Skip to main content
Loading video...

Vantage Versus Earthborne Rangers

Transcript 14:49

Hey folks, welcome back to the dungeon dive. Daniel here. I hope you're doing well and if you're not, I hope you are soon. Okay, in this episode I have a comparison between Earthborne Rangers and Vantage. Uh I have played them both now so I can do this kind of comparison video some people have been asking me for. Um, I'm not going to show anything in the games during this video. It's just going to be a talking head video. If you want to see my detailed reviews, I have detailed reviews showing things from both of these games. So, while each of these games is an openw world adventure card game, that's really where the similarities end mechanically and narratively and how the games approach their mechanics and narrative are wildly, wildly different. And so the games really do play and feel a lot different, but they are both adventure card games. And there's also no sense in bearing the lead here. I greatly prefer one of these games over the other. And the one that I prefer is Vantage by a lot. I really like Vantage. I thought Earthborn Rangers was was pretty cool with some great ideas, but the momentto moment gameplay really did just a little for me. It didn't do much for me. I'm hoping that I can present enough information to you where I can convey why I like Vantage more. But in the information I convey to you, you might take that and think that you would prefer Earthborne Rangers more. And so hopefully I can help you make that choice. And that's perfectly fine. I don't really care which one you like more. I hope you like one of these. Or

maybe you don't like either of them. I don't know. But here's the information. I think I have six different topics. So topic number one, and this is the big one. This is the one that could, you know, end the video right now. And that is a campaign versus oneoff sessions. So, I'm not a big fan of long campaign games. I just don't have the time to play them. And I prefer oneoff sessions. I prefer games where you take a hero from from zero to hero in a single session. And Earthborn Rangers is a campaign game. It's a not a super long game uh campaign. There are definitely longer campaigns, but you will play 30 in-game days, whereas Vantage is one and done. And so that is a that that's a a huge thing. Within just a couple of hours in a single session of Vantage, I feel like I've had a a a total and complete adventure experience. you know, my character progresses with new skills and gear, and I've, you know, I've attempted to complete a major quest along with a few different side quests that I have discovered along the way. I have a great feel when I'm done with two hours of Vantage. I put it away and I feel completely satisfied in the game that I've played. Earth Rangers, I still don't feel like I've had a really good, solid, complete adventure experience. It kind of feels like I've had little adventure snacks while I've been playing. It's just it's extended longer.

And because of that campaign, things are kind of spread out over a longer period of time. And this is really an important decision point right here. You can probably turn off the video if if that's the one thing. If you like a campaign, get Earthorn Rangers. If you don't, get Vantage. It really is that simple. Okay, second topic, the learning experience. What it feels like to kind of open the game and learn the game. Both games are welldesigned. I don't really have issues with that. One is definitely more complex and harder to learn, and that is Earthborne Rangers. Earthborn Rangers, I think, is a difficult game to learn. I've had to watch multiple videos. I've had to look up things on FAQs, look up things on BG, but uh that could just be because I'm not very good at the kind of game that it's describing. I think the rule book is well written and a lot of people may not have issues. Just looking at BGG, there are a lot of rules issues. I think more people are having trouble with Earthborne Rangers than Vantage. Not to say that Vantage is some perfectly easy game to learn, but I really had no problem learning Vantage. Both of the boxes have good storage with card dividers, so that's not really an issue.

Uh both of the games do require that kind of constant component fishing throughout the game where you are kind of constantly going into the box looking for things to pull out. Uh both I think both games suffer from that issue um in a little of a a kind of a different way because in Earthborne Rangers you're kind of completing you're putting together a deck of encounters but that deck of encounters you may not even use it for very long because you might move from one location to the next very quickly. So then very quickly you have to put together another deck of encounters. Whereas Vantage is kind of one off. you're kind of constantly in the box putting one card away and taking another card out. I think that uh Earthborne Rangers, like I said, is is much more complex and it definitely has a higher skill ceiling for player skill.

And so, if you like a game where your skill where you learn to play better and you can become more skillful at the game, then Earthorn Rangers might be the game for you. Whereas Vantage, you're kind of going along for the ride. I don't feel like my skill at playing Vantage will make Vantage an easier game to play. My knowledge of the world will make me have more fun and maybe be more efficient in how I explore that world. But I don't get a lot out of kind of showing off my cleverness or being good at games. And so that's why I don't get a lot out out of the kind of gameplay that Earthborne Rangers uh offers while I prefer Vantage. Okay, let's talk about uh topic three here is art and graphic design. I think both games have very solid art and great graphic design.

However, this is one area where I do prefer Earthborne Rangers. I love the art style in Earthborne Rangers and that kind of pastoral vibe that the game has. That kind of Miyazaki look. It feels like the world is kind of ripped right out of Msuka and Princess Monoke. And those are two of my favorite designed worlds of all time. And so being able to play in a world like that is a lot of fun. And I think this game just looks gorgeous. The art on the cards I prefer over Vantage. Sometimes the art and vantage can feel a little more abstracted in the way. You're kind of pulled further back from the world. You don't get a lot of close-ups of the creatures and beings that inhabit the world. Whereas with Earthborne Rangers, with that kind of cartoony style, it has a lot more emotion to the art. I feel more emotionally connected to the world via the art in Earthborne Rangers than I do the art in Vantage. Uh, next topic here is the world design. So, the world design in Earthborne Raiders feels more thoughtful and considered in the way that things interact with each other. It really does feel like they took the time to develop a real kind of ecology and with the way that the predators and the prey and you know the flora and the fauna and the NPCs with the way all of those things interact. And because of all of those mechanical interactions,

the world feels more alive. And because of its campaign nature, you feel like your presence in that world has a little more impact on what's going on. Conversely, in Vantage, it feels like more like things are happening to you as your character. you know, things impact your character, but I don't really feel like my character has a huge impact on the world. You're not writing down keywords to trigger other things later that you've done because of the nature of its one and done nature. You know, that just all of this kind of goes back to this being one and done and this being a campaign. Okay, next comparison point is in the variety. So, I think this is a really important element to me. I've talked about that kind of a game giving me the illusion of anything can happen of having a vast uh a vast uh like library of cards to to explore and to discover. And I feel like this is one area where Vantage is the clear winner for me. Um, I've played Vantage more than I've played Earthorn Rangers, and I'm still constantly discovering new things in Vantage. Every single time I play, it feels like I could play Vantage 20 more times without ever encountering the same thing in the same way, and I love that. Now, I had a pretty big issue with Earthborne Rangers because those various encounter decks that you take

and combine to create your encounter deck are really, really small. And I've seen the same flora, the same fauna, the same NPCs over and over again just in the six in-game days that I have played. And there's really, you know, the the the deck of encounter cards is pretty small in Earthborne Rangers. Of course, that is augmented by the more detailed interactions you can have in the uh in the campaign book, the campaign uh uh narrative guide. But I get way more enjoyment out of exploring Vantage just because of the abundance of stuff that there is to see and do. I think the interactions are a little more detailed.

There are more there's more variety maybe in the ways that you can unlock interactions in Earthorn Rangers, but because I'm not a huge fan of the way that the game plays, I don't get a lot out of those. And so, I do prefer the variety. I do prefer the interactions in a game like Vantage. Okay. And the last topic here is solo versus co-op. So, um, as most of you know, I play almost all of my games, uh, solo. I'm primarily a solo game player, and this is another area where I prefer Vantage. It just feels like it works more for the solo player. As a matter of fact, I greatly prefer Vantage as a solo game. I think I have the most fun because you're doing the less kind of component fishing when you're only fishing components for yourself. And so, that's why it works.

It was designed specifically for one player in mind. And there aren't a lot of character interactions in Vantage. And so that's why for me, Vantage is just such a great solo game. And it's fast. I love the way it plays. I love the variety. And I love that it's designed specifically for a solo character without needing a lot of those interactions. So, I feel like I can do everything that I need to do in a single game. Whereas Earthborne Rangers, while it plays fine solo and you can play it just fine single-handed with one ranger, I do feel like you are missing some of those um interactions between the players where other rangers who have built their decks in other ways can help you overcome the challenges that maybe your ranger isn't capable of overcoming.

And so I think Earthborn Rangers probably excels at a twoplayer game. I have read quite a few people on BGG say that the game kind of breaks down at a fourplayer game just because there's so many cards and you burn through things so quickly and the games can go on and on. But I think that if you're a couple of game players who like to play these kinds of adventure card games and you like that kind of deck building, then Earthborn Rangers might be a better game for you than Vantage because you will get more out of that interaction. But because I am a solo player primarily, I get a lot more fun out of Vantage. And there are some other minor things. You know, I I'm not into deck building and so the whole deck building aspect of Earthorn Rangers is kind of lost on me.

Um I feel like uh with with Vantage, even when you fail, you make some progress. And failure doesn't just mean that you've kind of wasted a turn. Whereas failure in Earthorn Rangers feels really bad to me. It just feels like you have kind of wasted your time and some resources and um yeah and just the overall vibe of the overall the momentto- moment game play all of those little details in how the game is played in Earthorn Rangers didn't elevate the fun to me. It just kind of added fiddliness. said added, "I felt just a a couple layers of complexity that prevented me from fully committing myself fully diving into the adventure experience. Whereas with Vantage, I never felt like the game was getting in the way of me having an awesome adventure on this weird alien planet, doing cool things, finding cool things, upgrading my character very quickly. you know, very quickly going from zero to hero. Um, not feeling powerful like I could destroy everything, but feeling powerful in that unlocking new things, new interesting things for my character to do. So, that's why I preferred Vantage. Earthborn Rangers is a slower, more methodical game because of that campaign nature. You will have to spend more time with it, but doing so, you will become more familiar with the world

and you will learn more about the world and its interactions. So, those are some comparison points and comparing and and contrasting Earthborne Rangers and Vantage. I'm sure there are many people out there who prefer Earthborne Rangers. I'm just not one of them. I prefer Vantage. Hopefully, I've given you some information and in tandem with the two detailed kind of reviews I've done of these where if you haven't yet purchased one of these games and you would like to, hopefully you can make a better choice. So, all right. Hope you enjoyed this video. We will talk to you later. Bye-bye.

Progress saved