Skip to main content
Loading video...

Nature-themed board games, deluxe/big box editions (guest: Ian Moss) | Ep 134

Transcript 57:09

hey everybody Welcome to the going analog podcast the show where board game industry guests bring their topics and games to discuss I'm Christina your host and if you've listened to some of our previous podcast you may notice that I love a pretty nature game so with the kickstarter for the new game ever Bloom wrapping up we wanted to invite the designer Ian M too analog Hi Ian hi how's it going welcome back you were here a long she forgot but I totally remembered man I didn't know you're I was like I hope she doesn't bring this up because I was like I'm like I think this is Ian's first episode she's like I don't think so and we have to look back it was a long time ago it it was it was we're on episode 100 something now 134 134 and this was like episode 51 so you were on with John Gilmore and we had a great time um and so but now you have a new game coming out and because in past you've done a lot of cod designs uh with John Gilmore of course so you know we've got wonderlands War duelosaur Island and dinosaur Islands some of our favorite games a fun news at 11 and now you're the designer at Nirvana games and the lead designer onun bunkers and badasses the Borderlands tabletop RPG which sounds super fun um because we love Borderlands like love love love and you get to make your own Vault Hunter and everything so it's cool so welcome back um I hope you remember it was a good time I guess back on episode 51 yeah I think I remember I think the topic that I had picked that time was

about uh RPG mechanics or like board game mechanics and RPGs because I think bungers and badasses had just been announced yeah like oh this is timely um and now I think everbloom is the first tabletop game from Nirvana is that right yep yeah they had done a small box game that was just like straight to retail with uh another um publisher it was the Tiny Tina's robot tea party this is our first like of our own IPS oh that's exciting and so we did get to play that on uh the tabletop simulator tetp simulator and we'll definitely be talking about that because our topic for today um is going to be nature games because I love talking about nature games and of course with me is Shu he's going to be discussing that with us also hello um and for you Ian what's the top of you would like to talk about today um so the topic I picked was uh big boxes and like deluxe editions do you do you like them do you do you get them do you pass them by uh talking to the right people so have I can't wait for this topic um but we we start off this episode by talking about some games that we just wanted to highlight so what is our game for today uh we're going to talk about clip second Dawn for the Galaxy for the Galaxy or of the Galaxy second Dawn for the Galaxy for of one of those

okay uh and then uh so it's the second edition of the classic Forex space game uh we played recently so yeah wait do you want us to jump into it now we're talking about it now okay so Eclipse uh this is a an epic epic Forex space game uh as epic as it gets short of another game Twilight Imperium that we've talked a lot about uh have you played this one Ian yes I played the original version at one of the John Gilmore game days um but I don't remember enough of it to like fully say that my brain's not going to meld it with the other big one you know what I mean those those I'm not going to forget parts of the experience and pretend that it was the other parts of the other experience and those are going to meld together in my brain because it's been so long I always misremember the factions I keep saying like clip factions are the names of the Twilight Imperium factions and I it uh similar setup like there's uh giant uh factions kind of buying for control of the Galaxy uh they're all fighting each other and then there's a map made up of a bunch of hexagono tiles uh you have to go out and explore to kind of conquer more territory you can uh research technology uh but the thing that kind of maybe sets eclipses apart from a lot of the other games is like everyone has blueprints for their for uh types of ships there's like fighter ships uh Cruisers dreadnots and then a star base which isn't a ship but it's like a floating uh Fortress that protects

systems and then you could buy you can research technology and buy parts to outfit them so for example if I put on a plasma cannon onto my Cruisers all of my Cruisers have it uh if I put on gal shields uh I'm not even sure if I'm saying these things right but uh that's thing uh it it would go on you would decide what ship you want to put these on so you can you start to customize all your ships like do you want them to have better targeting so better hit rates do you want them to do more damage if you do hit do you want better defense to screw up other people's targeting you want missiles that will fire first do you want heavy hulls but you you can only add so much like you you're have to power it and there's only so much space but as you can tell that part is the most exciting part for shoot oh I love that so it it's just so cool to be able to customize ships and and everyone's like when you're about to fight you're approaching and then people are kind of looking over at the other players player boards to see they're like oh man there's a lot of missiles on that thing I got to be careful uh or you could go into a fight confident because you're like oh they don't have any targeting at all uh so really epic game to take hours and the reason uh we brought it up uh even the second edition second Dawn uh is now a little bit of an older game at least two three years old uh but we played it recently because our friend James Hudson uh a druid City game GES uh so he's leaving he's our neighbor he lives down the street uh and then his family's moving back to Alabama so we've had a series of going away game parties for him and one of his requests was to

play Eclipse one last time and we had enough interest from our gaming group to have two full tables Sixers six players at one table six players at another table we put them all set up downstairs so we had them next to each other and then but James had a t a seat at each table so he would like take turns one side run to the other table take turns and then he he never this guy plays games very Lucy deucy he's like doesn't get bogged down in analysis paralysis so he's not overing for this weird situation yeah he'll go in and just does whatever feels good whatever sounds good at the time without overthinking it uh and he won one table handedly not handedly there it was close no not like our table I mean it was so close no he kicked everyone's asses at Christina's table uh and in my table he lost badly he like last place a lot everyone else was like pretty top four were really close within a point of each other so but it's just a really F if you're looking just for a really epic space themed game uh i' like I like this one better than Twilight Imperium because you could played in a third to half the time yeah I mean I think that it's a little bit more eury of a game versus Twilight I think the appeal for Twilight is it's like a whole day situation with a lot of negotiating with the politics and stuff so you lose that aspect with Eclipse uh but you have a lot more of the strategizing and like planning your turns which uh building up that Armada basically so um we also had a bunch of new factions we were trying out from the

expansion oh that's right uh so that was interesting as like i' never played my faction at all um James on the table that he won was playing a brand new faction that's obviously op you know so um so it was really fun to like explore these new factions uh that had different abilities and stuff like that so um good times we had a great time and what is your game Ian uh so the game that I was recently obsessed with is canvas um which was on Kickstarter in 2020 2021 they've had a couple of expansions since then um but it is uh an art game like it is an art piece in addition to being like a just a fun game like the game is good and then also they kind of leaned into uh the theming of the game with the packaging because you can it just has a a little uh notch on the back where you can just hang it up and there's no uh if you take it out you know I think you can get it it normally has a sleeve with it but you you don't have the sleeve on it and you just can just hang it up and it just looks like a like a little like a canvas painting on your wall yeah yeah have you done this have you hung up your canvas boxes no we I want to um which I think I'm going to do once the newest thing for canvas uh arrives um but no I just have the three they're on a shelf it is cool that they

the three have like a combining art also so if you have the both canvas and then the two expansions you can hang them up side by side and it's kind of got like a continuing art uh through all three which is which is fun which I I enjoy that a lot uh as um a person with limited shelf space let's say that dual purpose of looking good too yeah yeah the other thing I like about canvas sorry there other thing I about canvas is a mechanic which I don't know if it has a name I was I was going to bring this question to you because I don't know the answer to this because I couldn't find out in my limited research that I have done but it has a market mechanic where you can either take the very first thing in the market of in this case these are the cards that you're going to be combining to make your three different art pieces in the game um and you or you can pay one of your inspiration tokens which just look like little pallets uh with color on them with SW swasa paint on them you can you can put that on the card to skip it and go for something further down and it's I don't know what the S what that mechanic is called it shows up in more games than I think of any other mechanic that I've seen that I don't know the name of right maybe we should just invent one I'm sure there's a name but I have no idea what it would be this is our this is your opportunity own oh oh Market

piss everybody else off when you send them assist letters you know yeah Ian's Market uh pay to pass pay to pass that yeah cuz then the person if you take something that has that whatever that token is whatever you know in whatever game you get all of those tokens so now you have more opportunity to pass on future ones where if you spend all of your tokens you don't have that opportunity you just kind of have to take what the game is giving you or what you know what is there in the front uh on your next turn which I always like that mechanic because it's kind of push your luck you are deciding when to spend a limited resource when versus when to like save it or gain more of it and yeah I just I was like man this just show up in so many games and there I just don't think there's a name for it if there is someone will immediately like your comments will just say someone will just immediately pop like well that's actually let us know please let us know I need to know it's not I need to put in a game and trademark it it just be like this is this mechanic from now on um it's just such a pretty game that it and the rule set is so easy that it's so easy to bring like new players into the the hobby with it too where you're like I I love the little Touch where like when you're done making a painting when you've like slotted in um all the different pieces to try to get you know scoring icons but you've also made a painting with a unique name and then you sort of show it off to everybody and it's like there's a little like a easel right so put it out onto it's like so cute everything is super cute on it um I

love the whole packaging and and you know there are ways with the expansions to make them a little bit more complex for people who want more of more decisions and stuff too so Ian you should explain to our audience the the the probably the most important thing about canvas I think is the the format of these cards and the sleeves I don't think we mention that right no right so the the cards that you're using to make this painting you have your background of your painting already uh created it's already this is there for you it's a a wonderful um Panorama already but then you need to put stuff in the foreground so when you're grabbing these cards from this pay to skip uh TM Market you each of these cards is actually um transparent so it has the art laid over top of what is a clear background and you are combining three of these cards to make each one of your paintings you can get more cards than that you can have up to five before you're forced to create a painting but once you have five then you take three of them combine them and they have art at the top which is really cool and you're combining all these these things in these different layers and then obviously you can also get like your unique name from it and then at the bottom is where the scoring happens where kind of the game is unless the game is just trying to create the best name possible which sometimes sometimes I just do that um but really the the bottom is where you'll have these color

icons where each game you have a different set of these objectives that each of your paintings is going to try to complete and however you best complete each one of those objectives every time you complete a painting is the ribbons that you get and then you score based on how many ribbons you have at the end of the game in these various colors so yeah but the transparent cards I immed was it it created an instant back for me I I love games with transparent cards I feel like I hopefully we'll have one in the future a game with transparent cards in them because I think they're cool I I like their utility and I like the the way that they can kind of mess with the play space in different ways even if you're not sing them like even in a lot of games you just sleeve them into a card and it's kind of just creating these other things but if all the cards are transparent then you don't ever have to like playay them out in a specific way you can kind of spay them out in a way that works for you which I think is a a fun play space that maybe is explored hopefully is explored in the future with transparent cards yeah we haven't even opened our most recent expansion of canas yeah the third or the second expansion we have not opened yet yeah so that's on our Shelf part of it is uh we'll get to it when we talk about Ian's topic oh yes that's right that's right stay tuned everybody I I played I those we were saying it was it was great to introduce people we have some friends of ours who are newer to gaming like they played some games but I was like oh we should play canvas and then so we played canvas

and then we played canvas with the first expansion and then we played canvas with the second expansion so we just like played three games in a row each time adding a little bit more complexity that the expansions bring it was great co uh we'll have to do a progressive like that sometime too but we'll go into our first topic and that is what sh uh nature dreams so uh you know uh I think it's been a couple weeks ago or a month ago maybe uh Ian invited us to play uh ever Bloom on uh TTS tabletop simulator so uh just to kind of in case you're not familiar this is just a format for you to play board games it's like it creates a physical 3D kind of representation of the games uh so we got to play the game with you you taught it to us and our friend Derek fower from for game Spotlight and then uh and then yeah so want to give you a chance real quick Ian to kind of tell people more about ever Bloom but but when this podcast comes out we're just squeezing this in at the last second where it should be another 24 to 48 hours left when this podcast first comes out so you'll still have a chance listeners if if you're listening this as soon as we publish it you'll uh yeah you'll have a chance to back it so this sounds exciting to you go check that out on Kickstarter but uh Ian why don't you tell us a little bit more about everbloom and then we'll get into the uh the the topic yeah so everbloom is a an area control strategy game with that has features of like bidding and a little

bit of uh set collection in this world of Flora meets fauna um so the theme of ever Bloom which is uh kind of how play into the Nature's the nature theme uh topic is that there are these creatures that are hybrids of plant and animal and um they become these these mixtures of the the you know the cover features a lion with this like beautiful large leafy green Mane with flowers uh over top and these creatures are going around and kind of terraforming the world around them to help bring back um plant life to this world where it's starting to it started to die off and this this cycle is known as the everbloom because it happens every you know every age right it's kind of kicks off the age of the ever Bloom um and so these animals come in but they terraform naturally and without you know recognition of what they're doing so the players in the game are playing these factions of of like real world pollinators that you know be bats butterflies hummingbirds lizards lemurs um all these ones that go out and and pollinate in the day in their day-to-day life they are tasked with bringing them venturing out to the Wilderness and bringing these hybrids back to their own habitats so that they can help their you

know their home uh sort of rejuvenate uh back to its like original Glory but yeah so that's the theme and the yeah like the art is really really eye-catching on this game when we only did on TTS of course but uh yeah it was like a really beautiful game where like I I I'll have questions about like some of the things that that you you decided on later but we had a really I mean I had a really good time because I won but I had a really good time with this game um because even though like if you initially say area control to me I'm like I really like my thing but there's like so much more comboing going on in this game that I really really enjoyed so what did like what was your overall feel for it Sho yeah I I really enjoyed it um so I didn't when you first reached out to us Ian to play this game and he said it's going to be over TTS I'm like I I really don't like playing games on TTS I I feel like there's a time and energy tax of playing the if you if you have played it physically in person person and you could just reach across and grab things versus trying to do it with a mouse and Orient things correctly move right place or try to show people were to look on this board because you could scroll around different places and zoom in different places there's just like a amount of extra time and energy needed and so I generally try to avoid it but I'm like well this is the only way we're going to check this game out it's about

to hit Kickstarter and then I was very curious uh because we you know we enjoy your designs so I'm like all right we'll give it a try and then one of the things I really liked was um uh when the game was over it felt right and it didn't even with that the length of it was like the length was it was perfect it's like okay it was it was not too long not too short even with this TTS tax uh quote unquote tax that I'm complaining about it didn't feel like it's like oh that was a drag to play and then uh so that was my first thought I was like man this is a great length for what we just did like there a your strategy there it felt fulfilling and it didn't overstay its welcome uh and then the other thing I thought there's just like all these little touches here and there where was we playing you're like a uh it was like something like the last player I can't remember how this work player firster y yeah yeah so in the game a lot of time during the development we had we we originally had four rounds and we did kind of in development and these later stages we did kind of feel like it was kind of overstaying its welcome I had originally you know said like the rounds are season this was very thematic to have four uh but you don't stick with that just for thematic reasons like if the game wants to be three rounds it should be three rounds and with three rounds you have enough time to do a lot of the things that you want to do but not everything that you want to do like your your habitat at the end of the game you're going to be like ah if I only had one or two more cards this would be

perfect and that's where a lot of games kind of get you to which is is to this point where you're like next time next time I'm going to I'm going to perfect this this is going to be the best version um my habitat is going to flourish like no one's business um and so yeah so that was kind of a thing in development where we had this turn order structure of uh going down to three rounds you also have it in different player accounts some players will be first multiple times some players won't end up being first player but in general being first player was not good because in the flow of the game you're placing out these chips because I had just come off of wonderlands war and still had chips on the brain um chips okay so you have these faction chips that you're placing out that have these values of that's the number of pollinators that you're able to disperse and to send out to try and recruit these hybrid creatures in this Wilderness board setup um but that also means if you're the first player you're the first person to place your very very last chip and then you have in a four player game up to three other people who then get to go after you and see what you've done yeah and be like I'm going to take this from you specifically um so originally the mechanic was to just have a token that the first player had that would flip and then they could just add an extra pollinator to one of theirs just giving them an extra and that worked for a long

time but again it still didn't fix the core problem which was you stop touching the board first and then even with that extra pollinator you can just get things taken away from you and so adding shifting that first player bonus to this first player chip what that does is you everyone plays all four of their chips first player plays their you know uh they have a value one two 3 four they play all of those you know and then second player as you go through everyone has now played all four of their chips once everyone's played all their chips the first player chip can go out first player gets one more one more touch on the board and it's just a single one value chip so you can send it out to the Wilderness as you would normally and you have one pollinator that you can send to a card and just with that little bonus they have so much more agency in the game because now you know as the other players that there is still a danger that if you don't like outbid me by like two on something I could come back and tie it or take it back like immediately um so it just added that little line of extra tension and that little bit more of uncertainty to a game that like once everyone started placing their chips you can kind of start to see what everyone wants and that can kind of be your downfall of someone can see what you're going for really hard and they have the ability to stop you yeah yeah it's it's such a I remember at the time when I saw like it's such a little thing and it's

not something you put like on the back of the box or something you need like here's what this game's about it's not something you really mention but it it makes such a huge difference in how it flows and how it feels uh and then there's other examples of this so it's just everything just kind of comes together really well so yeah all the little details are great like everybody your different pollinator factions have a slightly asymmetrical power which is great um depending on where you put your chips which region there are different sort of bonuses or things that are penalties potentially and that's randomized and um you know different majorities you'll get get some other bonuses so like everything feels good as long as you win something I think um and yeah I really liked the flow and it was very unique because even after the bidding there's like you take you know if you win this this card you get to take it into your habitat um but then you still have to actually bring the pollinators back for the ones that you didn't win the auction for so there are times where you don't want to win an auction and so there's a lot of interesting um decisions to be made that aren't too overwhelming at the same time so it's a really nice mediumweight game for me so and one thing I appreciate and I'll use this as a segue to the actual topic because we do need to get to that um is that you didn't just go with a traditional just realistic nature thing you created your own world uh it because now going to our topic nature games uh it's kind of a tired genre for me no it's not for me it is from you can't

tell me it's not why do you hate nature so watch okay there's been so many in the recent years uh the so and a lot of it's like a lot EI whether it's like uh animal themed or plant themed like a lot of games are about like okay put these things Clump these things together or this thing will score better if these things are next to these things like it it's like that's always the case so I I was getting tired even good game like I I acknowledge that Cascadia is a legitimately good game and it's a great game to introduce to um uh new people who aren't necessarily hardcore Gamers uh but I was just like man I just I feel like I've played a lot of games like this uh and so uh I'm a little bit tired of the nature genre as a whole with one big exception to everything I just said which is Forest Shuffle uh that game uh have you played Forest Shuffle yes yeah I played it on uh what is that board game arena when it showed up on there I'd been wanting to try it and then they got it so I was like oh um uh my boss at Nirvana games Nolan and I played it on board game arena and again board game arena is like TTS but it takes all the hassle out uh if you if you don't know T simulator but you don't have to worry about cameras or moving pieces around everything is fully scripted so it doesn't auta yeah you can't cheat even accidentally um so yeah so playing it on Bor game Marino was was great cuz it was it was nice and fast uh it kind of calculated all of the kind of weird math

that you can get into in that game I still I still haven't played the physical version and I I fear the physical version because I know what old Edition that I'm going to have to do at the end of that to score it's not too bad it's just like you know you go through and score this and that but the basic idea of this game for people have not familiar you you plant trees and in each tree you can have a card Above It Card below so every card besides the tree cards are either split in half uh lengthwise or widthwise like horizontally or vertically so you have to decide when you're planting cards to use the upper half to go on top of a tree the lower half to go below a tree card uh right side left side things like that and then there's all these crazy combos of like I want to collect a diverse set of butterflies or I want uh predators to be hunting prey in my forest or I just want to go all trees and not worry about too much or do a lot of plants so I just like that system a bit more it's a slightly slightly more complex than a lot of other nature games up there but I like that one more mhm m one of my favorites so um I love a good multi-use card game um which for Shuffle totally is and yeah we've played that a lot recently yeah yeah I play the physical Edition I play on board game arena all the time so uh that one is great yeah uh how about you Ian do you have any big nature games that you're a big fan of yeah I think I was kind of in a similar vein to you where nature themes are there's there's a lot of them

there's there's there's been a wave recently there's a lot of space g yeah for a person who's made a a game in the in the nature theme space now with everbloom we like internally we're very happy that we kind of went I don't want to say the extra mile not that any of these other themes nature themes are lazy they had like force Shuffle that theme works perfectly I don't think you need anything else for Forest Shuffle besides that theme I think it you know all of the cards in that they feel very thematic but in in ours we want we went that extra level to kind of uh give it this sort of I don't know like Studio gbly like otherworldly magical Vibe um on on top of just the nature yeah to kind of live in its own space to um I kind of avoid nature comparisons to a lot of other games uh because that's a lot of times what these nature games have to do is they have to kind of fight with the other Titans of the nature theme or like with space games you're talking about like Eclipse like it has to fight with the other Titans of the space genre even the space 4X genre you know I had a question like where did the name ever Bloom come from because there's so many like you said there's so many nature games out there they're all Blossom and flowers and stuff like that like where did ever Boom come from uh so internally it had gone through a lot of theme changes which I had written a design diary that was what the very first design diary for this game on the BG pages about is this game is

technically 10 years old and has gone through five different themes um wow okay uh but a lot of things that change between these different versions like the only thing that from the First theme that kept to the second theme was the theme itself like none of the mechanics stayed it just was a very different game with the same theme I had on this other one um but then as it as it continued it originally went to a flower theme in which were just going to be it was just called pollinators at the time okay which is where we introduced the the factions you are you are pollinating factions and you're you're going out and now you're just pollinating cards but then the the systems of the game didn't really click as well like it it didn't really make sense for like that cycle that you go through to make sense to just get flowers and add them to your habitat cuz that's not how nature works so you don't like I'm just GNA pick up this Lily over here and carry this with me um so we wanted something that was a little bit more unique to the way that the game functions where we found the the theme of like the animal hybrids with the things and now you're recruiting like you're you're guiding them to your habitat which then makes a lot more sense that the cards are coming with you um so plal was never an option for the name no but like variations on hybrids or uh you know pollinating pollinators um but now they're you know habitats something but then in this last like couple years

you'll see that there's a game called pollinators there is a game called habitats there because the nature theme is having this kind of second or third wave now a lot of these names uh that I'm I'm glad we didn't go with because someone else already had them right and you know in their development putting those together M gives it that like sort of Otherworldly vibe that I think you're going for too yeah and it was kind of to build within that like that cycle so you know your pollinators go through a cycle they they venture out they either recruit and guide these creatures back to their habitat or they go to the Groves in which you they come back when they're able to pollinate your cards and that cycle is also the cycle in the game of like every age this ever Bloom happens so it kind of goes away and it comes back and it's forever you're forever blooming this world right and so that's kind of where ever Bloom came from was just a distillation of the theme and the themes of the game I guess that's uh let's see other nature games then what are what are some that come to your mind that you like really like or you still you know want to play a lot or or were very uh so one that I play a lot and this is uh a shout out to fellow wonderlands War co-designer Tim Eisner I love canopy canopy is one of my favorite nature themed games and the mechanics of that game are so much fun just to take this mechanic that was originally from like magic a

type of Magic the Gathering drafting like you would draft decks using this this Winston draft I think it was called system in Magic the Gathering and to kind of recontextualize it in the world of this you're you're trying to get these trees growing you're you're trying to basically create your own canopies with animals and shelter them from these forest fires and these uh diseases and stuff that you know the jungle is is known for um and of course the art vinent D tray art was fantastic yeah yeah the year that came out was definitely I think it was my game of the year in that weight class I was just it's like so beautiful so intuitive and uh it's like it's like a rainforest theme which you know you don't see too too much of the ma ones as a sub genre so um yeah I love that game um other things she was talked about Cascadia which we still actually played pretty recently too yeah we showed it to a couple of friends who don't get to play a lot of they love board games but they just don't know what to play we were visiting them and we broke it out and they both really enjoyed it yeah um I think another game that comes to mind for me with like just for different there's there's so many ways that you could take your them right um I think there like for I feel like you're just trying to you're sliping you're slipping in all these things to try to convince me yeah Shuffle was great you have to appreciate nature games more you should um arum for another small card game

really like actually sort of a mean scoring game where you're laying out trees and you're trying to like have them score but you know there are ways to block other people from scoring theirs and so it's like actually highly competitive card game for such a pretty game so yeah you're doing a very it looks like you're doing a very Serene thing but on the inside you're just screaming for 20 minutes and then on the super heavy side you could say dominant species is the nature game yeah I guess technically I'm more talking about more resour Ian knows what I'm talking about you're you're it's two against one here but it's just a lot of like like Standard current because dominant species is like uh it's prehistoric right if I if I recall um oh but there's some that were not PR prehistoric life too there were like other reptiles and like other types of animal things I don't remember I've only played it once and I was livid I hated that game personally it's just so so competitive like I I just hit this bad note with me but other people love this game and I I can objectively see why it's a great heavy game I just it's not for me yeah like I I'm looking at this list Christina has on her computer screen like there's like Earth and then I remember uh verdant and floriferous like a lot of these games have very similar yeah you're like collecting

certain types of cards to create these sets and stuff but uh very similar there lot there are lots of these well I'm going to call out some different ones call out another like Evolution that okay yeah I like oceans better oceans is pretty like crazy like swingy which I love which I love but evolution the original game you are developing your own species um that have different characteristics and you start developing this really interesting arms race with the other players because you have to feed your creatures and sometimes you might just go and eat other people's other people's creatures but if you haven't set it up well enough you might end up eating your own animals and so that's hilarious when that happens yeah that one thematically I think is cool I've told this story before probably on the podcast but uh we played a game where most of us were playing peacefully we're playing I think we're all creating herbivores uh and then so you're you're you're sort of customizing your animals to uh optimally eat and survive but then one of our friends Stephanie decided she's like I'm going to go explore being a predator and all of a sudden at our table of like five players there one Predator uh and no no one was ready for this right so she's just like free like about eating everybody up and we're like oh crap so then we had to develop defenses uh like CL like uh climbing trees or I think armored shells or like a hard shell things like that so it and it to me I was like that was so cool to

have to kind of like this is what evolution is right it's like people are developing different things not people animals I mean yes and no but yes I mean nature selects for those yeah nature selects I I know you get to more technical definition of uh how Evolution works but in general it's like these things uh start to uh become more prominent uh features because now we had a dangerous predator on the board so uh that was really cool to see and then oceans puts that into the oceans but with like the crazy variety of marine animals there's like and then you can like they add in all these like um extra packs with these legendary creatures which some would argue like oh that's no longer nature themed but it's just really fun you just almost like crazy Kraken or like all these intense different cards with um different characteristics and that one was uh yeah I haven't played that in a while sort of makes me want to replay oceans and evolution um they I think they're coming up with their ultimate version was it called nature where they're taking all of the Lessons From Evolution and oceans um to try to put it into this like Ultimate Game of a similar theme so I'm excited for that coming out D um one more thing I just want to mention of course wingspan uh sort of like was one of those huge huge games that's now classic that brought so many I think real life nature lover lovers bird lovers into the gaming Hobby and made some Gamers into Burgers so

yeah she s that he said turn some people into burgers burgers burgers burgers oh I know sounded like and burgers sure turn people into hamburgers uh also we want to talk about Ian's topic so what is your topic again Ian yeah so this was kind of inspired by the game that I had chosen which is canvas and my experience of playing it three times in a row which was I we we took we had the base game we took that out we played that and then we took out the first expansion and then I read the rule book for the first expansion and then kind of try to figure out where it combines to the base expansion or to the base game and combine those two things and then we got the third uh the second expansion out so now we have I have three rule books I'm holding kind of all of them to figure out the differences how to play with everything and then we play and then I have to figure out how to put everything back into these three separate boxes because it doesn't cuz they're thin they're thin box because the downside of of creating these art pieces is that they are these three individual boxes that don't really combine and you kind of have to put everything back where it was in the expansions you know in their boxes and if you want to play again you just have to take all three boxes back out and unload everything um and so recently they launched their Kickstarter for the canvas big box which I at very first like I not even going to the kickstarter I was like ah like do I really need it like this holds them and I can hang

these on the wall and it you know it's kind of a good system as it is and then I remember trying to play it and put it away and I'm like well maybe there's some improvements that can be made here so I looked at the kickstarter and it is a really good price for a big box and it was one of those times where I went out of my way to buy The Big Box version or the deluxe expanded version of a game that I already owned uh because I felt like it would enhance the experience of playing the game and it it it hold cuz it's going to hold all the components it uh has its own little sleeve I could then take the other boxes just hang them on the wall and never have to worry about getting them back down they can just be art pieces and then the best part is it comes with this a single rule book that has all of it together which I desperately needed it's funny Ian so what we were chatting and getting ready for this episode and you said that was your topic idea and you're like my game pick I think canvas my topic big box literally earlier that day maybe an hour or two before you sent that message I was on the canvas big box Kickstarter page and then uh uh I went through the same thought process I'm like well I I don't I don't know if we're going to hang it up cuz we don't have the wall space for it in our game room uh the the three original boxes but I'm like oh like all those boxes are really thin they're not going to share anything so oh you have to pack everything separately I'm like

having it all in one one box they could just pull from the shelf that had everything in it I like perfect I'm sold uh I love the singular uh rule books uh that combine everything into one sheet or one booklet and I was like so I I backed it and then like a couple hours later you're like I want to talk about these things it's like perfect I just went through this whole process what a devious master plan of canvas designers they were planning on this from the beginning I that yeah maybe I wish I wish other big box like solutions would give you the one rule book because I think it's one of the first times I've seen that where it's unless you unless it's like a deluxe edition of the game where it's basically you just you're reing the game that you probably already own but in a deluxified version that's obviously going to come with a rule book that has everything but any of the big boxes that I've gotten for like the uh West Kingdom series any of those Garfield games uh North Sea series big box any of those they give you room for all the components but you just bring your rule books with you so if you're playing with old expansions like in Raiders you just kind of again I'm holding three Rule books and flipping through each to figure out which which one which card is is that from that expansion is that a promo do I have the promo rules where is that at right yeah I I'd love it when they kind of rethink okay like let's if you're going to put everything into a big box how do you do that so like wingspan for example the aention wingspan they give you dividers for all the different uh territories for the expansion so this is like your Asia

cards go here your uh Europe cards go here European cards go here so they they like kind of figure out how you would want to organize it um and then uh the other side from the same company from stonem games uh they did create a single rule book and they have a spiral bound one for people just want it flat open they have a hardbound one for people who are hard cover for people who want more of a collectible look to it uh and then that's really cool uh one of my favorites uh is cthulu Wars uh they also did a single Ro book and it's like also hard cover hardbound uh because they have there's a million expansions a little a million little things and it's so they and they keep updating this there's like there's they're on their fourth version now and they all have different covers uh different titles of the roope book because uh it covers everything up to that point uh and so they update every all the different pages and everything it's a massive project but yeah I'm a sucker for this I want I want one for Eclipse because now uh Eclipse I have like four different boxes even though the first box is massive I have two more that has expansions another box that has all these little extras I have all these little pamphlets for these mini modules and expansions everywhere it's just a loose mess and I'm like man I would give anything for them to just give me one bigger box anything how much is it anything I would give up all our nature games in our collection to get the massive big box in one universal haven't thought about the marital consequences

of that yeah there's another recent one uh Village pillage where uh they released a couple expansions and now they have a big box in unified rule book I'm like I don't even care I backed it with two more expansions but like actually don't care about the expansions I'm just so excited to have a big box in unified rule book yeah I think the canvas big box comes with oh I say the canvas book comes with I think it's there's like a couple new cards and I'm like sure yeah add them in like let's let's do it uh yeah there was a new millennium blades Kickstarter uh but their previous Kickstarter was like here's the here's the big box here you go this will store all of your Millennium blades stuff and Millennium blades is like my favorite game that I will only probably get to play once every 3 years or so but I'll never get rid of it uh but it it is it had a couple of expansions and it you know the game features so many cards to begin with that this big box is was about double the size of what the base game box was to fit all of the stuff it doesn't fit on a shelf it's just above it's just on top of my one of my shelves currently but then they did another Kickstarter after that one and it was just here's some more cards I'm like all right yeah just get some more cards to throw them in the box I'll look at them in two years when I finally get to play the game again yeah it's just I think you know it does come down to in general like how much we like the game where you're getting that offering um and sometimes

we've differed a little bit I think you really wanted the Suburbia Deluxe big box thing and I was like on that one but then for me you know I if there's an added element of like Nostalgia like you said I'm never going to get rid of this game I still really have um a really big soft spot in my heart for like taido so when teido came out with its like designer edition whatever and I'm like I have all of the um expansions already the game is already beautiful but I really like this game so I think I want this like deluxe you know addition that puts it all together okay yeah oh and there were like of course they add in the extra bits like oh you can take minis now instead of like um and you can add all these extra bits that were not available before so that's all always very my least favorite my least favorite part of that is the the the taido soundtrack which comes on a CD that I have no way to play I like nothing in my house as a CD player anymore I don't know what happened in the last like 10 years but for some reason there's no CD players in anything like even like a PlayStation you go it in it's just like I don't this isn't a Blu-ray I don't know what to do with this wait you can't even like PlayStations uh play PlayStation 5 can't I think so yeah I don't know if it plays I might have to try again I haven't it's possible yeah I don't see why they would spend any work to make sure plays music uh I want to bring back laser discs that's now have you Ian ever you own

everything and you're like you would Reby it all sell the originals just to have a newer all-in-one Deluxe or big box Edition with the same content so you're not just buy a vessel not just a box you're reing the all the contents as well I yeah any of the like I said before I have all of the um the North Sea Trilogy big boxes I have all of the West Kingdom Trilogy big boxes I now I'm going to have all of the South tigis uh big well those are just in big boxes to begin with because their games keep getting bigger and heavier but in you know the previous ones I I have gone out and I've bought the boxes for for each of those I accidentally bought the Raiders of the North Sea Deluxe box two times they offered two different versions and I didn't realize I already had it yeah I think our most favorite like special edition recently has been the castles of burgundy so oh yeah yeah oh that's a good example of like so the castles of brundy we had the original version so that to get the 10th anniversary the anniversary edition anniversary and it was just and that was like just slightly improved I was like kind of disappointed and then we sold that to get the special edition which was amazing and that one finally really paid off I think because Castle burgundy classic game so fun but

you know you're using little uh in the original game cardboard pieces to lay them out and then you could accient like flick them off of your mat very very easily and you like that happens a lot with you I mean I'm clumsy so there's that aspect um but you know this like special what do they call it designer Edition what special edition special edition you've got really we got those really chunky acrylic sort of tile face they're so great to touch like the the like tactile factor of it and then laying them all out and it just looks fantastic The Minis we didn't really need yeah we those building minis um but you know you can have at least like a little standing Castle um whenever you've laid out a castle beautiful love that game so good and for you clumsy people uh the board is dual layered and it it gives you a little plastic overlay that the the uh tiles fit into people wanted that people wanted them it's no big deal but yeah that's a great set that's a game we bought three times now uh yeah ju just to get the latest version because each one keeps getting better but this last one's a big jump yeah I'm sure I I want to pick it up at some point but my plan was to wait you know until someone was offloading it to get the Super Deluxe Edition then I'll just take the regular deluxe edition I'm not I'm not picky I don't own it yet I just want to copy you know I think I played it one time but I really liked it yeah that was a classic um any other final favorites of collector's edition come to mind uh we already said the taido one I

really like the taido one I that was one of the first ones where I was like yeah I play this game enough I really like this game I want the super deluxified Edition and I don't care that I already have all the stuff that's fine I want to get my hands on the takenoko big box I that one is hard to find it is it is like a cube of like bamboo and it is it is like oversized one too the oversiz one yeah yeah doesn't it I I was because we when we were early on gaming together we really like takenoko as well uh but isn't that I I always got the sense that it's so big that it's not when if you play the game it's not going to fit on most tables I don't know I I'd have to see I he wants to find out yeah I I want to find out I have two tables one of them will probably be big enough and it will give you one opportunity to talk about our small world designer Edition yeah that's uh sort of my pride and joy uh we bought this years ago I took I spent a few months convincing Christina that I needed to buy very ex yeah and uh I think we paid $400 for it or something like that but I think it was people were selling on eBay for like over two grand later uh but it's uh the game small world which is uh you can think of as kind of like fantasy based risk but uh much better much much better it's got the pay to skip TM mechanic in it for the

factions I'm G say pay to pass I think I like to see what we'll see what sticks you know pay to pass has a nice alliteration pay to cuz it sounds like you're passing a turn or you're skipping a piece yeah I like I kind of like skip butter yeah POS no that's pts then oh yeah yeah pts um so small world this had uh it's map control like you're putting out different uh different races and they all depending on how you set up the game they have different powers and such but uh the original game uh you know it has a board and it has all the cardboard pieces and cardboard tiles representing your units now all of that's been upgraded to like chunky wood you have actual little uh boxes like if you're like okay uh Ian wanted the elves we would give him a little box that had the full color art on the top it has the power on the back of it he opens it up there's these uh wooden tiles nested in these little uh foam holders it's like just just like it's like it's just like such craftsmanship the the victory points are these really the biggest metal coins I've ever seen they give you leather pouches to hide your points into the maps are bigger uh just everything and everything's all felt line on the inside all the pieces now are represented by miniature pieces so from the mountains and the fortresses the catapults all that stuff is 3D uh Miniatures and it just comes at a big it

looks like a treasure chest wooden giant chest wooden chest uh has a little plaque that's like numbered uh rule book is like this little heartbound little looks like a little tiny Encyclopedia of sorts uh and it it at the time it contain all the expansions uh at that time that it came out which was most of them like they it came out pretty late in that game's kind of life cycle so it didn't really miss much it even has the team variant which was a late expansion that came out uh you could play that mode as well so it's uh it's really awesome and then like when we have people over at our place and they're like what is that because there's like board Gees Bo G and then there's this huge wooden case and then uh I'm like oh well let me show you I love showing it off and we'll open it up and take on everything it's just uh luxurious if you can't see the video she's been looking at me the whole time talking about this trying to reconvince me about this I think you don't have to look at me you already have it it's good it's worth it right Christina it's it's a it's a talking piece it definitely is and then every time people ask me has actually played it enough to make it worth it and I'm like I mean we have played it a bunch so I I guess it's there it's it's got to be I hope it's there yeah play for play uh so but thank you so much for joining us Ian and we had so much fun talking with you and uh everbloom of course is going the kickstarter is going to close uh if this comes out on schedule tomorrow

Friday uh the the 7th of June so if you listen to this in time U go check it out if you haven't back ever Bloom already and where can people follow you Ian and what you're doing uh I'm chaos Moss or chaos moss on places like Twitter Blue Sky if you find me there I don't post often but if you ever want to know things I'm working on I will have shared or retweeted the tweets about things that I'm working on there so still we could find it that way which is great awesome um thanks for listening all of our Super Friends of course and thanks to our fantastic editor Mike Zipkin for his help as usual now you can stop listening and go play a game bye bye

Progress saved