Skip to main content
Loading video...

Luthier and how publishing impacts game design with Dave Beck of Paverson Games - TCbH Interview

Transcript 38:16

Hello, welcome back to another episode of the Cardboard Herald. My guest today is talking with creative gamers and game creators and today I'm joined by Dave Beck once again of Paverson Games. Welcome back to the show. Thanks man, happy to be here. Yeah, you're coming from the HQ. Is that your game room? Yeah, it is. It's my game room / storage facility / office which is a lot I'm sitting on. Yeah, those are all the boxes I've got Luthier prototypes stacked on one side and the boxes to send them out on the other. So, it's kind of chaos here. All watched over by Jim Henson in the background. Of course, always. And Bob Dylan. He Oh, Dylan's Henson's on one side and Dylan's on the other. So, Love it, love it. I got some of my favorite movies over here on the side, some movie posters. So, you know, like we we're always looking for inspiration as creative types.

So, I don't know if you know this, but um people seem to be kind of into Luthier. I That's That's what I've discovered a little bit. That that Kickstarter, I was looking at the funding goal and and yes, I know that, you know, the funding goal is really the there's a lot of maybe horse trading that goes into what you set as the funding goal versus what you're, you know, actually needing to have, you know, a successful game launch and everything. But, you have a funding goal of $40,000 and what was it like 750,000 is what ended up getting pledged? Yeah, 790, 789, something like that ended up getting pledged. Yeah, it was crazy. Yeah, that's that's nearly a cool mill.

And what was it like doing this as your follow-up to Distilled? Because, you know, Distilled was of course getting a a lot of heat, a lot of positive reception. You had delivered it and it came up on a lot of year-end lists. You had this momentum. But, was it different going into Luthier as a more experienced publisher? It was. It was actually very much more different than I expected. I think part of it was I I felt this a certain amount of weight on me or I don't know if expectations is the right word. Part of that is for sure. I kept second-guessing what I was doing. The first time when I did this, I didn't know what the heck I was doing. So, I I was just I was doing what I thought was right at every step of the way. I, you know, I for that funding goal, I think it was like 18,000 or something like that. And I really did think I would maybe get to 50,000. If I got to 100,000, that would be crazy. I couldn't So, I ended up adding adding stretch goals on top of stretch goals on top of stretch goals there. Things I didn't even plan for.

Well, with Luthier, I said I'm not going to do that this time. I'm just going to build this thing exactly as I think I would want it and what I think other people would want too and offer that up. But, going into this too, I just it just I wasn't sure like am I spending enough ahead of time getting enough prototypes to go look at? Am I doing that right? Am I doing this right? Was Distilled just cuz people really like whiskey? Do people like music? I don't I think they do, but I don't know. Do people like one of the keystone art form that has been around since humanity has existed? Are they into it? Are they? Who knows? You're right. But, but you know what I mean? Like Will people react to a game called Luthier? They probably don't even know what that is or they they see a violin type thing on the cover. Okay, never mind. I like rock music. I don't want it. You know, so it's like that that type of thing where I was always second-guessing myself up until really until I I hit launch and even after that thinking like oh, is this going to go well? But, at a certain point you just got to step back and say especially once you you pass your funding goal and then some and you just step back and say hey, this is great. Like whatever this I just want to enjoy this. And that's what we really tried to do with the campaign is create a space for people to enjoy and come together and talk about music and history and that type of thing as well.

One of the things that has always occurred to me in talking to you is you really do seem like someone who's both a very I guess thoughtful game designer as you should be as a professor of game design. But, also as savvy businessman. Like you've reached out to me to do interviews in the past. That's how we first hooked up. You've been very conscientious about making time for content creators. You're doing things like getting prototypes in the hands of top-tier backers. Um Was there ever any point with Paverson Games that you were thinking about do I actually want to like start this as a business or do I want to pitch the Distilled to other publishers and, you know, just kind of focus on being a designer? Yeah, yeah. I definitely did.

I I had when I first came up with the idea for Distilled and then playtested it a couple times and knew that it was something that I wanted to keep going with. I decided I would ask my friend Eric Evenson who lives in town with me. He teaches at the university. He did the art and the graphic design for Distilled. I would ask him, "Hey Eric, do you want to do this with me? Do you want to do the art and graphic design? I'll do the design. And let's make this happen." And I said I remember saying to myself, "Okay, if Eric says yes, I'm going to do it. If he says no, I'm going to take this to other publishers because I don't even know where to begin. But, at least with him I could do that." And so, I I kind of I guess I could blame Eric a little bit. Like he said yes. You're the reason these cardboard boxes are in the background. Exactly. LOOK AT LOOK WHAT YOU'VE DONE, ERIC. LOOK WHAT YOU'VE CREATED.

Um so, I think that's part of it is that I did leave it to that. I really did. Um once that happened, because up until that point, maybe within days of that point before that, I didn't want to nothing to do with the idea of a Kickstarter at all. I I remember people saying, "Oh, you should do a Kickstarter." Not with the board games, but other my video games and stuff I'd done. No, I can't even imagine doing that. So, there was this point where once I realized I had someone in my corner in the case of Eric there too, I could maybe this it felt doable. And then that that then interestingly turned into this concept of as I was working on Distilled and discovered that business side of it. Discovered the side of like what you were talking about connecting with people like you and others, connecting with the backers. I realized oh man, I really like this business side. Like I really I really like this. And I like design too and I don't have enough space to do both full-time all the time. But, what I can do is every so often kind of work on some design stuff, but then also work on some business stuff. And so, that's kind of how how I've grown to to into my role at the company, you know, as the owner or whatever. But, also designing when I can too.

Do you feel like Luthier through the development? Because I I I know a little bit of the story leading up to it and kind of the the original genesis with another designer and then co-design and development. We talked about that at PAX Unplugged last year. But, with you having more perspective, having been a publisher coming out of Distilled, do you think that impacted how you developed and worked on the game? Because you have more considerations when you have, you know, like actually consulted manufacturers or, you know, had feedback about usability or accessibility. Like how much did your being involved on the business side impact how you approach your game design with Luthier? Yeah.

Great question. A huge amount actually. Um One thing that I I discovered with Distilled was that of course it's most important to create an engaging interesting game experience for sure, hands down. That's why we're making games. But, if I can integrate elements of art and that might be visual art, elements of what makes you maybe feel like you're working with kind of a luxury product or experiencing luxury product, I'm going to do that even if it's going to cost a little bit more money. And so, with Luthier and I learned that from Distilled and I saw that from people enjoying Distilled in certain ways. So, with Luthier, what I've decided to do is really lean into that. So, in addition to just the the base game this time, I have created two We've created two different games.

Sorry, different versions of the game. Both of course having all the same gameplay mechanics, but one really leaning hard into kind of luxury, deluxe, etc., etc. And I don't think without Distilled's with if I didn't have Distilled's experience, I don't think I would have done that because I wouldn't have realized the possibilities to keep Like you said, working with manufacturers, knowing the questions to ask, knowing what I can push, ideas I can come up with as well. Sometimes they don't even have to do with the game. They're just like fun accessories that people can get too. And that's again, I think the business side of me coming out realizing I think some people are going to enjoy this. I'm not going to make them get it, but if they want to pay extra for this, I might as well provide that experience for them as well. With Luthier, let's actually get into like some of the game itself and some of the choices that you made.

Because this is a crowded market these days. There are more good games that are coming out than ever before and it's not like they're completely outclassing all the games that came in the past. I mean, I'm looking at your shelf and you have everything from Dominion to Rising Sun. You know, Tapestry is up there and people have only so much space and you only have so much opportunity as a designer to say, well, this is worker placement but with a theme you haven't done before. Yeah. Like how do you make sure that what you're doing is innovative and new and satisfying like your hunger as a fan of games as a gamer who wants to try new things. Like what sets Luthier apart mechanically other than introducing people to this world of, you know, classical music and and instrument making that they might not have been exposed to in the past.

Yeah, the the probably the number one thing is probably the number one thing most people comment about as well. Um, it's what I was attracted to the game from the very beginning about was this mechanic that Abe Burton, the person I'm co-designing the game with, um, he came up with this mechanic in his first iteration of Luthier which we call hidden bidding worker placement. Um, that's might not be the best uh, description but essentially what it is is that we have family members that are part of our group and in the case of him at the time it wasn't actually family members but the same concept where they're represented by these discs and on one side is just a crest. It's blank. Whatever. On the other side though, there's a number of one through five. And so when I if you and I are playing, I might send my one of my workers, my family members, out onto the board somewhere. You can go to that location as well. You're going to go on top of me but these are all face down.

So, only I know the skill of the worker I'm sending there. Only you know the skill of the worker you're sending there. Sometimes if you send a worker of a certain skill, you get a bonus. Um, if you send a worker even if you're behind me in line, if you will, and you send a worker that has a higher skill number than me, then you're going to butt to the front of the line. So, there's this I found when I even when I played the very first time of Abe's prototype uh, years ago, this thing kind of called out to me as this is really interesting. It's not right there yet but it's close and it's really interesting and how can we tie this to this idea of again, family which wasn't in before. Um, so the way I describe it now is five is you, the master luthier in your workshop. One is your little kid, Jimmy, that started yesterday in the shop, right? So, they no skill. They can still do things but they don't have much skill. So, you might send them to do simple errands like go to the market or do do something like that while you might be the one working on the instrument cuz you're going to get more bonuses out of it that way. So, we've really tried to integrate again, theme and mechanics but I would say that is the the the number one. There's lots of other things going on that I think are are unique but nothing is as unique as that. Um, uh, and you know, I think there's he definitely talks about how uh, Abe talks about how he was in he took some inspiration from Caylus with that.

Um, I think he mentions another game now I can't remember that I haven't played um, as well. But so, I think there's other games that have done some stuff with this but as far as specifically hidden bidding worker placement where you you flip it over and then you resolve that action. That was something that we felt was was fairly unique. Um, maybe it exists out there before but it's something that we wanted to kind of build the game around. Did you have any reticence with the complexity? I mean, that that does take a lot of uh, mental energy and fortitude to think about like, well, I want to bid on different things and I have different strength of workers and, you know, what could other people possibly be working with? I mean, that that is uh, I guess in an age of um, trending towards more streamlined games, uh, shorter play times, more concise play space, um, this game visually looks more robust and uh, mechanically looks more robust. Not overly complicated but maybe not to the the general gaming tastes out there. Was that a concern at all while you were planning this out? It was. It was. It was honestly a concern. It was a it still is today something that I I think about like, could we should we have could we have made this less less complex? Um, it sits at around a 3.5 3.75 I would say out of five um, with the still being more like a three.

So, it was a pretty big jump. Um, but I there it was really we we kept stepping back from it and saying like, what is it that we would take out? And we just felt everything connected so well with the different mechanics and the different locations you could go on the table that we decided, no, you know, I think this is going to be the big game. That this is going to be the the main event of that night. You get together and you play this and only this. You don't you don't play this a warm up and then this, you know. Um, so it was and so I think that's probably part of why I decided to go all in on everything. Once we realized we had designed something that was a little bit bigger, let's make this a bit let's let's like you said, let's visually communicate how big this is. Let's uh, have lots of rich art and uh, components that you can see that are that are kind of playing into this as well. Um, the game ships with two rule books just like Distilled, one that kind of teaches you how to play for that reason Um, but yeah, we we decided that uh, we might as well lean into this even though I completely agree with you Jack like that idea of more streamlined, smaller table space, shorter games is something that continues to be popular. We're just kind of bucking the trend a little bit here and saying, nah, we're going to we're going to make something big.

People are hungry for it and I I think that that is just like one of those things, you know, they talk about fashion how it just goes in cycles, you know, things go in 20 year cycles. I know that when I was first getting into box board games, you know, probably about 15 years ago now, that was like right at the heyday of Fantasy Flight Games coming out with these big three and a half hour games and everything. Um, Eurogames were also taking ages to to play these incredibly uh, esoteric and complex games and then over periods of time, it kind of trended to that, you know, almost like a a half an hour expectation. How do we get it as streamlined as possible? But now I'm seeing more and more designers kind of bucking that trend and it seems like it's um, uh, it it's being well received even on a mainstream scale. I mean, obviously your Kickstarter did very well.

Uh, Arcs is another example of something that's very uh, complex and kind of weird uh, and can take a a larger play time and a larger commitment. Um, and then even things like a lot of GMT games uh, that are coming out now uh, have a lot of rules overhead but are getting more mainstream exposure. So, maybe it's just all working in cycles. However, you now as a publisher, you have to think about catalog and is that something that you think about for like the future? You know, you have Distilled and maybe Luthier is kind of the upper weight. Are you already looking at, well, what's the next game that we're going to publish and do I need to fill out a catalog so I'm not internally competing with myself? Yeah, great question. Yes. Uh, yes, yes, yes. So, what I've tried to develop is kind of a some pillars that I stick between um, uh, roughly 2.5 to 3.5 as far as complexity. So, we've got uh, Luthier on the top end, Distilled in the middle, uh, going kind of a little bit lighter as well if we want to but really always focusing on theme and mechanics and that integration is super important. Um, so yeah, we've got we've got a couple uh, titles down the road. Nothing to announce yet but uh, um, we were hoping to be able to start doing about one a year. Yeah. So, um, Distilled was la- launched Kickstarter launched in 2021. This was 2024. So,

that was a three year gap. So, now I'm really trying to kind of crank it up and focus a little bit more on it. Um, I I used to be in a much bigger role at my university as kind of director of the school. I've stepped back to just be uh, teaching professor game design. Uh, so I'm hoping that that's going to allow me to balance things out a little bit more but yeah, to answer your question, really trying to think about how I can continue to create kind of what I like to call exquisite experiences, you know, really cool opportunities at the table for people to gather around and whether it's creating narratives or just visually taking in what they see. Um, uh, and hope I can continue to do that with different sorts of themes. Uh, and not not always just you know, someone said to me at a I think it was at Gen Con. And it's fine cuz I realized without without realizing it, uh, they said something like, oh yeah, everything you do is about handcrafting. So, I can't wait to see what the next thing you do is handcrafting. So, I'm like, oh crap. I don't know if that's going to be the case here but but anyway, so um, uh, yeah, that's that's something I need to be aware of. It's not competing with myself but also last thing I'll say on this that I don't know. I I'll I'll be curious to see look back in a couple years at the catalog we've created because um, as an artist and designer throughout my life, I've always jumped from project to project and there there hasn't been a a real obvious continuation. So, for instance, um, when I was in grad school, I was

doing a lot of sculpture and 3D modeling animation stuff and friends of mine who are painters or printmakers, oh, here's another body of work that is more portraits. Like Right, right. You could point out you could be like, oh yeah, that was by that person. Or, you know, you can even do that with famous artists. With I'm all over the place always. So, I have a feeling that my game the games that my company are going to release are also going to do that. And it's just going to have to be like, yeah, you want to be along for the ride? Here's the next one I'm coming out with, you know, it's not another whiskey game. It's not like beer this time or rock music next time. Like I'm going to jump around to different themes that are just interesting to me if that makes sense. Yeah, that totally makes sense. And you mentioned that you got this question at a convention. And that was something that also occurred to me when we were talking again at PAX Unplugged last year is you've been showing Luthier for a long time. You had this enormous headway. How much did that public exposure impact the development of the game? Like did you ever have pivotal moments that changed the game on fundamental levels based off of being able to get it in front of so many people at an early stage?

Totally. Yeah, so yeah, I would have often times for about a year and a half yeah, about a year about a year. For about a year before the Kickstarter, I decided to have a prototype out that had in certain cases over in the UK Games Expo had no art, no graphic design. But I had people playing it cuz I just thought, you know what? Like I want to show people the backside of how I'm doing this. Like the the the back end of the development process and and get their feedback. To your point like can I gather some feedback when they're talk all talking about a certain thing or comment on a certain thing that helps quite a lot. So, yeah, that definitely happened. I I'm I can't think of one exact pivotal moment, I don't think. Because honestly, like whether it's us play testing on online with Discord and Tabletop Simulator or us play testing in person. But I can say, you know, I I take I take the game I would take the game to Proto Spiels other prototyping, you know, play testing events.

And some of the the how the orchestra is situated right now is completely due to that. How at one point I had polyomino tiles that were representing instruments and it was like it was not working at all. I was convinced that I could do that. but this ain't it. Yeah, exactly. So, and that was that was based on feedback so from people that it's just is so so important. And then I would say that um watching how people some people learn, how people interact with the game has definitely caused me to make some decisions in working with the graphic designers on developing, you know, certain things in certain ways as far as iconography or how it's laid out on the board. So, definitely for sure with some of that. And then one last thing about that too that not doesn't have to do with the game necessarily, but when we were demoing it actually I think it was at maybe it was at PAX Unplugged that this happened. When we were demoing it, we would have you know, I would have somebody either myself or someone else that's basically teaching the game. It's it's running the game. We we have a a setup where the whole first round like I said teaches how to play in the second rulebook. And so someone's running that. Well, at the time, I think it was even called the rehearsal and the person runs it is called the conductor. And basically this idea was suggested you know, what would be really helpful is I if I'm a conductor, I should have a baton.

And I thought, oh, that's that's funny. Well, I decided, you know what? We need to get a baton in the game. In fact, here's my um uh and I started giving batons to every single one of my music conducting batons to every single one of my demoers at the convention. And before I knew it, not only were they saying I'm never going to demo a game ever again without this thing, but I started having other people from other booths coming up to me and saying, do you have any more of those batons? Like I'd really like to do it. So, I mark my words. Dave Beck with the Luthier game cuz this is actually part of the Kickstarter people can get a baton in the game to be able to teach the game to their to their friends. It it makes things so much easier. So, that's an example of something that I wouldn't have been able to pick up just play testing at home with people online. It was out in in public realized, oh, this is another thematic element that I can use that's really helpful for all my games now. I'm going to use batons. Right, right, right, right. You're going to have to theme them all around batons somehow. You're going to have like an old London copper game, you know, you're going to have like a billy club baton.

Um Vincent Dutrait, you've hired the main man to do so many illustrations. There are so many great art assets for this game. And many companies at your stage who only have one game already published and you're just working on your sophomore game here would have felt honored to just have their box art done by Vincent Dutrait. You went ahead and said, let's get all of these character portraits and not just of, you know, random people, but you would have some iconic individuals as well as period appropriate styles and looks and also geeks like me who are way into instruments and the history of music we're going to care a lot about how these things are represented. So, tell me about that experience of hiring Vincent Dutrait and also like what was your role as the publisher and designer? Like how are you giving notes and feedback and you know, like how much direction were you giving on that? Yeah.

So, Vincent is my all-time favorite board game artist. And it really always has been. I've just always loved his work. And so, when I knew I was publishing this, the first person I reached out to was him. I wrote a long very personal letter to him about about like why I think he would be great for describing a little bit for him too. Hoping there's maybe some way I didn't know. I I really didn't know if that would be something that he'd be interested in. I couldn't believe it when he replied. I think part of it was because um uh he had meant he's he's he plays the piano. He played the piano growing up as well. But then also um his grandfather was a woodworker. He had a wood shop back in France. And so, I think that connection really helped as well, which is wonderful. Um Vincent's great. He actually lives in Korea. So, he his fam he and his family live in Korea even though he's originally from France. And so, our time zones really don't work. Like And and so, we really developed a wonderful, I think, method of communication through email where it would basically be every day I would write him and then wait I'd wake up the next day to find a response from him and we'd go back and forth. I think due to the fact that I have an art background, I I'd like to think he appreciated that, but I really got involved perhaps more than the typical publisher might with that.

And showed and maybe that demonstrated to him how committed I was. What I tried to do was since I knew that that he would do wonderfully with as much freedom as he could have within that space. Um we had kind of some initial overviews of of what that might look like, but then just kind of let him loose on that. And then of course, the reason I also did that cuz I knew certain things he couldn't like certain things we've got almost 40 different people in the game that we well, we do have 40 different people in the game we represent historical characters. Now, only probably uh half to two two-thirds of them actually have some sort of portrait of them. Some of them we're just making up. And he did it wonderfully there too. So, that was great. And then with the instruments too. So, what I did was I went out and found three examples of every single instrument and every single uh person that we had visual examples of and provided them to him and then just said, here's kind of the some of the ones I'm thinking. The musical instruments had to represent that era. So, I don't have a guitar. I have a baroque guitar. So, I have examples of a baroque guitar.

I don't have a flute necessarily that we know of as a a metal flute. It's a wood flute cuz that's what they were made of at that point. So, I sent him pictures of those. I sent him videos. There's a really great there's a couple really great channels that do basically they talk about and then play historical instruments. It was really fun to send him those too. And then last but not least, um I knew although I've got a really strong interest in history and music, I am not by any means uh um a well-versed musician nor someone that could really speak to the history of music as a specialist. So, I hired a consultant that is a musicologist. He's he lives in Canada. He's got a PhD in music history. And so, I worked with him on cuz we're going to have biographies and everything in the rulebook of all the different musicians and the instruments too. And so, I worked with him to make sure that what I was what I thought I was finding from Wikipedia was actually the truth, which as we know sometimes it's not. So, Speaking of Rising Sun back there, um Yeah, yeah, exactly. Exactly. I didn't want to have one of those situations that turned out to be just a Wikipedia entry and not actual cultural historically accurate. Right, right, right. Um Well, you know, like how much of like identifying an aesthetic and a style did you do because you know, Vincent Dutrait

while there's a certain iconic visual aesthetic that he brings to the table, did you point to specific references of, you know, I want it to evoke this or you know, like this is the kind of look that I want this game to have. Yeah, that's Yeah, that's a good good follow-up there. So, the game technically takes place spans a couple hundred years. So, it's basically Baroque through Romantic. We've got kind of late 17th century through late 19th century. So, it's a couple hundred years that it technically spans as far as characters and instruments. And so, what I wanted What I did was I sent him a number of different examples of portraiture, as well as buildings, building illustrations, architectural illustrations from that time period to try and evoke that as well.

I knew just based on his experience just as an artist that he would probably do more than enough research in terms of being able to to find that style that fits. But, I also knew that that's why I wrote reached out to him. I I said from the beginning to him, and I knew this wouldn't be a problem cuz this is how he works anyway. I said, I want this to feel like it could have been made in this time period to a certain degree. Yeah. Yeah. Maybe a little bit brighter colors than than it actually is. But, as much as I possibly can. In fact, as I was talking with him about it, originally I of course I expected and and asked and and planned for him to do everything. And at a certain point, early on, he said, "You know, I can do all this, but actually there's someone else I'd like to recommend for the the the main board game. Sorry, the main board of the game, which is a giant building kind of spans multi-floors and has an orchestra in the center. And his name was Guillaume Tavernier, and he's a French artist who is actually known mainly for doing maps for like RPGs and dungeons and kind of orthographic 3D, but kind of broken away where you can kind of see into these spaces.

And once he pointed the work out, I loved it cuz it felt like it was looked looked like a lot of it was maybe done with watercolors and really takes an architectural approach to it. So, that was actually really interesting to have that be a third component where I'm working with Vincent, but then I'm also working with Guillaume, and then Guillaume is working with Vincent as well. Right. And so, that the result was really great. The central board is done by Guillaume and then kind of embellished by Vincent to make sure it matches colors and everything else with with the cards that are going to lay on that table, too. Yeah, the board has just a wonderful dimensionality to it, you know, like it's as if you're an audience or a participant in it. It has a different aesthetic and and visual presence than a lot of boards. I think is a better way to put it than the typical just flat two-dimensional look to a lot of things. Now, I could spend all day you know, picking apart both Luthier and just anything to do with game design with you. But, given that you're a games professor, I I do want to just get your take on luck to kind of wrap this out.

You know, like when you're thinking about designing games and usability, whether they're video games or they're they're tabletop games, is there a certain tolerance for luck that you find is both like your preference, as well as like what you advise your students to think about when it comes to luck in games and and how much you account for if it that's impacted by the weight or length of the game or style of game? Yeah. Great question. So, I I definitely think about that. The way I like to think about luck in games, and you kind of noted on it briefly there, is I I think of it as kind of like a a spectrum or a scale. A scale maybe is better.

Where the more luck in the game, the shorter that game should be. Okay. The long the But, at the same time, the more strategy in the game, let's say, or the the more weight, if you will, if speaking in BGG terms, in the game, and if there's luck present, I think it needs to be mitigatable. It has to be. You don't want to play a game that lasts 2 hours where you have a bad couple rolls and you're done. Like there's no way you can That's no fun for anybody. So, I really try and with my students, but also with the games I designed to try and create that. We've got Distilled where you're of course shuffling up cards and you're pulling the top of the bottom card off, and those go out, and you could bust. Well, you could have made sure to get enough cards in there, so even if you pull them out, you still are fine, right?

In Luthier, it's the same way. We have one small moment of luck in the game. You roll some dice to do a performance. But, we've designed it in a way that you could play the whole game and never do a performance. It's your choice. It's I like to call it an auxiliary strategy. It's one of the supporting auxiliary strategy that you can do in the game, but you don't have to. And even so, completely mitigatable. Like if if you work and invest in that space and you decide to lean into that, it can really work out in your favor. So, it's that kind of thing where I really try and think about length and weight. If there is luck in the game, it better be mitigatable. And if it's a longer game, you know, there probably should be a little less luck. Or in the case of like what I just said, it's an optional thing that you don't have to necessarily pull into. For you, do you find some element of luck to be a necessity to prevent a game from being too deterministic? Yes.

all the time you'll see people online like, "Oh, I hate luck in games. I hate random chance in games." But, I think a lot about like, say, Go, which, you know, Go is a fabulous game. Turns out people like Go, and it's been around for a couple years. However, that's like one of those games where, you know, like you have to have a peer at a similar skill level, otherwise you're just going to get decimated. And luck is one of the ways that you can allow for, you know, those climatic outcomes, you know, the unexpected turn of events. Hopefully, that's not the only determining factor, but it does even the playing field, right? Yeah. No, hands down. I think there I personally believe there has to be some element of luck in a game for for that to be something that I'm interested in playing with other people, especially, and a variety of different people multiple different times. I think you hit it on the head by saying that, you know, Go is a phenomenal game. Chess is a fantastic game. But, those games only truly work if you're playing someone that is at the same skill level as you.

It is impossible, I'll say, for someone to even compete with someone that isn't without without some element of luck in that case. So, when we think about games, of course we've got some games where the luck really is, you know, when some people say, "No, I don't like luck in games at all." Well, guess what? If you've got cards at all in a game and you're turning cards over, there's luck in that. It's random. It's a just a an element of randomness, but it's still that idea of luck. When am I pulling that certain card out if I'm shuffling pulling that out? So, but then obviously people equate luck with dice rolls or or bag pulls or something that's very much luck-focused. I just think personally that luck is the thing that creates those memorable experiences. And those moments the table that can change from one game to the next and not just someone that gets really good at something and just says, "I have already figured out my the next 17 turns, and I am going to win because of that."

That's fine, but that to me isn't a game. That's not That's not That's not something where people are sitting around the table and making memories. That's more of like a competition on seeing who is the best player. Right. So, it's it's different. They're both games, but they're different types of experiences, you know. Well, one way or another, whether it was luck or determination, I'm glad that I've had the opportunity to meet and talk with you so many times. And this has been an absolute pleasure. For everyone who's been listening, I'll have the details on Luthier, so you can keep up with that. And also check out Distilled, which is available now. Thanks for coming on the show. Thanks, Jack.

Progress saved