Are These Board Games Still FANTASTIC After 4 Years?
Transcript
We've been doing this for four years, ranking and reviewing games. Some of those have been really fantastic. Right. Exactly. So, let's take a look at them if they are still fantastic. So, we're going to present a game that we at least one of us has rated as fantastic. And we're going to take a look at those games and see if that's still the case. Here's the whole rating starting from hangover way over there and fantastic here. Almost the best you can get, right? So, one of the best you can get, at least in our opinion, has been The Crew. I rated it as fantastic and you rated as fantastic with apistro. So, that was my thing. And if you don't know, The Crew is a trick- taking game. Cooperative at that one, where you as a team will have cards and tasks. I have to take a trick that includes green nine. Here's a simulation of an actual gameplay. It's my turn. I have to play a card. I will play a green six, which means you have to play a green card. I do have a green card and it's a green nine and my task was to get a trick which this is with a green nine which I do because you played the highest number in that color. Easy peasy. I think we're misrepresenting how complex this game can get. And you have this book which contains bajillion well it's 50 different missions with different rules. Four years ago we rated this as fantastic. Is it still? Let's see. 3 2 1 It's up. It's must play. It's just must play. What? What's so funny?
I'm so excited to write it. It's for a tea. I rate it as a fantastic and I'm saying it's a must have. It's a masterpiece of a game and now others are copying the same concepts and adding themes on top of it. The crew still holds up. Still a great game. We knew what we were talking about way back when. Hopefully this continues. The next game we reviewed as fantastic was Project Elra. Project Elite is about controlling a space marine, a guy who's going in to complete a mission. There's a tons of monsters coming at you. You're shooting them, trying to get in, get out alive. And all of this happens in real time. And again, it's a cooperative one. All are stressfully rolling bunch of dice, doing all the actions that the dice let you do, and then rolling them again. And it never stops for 2 minutes straight. You just roll actions, roll actions, and you will get really sweaty.
I rolled some dice. ah move then monster move then I roll some dice try to shoot that monster boom then I roll some more dice until I get here or die and everyone's doing that at the same time the game is divided into rounds and each round is 2 minutes then some things happen some events and things like that but then you continue hectic fun there's no time to be bored in this game so the question is now is it still fantastic you rated it as fantastic I did I rated it as really good three yeah two one it stays is really good for me. Oh no, it's up for me. It's a mustave. It's uh you just pitching it to me like I got to play this. This is like a video game in a board game format. The next game we rated as fantastic. Scythe. I didn't rate it. I rated it as fantastic and you rated as okay. So in this game, you play different factions uh trying to generate resources and control more territories because then you can generate more resources. And uh it's really a Euro game. It is a euro as euro gets with some uh yeah area control. The really cool part the mechs that you get and these basically are public transportation devices which means that you will have some troops and if you want them to move then uh you move them with the mechs. It's a really really solid game. Really fun game. Beautiful looking game. It looks gorgeous. I think it's one of the best productions out there. Let's find out if it's still fantastic or just okay. I wouldn't hold your breath. Maybe not okay anymore.
Three, two, one. It says the same. It's fantastic for me. Actually, has gone up a little bit for me. It's not okay anymore. It's just not okay. It's good now. For me, it's still fantastic. It It does really great things. Next game that we rated as fantastic is Spirit Island. I rated it as a must-have. All right. And someone here rated this as a fantastic plus. Fantastic plus. Yeah. What's the plus for Spirit Island is a cooperative game that at this point everybody who's into the hobby. If not played then knows already. But it's a heavy cooperative game with a lot of calculations and planning and playing out cards where you are spirits trying to protect an island and it's a highly rated solo game. Actually, a ton of folks enjoy playing this solo. You all will control island and invaders will come in and you by playing cards will try to defend and uh scare away those invaders. Yeah. And uh since each of you are playing a unique god, you have very asymmetric decks and powers. It's actually a quite the heavy game. Yeah.
Three, two, one. It's up for me. It cannot go up. It's already a must. These are our videos. We do what we want. It's already a must have, but it's actually in my top 10 of all time. I think that's the biggest of this channel. So, it can go up. I agree. But for the sake of equilibrium universe, you have it the wrong way. It's down for me. It's a very good game. I don't think it's fantastic. And what's with the plus for me? I don't remember even what was that. One game that we don't have here, but we rated it fantastic is Destiny. Destiny is a story game or there will be a set ending, but each of us wants that ending to be a different one cuz we all have our secret destiny that we're trying to fulfill and depending on who of us will fulfill his destiny, the ending might be different.
What you do on your turn is you move around the board and then you talk to NPCs or interact with things on the board and the board will reveal itself as well and it's all app assisted. You rated it as a really good game. I rated it as fantastic. So let's see 3 2 1. For me it's gone down a bit really good because equalizing the universe. You don't feel fantastic about this game. I feel really good about it. We switch around. I played it. I really enjoyed it back then and then that's it. Why it is for me here is that my daughter keeps referencing one of those games has become so memorable because of one plot twist there and she keeps referencing it all the time. Well, if a game stays with someone in your family for so long must be a fantastic experience. The next game that we ranked as fantastic is Seven Wonders Architects. You actually rated this as must have. I said it's fantastic. The seven wonders architect is a filler game where all of us will try to build a wonder and we build that by drafting cards. The game ends once somebody builds the wonder and then you just add up points. Who has the most wins. There are two ways you can support us. One way is just donating any amount you can through that PayPal link down below in description or you can buy our merch. And the game goes like this. It's my turn and I have to either pick the card in the middle or one of the piles in between us right here. And I just take that card and whatever is written on it I get. Yeah. And sometimes it will help us help me build my wonder which
gives me victory three points. Super simple, super easy. Plays two to seven players. Takes 20 minutes to play. Maybe 30. Uh let's see what we think after all this time. 3 2 1. Well, he said if it's red, what why is it so tiny? Cuz uh I think it's fantastic game. It's easy to get to the table, but there's so many alternatives that if you can get to the table even quicker and plays just as fun. Fantastic for me, coincidentally as well. I still like it. I will always play it if someone suggest. I just don't feel the draw to suggest it anymore. Next one we don't have with us, but it's called Parks. And you rated Parks as a really good plus. What's it plus? I don't know. You said plus phase, I guess. And I said it's fantastic. Parks uh is a game where you take a walk in a park. You you will have a track which will you move forward and on the spot you stop you will do an action. Tricky part is you can never go back. So you have to figure out in which spot you want to go and you will make sure no other players can go there and you collect resources which you spend to play cards like the park you visited.
Simple. It's a good-looking game. Really nice, easy to play. But do we still want to play it is the question. I said really good. Huh? Three, two, one. I have two arrows down. Wa, you hated it now. No, it's okay now. Okay, it's pretty much okay. I don't remember it to be honest. And if you would ask me to play it, I'm like I think we can play something else. I still think it's very good without the plus, whatever that meant. And uh I would play it. I don't own it anymore. I will not own it anymore. But if you want to play, I'll play parks. Moving on to the next game, which is of Cats. Or if you say it really fast, it sounds like Isle of Cats. So I said it's really good and you said it's fantastic. Isle of Cats is a tie laying game where you will uh get different Tetris pieces. Yeah. And then you can fill out your ship. The more you fill out your ship, the better. Yeah. You're saving those cats from the island cuz they're in danger. Some bad guy found out that there are cats and he doesn't like cats. That's basically the idea.
There's some card play, drafting, and other things there, but that's generally the game. Is it still fantastic? Let's find out. Three, two, one. Again with a smaller room. Oh, as well. I said really good. No, it's good. It's just good. Yeah, it's a really neat little game. Uh, I think it's a little bit over complicated for what it is. It's a family cut game and then you have card drafting and cages and stuff. So, it's down for me. Not fantastic anymore. But what do you think this means? Saturn. What is a Saturn planet? That is correct. So, this game has been replaced by Planet Unknown. I feel it does exact same thing placing polyominos on planets but it's just simpler easier to set up easier to get into. You can play it easily with non-gamers. You can play this as well but it just feels too much at first. Second to last game this war mine. Oh, this game is about Civil War.
It's based actually on a video game with the same title and basically the same gameplay and then they took it and created a board game out of it. You're playing a group of survivors stuck in the city that's been like uh surrounded by military forces. You can't get out. So, you're trying to survive. You're crafting. You're gathering food. You're going on scavenging runs. You're meeting people. Tons of tons of things happening and some difficult choices to make along the way as well. The best part about this uh game is how it makes you feel. Definitely, it won't you won't stay like neutral about it. You said it's fantastic. I said it is fantastic. Plus 3 2 1 It's up. It's up to must have. Well, I got news for you. There's a second edition coming out. Exactly. My I feel like this game tells a story that's really, really important about the people in war, not the civilians that just gets your emotions rolling. I love scavenging systems. I think this one has one of the best ones. And yes, as you mentioned, there is going to be a second edition that I think will streamline some things and make it hopefully even better. And I really want to buy that one. It's It's definitely an experience.
It might go up for me. We'll see the second edition because I wrote like and I'm like, "Oh, yeah, that part was great, but then the setup was tedious. Oh, and then that was great, but then I have to put it all back." And so it adds some issues, which might be fixed to the second edition. Hopefully, it's definitely going to look much better. But it's definitely an experience and a very serious theme, and I enjoyed that. All right, so last one. Unfathomable. It's a hit and roll game where which is in the Cthulhu universe where you are passengers on a ship and the ship's trying to get to Boston. One of you is the secret cultist that is trying to mess up your plans and then there are monsters attacking the ship and suddenly everything's going wrong and will you survive? Will you get to the end? Probably not. You ranked it as a fantastic game. That's why we're making this video. Well, I thought you made it a fantastic game. Please. I wrote down okay 3 2 1 it's okay I'll call your two arrows and raise one I guess it's okay but I could go down to can't recommend even and the biggest flaw with that game is what I understood is if you're playing the bad guy you don't have to play the bad guy you all you have to do is just watch everything go crashing and then do one action it's like well I'll go pull this lever and then you all die and I win and since then I've played feed the kraken that doesn't let you do that you still have to work around you and I don't know it's just this one thing makes it just okay for me. So, it's the biggest drop in the history of where are they now series. Thank you for watching. Let us
know if you enjoyed these series and what games have you changed your mind on. And remember to support the channel by checking out our merch or the PayPal account. It would really help us. Just $1 a month, that would be awesome. Thank you. Please.