Skip to main content
Loading video...

Long Shot: The Dice Game vs. Winner's Circle

Transcript 10:17

hello i hate horse races just feel too bad for the animals but i really like horsing games they're walkers unpredictable full of tension drama cheering shifting fortunes they embody everything that makes board games exciting and they're super simple and approachable by pretty much anyone let me very quickly tell you about these two pick a winner and then we'll send the other one to live on a farm and no you can't come and visit it oh a double review not so fast both long shot the dice game and winner circle are very much of a muchness in both of these games severe eight horses race around the track each round you'll roll dice and see which horse moves how far you bet on the horses and collect winnings if any of the horses you bet on finish in first second or third the person with the most money at the end of the game wins that sounds pretty similar right well it turns out that these two horses are very much for different courses which brings us to the sponsor of this episode horse university are you a horse why not join horse university you learn various subjects like equinology carrots and the art of hoofing it for a monthly installment of just two bales of hay you

two can be the horse of tomorrow today let's take a look at long shot first each round one player will roll two dice one guy determines which of the eight horses move the other die determines how far what i want you to remember here is that no player can change that if i rolled one on this die and three on that die that means that horse number one will move one two three spaces we can't change that this is a simulationist rule if you're out there in the rafters holding a ticket with your savings written down on it sad as that is no amount of willpower can make that horsey go any faster it's also fun at the table because shifting fortunes makes everyone go or oh or my favorite i did not see that coming there are also problems with this and we'll get to them later but i bet one immediately sticks out is it fun to have no control over what happens in the game well you do have control but not directly whilst you can't choose which horse goes how far you can sort of suggest things every horse in long shot has a card and on that card are cross boxes for all of the horses in the game let's see it's my turn i roll the dice and i get horse number three moves two spaces so i move it and then i look on its card and any horses that have their

checks marked on that card will move one additional space in this case horse number one will move one additional space and the best part is that over the course of the game you can fill these boxes in if you bet big on horse number four for example you can spend the entire game checking off box number four on all the other horse cards and even the horse number four card meaning that anytime any horse moves from a die roll horse number four also moves in fact that's just one of the ways in which you can manipulate your fortunes you can bet on the horses as the race progresses seeing which horse does better you can even buy the horses and then if your horse that you bought finishes third second or first you will get a big cash bonus this even this tic-tac-toe-esque mini-game fill it up and you'll get various power-ups like moving horses forwards backwards or even a money bonus in winter circle you can't do any of that just roll a die and then move a horse and i think i think that's better here's how it works instead of having one race you play a sequence of three races with the winnings of the third race doubled on your turn you do roll the die but most importantly this die does not tell you which horse will move the die has four

potential results bojack rugby helmet silhouette of a man's portrait and my favorite kinky time for example if you rolled kinky time and wanted to move horse number seven well away you would move it 10 spaces because kinky time says 10 right here however if you wanted to move regret story of my life you would only move four spaces let's examine what's happening here in comparison to long shot winner's circle has a different focus point both of these designs derive from the role and move genre your typical looters where you roll a die and move a piece that many spaces and both of these designs expand the scope of that genre to make it a little gamier but where they offload the decision making informs not just how they play but also the mood and tone of the table long shot the die scheme is a more modern design it has all the bells and whistles made a bad bet no bother there's 17 different mechanisms for you to offset things whereas if you made a bad bet in winter circle you just have to live with it and it can be excruciating it's a more blanket design where your tunnel vision mistake is part of everyone else's entertainment but that's kind of what i like about horsing games the theatrics the elation all the misery you bet big and everyone is going to see

just how well that's going to play out most importantly it's precisely that element of where the decision making is weighted that accentuates that in long shot you crunch on your own if it's your turn you roll two dice everyone evaluates the result and then goes to their personal betting excel sheet to do some accounting occasionally lifting their head to check if anyone else sunk their fortunes into the horse that they're propping up in a circle you roll it out and everyone immediately starts cajoling and convincing you that their totally selfless suggestion is the right move for you and it might be your interests might intersect or clash teens might form or dissolve let me give you an example of what i mean first up one last rule anytime you choose a horse in winner's circle you have to flip that horse's card you cannot move that horse until all other horses have moved so if i bet big on well away and did indeed roll kinky time i might want to move it because i would get to move it one two three four five six seven eight nine ten spaces getting past all the other horses but then the next player rolls a rugby helmet and they put a bet on regret meaning they get to move it a ridiculous 20 spaces now i'm not very good at math but this is just embarrassing do i

regret my decision probably because if on my talent i instead chose to not move well away and chose to move regret and remember i had rolled kinky time well kinky time on regrets card says move only four spaces so i would move it one two three four and then flip their card face down and they couldn't move it for another six turns on the other hand i didn't know that they would roll rugby helmet that result has only a one in six chance to come up whereas bojack which would move regret only one space has a 50 chance of being rolled that's getting very murky and speculative but that's precisely why i love winners circle all of that springs from one dire it's magical it brings the table to life it gets everyone invested and has one tenth of the rules of i don't know monopoly roll a die move a horse it's just intuitive and you don't need a degree from horse university to play so you should get win a circle right well it depends on you and your play group if everyone at your table likes a little bit more crunch likes getting invested into their own thing and likes fairness despite being a little bit duller longshot is clearly the right fit also whilst winner circle officially plays

two to six i wouldn't play it with any less than four and i'd argue that it only really shines at five or six whereas long shot the dice game is sort of okay at even just two players but once again not my favorite play account and it goes all the way up to eight and whilst i can't remember the last time i had eight people in the same room i imagine it can set up quite a vibrant evening additionally longshot dice game is releasing right now and should be readily available unless the susd effect sells it out whereas winner circle dates back to 2001 and copies are not as easy to find as you'd like it previously went under the title of royal turf and here you could either ship yourselves the japanese version with significantly more whimsical artwork than this po face nonsense and costing about as much as shot of the dice game or you could wait for the reprint of this korean edition which comes with nice metal coins but costs more than this game is really worth

Progress saved