Should You (or I) Buy Brass: Pittsburgh?
Transcript
Hello everyone. My name is Phil and I'm a doctor who likes to play and talk about board games. If you've watched my latest top 10 board games of all time video, you'll know that Brass Birmingham is on that list. It's in the top three. In fact, I would include Lancaster in that spot, too, because I just really love the brass system. So, knowing that Brass Pittsburgh is set to kickstart and release this year, I'm very keen on learning more about this new version of brass and trying it. The major question I have is though, despite the hype, is this game worth purchasing or backing? If I already have a copy of Brass, of which I do. I have Brass B&M at home. I'll leave you my thoughts, which are of course not sponsored by anyone. I have not played Brass Pittsburgh. I've only seen what other folks have said about it. uh both on the game found page with all the updates from the designers and others and of course the other content creators who have made videos. And so based off of the concepts that are introduced from those sources, I want to help myself as well as potentially help you decide if it's worth backing at this time. And if by the time this recording comes out, there's more information that is available by the time the uh Kickstarter uh campaign launches, then I'll insert some more thoughts here. But anyway, let's get into what Pittsburgh offers mechanically. There are great videos out there that talk about this.
But to summarize some of the changes that Pittsburgh offers the brass system, aside from a new setting and map, of course, with the region of, you know, the eastern United States being the focus here, you have first heavy locomotives, which is a new type of train that you place on the rail routes that stay on the board over the two rounds or the two phases of the game, but they're more costly to build. You have network line bonuses. So, when you place routes on certain lines, that grants like a one-time bonus to help facilitate and encourage building on certain areas. And it helps you, you know, focus on network scoring as well. I think there are some changes to how that works in addition to the bonuses that you get. Next big thing is decentralized markets. And so instead of one market that you're trying to get coal and iron from and manipulate through your the industries that you build, they are spread throughout the board encouraging you to build routes and build buildings close to these markets to take advantage from.
On the board, you have pipelines as well. And so connecting pipelines to cities and certain regions allow for oil which is a new resource very akin to beer in brass birinum to be used in order to build out these industries etc. You have a new resource in whiskey which can be used in conjunction with a card on your turn to be a wild location or industry. It's it's essentially the replacement of the scout action in brass birinum allowing for more flexibility in where and what you can build. You have the upgrade mechanism which replaces overbuilding. You have new resources like in addition to oil, you have steel and coke which are advanced upgraded versions of iron and coal. You have premium goods. It's kind of like a star system of the value of goods and industries that you build upon throughout the game to allow the pursuit for bigger prizes and points. You have the Vanderbuilt delivery. So, if you're not connected to a market, you can pay a higher price for a certain good that you're missing to progress your game.
Uh, so you're not like shut out from markets and you don't if you don't have any opportunity, at least you have this in your back pocket to help out. You have crown jewel building. So, at the end of your industry tracks on your board that you can build towards, uh, you have some kind of, uh, you know, one-time uh, big time bonuses that are kind of different from one another at the end of these tracks. Uh, it kind of reminds me of like the shipyard track in Lancaster a little bit, but at least you have a lot of variability in which tracks you choose to pursue and which industries to to try to pursue throughout the game. [snorts] And then finally, you have the two-player map. On the reverse side of the board, you have a smaller, tighter experience that is more fitting for the two-player experience.
So, initially, I thought this would be a relatively short list of the changes, but as I started to start to list them, you know, it turns out there are quite a few changes or alterations made or additions even. And reading through the designer diary posted on the game found, I see reasons for why they made these changes. Some of them were to reflect the game differently when adapting it to the new theme and setting. Other changes were to quote unquote fix the issues that new players to the older brass games had questions to that they were confused with when they're learning brass and playing it for the first time. The sense I get from learning about these new changes and additions, it still feels like this game is going to be a heavier experience compared to other brass games. Brass itself is a somewhat heavy game, but I think this is going to be a little bit heavier. I feel like if you look at Lancaster, which is in my opinion the most streamlined brass experience, Burman introduced new mechanisms and made it a little bit more flexible of a game and variable of the game, but it in introduced more rules that potentially could have been a little bit more confusing and uh put more of a front load to the rules, you know, intuition at the beginning of the game. Pittsburgh looks like it does clean up a few of these mechanisms and questions and confusing rules from brass birinum, but it also introduces a whole lot more nuance to the system and therefore might be the most complex game when it comes to rules that in the brass
series so far in my opinion. It's like they sought out to change some of the holdups from previous brass experiences, rules that might have been confusing, and then added some more rules on top of the fixes that they made to make it make sense for the setting that they have. And here we have Pittsburgh. One major comment from the designers, though, is that they wanted to make a distinct brass game that had strategic depth, perhaps even more depth than previous iterations so far. Now, this is one way to introduce strategy for sure by introducing more complexity and nuance to the game. Other ways that could have been done was to perhaps create new maps like for just for brass and essentially like hypothetically you keep all the rules the same from brass birmingham and you create this new Pittsburgh map and you keep pretty much everything the same but maybe you make one or two additions like having the onetime bonuses on routes and leaving it at that changing beer to whis or beer to oil but that's it right like you don't have any of these other mechanisms that are introduced So, that's another way to do it to keep the rules uh complexity, the rules teach, you know, on the lighter side, but still have a varied experience. Now, would that sell? Would that be something that most people would be interested in versus a whole another standalone game with a whole, you know, with a significantly different rule set? Uh, while keeping the same system intact, of course, but just introducing a lot more
nuance to the game. Maybe more people would rather have that and that would make it feel more distinct and worthy of your collection than just having, you know, the slightest tweaks and a new map essentially to give you, you know, brass Pittsburgh. So maybe some of those decisions came into account when they designed and play tested this game. But in any case, I think this new brass experience is is definitely going to be fun. It's based on brass and and so if you do enjoy brass, chances are you're going to like this game. The designers have play tested this game reportedly for hundreds of hours as well. And according to a game found post, they have been actively testing this game on board Game Arena. So, it's going to be a very finely tuned game and perhaps something that we could all at least try digitally at some point as well. So, the questions I ask myself considering the situation are, you know, is this going to be as fun or more fun than brass birin? think it's going to be different enough from brass birm, but is it more fun? And is it going to be different enough to warrant a spot in my physical collection which is limited? I think it's definitely going to be, you know, interesting. Maybe the in, you know, additional complexity together in conjunction with the rules fixes for some of the more confusing aspects maybe makes a very, you know, strategically deep brass experience.
Maybe it's going to be deeper than what you get with Birmingham and Lancasher. Maybe it's not. I don't know. I think it's but I definitely think it's going to be different enough that it's perhaps worth having. you know, is if you don't have brass Bum in your collection, you could definitely consider uh Pittsburgh if you're up to learning the complexity of the system to be that one game that you have. For me personally, I think that um I it's interesting, you know, I since I do have the game a a brass game in my collection personally and knowing that that brass B&M, brass Lancasher, and perhaps even brass Pittsburgh would be available at some point digitally on Board Game Arena, which is great because you get to try out games at least once or many times actually. Um it is I guess risky if you know if people have uh something that's more available online to play with especially if you don't have a lot of people to play with physically then this is the way that you play brass right and you wouldn't seek out a physical copy because you wouldn't be able to either find players to play it with or it doesn't have a solo mode.
So that's another hiccup that I have with this is that there's no official solo mode that is announced for Pittsburgh. probably won't because that's not in the spirit of brass and that's totally fine. Um, and in addition to that, like for me personally with the board gaming friends that I have that I play with, we tend to play a variety of games, right? We're not playing like the same game over and over again. Uh, we tend to bounce back and forth among different games. And so the likelihood of playing like a brass game is limited. Maybe once, maybe twice a year if we're lucky. But then what brass game do we play? Do we play Lancaster? Do we play Birmingham? Do we play Pittsburgh? I'm sure that the novelty of Pittsburgh would want to have it be played at least once. But then coming back to it, it you know what would be easier to recall rules-wise? I think perhaps Birmingham or Lanasher would be rather than um Pittsburgh because of all the additions that are made. And so, so for me, those are the holdups that I have personally about um backing this game. But like I mentioned before, if there are, you know, additional things that I think the game would come with, like some of the add-ons like the iron coins seem pretty interesting. And so there there is that aspect of the campaign as well that I, you know, don't know all the details yet because I'm making this recording before the Kickstarter launches. And so I'll have any additional changes I'll insert to this video. But I do take that into
consideration. So I'm kind of still on the fence. My my conclusion I'm still on the fence of whether to uh purchase this game or not to back it current, you know, back it right now or not.
Um despite my hype and love for the game and my interest in playing this game. Um, if more information comes out soon about a digital version to try it out on, that might be sufficient for me to experience this game and then I can wait for retail if I really want to. But, uh, yeah, that's kind of where I'm at. I I wish I had a more definitive answer at this point, but maybe I will insert my my decision, uh, after the Kickstart uh, campaign launches and we get more information. So, hopefully that was helpful. Uh maybe some of my thoughts make sense. Hopefully they do and help you in your decisions whether to back the project or to wait and and play it at a later date because it's a popular enough system that I, you know, I'm pretty sure that it would get a retail treatment at some point like the other two brass games. And [clears throat] uh so we'll eventually get our chance, but you know, not to, you know, persuade or dissuade from the hype that comes around this game and the Kickstarter campaign.
I just wanted to be, you know, honest with my thoughts at this time and and hopefully help you out as well. So, if you have any thoughts for me, let me know in the comments below. If I missed anything or if you have additional insights into what this campaign is all about and could um you know, persuade or dissuade me as well, just let me know. Thank you for checking out this video. Hope to catch you on the next one and uh take