Skip to main content
Loading video...

Beyond Solitaire Podcast 145: Henry Lowood on Preserving Gaming History

Transcript 1:03:40

it's adbreak time I'm proud to announce of the Beyond soliter podcast is sponsored by Central Michigan University's Center for Learning through games and simulations and as usual they are up to some amazing things their next game hydr logic cycle is scheduled to come to Kickstarter on March 26th clgs also continues to offer classes in partnership with Gen Con the next course classroom game design yes we can will be taught by one of my absolute favorite teacher Gamers Dr Christian hints it begins on March 4th and you should definitely sign up for it I'll also include a final plug for myself if you like the show and want to support it you can do so by going to patreon.com beond soliter thanks to listeners like you I've been able to keep upgrading my equipment subscribing to streamyard and more but for now let's get on with the show hey Gamers this isav from Beyond soliter and this week on the Pod I'm here with a very special guest this is Dr Henry lwood and he is the Harold C hobok curator at Stanford which entails a lot of things so Henry tell us more about your job oh my job what do I do uh I'm responsible for some collections at Stanford so I'm I'm the guy who brings in the stuff in history of Science and Technology and also the film and media Collections and in addition to that or as part of that I run something called the Silicon Valley archives at Stanford so we have our own exhibit space and we do our own programs and help people who want to do research in history of science or film and media studies and for this podcast uh the most interesting thing is that the game collections that we've been building at Stanford now for about 25 years um have been you know

through my work and through the collecting areas that I kind of preside over so if I recall correctly from Googling um y'all were the first video game archive at a university is that correct that is correct the um I've stated that in writing and numerous conferences nobody's contradicted yet uh we were the first institution to collect a historical software collection and this collection the Steven cabinet collection consists 80% of games because 80% of the title published in the 80s and late 70s and early 90s were games that's the range of this collection 70s to early 90s um to that time the only institution that had done anything really with games at all game software uh was the Library of Congress but that was not because they brought in a collection that was because people were depositing things there so we were the first that you know acquire a collection of about 20,000 software titles and you know magazines books uh 75 platforms you know consoles and things like that so that was a big collection and we're still um conducting projects around what to do with all that stuff yeah I have many questions about what one does with all that stuff uh but uh first I just wanted to ask do you feel I guess maybe we'll get here over the course of this conversation but

something I kind of want to define the rest of the episode is how have things changed terms of academic institutions taking games seriously treating them as something that should be preserved and studied um you know I feel like your career has really spanned like a full range of you know oh nobody's ever done that before so I think things are very different now um so do you have any general comments about that before we kind of circle back a few times through the course of the conversation oh yeah well your instincts correct massively change so the cabinet collection we acquired uh sort of nailed it down 98 99 somewhere in there um now and then you'll see people in game studies referring to the year 2000 as the year zero of game studies right so we actually are you know BC whatever that would be yeah uh as far as that goes um and I remember in the first few years there were several places like UC Irvine for example that had an initiative to introduce a game studies's Masters that was probably like around 2002 2003 something like that and the faculty Senate voted it down um you know there thumbs down to that uh so for preservation game studies everything in the early 2000s uh there wasn't much going on you know was just barely starting I remember I jokingly say this sometimes in front of the library director and he always corrects me uh because he was very supportive i' make this joke that

basically I'm I brought this collection in and I wasn't fired um and you know H say no no no no I was and of course you supported what I did but um it was you know I just said said a few seconds ago we're still conducting projects around this collection we had no idea what to do with this stuff also and you know say circuit 2000 so we've been doing we've been going through a series of funded projects in the federal government kind of in the order of the workflow you would expect from something like this we've done a project preserving virtual worlds on what to collect and how to collect it we did the the game citation project on How to catalog games we did a project with the National Institute for standards and Technology about how to get how to pull the software off of obsolete uh media and all those things so we've done all these projects to sort of figure out each step of the way we're still in a stage where we're figur figuring out access to the collection we're doing projects around emulation right now um and it really was uh just not knowing it was a not even to the point of do people is this legitimate or not U but there were just questions around the basic steps of acquiring cataloging uh providing access Citation for Scholars none of that was in place likewise game studies what you know the people who would be the customers in a way for a collection like this that field was just coming together so at the time it was

difficult to know what would be needed for for that kind of work um you know you fast forward to today uh game studies I would say is a thriving field there's loads of programs now uh certainly at the Master's level I think more more of the PHD level work graduate work is being done in uh traditional departments so in a history department or film studies department or media studies uh group or something like that um but people people are coming out with phds there's a whole new generation of Scholars now who are changing the field dramatically and in the preservation World we've figured out a lot of it in fact I would say today for digital games not for board games but for digital games the main obstacles are no longer technical the main obstacles are probably legal um you know for distribution and access to to what we've done but we can we can handle and we can distribute games through various means that are now in place that we that you know weren't even a twinkle in anybody's eye 20 years ago they they just didn't exist so it's it's literally kind of a literally I guess I'll say literally uh it's a night and day kind of thing uh where night it was um very uncertain now I'll say as a curator I've been doing this for a long time um one of the things I like to do is to try to figure out a field that is about to break open and then try to

anticipate the kinds of materials that would be needed for a field like that I'm not scared of media other you know when they're not printed books you know if there a digital if digital media involved or things like that doesn't scare me um and I just hope that my colleagues in you know the library will will go along with me to do that because none of this would have been remotely possible just by myself man this is super interesting so you know you mentioned that you no longer have as many concerns about the technical ability to preserve uh digital games um so I how do how do you how are you sure I guess the thing I always worry about you know like CDs go bad um you know the old hard drives you know I had to explain to my students what the save symbol on word was at school in recent years because they don't know what a floppy disc looks like yeah um you know how how do you you preserve things especially knowing that the thing you're probably preserving them on is also ephemeral in the long run yeah so um I will Bo I have to caveat what I said a little bit um let me and then I'll answer the question yeah the caveat is um the game the game distribution mechanisms of today in the last five to eight years have transformed my statement about we

can do everything with te technology the legal you know the legal things the main obstacle um many of the techniques that we can use now to and easily handle games say 1980s 1990s are no longer valid in the in the era of siloed stores mobile games software as of service you know where games are updated every day in some in some cases you know stuff like that and so that's the caveat about the technology I don't think we will ever if we think of the software part of it as a library okay uh I don't think that Library will be complete in the future so a game like uh if take I'll take something I I play like eafc which is FIFA former FIFA Series game um that's a game that's updated every day um and depends on a community of millions of people to play it there isn't going to be I don't know what the playing of that what you would have to preserve that you'd have to make so many decisions about the updating of the software what versions you would use what kind of experience you would deliver and all of that I think would it would be extremely difficult not so much because you couldn't do what you wanted to do with technology but because so many resources would be involved in standing up that technology and so many decisions would have to be made uh so that's my you know so caveat but my answer to that in part is that that's

the library and we can go with different approaches to the library that will deliver something to the historian of the future let's say so there could be video recordings of say a thing that happens in a massively multiplayer game that could be people could record videos and screenshots because standing up World of Warcraft in 2100 uh with no player community where it's just the gra you know the graphical world and some of the affordances that you some of the things you can do is you know you can kill a monster and that sort of thing but there's nobody in it is not particularly interesting it doesn't tell you much about the way the game was played in in you know our era but a a video recording of things that happen or recording a Blog of somebody who's telling you about their experiences the world be more important that's the the key thing we don't have to preserve the library doesn't have to just be we've perfectly assembled authentic versions of games running on the original platforms and all that we can figure out ways to deliver that differently but the other key component of this is documentation so um we have we assemble documents relating to games into the experiences that players had in game worlds and things like that you get a pretty good idea and guess what that's what historians do anyway historians don't live in the 19th century when they write about it they use documents to to to to uh learn about the experiences of

people who lived at that time and I think that would be the same for game players and likewise for also for game design you'd want to have developer notebooks uh you'd love to have a few games that are where the development process was very was was documented in a very detailed way so you could you could follow that it's complicated to do that by the way but um I think we end up coming back to a positions that's very similar to archiving history in general you know that it's not we don't when we think about record you know what his his historical documents will be left about the first Gulf War we're not talking about actually ex being in some kind of simulator of that world because that then would be our experience uh rather we want to know what people at that time experienced and for that we need to intelligently assemble all kinds of documentation visual written you know all kinds of things and I think we need to do that for games too so when you mentioned intelligent assembly I was actually going to ask so you kind of led me here um what role do things like let's plays and game reviews and think pieces about games uh play in the archive um so clearly a roll but so then my question would be how do you select what goes into the archive and then what kind of work is involved in archiving those aspects of Our

Lives yeah um first of all uh the player community uh we're talking about digital games again the player community has been for the most part generally ahead of institutions in doing things uh for documentation whether it's um analyzing the way the software Works whether it's figuring out how to get software to run in some way uh but also you know in many ways assembling documents like people PE people having a rare game magazine and scanning it putting on the internet archive that kind of activity those are are all really important and the thing about it is um I think g games present a very unique opportunity to do that because uh players participate in a very fundamental Al way in games maybe in a different way from readers say for books or viewers for movies uh they're actually in part documenting you know any game that they've played and part part of is documenting their own experience in that game it's it because each game play is is going to be different um but players have played a huge part in that and the thing to keep in mind is that if you look at the history of libraries and museums it's kind of always been the case that institutions rely on indiv uals outside the institutional world to um build Collections and con

you know convey them in some way to institutions if you think about Smithsonian you know the biggest brand in the museum and Library World it started as smithson's collection right you know and his and the stuff that he had put together or any library has numerous named collections things that people have given the library and like likewise I think in the G in the game world people will begin to put uh together collections in some cases they'll deposit them with libraries we're already assembling archives in some cases that have been given to us by developers Steve moretzky people like that but or we've um as we were talking about before we're also interested in documentation about the whole culture around games you know the podcasts Let's Play videos um all sorts of things like that um you may know I don't know you knew this I uh did a lot of my work on the history of Machin on early you know uh game based film movie making and that's uh work that was done entirely by the play player community so th all of those um films should be preserved I started a kind of a collection at the internet archive to do that uh that's very very uh important I think people should feel uh that they can do something like that if they want to and the the step I would like to see taken next I guess by a lot of Institutions is to create uh linkages between those

institutions who are you know in a position that they can ensure that things are preserved you know a collector um unfortunately has a limited time on Earth and at some point Uh something's going to happen to that collection and yes occasionally a family will preserve it but in most cases um it's going to be difficult and so it's it's it's a good idea to start forging those collection those connections with institutions to ensure that the work people has has you know what what people have done is preserved as documentation for future historians oh that's really interesting so speaking of historical work so you're a curator but you are also a historian and you do historical work related to gaming including board gaming um so uh I know I know that you've done a lot over the you know the course of a career you've covered lots of different stuff but um what are some of the topics that you have enjoyed as a historian as well as collector of materials um the the the big most General answer to that question for me is that while I have occasionally written about design related things or business related things uh what interests me the most historically is what players do uh and that's both board games and um digital games you know for example uh I did one piece for Zen uh on the history of um play by mail um with

war games and I used the you know what collection we have at Stanford but I also used my own personal Archive of playing by mail and um you know what that how that happened and what it also what it also means uh both historically and also for the archive those kinds of collections so that's the sort of General answer is I'm I'm my my uh blood pressure goes up a little more if I discover something having to do with players you know I get a little more excited um specifically uh I would say the the category I use to describe my interest is and I'm I'm on the cusp of starting to write about this as something is what I call non-fiction gaming um so that would mean games for which the theme is something related to activity in the real world uh for me personally that's three broad categories sports games war games and historical games so that's my yeah well that's my if you look at what I have I've I I haven't played a shooter I haven't played a fantasy game uh or anything like that shooter that's based on a fantasy environment or anything those kinds of things probably for about 20 years now I've just I just at a certain point at 20 is exaggerated let's say yeah at certain point I felt like both from a design perspective and thematically those things had run their course pretty much I love tolken but there only so many Fantasy games you

know uh for me whereas you know basing games on reality uh uh gives you you know so many more opportunities uh to do things and I realize this is just you know just my personal preference but yeah so that's those are the kinds of games that I play and I've been thinking more about uh you know what that means uh we did we did uh myself and uh Carlin wing and Ray gns did a book on FIFA few years a couple years ago bunch of essays about that game and you know it's you get into a lot of issues I know you've written some about this sort of thing about how uh game design and play and all that um interacts with what's going going on in in the world so if you play a game um like votes for women you know you're going to start encountering issues uh that you know that result in a reflection on how history relates to you know your current circumstance or games about as there have been games recently about that touch themes around identity and racism and slavery and and those kinds of issues um that to me is uh just fascinating you know that uh the problem that the designers face in producing games like that each on you know maybe in a completely different thing that happened in the world and then also the way that players digest those games and

relate them to their experience personally but also maybe to thinking about the world you you know the the things that are happening in the world right now so that's that's kind of my wheelhouse then I would say is um uh I love to I guess players and non-fiction games pretty much would summarize it I like it I like it especially yeah I think um in a way you know I didn't really know what I wanted for my podcast when I started it uh but I think that going through it's basically um you know there's no such thing as just a game and the reason for that is that every time you play a game Uh something's happening to you in terms of how you interact with a game and how makes you think um I think for me the thing that makes historical gaming specifically so interesting is that it it gives me something to grip onto when I'm doing I guess critical work because we already have ways of talking about history you know like you you're telling what you think happened but then as you do that you're also telling on yourself in some way even if you can't tell it even if people in our culture can't see it um and I guess I kind of feel like that's also what you're doing with your archive so looking back back on some of the things that you've collected so far um what do you think that your work has revealed about gamers in our our modern times like if we were going to go look through um somebody in the future what are some of the conclusions they might

draw from what you collected so far well from the collections yeah um one well one thing that I think might find interesting um if you know where to look is that a lot there were quite a few connections between um games that this covers this would touch board games and digital games alike as you and this cover I would say cover a lengthy period of time from the from the 60s uh into the 21st century is the connection between games and simulations and um activities of the government and the military you know you know uh that kind of thing we have quite a few collections that relate to that you know like we have the The Archives of the 73 easting simulation which was the one done after the first Gulf War that led to a lot of the funding that poured in in the 90s but also the simnet platform that that was based on provided if not directly in terms of Technology but at least the model for a lot of the massively multiplayer games in the 90s and you know the early 2000s that kind of thing you know these large games where you can fly through the environments and do all kinds of things and all of that just likewise you could look at things like um like like in the board game world uh that are educational games that were uh

you know a massively understudied topic I would say neglected totally is how many um mostly non-digital but it's also on computer how many games were produced uh Often by academics in the 60s and 70s around economics social various social uh interaction kind of topics relationships uh education you know things like that fields that are broadly in the social sciences realm but we're done in the at universities for the most part we have quite a few of those I mean these aren't the things that um you know people say oh my God they've got uh a bunch of they've got an infocom archive you know something like that you know which just really exciting to people who play who play games but we also you know we have things like uh there was a game called simu I can't remember if it's called simu or Sim University right now actually shame on me anyway was a game based on Stanford actually but the former pro uh the former um uh I think it was the assistant probos at the university the former controller of the University went off to a foundation and he funded uh a pretty well-known game designer uh to and he sort of had all these interviews with the game designer about how Stanford worked and they created this game as a commercial game did all right the game designer is Reon well known around you know running a user a

university um that's something um I've read you know next to nothing about is that whole relationship between games and and the the both the the state no in the United States and also um the university world the academic world um there's a lot to say about those kinds of games and if you know if you think about it some of the fundamental games we do know about came from universities as well like space War you know was done at MIT or the infocom games zor you know games like that were were done at universities those were more entertainment types of games but still so that would be one thing I guess maybe would be um available to people through our archive that in the future that may you know might be interesting um we also have quite a bit that emphasizes um maybe like the cultural Dynamics around games I'd mentioned uh I mentioned like the the no don't die podcast the the David wilinsky podcast we have the archives of that of that um we've also got things like um because of the silic Valley archives we have things like uh the hacker community and how that how they interacted with games so um uh the home brew Computer Club for example there are a surprising number of things in in in their newsletter and about games and those would be available

to people to do research on so it's not just I'm emphasizing things that are not like in the what you would consider the traditional game design world where it's for business purposes and somebody's designing it there are a lot of other things going on around games at other kinds of places people just Designing Technology or working at universities and thinking of games is another way of of creating knowledge about those subjects um so that's available in our archives um you know as well as you know a bunch of Nintendo games fantastic so kind of back to playby mail uh I'm I'm curious about this because my friend Fred serville from hob ludin and I do a series called war game archaeology together where we've been reading through the general and like we got onle and we played dday and like we're we're trying to go back and kind of like get a glimpse right of the history of our hobby so very good what how many people uh who played by mail kept was it common to keep archives of your of your play by mail are there a lot of people who did it other than you and and what did you discover about yourself as you were looking through that stuff so was it common I think it was uh because um should I what do you think do does everybody listening to this know how play by mail worked um um let's give the quick rundown just to make sure yeah the quick rundown is that you were using a thing called postal mail for the we're

not talking about email yet uh yeah uh so how do you how do you handle die rolls and all of that by postal mail and the trick that was the generally generally the trick was you would use um the stock market res results uh that were published in the newspaper and what we you would do is let's say what what's today today's January 29th so I'm preparing my move and I pick a day in the future I pick February 1 as the day that my turn will resolve I mail it off to my friend with my moves on it you I record where all my units are and if there were combats involved record them and do the odds and you know the modifiers and all that there it is just waiting for the results send it off to my my play partner play partner receives it on December SEC on the February 2nd gets the newspaper from the first and you go to the stock market sheet and it goes by the sales it doesn't go by the stock market price so you say apple and you take the number of sales and you divide it by six and then the remainder is the DI roll if it's a D6 of course so um that means I couldn't have known when I submitted the move I did not know what the result di roll would be because I those stocks were in the future those transactions occurred in the future the person on the other end would have access to that and they could create you know they're writing in the column a five a four a three and then they just

resolve the combat you know as necessary that sort of thing so that's how you did it now what that meant was okay you're recording the move on paper you're writing down every unit and you would have to most of the maps if you look back at most of the maps from that era you'll see that the the hex hexes you know they mostly these hexagonal grids on the maps right uh would have a number on it or maybe it would say A6 you know' be like a row and column kind of thing so you would say my unit this unit second Panzer Division is on A6 you know and that you're writing that all down uh on this piece of paper there were some clubs and things like ahck and such you could belong to that would produce sheets that you could use for this to make it a little easier and the moves would be recorded so you would end up and you play let's say you played a game often would take two years to play a game yet this because you know think of it a turn going back and forth it might postal mail might take a week or two to do like half a turn you know you it takes just a long time think life interferes with it and all of that stuff but then by the but you I would guess most players did not throw those sheets out as the game was going you might have to somebody might make a mistake and that's another thing if you made a mistake you uh you didn't correctly apply a movement rule so you put your unit in the wrong place your opponent would have to mail the turn back to you or you I guess you could get on the phone and say what do you do but that didn't happen too much could be mailed back to you and then you

would go on from there so uh I think most players probably did keep those sheets and The Correspondents that went them that's the other thing so let me talk about an archival artifact that relates to this a few years ago I acquired a copy of the game Stalingrad which is sort of of the Vintage you were just talking about Avalon Hill game from that early it was probably done around um early 60s um we acquire managed to acquire a copy I just saw it listed somewhere and was able to get it that was had been owned uh by a player who was involved in all these play by mail games and he was also a member of what was called the MIT simulation society which was a place where a lot of War Gamers were and playing these kinds of games and it said in the description of this object which I felt was written for me because I didn't know who else looking at this an aqu Aquarian catalog would have known what this stuff meant but it said it had all it had all these letters in there relating to a game that had been played by male or games that have been played by male I guess so we get this thing and it's basically the box stal and GR and then all these letters stuffed in the box from the 1960s and this this guy and so it is some of these sheets uh uh people may know this but diplomacy was the first game where this a system like this was widely applied Evon Hill adopted it so they these people at MIT knew all about this diplomacy was really popular on the east coast and it was

stuffed with all these sheets but it also had this correspondence between these people playing where they would say like you know uh you dummy what did you you know you you again I'm having to tell you you did this uh rule you apply this rule incorrectly you know the things about applying the rules they're talking about little stuff about family gossip and things that are going on um so that's you know that's like um where like play by play by mail game or might have been multiple games in a certain context which was this MIT club and we know about importance of MIT uh for for computer games and things like that uh is combined with this just a collection of corresponden around games where you can sort of see how people were interacting in a few case you can see how many of these people identified here were had maybe like military ranks associated with them and things like that I guess RC perhaps uh you can do a lot with that sort of stuff and it's kind kind of there because of the playby mail system generating these kinds of materials like correspondence around the game I don't know if I answered your question I just went on a r this like super interesting honestly because I actually never thought about how y'all did the die rolls I feel like I like really learned something interesting today like I could see the peace movement but the Ty rolls that's cool oh I uh I played that way so many games uh

there was a was an organization called ahx which stood for Avalon hill hill InterContinental Ciel Society C from the war ah KS and you join that and you would get um you'd play your games recorded your results win or loss would give you a ranking and different games uh there's also a newsletter around ahex that circulated and I have because I was part of that environment not the 60s I was not I'm not that old but you know cing up like like in the 70s and into the 80s um so there was a lot of infrastructure built up around games to to to support that but none of it was online oh maybe until I would say probably not at all until the 80s some some things started to be developed along some of the nent online services and um you know like Prodigy and things like that compus serve you know the some online games were developed at that point but up up until that point it was all paper and pencil stamps envelopes you know all that stuff that is that is really cool I like that a lot um so when you talk about archiving these these items first I I just want to point out for people out there like just because it seems like it's some random thing from your past that nobody would care about that doesn't actually mean that that's true

um you know even in Classics right like the best the best Papyrus collection ever found oxy Rus is a trash Heap so I'm just saying your old your old war game papers might be worth something to someone but uh also how much of your archive I mean do you have much board game stuff at all and if not is that something that people have started to think about a great really relevant question for us right now okay we're uh just this year we are putting everything together to get really serious about collecting board games for the library we have collected some I mentioned the Stalingrad thing we have um you know a copy of Jim dunigan's first game up against the wall um you know the game he did at Columbia University you know things like that uh collected individually those go to our special collections department actually because those are those uh types of things are quite rare we've done that a little bit uh at the Silicon Valley archives we have a new space now where we can do events and we have a thing called tabletop Tuesdays that we do every month so we've got a little collection of board games in house to service that event basically the structure of that event is we bring a speaker in to talk about a topic and then for for maybe half an hour and then we spend an hour playing a related game um so sometimes it can be a game that's related to Stanford by a theme let's say

we had a who killed Jane Stanford thing they you know around the book about uh Jane Stanford's death that was written by Stanford historian we had a talk about that and then we played a game of Clue that my exhibit designer had transformed into a who killed Jane Stanford game we do things like that but then we also will play like we just recently you know had a lecture about gems and we then played you know uh a game about that so we've done that same we starting to build up a collection and I've started thinking about uh getting serious about the library Collection part of it and there's a a very big positive reason for doing that and there's a very big problem with board games the big positive yeah big uh the big the big good reason is that board games are print artifacts and that's right in that that is much easier for libraries to see as like a Trad core traditional sorts of things and many people in a library who couldn't care less about board games maybe playing them uh can appreciate particularly the current wave of games there's so many just beautifully printed um maps and things like that there have been SE couple of exhibits now in libraries about uh Game maps um so that part of it fits really nicely into the library world uh in a way that maybe the digital games project was more like a new media

sort of project Al along with other things like that that are uh in this we're doing stuff in addition to the traditional sort of Library so that's a good reason the problem is you've got a board game with 500 components and somebody's going to check that out uh what are we gonna do when they return it how are we gonna how are we going to it's and it's fascinated me because uh this goes back a little bit to question you asked about earlier uh there we're not the only institution that's understanding the need to start collecting board games there are others and I received when when it a library an academic Library somewhere decides to collect games digital or board games they usually call me because they think I know something about it you know like just because of the history that Stanford has had in the case of board games I really don't because we haven't really collected that much but the nice thing about that is I hear about what when people call me they tell me oh and I've also talked somebody at this place or that place and they did this and they did that so I've been hearing about all the different mechanisms some libraries have put into place to deal with the problem of circulating board games um uh it's it's very interesting and you know we're gonna have to think about things like uh probably creating manifests for games that don't have them or uh another one uh believe it or not is accurately weighing games uh one of the things I've heard about there's a university that

does this is they do very precise measurement of the board game and when uh and I know there going to be people out there thinking like no this won't work but actually it probably works most of the time I'm going to say but when the game comes back after it's been used if if it circulates comes back they weigh it and if by this very precise measurement it's the same weight they don't check the components they assume that everything is still in the box and if if the weight is off then they they go to a manifest and they actually have to look at things if you think about it I mean in the war game world there's no game that has less than a few hundred components you know the the cardboard and if you if you have three three um counters missing the game could be is probably not going to be playable um yeah yeah so it's that's a big problem uh We've now identified a vendor that we can use to buy games you with the library you know it's a different thing than just buying a game like an individual would there's you have to go through a process it has to be received cataloged uh it has to go someplace we had to figure out where we were going to Shell them we had to figure out a space for people to use them and all of that but the momentum is there and in in fact it's kind of strange because we've already heard coincidentally it's not be uh for any other reason we've already heard there's a uh a board game club on

campus that I had not known about who just happened to contact us a few weeks after we you know put the system into place saying you know we'd like does the library have a space for us to play games for our for for our club and they they do focus on historical games so you know we're moving in that direction and I predict um just based on the importance of board game design in recent years and The Innovation that's occurring in that space that institutions that are serious about uh documenting game design and providing examples of uh of important game design are going to have to start thinking about board games so when you say documenting examples of important game design I know that in any archive right you're going to have to make choices I think especially with board games like I have to make choices in my own home because I do not have limited space and those boxes are big um how do you how do you decide like what games you want to collect is it like you just take whatever people give you if somebody gives you something you just end up keeping it are all board games important to documents are certain you know I I I wonder about this especially because so have tiny print runs they just disappear to The Ether the second they printed maybe yeah uh and there's a little bit there like with digital games the distribution channels are changing a lot for board games uh if you think about it

nowadays with board games so much of what you buy you pre-order through you know GMT has its what is it p500 games or Kickstarter you know projects and all that all that stuff um uh it's not a straightforward it's just like ordering a game that you know and game stores are not as plentiful as they used to be where you can go in and look around at things so um it's a mix of opportunities that come up that you just happen you know a game a person contacts you about a collection they have or you know it might not be uh the person a person contacts you who maybe has a Stanford degree so they thought they would contact Stanford first they tell you about the games they design it they may not have been on your radar at all they may be a kind of game that you that you know like speaking of me personally that I don't know about uh but it's a complete Archive of when I designed this game you look you say okay this is a known game in this other genre it's a I don't know a Barbie game or something like that um I don't know much about that but wow this is this person has really saved everything they did on this project that's interesting so that opportunity might be something uh that drives an acquisition uh then you add to it your own personal predictions you know what you like what you know about that's part of it that's they the curators are hired because of their subject knowledge and in my case you know there's things I will dri I am pretty confident about the

kinds of games I mentioned before like if it's a sports game or historical game or or a um a war game I'm pretty confident I know which which ones to get or which ones are like a game series that's published 10 titles but H you know it doesn't really add all that much you know there might be things like that where I sort of pass on you know I figure it's not we don't need to have that especially considering all the space and all it we use so there's that and then you know you um think about your own situation for your own games you make choices all the time it's the same it's the same for the library you know you you I remember hearing um at the San Diego historical games convention um GMT folks were saying they're up to publishing around a 100 games a year something like that uh when they they started out I think I'm I'm making the numbers up because I don't remember them exactly but they I think they said that maybe their first year they published like maybe three or four games and you know there a massive number of games nobody well there there are some rich people around who could buy every game I'm sure but and have the interest but most of us can't buy a 100 GMT games every year right so we're going to make selections we're going to choose that something will Define our interest we might say I'm only interested in soliter we might say I only want to play short games or you know whatever you know hourong games or somebody might say I'm uh I'll only play games about World War II and I want them as detailed as as possible you know th

those kinds of things well I might make similar decisions I might do something because a faculty member is working on colonialism so I'll say yeah Imperial struggle that's going in the collection uh you know and that that kind of thing so it's a lot of different considerations that you kind of track all at the same time and compare to what's available I left out one thing which I mentioned with the Stalingrad uh example there's also antiquarian games you know games that are no longer in print that come up in various ways so it may also be something like um out of my own interest or somebody I know is working on a project you say there's interest in the early history of spi as a company and so I'm going to try to get these games from the late 60s to mid 70s and that means that could be a yearslong effort you know of tracking different places where eBay and things like that where G where games might be offered just just a lot of every day is different there's just a lot of different things that you have to do that sounds great though uh so I do have a question then so we've talked a lot about tracking on physical media one one advantage I guess in disadvantage of board games right is they take up a lot of space they're physical objects that you can track down and look at and touch so I guess you know for video game collecting um what is going to happen when people no longer own games and are

thus not able to donate them because they're all something we streamed right you know I I alluded to that briefly before there's a there's an essay by uh Eric cman who used to work for me got his PhD at Santa Cruz he's not the University of Alberto he works on a he's has a computer science degree and has worked on game preservation but he's also a historian he's got a mix of everything and he wrote an essay when he actually while he was still working with our had they got game project at Stanford he wrote an essay called something like why current game preservation won't work anymore that the title is something like that and that's basically what you just described uh all of the game preservation stuff that I was so chirpy about before I saying like we've solved all the technical problems right right oops and you mentioned things changing and updating but like at least you could get a disc but now yeah so it's going to be a mix of two or three different things that will get us there one will be one thing we talked about before players figuring out some things uh that they could do so that we've seen that with uh these servers for example that people have have uh created around online games there's a lot of uh I'll use the word discussion about this in the copyright law realm you know the off off uh copyright office is looking at some

possible exemptions to the Digital Millennium Copyright Act to that might make Pro provide some more access to things like that but technically that's not legal uh but some players have done it for various reasons they want to play the game or they want to make a machine of a movie using the en environment but they want apply some of their own tools to it they can't do that in the regular game so they they do their own game and they they maybe collect a bunch of updates to the game and things like that so some clever techsavvy players are going to come up with some workarounds and some projects that they do that deliver something that will be useful in understanding some of the games that are like what you've just describe uh and some of that will wind its way to libraries with digital rep repositories and such the internet archive for example that's one thing uh I think the internet archive place is a one place by the way that's likely to tackle some projects uh maybe to sort of see if they can capture updates of software but you know if you add up all of the software game software that runs on a on rapid updating you know the service model it is a gigantic massive amount of data that uh requires everything to be in place correct sequencing you know all this stuff uh it's it's just a massive resource problem but some some places internet archives players are going to

figure out a few examples and we probably don't need to say I hate to say this people won't like to hear this but we probably don't need to save every such game to understand the way these games work uh right I'm confident there will be some examples and then for the rest where we don't have maybe a version that's playable that's where the documentation comes in and that's where players can by the way also can play a huge role if if you've done if you have a game where you've recorded your replays you have them in some way that's accessible don't you know think about saving them think about put you know uploading them to the internet archive or ask it you know if you've got them in a way to transfer them maybe Stanford can take them if they're uh you know place that that has the technology to do that can preserve the video files of of gameplay uh people do walkthroughs people do game plays people do documentaries based on game worlds fictional movies you know all kinds of things collections of screenshots I remember in Second Life when we did a project in Second Life we learned about somebody who was there who had a thing when you when they were walking around in the world that their system was set up to take a screenshot every second something like that there's a massive screenshot library that was sequenced according to like where they walk through second life um so we can imagine that some of those things will

survive and they'll give us yeah um some idea of things and don't despair because we don't have complete archives of every person who ever lived you know in human history we don't have anything like that uh but if we can get a good amount of material that's strategically put together you know that that tells us at least in a few cases how games like that worked or what people did in them that's going to be very important to have and we should see it you know as a glass half full situation when we've done that not not as a not as a negative thing that's that maybe some that maybe that we can't play every game that's ever existed well that's something that Grieves me regardless but so before I ask you yeah so before I ask you a couple easy questions I guess I'll ask you maybe the hardest question I don't know I think you think about it though um so you know working on games is interesting for me uh in part because you know when I try to take games seriously and write about them I get pushed back from one end it's like well I just want to play a game and have fun like why do you have to or you know get so into it and then you know also the first time I got excited because of my blog gotten some views I told told uh the school nurse who dropped by that I was really excited because I had this blog about games and like more people had read it than I expected and she goes oh Liz why don't you write about something that matters so why does it matter why do all of these years of collecting all of these projects all of these attempts to

preserve gaming history um why do you think that they matter I'm gonna say that was by far the easiest question you you asked good yeah I figur You' be the type the answer is the answer is you cannot understand our times without games and other digital media another related digital media simple as that does you you may not care at all about games but you cannot understand our world if you know nothing about digital games and I'll give you one example uh whatever you think about our current political environment um that environment and the way we use online media and such um owes a lot to online forums and such that grew out of the Game World you know if you're thinking about gamergate forchan you know all of those things there strong connections with the game World game world and in fact the politics uh on the right side of the spectrum there a number of people who are active in gamergate who who are active there so you cannot tell a complete story of that part of our culture and our politics without some reference to what was going on in game culture doesn't mean you have to understand like the lore of every game that was ever created or have to be an expert on what a first-person shooter is or that sort of thing but you uh just like you would do you would rely on a

historian or some other person assuming you still respect experts you know you would still rely on somebody else's account for for um any area of the history of our times likewise they going to be people that are going to need the documentation about games to do that work on games and that in turn will be a piece of the puzzle for every for everything else that inv involves our times if you were to say forget it games aren't important everything about games disappears no archives nothing we're not going to deal with that because it just wasn't important you're uh going to find out that a lot of things uh that you do consider important by however you uh whatever your metrics are for this important scale things that that you think are important for the late 20th century early 21st century are not possible to write about without that so that's the argument that I would make is that it's not about games it's about our history our culture and games are a piece of that so the the history the justification for historical attention to games is the same as the justification for anything else I like it although I also know that you must be playing games for fun in a career like yours so what have you been playing recently that brings brings you some Joy um well unfortunately I tend to play games where it they bring me joy

and they also make me feel like I'm still at work uh you know I like I uh so FC I play EC I play you know uh that football game football folks uh the real football um and uh I play a I play a um a payto playay game called Evony quite a bit it's an online game it's uh sort of sort of so loosely based on history it's not really historical game but it's got a lot of fun um references to history in it and it's got a the community of people I play with is pretty good those are games that you know like are uh persistent World Games basically a lots going on every day there are events in those games and so it's it's a lot of your attention besides that that's my digital world game playing and that's about it the everything else I play because I'm doing research on Something board games I'm much more all over the place uh today I was playing a little bit few turns earlier and we'll finish tonight with my one of my my one of my sons is visiting um oh and I just blanked on the it's the ear ah shoot it's that early coin inspired game about the war on terror why am I blinking on the name of it Labyrinth uh yes thank you um okay yeah uh I just want my man my mind just went blank there uh we're playing that right now uh we were playing flas point my

other son was visiting a week before and we played flasho South China Sea um I've got uh couple of solitire games you know those those games about the the island battles tarwa the more Rec yeah the D-Day ones yeah D-Day uh I have that set up um with but I I move around a lot but online board games I play with both of my sons and we play a lot of pretty much we're playing either coin games uh or games based with my other son on the Paths of Glory system so that's uh um I'd say my really like um exploratory fun where I actually allow myself to play different things uh is in the board game realm fantastic sounds like you're living the dream honestly and then for people who are interested in following you and your work uh where can you be found online where can I be found online well I'm at Stanford so uh there's a uh I would just say look up my name Henry lowwood it's a pretty unique name because because it's a um a bad translation of a German name uh and uh you can look up the how they got game project um at Stanford or I actually I guess I would recommend is the looking at the Silicon Valley archives SVA uh stanford.edu um so SVA for Silicon Valley archives and there you can see the projects that we're doing oral history work that we're

doing the tabletop games series and follow things like that um yeah on I kind of back and slowly away from Twitter so uh but if people want to find me there they can find me at liben valde which is l i b n uh W lde um that's the correct spelling of my name uh got it yeah back well my father's name I don't um not my name um so uh that's name that was badly translated um things like that all over I'm scattered as with everything else in my life I'm just kind of scattered around that you know what I feel like that's just a modern technological life well we can but you have a podcast everybody Beyond solitire that's Liz they go there and all your stuff is there I don't have anything like that just make a YouTube channel just put everything there oh that's so much work uh I really I have to say I really admire the work that you do um the everybody knows already but it's a great it's the Assembly of interviews as a total it's just an amazing snapshot of people thinking about games and design um so yeah Kudos man kudos to you I'm so excited about your work too so we will probably be revisiting this in the future oh super you know what you know how to get a hold of me absolutely but for now Henry thank you so much for coming on this has been an amazing conversation

this is super exciting for me and hopefully for everybody out there um so really appreciate it yeah thank you all right everybody please like subscribe comment ask questions and most of all happy gaming

oh

Progress saved