I'm talking about. That's not frustration with bad luck. It's not confusion about unclear rules. That's a legitimate betrayal of trust. You're mad. That attack was personal. It was calculated. It was premeditated and it took all of those moments of shared joy and trust and then it was abandoned. And the truth is, you can't even be mad at the game. The game didn't betray you. They did. Your friend sitting across the table who looked at you in the eye and promised to work together. That's what makes it powerful. Diplomacy's simple mechanics become secondary to the human drama. You're not really playing a board game. You're playing a people game. And people are deeply flawed. Now, I love this. I love the rush of realizing that I've been played. I love the sick feeling in my stomach when I see their moves and I understand what they've done because that feeling means I was invested. I believed them. I trusted them. The game created this social contract between myself and them. And then it was shattered. But, and this is absolutely crucial, I only love this because I knew what I was signing up for. Diplomacy isn't a game you spring on people. It's a game you forewarned them about. Everyone at the table needs to understand that betrayal isn't an optional mechanic. To betray is to play.

It's the core mechanism. And if you sit down to play Diplomacy and suddenly you're shocked that someone lied to you, that's a failure of communication before the game even began. The game outwardly advertises that this would happen. It's on the box, not a game of kindness, sweeties, and happy Labradors. And that's really the first key into loving these kinds of games. The games that make you mad require a mutual understanding. Everyone needs to agree to this emotional experience. You don't surprise someone with diplomacy at your cousin's baby shower and then wonder why they're weird around you for the next month. Now, someone might say, "Yeah, I'm cool with backstabbing." And then discover Midame that having their spouse lie directly in front of them might not be all that fun. I don't really think it's a fault of the player. You really genuinely can't tell how you'll always feel about something until you're in it.

But at the same time, betraying someone in Diplomacy isn't a moral failing either. It's not being mean or fulfilling a vendetta. A wellexecuted betrayal is just fulfilling the game's designed premise. So, there's a real tension here. The game is both pretend but also intense. The emotions are real, even if the stakes are fake. And sometimes those real emotions spill over in ways nobody could expect. So what about the optimistic scenario when everyone is on board to lie and backstab? That feeling of mad becomes this incredible shared experience. You get stabbed in the back. You feel that anger and then after the game you can laugh about it. There's a sense of humor in all of it. Those feelings of mad become part of a grander story and that story is really what you remember the game wants. social bonds to be created and then sundered. And this unique feeling is something that can be experienced and positively explored through the game. I've had games of diplomacy where I lost, where I got completely obliterated. And they're still great experiences because the journey of that loss was intense. I cared, I strategized, I trusted, I got burnt. But yet, here's another hot take.

I actually don't think diplomacy is a very good game. A game of diplomacy is at minimum 4 hours, but more like 8 to 12. That's longer than it takes to fly to Europe. It's an immense investment of time and mental energy. Then you add on player elimination and the endless feeling of circle in the drain when you're on your back foot. The game just isn't up to modern standards of smoothness and mechanical satisfaction. So why even play it? Because as a game, it is flawed. But as a vehicle for this very specific feeling of betrayal mad for generating pure personal vendettas, it's nearly perfect. It's almost unmatched. The game's flaws, in truth, amplify the experience. That long play time forces you to invest in those alliances, and the player elimination just adds to the punishment. The knife in your back feels that much sharper when you've spent 6 hours building a relationship only to spend the next two hours watching your former ally win with your land. To me, Diplomacy is a very messy game. It's often tedious. It's player elimination sucks. The gameplay is just kind of boring, but it's the perfect betrayal simulator. And sometimes being perfect at one thing makes for a much more interesting experience than trying to be good at everything. Now, diplomacy's form of mad is fundamentally social. It lives in the space between players and above the board. It's within the promises and the deceit that's behind those. But there's

other flavors of MAD that I want to explore. Let's take a look at one that's less about reading people and more about reading the game itself. Pax Premiere, the outplayed MAD. Pax Premiere is a game about 19th century Afghanistan during the Great Game. It's a period of time where the British and Russian empires were fighting for control of Central Asia. But you're not playing as the empires. You're playing as Afghan leaders trying to survive this conflict. And the genius of Pax Premiere is that your loyalty is flexible. At the start of the game, you might be supporting the British, playing cards that help the British faction position your pieces to benefit British control, but then Midame with the help of a loyal patriot or by capturing a prize, you can switch.

flipped to being a part of the Afghan coalition or the Russians whenever it works in your favor. Now, this isn't betrayal like in diplomacy. In diplomacy, you're reading people trying to figure out who's lying to you, who you can trust. The wrinkles in diplomacy come from one another. This is in contrast to PAX Premiere. You're reading the board state just as much as you're reading the intentions of your rivals. You're analyzing positions, counting armies, counting tribes, calculating when to shift loyalty, but it's less about social deception, and more about strategic ingenuity. Everyone can see the board. Everyone can see each other's courts, and all the cards that can be bought in the market. Even the cards in players hands can be public information if your group decides to allow for that.

So then the real question is, who sees everything best? And this is where the mad comes in. Imagine with me, you've spent 45 minutes building up the British presence of the board, carefully placing armies and roads and using your cards to strengthen the British position, gaining influence with them, and ultimately setting up what looks like a successful dominance check. And then your opponent, who's been supporting the Afghans this entire time, flips to the British by playing a loyalist. Now, they're also allied with the British, which means that all of the work you just did, it benefits them as well. All of those armies and roads, it's all mutually shared now. So, you think, "Okay, fine. We're both British. We'll score together." But this player, they've been smartly positioning their spies on targets of betrayal. They've lined up their court for a massive swing. And somehow, they saved all the funds for the perfect turn. They've completely flipped their loyalty, and it got a huge swing in influence with the British that you just didn't see coming. And then after the dominance check is triggered, they score a huge win while you collect the little scraps that remain. Sure, you think, "Let me give gifts to the British and next dominance I'll be able to outscore." But then they see something else you don't. They flip back to being loyal to Afghanistan. But now they have all of the momentum in the market and on the board. All of your hard work went to their benefit and now it's all lost to the sands of an ever shifting board.

There's a moment you realized what happened where you just got outmaneuvered. That's the outplayed mad. And you're not mad because you got unlucky. You're not mad because the rules were unclear. You're mad because you got significantly outsmarted and outplayed. Your opponent read the board state better than you could. They saw an opportunity that you didn't see. They made a brilliant move and now you're suffering for it. And I love that feeling, that sick realization that I was playing checkers while they were playing 4D chess. And I wasn't even winning at the game of checkers. Because that's the thing, you can only get outplayed if there's actual skill involved. If the game is just luck, there's no outplaying. If it's just follow an obvious path, there's no outplaying. But PAX Premiere has depth. Clever plays can exist, and if you miss them, you will lose. The outplayed mad is weirdly respectful. They spotted something you didn't, which means that the game has depth, and they could acknowledge and see it and take advantage of that depth. I've had games of PAX Premiere where I've been absolutely demolished, where someone pulled off a move so clever that I just had to sit back and say, "Okay, that was brilliant." And I'm mad. I'm frustrated that I didn't see that path or I got outplayed in the perfect way. But I'm also excited to play again because now I know that there's a novel pathway and I'm looking forward to doing it myself.

It's addictive. It makes you want to get better. It makes you want to see the game more clearly, to think five moves ahead, and to anticipate your opponent's thoughts and plans. And the beautiful thing about PAX Premiere specifically is that it teaches adaptability. The game punishes stubbornness. If you commit too hard to one strategy, and if you're loyal for too long, someone will find a way to exploit your position. You need to watch what other players are doing and be able to adjust on the fly. So, when you get outplayed, you're learning, you're getting better. The MAD is fuel for improvement. Now, there's a caveat here, too. Just like with Diplomacy, this only works if everyone's on the same page. Pax Premiere is not an easy game. It is complex and requires your complete attention. It even has a lot of real funkiness. And if someone at the table isn't engaged, they're going to have a miserable time. But if everyone's leaning in, if everyone's trying to win with all of their brain juices, that outplayed mad becomes this incredible engine for gameplay. You're all pushing each other to think deeper, to play smarter, to find those golden lines no one else saw. And that's why it's the second kind of mad I love. Not a personal betrayal, but strategic defeat.

The mad that comes from being beaten at a game you're trying hard to win at. But there's one more kind of mad I need to talk about. And this one's the trickiest because it lives entirely in your head. Blood on the clock tower. The paranoia mad. Look, I know I mention blood on the clock tower constantly. If you're new to this channel, yes, this is normal. If you're a returning viewer, yes, it's happening again. I just think it's a perfect example for this specific kind of mad. Blood on the Clock Tower is a social deduction game. One player is a storyteller, basically the game master, and everyone else gets some kind of secret role. Some of you are the good towns folk trying to figure out who the demon is and execute them. Some of you are evil, trying to help the demon survive and kill all the good players.

Blood on the Clock Tower has a lot of things that makes it special. But I want to highlight one aspect in particular. The information is messy. Unlike Mafia or Werewolf, where you know almost nothing, Blood on the Clock Tower gives you information, lots of it. The fortune teller can help pinpoint the demon. The empath knows how many evil players are next to them. The washer woman learns of which two possible players is a certain town's folk, but that information might be wrong. The fortune teller might have found the red herring. The empath might be poisoned. And the washer woman might have been the drunk the whole time. So, you're sitting there with information that might be true, trying to solve a puzzle that's deliberately designed to be unsolvable with 100% certainty. And that's where the paranoia mad strikes.

Here's how it goes. You're playing as the fortune teller. And on the first night, you learn that either player A or player B is the demon. Player B has convinced you that they're the chef. So, you've spent your entire game building a case against player A, watching their behavior, analyzing their claims, cross- referencing everything they talk about, and over time, you're just convinced player A is evil manifested into human form. So, you argue your case passionately. You convince the entire town to execute player A. You expect the game to end right there and then, but the game carries on. Wait, were they not the demon? Were they the red herring all along? Is a scarlet woman in play and now she's the demon? Was I poisoned?

Have I been drunk the entire time? There's a sick realization that your beliefs, your insight, they might have been flawed to begin with. You were so sure and yet now you're on uneven footing. That's paranoia mad. And it's amazing because it means I was engaged. I built a theory. I analyzed information. The game pulled me in so deep that being wrong felt personal. Blood on the Clock Tower creates genuine paranoia. Not in a destructive way, but in a genuinely creative puzzle kind of way. You don't know what's true. You can't trust your information entirely. You're going to have to read people and make judgment calls. And when the game is done, you have to live with those choices and what you could get a hunch on. So when you get it wrong, when you execute the wrong person or trust the wrong claim, you feel stupid. You feel mad at yourself for missing it, but that mad is proof that you were trying, you were engaged, and you cared enough to solve the puzzle. The paranoia mad is humbling in the best way. It reminds you that you're not as smart as you think you are. It reminds you that other players are capable of deceiving you and that the game state is more complex than you might have realized. In a weird way, that's thrilling because it means the game worked. It created this ambiguity.

It made you doubt yourself. It puts you in a state of uncertainty, where every decision felt meaningful. But being in that state where there isn't stable ground is where some of the greatest leaps of intuition will take place and the little great stories are told. And look, Blood in the Clockar has a big advantage here. It's cooperative and team-based. So even when you're wrong, you're still working together to solve this little puzzle. So the MAD itself is more internal and diffuse. You're frustrated with yourself, confused by the game state, but you're rarely angry at a specific player. It's way less personal than diplomacy. And since the information is designed to be imperfect, making mistakes is fundamentally a feature of the game, and you can't really get logic out of every time. But it still stings. And that sting is a spice that makes the game memorable.

So why why seek out games that make you feel this way? Why not just stick to cozy games where everyone's building cute little villages and no one gets their feelings hurt? Because games are one of the few places where you can feel the mad of betrayal, of being outsmarted and of uncertainty. These exact feelings we spend our lives trying to avoid. But in a context where there isn't harm but play. In real life, betrayal damages relationships permanently. Getting outmaneuvered in business cost you money and reputation. Being confidently wrong about who to trust has serious consequences. But in a game, you get to feel all of it. The knife in your back, the sting of being outsmarted, the vertigo of misplaced certainty. And then the game ends. You fold up the board and the friendship survives. You learn from failure without realworld consequences.

You can let go and the ego bruise will heal by your next TI4 session. This is the magic circle at its best. Inside of the circle, betrayal is strategy, manipulation is skill, deception is fair play. But the moment the game ends, the circle vanishes. The experience was real, but the stakes were fake. And here's the other side of it all. It's not just about feeling the mad. It's also about causing it. Successfully betraying someone in diplomacy, outplaying them in PAX premiere, deceiving them in Blood on the Clock Tower. There's something electric about watching their face as they realize what you've done. You get to exercise parts of your brain that normal life doesn't let you use. Things like strategy, time, and misdirection. The game gives you permission to be Machavevelian, and that's a novel area of the human experience. You're not actually hurting anyone. The stakes are fake. The relationships survive. But the feeling of outthinking someone, of executing a perfect play, that's real and it's contained and it's safe. That's a really rare thing to have. Most of the time in life, mad is something you have to control and manage. But in a board game, you can just feel it fully, let it wash over you, and then it passes and you're fine. I think that's valuable. You learn how betrayal feels. You learn what it's like to be outplayed, to hold your strongly held beliefs a bit lighter. And beyond just the psychology of it all, it

just makes for better stories. Nobody raves about the game where everything went well. You remember the game where you got betrayed, the game where you almost won but got outplayed at the last second, the game where you were so confidently wrong about who the demon was. Those are the games that stick with you. Those are the games you talk about months later. And the reason they stick is because you felt something. And here's the paradox. I truly do believe it's just a game. Winning at diplomacy has zero impact on my life. But that's exactly what makes the experience safe. The betrayal can feel real precisely because the stakes are fake. Winning doesn't matter, but caring about the game does. And engaging fully with a medium also matters. And if you care enough to feel mad, you're doing something right.

Now, here's the part that matters the most. This only works if everyone respects the magic circle. Inside of the game, betrayal is the point. Outside of the game, the betrayal doesn't matter. The difference between feeling mad and acting mad is everything. There is a reality, though. You can't always predict how you'll react. And there's a gap between agreeing to betrayal as a concept and having your friend or your spouse look you in the eye and lie to you. Sometimes you don't know which side of that line you're going to be on until you cross it. So I recommend watch the table. If someone's checked out, pause and check in. And if you're the player realizing that this isn't meant for you, calling it quits is completely fair and a respectable response. There's no shame in finding out that something isn't for you. Now, it is possible to ease people into this. You can start by playing games that have mechanical excuses built in. A classic example is in Root. The eerie player is sometimes forced to attack specific clearings, which means that it's a mechanical obligation, not a personal attack. You get to say, "Sorry, the game made me do it." Which is the board game equivalent of, "It's not you, it's me." Nobody necessarily believes you, but at least there's some plausible deniability. This kind of mechanical aggression, this mechanical obligation, it's much easier to process than diplomacy's six-hour long premeditated betrayal. You want stepping stones. And ultimately, there does exist a way into

meaner and meaner games. But, and this is important, I want to push back against the idea that feeling uncomfortable emotions or intensity in games means that there's something wrong. Sometimes people have one bad experience with an intense game and conclude that all emotional intensity in board games is bad. That any game that makes you feel anger or experience betrayal or strategic inadequacy is poorly designed or fundamentally broken. That's like watching one bad horror movie and deciding that fear is an invalid emotion to explore in film. or being genuinely terrified on a roller coaster and concluding that anyone who enjoys them is broken. One intense experience that doesn't meld with you as an individual doesn't invalidate the exploration of that emotion. The question isn't should games make people mad. The question is, are they making people mad in the right ways? Are they creating meaningful emotional experiences from within an expressive framework?

Now, before we wrap up, I need to make a distinction because not all MAD is created equal. The MAD I've been talking about, betrayal mad, outplayed mad, paranoia mad, these are signs of engagement and creative opportunity. They mean that you're invested and the game has depth and your decisions matter. And look, mad has been shorthand for a lot of terms I've been talking about, but there's really a whole spectrum of feelings. Frustration, indignation, the sting of being outsmarted, competitive fury, that sick feeling of betrayal or paranoia. All of those sharp uncomfortable emotions were often told to suppress in real life. But there are other kinds of mad, and many of these kinds are a response to the game being fundamentally flawed.

Powerless mad. This is when your decisions don't actually matter. You're so far behind that nothing you can do will change the outcome or the game systems have already locked you out of all of your choices. You're just going through the motions. I felt like this while playing Munchkin. I'd fallen behind early and the chaotic systems meant that I had no other way to catch up. Other players were fighting over who would win and I was just there drawing cards, playing them, knowing none of this mattered. My choices could be at best a way to slow down other players in a stale King's Lane roundabout. You've become a sentient speed bump. Rules ambiguity mad. This is when you're arguing about what a rule means and not the strategy. Does this card trigger before or after that ability? Can I do this or does the rule prevent it? A game like Robinson Crusoe is notorious for this. The rule book is dense. Edge cases aren't covered clearly. You're trying to survive on this island and tension is supposed to be high, but suddenly you're debating fog marker timings for 15 minutes. You'll get tired of the rule book and you'll pull up BGG to find a 50-page document about all those edge cases and you'll abandon all hope.

You're not mad at the game play, it's the language of the game that's broken. The game failed to communicate clearly and now you're stuck in this meta argument about timings and fuzzy rules instead of actually playing a game. Then there's tedium mad. This is when the game buries you in so much busy work and maintenance that you forgot you're supposed to be having fun. You're spending more time managing systems than making interesting decisions. Gloom Haven did this to me. The core puzzle is fine, but managing attack modifier decks, tracking status and elemental effects, handling enemy movement, doing basic arithmetic, setting up enemies after each open door. It all left me exhausted. Sure, I could use a tracker app, but then at that point, I'm playing a board game by staring at my phone for half the time. Why did I bother buying a $200 box? I could have downloaded a video game and kept my dining room table. It's just a sad reality that the cognitive load of maintaining all of these systems overshadowed the actual gameplay. Ego mad. This is when you're just mad that you lost, not mad at a brilliant play, not mad at betrayal, just mad that you didn't win. It doesn't matter what game it is, whether it's Wingspan or Patchwork. This mad comes from ego, not from the game's engagement with you. Winning is tied to your individual identity. So, you're upset purely because of the outcome. You could be playing Cascadia, a perfectly pleasant game with no betrayal, no direct conflict, and you're still fuming because someone else scored more points.

At this point, it's not about the game at all. It's all about you. The game could be perfectly designed. The experience could be great, but because you lost, you're mad. And I think this is what most people think about when we talk about madness or anger, it's this sore loser energy that gets confused with good mad. But ego mad is internal. It's not about the game's design. It's about the person. And that's the complete opposite of what we've been exploring. And here's a quick test. Good Mad is about forces within the game. the mechanics, the strategy, the story being told. Badmad is outside of your decision space. It's about the rule funk, the obscene amounts of tedium, powerlessness, busy work, or just about the individual player. This distinction is critical because sometimes people will confuse the two. They have a bad experience with a poorly designed game or a sore loser, and they conclude that all emotional intensity in board games is bad. But that's not true. The mad I love, the pain of betrayal, the sting of being outplayed, the vertigo from paranoia. These are all about meaningful decisions and emotional investments.

Games that respect you as an individual and as a player, and they reward your engagement. And one last obvious note, but not every game needs to do this. A game like Cascadia or Dorphomantic, those games create this peaceful, contemplative joy, and that's just as valid as a design goal. Those games are optimizing for a different emotional experience, and they're brilliant at it. I'm not saying that good mad is superior to good cozy. I'm saying emotional engagement, whatever form it takes, is what makes games memorable. The key takeaway is that mad just happens to be undervalued and misunderstood. There's often this allergic reaction to uncomfortable emotions while playing board games. Anger, envy, shot in Freud, even the competitive drive that we have.

It's because we become focused on wholesome vibes and positive table energy that we've accidentally stigmatized some of the most powerful experiences that games can create. Not every game night needs to be a cozy hug. Sometimes the best nights are the ones where you feel something sharp. In a real way, saying, "I love cozy games that make me feel productive and peaceful," is equal to saying, "I love games that make me tense and mad." It isn't that one form of play is better than another. It's just a variance in preference and an exploration of different emotions. And I mean, it should be obvious, but I love all kinds of games. I just also happen to love games that make me mad. So, that's my ultimate hot take. What game captures the sharp kind of mad for you? Drop it in the comments. I'm always looking for my next betrayal simulator.

Also, for my longtime viewers, I intentionally left out Dune 1979. If you watch my channel, you know I could do an entire video about how each faction embodies a different positive flavor of madness. Maybe that's my next video. And as always, thank you for watching and bye.

Progress saved