Fantasy Realms: Greek Legends - How Does It Stack Up to the Original?
Transcript
We are here today to do a comparison between this Fantasy Realms
and this Fantasy Realms.
This Fantasy Realms effectively, well, this copy right here is one that came out years and years ago
and has gotten so much wear and love from us.
This is probably almost 10 years old, at least eight years old. I think it was in the 2017 2018 realm. Uh if I'm wrong, I'm correcting myself below. This one here is brand new. Now, between the two, there was like an anniversary edition of this. There was also an expansion
Spider-Man and uh
yeah, the remix. Marvel remix.
Marvel remix.
Yeah, there's been a few versions, but Greek Legends, I think, is is the closest to just being a new version of Fantasy Realms. It is very much Fantasy Realms. While some of these other editions added new concepts, new decks, new ways, this doesn't do that. This is primarily if you know the rules to Fantasy Realms, you can play this game right out of the box. Now, it that's not to say it doesn't add some new stuff.
Yeah, there are some other things,
but it is all within the the the realm of what the original Fantasy Realms did, but but the first thing I want to say about this game, they have super cleaned up the graphic design. I mean, it is a huge improvement. Even going back now after playing Greek Legends a few times and going back to the basic fantasy realms, I'm like, "Oh, yeah." like the graphic design really needed this kind of love.
I will say that if you have the anniversary edition, which is a little deluxifiedish kind of the graphic design is a little cleaner in that one than it was in my original copy here. This original copy literally looks like a game from 1987ish. No offense to the game and the people behind it, but
it worked for the game.
It has an old school look to it. This one definitely looks like a game that was designed by a graphic designer from 2025. It's it's super cleaned up,
very clean. Uh a lot of uh userfriendly uh improvements here. Uh basically some quality of life in terms of iconography, making a lot of the scoring a lot more uh digestible, which is probably one of the things that tripped some people up playing the original is like playing it simple. And by the way, if you don't know Fantasy Realms, all you're doing is drawing a card from the top of the deck or from the face up display of discard cards and then you're putting that in your hand of seven cards and then you're discarding a card into that face up area. Now, this one changes that up a little bit, but the whole point of those games are you're trying to build the best hand of seven cards by the end of the game. Yeah. Now, this one shares that in common with the original Fantasy Realms. It does include a new place called the afterlife, which is sort of your own personal discard area. Some of the cards you get can be discarded into that afterlife, but all those are negative points at the end of the game.
So, you have to try to figure out how you're going to net points
to take away those negative points that you're getting.
Yeah. And that under that whole concept of the underworld kind of fits more into the the theme of this new one, the Greek legends theme. Obviously, if you couldn't tell by the name, it's heavily influenced by Greek mythology. I'll say for me that actually that gives this game points because when you're playing Fantasy Realms, there's a lot of a lot of combos in there, but it there was no theme to Fantasy Realms. It was just all this generic fantasy stuff like
generic theme.
Okay, you'd start to learn how things work together. What's cool about this being Greek mythology bases, if you're at all familiar with Greek mythology, you're reading some of these cards and you're like, "Oh, Hercules fights monsters. Okay, that makes sense. Hermes has the the nimble icon. He's the shoes. He's fast." like that makes sense. Uh, Hades wants cards to be in your underworld. Like some of these things just make like intuitive sense to you because you're already kind of built into that theme.
Yeah, having a theme having anything. Honestly, I never played the Marvel one, but I assume that incorporated some of that
Star Trek 2,
but it does make a big difference here. Even if you have the slightest of familiarity with Greek legend, you're going to see a lot of connections that make a lot of sense with the way the mechanics work on a lot of the cards. Um, and that afterlife, as we mentioned earlier, kind of plays with that as well, because you're going to get monsters in your hand and some of the monsters, if they're in your hand at the end of the game, they're going to send all of your heroes to the afterlife, which is generally not a good thing.
Sure. But it could be good. It could be good.
Combos that want it to be good, which that's another thing, too. Like, this game still does have all of those different combos, so many different paths to scoring. I mean, the whole tension of looking your hand and seeing a card that comes out that really works well, but then having to decide what to get rid of to kind of try to build a new direction. All of that still here. I will say that it does almost feel simplified. And I don't want to say that
streamlined, right?
Streamlined. Sure. But but even like the the points are lower like the the points on the cards are are smaller. You had cards in the base game that were like 45 points for a single card. The base scoring for these I think that there's like 25 points is the highest we saw.
But then there's uh the ways that these cards score they and I don't want this to sound negative. That's why I'm struggling. Let's say flexible. Some of them are a little bit more flexible. Whereas in the base Fantasy Realms, there was a lot of stuff that was like, "This card's useless unless you have this one other specific card, and if you don't draw that other specific card, then you might as well not even have the first one." There's less of that. I think in this game,
the way I would put that is I think in the original there's more highs and lows, and in this one, they kind of pulled those highs and lows together, so you're going to have a little bit more of an e even keled experience. Good way to say it. that's going to benefit you from the standpoint if you ever played Fantasy Realms and you're like, "Well, I was sitting on the shield of KE this whole time and I never got the Sword of K." If you've played Fantasy Realms, you know, uh, and that is fun when you're chasing those things, but in a big deck of cards, that sword of K might be at the bottom. You might
bigger cards deck.
Yeah. Yeah. This is a bigger deck of cards, too. But like Ryan was saying, there's a lot more routes to like mechanically getting your points. the original game, like you said, there there's a lot of highv value cards. You keep that card for its value, and then generally speaking, those cards had something on them that then made you go, "Oh,
yeah. Now, now I've got to do all of this to make sure that this card still scores. I can't have this. I can't have this. And I have to have one of these then." And that's brings me to another thing I want to point out. Some of these cards, now we've had this deck for a while. This is the base game, and it does have some uh the expansion cards in it. Some of these cards are a little obtuse in terms of like you read it and you're like, "Wait a minute. You read this and tell me what you think I get here."
This uh game eradicates most of that. There are some pretty robust cards with some text, but all of the cards in here also have a line of iconography that represents the text,
like a formula. It's like a formula for scoring.
And once you understand that, it just makes it much easier to understand the scoring. And I do remember, it's been a while since I played Original Fantasy Realms, but scoring that game was complicated because you might you score one card at a time and if you put a card out, put a card out, put a card out, and then you get to your fifth card and you're like, oh, wait a minute, this one shouldn't have scored this because this card affects that one negatively.
You you remember, oh shoot, this thing had a penalty. It blinked this other card, but I had had a hand in my card in my hand that I forgot that cancels the blanking. And then this one cancels all of these cards unless you have this one or this one is actually a copy of this one which means it shouldn't have been blanked. Like there was a lot of that in fantasy realms. Less of that in in Greek legends.
There is less of it. I think it's partly probably due to our familiarity with the concept of the game. It makes it a little easier. But I do think they streamlined a lot of those things. And like I said earlier, I think those icons really help the tags what I mean in the side of the card as opposed to like just looking at the color of the card. As silly as that sounds, it makes a big difference because when you see the equation that uses the icons and then you can just scan your cards and go, well, there's oneup there and you can figure all that out. And the blanking that goes on in here, there's definitely not as prevalent in this game as ours in the other game. There are some,
but most of the ones that we've seen are very specific to it blanks that card. Yeah. Or it blanks one card. Not like it blanks all the cards unless you have this card and if it's Tuesday like it some of the cards in the original game, my point is get a little crazy.
Yeah, which was part of the fun of the game. But yeah,
this one does. It also introduces what I think is pretty cool. Uh I don't even want to call this a mechanic. It's just a new card type. I like this idea that there are monsters now in this deck. Monsters being a a huge part of Greek mythology. And every monster is kind of like a little puzzle to solve because if you don't have the specific right type of hero in your hand, it kills all the heroes in your hand. And that's something you have to balance. And they have these quests which every quest that you go on, quests give you zero points,
but they want you to have like basically a set collection. Every quest wants you to have specific other types of cards. And I like that because you can look at a quest right away and say, "Okay, this is zero points unless I do this thing." And while that's kind of the same as what Basic Fantasy Realms does, I think the way that they packaged it in this idea like you're going on a quest, you know, right off the bat if you don't complete the text, you're getting zero points. Whereas sometimes in Basic Fantasy Realms, you get to the end and go, "Oh, wait a minute. This card was zero. Oops." Like,
yeah,
that doesn't happen as much. In fact, in I've played many games of many many games of this with different player counts now. I've yet to see anyone have a zero point card.
Yeah. Like I said, you're not going to get the highs, you're not going to get the lows. Now, we have experienced a couple highs in our game here. I had one card. I couldn't find it just now. I had it right from the get. So, it was in my hand and like I typically do, I looked at that and went, "That's what I'm going to go after." So, I basically built my whole game around that card and it served me well because while I got pretty modest points on a lot of the cards, that point I scored 60
60 points for that same 60 points card we've seen yet. It was three different things, like three different tags effectively multiplied by each other. This times this times this, which can get pretty big. Good for you.
As long as you have a couple of each of those things. Um, but it was really fun because instead of scoring a lot of points on one card because it just says 45 points.
Mhm.
That was a lot of points and I felt like I built it, right? Even though I lucked, you know, there's some luck in this game obviously, but it made the I think it's going to make players feel like they worked towards their points a little bit more than the original game where you do have to do some work in the original game, but it's usually kind of like crazy work where you're like, "Come on, Shield of Cath, Shield of Cath, Shield of Cath."
Yeah, I I think that these games are going to there will always be an audience for that basic fantasy roles because of that because it's a much smaller deck. you have a level of like predictability of probability where you say what are the chance if I have the one card the candle what is the chance I'm going to hit the bell or whatever there were these ones that you know you wanted very specific cards I think that purists might struggle with just the fact that everyone's scoring points willy-nilly in this one like you're just get but then there's I think a wider audience myself included is going to really enjoy this because you're doing the fun part more often which to me is looking at a card and going oh I get five for this five for this five for this boom boom boom and you you can like hear the points racking up in the back of your mind. That is more satisfying to me than spending, you know, the entire game, all seven cards building up. Yeah, this combo scored me 150 points. And that, you know, I don't I like the little getting points for almost everything you're doing kind of idea.
I think that makes it more accessible. And like we said earlier, I think the theme not only makes it more accessible because it's something people can uh understand, but as it relates to the mechanics of the game,
I can't tell you the number of times I taught Fantasy Realms to people and they're looking at a card and they're like, "What is the shield of care?" Like, I don't know what these I'm not I have no familiarity with what this card is asking for.
This one it just the theme helps, right? Like when when when you have Medusa and it talks about uh
Perseus
Perseus. Now you may not know if you're not familiar with Greek mythology, but some most people or a lot of people are going to go, "Oh, okay. I get
it. It makes sense that Perseus will be able to defeat Medusa." And we we looked through I think there's only two cards that directly reference wanting a specific
other card
other card
instead of a icon
instead of like scoring icons or types or suits or whatever. So that's much less. I mean, I I don't have an exact count for the base game, but there were a lot of cards that really wanted you to specifically have
Oh, yeah.
another very specific card, [clears throat] right? Exactly.
And there was always, like you said, that was fun, but it was always just when you played the game and you were looking for that one card,
you were really just that's what you were doing in the game. You were like banking on that and if it happened, it happened. If it didn't, it didn't. This one I think is gonna allow more players to just kind of pivot towards a more average amount of points.
Yeah. And you know, we didn't talk about the fact that this feels still like the base game. I mean, it's still a quick play. It's still like 20 minutes. The game's not any longer.
Yeah. Two players. It's even quicker than that.
Ridiculously fast.
Uh it still has that the fun comboing of building your hand. Like it does everything that the original Fantasy Realms did. Uh for me, I think this is my going to be my go-to. I like the art better. I like the theme better and I do like the almost more of a point salad feel that this one has.
Yeah, and I I agree completely. I would say what I said then, I'll say it again now.
This is a game that deserves to be reskinned in so many different ways. Absolutely.
And they did ultimately do that with you said Star Trek and Marvel.
There might have been another one, but those are the two I
It took them years to do that though, by the way, with this new addition. Hopefully this, you know, if if Fantasy Realms hasn't been on your table in your collection, hopefully this version will be and it will uh get some traction enough for them to do other editions or maybe even an expansion to this cuz as much as this did and I think where where it is feels pretty good cuz it's 79 cards versus like 50 something in the original game.
Uh there is room room for a little bit more a little bit more. But that is Fantasy Realms Greek Legends. If you have any questions at all, please make them in the comments below. We'll get down there and answer whatever we can. Until next time, make sure everyone has fun at the table and we'll see you then.