OWN IT, PLAY IT or SKIP IT | 6 Reviews in 30 Minutes | Rocketmen, Isle of Cats, Hallertau (+ MORE!)
Transcript
hey everyone dylan and carlo here from all you can board and we're here with a new uh video today where we're gonna be doing a bunch of light i guess bite size reviews we're gonna be looking at six games and we're gonna be ranking them rating them reviewing them whatever you want to call it based on three categories which is own it play it or skip it so you've probably seen something like this on other channels even out of outside of the board game world we're basically going to tell you our thoughts on this game and our experience with them and then we're going to end off by telling you whether we think you should own the game in your collection whether it's one you should just play it uh you know out of friends or at a board game cafe whatever the case may be or if you should skip it entirely now i just want to preface this these are not definitive like be all end-all rankings obviously these are our opinions so we could say to skip a game that you're going to tell us we are crazy for skipping and we can tell you to own a game that you are just not going to like for one reason or another this is just based on our tastes um and obviously if you've seen some other reviews in the past you might you know align with some of our tastes and our thoughts you might not uh agree with what we think about certain board games that's totally fine so don't take them as like the holy grail of uh of war game reviews for these this is just our opinions and it might help you make a decision on them yeah and for the most part these are ones that we just decided not to do a full review of on our channel some of them we've only played maybe once or twice or maybe not at all player counts but yeah and it'll be different games every time we pick these six this time and there'll be a whole different slew of them in the future so i think i'm gonna kick it off to you carla you can kick it off with your first game okay so my first one here doing a mini bite size review is the isle of cats so i'm gonna set it down on the table here this is designed by frank west uh and published by the
city of games uh so this is a polyamino strategy game that came out uh i believe in 2019 and the basic idea of this is you're competing with other players you the theme is you're on an island or isle of cats of course and the evil evil lord vesh is showing up to i don't know if it says specifically and then the rules that he's there to murder the cats but there's clearly some i can say the serious implication of something evil is going to happen yeah i can say with confidence that i like i obviously enjoyed this game uh i have no idea what the theme is in this game i just know it has to do with and apparently vesh is in some of the other games by this company but the idea is that you're trying to rescue these cats and put them onto your boat so with the polyamino aspect is every player's own player board is a boat um and you're basically trying to load up the polyamino tiles are cats so i'll actually put the box up here i'm not sure if you'll be able to see this on the back here a whole lot but you're basically trying to collect these cats fit them onto your boat there's different rooms and if certain rooms don't get filled up properly you're going to lose points at the end of the game but there's also a card system where you're drafting so basically every round you have a hand of cards you're picking two and drafting passing into other players and then you have the right to pay for those cards with your fish and the game plays over a certain number of rounds and a bunch of scoring categories at the end so it plays one to four players i've not tried the solo mode yet um and this is one so i'm i'm a big uh cat person like i've had cats my whole life so i'm always like intrigued by these kind of cat games and obviously with the kind of like influx of polyamino games i was this one definitely caught my eye got some really good reviews so i picked it up i've really enjoyed it there's a lot to like about the game especially the way
they handle the polyamino aspect like a lot of polyamory games we've played tend to have either a square or rectangular board like a lot of the time they're shaped the same way or maybe it's like an l shape or something this one it's like it's like an oval-shaped kind of thing but because of the different room segments and everything like the shape of it is really interesting and because of the way you're you know there's some rooms might have like five or six blocks other rooms might be big things and you're trying to fill them entirely and work around there's like rats on the boat that you have to cover up so i really like the polyamino aspect the puzzly nature of that where the game either maybe falls a little bit short for me or where i'm not really sure how i feel about it yet is that it's heavier than almost any polyamino game i've played like there's only the only heavier game i can think of off top my head is a feast for odin which we obviously really like um but this definitely sits above in complexity it sits above all the like other rosenberg trilogy ones like cottage garden trilogy or new york zoo um there's a lot of even my city from minor kanitsia like this is definitely above that and it's funny because polyamorous games almost have this like you just almost expect them to be lighter yeah because it's like they're doing a puzzle almost yeah so someone might have that expectation coming into it they're like oh it's a polyamory game i love polyamino games and not expect the added complexity yeah exactly the first time i taught this to someone they were actually a little caught off guard i think the game took about an hour and a half with the rules in the play so just note that it is a little higher above that but there is a family variant that allows you to kind of remove a couple of the rules and make it a more streamlined version i'm actually curious if i might enjoy the family variant more and the only reason why is because i have a bit of an issue with the cards like the drafting is like you're
drafting for the right to pay for them but then you still have to pay for them so i'm not i haven't played enough yet to know if that's worth the extra time that it adds and the other thing is just the goal cards that come out like the scoring cards sometimes you draw one and you're looking at your hand and it's like you get 12 points at the end of the game if you have this and i've had games where i draw that card and i've already met the condition and it feels like oh i just drew like a free 12-point card and so like obviously i'm gonna keep these and then like a lot of time you win the game by like five or six points and i feel like i just it was the cards that determined it so i remember in a game we played that that being the case where you were i would you i was drawing cards i still have to figure out a way to do and you're like oh look at this 12 points i just drew yeah exactly so for all these reasons i really like it um this is gonna fall into the play it or the try it category for me um it's definitely not one i would ever tell anyone to skip i think everyone should at least try it out and see what it is but if you're looking to go buy a polyamino game i think it's worth trying it first and maybe comparing to others before you see if this is going to fit into your collection the way that you'd like you didn't mention the best part of the entire game which was oh the little take this lid off here and show the people what they're what they're actually buying here which is the cat setup so your cat has a nice little comfortable spot to hang out while you're playing your game and literally the very first time i open the box up just unboxing it like my cat wandered into the room and within five seconds he was in that thing there you go the other thing i got to mention the rule book for this game is amazing because every like rule that it explains there's a little like paragraph about the theme of what's happening on the island with the cats or with lord vest showing up and stuff i'm gonna put an asterisk on the bottom of the
screen somewhere here that says it's a play it unless you own a cat then it's an owner because you need a house for your cat but yeah that is isle of cats highly recommend you check it out that is a try it all right my first game i'm looking at is rocketman by martin wallace so uh this is my first and i believe carlos first martin wallace game right yeah so we were obviously very late to the party with martin wallace games um this is the first one i backed it off kickstarter this is uh from phalanx games and i really didn't know what to expect i had a lot of high hopes for it because obviously martin wallace is a renowned designer there's a lot of games he's designed such as brass that you know are really hype on the bgg top 100 a lot of people love them um and so me and carlo went in high hopes and basically i guess before i get to my thoughts i'll explain a little bit so the entire point of the game is you're launching these missions to different planets i think it's earth moon and mars and you're basically having to it's a deck building game and you're basically having to decide which missions you want to launch um to go to these different destinations and each one is going to get you different perks different you know uh points for the end of the game and you're basically having to press your lock based on this deck that's in the middle of the board and this deck is going to determine how far you make it on your mission and so there's sort of this luck element that's involved but control luck in a way is i guess what the idea is here i mean that's i guess the point is supposed to be controlled like it doesn't always feel like that um where you don't know you might flip all the worst cards off the top when you're launching a mission that only allows you to draw three cards and you might not
make it or you might draw the best cards and you might easily make it to your destination so you're sort of controlling that as best you can by using different ability cards you have to start like later on on the track when you from where you launch um so you're having to kind of balance do you take these risks how much do you control your luck how many of these cards you use to make it seem like this is going to be a definite success mission rather than you know having it be a toss-up i won't get too much more into the rules we have the rules video up that you can sort of go over the entire overview basically i don't know quite what i think about rocketman and i've played it a bunch of times it's a game that every time i play it i'll be honest i feel disappointed but it's a game i keep wanting to come back to and keep playing and i'm wondering if it's just because that is the the essence of martin walls games is that they're so punishing that you keep coming back to try again and again and continue to be punished um it just felt like there was too many instances where i felt i had a great deck building strategy i crafted my turn and my mission as best as i possibly could i used all my best ability cards i bought the best ones i launched my mission i start four spots up and i'm like oh man this i made this turn come across perfectly and i draw a zero a one a one and a two and i fail and and it's just like i didn't do anything wrong except that the deck drew the wrong cards for me right and there are ways you can control really it says the first bad card you draw you can discard and things like that but sometimes in spite of those things you still fail and can i say too that in this game in a lot of games when you
have these types of things you have to like push like a try for something when you fail you're not set back but in this game if you fail the mission you don't just like leave your state as it is like you lose a lot of the cards that you've kind of teed up so it puts you even further back and slows the game down more so when multiple people are trying and failing the guy the game kind of like grinds to a halt near the end as everyone's doing that and that's kind of one of the problems i think we both had yeah we there was i think that was i think it was our first game or second one where the ending just felt like it was both of us trying to complete the same mission back and forth and we had you know um curated our deck so well by that point by eliminating cards from it that we were basically just drawing the same cards over and over again and trying to complete the same mission and it was just a matter of who's going to draw the best cards luck like block based off the top to succeed in their mission so that those that aspect of the game is something i didn't enjoy and that sort of has hampered the experience for me and yet it's a game i keep i've told carl a few times if anyone suggested doing play rock may be like yeah for sure like i want to play it well i think it's because the theme we talk about like yeah the luck we don't like mechanically how punishing it is but the theme of like nothing is certain in space so like you're launching this rocket you can prepare as much as you want but something can always go wrong and i it works thematically but it's just frustrating sometimes yeah and it's the frustration i think is is the tough part for me so this falls into the plant category for me um i there was times where i thought about it whether this is a skippet because of the fact that i'm not fully on board with it but at the same time because i keep wanting to come back to it um i think it's worth at least a play for you because i personally might not this might not be
against stays in my collection long term but if you're really into this theme and you're really into the punishing aspect of it you like other martin wall schemes and this hits that chord for you this might be a no-brainer so i feel like for me it's a play it could very well be an own it or skip it for you but i think it's gonna be one you have to try to sort of figure that part out um there's just some quirks about it even some things i've mentioned here that just each time i'm like this is still kind of weird this still doesn't feel quite right and i think it's just a matter of i'll have to play a few more times at different player counts too and just see ultimately is this just the way the game is or am i just you know having to get used to martin walsh's design philosophy a little bit so that is rocketman all right so next up for me we've got res arcana so this is designed by tom lehmann and published by sandcastle games you might recognize tom lehman as the designer of race for the galaxy and role for the galaxy uh so this came out in 2019 this is a fantastic game it is a tableau building game where there's basically a deck of i think it's 40 cards these artifacts every player gets dealt eight cards at random or you can play with a draft variant after you've played at a time or two which gives you a bit more control over what you have and basically those are your eight cards for the game you don't add anything to your deck you're just you start with a three card hand and you can take different actions like you can play the cards you can discard a card to take resources there's all kinds of stuff you do you can pass to kind of get out of the round and there's cards that you can play that can either like attack other players or force them to lose life and resources and stuff but you're basically you're getting these eight random cards and you have to find a way to make this
deck work like imagine being stranded out in the forest somewhere and you have a couple random items in your pocket and you have to find a way to kind of like survive that's that's kind of what the game feels like i've heard to refer to as like making lemonade out of lemons kind of thing uh sometimes you get your eight card deck and like two or three of the cards you're like what am i going to do with these these don't synergize with anything so you got to figure out which cards are you going to kind of build your little engine around and then it's about finding a combo that works and then kind of rushing that and trying to get to the end because it's the first player to get 10 points or if you have more than 10 points at the end of the round so very cool game it's um it has some similarities with race with the galaxy but it's a very very different game overall still because you're not just like drawing through a common massive deck of cards um and there's just so much to like about this because of that challenge of like sometimes you can feel a little bit like you're unlucky with the deck you have right i think we played once where some of those dragon cards where it's like if you have this your dragons cost less or you can do this with dragons then it's like if you don't have dragons yeah then the card doesn't really do anything for you but then maybe you use that card when you have just a discard to take resources and you're buying other stuff off the table there's like common you know places of power and monuments that players can all buy so there's some open information the players are competing with each other to get and like me personally i would even just say i don't think anyone should really play res arcana and maybe be on the first game without the draft variant um i played this so much on bga now it is on bj yeah and it's it's so much better when you can draft your deck and even if you might not get the perfect combos you at least get some synergy you're able to control the times there is there is an element that's really fun to just get a random
assortment of cards and feel like how do i figure this out it's almost like key forge in that way right yeah but it's it is the draft variant eliminates that aspect of like you got really lucky in your cards and i got a bunch of yeah not really good cards that combo together that it eliminates that right for sure i think the only time i wouldn't do the draft is if i was if i had played it a bunch of times and i was just showing it to a new person they wouldn't really know how to evaluate the cards so i think that might skew the the playing field even more yeah but after i'd say your first game just get right into the draft but uh i love this game the first expansion is already out uh lux at tenebrae uh which i think makes the game even better is such a good expansion there's a second one coming out in a bit if you haven't tried this out at least try it on board game arena um it plays very quickly too it definitely plays best at two players it would it's still good at three i haven't tried it yet with four i don't know if i would ever really want to play it with more than three just adds more down time without really adding a whole lot of interest to it i think the theme is also great i mean yeah we're both big fans of like the fantasy themed me especially like i i prefer games that have it in the same way that like you know people argue gaia project versus terra mystica right the the theme of this is just hits all the right notes with the dragons and all the you know fantasy elements and weapons and aspects like it just i love looking at the cards and checking out everything yeah the artwork is cool and i have to say to um because if some some people who might be watching this might have had issues with the iconography on race for the galaxy and made it tough to learn and a lot of games have that issue i think they nailed the iconography in this a lot of it is very straightforward like you just look at the icon and once you've had it explained once it kind of everything just sticks and kind of clicks together so um this
is actually one of my favorite tableau builders and this for me is going to be an own it um i think this is one that is going to give you so much replay value even without the expansion that if this even mildly interests you and you think it's worth it i think this is an own it type game and this one that's i think gonna stay in my collection probably forever yeah it's an awesome game i love it and that is res arcana all right what you got next i've got hauler tau you guys know me you know i love my uve rosenberg games one of my favorite games uh is a feast for odin um which is one of his other big boss games luv rosenberg sort of goes back and forth it seems uh most most years doing large big box games like this that the expert level tag on the bottom and smaller games like polyamino games and different things like that so this i've heard from a few people that this is supposed to be potentially his last big box game i don't know whether that's true or not yeah i think he said it himself yeah if it is i'm devastated but uh so hollered how i'm not gonna go over every rule here because it is obviously a complex game we do have a rules video that i can link above but in the same essence as some of his other big box games this one just does involve farming um this one also involves um there's basically this community center and that everything sort of revolves around in the center of the you know of your player board and the community center you're essentially moving it again i don't know what the thematics are behind this i've heard a couple people mention like how you move in the community center but yeah really there's this community center and you can sort of see in its window um a number and it that number is you know um what what is the number
indicated in all time number well there's one that shows the amount of points you're going to get the other one is the number of workers yes the number of workers is right so you so you have workers that i think everyone starts the game with like whether it's six or seven or something like that um and basically that number is going to increase as the community center moves and you're going to see a different number through the window those workers are being used on the main action board that you know is present a lot of his games and you're basically fighting for different spots every spot you can go to multiple times but it's going to cost you more every time you go there so the first time you go there costs one worker the next person or if you go there again it costs two workers things like that so basically you're increasing your workers by moving the community center you're increasing the amount of points you get by moving the community center the community center has to to move you have to move other little buildings that are associated with it to do that you have to gather resources from your fields there's a bunch of different resources you have to use different combinations of resources to move each of the little buildings which eventually slides the community center over everything revolves around you producing these uh resources um these goods um by using the different action spaces at your disposal so even though it is a complex game i would say that this one has less this one seems very um more linear than than other ones there is like other a lot of things you're doing but you have this one ultimate goal of just sort of produce goods in the best way you can um to be able to you know move this building um around whereas you know a game like feast road and it sometimes it often feels like i can play it completely differently than you do and we're almost playing two very different games sometimes not even competing directly except for scores this one we are very much are competing doing the same thing sometimes going for the same action spaces there's some
divergence obviously like some action spaces you'll go to that i won't want to but we're both having the same goals so i really really love hauler towel i'll start preface that right away um it takes a lot for me not to like one of uh his big box games they hit all the right chords for me um it's not a game i play all the time but it's one that if i'm sitting down to play a really deep experience i will absolutely like pick games like this so i don't own all of his big box games or many of them these ferdinand it might even be the only big box game physics steward kind of account yeah it's not as complex maybe but i think it's in that line of yeah that's true work replacement but like when it comes to like agriculture agriculture agricola um caverna um you know yeah exactly there's so many and i don't have a lot of them so for me personally this is great to have in the collection because if i want a different experience than a feast throne if i if i play that game a lot with people some people i'm playing with don't like it or i just want something you know new and different hauler towel is a great great one to put in there so this is going to be it own it for me um but i'm going to put a little asterisk by it is that i think if you own a lot of his big box games if you own them all you're going to fall into two camps one you're going to want to continue to that trend and have all the uver rosenberg games and have the you know the the whole gamut but i think that i don't know that this one necessarily brings anything wildly new to the table that if you have and have played a lot of agricola and caverna and lahav and avice rhoden that you're going to pick this up and say oh good a brand new completely different
ruby rosenberg experience the only thing i would say that caught me off guard at this one of my favorite things about it that is different from the other ones i think is the card system because you can play the cards almost whenever you want like there's no like you don't have to take an action to play it and cards become a huge but the first i think i've only played this once but i think i had like 20 or 30 cards because you play this card and then it allows you to play this other card and then you chains into this resource that gets this other card and that determines a lot of your stress that is happening that was a cool thing to explore that i really liked about it yeah that's actually glad you brought that up because that is one of the best things about it and unique things about it is that you're right even if in a feast road in agricola i feel like cards are more of a commodity and there there's a bit more like emphasis place i guess in police throne you can end up playing a lot but it not as much as hauler towel yeah and you have to take a specific action in those games yeah whereas here it's just like you met this thing on your card you just pull the card card and there are different decks of cards that you're using each game so each game's gonna have different cards in the game so there is a lot of variety in here so yeah you're right like it is gonna bring different stuff to the table it's not gonna completely like shake up the entire uv rosenberg big box formula but there is enough different stuff with it being very focused on this community center with the way the cards are played that i think it's still worth owning whether you have a lot or very few of his big box games it's an owner for me because it takes a lot for uh one of his big box games to not be an owner for me i i wouldn't get rid of it anytime soon because i will have always have people that i will suggest playing it or i know will want to play it um we've had a great time playing it at two players um i think with any of his big box games
you know played at have caution when you decide to play with three and four maybe more sort of four because with the games like this it just means it's going to be a long experience i know a feast from isn't a game i like playing at four players i think three is my my limit and i love it too so it's really going to be you know your your mileage there so yeah it's an own it for me um but i kind of knew that going in again you're it's going to vary for you just based on how many of these games you own um and you know how you feel about this kind of huge experience but i think it's a fantastic game if it's his last one it's a it's a great one to go out on but uh i'm sitting here with my fingers crossed that he's going to change his mind like stephen king and just keep keep cranking about every year to a year from now and that'd be great so that's all our job all right and the third and final one on my list is a small box card game called truffle shuffles so this is designed by the folks who uh make up flat out games so that is molly johnson sean stankovic and robert melvin uh this one is actually published by aeg though this is a 2020 game and basically the game plays over three rounds it has elements of kind of poker hands um and the board is kind of laid out at the beginning of each of the three rounds sort of seven wonders duel style if you've played that so it's kind of got like a pyramid of cards some are face up some are face down and they're layered over each other and all you're doing on your turn is you pick a card from the tableau and that's it unless you have one optional um play action which is to basically um i don't know what it's called you're basically playing like oh fulfilling an order so you've got these different types of truffles so the chocolates have different numbers and colors on them and you're basically trying to collect sets like poker hands so getting like a
flush which is like all of the same color not necessarily the same number you can get runs and straight flushes and all kinds of stuff so your turns can go really quick sometimes because all you do is just like pick a card the next person goes pick a card next person goes pick a card and then eventually if you want to pick a card and then also fulfill an order and then you're basically getting money for the type of order you fulfill right if you get four of a kind you get this much money if you do a straight flush you get this much money kind of thing but there's some cool cards in the deck that mix it up there's cards that allow you to like when you played it just says take two cards instead so on your train will just grab two or there might be a lose your turn but take three cards next turn and at the end of each round you can depending on player count you can carry over a certain number of cards in your hand to the next round so there's some trickery where you can keep one of those like you know uh like special cards for a future round to do something with it but then you have to discard all your other cards and at the end of the games player with the most points wins so it's a very fairly straightforward card game but after playing it a couple times there was some additional depth that started to surface with things like because of the three round structure that i mentioned there's stuff like you're holding on to cards for future rounds that you can plan with you can also see like oh if i saw a lot of let's say yellow and purple cards in the first couple rounds i gotta expect there's gonna be more be more green at the end kind of thing um it's not like overly complicated though i think it's a i mean it's even says your fun card drafting game for the whole family it's totally a game that you could just introduce to basically anyone really really beautiful artwork i think by dylan mangini like really nice table presents like you just want to eat all these truffles i was going to say it yeah if you had if you if you struggled
playing a zuul with thinking that the pieces were starbursts and when i see them this game is going to drive you up the wall yeah because it is uh it is a tasty looking game yeah yeah so and obviously there's going to be some people who are wondering how does this compare to point salad for example because that was the also designed by the same three designers and came out a year earlier i would say i've played point salad more i would say i like i like point salad a little more than this because point salad has a bit more variety from game to game you're going to get a lot more like there's all kinds of different scoring conditions you can try strategy where you go all crazy out and just getting onions and not these or whatever and the scores can also be all over the place though in point salad sometimes one person wins with like over 100 and the next player has like 60 points or something this is gonna be tight scores because everyone's just you're limited in what you can do every turn so it's going to be tighter closer games but it also means it loses a bit of the excitement that i think point salad has and a little bit of the replay value so if you kind of just want another game to have on your shelf uh to be able to pull out this is a great option for me it's going to fall under the try it category or the play it category because i think it's definitely worth trying for everyone but i hesitate to call it an own it because i don't really think it's a game that everyone needs to own or is going to play a whole lot i don't think it's going to be one of my favorite small box card games but i am happy to own it it's going to stay on my shelf for at least a while and time will tell whether it sticks around long term but which game is tastier point salad or trouble shuffle i mean truffle shuffle yeah yeah that's a ridiculous question my only thing i was going to say about it is the only aspect i remember about it and i have the same i'm sorry my dog is like whining because he's a big he's a big suck here um but the only thing i was going to say
about travel shuffle is the same thing you know the only issue one of the only issues i have with 700 duel is that i love the pyramid aspect and i love what it sort of introduces and allows with like you know blocking opponents and stuff like that you will run into situations sometimes where the way that the cards are laid out you're doing this sort of math calculation in your head being like if i take this and they take this then they take this then i'll end up with this card and that gets like after a while that gets to be one of the less least fun aspects of those kind of type of games it's just an order and math kind of thing yeah if i do this than this and then your opponent realizes that they vote matt you they've been out math and you're like okay well i can't do anything about that and they can add leads some frustration but i feel like all games have some aspect of that so it's not the worst thing but it's just something to keep in mind is like if you've played seven wonders you'll know sort of what i'm talking about and there's a bit of setup time too right you gotta lay out the pyramid and then after it's taken down you've got to lay out the pyramid for the second round and also the third round and then the only other complaint i have about the game is because of the fact that you the the fulfilling and order part is optional on your turn yeah sometimes unless someone gives you the cue like if someone takes a card and if they don't say okay your go you might be sitting there waiting like where are you gonna fulfill an order like no no you can go but then other times you go someone takes a card and then you go to take card like wait i was gonna fulfill an order it's like but you didn't say it and so it's this kind of thing where sometimes the game pace kind of struggles a little bit but yeah pretty minor complaint i've enjoyed it every time i play it great game it's just it's not a must-own but you should definitely play it that is truffle shuffle all right and the last game i am going to look at today is one that you might have seen a video on our channel for recently and that is sub astro which is a small enough box that i can leave it standing up here so sub astral is a brand new game from
ben pinchback and matt riddle and renegade games it is sort of a spiritual follow-up to stellar um and like it has some of the same elements it's a very different game but i would just say that in terms of that box our display and some of the gameplay elements you can tell it's definitely inspired by it seller was a two-player game this is it plays two to five um this is a very interesting game so you sort of have these cloud cards in the center of the table and you'll have these different biomes that are on each of these cloud cards you have a hand of cards and you have your journal and basically what you're doing is you're going to play a card from your hand to one of these clouds adding it to whatever cards are there and then you're going to choose to either go to the left or to the right of where you've played and pick up a set of cards from a cloud if you go to the left they're going to go into your i always get this right wrong wonder i think if you go to the left it goes into your uh hand and if you go to the right it goes into your journals so what and and sorry the card that you play the number that's on it is the cloud you have to play it to so it's a very there's tons of thinking but it's a thinking game but in a very good way like it feels great so you're constantly deciding okay if i'm gonna play this two that means that i only have one option if i go to the left i can only pick up the one whereas i have a three four five and six if i go to the right but is it to my hand that i'm hoping to rep cards or is it is it to the journal in the journal you're playing cards across the eight different biomes and in each of the biomes you're you know potentially having multiple cars at the end of the game you're scoring for your full matching set or um unique sets as well as which of your biomes have the most cards in their top two so there's tons going on in sub astro for this very little game and it's kind of similar like that
to stellar is it's a very small box with a lot going on um and very similar to stellar stellar is a game that takes up a lot of table space sub astral surprisingly takes up a lot of table space and because it plays up to five you have to have a very large setup to play to play with five players with this surprisingly um i really really like this game i hesitate to say i like it as much as stellar but they are different and they also play at different player counts there's a couple things going on here so sub astral is going to accommodate more people and if that was one of the if you played stellar that's one of the you know criticisms you had as i love this game but when i have a gaming group over or something i can't really introduce it to them this is going to fix that with a new coat of paint and with that with some new gameplay mechanics i think that stellar makes for slightly more interesting choices more dis interesting decisions each turn whereas sub-astral you can have some turns that don't feel like they were quite impactful there wasn't a lot happening wasn't you know especially near the end if you can't yeah take something to actually meet one of your scoring conditions you're just taking something to deny someone kind of yeah and sometimes taking cards to your hand doesn't feel super exciting you're sort of part of this game is you have to balance having cards in your hand that you can play with having to replenish cards in your hands because if you run out then you you don't have anything to play on your next turn so taking cards to your hand doesn't always feel super exciting you know your opponent could have done something where they did this great term with their journal left you some good cards and you realize you have to just pick up cards and you're just saying i'm picking up this and sometimes the choices are limited depending what you're playing if you're only playing a two you have to pick up the one so so you'll get some turns that aren't quite as interesting but i think that i've still enjoyed
every game i played of subastral and there's tons to explore here and i like the way it accommodates up to five people so for me this is going to be a play it but i'm putting a major asterisk on this because i think if you if you've played if you own stellar i don't think you need to own this unless the thing missing for you with stellar was the higher player count i think stellar is a better game and i don't i think if you can still own both and have a great time but i don't think it's necessary i don't think you're necessarily going to miss subastral if you're playing a lot of stellar unless of course you just really want to play with three four or five players then absolutely add it to your collection if you don't have stella if you've never played it and you're looking for one to pick up i would almost say you might want to go with subastral because you're going to have this wider range of player counts and you're not going to be stuck with just having to play with a single person this is going to give you more variety and it's still a fantastic game i don't think you're necessarily missing out by not playing stellar although i'd still highly recommend it um for me personally i own both i mean but we are content creators we you know get sent games and different things like that so if i hadn't and i played this i don't know that i would have necessarily bought both that had them both in my collection uh unless i really found that i just want to play with more people um again it's a great game it's just slightly you know below and owned for me because of the fact that i i have played stellar so much it's such a high ranking game i know that you me both but stellar on our you know best two player games yeah we really really love stellar so would you agree that stellar has an added level of complexity to like the decisions that this is a little easier to learn and easier to play kind
of thing just turn to turn there isn't the same like oh what am i supposed to do or if i do like this one seems like it moves quicker and maybe that's yeah it accommodates up to five right this one is a quicker game and that is a bonus because it has higher player counts it'll still be a pretty quick game at the higher player counts i will say the artwork in this game i actually prefer to stellar because stellar is sort of pigeonholed and having to be all about space um which this one has all the biome cards and the biome card artwork it's done by beth sobel is beautiful unbelievable i mean the box art as well is just amazing but um so aesthetically and it on the table aside from maybe the telescope aspect of stellar i prefer this but again overall i think stellar just is uh slightly above it for me but don't get me wrong this is actually still a phenomenal game i'm actually really curious if they're gonna complete the spiritual trilogy and do a third one at this point um because i think it is really great and i think they are both worth owning only specifically if i think if you are missing sort of that higher player count with stellar so it's a play it for me but i highly highly recommend you play it and see for yourself good pitch and that's it those are our six games so like i said at the beginning we're going to be doing these videos anytime we feel like we have enough games to cover um likely in the same range of you know each taking three each taking four or something like that we might at some point try to incorporate some older releases as well uh yeah highlights and games that we might not do full reviews on for on our channel but you might be interested what our thoughts are things like you know terraforming mars carcassonne whatever the case may be um so i hope you enjoyed this video uh let us know in the comments for any of these games if you agree or disagree do you
have them do you have you play them did you skip them and let us know especially in the comments which games you'd love to see us cover on this channel we might we might take your suggestions and use them we might even make full reviews on them we'd love to hear which games you want us to review which ones you want us to cover we have some exciting games we're going to be getting really soon that won't mention but some big releases as well so you're going to be seeing a lot of new review content on our channel still but otherwise thanks so much for watching and we'll see in the next one