Skip to main content
Loading video...

TICKET To RIDE vs MAGLEV METRO | Which TRAIN Game is the BEST?

Transcript 9:54

when I was younger I used to love playing with trains I used to have this cool wooden Ikea train set where I like to click the tracks together and build my own networks I have a lot of memories of playing Transport Tycoon where you've got to pick up goods from a particular station and drop them off and earn cash and try and create a cool engine and I'm not talking about a steam engine here I'm talking about an engine of actions and more recently when I got into modern board gaming I discovered Gateway games like Ticket to Ride Europe which had some really cool simple actions yet there was a great breadth of choice to the networks and routes that you could build and whilst Ticket to Ride has given me some really great memorable game experiences I'm always on the lookout for other trained games in this video we're going to see how maglev Metro compares to the classic game Ticket to Ride hey Danny this game's pretty thinky isn't it I totally agree with you it's a game that definitely trains your brain thank you Ticket to Ride is a tricky train game that feels like you've just brought a set of carriages to a knife battle it's a game that has you collecting brightly colored train cards laying down a spidery network of train routes enough to resemble a set of human veins players will be ultimately racing to claim routes by connecting different destination points featured on these hidden destination cards claiming routes gets you points based on how long your route is there is a huge timing effect

however in the game you can work towards claiming a long route by hoarding those carriage cards or snap up these shorter connections to block other players off it's a game that often feels like you're cutting it down to the wire score the longest route at the end of the game and gain extra points it's all a game about not missing your opportunity or your train stop for that matter maglev Metro is a modern Marvel of train gaming it introduces these fancy perspex transparent hexes which can be laid on top of other hex tiles to create this subway map effect very clear isn't it throughout the game players will be driving these rad looking metal trains around the map picking up passengers and robots from one hextile and dumping them on another each time players drop passengers off they'll be able to place them on their playboard allowing them to upgrade their abilities and actions it might be increasing your train capacity or even unlocking new stations I guess all of those train proposals have finally paid off it's a game that has a sense of Rush about it Rush here to pick up these passengers and drop them off like a FedEx delivery service tunnel under other players transferring hexes and watch your network grow it's a fun engine to build that levitates your game strategy bonus scoring cards help to focus your strategy on specific elements of your train Network maglev Metro may just be that tricky train game that has you building your best tracks When comparing the strengths of ticket to ride a maglev Metro Ticket to Ride is far more interactive it definitely plays better at the High Play account because

players have a greater chance of getting in the way when you're playing at the lower player counts you kind of have a lot more freedom at the higher play accounts I kind of like to describe to get to ride kind of like a funnel effect where basically at the beginning of the game you have all these different options but as you progress towards the end of the game it feels far more constrictive as the boards and the routes get claimed by all the players the route building in Ticket to Ride is really tense the game feels constrictive and sometimes the choices are really tough each decision that you make in ticket ride feels heavily weighted because do you try and fill in all those short routes really quickly while you can or do you try and aim for a long run and when you've got two destinations you want to connect to that are on other sides of the board you know how do you try and create your route so that they set up in a way that it connects them together there is a cool navigation additional puzzle in the game that keeps bringing me back to the game the thing that I really like is that it has a very satisfying feeling to it when you do complete those large long routes you know seeing your Victory Point uh marker you know Zoom ahead of the other players is incredibly cool and because the victory points are calculated in real time the players can really gauge where their stance is in the game something that I really appreciate in mega live Metro is the openness of the game he even though there's this sense of Rush towards trying to pick up the passengers and drop them off at their respective stations a lot of the competition isn't on the routes themselves but actually the stations that players build plays

might build uh you know a studio station unlocking a particular colored passenger and all of a sudden that passenger becomes hot commodity everyone's trying to rush to open up their ability to carry those passengers and build routes that spider out from that station I really like the fact that you know you've got so many different options on your board at the beginning of the game and whilst you have a lot of options the scope of those options is very limited in some ways I kind of describe it as the reverse funnel effect where you've got all these things you can do but you can only do very limited quantities of it and then throughout the game as you drop those robots off you can then upgrade particular actions and really uh hone in on particular play Styles and strategies you know one game it might be your ability to refill the station really quickly and another game it might be you know opening up your ability to build multiple tracks that kind of extend to the exterior of the board and whilst your routes don't really interfere with other routes the visual nature of seeing how well everyone's network is connected together really gives you an indication of how well you're progressing one of the things I want to highlight about maglev Metro are these recess play Boards these boards are superbly designed and they make you feel like you're slotting things in and there's a little satisfaction of putting a robot in a spot and matching the colors in the right column or right row that helps you to build your engine the fact that you're using the passengers and the workers in your network to help

you expand your game just really feel so thematically cool when looking at the weaknesses Ticket to Ride feels a lot more cut through if you're playing with the base game rules you know if you don't really like crowded situations where everyone's getting in each other's way then that's probably a game that you're probably gonna want to avoid I do prefer the Europe version mainly because it has stations that players can use that are later borrow other people's train lines and I like that open sense of flexibility also the different train routes you know there's fairies and also uh tunnels that kind of add a little bit more complexity to the route building the end game of Ticket to Ride does feel a lot like you're just randomly drawing cards off the destination deck to try and hopefully accidentally fulfill the routes that are listed on it which doesn't feel as satisfying to me I prefer a game where can be rewarded for the efforts that I put into the game one of the things I didn't like about maglev Metro were those personal bonus cards and whilst you can unlock the ability to score more than one personal bonus card I like the idea of having those options really work in my favor those red personal bonus cards didn't feel very thematic to me in fact they kind of feel like they've been tacked on they feel abstract and they feel like they're forcing you into these weird situations where you know you'll get 15 bonus points if you don't unlock these two passengers or you don't use this section of your playboard I don't really like that sense of imposed restriction without any thematic reasoning behind it one of the other aspects that was in two

minds about was the refilling of the station's mechanism the idea that you have to spend a full action to refill one of the stations meant that you kind of just spent that action to do account keeping and whilst the puzzle that it creates and the randomness it creates is interest Sting the idea they had to spend an action to refill that spot wasn't particularly engaging for me now before we get to my final verdict if you really enjoyed the video content that you've seen so far please consider hitting the like And subscribe button it's completely free and also don't forget to check out the other videos on my main page so in comparing the two games in terms of theme maglev Metro gets my thumbs up in terms of player interactivity tickets are right gets my thumbs up in terms of innovation and engine building magalev Metro gets my thumbs up in terms of the tension building and weighted decision making that solely hinges on your strategy Ticket to Ride gets my thumbs up so in considering my final verdict which of the two games do I think is better I definitely think Ticket to Ride is a fantastic Gateway game if you're someone who really wants to dive deep into Euros Ticket to Ride is a great game to start with not only is it so simple to learn but the depth of the strategy and the cool interaction do definitely lies within it I definitely feel like the game plays way better at the higher player counts and at the lower play accounts you don't really get the full experience of you know the constriction of the board it feels a lot more freeform and if you like playing a lot

more free form then maybe play this at that level in terms of magalit Metro I definitely love and appreciate the Innovative design those perspex hextiles and the idea of replicating those really cool Network underground Maps is just something that appeals to me so much I love the thinkiness and the puzzle that you have to solve in maglev Metro and I definitely think it is a Next Level train game up from Ticket to Ride the winner for me is Ticket to Ride Your thanks once again for joining me for another board game Sanctuary video If you really want to support this channel helper grow don't forget to head over to my patreon page and if you're a patreon porter thank you so much for being a supporter thanks for making it this far in the video this is Danny signing up hope your next game is an amazing one goodbye

Progress saved