Top 10 Games with Low Complexity & High Depth (Part II) - The Broken Meeple
Transcript
on this video i'm paying homage to a top 10 list i did a while back called low complexity but high depth games it was my most watched video on this entire channel so of course i need to do a part two hi everyone welcome to the broken meeple and luke hector host and if you like what you see and want to check out the rest of my content then please consider subscribing if i've earned your subscription and if the games i'm talking about on this list take your fancy then consider acquiring them from zatu dot code uk where you can use my code at the bottom of the screen and in the description to get five percent off on your entire basket of games if there's a gap on your shelf that needs filling consider a purchase and fill it up soon so what's the purpose of this list well a while back i did a list called top 10 low complexity but high depth games the idea was that i wanted to think of games that i enjoyed where it didn't take much to explain the rules or to get into the feel of the game but when you were in that game the depth ratio to the complexity was like a perfect sink you always were thinking you had in meaningful decisions to make and you know despite all that i could get the rules explained to you within a reasonable set of time so that it wasn't necessarily the rules dump that was hard for the players to understand it was it was more how to actually do well at the game but those sort of games are great because you you play them you get them done nice and quick it may
overwhelm the person at first then you're like well i get it but ah these things are starting to click now can we play it again because now i know what i need to do those sort of games really work well with people it is my current most watched video on this channel i forget what the numbers are something like in the mid 40 000 views for it which i know yeah baby compared to all the bix but come on i'm small fry give me a break alright i'll take i'll take this mantle if i can help it but it's a really popular video but it was popular both for good and bad reasons because everybody's distinction and definition of what is low complexity and high depth is somewhat widespread so it got its fair share of comments on oh yeah this is cool you know i like this choice of top ten here's my list of top ten oh yeah and these are really cool let's debate them but then it was supported by this side of the coin which was you deserve to burn in hell pitfalls our rage troll we have found a witch may we burn you know who basically sort of thought you didn't deserve to exist because apparently your definition was different from theirs oh well welcome to the internet i guess so i figured well you know people have heavily requested this on the patreon page so this was definitely the most requested video to be done out of the top 10 lists i've got planned and so i figured why not do another list now this list is not intended to replace the previous list it's just meant to sit alongside it so that was a 10 through 1 and this is the temporary one this is not my 20 through 11. and there's going to be games that i mention on these lists that you probably wouldn't consider in which case fair play discuss why you don't think so
but then also there's going to be games that you think should make these lists and still haven't in which case by all means get them in the comments below and tell me and others why you think they meet that category of course i want this video to be a good kind of resource for people to find these types of games because it is one of the most popular so without further ado let's get cracking and number 10 is a nice little puzzle game by blam games called chakra chakra has you trying to harmonize the chakra in your body you've got this column full of different bubbles with three little pods in each and you're trying to match the colors to the pods so free green in the green bubble free orange and the orange bubble and so on the idea is is that the crux of this game is very simple you've got three actions and one of them is just a clear up exercise at the end of the day the real depth of this game though is trying to be efficient with the actions that you have in order to move the gems up and down this column you've got negative energy the black energy which you want to try and get out of your columns because it's essentially taking up space you know you're if you fill up a bubble with gems and they're not harmonized then they block movement for the others so you've got to try and free up movement so it is like one of those imagine like the the four ring puzzle when you're a kid where you had like the four poles and you had the rings on one side and you had to try and move it to like in such a way that you could get the four rings stacked from one end to the other it's kind of a bit like that but turned into a very pretty and nice little puzzle game the game is not very complex it's not particularly long either granted not much reason to play it with the full player count it's really best as a two-player game and there's no solo
mode but for a simple teach this is just a nice quaint little puzzle game that most people have probably never heard of it was a hidden gem at the uk games expo it's still in my collection seven out of ten i believe i've done a review of this one by all means check it out and see if it's something you might enjoy but my number nine we turn to a recent game in my collection called the isle of cats from the city of games but in the last list i put barron park pretty high up the list is my polyamino style game and if i was to put the two alongside i would probably still put baron park ahead of this one in terms of where it would rank in this category but still there's not a lot of rules in isle of cats and the premise is like you would get in most poly amino games here's a bunch of tetris pieces get them on your boat in a particular way and be efficient the added depth for this one though is in the card deck as well as putting these cats on your boat you're also trying to fulfill lessons which are kind of objectives of scoring points in order to get cats you've got to get baskets which is another type of card on top of that you've got treasure cards which can get you cool treasure pieces for points but they also take up space and some of them are generic and some of them are worth points the common in the rare treasures and of course everything is all different sizes typical tetris pieces and you're trying to think where can this go cover the rats fill up the rooms there's all sorts of different ways that you can approach this game particularly from those lesson cards and they are really the crux of the depth here if it was just literally oh just get the pieces and put them on your boat then it would pretty much be a clone of barren part that takes longer here though unlike barron park you've got those cards that allow you to maybe try some
different paths to victory or you know one day i'm like oh i'm trying to get one of a particular family of cats uh the last game i played i tried to go all around the edge of my ship and then work my way in sometimes you go after the room sometimes you just cover the rats and there's a lot of different ways to approach it but the rules pretty straightforward the rule book is very easy to read it's you know big and big fun with a few pictorial examples but even then it's just a case of oh you've got a little drafting phase then you get the cat and then you play some cards rinse repeat five rounds okay not too complex you know i literally taught myself from the rule book while teaching three other players how to play this game and we all got on pretty fine granted i'm more used to games but still i don't think this is a particularly complex game to learn and if you really want to take the complexity down or not you could always just play the family mode that's in this game which removes some of the card aspects and gives you more of that tetris feel so whatever level you're at you can tailor the game to your heart's content it looks absolutely gorgeous on the table though and if you're like me and a bit of a cat fan then yeah you're going to love the pictures of all these cute little adorable little tetris pieces let's start come on hannah but it's beautiful looks great definitely worth my number nine on one of these selections i'm gonna get a box that doesn't have a white cover so i don't have to mess around with the glare yes my number eight is viral in fact i only just played this the other week actually been good to get it off the shelf viral is a straight up area control game you're all playing diseases and you're infecting a man's body don't worry the
man survives at the end of this but the idea is is that all the different organs kidneys pancreas brain lungs heart whatever are all areas for you to control and you control them in order to score points but the more points you score in a round the more chance you have of like i call it house md and his various doctors are able to knock you out of the system temporarily so you gotta build back up you play these cards which allow you to do different actions and different organs like move infect battle defend reinforce that kind of thing and you're restricting on where you can go because you always have to play the card for the zone the organs that you're gonna play in and then you don't get that back until a couple of rounds later so you've got to be able to plan ahead as well as think about the here and now you're trying to get points for yourself and you've got to try and deny points to the opponents there's a reasonable amount to think of here in terms of death but rule wise so straightforward the cards easy to read it's just iconography there's six of them and they're on your reference board delaying exactly how they work and most of the actions you may not necessarily even use you might never get a card that allows you to absorb a virus in which case don't need to learn it the step-by-step process of the phases of the round is on the board itself from one to six you basically just follow it through with the icons and the text and just there you go it pretty much teaches you the game from the game board but even without that the rules are simple it looks great the artwork is great this is another underrated gem in my book it was a dice tower essentials game and yet nobody really talked about it but
area control game in 90 minutes or less i would say you can probably get this one done in 60 minutes actually if you're pretty your favorite of the game and don't play with a full player account but you're talking 90 minutes absolute max for a simplistic area control game there's not many of those around really that i would consider to be good fun this one though it's got a funny little theme because yes i know you're infecting the guy's body and i know we're in covid at the moment but the viruses all look like yeah like cutesy weird abomination cartoons and stuff so it's not taken seriously in any way shape or form it's a cool game though not hard to learn but certainly we'll keep you thinking and cursing a lot at your other players in order to figure out where to go next my number seven is dale of merchants and i would like it to be higher up the list but then i have to accept that a deck builder is probably going to have that little bit of inherent complexity that otherwise might deter some players now normally i would probably think well hang on don't put any deck builder on this list but dale of merchants just has that very simplistic feel to it yet has good amounts of depth from whichever set you buy buy one of the mini sets you get six different factions and there you go get the master set along with some of them and then you'll have all sorts of different combinations but the premise is very simple build eight stalls okay how do you build a stool well you got one out of four actions on your turn one of those actions you almost never do anyway at discard and redraw so you've essentially got three actions you need to be aware of one of them is build the stall which is not exactly difficult and then the rest of it is the whole buy a card or player card so really the
only complexity in this game is the card abilities themselves but even then they're pretty straightforward for 90 of the story really i mean one of them may just simply go like oh when you use this to purchase a card it's worth two extra than what it normally is okay nothing too difficult there the cards themselves are easy enough to read and the fact that this is all kind of like weird animals and cool artwork and cartoons and that just makes it a little bit easier on the eye and a little bit easier on the brain in order to comprehend but i didn't want to put it too high on the list on the basis of that little complexity but depth wise i mean you know if you get one set on its own then there's so much there's only so much depth but all you need is one extra set on top and suddenly you mix and match the different uh factions and you can create some interesting combinations of like different paths to victory and different combos that you can build but then even if you do have just one set you don't necessarily use all factions in the box depending on the player count so again you can get some cool combinations of do you have a game where everybody's interacting with others and mean ways do you get one that the market is used more often do you get a faction that allows you to build stalls easier there's a lot of variety there's a lot of different paths to victory and combos to be had definitely i think is probably one of the few deck builders i can imagine that should deserve to go on a list like this oh joy another white game oh well hopefully this one wasn't too much of a hassle whistle stop is my number six whistle stop is a game that i only just managed to get into the collection recently i played it what like two three years ago i think once
at the games expo at one of paul grogan's parties liked it despite the fact i hate trains although to be honest this could have been re-themed with pretty much any theme whatsoever to do with transportation it really didn't need to be trains but even then i thought oh this is pretty good maybe someday i'll play it again took me about three years to get it back into the collection it's like oh yeah buy a second hand copy because i thought it was a bit expensive brand new bought a secondhand copy for half the cost i thought come on was it as good as i remember it is so good in fact that this has the easy chance of hitting my top 100 next year this is a great pickup and delivery game where you have these trains and you're setting them from one end of the map to the other but it's done a bit like tessuro and metro where you put down these hexes with all these spiraling different routes on them so you build the map as you go through and your trains go off into all sorts of different directions making all sorts of stops to collect resources and these resources can be taken to these major town tiles in order to collect shares or process them for various actions and points and i say shares i know for me shares is like luke you hate this sort of stuff what you want about it pretty much is set collection i mean you don't even have to call it a shared company you could just say it's the blue one the green one and the red one for all that matters theme wise so it's pretty simplistic this is more about pick up and deliver and less about that whole little 18x stuff but this one is a very simple game there's not a lot of rules at all movement is very straightforward you essentially have so many action points and you use them to move as many of your trains as many as spaces as you can afford and then whistle tokens allow you to
move them in a slightly different way the town tiles themselves have got pretty straightforward abilities there's an easy appendix i can teach this game and get it going pretty easily and then the depth comes from how you're going to get across from one map sorry the one side of the map to the other because the routes go off in different areas opponents are putting tiles near where you are which means your train has to maybe detour or get sent off in a weird direction and even then what are you going to do are you going to gun it for the exit as quick as possible for the bonus points or are you going to take your time and hang around the middle of the board and do some cool back and forth with the town tiles if you want to add a little bit more complexity then you can put in the uh what do you call it the rocky mountains expansion which i've got in there but even with the rocky mountains expansion in there the complexity level's not that much higher to be perfectly honest it adds a cool little bit of setup and makes the game a bit longer but in terms of rules teach i think you pretty much have to teach like a few extra icons for like certain tiles but then that's the same if you were to start it from scratch and you basically have to say oh when you build on the mountain you got to pay an additional cost apart from that that's pretty much all rocky mountain adds in terms of complexity so you could pretty much teach the game with the expansion in it but i really enjoy the whole getting the trains from one end to the other i just like the fact that the map can just go off in all sorts of different directions and the fact that the town tiles in that are set up randomly each game it can make for some interesting combinations and different paths to victory everybody's trying different things if you've got five players then be prepared
for everybody to get in each other's faces it's just a really cool game a really cool game for a pick up and deliver train themed game i never thought i would be like singing the praises of it but yeah it fits this this nicely because rules are pretty easy to teach but i can see the gears turning in people's heads when they're trying to decide what to do on their turn if you've not tried this and you like pick up and deliver games you owe it to yourself to give it a shout now seriously i think most bird owners would send their pet birds after me to pick my eyes out if i didn't put wingspan on the list wingspan is a very simple game to teach the cup yes you've got the abilities on the birds themselves but then that particularly complex particularly if you don't throw in one of the expansions but the actions themselves what have you got four actions and they're all pretty much explained on the board itself really the complexity is more just bird abilities not the actual rules so where does the depth come in well the combos themselves i mean you've got to put these birds in different areas you've got choices of where to put the birds on many occasions you might decide hm do i want this type of bird here to the points do i like the ability what if i put this bird with this bird on the right hand side then maybe when it combos through with all the actions it can really get this engine going it's essentially an engine builder at the end of the day and you can approach it from many different ways people might argue well there's too much luck in the game therefore there's no depth look okay yes you draw cards from a deck for the birds terraforming mars anybody you know so this one is a great game for this list you know i enjoy it a lot it's got a very
approachable theme yes okay the theme is not super strong in it but in terms of a setting it's beautiful looks the part it's you know it's something better than 19th century prague or whatever you know the hotness is right now you know so it it really does just work and if you want to add more depth than just put in the expansions you know the expansions don't necessarily add much well sorry oh sh the i can't speak for oceana but the uh the recent one the european one had some extra abilities you know not that much else in the degree of complexity though it's just more birds that you can use you know the complexity doesn't go up that much compared to how high the depth factor can go up as i say i think there are games that fit this category a little bit easier than wingspan but i can't imagine many people out there that would disagree with this choice although touchwood every time i say that i usually get me color felt so we'll be interested to hear what you say in the comments i bet you didn't expect to see this one on the list runestones yeah runestones has really been working for me nicely as a new deck builder so oh yeah i was talking about deck builder earlier i didn't realize i had two on this list but dale of merchant does have more in the way of abilities because you've got the different texts on them so you gotta read lots of different abilities runestones though the abilities are literally just get gems or convert gems to this or cell gems that's pretty much what the abilities are and it's all done by iconography and each card has a very simple piece of iconography in fact the cards are laid out that you can read them left or right-handed which is pretty cool but the cool factor with this is for as
simple as this game is to teach i mean you pretty much have three actions to pick from of which you're going to do two of them more often than not and even then one of them is by a card one of them is play two cards and the other one is making a buy an artifact well how do you buy stuff well you pretty much spend the mana points or you spend the gems pretty straightforward but on top of this the depth comes from the abilities and the combos themselves you're making artifacts and when you do you get rune stones the runestones give you points the more artifacts that you trade in for it but they also give you a really cool special ability that you have for the rest of the game so you have a decision do i go for lots of points every time i convert or do i just do lots of little little points because the longer you take to do the artifacts the less abilities you get but then the quicker you do the artifacts the less points you get but the more cool abilities you get on top of that the whole cool twist with this one being that when you play the two cards the one with the higher value goes out of your deck and into a communal discard or out of the game entirely if it's one of your starter ones so while you're looking at what cards to play you're thinking well i like this ability but i don't want it to go just yet have i got anything lower than that i could play this with that combo well if i put them like that and you it does really get your brain cells working but not to an overwhelming degree but even though there are games on this list i would add probably have like more depth the fact that this one is just so so simple i mean it is one of the simplest deck builders out there it's close to dominion levels of simplicity and i dare say possibly even slightly easier than the minion in a sense i mean especially when most of it
is just iconography and easily like a colored board that's easy to read this one really has kind of a won me over as a really solid deck builder and i didn't think i'd be saying that very often about anything from queen games because i don't mind queen games they just haven't really shall we say uh blown me away as much in recent years they tend to be more sort of dry euros this one though was a bit of a surprise a friend of mine you know brought my attention to it and i'm glad he did so runestones makes my four now my top three were quite hard to arrange i was thinking which one has that better ratio which one's more depth this one makes my number three though on the underground i have been singing the praise of this a lot lately in fact i've even done a a solo play of it recently this one is a really cool game and i didn't think i'd be saying that about a game set about the london berlin metro system but with this one the rules are ticket to ride levels of simplicity you essentially have four action points and you spend them on laying tracks or getting branch tokens that's essentially half the rules already the rest of the rules is where you place the tracks and how this lazy passenger moves the idea being that this passenger moves from stop to stop based on the selection of cards and the golden rule is that it takes the easiest way possible so the least amount of walking doesn't matter how many networks they use they could go around the entire world by networks if it mattered but as long as i don't have to walk that five feet i'll take this route so all the players are laying tracks in order to get the passenger to land on their networks thus scoring them points there's other ways to get points by connecting up certain bits on the map so you've kind
of got like an element of the ticket to ride route connection system but also the whole new sort of unique system of trying to get this one aspect of the game to constantly use your tracks so to make an efficient one or to steal routes from other players you know like somebody's built a route round here but if i connect this over to here and here then he hops on mine completely bypasses your system and your face granted i wouldn't really want to play this before and i will refuse to play it with five this is much better as a two or three player game but if you check out my recent solo mode video you can see the mini expansion the underground challenge where you can play this solo and i actually would say it's one of the most fun ways to play this game but it looks beautiful that stark white with the colors of the tracks on it it's blown up nice so you can read what's going on i love how simple this game is but as you'll see in my solo mode video you've got a lot of decision making to do about where to put tracks what where'd you branch off you know which network to use here and which one to use there where's the passenger going to go now where could they go where if they're yet to go there's a lot to think about despite the fact that i can teach you the rules to this in less than five minutes it's really solid you really need to try this game out preferably as i say if you're gonna play it with less than four players my number two i'm gonna have to hold up because it won't quite fit in that little space on the shelf that is awkward guess i was really i'm in orange i put this at number one but the reason why number one beats it is because the number one still makes you think quite a bit but definitely has a lot less complexity than this one does this one is not particularly complex
it's essentially a modern cludo game but with this you're trying to figure out who murdered this person what was their motive and the weapon they used okay kind of like included but there's no dice you instead have these cards with the clues on there to eliminate suspects in that but you trade them with other players and you're trading clues so you're getting information but they're getting information but you're hoping that you give them less information than you glean as you start figuring out let's see there there's nobody in the living room that time uh no one went through there so that means that uh i can't remember their names professor plum we'll just use these you know if they can't go through the living room that means they couldn't reach the spanner which means they couldn't use that to murder the person the logic puzzle you have to figure out in this and this is on easy difficulty is already a brain burner you up the difficulty level on this and you can have suspects that lie to you with accomplices it gets ridiculous like you up the difficulty to a certain level and i will never figure out who's done it but even on the easy mode it's pretty high def but complexity wise not a lot of rules you've got to learn the trading phase you have to understand in advance what the various like like different cards would mean like if someone says nobody was in this room what does that entail so there is a little bit of a learning curve but not too much particularly if anybody knows anything about the original cluedo game but once you've got that down the depth factor oh boy i mean you could argue that any deduction game could fit this list but i would say that out of all the deduction games i can think of where it's just pure logic deduction like this with some element of flexibility
this is definitely my favorite of the batch it's a really cool game yes okay it's not exactly a looker but it just if you know if you want modern cluedo there is no better version to get than this and then finally for my number one of course the crew it's gotta be the crew hasn't it this tiny little game this tiny little trick taking game one of the easiest games to teach especially if you already know how to do trick taking games you've already learned 90 of the rules you've got 50 different scenarios in here for variety and they get more complex as they go on but even then they're pretty straightforward you essentially have to work with your other teammates in silence in order to win certain tricks at certain times from certain players but you can't communicate except for a little token that you can use once in a round and even then that tends to vary depending on the scenario but it's really simple to teach but the depth is there the fact you can't communicate and i know i've hated on games like the game and the mine before but those just seem like complete luck fest particularly the mind this one though has you able to make educated guesses if you know how trick taking works and when somebody plays that card or when they communicate this is my highest green in my hand you can start making educated gambles on well hang on if they've done that then they must be trying to tell me this because that would mean that i could play this card they must believe i have this card so that means if i play it then they'll follow which means they'll get the two they'll win the two yellow sweet we're on roll right let's play it and then when the plan comes to fruition it feels good
it gives you the sort of ability to make informed decisions a bit like hanabi used to yeah hanabi you had the cards facing away from you and people would say this is a four or this is a yellow and it's like why is someone telling me that this is a yellow why don't they just tell me this oh and it's a bit like that everybody's got to be on the same wavelength low and it's harder to win this game than you might think but the game can take anywhere from something like two seconds to about 10 minutes depending on the scenario you're doing and it will certainly get you thinking despite the fact that if you know how to do trick taking i will teach it to you in about 60 seconds if you don't know trick taking i'll probably teach it to you in five minutes really low complexity ratio with a pretty decent amount of depth yes there were more complex games on this list that you know awkward guess clearly has more depth than the crew does but you will not teach awkward guests anywhere near as quickly as you will the crew so that's 10 games with a low complexity rating but high def and i'm certain you're going to have games that would fit this list five tribes gets mentioned to me all the time i just feel that it crosses that line slightly at being a little bit too complex but i can totally understand if you want to put five tribes that's the list that's why i keep mentioning it as an honorable mention in fact it's such an honorable mention that i believe it turned up in the patreon choice as well so yeah the patreon choice and my honourable mention are the same thing here five tribes is definitely a good contender for this list but it's just that borderline it was really
hard to decide and like i say if you think it should be on the list i totally totally understand but hopefully you got something out of this list and if you haven't seen the previous 10 then by all means go watch it it was um a darker day when the quality of my videos was not particularly uh sharing so professional but uh you know hopefully you'll enjoy that list and hopefully you got something out of this list as well now i hope you've been enjoying the content on the broken people channel but i'm not the only creator out there producing videos for your like entertainment forget about the big ones we already know they exist i'm talking about the smaller creators that deserve your time and deserve the support as well why don't you kick start with this channel and see if they're right for you hey guys what's up i'm jody and i'm justin and we are a board game perspective so our passions are board games and photography and we want to show off the awesome world of board games through high quality how to play videos cinematic sequences and photography etc so our channel is in honor of my brother he's actually the one that got us into loving board games unfortunately he passed away a few years ago but he wanted to leave us his entire board game collection which consisted of over 200 brains some of them of which are even behind us now so if you guys are interested in following our channel go ahead and search board game perspective in youtube or you can find us at board game perspective on instagram if you want to follow some of our board game photography so thanks for watching today we'll see y'all later and thanks luke for the shout out so that's it for me on this episode of
the broken meeple if you like what you've seen have earned your subscription then hit the avatar in the center to subscribe and hit the bell for future notifications until next time you can check out my most recent upload or video suggested by me until next time remember it's only a game