Skip to main content
Loading video...

Why I Haven't Made a Video in awhile... Plus Recent plays Nucleum, Weather Machine and More

Transcript 32:09

Hello everyone and welcome back to the board gaming doctor. My name is Phil and I'll be your board game doctor today. In this video, I'm going to go over a couple of recent plays and also talk about why I haven't put out a video in almost a month. Um, but let's start and so I'll save that for the end and start with some recent plays and and recent updates. Part of the reason why I haven't done a video in a while is because I've been able to play games with other folks in real time. And one of those games is Nucleium. So, when I first played Nucleium, I played it solo and I enjoyed it. I gave it an 8 out of 10. And so, that was kind of my first impressions, preliminary thought on this game.

Having played it again, I came to realize a few difficulties that I had with the game. The game itself, you know, is is fun. I would play it again for sure and probably would play it and enjoy it more now that I've had the chance to play it again, but this game was uh my and my experience with this game was with three other folks who had not played Nucleium at all. Uh, so we, so it was a four-player game. It was a learning game essentially, but it was one of those experiences where we were learning throughout the entire game from the rule book, always questioning what things meant. And even after an entire play, and even after having played this solo, I still had a couple of questions and rules to clarify. I ended up playing this again a third time uh solo to make sure I understood some of those rules, mistakes and questions that we had during this play and of course it incorporating all of that. It was a very long experience.

So updating with the new CR cuz I played this game before I had uh criteria established for what I tend to enjoy in a game that I want to review, you know, quote unquote officially. And so the complexity and the ratio uh play time and complexity ratio meaning you know how hard is it to learn as well as how hard is it to implement those rules throughout the game really lowered the score for me personally uh since uh there are a lot of concepts that uh were difficult to for me internalize and also to convey to those around me. uh a game like Brass, which this is an in it's uh it was inspired from Brass and that system I think is a more streamlined experience and it does have a few edge rules and edge uh uh things to understand, you know, mechanically about that game, but I think it comes together a lot quicker in the original brass as well as brass birinum compared to Nucleium. I think Nucleium adds a little bit more complexity than than those games to make it feel more like a Euro style game, probably incorporating some of the elements from games like Barrage, but otherwise was very fun. I I gave it a five for thematic integration. I think um you know I I think the the way that

this game is it's not the most thematically interesting game, right? like you have a lot of games that are like sci-fi and I and I think this is where maybe some misunderstanding might occur but like you know games like sci-fi uh or other you know fun themes have an easier time being thematically integrated into the game I think versus something that is more economic and perhaps mundane as is Nucleium but I think the elements of uh the mechanisms of growing these nuclear plants plants and making them um slowly coming into fruition as you build out your routes, I think makes a lot of sense. And so uh so I think the mechanisms and the thematic integration of these games, the explanations for some of these mechanisms comes through pretty well. Otherwise, um yeah, I think this game was just it's just a little too tough to really internalize as uh you're playing this game. So, those are my thoughts on Nucleium. Next is Shipyard. This is the second edition uh from Vladimir Suhi that was out in 2023. This was a game now that we're approaching the essentime, a game that I was excited to try out coming up on 2 years ago. And the fortunate thing about this experience for me was that I had the opportunity to play this in person uh solo I should say but I had a physical

copy due to the library that we live by. Fortunately we live in a place where the libraries have an extensive game library and so I have been able to pick up uh Shipyard. I that's how I played Nucleium in person as well and a few of the other games that you will see in this video and in videos to come. So, that was pretty exciting. If you're not familiar with Shipyard, you are, as is noted on the tit title, you're building out ships. You are utilizing a rondelle system of multiple different rondell's. Uh, and this really comes into play in the um, uh, the solo game, but uh, here's the the rondelle that is kind of laid out in front of you. I'll zoom in if I can. So, you end up choosing an action from one of these that are displayed. I think a lot of Suhi games offer this, such as in Praga and elsewhere, woodwork or woodcraft. And so, uh, you choose these actions to gather different resources from these other rondellish type of, uh, resource offerings to, uh, get, um, goods, uh, crew, and equipment that you put onto your ship, as well as the ship parts themselves. And you're essentially building these ships out to um make and then make sure that they are seaorthy by

um test running them through canals and the you know how how well you build these ships out and uh put stuff you know like the people and the uh ship parts on them. If you are able to create these combinations together and follow different pathways on the canals that are also drafted from a market and I don't really see a good picture of that here listed, but uh essentially you are you are oh here we here we are. So you get to move a marker along these pathways and some of them offer some of these symbols and icons that are uh that match the some of the things that you can put on your ship. So all that to say is yeah, you are uh choosing action having an action selection uh choosing from a rondelle of sorts to put together ships and to uh do that as efficiently as possible to get points. And so this game kind of reminded me of a game that I'm going to talk about really soon, which is Weather Machine. in the fact that there's a lot of pre-planning ahead of time.

Hopefully, you know, gathering and using these actions as efficiently as possible to gather the parts that you need to put things together uh as coherently as possible. And you also uh need to uh make sure that you, you know, have enough resources to do so. And so there's a natural eb and flow in having, you know, resourcerich and resource poor uh moments during your game as well. And uh yeah, making sure that you uh gather uh the right actions at the right time. If you choose one that has been falling down in the queue, for example, for the action selection, you get money based off of where other people are positioned, etc. So, this was a upgrade or I guess a second edition, right? Um I don't know how things have changed from the first edition. I doubt things have changed very much, but uh after playing this, so I just realized that I hadn't logged my play and rated Shipyard. So, I did that real quick. And interestingly enough, uh so this game I gave a 6.9 out of 10. I went ahead I I would have given it like a seven anyway. So, I think this is pretty accurate for a first impressions. It's pretty uh pretty much a middling, you know, kind of down the road type of game experience for me. The solo mode was very easy to do. Uh you end up playing a threeperson uh game which is very interesting but

only in terms of how many people are utilizing the rondelle and therefore interacting with some of the markets and other like market rondell's that you interact with yourself. So player or sorry AI turns the um opponent turns are are really quick in this game and don't take up a lot of time and at the end of the game it's a beat your own score type of experience too. But you know I thought this game like in comparison to Nucleium was a lot easier to intuit it and play. Uh there is variability in this game, but I feel like the strategic uh avenues are pretty d uh there's a dichotomy essentially. You can either build real, you know, a few really big ships for a lot of points or you can try to focus on building a lot of small ships to uh pump those out a faster for more points, you know, throughout the game. I think either strategy really works and it's really dependent on what other players are doing and you can kind of have a mix of both of course too. So, so there is a dynamic flow to the strategy of this game I think but I don't think it would take a lot of time to really intuit it the strategy of this game. I could be wrong, but I think this game uh was fun to play, but great for, you know, a single play. Maybe, you know, play it again at some other point

if it ever comes up, but nothing that would have, you know, stuck with my mind. And in comparison to Nucleium, I think despite the difficulties that I had understanding the rules and internalizing them, it's still a game that fascinates me strategically that I want to come back to and I think I would enjoy the game more and more as I played it and understood the base rules better. Uh, so I can get into the strategy of that game. And that's kind of the opposite experience with shipyard where it felt like it was, you know, easy enough to understand, but at surface level in my experience with it, it doesn't have a lot of depth strategically. It it very much is a med, you know, midweight Euro game that is really, really good. I mean, the and the original game to its credit did come out a long time ago, perhaps about 10 years ago or so. So, you know, whether that's an excuse or an explanation for maybe some of the uh bases, the basic nature of some of these mechanisms, maybe maybe that's the case.

You know, for for Suhei games, I would rather play evacuation. I'd rather play uh Woodcraft, etc., you know, uh things that perhaps he has iterated on in future games. Um underwater cities, of course, Praga. Yeah, I think I would play all those games before Shipyard, but I still enjoyed my experience and finally got to tick that box off of a an experience that I've wanted to have for almost 2 years now. Next, I had the chance to play Fields of Green. So, this game is about 9 years old now, and this is a game that also has been on my radar to play. And when I saw this at the library, I knew I had to try it out. it. Now, it is for two to four players only. There is no solo mode to this game, but I did play two-handed to experience what this game is all about. So, what this game is about, and obviously it's a farming themed experience, but what you're trying to do is build out your farm tile laying style, but with these uh cards that you are drafting. Now, the interesting thing about the the draft and these cards is that you have uh and I'll try to zoom in on this picture to show you.

You have four different types of cards, card decks that you can draft from in addition to some standard ones that you can draft as well. But they're broken down into fields, buildings, constructions, livestock, right? And so all of these cards intermingle with each other and give you certain abilities and ways to score points at the end of the game or immediately or during the harvest phase in which you use your silos and water towers to fuel these buildings with. And uh you gain income based off of that primarily off of these buildings with the water and the weeds. And you're also gaining money to be able to play these buildings. And so there's an element of engine building in terms of having more and more of these silos and water towers to uh use more and more of your other building tiles, the the you know field tiles, livestock tiles, etc. that require these resources during the harvest phase. And so you're accumulating these abilities and the um methods to to do that with all the while trying to put out buildings that give you lots of points at the end of the game and so on and so forth. And then the other thing that's really interesting is that at the beginning of each round, there are only four rounds, you get to choose a different combination of six cards from these four

different piles. So, you know, you can really go heavy on fields or buildings. You know, there has to be a mix of all of them, but you can really tailor which cards you are drafting blindly to your hand. But in a multiplayer game, everyone does the same thing. They try to draft card types that would perhaps fit their play uh direction. And then you draft them. you, you know, draft a card and you take an action with that card, whether it's to build it or to do something else on your board and then you pass the rest of your hand to the left or the right and um and so it's like a seven wonders type of draft experience there too. So that element, you know, not just drawing blindly from one deck, you know, you have these different decks that you can kind of tailor what you could potentially build out. Now there's a lot of repet repetition amongst these decks right you have many field cards you know many tomato fields or many uh cow livestock etc on the board or you know within the deck and so there is a chance that you will see the same card a few times in addition to the building cards too. And so for me is seemingly you know a lot of on the surface level a lot of variability and um you know with the the different types of decks but when I looked through all the the different cards you know it they essentially kind

of did a lot of the same things you know offer different things and so it's not like a Gula type of nuance to every single card in this deck which would have been awesome. I think that would have really bumped up that score for me. It's more akin to like, you know, Dominion or other card drafting, deck building type of games where there is variability, but to a middling sense, if if that makes sense. And, you know, it reminded me a little bit of Beer and Bread. Uh, it doesn't have that. I mean, the cards are kind of multi-card multi-use types of cards that you're drafting, but also uh with the, you know, differing types of abilities that you can do in in both games.

Aesthetically, they kind of fit the same bill as well. Uh other games that this reminded me of obviously mechanically was Seven Wonders with the Draft and uh games of that ilk as well. So, it's not a terribly complex game. And so when I look at my rating here, uh, you know, it's fairly easy to teach and plays pretty quick because you are drafting these cards simultaneously and passing them along in the multiplayer experience. The two-player experience was very interesting where you each pick, you know, six cards each. You shuffle the 12 cards and then you lay out six of them uh for a draft that's kind of snake- like, I suppose. But so that that was pretty interesting as well. It doesn't have as much depth as I would expect or I would hope for in a game like when I compare this to pretty much all of the other Rosenberg big boxes that I enjoy. Personally, I think Fields of Green doesn't have that same depth that those games have have. But it I really did appreciate the mechanisms that are in play here. I think there's a really cool core of drafting, you know, the cards that you're going to draft later on from these different piles and having that uh that ratio and that mix be different amongst the the different uh collections of cards that you have in your hand that you're passing along too.

So, uh yeah. So, I I think of this as kind of like a beer and bread for more than, you know, two players. Um it Yeah. And so I I I did enjoy my experience. I rated it a little bit higher than what is rated what its rating is on average. But but yeah, so there you go. Um give this a try if you ever see it and if that sounds interesting to you, that's Fields of Green. The last game that I wanted to talk about was Weather Machine. So, this is a game that I played. Oh, this was probably in 2022, if not 2023 is when I played it and talked about it on my podcast uh way back when. And so, this was the first time bringing this game out. It was also at the library that I frequent and playing this with another player in real time. So, this was a return to this Lerta game.

It was crazy. Uh, so I'm a I'm a fan of Lerta games, particularly with Lisboa. I'm a big fan of On Mars. Uh, I do enjoy Venus and, uh, Gallerist as well is pretty fun. I think a lot of those games have the advantage of having a theme that you can mechanically latch on to. And I think I felt this way when I played this game before, but I I felt that again coming back that weather machine uh the theme of it is somewhat abstracted and the mechanisms that are related to this theme also feel a little abstracted as well. And so it was a lot more difficult for me to init this game, even more so than Nucleium was. Right. I felt like there was probably maybe five or so core concepts and rules that I would mess up in Nucleium and there were pretty much uh issues that I had understanding this game at every single point. U and and same goes with my playing partner as well. We we uh were in our player aids in the in the rule book pretty much the entire night. And so the experience probably lasted us about uh 3 hours with uh with playing it. You know, we didn't have to teach it because we tried to learn it. And you know, I watched videos I and etc. And it

still was very difficult to intuit it and play. And so this was probably the hardest game for me to learn out of Lassera's uh repertoire. And for that, I think my score did go down uh I think it was at a six, which wasn't terribly high. Definitely lower than the average, but it it came down to a 5.4 for just because it was it was really complex and overtly complex and abstracted to the point where I did not feel integrated with the theme at all. I did really appreciate the fact that you are pre-planning when to, you know, get your bots and line them up and and allocate them towards the experiments just at the right time. That way you can maximize the amount of points that you get and progress that you make with research. I thought that element of strategy was really interesting. But uh you know there were many times where I was failing to do that because I could not plan ahead enough. It was a str a struggle just to keep afloat rules-wise but also strategically throughout this game. And the game itself, you know, we actually ended up being quite close to each other in score. And we did comment that this game would probably flow a little bit better at a three player count, maybe even four. Uh at two players, it's difficult to plan ahead uh

you know, coherently and run these experiments together, which is what this game is trying to do. is trying to have opportunities for everyone to work together to activate these experiments to run them so everyone can get those points. And in this game, you know, I was focusing on the rain uh machine part of the machine and my opponent was on the wind. And so we didn't really butt heads a lot with where we were trying to go, but that made it long it made it longer and harder for us to accomplish our goals. And so so yeah, there there was that element as well, but uh yeah, so I it it wasn't a fun experience for me. It was I I respect it. It's it's hard to make a game this complex and visually very appealing and but you know, it was just a little bit above my comfort level when it came to its complexity for rules as well as for gameplay. So unfortunately that's where I am leaving weather machine. So that leads us to why I have not put out a video in a few weeks and mostly so some of the reasons that I've mentioned already is because uh a lot of my time now fortunately in a positive way has been towards playing games with other people in real life. You know, I've had the opportunity to play physical games that I never thought I would play. Both because I've, you know, met a lot more

people and have been able to frequent groups of people who do have games to play, but also because I live close to a library now that has a lot of these games. And so I I feel fortunate enough to do so. But and in reflection, I feel like this YouTube channel and my podcast in the back were attempts to connect with other uh gamers as well as to be a creative outlet for me to experience some of these games and have a place to talk about them, whereas I did not have those before. As I've mentioned before, I've I really discovered the majority of this hobby during COVID. And so, I didn't really have a lot of people that I could play with in person. And that and that's why I played a lot of tabletop simulator and Board Game Arena and still do, but I feel like it's the tabletop simulator scene is I feel like waning in terms of having new releases be available on tabletop simulator to try. So, it's it's getting harder for me to find games that I'm interested in to play and demonstrate for myself as well as for you. And, you know, it's definitely a lot of hard work to set up a live playthrough. one for the the cost of it. Uh I could probably afford it now but or I could afford it but you know

not in terms of time you know to really make things as pristine as possible as some other folks do who have a more established routine in in terms of how they make videos. And so I don't anticipate doing that. Uh, as you've seen perhaps seen in some of my past videos, the quality, you know, wasn't really up to par for some of those playthroughs that I've made for uh in in real life, you know, with some of the games that I own. And but now, you know, that time that I probably would have spent in isolation in alone to making a quality uh video would probably just be spent now teaching and playing games with other other people, which I think is a better experience for me in general, and I think you would agree as well.

So, that has been kind of a a tear away from this channel. Uh, and part of that too is, you know, I'm able to play some games that I have wanted to play for a while, but some of these games are older, you know, as far as maybe one or two years older. And so, I don't think they would be as interesting for me to talk about. And it actually took me quite a while to sit down and make this video because I, you know, there might be a handful of you that really appreciate my opinion or maybe this is something that is, you know, that you would look forward to is is hearing me uh talk about some of these games that I've played before and rerate them now that I've had different experiences with them. But I think for the majority of people who are out there looking for content on YouTube, they want reviews of the latest and greatest and you know that's not what I have access to right now. One because of Tabletop Simulator, not having those games that I'm interested in and not really having the opportunity to have those game uh those copies uh personally, you know. So, so yeah, I think as more of those games do come around, I I will try to cover them.

But ultimately, like this channel, and I think this has been mentioned before, it's not about the uh it's I I do this as a part of my hobby. You know, this is my relaxing time after work, after time with family. And I if it's s, you know, as soon as it becomes a chore, then it's not fun and it's not something that I'm going to pressure myself into. No matter what outcomes, you know, happen, uh, whether the channel grows or not, it as soon as it becomes a chore, it's not and it's not fun, then it's not worth my time. And and not to say that you guys aren't worth my time. it just it's you know if it's not fun for me to do then I I would rather go and play a game with other folks and have fun doing that. So lastly uh the I I think yes the biggest reason is that that I haven't been playing a lot of games is that I've been playing Silkong and so I've really been enjoying this experience. It's a a very long experience and it's a tough game.

It's rewarding though. If you haven't played it, I would check out Hollow Knight first, the original game. Uh because Silk Song is uh like the it's a sequel uh mechanically to to Hollow Knight. Perhaps it's a I think a probably a prequel when it comes to lore, but mechanically having played Hollow Knight first was a of benefit to uh getting into this game and surviving through it. Um, a big reason why I've been playing it is not just for my own enjoyment, but for my kids. They really enjoy watching me play it. And so, um, that's kind of been our nightly ritual. And so the time, the extra time that I've had to uh play or or to like make videos in the past has been taken up by playing Silk Song. And I think that's totally fine. And hope you understand that that's kind of where I'm at right now. And and so in the near future, I probably won't be making a lot of videos. I'll probably be talking about some of the games that are coming out at essentime if any catch my eye as well as other games that I will play in the near future that will be of interest to me to talk about whether they are the latest hotness or not. And of course I'll cover Rosenberg games as they are coming out. I believe Garden Lake is coming out very soon at like around essent time I think as well as the new version of Canal. And so I I would be

keen to getting my hands on them and and trying them out as well. And we, you know, and go from there. But in any case, I I think I'll leave it there. Um, just as a side thought, too, I think it'd be really interesting if someone put together a board game based off of Hollow Knight. I think that IP would be very interesting to see how it would mechanically be portrayed in the board game experience. I think of games like Slay the Spire, which are fun video games, but also, you know, it can be really well translated into the tabletop experience. Uh there are other games that I think like video games that are uh more thematically driven rather than uh like with the euro mechanisms that I'm used to. And so perhaps Hollow Knight would be more of a thematic game anyway. But it it's fun to think about what um what kind of games, video games and other IPs as well would translate well into the Euro style uh gameplay in specific.

So let me know uh what you think about uh some of the board games that I've talked about today. If you have any opinions one way or the other. Uh if you've played Silk Song, let me know if your experience with that as well. And also if you have any IPs that you would hope would get translated to the tabletop experience, uh, let me know as well and I think that would be fun the as a discussion in the comments. So anyway, thank you for listening to the my ramblings and for this video. Um, once again, we'll see how frequent frequently I can put out content, but we'll see uh in the near future if something comes up. Uh maybe I'll be back in form as I was a couple of months ago. But in any case, have a good one. Thank you for uh scheduling this appointment with me and hope you schedule an appointment with me real soon. Take care.

Progress saved