Skip to main content
Loading video...

Does Scythe need fixing? What do the expansions bring to Scythe? - The Mill

Transcript 20:15

hello and welcome to the mill I am your host dusty crane this week I have a little bit of a head cold so I'm gonna do my very best to get through this with this little bit of slurping as possible I know that's gross I won't do that to you but what I wanted to talk to you about this week is that I read a review this week titled scythe the the rise of Fenris the expansion that fixes nothing or something to that extent and kind of a clickbait title but the implication being of course that Scyther choirs fixing and you know i can understand that people come to scythe for different reasons or maybe they came to scythe because they thought it was something that it's not I've heard that argument that I thought I was getting a wargame and it wasn't really a wargame so I wanted to kind of approach this from a different angle from kind of a constructive angle and let's you know we take that word fixes and discuss what the scythe expansions fix from the base game aside there are what do they add and what do we gain by what we add into our game so let's start with bass game side that is one to five players it is it's almost like a posturing for war and trying to avoid war it's kind of you know bulking up and in and saying listen don't come at me but if you do come at me I'm going to be ready for you that's kind of a the the feel that I get from

side that it's more about the threat of war then about war itself and so you're doing what you normally do if you lived in those those those times where war had ravaged the the lands and and now you're trying to rebuild you still have those those utilities of war but you're you're so tired of it and you just so you don't want to use it it's there but you don't want to use it and so you know that 1 to 5 player game is is more about posturing in my opinion so let's talk about what fixes are provided by the first expansion which invaders from afar so what this fixes inside is we get two extra players or two extra factions we get Tagawa and we get Albion and we finally have all of the bases that are around that that base board are occupied now we we had the the Albion territory and we had the Tagawa territory and they weren't functional we didn't have any you know use for him really so this not only took scythe from 1 to 5 player game to a 1 to 7 player game with the two extra factions it gave us some some different I guess behaviors now we have flags now we have traps now we have factions that aren't landlocked

you know they can move right from the get-go but maybe they're limited by speed because they you know they're they have you know limitations and there's ways to make up for it in terms of like how you use those flags and some of those movement options but you you basically what we fixed was the fact that a one to five player game became a one to seven player game and now we had new factions to play let's talk about what the wind gambit right here what what that fixed inside and I guess you know what we might say that this fixed inside is we added vertical verticality to the board now we have airships of our airships work kind of like our mechs in terms of you know maybe one game they can carry resources may be another game they can carry workers but we also had another unit another large unit it adds a lot of presentation to the game you know not only do we have you know our leaders and our our our mechs wandering out on the board we also have these large airships and it's just something to behold but I think if ever there was an addition to scythe that kind of would make somebody look at the game without knowing what it was and think man look at that war game it was probably the airships I mean they look big compared to the other units on the board they look intimidating but depending on which tiles you drop because you know the airships you know they move on their own but you draw a passive Thailand you draw an aggressive

tile and that kind of dictates how all of the airships in that game work and there's some variance on on maybe you eat straw passive and each drawn aggressive and in what you get there but you know not only do you get these airships that look awesome you also have a resolutions module and what that works or how that works is there's alternative endgame States so I know some people have said you know the thing about scythe is like sometimes it ends so abruptly you know somebody gets that six star and it's just done and what those resolution tiles do is they give you or they fix the game of size by giving you alternative endgame states so maybe you just are outright playing twenty turns and that's it or maybe you're playing to a state where at the end of the board the factory is gonna explode and you know take the resources and in people and and mechs and some of that take that stuff with it there are multiple different tiles that change how the game of scythe works now you can go ahead and randomly draw those or maybe just when you're looking through that resolution module you go oh me and I really really really like this one I I want to play a quick game aside I want to know how good I can do in those twenty turns then maybe you just always play with that resolution downtown I think it's doomsday clock or countdown anything as doomsday but you might find a situation that works that works great for you and your play style

and I would say that is what the wind gambit fixes so now let's talk about this one right here let's talk about the expansion that fixes nothing and I'm and I want to stress before I get into this that I keep mentioning that review there's no hard feelings the this guy you know he has his opinions and they're valid for him scythe is not a good game and and that's fine I don't want anyone going over there and be like man I heard what you said it's it's nothing like that at all I just I like I said I wanted to talk about what more or less what each kind of expansion gives us you know because everyone while you'll see someone come into the side Facebook group and they'll say I'm new to size what I need to get maybe you can point them in this directory and and/or this directory wow I'm a little bit sick point into this video and say this guy kind of talks about a little bit of what you know each expansion brings so getting to the sigh their side the rise of Fenris if you were ever playing side than you thought and you're looking at the board and in Yaakov's beautiful art and you are looking at the mechs and the cards and kind of the stories that the encounter that the encounter cards bring you you might have been thinking like you know the stories that kind of come to mind and that's why I really like what Ryan did with this expansion in bringing a campaign you know legacy games were kind of hot and

still are but like we're kind of a new ish thing and this is not a legacy game I want to state that right off but there are changes that happen through the campaign that you know kind of carry over in terms of your campaign blog so maybe you gain something in a game that helps you later so but let's talk about that that campaign itself I loved the story that it brought to the game asides now maybe side is not missing a story for you maybe you look at the board nearly I like the game but I don't need to know about the world of 1920 plus that doesn't interest me maybe the campaign piece won't be of interest for you but there are other modules that are including in the book included in the box and that is also one of the things that I wanted to bring up was that if you don't like the campaign you don't have to play the campaign no certainly I for me personally I love the story I wanted to open those boxes and see the new stuff that's in this box you know that self contained within I wanted to kind of encounter those things or find out those things organically as I played the game new boxes opening and new things being revealed I love that aspect but if you're somebody who just wanted to you know add these many modules I literally turn around here 11 interchangeable modules there's a lot in this box for people now let's say one of the things you don't like is I don't

like being you know at war with the people around my table we don't like working against each other well there's a co-op mode that's in this box that might fix size for you there are different things that people come to size for some people want more battle in their games and there's ways to make that happen within the rules of the expansion some people want less battle but they don't want to co-op that's also something that this expansion provides there are and I'm not going to get into spoilers I promise you that there are different ways of changing the game of scythe to make it more into the the type of game that you want it to be now I want to be careful to frame that in that this is not in my opinion a way of saying I don't know what you want if you want more battle do this and I maybe I shouldn't have had so much battle so here you can try this it's not throwing everything at the wall and seeing what sticks it's it's saying hey I've heard you and I know you like these things and I know some of you like these things and I know some of you like these things it's not about fixing size it's about making the game of size of

your own now when we look at the wind gambit and we look at the rise of Fenris these are things that fans cooked up tie with the wind gambit and Ryan with the rise of Fenris these were fan creations now not everyone wanted a campaign cool not everybody wanted airships cool you don't have to get those expansions if these things don't give you more of what you want from the game of psy then you know they're optional the base game aside anybody who's been playing side the digital edition you know has been experiencing that base game of size and you know thousands of games are being played and and certainly thousands of games are being played with the base game aside there's nothing wrong with the game of size for me you may find some issues with it some of these expansions may fix those for you but that doesn't mean that the game needs to be fixed so let me tell you what I really really like from each one of these each one of these expansions so for the invaders from afar what I I what I really liked about that was the introduced the introduction of these new mechanics the traps and the flags and and how these factions feel different from each other and from the different factions that were in the core boxset i liked this because i feel like this was the the finality or the the full realization of Jamie's of Jamie's vision

for scythe you know these two things were playing together the base game and invaders from afar so I felt like that right there was this is what Jamie intended now the airships were something that cuffed up in that the fans loved and Jamie looked at it and goes wow you know that's pretty cool let's go ahead and build that I like those alternative resolution tiles now I'll fully admit that I don't play with the airships all that often it's it's just kind of for my house and and and the way we play or the game we play I don't have a game table yet so it's kind of like a card table and you know the wobble and in the airships you want to fall over on my table because I you know I got kids around it so it's wobbly it's it's just it's not a great situation for me so those resolution tiles for me are my favorite part of that expansion I like having a different end game rule set now the rise of Fenris to me is in my opinion the most ambitious because not only are you thinking in terms of what do I do to complete this one game you're thinking in terms of what am i doing to complete this campaign but I also like the the individual modules - I like that there's a co-op mode I like that there is ways to make it your own in terms of I want more battle I want less battle I want to play multiple

people with the automa to fill up that board I felt and I know I've said it before but I felt like the rise of Fenris was was kind of the kind of like the final bow for four sides now I know it's it's the final expansion in the in the side of expansion trilogy but like for me like it really felt like Jamie and Ryan saying you know you've been so good to us and in size means so much that we want you to have this tool box to continue making it your own and continue playing it how you like to play it it was almost like a Lego kit to me in terms of like you have these individual blocks but like some combination of all these modules and the base game and like whatever it is that makes you happiest to play in this sandbox we're giving you the means to do this like I feel like that you could probably take some combination of any of these things and make scythe at once both familiar but also different enough that it may not be what Jamie originally intended but it just it does it for your group and so the rise of Fenris to me felt like giving the fans the keys to the kingdom and saying like all right it

almost feels like in videogame parlance it almost feels like when the developer hands over almost like the engine resources and says you know here's the sand kit or the the the sandbox toolkit editor whatever it is and saying like turn the game into whatever you want you see these games that are like platformer is another games are you know it was a balloon shooter and now it's a deep-sea exploration game I mean it felt like that to me which didn't feel like saying I don't know what I'm doing with sigh that felt to me like we are saying are we like I need to do with it it felt to me like like Jamie and Ryan were saying go and make of it what you want obviously the way they intended for it to be played the way Jamie intended for it to be played is right there in the box you want to know how sire or how Kai intended for you to play it's there in the wind game but you wonder how Ryan intended free-to-play sign it's there in the box and I think all these things are complimentary without fixing anything that's broken instead I see of it being like seasoning it in and just you know adding flavor and I know that some chefs you know like if you go to a fancy restaurant if you put ketchup on your food you know you're probably gonna upset somebody but like I don't know what it mean it feels almost like what they're handing you that the keys to the kingdom they trust you with this thing that they've made and they acknowledge that that now it's yours now it's ours

to do with what we want in so in my opinion that's that's really what I like and what I love about these expansions if I had to rate them me personally in terms of what a new player to say you know they have the base game they love it let's start there let's not try and say oh you got to pick up side you also need these three expansions realistic resources get yourself a legendary box you need a broken token organizer you get the metal mechs right all of these things that really really just augment this thing that we love let's start at the base game let's start there um let's say they have scythe they love it they want more I think the very first thing you steer them into particularly particularly if they have the ability to play a large group but I still think that the first thing you point them to is invaders from afar because you get those two extra factions you have new places to come at it from the board so for me that number one invaders from afar for me the second one I think I would add would probably be the rise of Fenris for all the reasons I already mentioned there's so many modules so many ways to make sign what you want it to be and I think it's just a great story to begin with if that's something you're interested in and then last but not least is the wind game but I really like those resolution tiles and you put airships out on the table you're gonna draw attention you're gonna have people that that maybe take

notice of a board game for the first time because all of these pieces altogether just make a gorgeous tabletop presence and so yeah that's what I wanted to talk to you about this week it ran a little bit longer than I was expecting and my voice is starting to go a little bit but thank you so much for joining me I hope you will let me know in the comments what you think are maybe the essential expansions in what order and yeah in terms of stone mire news this week we we finally got we got to watch it played video from Rodney we got the the rulebook for the modular board which looks awesome we don't have a price point for that yet but May 29th we will know what that's going to cost I'm excited about it if you didn't know Jaime posted some another picture of the other side of the board the modular board is you know double sided so if you want to I think you've probably have enough pictures to know all the different combinations front and back of both boards the front back of the board's the front and back of the tiles you can check that out and yeah that's all I have for you this week thank you so much for watching I appreciate it more than you know and just be good to each other that is that is what I want to ask this week and every week if there is an opportunity for you to help someone up figuratively literally it doesn't matter if you can build someone up do so we as a people are pretty

broken sometimes and sometimes the the smallest little gesture means the most so that's all I got for you this week thank you so much for watching and I'll see next week by you

Progress saved