Skip to main content
Loading video...

Q&A: Scott Brady - Thrift Review to Game Design

Transcript 31:41

hey everybody Edo here and I am so excited tonight I've lost my voice I have Scott Brady on the line say hello Scott how you doing I am well and if if so Scott if you're not familiar um is designer of Hues and cues as well as Boop um but uh we actually met earlier when uh when it's still an active part of um Sam reviews and I want to walk through this whole thing because you have a really interesting journey into games and design so you know just back in all the way up sure uh tell us a little bit about how you got into games and then how you ended up uh partnering with with your wife on Sam reviews well I mean it it really it goes way back to when we used to live in Los Angeles area and we moved back to the Midwest to raise our kids and uh my wife was um a stay-at-home mom and looking for something to do and I suggested that because she likes writing that she started a Blog which was kind of the thing to do at the time and she began blogging for her just for her own benefit stories about the kids and things like that and then over the next I'd say five years and this would have been in the late 2000s over the next five years she started getting contracts

from Fortune 500 companies to help Market their products via content creation so she got to appear in a McDonald's commercial with Grant and mahara this was even so is this as part of the stay-at-home mom reviews thing or was this just okay yeah so it's it started as her first name for it was Sam ramblings because it was just you know her rambling about day-to-day life and then when she started getting some um inquiries from people to write about their products or create recipes or things like that she changed her name to Sam reviews and um so she began working with those and was writing oh probably three to four articles a week for different companies and taking trips and things like that and um we decided that she needed a little bit different content to offset some of the things she was writing about which was a lot of food products a lot of household stuff things like that so I volunteered to start writing about games and we had recently as a family been playing games my daughters were in middle school or grade school at that time and we were playing games as a family and buying games at thrift stores so we decided to just start writing a weekly article about games we were finding at thrift and so so if you think back I'm curious I don't know if you know offhand I didn't prep you but like what were some

of the first games that you were playing like what were some of the fines you took from thrift stores first well I think the best one and it became kind of a family favorite at the time was sequence and it's still a mass-market game but I mean this is something about it grab the whole family and we would sit down and play three or four rounds in an evening and that was really our jump into games that weren't Monopoly or Candyland or things like that I mean it's not I today it's not a traditional Gateway but for us it was yeah yeah I know it's a good it's a good uh I mean it's a great game but so so that so that time when you're getting games from the thrift stores you were playing games that were more of that Monopoly Uno standard fare and then it was through this Thrift Shop gaming and the reviews that you started to expand into the hobby can you talk about that a bit Yeah so um you know once we started playing uh games at home and some of the non-standard games you know that we're all used to um I found a local Meetup where the people were meeting at a uh the local Chiropractic College and we decided to attend there one night to see what all these people were doing playing board games and we were introduced to pandemic and oh there you go you know some you know more traditional Hobby Games and we were hooked from that point on um and that became a regular weekly thing for the entire family to go there on a Friday night and play with um you

know we at the time there was 40 to 50 people coming every year that's a big event it was it was a really good group yep and so about how um like how much how much writing were you doing I mean this is all I assume written reviews and or con whatever the content was like how because that's actually I mean for what it's worth it's how we met um uh early days I don't remember I don't exactly remember how I saw your stuff or or maybe you just maybe you actually reviewed something independently on your own and I was like it could be yeah but so so how how often were you writing reviews at like when you peaked uh you know with that work well so when we when I started the thrift series we were just doing once a week and then once we started going to um these game nights we realized we started seeing names of Publishers we didn't know and one of the first ones we saw was tasty Minstrel games we were playing one of their games and um Nicole and I were talking about it afterwards and said you know we have an audience and at that time we had about about 60 000 uh unique monthly views and something like 250 000 unique users every year so we had and they were all women aged 22 to 45 and that was Nicole's target market with the site and we decided hey you know we've got a unique audience maybe these

Publishers would like to utilize us to reach out to a different audience other than traditional Gamers and so we cold called on uh tasty Minstrel and they were super open to it and sent us a game to to write about and we wrote an overview and they started getting traffic from it and we could see the results via Amazon sales so it was kind of a win-win yeah and actually let's just stop here because this is a really really interesting model so like just just today in the board game review and media site is this this mountain of the the the usual topic about paid reviews content oh you want people to not have you know have to work for free uh or you know Publishers but what's interesting in your case um is you um you actually and correct me is wrong but like in in addition to um um you know posting and doing the review and letting people know about where to get it you linked it on Amazon like hey here if you're interested here's a copy of this you know this is where to get it and Amazon I think I think they still have it I don't know if I think it changed over the years but it used to be that you got a pretty good referral which could also include like not only what they bought but if they came in and they bought a TV you brought them to Amazon so like you'd get a little like that can you how did it work back then how does it work now so that's exactly how it worked it was

it's you could a 24-hour cookie when someone clicks through and anything they purchase on Amazon whether it be what they clicked through or something else they added to the cart you made a commission on depending upon the category of items so for instance books were lower than some other categories because that was at that time that was what they were pushing stole as a company was they were a book seller um at the time it was a tiered program that started at three or four percent of the selling price of the item and then depending upon your volume you could get up to eight percent in the toys and games category which is primarily where we were selling and uh we were at eight percent because of thankfully because of our other articles our non-game stuff also got us up into those questions so that was really good for a while um and it was a way to monetize the posts without having to charge Publishers for our time this is totally different avenue to you know because it you know it's not like you were part of a journal you know you were part of some large journalistic organization that was paying salaries nor you know but not necessarily getting paid directly by the consumer nor getting paid for your reviews but this is a different sort of different wheel of way that you know it's sort of like it's I mean it more productive than just banner ads on your site exactly and that's what we didn't

do we didn't have any ads on our side or anything it was a we were going for a real clean look and we were trying to monetize it through Amazon and that worked very very well for a while but as unfortunately as companies like uh cool stuff and Miniature Market and on the online game vendors got bigger Amazon got competitive with them and began cutting the commissions in the toys and game categories specifically so they could keep their prices competitive right right other online vendors so today it's now flat three percent so you know it doesn't take much to figure out that we're making much less than half what we used to for the same amount of traffic so but we still get paid when you know they add other things to the cart um which is nice because that can and make the average sell price you know much higher than uh um but it's been it's forced us to monetize in other ways with ads and we're fortunately have the traffic that we're with one of the largest Banner ad companies that um that pays for the majority that the benefit of the other content goes a long way right the the larger definitely does and I think it adds validity it's not just a game review site I mean we're still doing a lot for Netflix and for uh for Marvel and Disney that keep their you know to promote their new offerings and um so I we've tried to be the you

know we've talked about ourselves as kind of the biggest gaming site not about gaming if that makes sense in our primary focus but the audience is definitely there and um so that was like oh that's been on right at about 10 years ago that we started this Thrift series and uh and and look how far uh you both have come but to answer your other question you know so at one point we literally we were pushed on an article a day we wanted one fresh article one 1 000 word article it's a lot of content and um did that not stop for you know four or five years at one point until covet hit and of course that changed everything for everyone yeah well so so let's transition here so so you are doing this you're in the you know written online media and um really built a pretty successful uh Channel both through uh the the non-gaming stuff and the gaming stuff there's Market Transitions and obviously covid I mean how how do we get to q's and q's like I remember seeing that or you posting about it I was like oh I didn't even know that dude design stuff like what how because and also I mean it speaks it's a very approachable game in a big Market I mean it's a big first game I mean honestly it turned out to be yeah it did oh yeah so how when did you start thinking about designs how did it

happen what's that story so it was actually before covid and you know this dude didn't decide to be a game designer he was just looking for something so in my previous life I was part owner in a company a printing company and we made credit cards and ATM cards we actually manufactured the plastic and the printing off do you know uh uh uh Sherry Shapiro Spiro Spiro the owner of breaking games oh yes yes yes am I what's her name am I mispronouncing I apologize it's all those names I I don't she she was like originally printing like cards and like her background was in in in in printing media and but like also credit cards I didn't realize that I'll have to yeah yeah I mean I I don't but like her her business Sherry Spiro just be clear sorry again but no because she got into board games through manufacturing okay um and I could have sworn she was like she'd mentioned that and I was like really you guys okay anyway but that not the story no that's interesting you're not your story okay so credit card manufacturing is a small industry there's only there's less than a dozen companies Nationwide that actually do manufacturing so I'll definitely have to have a talk with her about that yeah yeah okay but so that's what you did in your ear yeah so that's what I did I was in the printing industry and I kept seeing a lot of games coming out about

color but none of them were what I wanted in a game about about color personally and so um I just it was 2019 and I just started sketching out some ideas and my concept was a play on color matching systems but before you had color matching systems before printers had these nice Pantone books and things like that we had to deal with abstract color names much like shopping at Home Depot for paint you know they don't go by the numbers you go by the Goofy name that Sherwin-Williams gives them or whatever uh lavender luster exactly exactly my wall that we painted last year was reindeer fur as an example so um and that's how all printers dealt with color um they tried to match it to abstract names to to come to an agreement about what shade of blue you want on your business card and so that was the idea behind the game and then I spent a good part of a full year going from a card game to a not card game to a board game before I finally nailed down at the time I called it guess Hue and that's what I pitched it under another good name another good name yeah I love the I loved the name but in hindsight we didn't want to make Hasbro mad sure um but um yeah it was one of those things where I just made it we played it at home I took it so that

the game nights I mentioned before they loved it there and then I took it to uh we go to geekway every year and I took it there to show some of the publisher friends that that go there and they got excited about it was like you need to look at you need to talk to Big Publishers with this and I and I was like look I'm just happy to get it published that'd be the coolest thing and then it really turned into something much much bigger um and I know it's not a normal uh experience for most first-time designers but I was lucky enough that I had multiple Publishers making offers on it courting me instead of me have to intercourt them it was it is not commented there I I have interviewed a few folks that got that experience sometimes you just have a lightning in a bottle so uh you ended up publishing with the op right right right how did they win what was I mean you know they give me the numbers because they just have the best deal did they take you out to dinner like what was that no so um I had a lot of long talks with Tony Sarah brianni who's their inventor relations uh guy um he's he was very honest about what they would and wouldn't do with it and I tell you I had some great conversations with other companies I had amazing sit Downs with greater than games with Floodgate um you know at one point Cosmos was

looking at it and all the conversations were fantastic but I ended up going with the op because um one thing that they were excited about was they said they were going to put it in there and they had a name for it it wasn't Evergreen but it basically meant their Evergreen line which means they were going to Market it with telestrations blank slate and one other that they had at the time that is separate from their IP stuff and um you know they were really talking about you know the first run was going to be 30 40 000 units which was fantastic it just seemed like well and we had actually worked with them through PR agencies on prior game stuff so we knew that they hired outside marketing firms as opposed to be a smaller company you don't want to make it bigger yeah we knew they were putting their money behind their marketing and it was um it was Gen Con um 2019 is it 20 yeah I guess so I guess I started working on 2018. Gen Con 2019 when we finally signed when I finally chose after one last discussion there and um they were able to push it through get it into their schedule pretty quick and were in production when covet hit yeah well you suddenly see it did they did they did they end up doing that run

size give or take that you were expecting yeah they did the Run size um it was already man pretty much almost completely manufactured when all the lockdowns started occurring and then of course there was the fear oh we're issuing a 10-person party in the middle of a pandemic what's going to happen but really had no choice you know because they couldn't they didn't want to sit on the product so when they released it to they decided to release it to hobby first which was a first for them and so hobby got it in May of 2020 and uh retail or like Barnes and Noble and Target didn't get it to August or so so they had the whole summer to move it through retail and it did pretty good um got a big Boost from Dice Tower it won their party game of the year um so that that was a nice little boost and now that you know as the pandemic progressed we can we just saw volumes picking up picking up um got lucky with a couple tick tock uh videos that went viral um which of course are non-gamer market so that was great um you know I think the first one did something like three and a half million views or some crazy number like that and you know it's those viral posts it really was and it was you know it's free marketing so they we were all over that and um yeah it's been a really good relationship with them

um they're uh a lot more professional than I anticipated and I need that a good way I mean but what that also means is as a designer I I lose a little bit of control but in hindsight that's perfectly okay I mean yeah I mean yeah the opportunity to have a game that then can be leveraged and grown in the manner that you you know that's just gonna for lack of a better way of saying it bankroll all your future things and your time to do it like yeah so so okay so then there's this game Boop yeah which I admit I didn't know very much about but I'm looking and it's like like I can't quilt with a little cat models on it so like what what is that and that's not that's not the op that's smirk and Dagger right right that's right and and so uh what what is going on with this game what's uh what's what is it about all right so I'll keep I'll try to keep those briefs there's a bit of a story to it okay okay so and pandemic hits I'm worried about using Q's party game you know like I said and everyone's looking for and especially for Houston cues asking are there two-player rules which there aren't um everyone's looking for two player games during the pandemic because no one's going out they're playing with their spouse or whatever um and I love abstract games that's always been what I've personally played

growing up I played I love playing cribbage and checkers and chess and things like that so I had this idea from a mechanic that I had never seen done in a published game and designed this game around the mechanic and it I probably spent six months on this and designed it as a just a basic abstract with glass beads and a marble board and just like you would expect an abstract game would be and yeah and the mechanic is what the mechanic is if you think of so we're calling it a Shockwave mechanic is what we're calling it but what it means is when a when a piece is placed on the board everything around it moves out one space like a shock wave like a meteor hit in the ground or a splash of yeah like like maybe like an Othello Vibe but more like an outwards like exactly okay go ahead cool exactly right exactly right so and yeah instead of flipping like you do in Othello these actually physically move the pieces out so like it leaves a crater or something and um gave it a a thematic Japanese name called geckatai which means push away in a military sense uh the ended up publishing it for free on BGG for people to be able to print and play yeah and it got fantastic response especially

internationally with people playing it you know making their own copies people are uploading their own uh homemade boards and things like that so I decided Well let's see if this is pitchable and so contacted some people that in the industry you know this is again thanks all the work Nicole had done in the industry with Sam reviews we had all the names you know we could kind of just you try it I mean if you were like hey I made that using cues game you want to get on the phone I mean I feel like you could have I don't feel like you needed that but I mean just been released I mean so it was it hadn't gone as viral as it as it did a couple years later but yeah that probably would have opened some doors but I've never been one to to really do that you know to try to open the door that way and plus like I said we've had such good relationship with so many Publishers like yourself even that over there I I would like to I would like to point out that you had you didn't come to pet the first games for either of those titles picked up the phone there were plants on it and there weren't no I get it in all honesty I didn't think it was pretty I didn't think either of them were pretty enough in the in the state that I had it because in a certain thing right um yeah but um so anyway I I talked to a couple people uh Jacob MC out of France was super interested but ultimately everyone

passed um didn't want to take the chance on an abstract game in the market uh two player abstracts you know abstracts in general aren't aren't big sellers sure and um even smirk and Dagger had turned it down because I sent Kurt a copy and he liked it but sent it back he's like I don't he wasn't sure he wanted to be in the abstract business sure so it came back and sat here and and I talked to some other people in the industry about you know what's marketable what can we do when we finally I finally came up with the theme of cats jumping on a bed um just actually from watching a TV commercial and made a little prototype of a bed with instead of a quilt it had a board on top but the sides was actually material so it actually had a bed skirt and then the cats would jump on the bed and it and it fit the mechanic because the cats pounce on the bed and then all the other cats jump away you know uh that Shockwave mechanic gave it a cute name called it pounce house it was my name for it loved the name um no one wants to stick with the original names no that's and I'm okay with that because in this case so I showed it again Kurt and I were both in keepway again and I showed he asked what I had done with it and I showed him like oh you know let me show you what I've done with this now and I didn't have to show it to

anyone else I didn't have to take its origins or whatever um he was so excited about it and I knew that with him being a smaller company that he would really Foster its growth and really take care of it because he's so tied to the profitability of his company whereas an employee at a larger company may not be as tied into that so it was during a play test that he was doing at Pax U where um one of the one of his uh volunteers made the comment that they were booping cats off the bed and the name stuck from right there he called me and said what do you think and I'm like I love the name pounds house but I think I think this was much yeah yeah and I I think it you know it's easy to see why somebody would see it at a Target or Barnes Noble and go wanna read some more and see what that's about well and it also because it became the sound people make when they take the move so it became a little more of a vocal game than it was under under the name Palace house so if you ever have a chance to see a demo or something at a convention you walk by the boot by the booth and everyone's going that's great no no you know um awesome well and so it also I think is a good demonstration of some perseverance with the design right looking for getting that feedback getting good response on the print and

play side but finding that hook to make it marketable right that's and I think that's the key and I'm sure you can attest with that as well I mean you can have a great game mechanically but you still have to sell the product and I think a lot of game designers and I'll put myself in that category don't have the breadth of knowledge to go to be able to say this is how I'm going to make a game and this is how I'm going to market the game and that's we're going to a publisher who has the experience and the established channels um that it's definitely to everyone's benefit to lean on their expertise in those in those areas and I'm glad that both the op and smoking dagger have done well for me in that in that situation I mean you know it's it's a it's a good first two titles what are you doing more designs are you yeah actually I am um we actually have I think I can say this without saying too much there's actually two follow-ups planned in the book line already both are completed designs one is completed art um yeah um that one has neither of that one hasn't been announced yet as much yourself in trouble man my gigantic audience viral videos yeah so uh one should be out this fall and one should be out in 2024.

um and then I've got a couple other really interesting things I see I like I don't know about you but I like the design from mechanic first sure uh I'm not good at you know picking an IP or a theme and say let's make a game that's not how I I can do things and so I've come up with a couple interesting mechanics um that have either not been done or have been not done in a long time that um have yielded some really interesting play tests lately so um I guess I have a few more that are in the works that um I'll be taking around this season and you know see who's interested very cool very cool I know you're still writing content as well for the yeah yeah in fact right before uh we got on this call I just finished one of my articles in proofreading one of Nicole's so we're still doing that and um you know it's one of those things where because the site is monetized by ads and by Amazon you know we just have to keep the Articles fresh to keep the people coming back and then you know as long as we do that then it then it's kind of you know self-perpetuating as far as you know paying for itself and at this point it's pocket money you know after the fact it's not as lucrative as it used to be but um it's still there because we enjoy doing it right it sounds like it's something that you enjoy it it gets you you know your your it forces you to play and engage with your content in a certain way it builds relationships I

mean you you do you do your your holiday drive you know your holiday thing right as well um so no I mean I think I mean I think it's pretty awesome but uh and and a really a really nice narrative it was it was great to learn about those other titles and I think it's You Know It uh I did a yeah there's a couple designers who have had some interesting paths um I think along the way but you know I hope your your designs keep coming together I look forward to it um I I'm hoping to get a chance to play Boop and uh I think it'll be uh but thanks so much for your time tonight and and taking us through your journey oh sure thing I am you know I hope that we have many more conversations like this yeah for sure all right have a great night all right you too bye hey everybody Edo here and thanks for watching gaming with Edo reviews over here on this playlist league and Insider videos over here on this one subscribe share all that good stuff but most importantly play some great games thanks but yeah

Progress saved