Clank! Catacombs: Underworld - Discussion
Transcript
Some viewers may find the following video disturbing. Viewer discretion is advised.
Hey everyone, welcome back to Board Games Unlocked and today I'm doing a discussion over Clank Catacombs Underworld. I believe this is the latest expansion to Clank Catacombs. And if you have watched my previous discussion over the layers and lost Chambers expansion, I said that in [clears throat] that expansion, basically everything that was added to uh the game was an improvement like but it didn't really change the the needle of my thoughts on Clank. Like Clank Catacombs was still like a seven. Um whereas probably base Clank would have been maybe like a five or a six. And Underworld does change the needle for Clank Catacombs in a positive way. I really like this expansion for a variety of reasons. One, like the first expansion for Clank Catacombs added a little bit more tiles, uh more cards, and uh that was pretty much like the the main additions to the game. This adds more to everything.
more tiles, more uh well more tiles, more cards. So now I think it brings the total count of Clank cards to 200. Whereas the base game had 100, Layers and Lost Chambers added 50, this also adds 50. Um it also adds new prisoners, new secrets, so minor and major secrets. And then it adds a whole new board. Well, kind of a whole new sideboard that you get to explore and encounter. So, it's pretty much a marginal improvement in every way. Uh, and it also adds like a whole new deck, like a whole separate deck and actually a new market. Um, not a totally new market, but at least something. So, pretty much if you're looking for like the the magnum opus of expansions, two clank catacombs and you can only pick one of the two, this would be the one to actually go out and get. Um, and you know, it's actually kind of interesting because lately for a lot of games, it feels like expansions are just more just [ __ ] Just that that doesn't really enhance the game. It's like, oh, I have this I have this stuff and I haven't touched any of the extra stuff because it feels unnecessary. Um, but they also just feel kind of like more of the same.
And maybe it's just because these are the games I'm backing, but this expansion really felt like an expansion of old, like something that you would go out to a a lo game store and buy because you would love the base game so much. It's like, oh, here's something new. Oh, and it's a kind of a completely different theme. Off the top of my head, the the closest expansion I could think would be like something to Eldritor where it's like, oh, hey, we're in, you know, Elder, we're going around the world, but now we have this Egypt theme. Now we have this Arctic theme. Now we have this uh, you know, this different biome, and this kind of shares uh, something a little bit to that. It's still catacombs, like it's still the under underground stuff, but now you're kind of descending into almost hell. It gives off a little bit of like Greek vibes because the major boss to go in is a three-headed dog.
So, it was just kind of neat. It just it reminded me of those old expansions that you would get for board games. Um, but yeah, like everything about this was great. So, if you watched my original discussion of Clank Catacombs, you would know that I found the entire game to be more random than what I tended to enjoy. Uh, mainly because of the like the draw bag, like the token bag. And I mean, you had the random tiles, you had of course the randomness of your deck. It just felt like it was a little bit too much. But now with this expansion and the other expansion too, when you have all 200 cards, the bag doesn't really feel like it's actually that big of an issue anymore. Like it feels like there's enough ways for you to remove Clank. So you can accumulate a lot of Clank, but now you have ways to remove them. Um, more cards that give you acquire abilities, so you get more combos out of out of the cards that you're buying. uh more ways to heal. Um like because there's more tiles that can give you more secrets which have more ways to heal yourself. So even if you do get screwed over by the deck or by the deck by the bag, then you can actually find a lot more ways to reduce the damage that you've taken. Both expansions seem to have increased your survivability while being in the dungeon, but also still feeling like you could still die. um like it didn't
remove like any any sense of okay well we're just going to be able to do whatever we want because we'll never take damage and the dragon's not even a threat. No, he still is a threat. I mean and the chances of someone going in and deciding to get out and every single time it's their turn they're drawing. So, not only do is there a chance of the dragon attacking whenever you refill the market, there's a chance the dragons I mean go into attack when it comes around to a bunch of people's turns whenever it's their turn. So, that element is still here, but now it feels like it's a lot more balanced. Again, I don't know the ratio of all 200 cards. It could still be the same between the original base 100 cards. Again, let's say it was 7030. Let's say they added 100 new cards with both expansions added and it's still 7030. I don't know. But it I think with the margin of 200 cards to go through and you're not even going to go through all of them, there seems to be a higher likelihood that there's not the dragon's not going to attack as much. So even though you have a lot of Clank in the bag, it might not be pulled as frequently. So that's just a huge improvement from one having both of the expansions added. Um, and then the [clears throat] cards that are added are a lot more interesting. In this expansion, they added ways for you to get abilities for trashing. Uh, so whenever you trash a card, say, "Hey, if you trash this, do this." Or one card is like a payoff. It costs one and you get three skill out of it, but it's a
one-time use. So, uh, just things like that. One central theme I noticed with the underworld expansion was they really focused on the tombs. So, one of the the sections are these like imps that you can go out and and acquire. And every time you acquire secret tomb, you have to burn two cards from the market deck or not the market deck, from the dungeon row. And of course, that's going to refill them and that's going to cycle through that deck even more, increasing the chances of the dragon attacking. On top of that, they are worth points for each [snorts] secret tomb you have. A lot of the cards were like this counts as a tomb or if you play a tomb, this happens or at the end of the game you get this many points for this many tombs. It was just um a lot of tomb or tome or however however it's pronounced. But that seemed to be kind of a running theme I noticed with this expansion which I'm all for because the secret tombs were kind of just a almost a nothing card. I mean, there's seven points, but they go through your deck and they're kind of like the Providence cards in Dominion.
It's, hey, this is I know this is worth points, but it's clogging up my my deck. Now, you actually get something each time you uh each time you play those uh or you just get a bunch of points at the end. So, that was really neat. Then you have one of my favorite things that actually came with this. Actually, I'll save that. Uh, one of the other things, well, no, I will talk about it now. Now they have this fate deck, and I think this is really, really cool. Uh, now a lot of the stuff that is tied to this expansion is is tied to the underworld part. Um, so actually, let's hold off on that. Now, there are tiles that get shuffled into the top seven of the of the depths deck. So, this the blue square tiles you take. There are six tiles. uh corresponding to the edges of the actual underworld. And you put three of them, shuffle those with the top seven. And now the top 10 tiles, three of those tiles have ways for you to get to the underworld.
And the underworld is uh very dangerous, but also very powerful. Um because there's tons of ways ways for you to mitigate your deck. So you can go into like a a lake that lets you trash cards easier. Just more inherent control. There's an underground market that has these five items and there's only one of each. One gives you it's uh gives you a boot every single turn. One lets you draw a uh like you have two of these fate cards. One lets you it's a healing potion. One is a jester that's seven points for each stumble you have in your deck. Uh one is the boatman which I can't remember what he did. I remember he was eight points. Um, and oh, every time you trash a card, it goes underneath the the token. And so, and now every uh card underneath there was actually you got to you got to count up its victory points. So, those were just really cool. They're very powerful. Um, there's also more uh there's ways to heal. There's ways. And what's cool is that there's a new currency called silver, which at the beginning of your turn, you have to get rid of a silver or if you can't, you have to place um two clank. And I like that because I much prefer adding two clank if you can't pay the silver, then just take an innate damage. So, and there's a bunch of new cards and potion or not potions,
uh secrets that give you a bunch of silver. So that allows you to survive in the underworld longer, but then one of my favorite things about this is a spot to get a fake card. And these are really, really neat. Like, so you'll draw three cards and you keep one of them. And you can only ever have one of these in the game unless you buy the gauntlet, which allows you to have two of them. And that's really cool. And some of these are like the emperor worth 12 points if you have an artifact enhancer, a crown, and a monkey idol. Um, reveal on a future turn. When revealed, you don't have to stop in crystal caves this turn. Some of them have reveal effects. Some of them have um just different ways to get victory points. Uh, Wheel of Fortune worth 10 if you have 10 coins or more. So, the Empress worth six if you have a crown.
So, a lot of them are kind of enhancements to stuff that you um that you might already be going for. Like the the game I just played, one of them was uh a certain number of points for each harpy idol or harpy trophy that I have. And harpies are a new tile that cover certain areas that you have to fight them. So, little kind of mini bosses or um gatekeepers in a way that you go in there, it's like uh okay, I have to kill this and otherwise I'll take a damage. So, some extra ways for you to take some damage outside of the actual dragon, but you can see them. You know, there's a harpy in that room and you have to defeat it to get the effect. Uh but one of them was like if you got three three Harpy trophies, it was eight points. Another one was it was worth six if you got a monkey idol. So, not only do you want to get a monkey idol because they're worth five points, now I got six points on top of that. And in this last game, the prisoner we got to rescue from the middle board was one that was worth five points if you had a monkey idol. So, I was like, "Okay, I think I'll just go out of my way to get a monkey idol to get a bunch of points that way."
Um, but this is just really cool because you'll enter in on a different section which gives you different ways to traverse the board. And what's even better is this uh board that you come into is double-sided. So, it has a little bit more effects and the areas that you enter based off the ladders are different. So, like there's a C on here and now on the reverse side it's the exact same. Never mind. It was just I was like, "Oh, it's not the same." It's cuz when you flip it. But this is just a really cool It's an extra layer of the game. So, even though the game is completely modular with the way that the board comes out, uh, having the opportunity to go down here, this gives me, which I know not many people are a fan of, but it's still a game that I have in my collection that's just very uh near and dear to me, is Talisman. It gives kind of that and maybe it's just because it's the depth, but it gives me like the dungeon expansion to talisman, which I was always one of my favorite expansions, but there's also the overall boss you want to go in and defeat because if you can defeat him, then you get this modifier. Uh, this one is the 1.5, but it's a times two token that goes on your highest valued artifact that doubles the value of it. So, if you can get one of the highest values, which there's actually a new artifact, the 16
value artifact, if you can go in there and you can defeat the the boss, then that artifact becomes a 32 point artifact, which is just really neat. And then other people can go in and get the 1.5 uh without having to beat him. But that just kind of gives you I think it's half the value of what it's worth added. So, like I don't know, an eight value would be a 12 if if that's how that math works. But the underworld, which is obviously the name of the expansion, is a really cool area to go to. Now, I don't even know when this expansion came out. I want to say it was it must have been like last year. Uh, let's see. Clank Catacombs. Let's go down to expansions.
Oh, 30 expansions. Uh, this came out this year. Wow. or it well, but maybe by the time this video goes up, it's 2025. Damn, that's a missed opportunity. I think I actually this probably would have made my um top five expansions cuz I but I didn't even think I was going to like this expansion. So, okay. Yeah, all the 30 are just promos. Well, that's actually kind of cool because The Lost Chambers came out in 2024. This game came out, Clank Catacombs came out in 2022. Wow. So, it took him two years to make an expansion for it and then they made another expansion a year later. So, yeah. So, this is an improvement. I really like the fade cards. These are I mean, they're all different and you could because you can only have one. They're just incredibly powerful. Um, I love the market uh the new market that you can get. And the cool thing is you're not going to really stay in here. It's not one that you're going to spend the entire game in. It's one that you would go in kind of go in and out as quickly as possible so you don't make a bunch of noise. Um, but there's also the risk of if you're ever defeated while you're there, your score is just zero. So, which is the exact same as the the blue tiles because it's like it's still the depth. But yeah, everything about this I really like. All the cards that were added are great. Like they're just more
they're more um involved I feel like. And some of the monsters that are added also are more involved. So the entire market now has a little bit more combo um what's the word? Uh combo opportunities than what base game Clank gave you. Cuz base game base game Clank, even Clank Catacombs was relatively straightforward. But now with all the additional devices and and arrive abilities and acquire abilities and trashing effects, it it starts to feel like a a more well-rounded deck builder. Um, I mean, and that's that's pretty much it. I'm trying to think if there was anything else that was added to this expansion. It's also again they they did a really good job. I mentioned this in my layers and lost chambers uh expansion discussion, but they did a really good job of adding more to the game without over complicating the game. It doesn't become this whole thing of like, oh, now there's this whole new sideboard. Let's learn something completely different.
It's still I mean, yeah, you have to learn kind of how you get here and that's pretty much it. Everything else is shuffled together. All the tiles and tokens and cards all shuffled in with what you already own. And you don't really need to learn what the new tiles do because or what the new tokens do because whenever they pop up, it's like, "Oh, let's now take a look at the reference sheet. It's it's all extremely straightforward forward, which is great because the rule books for these games are atrocious. They're they're some of the wor if you need to look up anything, you're not going to find it. It's awful. I hate these rules and I forgot to mention that in my original Clank Catacombs discussion, so I'm mentioning it here. It is they are bad. They are very bad. So, but yeah, like there's not really anything that was added from this expansion that I'm like, I could do without that. No, I mean it it literally adds more of everything and it surprisingly makes me excited for if they continue to support it. Like there's already a ton of variety here with how many tiles there are, how many cards there now are.
Um I mean, hell, there's a whole another deck and a whole new new board. But um but I mean I think they they have they have a lot of like opportunity if they wanted to um make more because of just doing like a different biome. Like you have the underworld which is very like hell themed. You could do one where it's lich themed or you can do one where it is that's all I got. It's just lich. like another kind of idea. But at the same time, I could see if they didn't want to do anymore just because of the fact that this game is surprisingly a big table hog just with the sprawling um the sprawling map. Now, one thing that they did add in the back of this rule book was a uh variant that I'm probably going to play. Um, and it's restricting the the dungeon size.
So instead of it just being sprawled out in any which way, which is still fun, like I mean you could you could absolutely do whatever you want to do, but one of the variants that they added was making it like a oh this dungeon can only be a 5x5 um or a 4x4 or a 6x6. So it kind of restricts how people can maneuver around. And I can see the pros and cons to both of those. I think there is a another variant in there called the mercy rule where it's like if you somehow get stuck then you can just kind of pop out somewhere but I haven't ever implemented that. I have played with the the restricted tiles so and that just helps for organization but there's also something fun to be to be said about just wandering around the catacombs and just seeing what you come across. Uh, but that is in the back of the rule book and it's one that I actually enjoy. Um, so yeah, like this this expansion is honestly another expansion that I probably won't play without. Both of them are like they're just so easily um compatible to work together. It's not like, oh, if you want to play with the underworlds, it doesn't work with the Layers and Lost Chambers expansion.
Nope. It all completely works together seamlessly, which is awesome. and they're both I' I'd say must have expansions to Clank Catacombs, especially if you like the game already. [snorts] Now, and a testament to this expansion is that it does actually change my original score of Clank Catacombs. Uh, so the expansion by itself, I'm going to give I'm going to give I'm going to give a nine. I really like it. like uh if the layers and lost chambers gets an eight because I think it just marginally improved the the base game, this one does that but a little bit more because it gives you a whole new deck, gives you more cards, gives you a whole new area to explore, gives you more tokens. It just makes the game a lot more deeper,
but makes it just feel a lot more balanced in my opinion. So, this expansion gets a nine. Uh, the first expansion got an eight. So, that is actually gonna blump uh bump up Clank Catacombs to an eight for me. It is now a game that I consider to be um very good instead of just good, you know, where it's like okay. Um but funny enough, now it kind of becomes, hey, you want to play Clank Catacombs? It's like, do you have the expansions? No. Okay, let me go home and get my copy. know it's uh uh but I mean I would be less inclined to play base game Clan Catacombs. Um but I'd be a lot more willing if one or both of the expansions was were added. So yeah, it's actually surprising. I literally bought these together kind of to as as an experiment on does does mindset and expectation alter how you feel about a game?
And with Clan Catacombs, like I said, the original ver uh uh ranking I gave was a six and it bumped up to a seven. I'm like, "Okay, that's cool." Uh, it went up a little bit, but I didn't really expect much from the expansions, and now I'm like, damn, I kind of want more expansions, which is huge. That's that's honestly uh surprising to me. Now I got to figure out if there's a 3D insert to organize all of this because the organization is not great. Um, but that's it. Yeah, just double checking that there's not anything else. [snorts] Nope. Nope. That's uh that's everything that I have for Clank Catacombs Underworld. Here's hoping again that they make more uh expansions, but now damn it, I'm going to have to revisit Clank Legacy because I didn't really like Clank Legacy. Um but now maybe I will. Uh so I guess keep an eye out if I do end up getting that. Keep an eye out for my my discussion on that.
Anyway, that's my thoughts on playing Catacombs Underworlds. Let me know what you think of the expansion in the comments below. Other than that, like, comment, share, and subscribe, and have a wonderful whatever time of day it is for you.