Food Chain Magnate V.S Magnate the First City
Transcript
Hello my friends. It's the Game Boy Geek here. Today I'm joined again by my friend
Greg Dixon.
And recently we kind of played a bunch of our favorite economic games or one of our favorite economic games. Uh which was Magnate the First City.
Yeah.
Uh and then recently we got the new version of Food Chain Magnet and and I had never played it until this new version came out from Lucky Doug Games
and I hadn't played it in a long time.
Yeah. So, we kind of played it and we thought it'd be kind of fun to kind of compare and contrast because they're both have the name Magnate in it, which is like the leader of the industry.
Uh, and they're both
pretty heavier economic games. One of them is
regarded very highly at Board Game Geek. One of them is not just because it didn't have as wide a distribution and big enough following. So, we thought it'd be kind of fun to be like, hey, which one is the real magnet? Which magnate versus Magnate? So, we're just going to kind of compare and contrast a little bit, just talk about our thoughts about like which one do we like better and why. Uh, but before we get there, uh, I'm just going to give you a quick overview of both of these games in case you don't know what either of these are. So, here we go.
Before I get to the moment you've been waiting for, I wanted to tell you about the sell trade program at Noble Knight Games. Now, as gamers, we all have games that are cluttering our shelves that we either don't have the right group for or might even not like it. Well, now you can turn those unappreciated games into cash or store credit. Noble Knight Games buys thousands of games and gaming products. It's easy to send them a list of the games that you'd like to sell or trade. Now, they'll send you a quote and even pay for the shipping of the games. Get treated and paid like royalty while you sit back and collect cash or store credit. To get started, click the link in the description of this video or in that upper right corner there and then click the sell trade button. In Food Chain Magnate, each player is going to have a CEO, which is going to allow them to hire employees each round, but they're also going to have a restaurant, which gets strategically placed at the beginning of the game. The map is randomly created each game with different map tiles, and the size of it will depend on the amount of players, but you have restaurants, and you're trying to get people that are in houses to come out and eat from your restaurant. So, you'll be hiring all different types of employees, like a kitchen trainee that can cook you a burger or pizza, or some specialized cooks that can do either of those two, but do it better. Or maybe you're sending some people off to go get drinks and drive away from your restaurant to go pick those up, like the errand boy or the cart operator or the truck driver.
Now, in order to sell these foods and drinks, you're going to need to market it. So, there's different marketing that you can have, different types of trainees, different types of managers, and they're going to be able to give different types of marketing out onto the board, like a billboard marketing lemonade to this house that's right close to me. And you might be adding houses with gardens that will pay twice the regular price. And you might be marketing with mailboxes and essentially marketing pizza to every house that can touch that mailbox. Or maybe you'll fly airplanes over different neighborhoods, marketing certain things on all the houses it flies over. But you got to be careful because if you can't deliver everything the house wants, you don't deliver anything to it. So someone might spam your marketing with something else knowing that you can't deliver it. And each round it's dinner time where all the houses will go out in order of number to the restaurants that will be able to give them what they want. Like if I have lemonade and I'm here, I am a lot closer than this one. So even if this one has lemonade, I'll be able to deliver it and get the sale instead of them making money, which is the name of the game because whoever has the most money at the end is the winner. But there's different tricks you can play like discounting your different items to get there cheaper. So maybe they're willing to go a little bit further and buy it from you anyway. Or maybe if you have a monopoly in a corner of the neighborhood, you can actually raise the price with luxury managers knowing no one else can deliver it, making tons of money. So over the course of the game, the map's changing with players adding restaurants, adding houses, and it's a dynamic game. Now, there are a ton of different people that you can hire. Some at management levels, some that help you recruit, some that help you train, some that help you place new restaurants and new houses and all sorts of different things. There's tons of strategies based upon all these different types of employees. But how you get the most money is by focusing on these milestones
which are essentially goals that you need to race to because the first one there is the only one that gets it. Like if you're the first to throw away food, you can actually store up to 10 food and drink where nobody else will be able to do that. If you're the first to get $100, you are become a CFO and get 50% more cash each round. So there's all different ways and strategies to do it. $5 for first for every pizza sold if you're the first one that marketed pizza. Uh plus one range to go get drinks if you're the first one to play this. So you have all different strategies pouring in to comboing together strategies and that's the main way that you're going to win this game. Magnate the First City is an economic cityb building game where you're trying to have the most money in the win. You keep it hidden in the envelope here and has a really cool first player marker that truck. So in this game you're going to be buying land, buying buildings, attracting tenants, making money, selling buildings, and doing it over again and trying to time the market right. And there's all sorts of different tenants to attract in different segments like commercial for law firms and call centers or residential, retail or industry. And they give you different amount of money for rent. But they also help influence other types of buildings that are close to it and it's all very thematic. But then building a big apartment building attracts some professional couple which actually will help out retail because they want to shop close by. Everything is interconnected. But each round depending on what's been happening in the economy, you might be moving the crash track down. And if this ever gets to zero, well, the game will end and there's a big crash. Are you trying to find the right time to sell things before the crash ends? Before I get to the moment you've been waiting for, I wanted to let you know that Game Toppers is giving 15% off premium game mats and
accessories, specifically to my US and Canada audience using code game boygeeek 15 off for a limited time only. Hear more about this at the end of my final thoughts. All right, before we get started, I'm a stats nerd. I'm an engineer, so I just kind of run down a few stats on these games.
Okay. Um, and I also want to preface this by saying, uh, First City, Magnate First City was my game of the year when it came out in 2021, and it's been one of my favorite games of all time since then. In fact, we just did our top 100 recently.
And, uh, if you missed any of those, you can go back and and and watch any of those. But both of these were actually on my top 100. They were both actually right next to each other because I just love them.
Yeah.
Um, and Magn City was on his list. Was on my list. So, we we both love Magn City. And then we'll talk about
it's because we love economic games.
That's right. That's right.
So, just quick on the stats. Food and Chain Magnet came out in 2015. And then this past year at the end of 2025, they delivered the huge special edition and/or deluxe version from Lucky Duck Games, which was the first edition I had ever played. Um, and so it's ranked number 49 on Board Game Geek with an average rating of 8.0 with 22,98 ratings.
That's a lot of ratings.
A lot of ratings. It's got a weight of 4.19, which we talked about in another video that like I don't really think it should be that heavy because it's like sure the mechanisms aren't that that bad. Like I feel like it should be like more in the 3.75 range.
I think it's appropriate.
You do?
Yeah,
because Magnet the First City is ranked 3,594. Not even close. A weight of 3.14, which feels about right. With an average rating of 7.5, but only 719 ratings because it didn't have as big a release. It was a Kickstarter. Yeah,
that came out and they did. It's actually for sale in stores still too actually. Like you my our local store has it here. But like 8.0 to 7.5. Some people would be like well that's kind of split hairs. You're five away, right? But it's the amount of ratings. Yeah.
Is that that that really
Well, magnet's been around longer, too. Yeah.
And it was like you said, it's been it's been published by fairly large publishers, different publishers multiple times.
Yeah.
Whereas this was a magnet per city was a very small publisher. Very small.
Yeah. I was kind of like the flag bearer of Magnet first when it first came out cuz I think I was one of the first people to review it if not the first person and I just fell in love with it and I was trying to play it and show it with everybody.
U and again I got it got game of the year for me and and I have loved this game for for a long time. You and I played it when it first came out. We even played a two-player back then. We're like wow this is awesome. Not a lot economic games work with two.
So recently when we started playing food chain magnet I became absolutely obsessed with this game. Like I just like fell in love with this game.
I didn't play anything else for like a week or two. I was like, "Let's play magnet food chain and magnet again. Let's play it again. Let's play it again."
Yeah. And so I was telling him how much I I loved food chain magnet. And I was like, "Well, let's let's also play both of these backtoback two-player just to see how do they because it had been a couple years since we had played a two-player, the Magnet for a City."
And I was curious if Fujain Magnet would even really work at two players.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Uh and so from that, like at least it solidified in my mind that Ma uh Food Chain Magnate does play very well with two players. It's very even maybe even more cutthroat because it's you against them. But it's also fast. Like 75 minutes and you're done.
Yeah.
And you got a lot done. And then
as long as both players have played before, of course.
Yeah. But same for for Magnet First City. It was about 75 minutes as well for two players.
Yeah.
Um but here's the interesting thing is like one of the big wraps and the the big uh things that people don't like about Fujain Magnate is how unforgiving the game is.
Yeah. It's punishing. I think that's part of why the weight's as high as it is, too, because it's not just that it's there's a lot of rules to figure out, but it's like if you make a misstep, you get hit hard. And I wonder if that's part of why people rate the weight so high.
Yeah, it it is very very unforgiving. If you haven't played it before, you really have to play it with a teacher and a group of people that if they're experienced,
they are willing to not to not stop teaching when the game starts, but to give you advice
early and often and give you choices and tell you like, hey, if you do this, you're going to get you're going to be out of the game. Like,
you need to research it ahead of time almost, too. Whereas, I think with Magnate, the first city, people can just show up to game night and you be like, here's how it works. And they can be off and running,
right?
I don't think you can do that with food chain magnate.
No, definitely not. However, the odd thing was in our backto-back two-player games.
Yeah.
Uh that was the first time you you ever won Fuche Magnate and you destroyed me.
Yeah. Yeah.
Right. But but oddly enough, we played Manny at the First City and you destroyed me in that too, which we hadn't seen before. Like I made Granted, I made the I hadn't played it in so long that I had made a very big mistake for sure in the first round and I could never catch up because I got no income in the first round. you did and I could never catch up.
And it was interesting cuz they're like, "Huh, I don't usually see this game as being
unforgiving, but if you make a mistake similar to what you did in Fuan Magnet, we just found out it can be unforgiving."
I think the difference though is that, and this is why, you know, between the two of them, I prefer magnate the first city is there's this at the end you have to basically liquid, you have to predict the ending and liquidate all your assets. And if you are kind of struggling throughout, that's your chance to sort of catch up again. And I feel like it's built into every single play of Magnate the First City. Whereas Food Chain Magnate doesn't have anything like that.
Once you're behind, you're behind. And and there's really there's kind of no catching up
unless you're in last and you're not too far behind that the second and third players try to beat up on the first player and mess with this marketing. They don't worry about you.
You're consuming a four player game.
Yes. and you can do your own thing in the corner and catch up. It can happen
if we're talking about two-player games though.
No, no, definitely not.
Yeah. And as Yeah. Yeah. I I just think food chain magnet and it's why I don't enjoy it as much. Although I can see the appeal of it because it's very sandboxy and there's so many ways to kind of mix and match the expansions and modules and stuff to have very different experiences each time. Uh, plus the map's different every time. I get the appeal of it, but it's just it's even after multiple plays, I still don't feel like I have a great handle on it. And I just don't I mean it simulates the theme well of like how hard it is to start a restaurant,
but I don't know if that's what I want. I think I want the whatever they're whatever is being simulated to be gamified enough that there's still sort of a sh shot shot to feel like you're in it.
Yeah.
And then you have a shot at winning, too.
So, another big knock on Food Chain Magnet is that the base game, not only is it extra even more forgiving than than with the expansion, but it's a little more telegraphical. It's a little more formulaic. It's a little more a little less variable.
Yeah.
Where like there's like there's like six main strategies. Then you kind of like dovetail off to some little
he's like studied this.
If if you don't take one of the one of two cards. If you don't take the recruiter girl or the trainer on your first turn, you've lost the game.
Yeah.
The big thing with food chain man, the reason why it's so high is because I'm including the expansion with it. The expansion module not only changes all of like the goals that you like combo together, but there's also like 18 or so total modules that you can mix in and out. different food, different this, different ways to do this. And like it just adds so much to the game that you could play it for a lifetime and you'll always have a different experience.
Yeah.
Now, when I compare that to Magnet the First City, if I were just comparing base game to base game, I feel like, and again, these two were right next to each other in my top 100. So, I love them both. It's like we're splitting hairs here, but Night at the First Cities base game I feel like is a more like it's it's a more replayable experience because of the the things I just said, right? But when you add expansions to both of them, Magnet the First City has an expansion, you get apartment buildings and some event some like special ability cards that I don't use, but like and then the Mag Fuji Magnet, the expansion takes that game from like an eight for me to a 10 cuz it's just every game brings new problems and new solutions to those problems. And you're always trying to figure it out. It's it's very nonlinear where you see an opportunity that no one else can see and you figured out a way to exploit that opportunity. We're like, magnate the first city. It's very linear.
I'm going to buy land. I'm going to build a certain type of of building, industrial, commercial, to get good tenants to get income. I need to find the right time to sell to get a bigger building.
Yeah.
And I need to try to sell at the right time before the game ends. It's very linear. Like the experience is
you're going to have roughly the same kind of experience each time.
Each time, but every game will still feel different. There's different map tiles there. What everything somebody else does affect Yeah. Yeah. So like I feel like if you're looking for a more like controlled experience that will be closer if you have been like my best experience of this game my worst experience of this game like magnet the first city has a tighter standard deviation where like food chain magnet it's like this right
yeah you could have a game where you're like this is so punishing so frustrating so excruciating so long that I never want to play this again
right if you play the wrong group for sure
yeah uh yeah yeah I think one of the things that you cons that people consider consider a um an aspect of a modern game is that feeling of a catch-up mechanic. That feeling that you're always in it. That feeling that like, oh, maybe I I misstepped a little bit, but I I can still kind of regain my stride and have a shot at it. And I think with food chain magnet, even though it's it's from 2015, it feels dated because of that. And I think a lot of people are going to kind of hit a wall when they try to try to access it and try to play it because of that alone. Um, and it's one of these games where it sort of assumes you're going to play it multiple times um, before it really fully reveals itself. And I think the expectation with most modern games and most modern gamers is that you can enjoy a game kind of the first time you play it. Yes, you'll enjoy it more in future plays and it'll reveal itself more, but sort of that emergent feeling of like, oh, I get it now can happen even in a complex game in sort of that first play. And I don't think that's the case with food chain magnet. I think you have to kind of experiment with it or research it a bunch ahead of time uh in order to kind of have that positive experience, you know.
Yeah. You either need to be coached during the game
or if there are
or combination of all those things.
If there are exper if all the players are experienced, you get really good at spotting the opportunities.
Yeah.
And you also get you also get good even though you don't see them all, other people will still see opportunities that you haven't seen. And they as soon as they start to do something Yeah. you can look at it and go, uhoh, if if we don't do something about it this turn, we're all going to be dead. So, there is some table talk of being like, hey, why don't you put instead of putting that there, why don't you put that there? That'll then they'll stuff them here. I'll do this over here. Like, there is that. If you have that, there will be less of a runaway leader in that game. But everybody has to be experienced and know the different little like nuances which are almost unlimited that game, the different opportunities. I think you and I like economic games so much that there's just a lot of other ones I can think of that um are just fun right off the bat. They don't have as much. They're not sandboxy. They don't have the variety of problems that you need to solve like you said. Um but I think they to me all like the ones I think of like Smartphone Inc. and Power Grid and and Magnate the Fair City and um um a lot of them I think are are more elegant and I just I will sacrifice a little bit of weight and variety for an experience that's more elegant.
Yeah, that's
that's kind of where the trade-off is.
Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Versity is definitely more elegant for sure.
So, yeah, container. I mean, there's a bunch of them I can think of where it's just like it just doesn't hold a candle to those, but I think it depends on what you what your priorities are and what you value. And I I definitely value sort of an elegant system uh that gives everyone a shot and sort of keeps you in the running even if like you stumble a little bit here or there.
And it's not that magnet first city is super easy to teach. There's a couple of clunky things with the dice rolling and hey, where do you get the tenants from? It's the neighborhood but not your tile, but then when you do the bonuses, it has to be your tile. Like there's some
there's some inelegant things. Yeah. But
and that's why I think there's other economic games I like better than it as well.
Yeah. But it is it's one of your top economic games for sure. We did that top 100 list and it did land in there but but higher on the list closer to 100. Um I do also love the variety of player count with with Magnate and that it's so fast at two and so but but it's great at all player counts.
I think it plays up to five. It is longer with five though.
It's long with five of course but but it works and it's nice to have a game that works at that that higher player count.
First City
it's still a lot shorter than food chain magnate though especially the higher player counts. Yeah, probably.
Food chain magnet with five players is like, "Okay, hope you have a whole day."
Uh, so first First City is a game that you and I would almost always be like, "Hey, let's play it." Oh, yeah. Right.
Fuj Magnet. I feel the same way, but it I would probably have to talk you into it.
Yeah. I mean, it's something where we've talked often about how there's games that you'll play if people want to play them, and then there's games you kind of like crave that you're like, "Oh, I want to get back to that when I try that again." Food Chain Magnet, especially after the last few weeks and how many times we've played it, I'm good for a while. Now, that said, if everyone's playing it, I'll be a sport and I'll jump in and play it. But the First City is one that I'll be, especially if a little bit of time's gone by, I'm like, I got to get back to that one. That one's so interesting. I want to get that back in my head. I really like that, you know? Uh, it's something that I'll crave in comparison, I think.
So, Magnate versus Magnate, First City wins for you.
Oh, definitely. By a lot.
And for me, it's it's it's basically a tie. Like I know that's horrible to say, but but I did.
Which one did you require?
Food chain magnet was one space higher.
Space higher
with the expansion with the new version cuz I won't even play the version that looks like a prototype, which is the original one. So I'm saying the early version was kind of the new version with the expansion. I put a hair higher just because of the variability and and and just how amazing it is.
A hair higher, but it costs three times as much.
It does. Oh, by the way, they only did one printing of that. It was a big uh crowdfunding campaign. Lucky Duck Games does have a very limited amount of these for sale and they're never printing it again.
Assuming you're watching this soon after release, they could disapp.
Oh, it might be 80 something. Yeah.
For the base game.
Yeah.
So me it's like it's basically a tie.
Okay. Food chain magnet's only a hair better, but but it's two or three times as much than Banging the first city is the better bang for your buck, right?
I I guess
I wonder if you were to do your top 100 again in five years if that that chasm between the two would grow and you would just like food chain magnet more and more.
I think it will.
Yeah.
Just because again, every time you play it's going to be a different game.
Yeah. [snorts] Yeah. It definitely has more variety and it's more sandboxy. Yeah. But for all of that, it's also way more punishing and way more unforgiving and potentially so much more frustrating.
So for those of you that have played both of these games out there, why don't you comment? Let us know which you think is the magnate. The real magnate.
The magnate versus magnate.
Yeah, let us know in the comments and uh we look forward to seeing you next time.
Yeah, that was interesting. Thanks for watching everybody.
Game Toppers upgrades every game you play, being the one table to rule them all with game toppers, leg kits, dining covers, premium game mats, and more. And for a limited time only, my US and Canadian audience can get 15% off their premium game mats and accessories using the promo code game boygeeek 15 off. Also, go to game topperslc.com to check out all the options or for worldwide late pledges of their recent 5.0 Kickstarter.