Skip to main content
Loading video...

What are the Top World War 1 Board Wargames? | Best World War 1 Wargames

Transcript 23:48

Hi everybody, I'm Sil Blitz and welcome. In this video, we're going to cover the top 10 tabletop board war games primarily about World War I. Now, this is a mix of games. Some soliter games, top two-player games, some simple, some complex. But a few things about it before we start. First up, these are my favorite top 10 games. I'm not saying these are the top 10 games of all time. These are the ones that have particularly resonated with me. A second thing is this is a very much an incomplete list. I have yet to play all of the great games about World War I that are out there, and there are a number of games that I think might eventually make this list once I play these games in the future, but for now, this is my current top 10 ranking. This video is sponsored by Fort Circle Games. Now, Fort Circle Games does not have a game on the top 10 list here, but they do have a game that you might like if you like the top 10 games we're going to hear about in a little bit. Hunt for Blackbeard is one of their recent releases. And in this game, you either play Blackbeard in North Carolina in 1718 trying to live your life of piracy or settle down or you play the British hunters who are trying to end his existence. There are three reasons why I think you might enjoy this game. The first is the designer. Vulkari is the designer of Hunt for Blackbeard and he is one of the premier designers in historical board gaming today. He's the founder of the counterinsurgency series which is very popular as well as the levy in campaign series and in this game he explores the topic of hidden information which is the second reason why I would recommend this game. Hidden

information has been a constant challenge in historical board game design. What do you know about what your opponents are doing? What do you know about where your opponents are and their intentions? Hunt for Blackbeard uses some amazing mechanics to explore this topic and leaves you always not quite sure where your opponent is, where they're going, what they're trying to accomplish, what they know about you and what you know about them. It's a fascinating exploration of this topic in historical board game design. The third and final reason is the most important reason, the theme pirates. I mean, everybody likes pirates, right? And you're going to be either Blackbeard trying to live your life of piracy. There's rum and raids and parties, or you're going to be the British hunters, arming your ships, seeking out information from informants and trying to capture or force a final battle with Blackbeard. These are all fun topics in a fascinating theme. Now, Hunt for Blackbeard is available now from Fort Circle Games. I'll put a link in the video description if you'd like to check out more about this game.

Now, let's jump right into the heart of our video, our top 10 World War I war games. We're going to start right in with number 10, Ricktophins War from Avalon Hill. This game is a World War I dog fighting game. It's got all of the classic combat of in the aerial skies above World War I. You could fly either as Allied pilots or Central Powers pilots over no man's land. A beautiful map for its time. Now, why is this game on the list? Well, first up, the nostalgia factor. I had so much fun playing this game in my early days of wargaming. I mean, this is an older game. We're talking like 1970s, so it's been around for a while. And yet, the gameplay holds up really well. I love the elements of aerial combat that they built into the simulation and the gameplay. And again, at its heart, though, this is a two-player game. It's not the greatest solo experience because you're trying to outguess your opponents in many ways. So, this has a lot of nostalgia factor for me. I have very fond memories for playing this one. The second reason really is the topic. I I just love the idea of dog fighting in World War I. I've always been fascinated by the topic and to be able to play a game with this as a central feature of it as you'll see in some of the other games coming up, it holds a great deal of appeal for me. So, if we're talking about my favorite war games of World War I, we're going to see a dog fighting theme show up over and over again in these games. The the third reason why this game is here though is that this was one of the earlier games that I think had legacy elements in gameplay.

And by that I mean you could take a cast of pilots and you could easily build up a cadre of pilots and lead them through a series of missions tracking their kills and tracking their accomplishments and recording their deaths and wounds and lives and getting lost. And the game would tell a story over more than just one gameplay session. This, as far as I can think, is probably one of the earlier games to attempt to do that where what happened in one mission could carry over. And indeed, if you got to an ace level status in the game, it would give you gameplay advantages in subsequent missions and subsequent gameplay. So, I really like games that have those types of legacy elements to them, campaign games, and this game has that as well. The the last thing I think I want to mention about this game too is it connected with that campaign element.

This is also one of the earlier games that invited you into the game as a design your own type of experience element. It was really easy. There's so many different planes. I think there's over 30 different planes in this game. So, you could mix and match planes and in scenarios. They had the set scenarios in the game, but it's really easy to just design your own and throw something down and see how it turns out. So, this was one of the first games that I remember saying like, well, what would you design for a scenario? How would you build the gameplay experience? So, for all of those reasons, Rick Toffen's War, the classic game of World War I combat, has earned place number 10 in my top World War I board game list. Game number nine in our list of top 10 World War I board games is a game you may not have heard of yet, but I feel like it's an underrated gem in our area.

Queen of Spies by Liz Davidson and David Thompson. Now, this is a World War I game set in occupied Belgium. You're going to take charge of Alice and her team of spies as you try to accomplish critical missions to advance the Allied cause. Now, why is this game on my list? Reason number one is a lot of games feel like a theme is just pasted on, and this feels like to me the exact opposite of it, but I really like the game engine, the quest and task engine that is the heart of this gameplay. The actions you're taking and the decisions you're making feel really embedded in what would be really going on. You're going to be assigning operatives to particular tasks based on their skills. Their skills can improve over the course of a game. You're going to have to find certain items and tools to be able to accomplish your task. You're monitoring enemy activity and all the while there's a really cool time mechanic that's leveraging your pressure to get the job done before time runs out. So, I really like the gameplay and it just feels like what you're doing is connected to the actual actions that you'd be taking in a situation like this. The second reason is the challenge. This game, for whatever reason, maybe it's just where I am with gameplay skill, it's the perfect difficulty for me. The missions aren't too easy and they're not too hard. I feel like you're going to have some spectacular fails and some spectacular successes, but I always feel like things are balanced on a knife edge as I'm playing this game, which makes it just really fun to play. The third thing is connected to that, the stories this game tells, whether you're going to fail, because there is a luck element in here.

There's a push your luck element and some games things are just going to go sideways and you're going to epically fail. But no matter whether you succeed or whether you fail, there's memorable stories that happen. The bold actions that your spies were able to take out, the epic fails that happen. You can retell the story of this game after you play it in your mind's eye. And I'm a big fan of narratives and games. This one does a great job with that, too. So, Queen of Spies, game number nine in our top World War I board game list. Game number eight on our list of top World War I board games. Probably wouldn't surprise you if you've been watching the channel for a while. Raiders of the Deep: Yubot of the Great War, 1914 to 1918. So, this game is one of the soliter series games, right, where you're going to be taking charge of a submarine and leading it on a campaign of short missions. A mission can take anywhere from five minutes to a half an hour for a longer mission. And you're going to be advancing your ski crew's skills as you go through the war.

You're going to have some epic catastrophes that almost end up in your yubot getting sunk. You're going to have some fantastic successes and you're going to be basically playing through the story of your yubot as you go through World War I. Now, I'm a big fan of these soliter games. You know, there's the Hunters and Silent Victory. This one, Raiders of the Deep, of course, is centered in World War I, which is why it's on this list. And I think one of the reasons in particular why this game is here is that I think they did a very good job embedding the flavor and the history of World War I yubot hunting into this game. There's a lot of unique features about it. You know, at certain points in the war, you can't attack unescorted merchants. Um, all of the technology with the development of depth charges over the course of World War I plays into the game. So, as you're playing this game and living the story of your Yubot, you're also learning a lot about how submarine warfare advanced from its nassent stages at the beginning of the war to a much more advanced state at the end of the war. And the events that happen help you to understand the larger picture of World War I. So, this is just a fantastic, fun, engaging submarine solitaire based on World War I. Raiders of the Deep, Yubot of the Great War, number eight in our list.

Game number seven on our list of top World War I war games is taking us back to the nostalgia factor. Let's get right into it. World War I 1914 1918 from Strategy and Tactics magazine. This is the magazine itself. I've actually got the game. I'm playing it right now again on the table underneath this top right here. Uh this game is a strategic level work look two-player at World War I. Each turn is six months and you're going to be playing through the entirety of the war in both the west front and the east front. Now, why is this game here? Well, I played this game a long time ago and had some vague recollections of really enjoying it. But when I was doing a recent top seven war games interview with Herman Lutman, he mentioned this as one of his favorite games. So, I decided I wanted to take a look at this again. And I've been exploring it on and off over the past couple months. I'm really enjoying it. I mean, a lot of older games have a strong nostalgia factor, but as you dig into the game, the gameplay feels a little bit thin in some places. And sure, there are some things I think you would do differently now if you were designing this game as opposed to, you know, 40 years ago, 50 years ago. But the game play holds up remarkably well. I love the decisions it's throwing at me at a strategic level of World War I. And in particular, I like the resource point mechanic, which is a great way of capturing the gradual deterioration of forces on a front.

you're going to be pulling away from your resource capacity to fight and then finally when it all collapses, the front collapses and you can start to punch through your opponent's line. So, it's just a really simple and brilliant way to capture that static nature of trench warfare in World War I. So, yeah, I'm really enjoying this one. Game number seven on our list of top World War I war games, World War I, 1914, 18 from Strategy and Tactics. Game number six in our list of top World War I war games takes us back up into the skies. We've got Aces of Valor from Legion War Games. Now, why is this game on the list? Well, first up, this is a game where you're going to be in charge of a squadron of planes as either the British, the French, or the Germans. There's actually a number of nationalities in the game that you can play as, and you're going to be leading them forward on a campaign of missions trying to keep your pilots alive and to do as much damage as to the enemy as you can. Great variety of missions in this one, as well as just dog fighting.

There's strafing and bombing and balloon busting and all these elements in here. Now, why is this game on the list? This game tells great stories. Now, to be fair, okay, one caveat. If you are a game player that is is decisionoriented, th this game is very decision light. So, there are stretches in the game where things are just happening for a bit of time and you very much feel like you're watching a game unfold rather than making a ton of decisions that are going to impact gameplay. So, if you are a person, a gamer who likes decision-heavy games, I wouldn't recommend this game. But if you like, if you're a gamer who likes story in your games, this is one of the more compelling games I can recall playing over the last three or four years where it's like, "Oh, I just want to do one more mission. Oh, I just want to do one more mission. Oh, let me just do one more mission." It's just a ton of fun to play. Your pilots are going to advance in skills as you go through. Great variety of missions. The gameplay is really fast and easy to figure out and the game just tells great stories. So, I have had a ton of fun with Aces of Valor. Again, with the caveat that it is definitely a very decision light game. So, if that's not for you, I wouldn't recommend this. But, if you like games that tell great stories, Aces of Valor number six on my list of top World War I war games might be something you want to check out.

Moving into our top five now. Game number five on my top World War I war games list. Ladair Deair from Hexasim Games. Now, this is a soliter or two-player strategic level game of World War I that's playable in about 2 hours. Now, why is this game on my list? Well, I've actually over the course of the past year or so now, I've really started delving into a lot more strategic games with World War I, and this is one of the ones I've really enjoyed. You know, there's World War I that we talked about and another one coming up. Um, I like this game because this is a very tableable game. You can learn the game very fast. It's got a modest rule set, playable in two hours, and yet you feel like you've played World War I in that time span. The game does a great job with the events cards of really bringing in the history of World War I. So, as you're playing it, these are events are unfolding that add a lot of flavor to the game. The game is a little bit abstract in that level in terms of combat. you know, you're dealing with a strategic level game that plays in two hours. So, you have to have some abstractions in there to keep things moving, but the events really balance that, I think, and give the game a strong historical flavor. I love the way technology works in this game, too. So, you're going to be advancing your technology. You get hard decisions about what you want to advance. Sometimes it advances and sometimes you can make those discoveries. But that gameplay element, I think, really can make every game feel different. feels really well balanced between central powers and allied powers in terms of the decisions that you're making and yet historically representative. There just so many good

things I think to say about this and as well if you're a solitire gamer the soliter mode is really good and it plays great as a two-player game. There's just so many good things about this game in addition to the fact that it is you you can play the entirety of World War I in a single evening. So Ladair Dair from Hexasim Games really enjoy this one. Game number five on my list of top World War I board games. Game number four on my top World War I board war games list is another one that might surprise you. You may not have heard of this one, but to me it definitely deserves a place on this list. Downfall of Empires from Do It Games. Now, this game much like is here for much many of the same reasons that I mentioned about Ladair Dair. This Ladair Dair, this is a strategic level game of World War I that is mostly playable.

It's a little bit longer gameplay than Ladair Dair, but mostly playable in a single sitting with a modest rule set. Now, this is a two-player game. It doesn't have a solo mode, and there's a little bit of hidden information there that doesn't make it the best choice perhaps for a solo game, although it is definitely a good experience solo. Why is this game on the list? Well, it does a great job with technology. It's a finely balanced, very competitive thing. love the decisions it makes and I love the way it structures the technology in the combat and the decisions among the different fronts and where you're moving your troops. It's an area control movement game. So, a little bit more concrete than the abstract nature of Ladair Deair. So, for that reason, that really pulls me in a little bit more. It's a little bit more granular in terms of the strategic movement that you're going to be having with your forces.

This just a really fun game. Really well-designed, very competitive with the way it's structured, victory conditions. It's just a lot of fun to play. Um, Downfall of Empires from Do It Games. Number four on our list of top World War I board war games. Game number three on my list of top World War I board war games somewhat surprised me, right? So, I took all the games that I played with World War I that had a big pool and then I just kind of pitted them against each other and I used a little ranking tool to figure out what my top 10 were and then I looked at the end and said, "Yeah, this feels good." And every time I came to this and I match it up against another game, I'm like, "Yeah, I I think I'm this one's ahead of that one." Yeah, this one's ahead of that one. Without any further delay, though, let's get right into it. Trench Raid from Compass Games and designed by Lisa Smademan. So, in this game, you take charge of a patrol of British soldiers in World War I. And you're going to be given a variety of missions. Some of them are incredibly hard to make it to the enemy trench line and accomplish some extremely hard tasks like capture prisoners over there. Some are relatively easy, like wander around no man's land until you find the down pilot. And some of them can go easy and hard. It it I mean, things can go in so many different directions.

Why I like this game and why it's so high on my list, though. The biggest reason I say is that you you can't talk about this game without talking about great story. The there's a campaign in here that's a sequenced set of missions that you can play through. Chances are it's going to go badly. I mean, that is the nature of trench warfare in World War I. And these patrols were brutal at times. And you're going to have patrols where it's a cakewalk and you accomplish it so easy and everybody comes back and survives. And then you're going to have another patrol where you're going to get hit by artillery and gas and run into an enemy patrol and and you're going to come back with like two or three people. And it's just the the the the stories that feel grounded in history for what it must have been like for these men in the trenches asked to carry out these missions. That balance between history and story that just feels like it brings you to this moment in time is just fantastic. So yeah, as I as I was ranking this game against other games and making this list, this one just like no, I just really like this one. This is a fantastic game. so original and creative and again it is a soliter or cooperative game and mainly a soliter game of World War I trench warfare. So, you know, it's a soliter game for people that like soliter games. But yeah, this game tells just amazing stories and it's so unique and creative and just fun to play. Trench raid from Compass Games.

Game number three on my list of top World War I war games. Before we get to game number two on the list of top World War I board war games, you know, there's a theme with these games, right? I'm obviously a fan of soliter games and two-player multiplay multiplayer games too, but I really like solitire games as well. And I like games that give you put you in charge of like a submarine or a tank um or a plane and let you do a series of missions that are going to play through over the course of a war or a certain time span. So this game, Western Front Ace from Compass Games, the Great War in the Air from 1916 to 1918, is perhaps one of the best executions of this concept. you know, where you're going to be in charge of a single plane, a single pilot, flying on a series of missions through World War I. You're going to earn skills, get promotions, have all these different types of missions. Incredible depth, great execution. The missions go fast, so you can just advance your campaign. A fairly good balance between decisionmaking and narrative and fate that certainly played the role in any World War I fighter pilot, as history will tell us. The story of this pilot's life as you play through this game is just miraculously to it's beautifully told with this game. I mean so many people praise this game. Like if we talk about this soliter game series, we talk about the Hunter, Silent Victory, British Tank Ace, American Tank Ace, these games that allow you to do these types of things in a solitire fashion.

So many people mention this one as being one of their favorite games in that category. And for that reason, I I mean I totally agree with the decision. It's just a a magnificent game with great depth in it with all the different nationalities and planes. Um, Western Front Ace, the Great Air War, 19 or in the Air 1916 to 1918 from Compass Games. Game number two on our list of top World War I board war games. And we've come full circle to game number one on the list of top World War I board games. This was a clear choice for me. Okay. Okay. And I've the and a lot of these games I've come to in the past year as I've been trying to broaden out my gameplay tastes from World War II to World War I and other conflicts, ancient and Napoleonic. Um, and I've been making a concerted effort to play more World War I board games. But as I was looking past on all the games that I've played over the past years, I was like, "Yeah, this one's got it." And let's let's jump right into it. Paths of War from G&T Games. Now, this is a two-player game. Very much a two-player game. It's card driven, so it doesn't work the greatest for solo. can play it solo, but I think it really comes to life as a two-player game. Strategic level complex game. I mean, it's got a big rule book and the rules for supply and combat and how to integrate the different events and how they can play in and some of the different requirements you got. is a meaty, long two-player game of World War I at the strategic level, but it encompasses so much of the history and the events and the decisions on the different fronts are very nuanced and very intricate. It

just pulls you into the history of World War I as you're figuring out these decisions that these nations had as they're going forward in conflict. and is a point-to-point map, so you're moving along there, but the way the mechanics build up. I just can't say enough about this game. Now, to be fair, I've only played this game probably maybe a dozen times now on Rally the Troops, so I have not actually played it with the board game itself. I love playing it on Rally the Troops because it executes that rules framework for you. That makes it easier to focus on the game decisions, but I've just been having so much fun. Every game I've played with this game has been such a fun thing. Playing better players. I'm just learning how to play from watching them destroy me. I'm playing players at the own level and see things swift back and forth. And the the other thing about this is don't give up. This game can shift. All it can take is one opportunity where you think things are lost and all of a sudden you get a breakthrough on one particular front and it's a whole new game and it's back to game on. So this game can go back and forth much like World War I with all the different es and flows of the forces. It really captures that for some reason the way that gameplay has been executed. So yeah, I've been having a marvelous time.

My only caveat, and this is something that a number of people have mentioned to me as well, supply can be incredibly devastating in this game. If you know, you know, but there are some ways that supply feels a little bit overpowered in this game. So, I I wouldn't say this is a perfect execution of World War I. It does have its warts as you play into it more, but it does so many things right, and it tells great stories as you're playing through it. For a strategic level game that tells such great stories about the war, yeah, I can't stop saying good things about this game. I absolutely have had a great time playing it. It clear in a way number one for me on my list, Pass of Glory, the First World War I from GMT Games. And there we have it. My top 10 World War I board war games at this moment in time. So, I realize again there are a number of games that I haven't played. I'm going to try to redo this video in about a year's time and play some of these other games that I've yet to play about World War I. But I'd be curious to hear down below in the comments what you think about this list and what your favorite games are. What ones have I missing?

What ones would you recommend I play to look for future candidates for this list? Now, and if you have enjoyed this video, I have a video about my favorite World War II board war games. I'll put a link to that up here in case you want to check that out.

Progress saved