Skip to main content
Loading video...

WINGSPAN vs EVERDELL - Best Gateway Euro Board Game

Transcript 19:44

when i first curated my board game collection i used to own a whole heap of party games games that you could play down at the pub light games you could play at your friend's house on a friday night but i felt that those games didn't really scratch that each to play something heavier so it turned my attention to thematic euros and in particular when i first sat down to decide what sort of euros i wanted to play in my collection and get in my collection it was incredibly overwhelming there were two games that constantly appeared on my radars ones that were family friendly approachable and ones that i thought that i could get out to the table quite often and they were evidel and wingspan and in this video we're going to bring this giant delicate tree out we're going to compare both of these cool euro games and see which one is the perfect fit for you hey dude you'll never guess what game i just bought hey i just bought a brand new board game too it's a euro game that i know you're probably gonna love wait mine's a euro as well it has animals in it and so many colorful components same my game also has card driven gameplay my game has plays building a tableau wait do we both just get the same board game wingspan is an excellent bird engine building game where players craft

natural bird averys out of these pretty looking pieces of cardboard it's essentially a card game where each card features a unique bird trapped in two dimensions inside a very white border like some sort of museum exhibition across the game players will use these bird boxes i mean cubes to activate actions on their playboards and trigger the effects of different birds placed in their habitat rows players can play bird cards from their hand like some avian poker game by paying the resource and egg costs shown to continue filling up their grid of birds players will need to activate the forest road to gather resources from this yahtzee tower of dice laying eggs is important for gaining victory points and plopping them on different species means you can keep those nest eggs nice and safe finally developing a car drawing engine in the aquatic habitat provides you access to more birds allowing you to enhance your menagerie of birds like some sort of peacock display the interplay of triggering actions in different rows fosters a system of actions that grow and compound across the game have you ever wanted to delve into city building with a range of forest creatures right at your helm well it doesn't seem quite convincing at first when you have a badger who's an architect and a crow as a teacher they actually might serve you better than you think everdel is about plonking things down plonk a worker here gain a resource plonk a worker there and draw a card and get a juicy berry at the same time gather enough twigs resins and stone and you just might also be able to plonk a building in your city too all of this

plonking does have a purpose however building certain buildings helps to start your city's engine critters can be played for free if their matching building already exists which is totally cute players are competing for victory points by vying to satisfy event cards building a synergistic tableau of cards by using cards that make things cheaper to build your workers are particularly special as you can unlock more of them as the game progresses widening the scope of what you can do this plonking effect helps to block important spaces so that other players can't get what they need how considerate who said we need roadblocks when we can use these anime bulls instead ultimately this walk in the woods is certainly surprising so when it came to deciding which of these two games i was going to get theme was a big important factor how the theme was accentuated and presented in terms of picking up the box playing the game and also feeling the mechanics was really important to me when i got wingspan i felt like when i was playing the cards i loved the factual information on the cards that kind of reflected where that bird came from their wingspan but also the mechanics and effects on the card really reflected some of that bird's unique behaviors and that's what i really loved about the fact that they can nest or produce eggs or forage for food or they hunt that was something that i thought was a lovely beautiful elegant touch with everdel i really liked the fact that you could house certain critters in their matching houses so the bard goes with the theater it has that nice

beautiful elegant thematic connection that really immerses players in the game i also like the fact that the forest board is shaped like a giant lily pad as well as this big beautiful tree which i've actually purchased the wooden version of the tree because my cardboard version actually got torn after two or three plays but this tree really creates a visual sense and i'm someone who loves things that pop off the table it just really creates for that extra immersion although i do find that this tree sometimes gets in the way if you're sitting from a particular point of view and you're trying to eye out a particular card in the meadow i think one flaw for me is when it comes to building the town in everedarl the fact that you're placing these buildings just feels like you're just kind of building rows and columns whereas in wingspan as you're placing the birds into the three different habitats you feel like that habitat is growing not only mechanically in its power and its effect but also in the birds that are housed in those particular areas like for me theme really spoke to me more in wingspan well when you look at the card playing combos in a game of wingspan every single card is adaptable flexible and has multiple uses to them there is a sense of timing that is required when you're trying to vie for particular synergistic combos executing a well-planned combo feels incredibly satisfying especially as you get to re-use that same row of actions again and again throughout the game because players are laying out these birds in a particular sequence on their game board it's important to order the birds in the habitat that the sequence of bird effects resolves cascades into one another some of the brown bird

effects causes plays to look at the top of the deck and tuck cards under their existing birds some help you to lay more eggs some even have the flexibility of moving around to different habitats the pink banded cards really help place explore opportunities that are presented on their opponent's turns adding the expansion cards provides extra end of round and game end effects there are two main types of meadow cards critters and buildings green card types are all about helping players to generate resources purple cards allow players to gain points for satisfying certain conditions whilst red cards provide players with extra locations that even your opponent can use whilst the blue cards provide effects to help your engine run more efficiently and smoothly in comparing the cards from both games i found that the wingspan cards are a lot more user-friendly and a lot more approachable for players especially if they want to mould and tailor their strategy and whilst the strategy not might not be incredibly deep and complex the fact that players can use any card in their hand and even though you don't go through the entire bird deck there's enough variety there where you can use the bird cards in any sort of situation whether you might focus on tucking your cards or caching food or using it to play other cards for a cheaper price those cards seem a little bit more adaptable compared to the everdell cards i'm going to have to give it to wingspan you wouldn't have a fan of wingspan love a good expansion that provides you with more content and more bird cards introducing the brand new expansion chicken wingspan featuring cards with brand new art and special

abilities like picking order the first player now becomes last and the last play becomes first and new mechanics like the baby chick mechanic where your eggs now hatch into baby chicken tokens and for added thematic integration with the clucking the first place to emulate their favorite bird sound would be crown the bird king nesting soon in a board game store near you when it came to deciding between the two games i had to really consider the game arc the journey that you take each and every game that you played so when i was kind of looking into both games i wondered whether the narrative of both games was something that i would want to explore time and time again and would that narrative be different each and every time i play now when it comes to game arc i think it is really super important that a game really takes you on a journey think of it like a little bit of a snowball where you start off with a little small ball of snow and as it rolls and as you kind of get into the momentum of the game that snowball really grows to a big size that really has huge impact by the end of the game wingspan has to follow the same sort of sequence of steps where you've put the birds into the habitats fill up the habitats you're either going for eggs or you're drawing cards or you're getting resources and then from there you're triggering the effects from the cards it does feel a little bit more linear and it feels like by the time you finish two or three of these games you've kind of gone through similar processes of what cards you're gonna play but also how you're gonna get the resources that you need to do what you want as you get closer to the end of the game you have less and less actions but

the actions that you use in the last round become more and more powerful because as you've broadened and expanded the number of birds in your habitat every time you trigger the particular rose those effects kind of accumulate when it came to everdel i found like the at the beginning of the game the opposite to be true where you had less workers at the beginning and as you go through the seasons you kind of unlock more workers which provide you more actions more decision points and branching elements to the game which i actually found the game arc in evidel to be a little bit more interesting in fact the more you revisit evidel the more different avenues and paths to victory you kind of uncover the idea that there are no structured boundaries to the rounds in evidence means that a player who advances really quickly through the game and has all of their workers might occupy really crucial spots for a long amount of time maybe that resin that you really need from the game board might be out of service for several turns because that player has purposely put a worker there and that really shifts the tempo of the game this summer comes the long-awaited sequel to your favorite worker placement game everdell cities will be built and critters will rise in ardell including three new exclusive ways to play a solo experience that you've never seen before

hello an exclusive two-player only mode hey dude i don't think i can play everdare with you this weekend i'm a bit busy never mind i'll find someone like you and a one time exclusive rolling right module called rolling in the deep end of modern board gaming when i first acquired everdel into my collection i wasn't really sure what i was getting into in terms of what strategy i'd employ i thought you just placed a worker out and then got what you need and tried to build whatever you want but i realized very quickly that this game is all centered around adaptability being flexible and responding to how the board game state constantly changes is something that you need to do there are certain cards that you really need to get out in the early game and there are certain cards you can kind of hold on to and wait out the game to find the perfect pairing before placing it in your city early game cards like production cards are going to get you the resources that you need especially if they're taken up by other players which they're going to be i also realized that this game is about scoping out the options you've got the option of cards in your hand you've got the options of the cards in the meadow and the fact that if you're playing at a higher play cat you're churning through the meadow deck really quickly means that you're going to see a lot of cards come up and i did however discover that on my first couple of plays of this game it was really hard to find out what i needed to do to optimize my turn effectively i'd have three or four cards

that didn't really connect together and i didn't really understand like the composition of the deck so it was really hard to work out how to best optimize what i needed to do to do well in the game so the combos in this game work really well when you have the right pieces in place and they appear at the right time and you've got the right resources to connect them all together but sometimes you can find yourself putting buildings out and never really fulfilling the critters that go in them or you play for a critter and then you play for the building and then you never just can get the resource efficiency right in this game i guess ultimately on my first couple of plays the specificity of each of the cards especially the event cards in the game just made everdell feel a little bit disjointed for me and something where i kind of approached it with further trepidation on subsequent plays very good very good strategy indeed when it comes to exploring the strategy in wingspan the main thing that players are doing here is they're trying to manage the scarcity of the resources that come out of that dice tower with the certain bird card options that they have in their hand the strategy in this game is primarily revolved around getting the eggs also increasing your ability to draw more cards and more options because you really have only access to three visual bird cards out in the market area and in order to get more bird cards you do need to draw more from the actual deck itself there are all certain cards that allow

you to tuck cards under your bird cards which also then allow you to draw additional bird cards that kind of card tucking and drawing engine is going to help you to accelerate the amount of options that you have and having card advantage in wingspan is a powerful strategy for giving you more to do there are even bird cards in the game that allow you to play other bird cards for a much cheaper cost this kind of resource efficiency and card efficiency is what you really need in order to succeed in a game of wingspan and for me that satisfying feeling of putting everything into place initiating the actions with each of my action cubes as they go along the rows and creating combos in your habitat rows is what really makes the strategy in wingspan so inviting and when it came to picking my first big strategy game variability was a really important thing that i had to consider i didn't just want to get a game where every time i played it the same things would happen i mean if i wanted to play connect four i would play connect four with wingspan whilst the birds look visually different a lot of the bird cards are relatively similar with the deck of you know over 100 different bird cards there isn't really too many cards that are very unique and i think that's a part of a design aspect of that game where because there are so many different cards you want to kind of feel that every card that you do get feels like it can be

played in some way i know there's different objectives different public and private goals to go for but they're all kind of relatively similar basically collect this or get the most of this have x number of cards or whatever at the end of the game whereas in everdel i felt that the variability was a bit deeper and richer you feel like you're going down different avenues each time you play it is a little bit harder for new players to get into the game because the deck really feels like you need to know it well so you need to know how many of the buildings are in the deck what you need to match with what the game doesn't feel as smooth the first time you play but then when you get to like the third or fourth play you really start seeing things connect together when it comes to comparing the player count and what's right for you i found that wingspan plays ideally at two plays where players are kind of moving back and forth between their turns because a lot of the game involves a lot of indirect play to play interaction i find that wingspan as a couples game helps to helps the game to move a lot more briskly whereas if you play wingspan at a higher play account you tend to wait a lot longer for your turns and your turns don't really significantly impact the other players that much the kind of racing element towards the public objectives is kind of little side element that gets tacked onto the game but it doesn't really influence a lot of the big choices that you're going to make in your tableau whereas on the other side everdell

really plays well at the high play count at four plays this game truly shines at the two player count it's really hard to sift through the deck to find the cards that you need to match to build your tableau effectively whereas at the foreplay account there's a huge dose of play to play interaction as players block up spaces you know a player might need that berry resource and you'll plonk your little animaple there to block it out and just kind of snug yourself in and you know stop any other place from getting that ideal worker placement spot as a huge level of tension as well as being able to use other plays red location cards helps to promote a lot more interaction between the tableaus as well as between the plays and the later you get in the game the more impactful blocking those spaces off for the other plays really and will truly becomes so i like the high level play interaction with everdell so i'm going to have to say with that aspect evidel is my pick for that category

yep oh hey there would you like any help well yes actually i can't quite decide which of these two euro games i should add to my brand new board game collection i really like the card playing wingspan and i also like the resource gathering in everdel which of these would you recommend i'll take it wingspan and everdell have a really big place in my heart and on my board game shelf and i sometimes like to display these board games so that when people come over they're like what are these two beautiful games tell me more about them so if you're thinking about picking your first uh thematic euro to start off your board game collection then out of the two games i would definitely recommend wingspan first just because the flexibility of the cards is a lot more easy to play with the idea of engine building works a lot more smoothly in wingspan and it does have a very highly accessible theme if you're thinking about going to other deeper worker placement games however i'd probably recommend everdell instead because everdel is a great stepping stone into other crunchier worker placement games so out of the two probably say wingspan is my favorite but as you can see i gave in and bought both of them so which of these two games do you have in your collection are you thinking about you know getting one or the other or you own both please let me know your thoughts about the games and the analysis in the comment section below now thank you once again for joining me on this journey so far and if you really like my videos please consider heading over to my patreon page

and supporting me on patreon or don't forget to hit the like and subscribe button uh for more awesome board game content from the land down under this is danny sunnier i hope your next game is an amazing one goodbye

Progress saved