Skip to main content
Loading video...

TCbH Podcast - AITA: Board Game Etiquette

Transcript 1:16:38

welcome back to the cardboard Herald podcast I am your host Eric joined today by both the uh always charismatic uh co-host Jack and our friend John I will let them introduce themselves and let John tell you just a little bit about how he has come to be here this this fine uh podcast yeah how did you come to be here John where do we start uh well see it's like this when a man and a woman love each other so John has been on the show uh in various forms in the past we've done some podcasts he's done some video stuff even surprise guest appearance by m in the background I love that makes for perfect audio listening though when I call out visual cues in the background but hey that's what we're here for um but John's visiting for platy poscon right yeah yeah so uh I'm I'm a longtime Juno resident relocated down to Ohio last year and I'm in town for H for our local convention uh as an excuse to come see my friend Jack so uh so he's here stop in yeah and it works well for the podcast topic today because we are dishing out judgment or etiquette advice however you want to say this in uh in new new internet terms hard hardcore judgment we're throwing shade to all of these uh hot board game takes um first off let's start off by

talking about what we've played this week uh John as the uh as the guest why don't you start any any particularly interesting board games you've gotten to the table this week uh yeah you know to be honest I'm I'm a little behind on getting the hotness played so uh I'm getting a little caught up uh been a lot of games like uh Leviathan wild Wilds yeah Leviathan Wilds uh we got some games of The Lord of the Rings trick taking game yep um some delving some delving there was delving there was delving because if you beat shastar the great that's a that's a delve right if anybody hasn't seen go see Jack's uh review of kfire delve um but uh uh that and um boblins boblins goblins goblins and boblins the rebellion of boblins rebellion uh I have some stuff coming out on that and it is unhinged and weird and engine buildy and delicious yeah that was a good one yeah all are we have platypus Con coming up uh here shortly and I I imagine that we'll have some sort of dedicated podcast uh to do based off of that but are there any games that you're like hot to play at platypus conom um you know honestly no it's it's a good excuse to break out something that I otherwise wouldn't last year what was our our hot one for last year we were a little behind on getting into it but an first time just something that we just didn't have the opportunity to play any other time but they've got such a massive library that it's a good time to dip into those that's weird that it wasn't

gangs of junkyard City it's just interesting that you played that game and then that just wasn't on your on your list so weird I mean that was kind of by like a no-name designer yeah can we name drop can we name drop on this can I like just casually be like oh yeah yeah well John D CLA Fame designer John D CLA is the like guest of honor at the convention this year um and I was uh already trying to shmoo with him to talk about playing the new mbor game that he designed which is really exciting I'm I'm hyp I'm reading through all of the I'm reading through Mporn right now I'm really excited this is going to just sander lanch straight into a sander cast that's what we're going to do um but uh yeah so I'm excited to do that uh but he happened to be like hey I watch your top 10 uh Game of the Year video and I saw arcs is pretty high on that you want to play a game of arcs I haven't played it yet and I'm like oh hell yeah I want to play some arcs at the convention so uh hopefully we'll do that as far as things I've been playing um the only thing like particularly of note uh is everdell Duo uh a new one to me that hit the table uh that's coming out soon and it's good but like anytime that there's one of these like Duo games or re-implementations or new versions or spin-offs the question is always is it like good enough to like warrant its

existence I don't want to say like it's worse than everdell 2 player there are some things that are smart and interesting about it but everell was perfectly fine at two players and I don't know that this like is going to replace everell in anyone's collection and it's certainly not competing with the territory that like Splender duel and um you know Seven Wonders duel or something were which I think are are broader modifications to the overall system capturing the spirit whereas this is like hey everell two players but a bit tighter there is a co-op mode that I haven't played yet so interesting I'm wondering if that's going do I imagine my recommendation is going to end up being like if you only Envision playing everell at two players and this is probably going to be the way to go but so far I'm like this is good this this is good that it's fine yeah yeah yeah what about you what what do you think uh on BGA I got New York Zoo played today uh the oua Rosenberg and I am absolutely terrible at it um I do very poorly with like the the spatial reasoning games like that um so I I not very good not I it's a solid game it's not the game's fault I am just bad at it and I understand that and that's fine um

I also was inspired by you a couple I think it was two podcasts ago talking about playing Spirit Island so I broke that out uh played some spirits that I haven't played I mean I haven't I also you do two-handed solo yeah two and it's solo for sure what what Spirits hit the table uh grinning trickster stir up trouble and oh I'm forting the Mist guy M guy I like M guy the M guy that's like the ghostly spirit that has persistent damage oh that was cool yeah that one was trickster is interesting too I mean it's got a lot of random stuff but it also has like I don't know it's like wild magic the spirit right yeah yeah yeah I felt like they actually there was some nice Synergy because they with the minor Powers could do like one thing of damage and then it would just stay M uh which was really nice and then also uh randomly during the game with the events the uh Invaders had uh or uh the Invaders had one less health for like a c like it was like two rounds back to back between f cards and then an event card and so she's like oh I'm knocking out all of these cities all of these towns so it was a it was a nice it's because they were already injured from the ghost ghostman right right

ghostman I think I that's the name of the spirit that that's the appropriate name yeah the technical name as the D call him the ghost man the Ghost Face Killer um so uh another way that we could der rail this podcast where just putting pins like little DS into all the different things that we could do Sanderson podcast we could also do Spirit Island tier list that seems like a Content thing to do I wanted to ask how do you pick your spirits because if the answer isn't well I look at the back and go which ones are super hard and go for those then you're doing it wrong I I usually do random unless it's like I'm just gonna unless I'm like purposely trying to play Spirits I don't play frequently I'll just choose I'll just like go go to the all of them are in one stack for me shuffle them up as much as possible and just grab two I like it I like itally how I go which also means that I don't know any of theirs uh I was going to say that's why I don't know any of their names because I don't actually look at the names or just go cool Ghost guy I like it um um I also got uh a play of Twinkle Twinkle which is the new allplay game yeah that we're going to have to turn around a tight review for but think'll be able to yeah I I got I got some games in with a board gaming Bud from Instagram who appeared in our our top 10 game of the year as a friend of ours nice so that

was helpful but it's it's on BGA now in beta mode right it works pretty well uh yeah it's it's really nice it's definitely uh lighter than I was expecting but what I can say about twinkle twinkle is I was invited or we were invited to play some of allplay stuff and during the scheduling we were able to make a a slot either for aliis or for Twinkle Twinkle and just based off of the name and the beest description I was like I don't know Alibi because I was like twinkle twinkle I don't know I try to not be overly judgmental but when I sat down at The Alibi I looked over I was like what's that cool game over there with the acrylic tiles and everything it was twinkle twinkle and I'm I'm not saying I'm regretting the choice but my my interest in twinkle twinkle went up dramatically when I saw the visual I think they it it it's clearly far too late for this I would love if they changed the name because it what are you talking about a different game than it is vast vast changed names uh you know like the flagship game of leader games changed names from oh God what was it called I kickstarted that game way back when and they it was originally called

something else and then uh changed it was like glimmer or shine or or something like that but they ended up deciding they had to change it for like copyright purposes um and so they went with vast and I was like okay cool and I think that became the Genesis of their four-letter name uh routine that they went with I I think again just let's just go into more sidetracks I think as a board game designer I should really start just really honing in on a design that will have a fourl title just just so that I'm not like excluding a publisher yeah exactly because if I have a board game that isn't afford letter title I'm excluding leader games entirely as a chance to be a publisher so I think that's one of those things that whenever you go to a workshop they say like first things first solid name design for a title don't Title First mechanics at this point flip through the dictionary find a word you like and make a game about it yep and also commission all the art up front before you make any pitches or anything like that we are building this house roof first I love it and that's just the way it's going to be I think if you're GNA I think if you're going to pick a good name that's an allp purpose you need to go ahead and throw in that colon It's you know four-letter word colon Something Something Something elaborate that way you've got both audiences there you could drop the colon get in with leader but if leader does it leader does

it arcs uh uh conflict and Conquest in the reach okay so there title anything after the colon is free granis I love when board game Publishers have very strict rigid rules about something that seems otherwise innocuous or inconsequential like um uh board game tables or or all play has like a we will not have more than a singlefold pamphlet and rules that was like one of their stipulations you you could have four pages all together front middle middle back and that's it and when they talk with designers when they talk with developers um they would be like yeah I know it would it would be great if you had another page to explain this a little bit more but that's not us um but yeah I think that's what I've gotten played this week it's been some nice nice cozy games in uh BGA and then in person um as far as our podcast theme uh it just seems really great that John's here for this one because there's a lot of H I know right he said that the second time I'm like which side of the am I the am I on you just I was going to say these are a lot of hot takes and you at patch unplugged like a hot take generator like you would say something be like this is a very Firm Stance and this is a hill I'm dying on right now out of nowhere JN shoots from the hip uh

and he doesn't always hit but man is it impressive to see it unload I I am your I regret everything I just said Kirk Lar strong opinions about things that don't matter so uh you pitched this uh the AI the Mi the [ __ ] um I don't know if you're going to beep that or not this is your podcast fig out butly aita uh and because I'm an old person um I'm familiar with it but I really just think of this as like the New Millennium etiquette questions right you know like the uh writing into your newspaper and being like dear Susan or Dear Abby you know am I a complete unhinged jerk for doing X Y and Z well that's what we're trying to evaluate both in submissions and some of the ones that you found kind of spicy on the Internet is that right yeah so well the the term Mi I ta I don't know if we're going to bleep it so I'm just going to oh maybe I'll just avoid trying to to say the term entirely we'll sort it out okay well I I've already given it the the elaboration am I the arvar we'll say am I the arvar the other one that I that I that I see online especially on Reddit that I look at sometimes is uh am I overreacting to because it's really just trying to gauge like am I having the appropriate response or maybe I'm just being overly emotional about something that if I step back there's a better explanation for am

I overreacting or not I think that's a that's a good way of doing it but so like that I feel like really not entirely but there that's a huge community on redit is just am I overreacting so I thought of going through the board game Reddit and also going through the am AIT Reddit and just searching board game uh to see what came up and you pitched board game etiquette as a podcast topic and I felt this played right into it because it's it's essentially what this is so I have two three four five six and then we also o asked our listeners and got some sent in um I ordered the ones I found on Reddit in uh I think least spicy to most spicy question I I think you just need to lay it out there but I am going to uh because uh clearly we are always going to be looking for content right hasht content yeah you know what I'm going to say it right now if anyone ever wants to send in a deer heral uh we can have a dear Herald corner on the end of any future podcast episode or we can tackle it in shorts or something so lay it on us give us the dear Heralds but yeah let let's proceed with what you got so first one is a post on Reddit uh by Kim T Kim T hwa and it is am I overreacting

for not wanting to learn and teach a regular players's game for them and essentially the the post which I'll summarize here is they go to board game nights frequently they have some friends who play in the board game night regularly and uh the original poster is the one always having to learn and teach the rules even if it's not the game that they own so when they show up to a game night they are given the rule book to start off and they have to learn the game while people socialize is essentially the question oh I I'm I picked up what you put down John do you have some thoughts on this you're you're a learner you're a learner teacher out you know you're the Uber gamer of a group it's going to be the common theme for most of my answers when they're well thought out is going to be look is that what you signed up for because if that's what you enjoy and I do enjoy teaching games and I do enjoy learning new games on the other hand I would instantly become annoyed if you showed up with a game that you specifically wanted to play on the premise that I would learn at first in that moment while you get to go have fun and socialize you want to send me the title of your favorite game now I'll look up the rules online I'll learn them ahead of time I'll be ready to teach when I get there but don't expect me to sit quietly and read the rule book while you hang out with your friends yeah definitely not that uh I showed up to actually play a game so you know don't just spring that on me but also you know

what homie that's your game like that that's your game learn your game if you went through the work of purchasing it and getting it unless you clearly asked and then politely accepted whatever answer and response it should be no one else's obligation to learn a game even if that's the normal person who like teaches for a group right you know I I go to public game night here in Juno quite a bit I have had people who have been like oh man I saw this game and I picked it up because I was really excited but they're newer to board games right and then they start looking at it and they're like oh jeez this looks like a lot and then they've been like Jack this ended up more complicated and you've taught every game that I've learned at this point is there a chance that you know you'd help me through this I get that but if I was like H I just got a lot on my plate over the next couple of weeks so if you want to get that played we're we're not playing it and they like had some out- of- pocket response I'd be like forget you man come on M it's like it's like Spider-Man says everybody gets one if you come to me if you're new to gaming in the case of a new gamer if you're new to gaming you come to me and you say hey can you teach this game I bought it and I I in over my head sure sure that's your freebie but maybe you shouldn't be buying board games if you're after that if you realized you're you're in over your head maybe maybe let your friends buy them since you're not willing to learn them you are not the arar you I I my take on this and then I'll all summarize the uh

uh comments in response to this post um my take on this is actually if they have attempted to learn it and just are not able to and I have the time to sure that's a thing that I would do and I don't it as long as they're like being grateful I think the thing about this is also like some people are not able to read Rule books and actually comprehend what's going on that's just not the way that they learn at the same time there are so many learn to playay videos on the internet uh that if if that is the tough part is that you're not able to read a rule book it's kind of back on them to to take the onus to learn um I think in this one not overreacting would be my opinion uh the opinions of the comments are pretty similar to us uh I there's a lot more Nuance with some of the these answers which are but the the Internet isn't for nuance come on the Internet isn't for nuance there's some also also note just so we're clear we've got a clear signal here I got the I got the judgmental crossed arm thing going here this is your clear signal that wait a minute wait a minute wait a minute you're going to tell me reading Rule books is hard but then you went on to say videos I was like that's exactly what I'm thinking if your excuses rule books go go watch a video there's so many other resources for how to how to learn a game now yeah well I I went ahead and pulled up your next one here and I love the title on

Reddit so this is from user electronic snow 6489 uh aita for trying to win the board game uh so long story short this person's playing Ticket to Ride and it looks like uh they were playing with their family and they scooped a route a necessary route that someone else was clearly working their way towards and this is one of those things that comes up in carcasson it comes up in a lot of a lot ofam where there are games that you can play that tend to be more family friendly you know like the these are great games that aren't too aggressive but the rules do allow for some real nasty stuff SK dugery we'll say skull skull dugy uh and it sounds like by doing said skull duggery it ended in a very uh tense tense situation situation so so if you're playing a game with your family and uh there is a way to win and that way to win is at the direct expense of what someone else has been working towards what do you think what's the adate there did you break an unspoken rule okay so so can we qualify this with who because I'm noticing I'm seeing six-year-old daughter so who did he snipe the wind from because it's a very different ser circumstance and and and

we won't get into parenting advice here it's a philosophical difference are you trying to teach the kid a lesson or not but is this the wife he sniped or is this the the kid the wife this is the wife and she is an experienced to to ride player she plays a lot on her phone then snip yeah because if you're playing a competitive game you you're there to compete now there are certain games that there are actions that are detrimental to other players remove their ability to have fun and don't necessarily serve your goal those might be considered you know okay well maybe I I don't want to do that you know a classic example i' use is you know okay maybe we don't break out your land destruction deck you know with a brand new magic player or something right don't don't remove their ability to play but don't forfeit the game just so that they can have their Victory that's the point of a competitive game right yeah I think my big takeaway from this is it's it's kind of about the expectations you're setting and I think it it's kind of tough to tell since we weren't there but it does say in in the post itself that the wife was also actively trying to win like the they were not like playing down so that their child would have a chance to win they were playing against each other and their child was also there playing separately at that point it it it's a tough part of the optimal

move is to block the route that lets the other player get more points like the goal of the game the goal of the game is to win to play optimally you do want to block that route um and it seems like uh the uh the couple had different expectations on what the game was going to be and I'm going to guess that if the uh wife play on her phone all the time either she's playing against like the AI which won't do that and so it probably felt like really out of pocket for somebody to do that because that's not how the computers play so that's just an expectation that just that's a different expectation between the two yeah I I think it's a difference in expectation but you know like for me you know if we're bringing this back to Etiquette it comes down to you know match to the level of the people that you're playing with and you know like I If if you are uh sitting down to play a game uh with someone who's either inexperienced or you know that they are just never going to do super aggressive things then get a little creative it might not be as fulfilling of a situation uh for you um but if they are uh you know not giving any resistance because they're not playing even half as optimally as you should then you probably don't need to D on them right but if you are in a position where that is going make the

difference between Victory and loss so they are clearly keeping up with you then yeah use the tools that are available to you there's plenty of times where I've gone maybe not easy on someone else I'm never throwing a game but you know I've gone for like well you know this really is the type of game that they kind of struggle with so I'm just going do a nonoptimal strategy or be creative those things that I see and go like I don't that would be interesting to try but I'm not going to try it because I want to win well that's a way of giving a contest for myself um but the moment that they're giving me resistance then I'm going to meet them at that level and give the you know everything that I got yeah can we just stop for a minute and address the fact that this is almost sitcom level of funny that the the two parents are doing it and nowhere in this discussion is like okay they're going for the win and I can just imagine in my had the kid sitting in the background going like you know just well just being lost in the shuffle like the two parents are standing up arguing and the kids just minding their own business in the background the kids like connected Miami to Seattle I have no routes all of my routes are in the Northeast but I built big train are you proud of me exactly yes we're always proud of you at the same time though how dare him honestly the fact that one person is upset tells me that victory was important to them and that person needs to take a step back and take stock of

the fact that well if Victory is important enough to them to get upset then shouldn't they also assume that Victory is important to the person who sniped it you know who took the route so why should one person that's part of the social contrac of competition is you know someone's not going to win so if you if it's important to you to win you have to assume it's important to the other person and not be upset if they happen to take the victory yeah totally and I think you know this this feels less like someone is or is not overreacting and more just everybody is overreacting that's the the the general Vibe of the comments is uh everybody sucks here yeah that's that's the general Vibe I I think it flows nicely into our next one do you want to you want to load us up with the uh the competitive one this one is uh a post by proud hyphen primary uh am I overreacting for making a board game competitive the general gist of this game is uh a person and their girlfriend met with some of the girlfriends close friends uh to play a game of Katon in that game of Katon uh there was some awkwardness between the partner and the two close friends uh before before the game like just separately they were having like a weird energy and then during the game they got a little upset

that the partner was like actively playing the game with the intent to win yeah like do doing things optimally in a way that they were just trying to like chill and have a fun casual game I this drives me nuts John have you found yourself in this situation where like if people are sitting down and they're essentially using the board game not as the tool to facilitate interaction and companionship which I think all of us do to a degree you know it's a way that we hang out with friends but almost like it's someone passively scrolling through their phone except it's a board game you know what I mean yeah they're they're Focus isn't on playing the game it's it's I mean it's okay to focus on the social stuff but I guess if it's the TV show that you turn on while you're doing other things that's where it becomes the problem for me I'm there to play the game and I can just picture the poor uh partner sitting there while they're beefing going like I was here to play the game guys what are you doing play board game yeah excuse me wood for sheep please yeah I think the one thing that is important to note is the partner who already had the awkward kind of interaction beforehand started out by doing playful trash talking which it seems like the the two friends of the

girlfriend took as being serious right it's like and I think that just is and that could be tough that that's a different situation I mean I I stand by what I said but that's almost like a completely separate etiquette thing and something that John and I have you know had to na navigate over you know what 12 years of friendship or or whatever I have a theory on trash talking and as the resident trash talker in the house I am guilty of stepping putting my foot in my mouth and I gotta I got to change my opinion on this one it's probably the partner's fault at least 30 to 50% for antagonizing a situation that was already T I'll be honest I've gotten better over the years My Philosophy has always been the more you're winning the less funny trash talk is and the more you're losing the funnier it is cuz then you get that come from behind Victory or you just look like you know ridiculous right but that's because I grew up in a very competitive household and it was a spirit of humorous trash talking like you know I'm coming from behind 10 points behind but I'm going to you know I'm going to take you down or something but you don't rub it in when they're when they're losing and you don't start the game with with friends of your partner who are already uncomfortable and set that atmosphere let the game progress a little bit and feel it out maybe before you start dropping the trash talk so this is something that uh you know I I am overly sensitive when it comes to trash talking and I I recognize that but like I grew up in you know like a an environment of

you know feeling like we needed to lift each other up and I was probably you know more often than not kind of the Diplomat of the house you know the cheerleader of the house um and so I found myself in situations where the only level of trash talking that I would realistically do is say I'm going to win or you know like oh I'm going to do this or check out this awesome move this is going to be great but that's like instead of tearing them down I'm lifting myself up um which you know the moment where I was like telling my brother like you suck at this game or something that's when he would hit back worse and I was so sensitive that I'd be like oh I do suck at this game so I wouldn't invite it I would never engage in it um so the trash talking that's a separate issue if that comes up in another post I think we can really we can really check into that um I am never going to uh miss an opportunity to bring up uh the famous rinard Kia quote on games though because one he's like the good doctor of gaming and two it's a damn good quote which is when playing a game the goal is to win but it's the goal that's important not the winning so like the social construct of us playing a game is that this only works if we're playing to win like if you're not playing to win then I'm not even really playing a game here I'm not saying you have to be good but you can't

just like break all the rules disengage from the game like that completely makes the social contract fall apart so at at that point just do anything else other than play a game like if if game is just a way of facilitating interaction between some people who don't really know first of all maybe choose a game that isn't like as play micro macro City or whatever play micro macro Crime City it's nice Cooperative I agree or like you can even play something that is mostly Cooperative like uh medium medium would be a good one like are games that can facilitate that um so I think that one nobody I think is necessarily overreacting but again it's just uh expectations were wildly apart from one another in a way that made both sides feel awkward and not really uh come out of it with a great experience so the next one in line John I I just handed over to John here so what's up with the tldr here what happened what's up with this guy oh my God girl that's a can I can I read that on air whoa uh it's a saucy post it's a yeah I mean there that one point they mentioned a punch to the junk is all I'm I'm going to say there not not necessarily in that way um wow okay so

let's do with the tldr that long ver wow they must have some strong feelings okay so play to point scoring game alternate player eliminating Victory ignored points entire so it sounds like they played a game that it has a point scoring area control element to it where you can win the game on points however the alternate Victory condition is simply eliminating the other players so it sounds like they went for the the spicier version of just eliminating other players uh calling it a spree uh and would like to know uh you know are they the jerk and uh I'm GNA say like if you you invited it if you sat down to a game where player elimination is an option again it's expectations the expectation when you open the rule book and realize that's an option is that that it might be done I am of two minds on this uh so like Eclipse would be a great example if there was someone who was like my neighbor and to their detriment they were on a spree because they were like there's a Gambit that I might win if I take this other player out but they are leaving themselves vulnerable and taking advantage of the other players knowing well they're never going to do to me because this is a big jerk move so I'm going to you know like mercilessly attack my neighbor there is a social Dynamic where if I were the person getting wiped out I'd probably be like what the heck yeah I signed up to play like a

three-hour game and if I had gone to round three then I would be maybe not winning but at least able to defend myself but because there's a couple players on the sidelines who are like well I'm just here to build I don't I don't want any part in this uh one player felt like they were entirely empowered to destroy me but at the same time I get it I do get it it's a player elimination game and one of the reasons why I don't like playing a lot of player elimination games isn't that kind of why because human nature is what it is is that kind of why we the game design has moved away from that as a strict qualifier for how to win but the other thing is is okay so I agree but if you're using that's a different story if you're using good strength strategy most decently balanced play elimination games don't really reward you for picking on someone who's already losing you kind of want them around it's it's like a a political situation right you want them as the independent stripping votes off your opponent kind of thing you want them siphoning resources being a thorn so you never just blow someone out of the water you go after the person who's clearly winning the game and you overtake them if you're just sitting their picking on them because you enjoy eliminating players that might be a jerk move and it goes back to the look are you going to Stone rain all land you're going to play a game where you eliminate my ability to play if it doesn't explicitly win you the game right now if I have to see for 3 hours yeah that might be a problem I think in just some additional context with this game specifically is uh it's it's Warcraft and it seems like I've not played it uh

it is we've played it we've played Warcraft it's been it's been a day uh there are two sides three players on each side one of them immediately out of the gate went for the player elimination strategy like that instead of like building up a base and then going attacking later was like I'm going to rush you down before you're able to build your base up and build your engine up in hopes that I take you out before you are I mean look I I th this is even better because it's related to Warcraft um and it sounds like maybe this is World of Warcraft because that had the kind of like team versus Team where which I have played but I was thinking of the warcraft which is kind of based off of Warcraft 3 which was also cool but I played a lot of Starcraft listen man if you're sitting down to play Starcraft you may really love the ability to build up your Empire and everything but if you're not prepared for a zerg rush that's on you like you just I mean at a certain point if this is a game that has the possibility for that and it's a game that's worth its salt at all then they can't do that in one Fell Swoop and unless you have some social agreement beforehand like hey no Zerg Rush first 10 minutes or something like that then they're just playing the game it does sound like it was Warcraft Warcraft not world oh because they do mention that

their experience with Warcraft proper uh is uh is the video game is transferred he feel they feel like it transferred across and get Edge even better but yeah I mean look if you're going to sit down to a game where that's a possible strategy maybe have a little bit of a discussion about okay so whoever gets eliminated first gets to finish making dinner or what you know makes the snacks something you know I or choose a game that doesn't have a two or three hour long play time and could lead you you sitting there for most of that or or don't leave yourself open like if again if it's a game where you know like you are playing a game that is worth its salt that has player elimination almost always circumstances are such that you can see what's happening like and you can prepare for that that may suck because it may mean that you're not engaging with the aspect of the game that you want to which maybe like the Civ building or engine building or whatever else is on the side but if someone is coming right at you and they're coming right out the gate then prepare some defenses and fight them and that's leaving them vulnerable try to get the other players to put the pressure on them and if if you don't like that have I got a Suburbia for you if you like building you know your little Empire and oh look I can make workers but those workers are office drones and they go to this fast food place over here there's no Zerg rushes in Suburbia no just tenements and and

exactly mobile home parks the big thing with this game is everybody at the table sat down knowing that that is a rule that is a possibility and usually it's just the threat of it will make you act differently and this player the player who was upset about player elimation just it seems like they thought there was an unspoken agreement that you wouldn't do it immediately and again this is I'm going to kind of say it with most of these it's a difference in expectation think forget that person if you have a secret it's not a difference of expectation it's a of that person is a jerk if they think that there's some un unexpressed but you know universally understood expectation that's kind of a jerk thing to do to your friends like it okay okay we're going to play basketball but I'm going to get mad if someone tries to take the ball from me because there's an expectation that everyone gets five minutes with the ball you know like Express that you know like by not expressing those things upfront um then you are creating the situation for yourself to get disappointed so I have a follow question for you two then as as the resident you know generally conflict heavy upbringing that you know and and I'm usually having to temper my Zerg rushy Tendencies for that reason um what

about table talk in that same context because one of my main defense is to sit there and be like hey Jack Jack you notice that mot's over there he's uh he's wide open buddy we're gonna get to that we're going to get to that okay tell me there's a tell me there's a tabl talk question there there is there is one all right the next one yeah it is King making in a game uh there is a uh the topic of the post is uh diplomacy and essentially the the big Gest of this one is there is a person who is clearly winning and they have partnered with a person who is going to lose to them there are two other players in the game they approach the person who is the partner to the king is what it says uh and they were like hey are the three of us our only chance of winning we've done the math is to take out the right now but we need your support to do that and the prince which is what the post calls him said no uh I'm going to write it out and then I'll come back and beat him in the late game so I think you are going to be particularly qualified to talk about this one because you've still kept up your sessions of playing diplomacy with Henry and Kissinger's ghost there in DC yep so

I someone going to explain that one no well you know just famously Henry Kissinger and JFK like to play diplomacy and uh a resident board gamer has moved to DC I assume no one has played board games in DC since Henry kinger and JFK and so um moots here is uh being haunted uh by uh the the ghost of the past and having to play for sovereignty and Victory and um he he wakes me up in the middle of the night and tells me to

underdeveloped diplomacy a fair amount and and I will say there has never been a time that I have ever allied with someone that I fully that I did not fully intend to stab them in the back at the most opportune moment but it and so it may be a case of maybe they just aren't kingming maybe they are just misevaluated the situation they really think they have not done the math maybe they think they can do something but if they are just King making that's I call party Foul on that one yeah the the wrap up to it is uh after their conversation with the prince the two players left just gave the win to the Kings to end the game early I've seen that yeah that's that's the uh the wrap up in that's the question of are they did they overreact or not we've played a lot of Game of Thrones together and that's where you know like the the closest analog to me comes because I've actually never played diplomacy um and I think that okay my general thoughts on King making um the term gets turn around a lot uh and people sometimes get frustrated when someone ends up doing a move to decide a winner that isn't them but if it means that I'm making a decision that's going to result in me having higher position than I otherwise would have hell yeah I'm going to do that yeah I don't care if if I see that

there's no possible way of me winning however if I do this move I'm going to come in second place instead of third place and this is going to be the decisive end to the game sure I'll do that you know like what am I just supposed to exit out of the rest of the game and let the top dogs fight you know like that's not going to be fun for me either um and time is a commodity I wouldn't throw a game like just completely uh uh just go like all right I'm giving up the game and this is going to end it because I have no possible way to win I think that is kind of like a a spoil sport uh way of going but I could see in a game where there's a lot of negotiation um you know if I have no possible way to win then what I can do is try to interact with the game the most that I can you know I'm not just going to be a passive person on the sidelines John you want to help beat you know help me beat Eric you know uh it neither of us may be the winner of this game but that gives me some way of interacting with the game and an objective that I might possibly be able to do with someone else so just because you're not the winner and you decide the the victory condition I don't think that makes you a jerk um but there may be some more Nuance to this than I'm just broadly

painting what do you think uh I think a lot of it comes down to motivation I actually haven't ever heard it put that way and I think that's probably a good one because I think my question is well if I'm definitively in say third or fourth place what is my objective now for the rest of the game if I know I can't win do I play the neutral party and I think the answer to that question is which is a good one is well you can set the personal objective of you should still strive to be you know second place or third place you know what but if it doesn't Advance your position so King making without motive other than well I expected a significant other to be involved somewhere at some point no I mean that's like that's one of the main kingming situations is you let this the partner win um if that's the goal is just to advance the winner then that no that's that's a party Foul but if you're actively still engaging with the game yourself I think you know and that leads to that outcome I think that's totally fair what if it's going to prolong the game by you not doing something and yet you have a certain allotted amount of time we have five hours tonight we're at the two and a half hour mark and this is like our once a month game situation and I know for fact that if I don't take action this game I'm not going to win and this game May persist for another hour and a half whereas if I take action this game May end now or within the next half hour and there's

still time enough to play another two hours does that affect your Calculus at all how believably can you fib and say it was for other reasons I love it the I think for me the big my big complaint with this particular instance is it it did not enhance their game State at all like it was just them saying okay well we want the gamed in now we if if you're not going to help us there is no way for either of the three of us to win because the two of us will be eliminated and he'll get our lands or something like that and then you will just be along for another hour or so and it'll just be the two of you playing the game I think that that was maybe a party Foul of you know that's it kind of sucks that that's what's happening but you you did just actively take away the opportunity for somebody else to win and just lost the game like you didn't Advance your state at all in a lot of games there is a sense of well I'm fully eliminated there is no chance for me to win I'm still interacting with the game I cannot and

we are down to like choosing one of these two players is going to win based on my action and I have to choose somebody to win essentially and that that's the game's fault that's definitely like not frequent anymore but there are like games I I I believe there are games where it's well it's the last turn you two are tied I yeah but there there's no clean answer like what am I supposed to pick one friend over the other and you're you're like oh well you're a jerk if you pick the other one you know like yeah if no matter what I do I am making someone win then I'm going to take whatever action seems the most fun the most lucrative or even be like you know what it's their birthday was last week so you know there there's no easy the answer I'm going to take it or they earned it you know they worked for it or they were the underdog you know like I'm going to apply some Metric but if no matter what I'm in the no win situation where my final action is dictating whether one person or another wins then I have to make some decision two thoughts the short one is I do think that the people who quit might have been the Party Poopers on this one too though because as you said you're you're taking away somebody else's Victory where maybe they earned it and it's you know there could be a little bit of King making but they still lost their opportunity to feel like they won a game potentially um but it just that's very subjective because I think it's acceptable like in diplomacy I've seen a lot of diplomacy games forfeited but usually it's it's

you kind of let it get past a Tipping Point where it's very clear to everyone and even though winner feels good like yeah you know that's fine you know concede graciously but you you do want to play a couple points past the look just because you're feeling like you're not going to win give it a few more turns to let it let it really sink in that yeah definitely this is what happening it feels inevitable but that said um I've completely forgotten the other thing that I was going to say which was um you know well we'll have we'll have plenty of opportunity for you to say things about all kinds of other things because yeah we we actually got some listener questions on this did you curate those as well um I did not these ones I'm just ba grouping based off of where we got them so we're going to start with the questions we got from Blue Sky you can find us there at cardboard Herald we should know these things off blue sky is you know like we're we're still building there so so welcome to the ADHD moment in the in the podcast too I just remembered what it was that I was going to say which is that like the who goes first rule I have a very strong opinion on if if you can math it out and it's re all other things being equal you don't stand a gain or lose anything you know your your objective to go third or fourth or whatever you know if you have no other motivation than I have to choose I don't care whose birthday is flip a coin yeah let it be fair and random at that point because at least then no one has to feel like oh I chose this person over this person yeah I respect your motives I I disagree

I I remind me not to play with him if it's not my birthday no I I'm not going to make my turn in a game decided by a dice roll like I that takes away any of my agency uh and uh the social element the fact that I'm playing not with robots I'm playing with people I'm going to make decisions based off people at the table I hate that it comes down to you know things that are kind of irrelevant to the game but if I have to make a decision I mean maybe I might go like sure I'm going to flip a coin uh but that would not be my my default I would try to sus out some reason for doing one versus other yeah fair enough um our first Blue Sky question uh we'll move right along here is from J Shan Allen Shan spelled s a n uh and this is uh from a uh a post that Jack made looking for uh our listeners uh thoughts of uh am I overreacting and this one is uh the issue of stopping the game to look up slash debate rules some players are are purists who are fine with that because it's important to them to get it right but others at the table just want to keep the game moving who's overreacting yeah I'm a rules guy I I don't like house rules like if it's a

Cooperative game then I'm going to uh probably say let's just kind of move on because we're all in this together I mean generally if it's easily accessible all lookup rules we all have you know like hyper computers in our pockets we can just go BGG specific rule game and get the answer like that exists so it's not like it's real time intensive I like to play games accurately and learning a game accurately and playing it to those rules is a big part of it um I'm not going to like go like all right take your turn take your turn I'm going to you know look up the rules and then you know be like actually you can't do we need to unwind everything that would be Insanity I don't know what what do you think Eric I think it is a first of all depends on the game party games do whatever you want I don't know live your live your dreams on that one but if you're sitting down to play like a dude Imperium and you have a uh like oh I'm GNA do this and somebody's like wait I don't think that you can actually send those troops into this battle because you just got them which is not correct I think that is an important thing to okay well that like drastically affects the game and this is also a game that takes time to learn how to play and the rules are reasonably well designed for the heaviness I think at that point it's it

would be you are changing the rules in a way that will greatly benefit someone even if you don't know you're doing that it can greatly change like who who who has the chance to win based on how they've been playing like if if you house R and be like Oh I'm not sure let's just play it this way for this game and then we'll see how it goes if this is like an hour long time investment I think it's worth another two three minutes to look up that specific rule at the same time if you are stopping the game constantly to look up rules that is somebody didn't read the rules or the game is rule book is written way that makes it not easy to understand and that one the blame Falls Less on the players and more on the game but in that situation if if you're like oh well this is supposed to be an hour long game we're at 50 minutes it seems like we're about halfway through because we've kept looking through the rule book I can see how that is wildly annoying and at some point or another just I I'm I'm I'm not going to equivocate here in the spirit of dear Herold am I the arvar the arvar is the person who gets mad at me because I want to make sure that I'm playing the game correct I agree sure there may be other situations but arvar is the person whining and

winging about actually wanting to play the game accurately to the point that it can be that the rule can be found if the rule is written if you find the rule and it's an interpretation question of how should we play this Rule and now we're diving into BGG Forum you know threads and like okay what's the what does the designer say look I'll even allow a certain amount of that in a competitive game where it drastically changes okay well does this change the course of the game from this point forward how will we play the rest of the game if we're if we don't have an answer to this we'll make a a reasonable attempt to find an answer and if we can't within a few minutes then we'll we'll go ahead and make a call that and assumably you're making this the first time it comes up not after someone's already played Four rounds of and and used this strategy and then said well I don't think we should be doing this okay well that that's great we can do it going forward maybe but we're not unwinding so I think there's a level of reasonableness to where we can call it and say look we'll we'll research it after the next game but we've made the all reasonable attempts to find out the answer yeah and I think that's uh a matter of rules judgment and interpretation versus reference but if it's just I don't want to open the rule book to find it no we're playing by the rules all right I I think for for time purposes we're going to lightning round uh some of these so I I'm going throw these out John I need to know lioness has asked here saying a player declining to tally their score in a multiplayer point salid game where

it's obvious they're well behind the rest of the group so you just finished and then you're counting up points and someone is just kind of throwing a little tanty they're they're like I don't want to count it I don't want to count it what do you think uh I mean poor sport like yeah you know you knew losing was an option like you know it might be a little bit embarrassing but at the same time you know if you can't stomach it then maybe you don't really want to play games with these people yeah I think there's a difference between uh just being able to confidently you know like I concede the game like uh we both have magic backgrounds Eric you played a lot of Yu-Gi-Oh you know like if you're playing a game and it is clear that you've lost there is a sportsmanship element where it's like all right good game I concede but you know like if it maybe it's clear to you but it's not clear to everyone else who the verifiable winner is then count the ding-dang points I don't want to have any of this like election fraud judgment you know doubt down the road because he didn't count the points I think that it depends on the game group if you're like playing with uh some people who are newer to board games and they're like oh I can just look at the board and see that I lost by a lot I want to kind of save my ego to not know how much I lost by it kind of sucks but I think you should still tally up your points I I don't know that one is also that's where to me that's where it gets a little bit

spicier where it's I don't know if that is uh for sure yes I think you definitely need to count it up because you want people to continue engaging in the hobby and if they're like going to be so embarrassed by how much they lost by that they don't want to play again that kind of sucks at the same time that is part of board gaming and that feels more like a ego maturity Thing versus the board game itself is not the issue it is you feel embarrassed and you're not comfortable enough to accept that you are going to lose board games all the time like frequently if there's a big skill differential I I'll agree with you on that like a newer player to board gaming in general or or or a really complicated game that you also have experience with sure you know that there's probably a disparity and you as the experienced player aren't gaining anything by stomping them and their ego into the ground I could see giving them a gracious pass on that first go but they need to work their way towards that can't be an every time thing yeah because the question is just declining to tally their score not like aggressively declining which I think that that wording gives enough vagueness of are they going oh yeah you guys stop me it's I I I'm okay you guys you guys beat me by a lot that's all right versus oh no nobody even look at my board I don't want anybody to do the tallying for me okay I have a lot of opinions about this one and I'm going to kind of shut up because I want to hear your

guys's and because holy cow we got through actually a lot of these but this is more of an etiquette one the sludge man asked us very approp name for this question I yes yes uh they went to a gaming Retreat there were four players at the table one player was them two other players perfectly fine but one person had so much analysis paralysis that it was taking a game that might otherwise take like an hour to take like three hours and when they tried to politely point it out it exacerbated their stress and their anxiety so much and made it uncomfortable to the point where the person was taking even longer to play through their turns so I guess we could distill this down to what happens when you find yourself at the table with someone who is just taking way way way too long especially compared to everyone else at the table how do you handle that and is it a matter of just learning to be more patient do you address it in the game or do you address it afterwards um go ahead oh I I just honestly I was just going to interject something I was just going to say you know coming from Jack the box cake maker Eddie this is an interesting subject indeed I actually to be honest I've never found you particularly bad at the analysis paralysis but um I think it just comes down to look I

don't think there's a polite way to escape it in the moment in that game I do think you have to ask yourself is this someone I want to play games with cuz you can't change the person you can politely suggest things you can recommend things you can pick games that are maybe more suitable to that style but at the end of the day you have to ask do I want to sit at the table with this person again if they don't change because I can't make sure that that's going to happen that's not in my power to do yeah I was going to say that there is um there are a lot of older games and I think modern games have have grown out of this a little bit but there are a lot of games that are really prone to uh as uh Jack has been known for box box cake turns what what's is all this box caking is a term that was originally levied at another friend uh and uh Christina Eddie uh famously asked that friend like hey are you going to take your turn or should I go ahead and whip up a box cake while I'm waiting and then that became the inside joke I will occasionally take that long turn and I will get threatened with box cakes but that box cake terminology is thrown around at anyone who is taking a long time Jack Ed specific boxes yeah yeah cooking here we're cooking here um but yeah I think that there is a there are a lot of games

where that is a something that is prone to happening because people are if people think that they can math out their turn they will try to cuz again it goes back to they are trying to play to win they are doing it in a way that is not fun to other players but they are trying actively as much as possible to win the game with that said um people need to just maybe take a step back and be like oh we are the goal of the game is to win the other goal of the game is to have fun we are going to have have more fun by playing three games in three hours than one game in three hours like everybody's going to have more fun doing that I go back to John on this one the the etiquette thing here get through the game even if it's miserable you'll find yourself in a lot of miserable experiences in life and then afterwards politely in a friendly way talk to that person if you intend on playing with them again or maybe you know they're someone that you actually care about and they're new to Gam gaming and everything and talk to them about it you know like that's uncomfortable but we're we're adults and you should try to you know be like hey I'm not trying to hurt your feelings or anything here but I know like typically this game takes like an hour and we took a lot longer than that and it seemed like maybe it just wasn't

jiving with you do I don't know do you have any thoughts on this just because I want to make sure that we're if you're at the table we want you to have fun with the game in the way that you want to have fun but we also want to have fun in the way that we want to have fun and if that's mutually exclusive then let's figure out some other games to play that will work for us you know like but having that conversation and that sucks sometimes you have to do that but like social anxiety or not adults are probably better off actually addressing those sorts of elephants yeah there's a follow-up comment I fully agree with that I think you two will also agree with which is from vmc V2 uh it is uh how much I feel you in my opinion she should speed up in fact I think most people have a too strong desire to win and thus tend to fall into analysis paralysis reminding people that we are just playing games sometimes helps to speed things up since at the end of the day it doesn't matter who wins and also nobody is going to remember anyways also playing fast allows for more reps and you get better at a game way faster yep I completely agree that um well then let let's take it out with this last one here um and this kind of goes back into the uh kingming thing but Daniel Crowley 450 uh was like well is someone hardar are they are they overreacting when

someone points out another player as winning and then encourages other players to go after them so we're sitting at the table Eric has secretly just kind of built up an Empire and you know I noticed that John he he hasn't caught on to Eric's little scheme over here I'm like hey John you know Eric he's he's going to be out of control he is going to win if you don't do something about it am I a jerk am I an Nar I maybe I'm the outlier but I say no because honestly calling attention to something that could be readily apparent to other play if you now if you somehow had secret Insight information okay that would be a problem but the reality is is you know if it is a game where kingming or or knocking another player is down is a possibility like like a Game of Thrones right you know this is an aggressive game so pointing out something that someone else might not notice to point their aggression toward is a part of the game and as the person who's in the lead you should be sort of hedging against what if someone notices CU you don't know who at the table will notice so the fact that someone else had to have it pointed out doesn't change the fact that they could just as easily have noticed on their own right you failed to defend against their actions regardless of why those actions were taken honestly I feel worse when someone is kind of secretly you know kind of off in their own Empire and not you know like I I don't want you

to have to boast like hey everyone just so you know I'm winning at the this point but I do want to know what you're doing uh and if you're not at least kind of semi narrating your turns you don't have to say every action I know I'm guilty of like overly specifying like now I will do this and then I will do this and then I will do this and I will do this but you know like if someone is in entire seclusion over there and no one's even caught on to the fact that they're potentially going to do something that is obvious to a more experienced player then they're kind of letting the rest of the table down uh I mean if they're being subtle about their their actual gameplay I would say that's a problem but as somebody who has who has done this a few times in fact in Game of Thrones look if the whole table fails to notice and it might not be experienced it might just be that they just didn't spot the Waldo in the in the picture there hey look he's positioned that if he takes this move here and this move here and this move here suddenly he's got victory in in one turn you know look that's I get giddy I have a hard time not getting like they don't know they don't know until someone says something and it's like well you okay but that's the fun of it is I get giddy because I might get away with it I know that I'm trying to get away with something if you point it out then good on you for spotting it I think that there's kind of two two big thoughts of it which goes to

one people should be doing what they can to win a game like again that's if people aren't trying to win the game then that is what it is if the aspect of the game is that you have to police the table yourself so a Reddit thread I have here which is just a really similar concept is uh player a the Marquee player is close to a fox dominance win and somebody points out oh I think they're going for the fox clearings so we should stop them from doing that right uh and the person who had that called out on them got really upset that's part of the game that is like fully what the game is about is placing the table yourself and I think that most games were the opportunity to like point out oh hey that person is going to win unless we do something about it is that's just how the game is designed to be played yep at the same time I think that there can be some really tough situations where it's not clear who's winning like it might be a game where you know multiple paths to Victory like I might be doing pretty well in like the real showbo path but somebody else is doing really good in a different path and that person is like oh no go after go after Eric because he look how many points he has you have to go after Eric right now that then becomes uh okay

well you're winning though like you're winning in a way that the other players can't see but I'm pretty sure that's the only reason you're doing what you're doing right well I what I'm surprised by and what I'm encouraged by is this was overall fairly diplomatic somewhat consistent but not entirely uh singular perspective I I like that there was not always uh a a clean answer to any of these questions uh which I think can summarize everything with just like it depends right yeah being adult talk to your friends man basically well if people want to Dear Herald us for their own am I theard vark where can they do that you can find us at cardboard Herald gmail.com or at our website the cardboard herald.com or on YouTube where this video is being posted or on Spotify where this podcast is being posted um or blue sky blue sky is also another social that we are on um we're going to be posting like some sort of YouTube post typically the week before or the week of when we ever we film a podcast so feel free to comment on there as well kind of wherever you are hoping to reach us we're probably there uh and please feel free to reach out to us yep thanks John

thanks for coming on it was good to have you good to have you back on the channel good to see you again Eric and you know like John May pop up now and then especially if we need some guest co-host so you know like don't don't discount the return um and the Judgment He he'll be more fiery I had him I probably had him too much on a caller here he was eager he was ready and I was no you can't give them the The fulln Experience just yet save that for the sequel I grew up playing risk as a kid I'm not a good person that just made me who I am so he told me to be nice he told me to be nice going into it uh we're super glad to have John here um thank you so much for being on John thank you to our audience for listening thank you so much for tuning in every week uh I am Eric along here with Jack and John for cardboard Herold

Progress saved