Skip to main content
Loading video...

What We Talk About When We Talk About Game Balance - TCbH Podcast

Transcript 1:31:04

Hello and welcome to the Cardboard Herald podcast, the the standing edition. I'm standing today, so I don't have my wheelie chair, so I decided to run a little bit uh to start off the podcast. Hello, welcome. I am Eric, joined as always most of the time, by my lovely youthful co-host, Jack. He

Yeah, we decided that we have a

a portrait of Dorian Gray type of situation going on here where as long as I uh undermine all of Eric's efforts as he does all the, you know, audio video stuff behind the scenes as we're preparing to record, then I can remain youthful forever.

Yeah. And it all is shown.

It's all shown in my copy of Furnace. The more damaged it gets, the more youthful Jack stays.

Yeah, I got that.

And the more thumbs up. Yeah, exactly. The accidental thumbs up.

The accidental thumbs up. It's not even really like it's just on your shoulder. Like that's not even uh I'm not going to I'm not going to argue with with Apple and their filters. Um

hello Jack. Um welcome to this lovely podcast recording day. Um what have you gotten to the table this week? Man, I've gotten some good games to the table, but the priorities to talk about would be I got to play Nature, which is the kind of re-implementation of evolution,

and then I got to play uh Tidal Blades 2. Both of these are really big, extravagant, lovely Kickstarter games, or at least crowdfunding games um that I didn't back. And also I don't have his review copies, but I have friends who backed them and got the super deluxe versions of these games and were like, "Jack, we should play these." And they're pretty good. Um, I liked evolution uh in the past uh and nature from a first play. I was kind of expecting it to feel more dynamic and exciting and taking some of the really like cutthroat aspect of Evolution and uh Oceans.

In some ways, it's less punishing. And maybe it's been long enough since I've played Evolution. Um, certainly it's been a a a grip, a metric grip since I've played them, but I I felt like there was more variance in the cards. We just played the basic mode that's not using one of the like 11 gajillion additions that could be added,

but it felt like there were only

like eight animal traits and they were all pretty distinct. like I wasn't creating some evolutionary freak uh in the way that I really wanted to, you know? I wanted like serrated teeth and uh you know, slanted predator eyes and I don't know, like a bifurcated tail and wings and all kinds of stuff. But uh it was just like

it's not like you get your freak on.

No, I was like I'm fast and I have claws. What kind of claws doesn't matter. I just have claws. You might be played it.

Does it show you the claws? Like is there like a little picture of the claws?

There's a picture of an animal with claws and it's one of our terrestrial animals. So, it even feels less imaginary and exciting. I don't know. I I don't want to like really rag on the game. I I had a good time, but if anything, I was expecting the the best aspects of the original to be amped up. And I was a little deflated to feel like it

seemed like it took the best aspects and softened them to make a somewhat less interesting game.

But it's been a long time since I've played the original. for comparison. I also recall it being very brutal,

but so is just nature in general.

Um,

yeah,

Title Blades 2, on the other hand, uh, I bounced on Title Blades 1, which was a game that I kickstarted and, uh, it felt like it was an amazing production, a very mediocre game. Title Blades 2, I am now jealous of the ownership of it. Uh but fortunately my campaign group is playing this as our next campaign and it's great. We played through the first two scenarios and it's um it's just a really great uh reinvisioning of something like Gloom Haven.

Uh a little bit uh softer of a game. The first one

Title Blades one is a Euro, you know, like kind of a midweight Euro with

uber production. Uh, this one has only thematic connections to the original and otherwise is just completely different style of game. It's a dungeon crawler adventure type of tactical dudes game. Um, it's got a really interesting uh ability system. Uh, it's got uh great production values. The uh automation for the enemies seems easy to manage. I I I'm just really impressed. Like we played one scenario and it was our learning game and normally that would be like okay that was enough for tonight and all three of us were like can can we play again? Let's just play the next one. I want to play the next one. And we nearly played a third way past uh our like old people bedtime. Uh we didn't. But uh the fact that we got two games in one of those campaign tactical games in a single night was uh

uh pretty uh indicative of our enjoyment of it. So Tuttleblades 2, I'm looking forward to playing more of that. Amazing. Yeah, I that one I feel like got especially at PAX Unplugged and then I think more recently that one's been hyped. So, I am glad that we have somebody somebody on the channel getting getting some of it in.

Uh,

you got the intel, you know,

intel the guy.

I I was expecting I had counterhype because of how I backed the first one

and I really really wanted to love it. I think it was because it was tapping into this aesthetic for a video game that I really love, Chronocross, and I was like, "Oh man, I really want to love this game." And it just disappointed me and felt uh like filler as far as game design. Um I I kind of rode off the second one and I was like, "H, this is just all hype and I didn't want to buy into it." But here we are. I I have played a lot of these types of games and this is one of the best first impressions I've had in a while.

Great. Amazing. Yeah, I have not played Tidal Blades one or two. Uh so I will have to I guess refresh myself on on what those systems look like. do just a cheeky little peruse through the rule books as I do

for a game that I don't own or really have any access to

just exactly the thing that I do frequently and then go that looks like a good game

and then just lament the fact that I don't own it

or have a gaming group that I think would want to play it consistently. I don't have I've never had a campaign group before

like build it up man. I know. I would. And well, and here's the thing is I some of the games where I would be like, "Oh, I would really want to do that with a group of people." I've already kind of like done like done solo.

So like Gloom Haven would be one where I'd be like, "Oh, I would do like a group playthrough of that." And I still can like obviously like

y

I mean Gloom Haven second edition is just about to come out. Frost Haven's there. Jaws of the Lion would be a great one. Oh, I've already

Adventure Tactics.

True.

Yeah, Adventure Tactics. I though I think the company that makes that may be Defunct now. Uh, but if you could get your hands on it, it's poppy, it's fun, it's cute. Uh, and you know, just like picking up one of those games under the mutual agreement. Hey, you know, can I get once a week or once every other week to sit down and play one of these games? uh two or three other players and you'll have a great time. So DCbased gamers, uh, Virginia or Maryland based gamers,

uh, the area,

you know.

Yeah. Uh,

get get in the DMs.

Are we get in the DMs?

Get in the DMs

or the comments. The comments are probably a better place.

I don't necessarily want to dox people, but uh,

what have you been playing? Uh so we had a very casual uh get together which meant more things and rings

always that has become my go-to just like I very casual people who don't really play board games were getting it out. Um I've played solo Finsspan for the first time.

Uh I got that to the table recently and I got uh So You've Been eaten. I've I've started playing the solo mode a bit more just because I it's a pretty cool system. Um I still am not fully sold on how deep it is.

Uh I still think that it's it's a thing where I don't know that I'm going to get more out of it the more I play. like you can do things to make it a bit tougher, but I feel like at some point or another, you just either are winning based on luck or losing based on luck. So, I'm still figuring that out. Um,

how are you feeling about Finsspan?

It's a cool solo mode. I think that it's it's pretty interesting. I like what they did with it. I do think that it it is such it's in such a weird spot because I it is always going to be compared to Wingspan in Wingspan solo mode

and I like Wingspan solo mode pretty well like in terms of

it plays the game pretty well against you against yourself.

Yep. So

yeah, it it's one of those things where I I like Finsspan and now I own Wingspan and Worms Span and Fins Span

and when I'm in the mood for a span game, Finsspan is generally at the bottom of that list. I have managed to play it since Yeah. of the spans, you know, like uh you know, when you're looking for a span type game, uh we're we're getting into like some uh cojimaesque strand type of game

type game.

Yeah.

Yeah. Um, but if I have gotten to play it since uh reviewing it and I enjoy it and I intend to play it, but it is it's eating into the existing time that I have dedicated to span type games as opposed to eating into the general time of non-span games, if that makes sense. Like,

so

if anything, it's causing me to play less of my preferred other games in that series. Even though I enjoy it, and I enjoy all three of them. I don't know. It's a complicated situation. As I said in the review, I don't think you really need to own all three. Syrian, my kid, likes Finn Span the best, so I guess, you know, that's a good indicator on why to keep it, but,

you know, is what it is. Is what it is. Um, but yeah, so I've played those. I think that the especially with So You've Been Eaten because it's like a twoplayer game that's asymmetric. Uh, it's always kind of like an interesting thought process of like how are they going to like pair up against one another, especially like when you go from being like a person versus a person to a person versus a program. And you can do that from either side. You can either be the monster playing against a robot miner or a minor playing against a sleeping monster. And it's just interesting to see like how they level out things in terms of like power level or like what things are better than others. Um and just I think the key word here is balance

which is our topic this week.

Nice.

I balanced intro. Uh our topic this week is uh balance uh game balance g balance in game design. Um

yeah, so I I I've been thinking about this a a lot because a lot of the discourse for time and memorial when it comes to games is, you know, like is the game balanced? Uh you see this in video games, you see this in uh tabletop games. Um you even see it in sports. Uh though sports tends to be uh a little bit more symmetrical um and a little bit more forgiveness uh in terms of balance because individual players can exert greater physical skill, right? Uh but um I don't know like I recent discourse uh some recent videos that I've seen uh and even some commentary on um uh some Kickstarters and stuff. I I've seen a lot of discussion about the need for balance and it's gotten me wondering how important is balance and I wanted to just dive into that with you Eric. Yeah.

And I think that it's it's an important thing to have a chat about because it is really like I'm not going to say like a hot button issue. Uh because it's it it it's been a part of game design since the very beginning. Um, but it is something that I feel like

comes up a lot in discussion of games and especially as we

I feel like the current era of game design usually has a lot of asymmetry.

Like we I feel like just we've we've gotten to a point where

an asymmetric game is a lot more common than uh it has not always been. And I think balance is a term that gets thrown around with a lot of different connotations. Like it really is can apply to a ton of different things where it's like is a certain

asymmetric power balanced? Are these two factions balanced against one another? Uh is there just an action on the board that is so powerful that everybody wants to go there on their first turn? Is that balance? Is that a game balance issue? Uh, and I think that we have a kind of a diff couple different viewpoints to look at it from. Um, which would be

defining what we mean like what you and I think of as balance,

right?

Um, the games that we think are very good discussion points for balance. Uh, I have a couple that I thought about, one of which I posted in like our every week before the podcast typically, uh, unless it's a surprise podcast. Um, I will put a post up on our YouTube channel, uh, basically saying, "Here's what the topic's going to be this week. We want to hear your thoughts on the matter." Uh, and I put up a photo of the game Harvest, and there were quite a few people who commented on that saying they would be interested to see how Harvest is discussed here. And I think that we'll we're going to get to that because I think we have a couple other things to talk on first. But, um, just games that we think are good discussion points for that.

Um,

yeah. and then

some things that maybe help the game feel balanced and whether or not a games should be balanced.

Yeah, that that's really the the core of it for me. Like I I think balance is one of these things that people often want or at least they think that they want. Uh, and ultimately it it's like a monkeykey's paw situation. When things are too perfectly balanced, then they become a lot less interesting.

Yeah.

Now, this this is all preference stuff for everyone, right? you know, like everyone's going to have their own preferred level of um, you know, balance and fairness, but this is definitely going to, you know, be a a subjective. Here's our thoughts on it. Now, as far as

unbalanced thoughts,

maybe some unbalanced thoughts or maybe we'll find balance, perfect harmony between us.

You want to play harmonies right now?

Let's do it. Let's forget this podcast. We're going to stop the podcast. We're going to go into a live stream of harmonies.

Sorry, this is a tangent.

Would people be interested in watching like live plays of like if I were to just go on board game arena and play games with commentary? Is that a thing? Like I know live plays happen, but it's usually like at the table where people watch it.

I think that's a thing. Uh, also people are hungry for solo live plays. Uh, I just on a whim during co did a solo live play. I I had no idea how to do anything. Uh, and I I'd never even opened Streamlabs before. I just figuring everything out and I was like, I I don't know. I'm going to try to play a Gricola solo and I'm going to put that on here. And it it got a surprising amount of views. Uh, and I still get comments on that. Um um like I I don't even know how a live stream gets these comments. Like people are still interested in the live stream four years later. Um anyway anyway uh so balance when I think of balance in a game if someone is like is this game balanced or or if I'm considering it for a review I tend to think about is there a a general sense that uh the various options that are available to you whether they're powers that you have or the way that you interface with the game um presents um multiple avenues that have relatively even footing as far as strengths and weaknesses. Um

but that that's you know kind of vague and big picture. Uh but that's the the best way that I can really put it. Have you given some thought in how you define balance in a game?

Yeah, when I think of balance kind my thoughts immediately go to at the start of the game does everybody have an equal chance of winning?

Like when I hear the term game balance uh does everybody have an equal chance at winning the game if it's competitive, if it's cooperative? That one's more up for grabs. There are some games that I would like to win more frequently and there are other games where it's if it's a challenge, it's okay uh for cooperative. But I think I go to how easy is it to win this game with each if it's asymmetric with each faction

or if it's not asymmetric. Is it like is there something that if you're the first person to do this, you just are going to snowball to a win?

Right.

Uh

yeah, I I think that's the thing that everyone's trying to avoid is when things are so offkilter that there are certain dominant strategies that'll just always happen

and unequal access to those dominant strategies. You know, if if one player because of their specific player power or because of where they start on the board or whatever, they just inherently have so much more access to the things needed to win that it becomes an uphill battle for everyone else. such that a a less skilled player will be at a much higher advantage than even more skilled players in other positions.

Um I think the thing is is that chasing that too much is a great way of shaving off everything that's interesting about a game. Um, you know, like sometimes people want perfectly balanced games and one of the most frustrating uh bits of asymmetry that a game can develop is when uh the balance is to the point of where it's essentially different colors of exactly the same thing. You know, like a purple gem is worth one green and two yellow, and a yellow gem is worth one purple and two red or or whatever. But there there's a perfectly even exchange where it's clear that all sense of identity uh and interest has been removed that everything is just doled out perfectly equally and there's no longer like different strategic avenues to explore.

You're just having a a a pixel swap essentially of the same strategic avenue.

Yeah. And I think just touching on the there being a dominant strategy that some people just don't have access to. Um there are just sometimes where it it's okay to have a dominant strategy like that's not like a death nail for for a game especially if it's like it is difficult to pull off or if it is like something that requires a lot of investment that might pay off. it might not pay off, but in if you can get this engine running without anybody else at the table hindering you from building that engine in that way,

right,

I think that's a super reasonable thing to have in a game. Um, I think the things that make it difficult where it's just like, oh, well, this is your first time playing the game and it doesn't jump out to you that, oh, you have to start getting purples immediately because come Midame, those are the only gems that are valuable and if you haven't gotten those, you can't power the engine correctly.

Right. it. That's the point where it's like, okay, well, maybe that's still balanced because once you do know that information, it it now is okay and now it's like a scarcity of that resource. But if the game can only be won by doing that, it should maybe be more obvious to do that. So, or this is less of this is a very minor example of this, but it is in Dune Imperium. On that very first turn, everybody ever wants to take the one water you get for free, go to the spice thing, and then on the next turn, go exchange that for money, and then on your very first turn, next round, go buy a swordsman. And if you're the first player in turn order,

you can do that. And right, there isn't really anything anybody else can do to stop you. And that's not terrible cuz it's just the first turn, but it just was so comically, oh, this is what happens at the very start of every single game.

Uh to the point that it was kind of fixed in the second or or uh not the second edition, but the uh

yeah, the first expansion. Um, I think that when I think of game balance,

that's something that comes to mind of that is a dominant strategy that some if you're the first player, you have access to, but if you're not the first player, you just inherently don't have access to that strategy that lets you start sending three workers immediately.

Yeah. Whenever there's a like win-loss ratio for one particular thing, whether it's a strategy in the game, whether it's a faction or whatever, and it is clear that one has the capability of winning more than any other, then that's that's a problem. Um, at least that's going to be a perceived problem for uh the the people at the table. However, you know, like you in theory could balance that through the game mechanics, you know, like the the game can give you ways to leverage against uh a more particularly powerful faction, right?

And not everyone wants to do that in a super aggressive way. And that gets into like king making in games. You know, you hear a lot of people talking about like I hate the idea of kingmaking. But like certain games, if someone is in a position of power, say halfway through the game where it's clear that they, if left unchecked, they will have more resources, they'll have more advantages, they'll have whatever, then it's up to the other players to figure out how to interfere with them. Um, and that's kind of like an old school thought on board games that has grown out of vogue. um to to just say, well, it's it's up to players to figure out, you know, like put down the person who is stronger and if someone has a particularly powerful combination of faction powers or, you know, like specific placement or whatever. Um, Harvest might even be an example of this.

Harvest is a is a friendly farming game where you're just trying to work on your little tableau and manage your farming. But if you really wanted to get down to balance issues, if someone has a particularly powerful combination of character and what is that sunrise power,

the other players at the table in a greater than two-player game could in theory go, well, it's our responsibility to somehow inhibit their capacity to take advantage of this. There's only so much that you can do in a Euro game and there's only so much that you can do in a lot of different games. But um there's something to be said about uh a game that allows player agency to tackle the uh meaner aspects of balance.

Yeah. And I think that one of the things that is so tricky with balance is different tables are going to approach problems differently. Like there are going to be people who will just say, "Oh, well, there's just no way for me to stop him because there's the only way that I could stop him is by attacking his field and that's just not a thing that we like to do." And it's like, well, that's the the designer put that in the game. You can attack fields in harvest to my knowledge.

I believe there's not a Raiden pillillage sunrise power in harvest.

I'm going salt the earth. My my little Miss Piggy is going to come in there.

Could be very fun. Uh in the expansion,

we need to talk to key master about

key master.

Katon has hunters and gatherers. You could have harvest raiders and pillagers. It could be very fun. everybody at the table would be super cool with it.

Tie in with the Blood Rage sequel that's uh being crowdfunded. Um,

yeah, I was just going to I was going to say that tables have approach problems differently and therefore are going to see different solutions to the same problem in that

some tables are just not going to see the solution being the game is designed for players to balance against each other. Uh, right.

Because I also I one game that comes to mind just that I feel like is the epitome of that is in Root.

It it is everybody at the table's job to whack whoever is

in the lead and is is most dangerous.

Like that is the goal of the entire table is to police the board state

in a way that will make it so that somebody can't run away unchecked. And because of that, I think that it allows more forgiveness and balance. Like you could just say, well, the cats are less powerful than other factions. And that's kind of okay because they will be less of a threat than the other factions at the table, which means they will be whacked less and you can take advantage of that seeming underdog state. Yeah,

some people would also argue that cats need to be more powerful, that that Marqueis cat needs to get a get a buff um or other factions need to be nerfed. Uh but I don't think that anything is really broken in the game and that that's what we're trying to ignore. So, I I think one of the most egregious examples of broken elements in games in recent memory um is right on the shelf behind you, Wingspan. Uh

I was wondering if you say it.

I was wondering if you were going to say it or if I would have to bring it up.

Yeah. So, uh there are what, two or three ravens in the original or crows. three three ravens and then there are two birds who synergize really well that are also typically banned.

Uh the Franklin Skull and the Kilder, I think my memory is correct.

Yeah. So, the the deal with the ravens is that they can be in your grassland row, which allows you to uh as part of the action produce eggs, and you can then convert those eggs into a hefty amount of food that then disincentivizes engaging with all the rest of the board. And you don't have to make intelligent decisions about anything because you now have one action that's going to produce the majority of all the resources that you need in the game such that

as soon as it becomes available, it becomes an obvious choice. you're going to snag that up. And it becomes the focal point of any engine where it kind of feels like if someone has that and knows how to put it in an engine, they've won the game and there's no obstacle that anyone can do to prevent them from doing so.

Yeah. Well, and I think that it just go it it kind of boils down to especially with the if you can get the combo of one of the Corvids and the either the Kilder or the Franklin's Goal. I I forget ex I forget the other two, but those ones are you trade an egg to draw cards.

And at that point, you're just you don't you just do that same action and it gives you everything you need. You will have too much food. You will have too many cards in your hand. hand the entire time you're still laying surplus eggs which are you are going you're just going to be able to just take that action over and over and not have to optimize any of the other lanes which to me is the fun part of wingspan is being like oh how do I build the best engine using all three lanes or do I just give up on this lane a little bit to make these ones more powerful but if you have the option to just get all of the benefits without having to make any of the choices.

Mhm. your game just becomes a lot your your board becomes a lot stronger and everybody else at the table that doesn't have access to the Corvids or the other birds because they have just haven't drawn into them immediately becomes at a much more difficult place to win win the game. I think that in Wingspan's specific case, a lot of people have come to the same conclusion as you. Personally, I never removed them. I saw that they were really powerful, but it was also something like, eh, I I don't really care. If they come up, that's great. But also, I'm always trying to, I guess, self police, like do something that I haven't done in the past. So, like if I've seen that I've done that with those guys before, then I'm going to be like, well, what sort of wombo combo goose strategy can make with like a bajillion tucked cards and see if I can ring something out of it. um they are very easy to plug into a system. And if a game is being played in a competitive way, then that essentially does throw off the the sense of agency investment. You know, if my opponent gets that, then like what am I going to do at this point? If the goal of the game is to win uh against my opponent, then I I no longer have the the ability

to achieve that goal.

Yeah. And I think one of the most egregious things about it, to me at least, is with with wingspan, there's not really a way to counteract it. Like there are some things you can do like there are birds that will give you like every time an opponent an opponent takes the lay eggs action you get a bonus

but it just is not commiserate value and I have removed them but it's for me it's just because the game becomes a lot more fun when you don't have to worry about that. Um,

right.

And I think it kind of is what it is. I can have fun playing with those. Like those are really fun to get and those are really fun to uh have and just have them come up and be like, "Oh, uh, I I wasn't going to do that, but let me try to rearrange that and fit that into my engine." Even though it's it's it's really simple. You just put it in the fields and then it's done. But I also just I get less fun out of it because it is I'm also like you where I'm trying to build a different engine than I have before every time I play Wingspan. And I think that the birds make it difficult to the the Corvids make it difficult to do that. At the same time,

they're in the game. like they're they are in the game and I think that while I think they make it more difficult to win, I have seen people beat the corvids, especially if they don't if somebody doesn't get the ravens until later in the game. They're less useful.

But, you know, Stonemer kind of has a reputation for this. And I guess I've never really thought about it in the past individually in games. I've thought about it, but uh Wingspan uh a lot of people felt this way about the Corpids. Um like you said, I kind of disagree. It it's an easy to implement engine and with the correct combination, then it becomes like a near unbeatable engine. However, uh for the most part, you know, like there are other very powerful engines, just a little bit harder to either uh utilize or set up or kind of see. Um just less obvious.

Um but people have had that issue with this. Um people uh definitely had an issue with the balance of tapestry uh which uh got a ton of accusations that it wasn't play tested which I'm certain that it was play tested a ton but there's only so much play testing can do until it gets in the hands of uh the the the uh players

and Stonem has kind of acknowledged this in expansions releasing erratted versions of the uh original factions to apply more balance after taking data from thousands of plays or whatever. Um, some people accuse that as uh uh Stonemire of not play testing their game thoroughly enough and putting that on the backs of the people purchasing the game and then requiring additional purchases to get the final versions. Um then uh Scythe also uh there's a straightup combo of player board and faction that is just not allowed in that game. You know like is has been eratted to not be a legal combination uh based off of it being completely broken. It has an unfair advantage. Um, that said, I think that part of what makes Stonemer Meer prone to this is the designs of these games. Um, which at least two of these are designed by Jamie Stagmire himself. um they tend to be very ambitious to create a lot of asymmetry, to create a lot of interesting combinations that aren't just um I have my faction and then I'm done with it and

I just kind of have my board. Both Tapestry and uh Scythe have tons of possible uh permutations of different faction components that can evolve throughout a game. Um and that level of um flexibility and permutations I think is inevitably going to come up with something. Yeah.

Right.

Yeah. And I think

it's going

Yeah. I that's one of one of the reasons that I this is a mostly off that topic, but one of the reasons I put Harvest on there is when I was thinking of games that I believe are balanced pretty well. Harvest came to mind for me because you are you choose your starting position like cuz you choose you have an option of two

characters and then I believe it's two starting sunrise powers

and you're not going to you might not have like a clear like oh this is a broken combination but it's like there is so much asymmetry that goes into it but it is I I don't think that I have found something that is just like, oh, there's no chance I'm going to beat that combination.

Uh even like there are going to be through just the sheer number of permutations you can have of what two starting characters do I have and what two sunrise powers do I have, you're going to have some combinations that are more potent than others,

right? But it's not to the point where I think it does a good job making sure that you have a pretty fun choice to make at the start of the game of what do you want your sunrise power to be and what character do you want to be? And some people just choose character based off of vibes. That was I played recently and we were like, we're not looking at the front, just the back. I had like vague memories of I'm pretty sure this is the power that this person does, but I'm not going to actually like look I'm just going to be like

I'm just going to choose based off of the images.

I'm pretty sure that woodpecker lives in Juno.

I I agree. I think I think her name is Rosie. I think I had her the other day when I played. Uh

yeah. Uh like I see that person at the rookery daily like

every person who comes to

uh uh

the Devil's Club game night.

Devil's Club game night.

Yeah.

But

um

I think

very very Pacific Northwest vibes.

Very peed up. Very peed up.

Yeah. I Well, it it's funny, but in Harvest, I I would actually argue that you have more opportunity to interfere with your opponents uh based off of what they've chosen and kind of evolving your strategy to meet that than you probably do, at least in the earlier stages of Scythe and uh Tapestry. in in those games, the first several rounds, you're kind of doing your own thing, and there's only so much that you can really do to interfere with your opponent. Whereas Harvest, your presence on the board just by proxy of it being a a worker placement game, not to mention you drafting the uh the wake up powers uh at the beginning of every round is going to fundamentally change what opportunities are available to the other players. I definitely think in Harvest uh I've had powers where I'm like, "Oh, well that's this one really doesn't seem as good or at least as dynamic or interesting."

Like um I I feel like buildings aren't particularly great in the game. And so the I want to say it's the beaver or something gives you the ability to buy buildings either cheap or freely or or or something.

It's funny you say that. That guy did that guy just did so well in the game I played recently.

Okay. Well, there you go. Uh but like you know compared to the flexibility of some of the others where you just see

wow this has so much application so much utility whereas beaver guy

he's just leaning into buildings and you got to hope that there's good buildings up and that you have the space to build the buildings. But on the other hand, I in many many plays of Harvest, I I still haven't seen anything where I'm like, "Oh, that is broken compared to everyone else."

And I think that the one of the things that I found interesting about it, which I do believe is one of the reasons I I had it on here or I had it as the post, is I think I also thought that about the Beaver guy, but then there was like a random like it wasn't random. It was the

dominant beaver.

Dominant beaver. Nope. I think it's there was a

uh there there's the building that gives you points for all of your end of game point buildings

and and the player just loaded up on those and it was like, "Oh,

this is like what the beaver is meant to be do." Like I this is what the beaver should be doing. And I think that it

it was something where I I hadn't really considered that as like, oh, this if I'm playing as the beaver, this would be the strategy to take. And I think that there's

a number of things there are a number of games like that where something

seems like it is just inherently weaker than the rest but it is just you need to line it up. Which is also why I think just going back to wingspan, I even with the corvid still think of wingspan as a balanced game for the fact that so many of these birds have places in different engines where it's like there are birds that seem very weak on one playthrough and then you've built your engine in a way where it's like, oh my god, where is the mountain chickity? I need the mountain chickity. Uh

I I'm always uh when I play Wingspan, I always forget just how much just like dope point birds are good. Like I I feel like all I got to get all this utility and I got to build up my engine and then my wife has like five nine point birds at the end. I'm like, "Oh,

oh, that's 45."

Yeah, that's

that's 45 points there. That is a lot of points. Uh that can be very powerful. Uh especially when I'm looking at the ball of the eagle because Juno is littered with eagles and I'm like, man, the eagle should be better than just getting a a couple a couple fish.

All I get is a couple fish. You get nine points out of it.

The eagle should introduce a new food source. Trash.

Yes. Uh if anyone comes to Juno, if you want to see eagles, you can go to the dump. Uh it's insanely expensive to go to the dump. That's a different discussion.

Don't actually like pay to enter the dump. Just drive past the dump.

You will see so many bald eagles.

Yeah. If you're going to the dump and actually dumping trash, like they are a nuisance. They have to like shoot off flares to get rid of the eagles that are just kind of like mowing down. There's herds of them

and they're massive. So you can't just go like shoot. No, they they they will take your trash for you.

What would a tra What do you think the trash food would be in? Like would it have any special powers? Is it like nectar where all birds can take it?

Uh I think it is uh something that unlike nectar where you get positive points. I think the utility of trash would be negative points. You can attract certain birds with trash. Uh but then you shed a tear for your humanity that you are destroying the ecosystem and

you have to cry or else you lose 10 victory points.

That's the plan. That's how it's going to work.

Um

um okay. So what about heavily asymmetric games? Um, these often get an accusation of imbalance, but uh, for example, uh, Kelp, you know, it's really hard to sus out what the right level of balance is, uh, in a game where the way that two players are interfacing is different. And Kelp is distinctly a two-player game, so you can't really rely on a third player to help

gang people up or, you know, like alliances form, that kind of thing.

Uh, yeah. I think that I mean, for kelp especially,

I feel like it's there might be cards that the octopus has that are more powerful than other cards, but also I feel like they The whole thing with me is like you're controlling the flow of information like that is as the octopus like that is your opport that's your source of income and like what you can use to pay

is by revealing yourself and revealing food

and I think at that point it it the balance comes down more to player skill level then and player familiarity with the game versus like anything the game is going to do. Um I think right

with asymmetric games balance is really easy to throw out there. Like it's really easy to say the word balance without actually having

balance balance. Balance balance balance. It's really easy to like bring that up in discussions without really having any thoughts on it because inherently these two things are different and things that are different no matter how hard anybody tries are going to be different balance levels or like different power levels.

At the same time though, I think you can get pretty close and let the players kind of balance themselves out. Uh because like going back to what we said earlier with root,

I think if you look at like the

player data of all games, all four player games or lower, but we'll say four player games, uh one of Rude. In theory, you want every faction to have a 25% win rate. Like in theory, you want every faction to enter the game and have an equal chance to win.

And that probably is not exactly accurate because there are so many factions that are

there are a lot of factions in in Route. And as we were saying, the Marquita I feel like have a reputation of being underpowered compared to the other people at the table. But again, as we were talking about earlier, with that asymmetry comes, you know that the Marquita cat are going to be weaker and the players will balance it themselves. And I think it is to the point where at some point another as a game designer and developer, you can do as much as you can, but it's just always going to be in the player's hands,

right? And and going back to sports earlier, you know, like ultimately if you're looking at the 1992 Chicago Bulls, um you know, is that balanced against the the other uh teams? How much do we want balance? uh if that's going to take away interesting situations. You know, ideally when people sit down at a at a table and they're playing a game, you want that sense that you could win. Um personally, I don't want that to be at the expense of it being an interesting game. Yeah. Um, and uh, like I was saying with nature earlier, um, instead of taking the more interesting aspects of the game, uh, and then leveling things up to that, it feels like they took evolution and shaved off the more interesting things to take away some of the, um, feelings of, you know, uh, take that or, you know, having your stuff, uh destroyed because predators are coming in here, which is fine.

I I think you should have catchup mechanisms. You should have rubber banding. Um I love when that happens kind of organically in a game, but even shoehorning in some mechanisms to make sure that someone getting picked on doesn't get absolutely decimated uh should be in there. However, I I don't want balance and fairness uh to come at the expense of interesting games. And I think some of the best games, personally, the the ones that you and I tend to really gravitate to, um, become almost impossible to imagine the game being what they are if greater care or like a significantly greater care were paid towards trying to make them even for all players at all time.

Yeah.

You know, you

you want interesting situations. You want interesting combinations. You want to feel like,

damn, this is awesome. I One of my favorite Euros to have an example of this is is uh Marco Polo uh 2 specifically. Um in service of the con, every single one of the faction powers in that game make you feel like, "Holy hell, this feels broken." And then you play the next one, you're like, "This feels broken. This is so good. What do you mean I get this much jade? What do you mean I just get resources out of the way? I have two pawns on the board. Like, I can travel in two different It's crazy. I can't tell you if all of them are perfectly evenly footed to win the game. But what I can tell you is all of them can win and all of them present interesting situations and different ways to approach the game.

Yeah. And I think that it uh it's a thing that I've read about before, which is and it's kind of something I was talking on earlier in this podcast where I was talking about with So You've been eaten and saying that I don't feel like I can really get better at this game because it just feels like there's

you reach a certain skill limit. And I think that you want things that are going to be ever so slightly unbalanced that reward players for thinking about thinking through their options more. You want to be able to reward players for playing the game more and then also just I think reward players for being innovative with the the tools that they have at their disposal. So, one

right

thing that another example that I have here is River of Gold. I feel like every random player power that I got at the start of the game, I'm always like, "Oh, this is a really interesting thing that if I can play if I can play to this and like change my play style to better reflect this, I can get a lot of value out of this." And I felt like that that happened super every time I played Rever of Gold, I would always take a look at that and be like, "Oh, wait. This is something that I can I can play to." And I think that's one of the things, especially with asymmetric games, that to me is the big draw, which is inherently you have to have a different play style every time you approach it, which creates interesting situations.

And you don't want it to be like you obviously don't want it to be oh well I'm playing as this faction so if I just do this I'm going to win every time like

right

that's obviously what you don't want to have but I feel like especially in today's day and age it is games get should get play tested enough that there isn't something that is so broken that that happens or if it is that players have a way to engage in that. So like if there was a faction we're using it a lot and I think that it just is because it has it has a really clear element. If there was a faction that came to root that just was so dominant like they just had a power that if they can just trigger this every single turn they will win the game in like four turns,

right? It is up to the players to take note of that and do everything they can to stop that from happening. And I think that that is that game allows that to happen. If it were in harvest and there was just a faction that or like a player you could like player character you could get and if you got that character you just got to plant a pumpkin for free every single turn. there's not really a way to stop them in theory if they just get it. And clearly that's not in the game. Uh I sure I don't think so.

I'm pretty sure.

And and it could even be too egregious in a game like Root as well. You know, like if there's just something that is inherently going to be most likely to win all the time. Um, and you could take advantage of that uh in a way that it it kind of diverted everyone else at the table from being able to engage in the most fun aspects of the game for them, then that would be really frustrating. Um, that kind of happens in say Magic or or other CCGs where there can be uh like a meta that's developed that's just a very unfun meta. There's something that is so powerful that everyone has to have an answer for it.

And maybe that does balance out the the tournament scene, but it creates an unfun situation because either you are playing with this thing or you are packing your your deck to specifically deal with this thing. Yeah.

In ways that it takes away the agency, the feeling of I can engage in this game in more interesting, creative ways. I I I think that's something that I'd been dancing around that you hit on earlier is that you want to reward players for being innovative and using the tools that they have at their disposal in interesting ways. And if dominant strategies, which really is is a different thing than what we're talking about, like even footing, um but is part of this discussion, which is why we're having it. Um, you know, like I if a dominant strategy is such that it prohibits a reasonable investment in other more interesting things, then that that just kind of tears a game down.

Yeah.

Um, but you know, it's going to be different for everyone. Some people are going to want chess, right? Some people are going to want goat where everything is perfectly tuned one versus the other and there are no differences. Uh there's no random situations. But I think for board gamers who are in hobby board games who are playing a lot of different games, sometimes they're playing like a new game every week. You're introducing new people to the games that you love. You want to have opportunities for people to see interesting permutations or the possibility of interesting permutations and not to be disincentivized from it. And bringing it back to kind of that original do people want balance. I think too often people want things to be flat instead of balance where it can kind of teeter one way or another. When I think of balance in a game, I I'm fine with that teetering as long as it doesn't fall off of one edge. What I really don't want is where it becomes a fixed platform where everything is perfectly even and it no longer has that element of agency that you as a player can involve yourself in the more powerful and less powerful uh paths through the game.

Yeah. And I think that there's there's a lot of different ways to approach it, but I think that there's

the teeter totter is a good way of explaining it, which is

I if players have the opportunity to adapt to it in a way that they will even if somebody puts something online that is like in on their engine, it is in their engine and it is pretty powerful. both players have a way to adapt to that and respond to it. I I think it can be balanced and I think that that's more what people want is to be able to make interesting decisions in the game. And I think that's the thing that people sometimes see as unbalanced is if something is so powerful that you no longer make a decision on it,

right? And you know, like even if something I know is inherently less powerful, but it might make for some interesting gameplay,

as long as it has a chance, as long as you can see how it might be used, you know, like terraforming Mars has a ton of those things where it's like, yeah, you know, like there's some tried andrue strategies that are just going to work in terraforming Mars, but you can see on the periphery some synergy ies that are like, okay, I could see if the right cards line up in an interesting way. I can really ring a lot out of this and maybe I'm going to invest heavily in that in this game. Now, if that specific strategy were taken to like some sort of in-depth analysis and you saw that it lost uh the majority of time, I don't know if it's inherently imbalanced unless that strategy were like it loses, you know, 99% of the time or or even 95 or 90% of the time. as long as ways that you can use the things that are available to you for a reasonable chance at victory. Uh I think that's what we're all looking for.

Yeah.

Yeah. And I think it it goes back to me as I would like the chance to win a game at the start

if that's that's I think what we're going for.

Um

that's what we're all going for. That's what we're all chasing. Um, we had some comments on that post as I mentioned earlier. Um, uh, I'll start off uh, here uh, with our, uh, most um, frequent comeer, Blue Se Pearl. Um,

friend of the channel.

Friend of Blue Se Pearl. Balance gets thrown around a lot, especially after someone has played a game once and may not get the strategic opportunities at their fingertips. Twilight Struggle requires multiple plays and understanding what cards will come into play during early, mid, and late war phases to be able to get to victory.

Um, I agree, we kind of touched on this earlier where I think strategies will develop as you play more and kind of understand it more. And I think that some people will it's easy for somebody to be like, "Oh, that is that is a dominant thing to do. Like if you do that, obviously you're going to win." But then the game play is actually about, "Oh, I need to stop other people from doing that." But I didn't realize that was my job

the first go round. Um, yeah. And I think it is easy to say something is overpowered when you haven't had the chance to to play it yourself or to like see what are the downsides of it. Uh I I have talked about I haven't played Twilight Struggle. You have

Yes, that's correct.

Yeah. Yeah.

Yeah. Yeah.

But that's a game that I I can't speak to, but Sure. Sure. Yeah, I I it's like a lot of games, particularly a lot of historical games that have cards tied to like historical events progressing at a certain time. Um, votes for women does this, shores of Tripoli do does this where uh you have, you know, like a particular era and you know that within this particular era there's going to be certain events that are going to come up and you can plan around that. but you also need some sort of knowledge of what's going to come in uh era 2 or era 3. So in that regard, it's less um to me like a an issue of balance. It's more a game just about for knowledge.

Um it's not even knowledge of like what strategies or capabilities are available to you. It's just kind of knowing the overall structure of the game.

Yeah. Yeah. Totally. And I think that it goes it goes hand inhand with sometimes when people are talking about balance, they're they're just talking about they need to as a player understand the game more.

Um but yeah, I think that's a good point uh to be made in terms of you know it's it is a word that gets thrown around a lot. Um, our next comment is from Sapion01101. Uh, I'm primarily a solo/coo-op player, so when I think about balance, I tend to focus on difficulty balancing. One game I actually enjoy, despite its poor difficulty, balance is unsettled. In my experience, the scenarios are usually either too easy or too difficult, and both extremes tend to rob the game of suspense. Um, you you and I have like touched on this and I think this is as good a podcast as any to talk about it. Uh, which is in solo games or co-op games.

I think it's okay if you lose most I think we both agree it's okay if you lose most the time if that is the vibe of the game. At the same time, I do totally agree with

I if it is like, oh, I cannot I cannot win this game. Like I one example I have is with Molly House. Uh if you are playing against the Rookery, which is a restaurant in Juno and that we mentioned earlier and also the name of the solo mode, two different things. Um,

okay.

Though we probably would also see that per the the woodpecker in the this rookery as well.

Okay.

Um,

but in that game or in the when you play Molly House solo, uh, the rookery always just always diverts to one ending that is like very antithetical to the game because it always it it just always diverts to the community has been betrayed ending. Right.

And it's like, okay, well, it doesn't feel balanced because it doesn't feel like I can win the game trying to play it normally. I have to do this other weird thing, which isn't fun. Um,

yeah. Normally with co-op games or or solo games, I tend to say like I I want to lose the majority of time, but that's not necessarily true because I play one of my favorite solo games is Spirit Island and um and cooperative games. And to be honest, I tend to win in Spirit Island. Um, but I derive a ton of enjoyment out of it. Uh, and I think it's because, uh, I play at a difficulty level where, you know, like I I tend to play like one of the adversaries and I think like level two difficulty or something is kind of my sweet spot. But in that game, I can still feel the pressure. Like I the the adversaries, I see them, they are a problem. if I don't do something, I I perpetually feel like I'm on uh the back foot, but I'm making empowered decisions to react to that. And so that's really all I'm ever looking for out of a a solo or co-op game is to just feel like I'm

um I'm having a reasonable amount of pressure pushed against me and it's not that, you know, so it's so easy. I didn't really have to think about the game or get creative. Yeah. Uh or so hard that no matter how creative I got, there's just no opportunity for victory.

Yeah. And I feel like Spirit Island is

both a great game to use as as an example of this and also not a great game.

An exception. Well, it's because Spirit Island just gives the player so many levers to pull to adjust the difficulty level to whatever you would like it to be at the moment. Um, whereas there are a lot of solo games where it's just like, oh, this scenario is so difficult that I I don't have any levers to make it easier like that. This just is the scenario I'm playing as right now. Uh, and this is a difficult scenario to beat. Um,

I'm sorry you had that problem with Wingspan. I mean, someday you'll be able to

Someday you'll be able to beat the Corvettz.

Yeah.

Um, but yeah, I just think that it is uh it's a different aspect of balance that we didn't really touch on because we were talking more about like

competitive games,

competitive games. But it is like a super important note to have which is solo and co-op games have on top of on top of everything we've discussed here the difficult of balancing each scenario to be the right amount of difficulty. Um which if if I agree where it's like if it's too easy it's not really fun because it didn't really itch the scratch of like oh I'm solving a puzzle. Uh, and if it's too difficult, then it's just like, oh, I'm

running into a wall over and over again.

Um,

with cooperative games, you often run into the problem of like having just one player so much more powerful and carrying the team for everyone else, you know, like

Spirit Island can sometimes be that way. I I think if you know how to use a spirit and you like go into it from the beginning uh with the intention of kind of ringing the most out of the spirit, then you pretty much do it. But like I I've played lots of cooperative games over the years where it's like, whoa, your power is incredibly useful all the time. We are super relying on that. And my power is extremely niche. I'm like some merchant dude who, you know, like might come into play at some point possibly. Otherwise, I'm just kind of like a default pawn. That never feels really good. Um,

that really kind of

varies from game to game whether or not you want to have niche powers.

And players can also kind of self- select. Like if you know that this is like a fantasy role playing type of game and you're playing a healer. Yeah. Uh you're probably not going to be smacking some orcs upside the head and you might just be hanging back and healing, but you you chose to do that.

Yeah. Well, I was going to say that's that uh in set of watch uh Doomed Run, they have the merchant, which is a character you can play that is just like

everybody could only have at most two item slots. So like at most you're getting seven uses of your power throughout the 12 scenarios. Like it's just it's sometimes not helpful. This was something that I actually found very cool about uh Fate of the Fellowship, the the recent pandemic system game.

Um you play, every player plays with two characters and on your turn you take four actions with one and one action with the other, but you can alternate from turn to turn who takes uh more less actions.

Um and I found all of the characters interesting in one way or another. Um, and some of them are a little bit more cinematic, you know, like Gimly can recruit dwarves for free, which is kind of cool, but freaking Aowin can slay Naz Ghoul permanently from the board, and you're like, "Oh, damn. She She's the only one who can do that. Someone's playing as her, you can just permanently remove Naz Ghoul. Whoa." Um, and if no one's playing as her, then you can't do that. Uh but nonetheless, I I find that game does a really good job at having interesting differences between the characters uh and uh having them dynamic and thematic while maintaining some sort of even keel of capabilities amongst all the players at the table.

Totally. Um our next comment comes from Give Pause Hobby. Uh I'm curious to listen

Kyle Frost. Kyle Frost. Hello.

Uh yeah, uh Give Paws Hobby hasn't been putting out as many videos uh recently, but uh has been a former guest on this channel and uh uh supporter over the years and all around cool guy.

Hi Kyle. Kyle commented, "Uh I'm curious to listen to see how Harvest plays into the discussion. Honestly, I love the game and can't wait for the expansion. Raiders and Pillagers coming soon. Key master, get on it. Uh,

it's locked in. Eric Lang, guest designer of Raiders and Pillagers, the Blood Rage expansion to

Exactly. to uh it doesn't hit the table as often as I'd like, and I don't have any strong feelings whether or not it fits the bill. That said, I just played OG Lords of Water Deep, no expansions even, and I will die on the hill that the builder lord just shouldn't be in the mix. I feel like the people I play with, myself included, are already naturally inclined to build in that game. So, I've both had games where someone got way too much bang for something they were already going to buy and others where the player who had her just got perpetually pushed out by other players just doing the water deep landlord thing. So, I guess maybe that evens it out. I don't know. I don't like how she plays, so I just never shuffle her in with the others. And all the players know that.

Strong disagree, Kyle, uh with you here. Uh I think every other lord should be as interesting as the builder lord. Uh I think that's a perfect example of where uh the the interesting aspects of the characters were shaved off. She has a thing where it engages with the mechanics of the game that is unique to her. She gets extra points for the buildings. Great. The buildings are a cool aspect of the game. Everyone else is like, "Well, I get extra points for warfare and piety or piety and skull duggery or skull duggery and arcana or arcana and warfare." And it is just

so perfectly even. And I I really do love Lords Waterde, but it is uh kind of in that trap of you can see through the matrix, you know, to the point where it's an Excel sheet and it's like, well, one orange is of this value, so two oranges have to equal one character placement of one white or purple. And so therefore, if you're getting a quest that's going to give you X number of points, you need to have a perfect amount of resource output and like all kinds of

stuff where it feels like

it's it's not the

stripping away some of the

It's not the builder lord's fault that all the other lords are

less fun and less interesting. I agree. I agree with that sentiment. Side note, side note, Builder Lord, uh my wife, her favorite game, uh Christina's favorite game is Lords of Water Deep. Uh she also loves the digital Lords of Water Deep. She knows how many games of that she can get in a flight from Anchorage to Juno or Juno to Anchorage, uh which she plays every time. And she generally, not all the time, but most of the time will restart the game until she gets the Builder Lord just because it's her favorite. I think it's because she likes how the builder lord looks more than anything. Like all the other characters kind of have some whack artwork.

Yeah, I agree.

But

yeah, she likes the builder lord and she wants to build buildings and she's like, "This is the one that I want to play and if I'm playing by myself, I'm just going to restart until I get the builder lord."

Yeah. And I agree. I think that I I see both sides of the argument, which is one, the other lord should just be more interesting and should meet it. And also I can see why it being house ruled out makes total sense cuz I do kind of agree where it's it is the only odd one out in terms of balance. All right, here's my petition. I want a Lords of Water Deep Second Edition. Um, one, uh, the needs a better box. Uh, it's got a cool thematic box, but I think, uh, a better box could happen. Uh, two, um, it needs better artwork. Uh, I think the board art is amazing. I think the illustrations are very hit or miss. Um, love domesticating owl bears.

Uh, three, uh, it should just have Skullport in there from the very beginning. It should. Four, I agree with that. It has better lords. Uh, just more dynamic, interesting, uh, lord powers. um either just public powers and make it devoid of points or just you know give points for doing different things that kind of incentivize different uh paths in the game. And then uh lastly uh I think it should uh maybe have an included mini expansion that allows for dualclassed uh uh workers um not workers but

really cool. I'm I'm

like you should You should have a monk uh that is like a a I don't know a warrior thief

or or cleric of warrior as a paladin or something. Yeah,

I can see that. Or and then warrior wizard

blad singer.

That's a fifth edition reference

and other probably other editions.

Um

yeah,

color combo cube. You know, you could make the cube half of each of those colors or you a blend of those colors or whatever and could be spent as either or giving you greater flexibility, but maybe they're harder to get. I don't know. Get on it. Wizards of the coast. Listen, you you're making other you got you're making the license. I got right here. Builders of Balders's Gate, Dungeon and Dragons. It is it is out. You are making D and D board games. Read up it. I'm here for that. Um, one thing that I wanted to touch on with Kyle's comment, which I I want to touch on it because you just mentioned it, which is the builder lord is interesting and the other ones should be risen up to that. I actually when I play Wingspan with the Oceanana expansion, I add the Corvids back in because the Ocean expansion has so many interesting ones that I feel like can compete with them that I

at that point I think they are no longer like a detriment to the fun of the game

and and the egg row is made less powerful. So you can't immediately take advantage of that. You have to lean into it harder to really take advantage of the corid.

Exactly. So then if it's that's that goes back to make the other lords more interesting and more powerful.

Don't don't take the builder lord down. Raise everybody else up.

Uh I agree with that.

Um but

yeah I think I kind of I agree with I agree with these thoughts of Lords of Water Deep second edition. Um, our last comment comes from Cameron Art, who is uh one of the developers for Harvest. Uh, his comment is, "Funny to see Harvest here. I was on the dev team and we spent so much time play testing all the levers of asymmetry in this game." Thank you. Thank you for doing that. Uh, I'm a big fan of asymmetric power players, player powers in games, but they are some of the trickiest things to design. They have to simultaneously be interesting, fun, functional, and as balanced as you can reasonably make them. Most publishers also just can't get the critical mass of testing you would need to truly balance asymmetric powers. So, there's also a lot of mathematically trying to evaluate the relative value of a power over the course of an entire game. It's hard. And I agree that's I said in the post that it is one of the trickiest problems in game design and I fully agree with that where it's it it just we said it earlier you just are not ever I feel like going to be able to get to perfectly balanced asymmetry uh without it being like without it being just like a colorcoded Excel sheet where it's

yep

one green is worth two blue which is worth one white and those are the only like that is you can see the Excel spreadsheet when you do it where it's like one wizard and one cleric are worth two warriors and two rogues

like those are the only that's that is it

and four and four gold

and four gold and there's

y

you can you can exchange them at certain points of the game but that is that is the exchange rate and there's nothing that is like inherently different other than some quests are going to ask for white cubes and some quests are going to ask for red cubes but those are like the only differences that between them other than this one is worth two of this one

right

yeah and and perception is a big part of balance as well that I got to imagine is a problem for asymmetry I mean that again with harvest you know the perception that you know this seems imbalance balance and then you have a confirmation bias aspect. Um, and also there's like how much will an experience versus a new player know how to take advantage of one? Like some asymmetric powers are very obvious how to take advantage of them. whereas others may be more nuanced and maybe with a lot of play testing they do come out relatively evenly matched but it takes a lot more experience and guile to really uh take advantage of them. I think a huge problem for um the cats in Root is that they get points earlier on in the game and so then they get beat down. Whereas the other factions, particularly the Woodland Alliance and the Vagabond, they don't really get points at the beginning of the game.

They get points at the end of the game and they start getting

huge amounts of points. And so there there's this subconscious uh need to keep the cats in check because they're already all across the board. They seem so powerful at the beginning that people will inherently start picking on them when some very very experienced players may be like, "Yo, we just got to keep the woodland alliance in check from the very beginning and not let that become a problem." Um and if that were the case, then maybe the cats would have more

Yeah. And I think that it is maybe easy to lean on root because it is very much a the players can decide the balance of the game for the most part. Um,

right. But like with something like Harvest, I I would be really interested and maybe I'll I will reach out to you Cameron about uh chatting with you about this. But there are so many small levers to pull that I I can see being worried about like which is there a combination because there's so many permutations. Is there a combination that is just inherently less interesting or more powerful than all the other combinations? Because every time I've played it has been the choice between those always is interesting to me. And I I can't tell immediately which one of these is going to be more powerful, but I I will just choose the one that I'm like, "Oh, this seems these seem like these should link up." Um,

right. So, I'd be interested to see I what what things got rejected? I That's maybe something I I will have to uh

release the Gary files.

Release release the

Gary's the mayor, right? I think Gary's the mayor.

Yeah, Gary. Uh

Gary the cow.

Gary the cow. Well, I want to see Gary's file. I also want to see uh like a raccoon faction that just goes and steals everybody else's things.

Terrible.

Where did he go? Where did he go? He definitely was in the game. I know. I know it.

Definitely.

Um

yeah,

but that that's something that I think

it'll be fun. I'll message him. We'll see. Maybe. No promises.

No promises. Well, thank you so much for tuning in. Uh, this was a really fun discussion. If you have something that you think is going to make for a fun discussion, we we have one that we're currently grappling with exactly how to approach it. We've we've gotten a topic suggestion that we are working on. If you have one, please send it our way. There are a few different avenues you can do. Cardboard herald@gmail.com. You can comment on whatever platform you are on. Uh the cardboard herald.com I believe has a contact form on it. Feel free to reach out in whatever way you would like to. Uh we'd be interested to talk about things that you would like to have us talk about. Um if you have any thoughts on balance, feel free to comment those on whatever platform you are on. Uh thank you everybody for listening in and tuning into our discussion. Um, thank you to the two people on Reddit who led listed the Cardboard Herald as one of their favorite YouTube board game channels.

We're on there. I didn't comment,

but I somebody made a post today that said, "What's your favorite YouTube channels for board games?" We had two comments.

Love it.

Love it.

We're We're getting there.

We're getting there. One day, three comments. Um, but thank you all so much for tuning in. Uh, I have been Eric with the Cardboard Herald joined by Jack. Later.

Progress saved