How to build a million dollar publishing company with Amy and Dusty Droz
Transcript
Amy doesn't know this story sorry Amy Artistry has two ratings and one of them is a three and the guy literally says in his review haven't played it but didn't like botney and I'm sure this one sucks too was just like I don't get how you can raate a game without actually playing it yeah yeah on Board Game Geek they have the top you know whatever you can rank them one to I think 26,000 or something like that like the the worst game is 26,000 well you can flip that and you can look at it from bottom to top and in that bottom 20 is Monopoly Connect 4 I think's in there Shoots and Ladders The Game of Life twister games that have sold hundreds of millions of copies like games that have built empires of board game publishing companies I think I would rather have a really low ranked game that sells a million copies then have a really high rate game sell and not just that yeah when you walk by and you're just casually saying monopolies a piece of garbage the sales numbers do not agree with that at all what's up my friends welcome to the board game Design Lab today we're talking business talking about what it looks like to run a Indie publishing business and all the things involved whether it's crowdfunding uh tariffs fulfillment Amazon like we're going to dive into as many topics as we can pack into this episode I'm talking to my good friends Amy and Dusty Dro welcome to the show howdy howdy hi I guess I should say welcome back last time we chatted y'all had just made a you know a million
dollars on Kickstarter running your very first campaign bney and it was so it such a great episode I got a lot of really good feedback from that episode from people saying oh oh that makes sense like there's a lot of understanding of people going oh okay maybe I could do that too maybe not make a million bucks but I feel like y' did a great job of just kind of simplifying your process down and making it easy to understand and now here we are several years later and you've got a whole publishing business where you're you just now launched your third campaign all your campaigns have done very well very very well like hundreds and hundreds of thousands of dollars maybe not quite hitting that boty level but still doing great you're selling a ton of games on Amazon you're selling a ton of games on your website you're selling a ton of games in distribution and Barnes & Noble and like y' got a lot going on and so what's really cool is I've been able to watch this whole process I think Dusty you and I we probably talk more than I think I think I talked to you more than anybody else in the industry like it's pretty regular where something will happen and I'll be like hey Dusty you see did you see did you see what happened today and we just you know then we start talking about the death of Star Wars and like all the other crazy you know things that going on in life and I feel bad because I'm bouncing between well let me talk about the math here and oh my god did you see what happened in Star Wars and okay now we're back to math and oh but Warhammer was cool like right and it's it's just been really fun to get to know y'all and become friends but also just to see your journey from hey we had this idea for a really pretty game oh now we do this full time and we've got a really really robust business that we've built and we
were able to Y y'all quit your photography jobs y'all quit everything else is that right it's it's sleeping CU we believe in we believe in backup plan my backup plans have backup plans and so the photography is hibernated and could be turned on at a moment's notice if needed yeah right I guess as long as you have the cameras you could still jump right back into but right yeah but right now publishing is y'all's full-time gig right yes and so yeah I'm excited to talk about how do you do that because I know there's a lot of people that listen to this show and are in the board game Design Lab community that that's that's a dream that's like a long-term goal is how do I get to that point now if you're only designing games that's going to be hard like that's a challenge like you're going to have to design Ticket to Ride you know 2.0 and just sell a million copies every year or you're gonna have to design like 20 games a year and get most of them signed or you could go into publishing and I think that's really the best way to kind of do this full time now that comes with all the other garbage of customer service and I say garbage the other stuff I don't mean customers and their service loving garbage it's a good garbage to have it's it's um it's cleaning out septic tanks sometimes man is what it feels like and um because it just is what it is but you have to deal with all the other stuff and so y'all have figured a lot of that out and you and I have had a lot of conversations and kind of figured some things out together I've been learning a lot from you I like to think you've learned a few things on my end you know absolutely we have a very different model where I'm doing a new campaign every single month and then delivering directly from China internationally and you're y'all are doing the more traditional you know run a one or two campaigns a year uh you
know Freight ship get into retail get on Amazon get into distribution and so we have so many cool differences but at the same time you know a lot of stuff to figure out but um yeah I'm just excited to chat with y'all about some things let's um let's dive right into the hot topic of the day though we got some plenty of business stuff to get into that's more like core Evergreen stuff but let's talk about tariffs let's talk about what everybody is posting online about that you know the sky is falling because it's a 10% 20% tariff potentially and now you know we got all these retaliations with other countries and they're dropping all sorts of tariff War kind of stuff and I've seen so many people post about like I'm just gonna not you know publish any games this year I'm just going to wait and do it next year or you know we're gonna have to raise our prices $30 and it seems like people are thinking or saying the sky is falling but I don't you know I'm not a math guy Dusty you're a math guy you're gon have to help me out here I don't believe it's that big of a deal for most Publishers now maybe there's certain Publishers that do things a certain way that their margin is already like so paper thin that now we're getting even thinner you now we're getting into air it's air thin at this point but I feel like for most Indie Publishers it's it's not the it's not the end of the world so tell me what you're seeing as far as tariffs go how do they actually work because I think some people just don't understand what 10% literally means like it doesn't mean if you have $100 game you have to pay $10 in shipping that's not what that means and so walk me through the math and just your take on the tff situation as it is right now so I have a I have a bit of a complex take on this because it
is directly affecting me but at the same time I've studied a lot of economics and so I I understand what is happening globally and why these things need to happen for certain things to be healthy in the economy which is going to be a hot take for some people but up until the last few years tariffs were not a thing that was like one political side or the other they were just a standard tool of econom ICS um as far as like how they work people get confused by the term declared value the declared value is not what you declare your value is it's the value that you paid for that thing so it's not your $60 MSRP yeah because imagine coming into port and they're like well how much is this worth and you're like well I might sell it at full retail to a consumer for $60 or I might sell it wholesale to a store for $30 or I might sell it to a distributor for $24 or maybe I'm going to pass it along to somebody who's doing like a hybrid consolidation and marketing for $15 so what do you think you should charge me they're going to look at you and just be like you know I don't know and so when it comes into Port whatever you paid for it and then sometimes shipping it varies your freight cost like your freight cost so the safe thing to do is just estimate based on landed cost so if your landed cost for your game is $10 your tariff is $1 that's it that's the whole thing that does matter multiplicatively when you're looking at your um like your your multipliers so if
you're doing a 5x or a 6X or a 7x you still have to sort of take that into account to make sure that the rest of your deals are healthy through distribution and through other stuff but for the most part I mean like I talked to somebody and he was like my tariff is going to be $6 and I'm like but your I I know for a fact your game only costs $3.50 to produce and he's like and my tariff is going to be $6 on the MSRP and I was like no your tariff is going to be 35 cents per copy and he goes I am so much calmer right now than I was this morning like like these are not terrifying or scary things and the other part of this equation is that if you're doing things in a way that's that's really healthy for your business you're dealing with this stuff full-time anyways because it's not just a 10% tariff now it's 9% inflation year-over-year it's oil prices have gone up and so you have to pay more for Freight it's a butterfly flapped its wings and sneezed in Australia and now there's a hurricane somewhere it's somebody's shooting Rockets into the Red Sea and our boat twice now has had to go around Africa and both times they said well we thought it was going to be cheaper but now the cost went up by 20% this stuff is happening continuously and that's why you build your multiplier you watch your margins carefully and and if you're running paper thin yeah that's a problem but if you have a good healthy margin on what you're doing the the point of that is not just making a profit the point of that is also protecting yourself from all the crazy
stuff that the world is going to throw at you when we're a bunch of small businesses dealing with a global economy yeah absolutely and unfortunately there are some people out there some businesses maybe not in the board game Space hopefully but probably just because that's the nature of human nature um that are seeing this as an opportunity to increase their margin to say oh hey there's 10% care of 20 % tariff you know the MSRP unfortunately has to go up $9 $10 it's like wait like but it only cost $9 before like that math doesn't Square huh you know and so they're raising prices to increase the margin which is just kind of what people do you know and we we might call that price gouging we might just call that capitalism I don't know I'll let that I'll let the listeners decide what they want to call that but you know if you're seeing companies raise their prices by a substantial margin I I just have to question that now I don't know math I don't I don't see their you know profit and loss sheet I don't see their ins and outs but it just doesn't seem like the tariffs for our particular industry are that big a deal overall now again if you have a $20 game and you're selling that into distribution so you know maybe you're selling the game for eight and you're it cost you I don't know $2 $3 to manufacture and you've only you okay now now all of a sudden like your your margin was already from a dollar perspective already kind of low not necessarily from a percentage but from a dollar perspective that's not a lot of money sell localization deals and you're only making $3 a box making $2 a box is a pretty big cut like that's some damage
the the other thing too like to take it one step further is a lot of people are are like you know oh God I might have to change my price I might have to change my price okay yes you set your price originally and our price like our botney cost $60 even before tariffs I knew that it would not cost $60 forever 10 years from now it's going to cost more to produce botney like that's just the world right and if that's the case if that's going to happen 10 years from now then I every time we do a print run I check hey is the mass still adding up are we still hitting our multiplier is is it costing more for Freight and so far we haven't Chang the price tariffs aren't going to change the price because we have a healthy multiplier but there's two options if you're cogs because that's effective what's happening with 10% T up go up by 10% either you look at the math and you say well you know I had a better multiplier before but I'm still within like that minimum five six whatever I'm aiming for Price doesn't change or you look at it and you're like oh yep my multiplier is not where I needed to be it's down to 4.8 let's bring it back up to five price goes up by $5 now you have a $65 game instead of a $60 game also we have heard that it's better sometimes to raise it more so it will last yeah you don't want to be raising by dollar and then a dollar again two weeks later and a dollar again three you you know you go up in increments of five and so yeah and that's the that's just a simple math and people are freaking out I think because it's a politics thing but if you look at
it they were already doing that like I said for inflation for random Wars for hurricanes you know for that fluffy puppy that distracted the UPS driver whatever doesn't matter all this math is things that everybody's already doing but for some reason some of it they just are like oh I'm just doing math and some of it they you know they get really tied up over and it's better just to look at the obstacle see how you're going to get through it and move through it and then you're done exactly that's and that's the way I try to look at everything is take it say take the emotion out of it now politics get very emotional for all sorts of reasons and lot of those reasons are good but when you start allowing the emotion to affect the business we got to take a step back and go wait a minute what would I do if the container with all my games fell off the boat What would I do if I had to just like replace all the things and figure out the money and figure out like okay how we're gonna I wouldn't like hopefully I would not lose my mind and post a bunch of stuff on online and be like oh no the sky is falling I would just be like okay how are we going to overcome this obstacle and then do it like figure out a plan and then work the plan and then come out on the other side hopefully okay I I try to take every everything that comes along in that same approach because one getting emotional and losing my mind doesn't help any if anything it just makes everything worse two if I go online and I do these Rants and Raves and all that it's I'm not the only one seeing that like other people are seeing that and so if other people who maybe want to do business with me and partner with me on things they say they see me
losing my mind and like this rant and R and all this kind of stuff they might take a step back and go maybe I don't want to work with somebody who lets things bother them this much you know like politics aside it's just like CU I I personally have have have done have taken a step back like I've seen artists that maybe I wanted to work with or Freelancers that I maybe wanted to work with who post these long things about like specific people or specific companies and they're just like airing all their dirty laundry and you know maybe there's a time and place for that but in general I go I don't want that to be me like if I make a mistake and maybe I don't you know return an email quick enough or maybe I don't like maybe there's disagreement about payment terms and maybe the contract wasn't clear enough for something am I going to have to deal with all this other Fallout as well working with it so anyway I think there's something else to be said for just like take a step back and just assess is this worth it you know is it worth all the extra if I can step up onto the uh the soap box next to you too um it's not just the people you work with that see these things it's your customers and it doesn't matter what you think on any topic more than half of people because it's it's more complex than just a left left and right uh you know yin and yang kind of thing there are many different perspectives on this stuff will not agree with whatever you are ranting about online and that will cost you sales and I can't remember who it
was I'm I'll say it out loud maybe it was Liberace I don't know this was a while ago this was 30 years ago 40 years ago somebody asked him they're like how come you don't how come you don't make a political statement how come you don't get involved in this stuff he's like because I don't want to lose half my customers right even if it wasn't him it was definitely a singer I'm doing a terrible job of telling this story I I want to say Michael Jordan said you know Republicans buy sneakers too you don't want to like undercut I mean you're costing yourself money first off if you if you want to make it real personal but second off you know these people are just people that want to play board games and things are bigger than just just the statement of the day and if you I mean we I'm sure we could if we worked real hard at it we could find a few examples of a very major company that keeps waiting into politics and no matter whether you agree with them or not the financial statements they're releasing at the end of every year are telling you that they have lost half their customers right so for us our customers have no idea what we think I mean none other than the fact that we like flowers and I like Warhammer they don't have a clue and they never will because it's not the place and it's not the time I want to play a board game with them and I want to have fun would you like to play a board game neat let's play like right and and speaking from a just a sheer customer Place let's pretend for a moment I don't know y'all I don't know anything about you all I know is that you make pretty board games that are fun to play with my family that's all I know that's all I care to know I don't care about the rest I don't want I just I just want interesting part yeah I want you to provide a great gaming experience at a good price at a decent shipping rate that my family and
I can enjoy together that's it like you know and that's you get from us guaranteed 100% of the time right because that's just good business you know what I mean and I know some things come along and there's like a moral imperative like people make it into an ethical deal and there's a whole gray area complexity that goes into that but as a publisher I'm just trying to create great gaming experiences that I can put on other people's tables and what I believe about whatever the political topic of the day is does not factor into that if you want to have a conversation one-on-one you want to ask me my thoughts on this that or cool let's sit down let's talk but in general I just want to make great games and sell them to people that want to play them like it's not to the topic that got us on this tangent in the first place when you come to terms with the fact that you are you are providing a service and you are you are serving everybody regardless of what you know whatever they may think and you're just in it to make that also makes the other problems easier because you can look at them rationally and you can go 10% tariff okay that means my cogs is this I will do this math and oh I do have to raise my price by $5 I will imp mement that on this time the one time that that that actually gets like the one danger for most people is if you sell a Kickstarter at a certain price not having had the tariffs in place and then you don't deliver for three years and then three years later and my gosh what can happen in three years right you
can go you can go from not World War II to World War II if you study history in less than three years right three years is an incredibly long time and so the more time you have there the more you open yourself to that risk well that gets dangerous and that's again where you need to make sure that you have that like I keep going back to the math if you have a healthy margin you do pad against the amount of time it takes you to deliver for us we're in the position where we don't launch a Kickstarter till the game is done and so like Artistry is gonna be printing the moment the kickstarter ends well and Gabe's like every month yeah and and and we got that idea from Gabe specifically and Gabe makes us look like Chumps with a four-month turnaround well when I'm like that because I fell a big old fat hole called roboman that is taking me forever to finish just because it's gigantic game it is a good- looking hole to be fair but I learn I have so many scars from roam mine that have informed everything else I do and so because of robam mind that's why I went to this model of like Hey we're gonna finish a game like the Art's gonna be done graph Design's gonna be done rule book is gonna be as done as we can get like you know we'll do some extra editing and whatever right before print but for the most part 99% done because I don't want to run into a situation again where I'm just sitting on G waiting on o for a long time but it's also why I haven't opened the roboman pledge manager because I didn't want to open it prematurely when I wasn't for sure what the shipping rates were going to be and now I'm not for sure what the extra tariffs and costs and duties and vaps and all this kind of St it's like I'll just wait and people get annoyed they
get frustrated they post angry comments about it and that's okay that's fine I think that's another thing I've learned as a publisher be okay with negative comments people are going to make them if you have a big campaign and you only have 1% of like lunatics that's still going to turn into like a decent number of people if you have multiple thousands of backers look at the number of people who have said negative things about you and then go look at the number of backers you have and and then do the math on how many people haven't said anything about you and exactly yeah exactly well game trying to get a harder skin Amy's not allowed to look at stuff like she'll walk over to the computer and I'll put my hand across it it's like an email and I'm like you do not look at this email it's not she's like what's it say I'm like it's not a big deal you don't look at it don't touch it I actually saw the other day we were gonna add is on board game geek right and they have like a warning like you need a tougher skin because people are when you go to sign up for advertising they're like you will get negative comments for doing this don't respond negatively I like what well that's also we'll come back to Board Game Geek in a minute but like the board game geek audience is so different than like the normal gaming audience but a lot of times the board game geek audience thinks they're the only audience even though they make up maybe 1% of the the fool you know and so that's another thing when you have a game like botney or Game Geek ain't going to like it that's not their kind of game highly controversial apparently I mean it's just kind of crazy but at the same time botney has sold how many thousands of copies at this point 35 we're just doing our next print run for 10 so in a year we've done 35,000 copies and what's funny is they are liking laf floor better yeah that's what we can't
understand is for us we look at lafl and botney and it's both like pretty fun yay let's go and uh and Board Game Geek is rating lefl it's sitting at like an eight like looking at this going you know eight on Board Game Geek might as well be like a 9.8 because nothing ever scores a 10 for whatever reason um even though I have some games here that I would absolutely slap a 10 on no problem and a lot of people put in ones just because they don't think a game is worth a 10 like they haven't even played it they just want to give it one because it's got a bunch of artistry got a Amy doesn't know this story sorry Amy Artistry has has two ratings and one of them is a three and the guy literally says in his review haven't played it but didn't like botney and I'm sure this one sucks too was just like I don't get how you can rate a game without actually playing it yeah yeah so you know you probably shouldn't but you know it doesn't stop people yeah but thinking from a number standpoint I think you and I talked about this the other day just on the phone where I was curious about what are the bottom number like what are the bottom ranked games right on Board Game Geek they have the top you know whatever you can rank them one so I think 26,000 or something like that like the the worst game is 26,000 out of the total well you can flip that and you can look at it from bottom to top and in that bottom 20 is Monopoly Connect 4 I think's in there Shoots and Ladders The Game of Life twister it's Battleship I think it's like games that have sold hundreds of millions of copies like games that have built empires of board game publishing
companies I think I would rather have a really low ranked game that sells a million copies than have a really high ranked game and not just that yeah not just that but if you think about it there you know there are games like chess and uh Checkers and you know a few other things that have been around for centuries that you know people you you go to the Wikipedia entry for the thing and it and it's like a history lesson right games like Monopoly and Shoots and Ladders those will be studied by cultural cultural anthropologists 200 years from now will any game on the top of board game geek be studied by an anthropologist centuries from now if I had to bet a kidney I would put that kidney on Monopoly you know and not brass Birmingham brass Birmingham is a great game but when you're when you're when you walk by and you're just casually saying monopol is a piece of garbage the sales numbers do not agree with that at all right and so you know speaking from a business perspective I actually had a really good conversation the other day I was doing a a coaching call with a A fatherson Team they're doing their first game it's like this card game that's very general public type of game it's about underwear and like it's a silly underwear themed game and very much for like families with you know 11-year-old kids and they were they had asked a question or something on Board Game Geek and they were just like we got really negative feedback and I was like oh of course you did like you I would have known that before I asked that question like you were gonna get
some bad feedback on that is not the group of people you're trying to sell this to and we were talking about Kickstarter I was like look Kickstarter is not even the market for your game either you're going to have a hard time making a lot of money on Kickstarter because people aren't going to Kickstarter for underwear games they're going there for Miniatures games that cost $200 but I tell you what Amazon is gonna be really good to you because that's where normal Gamers quote unquote that are just like you know they buy a couple games a year that they want to learn in two minutes and play in five minutes just as a fun little after dinner thing you're going to do really well on Amazon I think but you're not going to do great on Kickstarter and you're not going to be ranked highly on Board Game Geek just know that going in they're like oh that makes a lot of sense it's like so I think there's a lot of listeners that need to hear that too just because your game doesn't do well on Board Game Geek just because it doesn't do well on Kickstarter or gamefound or backer kit wherever it doesn't necessarily mean anything because you could sell a lot of copies in retail in distribution on Amazon just because it's that type of game so you know understanding your audience and let's talk about that um I feel like y'all have done an excellent job of kind of figuring out who your core audience is and we talked about that a lot on the that's right on the last episode is is figuring out who that customer Avatar is but talk to me maybe some things you've learned since botney about how to hone in and really focus on that core buyer that core customer and and just make sure you're delivering for them the best experience possible even if Board Game Geek is like oh this is terrible so when we had when we started botney by the way for anybody out there
that hasn't listened to us before you will know that I I fill air with noise continuously and then Amy Says smart things yeah Amy says the smart stuff uh when we started with botney we just made a game that Amy liked that we thought would be fun that we were kind of like oh this will be neat like people will enjoy this and but we didn't really understand the target audience and it was ory at Kagan Productions that that we first like had a meeting with and he's like who are you selling this to and we're like uh and he's like well let's come up with who you're selling it to we went and we defined her her name is Mary we know everything about her where does she shop what does she do for fun you know what does she like to watch on TV everything she's basically Amy it was pretty easy Avatar yeah we were making it for me yeah we're making the game for Amy once we learned that and we it really started to settle in during botney Kickstarter I began to realize it informs everything it's it's how I handle emails it's the next games and the next games and somebody was like I can't believe you're already making your next game for Artistry there's three new games on artistry's campaign we put warlord posies and little Artistry on there um we're making decisions while we're doing game design and I'll be like H I don't like that and Amy's like I want more dresses in this game and I'm like we don't need more dresses there's no reason for them to be here she's like Mary will like more dresses and I'm like you know what you're actually right we need to figure out how to get 50 more dresses into this game it's stuff like that once you understand that like I we know how to lay out the website we know how to handle our shipping policy we we know how where to Market how to Market when you realize who you're selling your
game to and and by the way after having bashed on Board Game Geek a little bit if your core audience is Board Game Geek well then you know right there who you're selling to and how to sell to them and I know folks whose target audience is boor game who do very well because they understand that Mary would never buy their game but that's okay because they're not making a game for Mary just like Board Game Geek it's okay that you don't like botney because we're selling thousands of copies to people who do like it and I saw somebody put a quote up the other day that was like if if there's a game that's selling a whole bunch and you don't understand why there's a lesson to be learned there right like and so just knowing who is knowing you know who Amy is and then Amy yeah well we know that everyone likes like the quality components like they don't want cheap we got so many fights about foil on botney and now Amy's like I want foil on the box I'm like do we even need to say that at this point of course every game is gonna have foil on the box shiny yeah pretty um Amy's like well I like this and I'm like you know and she's like what do you think and I'm like I don't feel like I'm qualified to answer that but I know you like it and so it's probably going to be a good decision like let's go like well and then for um our kickstar started right now Artistry instead of like doing a traditional Deluxe game or Super Deluxe more trays more trays yeah more trays Miniatures well we do have little like um metal bust in the jewelry box space but they are but they're 3D scanned from actual art new vust that we have here at the house and they're being made in metal and they're all like in Golds and Silvers and stuff and so yeah the
jewelry box Edition I mean that was actually funny because Amy's like I want to I want to I want to aim for this crazy Edition comes in a jewry box faux leather faux velvet inserts like the whole nine yards she's like I want to do that and I was just like Okay sounds like an interesting science experiment let's do it acrylic player board acrylic player boards on metal legs like and she's like I want all this stuff and we the funny thing was we went to our vendors and we're like hey guys here's what we're thinking they're like you want to do what now like I've never seen anything like this in my life and Amy and we've sold to date uh our mq was 500 and in two days we sold 500 copies of this $200 edition of artistry that Amy Custom Design jewry box for it's fun to see on Kickstarter like is there demand for it yeah so we kind of test Waters too but I should have known of course there's demand for it because Amy knows her audience right and that's man and that just comes with time that's something I think I've been able to hone in on with the solo Gaming Community that the backers and and customers I have on a regular basis where hopefully to a point where when I put a game on you know the next campaign they know it's it's going to be good for them like they know they're going to enjoy it because it's coming from my company and you know I am the gatekeeper now to say hey if I'm putting it out there it's because I enjoy it it's fun for me if you have enjoyed the games previously you're probably going to enjoy this one too and really being able to hone in on that Community it just takes time it takes trial and error it takes doing some things you're like um that didn't quite hit the way I thought it would um and then looking at games that did really
really well and going okay how do I do more of that and you know looking at your audience and going hey we want to do a nice jewelry box like Super Deluxe Edition that's going to be kind of crazy expensive but it's also going to be like an heirloom that people can pass down you know to their grandkids it's going to last that long it's made of metal it makes sense and that thing is you know it's like 250 bucks I think right 199 is what we're selling it for but the MSRP after is g to be 300 like yeah yeah it's not cheap to make it limited same at the same time you've sold kind of a lot of them not you know so obviously you were on the right path with that and let's let's Also let's kind of bridge that Gap and talk about ads I know y'all been doing a lot of Facebook ads a lot of just kind of online marketing figuring things out targeting your you know customer Avatar tell me what you've learned from the ad side the marketing side that kind of brings all this stuff together to get people to buy after the campaign and we'll talk about post Kickstarter life in a minute that's a big topic that's going to come up but when it comes to ads what have you been learning what have you been seeing it seems really scary because you like turn the thing on and you don't know why it's working but the fact that it's not working is actually one of the benefits of turning the thing on um I I was talking to somebody the other day and ads ads actually like they're like I don't know what to do and I'm like run a bunch of ads and the ads will tell you what to do that's the thing when you so first off if you know who you're selling to you know where to look you know like we're talk you know we do a lot of meta advertising um my
favorite comment my absolute favorite comment from botney campaign multiple people said what was effectively they must be advertising well of course we're advert always this a business let me you know what okay if you look outside my house you could drive out our front door and it's 40 miles to the next road if you go straight right we are pointed at Wilderness if I walk out my front door and I'm like who wants to buy a game I will be there for my dogs will be wanting attention they won't if I give them the game they'll eat it up but no one's going to buy it of course we're advertising well if you know who you're selling to that makes it easier to figure out who you're advertising to you go in you make custom groups or custom audiences you bring in the people who have bought you use that to make audiences based on their interest too and so and then you know what to show them but you never EXA like exactly what to show them so Amy usually takes like 12 pictures and we look at them and we're like oh hey let's try these four and we put the and this is I'm I'm intentionally not saying this in any scientific manner because you talk to somebody who does advertising it sounds very scientific but it's not it's easy to understand in layman's terms you put up four pictures and you say Facebook go and now it's gotten even easier you don't have to make audiences you can tell Facebook to try and find out audiences which is also pretty smart so we do that too and you say Facebook go and Facebook will be like these two are doing great and you're like cool turn the ones that aren't doing great off put two new pictures in see if those do great and the ads will actually like guide you through the process of figuring out what's working and what's not and the other part of that too even
beyond the ads themselves and you know we work with launch boom and launch boom is so great at this is you will figure out that based on which ads are working and which ones aren't and which audiences you will start to learn if you don't have a real solid fix on like who am I selling this game to the ads will also begin to tell you this is who you're selling the game to like we didn't know I mean you know knowing that our Avatar is Amy we should have known but we did not know that 75% of our customers were going to be women but they are in an industry that is 85% men and so the ads also helped us figure that out you know you start to learn like okay you know when you you see the interactions you see people engage on your ads you know the the eventually we have a VIP group for everybody that signs up for our pre-campaign stuff you start to see the things they're talking about the things that they latch on to their favorite parts of your games and over time if you're paying attention you don't have to come up with this stuff out of the blue it begins to take shape and evolve in front of you and advertising is part of that now I'm sure there's a lot of people out there who are doing their first game they don't have the budget for advertis paid advertising paid advertising is the the method that we understand and know but you can do this on uh online you create an Instagram account you do it for free you see what people are interacting with maybe it's only 10 people somebody once said to us a long time ago for our photography people get so hung up on the the quantity of people that are reacting to what you're doing and they fail to
notice that when one person says this looks amazing that one imagine if somebody walked up to your face and said that you'd be so happy well that's what's happening online and okay well now okay 10 people have reacted to this what do those 10 people like what do they like you know even in little quantities you can begin to understand your Super Fan this way through your advertising through everything you do because it all builds in on itself and then the next time you do advertising you're like okay well these ones did well and oh and these people reacting to it maybe I'll try these two that did do well and I'll try two more that I think would be more targeted at the people that that are really reacting to my product also whenever we creating like our own audiences we like to think outside of the board game audience and we do like people who like Jane Austin Books or people who like art history art history or Cottages botanical gardens like one of the big ones for botany we created um uh botanical gardens around the world there our better we had an audience for Better Homes and Gardens yeah the magazine right and it did incredibly well um and so if you're working on a theme uh if you're working on a cake based theme don't try and advertise just to board gamers and say Hey look it's the same game you've already played a bunch of times and it's not I know there's something unique about your cake based game but don't don't just be like it's another board game and you have 5,000 go find people who are like I love cake I bake all the time and you're like have you ever played a board game about cake and they're like no how do I buy this right that that's what you're looking for yeah and that recently happened with a game from Kurt covert who's been on the show I think his company is smirk and laughter games but
they have this like really cozy book or game with about books yes and they did great it did over a million dollars and I'm pretty sure Kurt was using ads targeted ad Book Lovers people who read not just you know not necessarily people who are Gamers and you don't get you don't get to that level on a game like that uh without reaching out to other audiences like you just don't and so yeah figuring out what the theme of your game is you know is it complexity level appropriate for those people you don't want to have like a you know seriously complicated game because then you run into the issue where maybe they buy it but then they hate it and that's also a problem like yeah you got the money up front cool but they're not going to buy anything else from you and so you you got to think long-term Vision as far as building a company that's another thing I see is a lot of people they want to sell a game that's very different than sell you know than building a company that's two different things you're trying to do shortterm versus longterm and so you know just things to to be aware of there uh all right so ads and marketing and let's let's get into post Kickstarter because I feel like ads play a huge role in that um in general people are more likely to buy at least in my experience during the crowdfunding campaign and it's harder to sell them a game outside of a crowdfunding campaign there's no you found that and that's it right there's no time limit even though there's the pledge manager even though you can late back even though it's kind of superficial like there's G to be time you you're probably gonna have several months where you can back this game but that little countdown man that little C that that timer pushes people to act and so tell me what y'all are doing to sell I mean you've sold you 35,000 games not
all of those are on Kickstart so what are some things you're doing or have found that are working to sell on your website and we'll get into distribution retail stuff in a minute but like just in general selling direct to customers what are you finding it was Jamie STM specifically and I don't remember the exact quote but I read a thing from him that said he likes to make sure that his game is available anywhere that somebody is looking to buy it right as business 101 person has need thing is available where a person is right and so that's that's what we try to do um first I mean step one created a Shopify account put things on Shopify began advertising so people know things we have on Shopify again advertising sounds some people some people especially on YouTube like spit on that word when YouTube is an advertising driven algorithm right absolutely and so we start advertising hey people we have this thing on Shopify would you like to buy it and it turns out people would okay great okay step two then we put our stuff on Amazon we listed on Amazon ourselves so we have control control over it now you know all these people are fighting to get into a limited number of slots at Target Target has like four slots for $60 games right online they have a few more but in the store there's like there's like a there's like four feet of shelf and that's it $60 games you get on Amazon you set up yourself up and you list on Amazon you're Nationwide tomorrow well I mean it takes a few it takes like a week to get your stuff into FBA but you're basically Nationwide very quickly right on Amazon okay cool step two okay now that I have that Foundation of control
maybe it's not the highest volume it's low to medium volume because it's you know because it's just me now I need to find a way to get into distribution because the Distributors are also going out and selling stuff for you you have very low control over that like we have a placement in Barnes & Noble and we think that is super cool that we're in Barnes & Noble what if B what if Barnes & Noble decides to stop selling games completely not just like our game but like games or what if they only sell games that start with the letter A well we didn't make aony we made botney right and so you don't there's a lot of things that are out of your control there and so you have your Baseline of the stuff you do control Amazon and Shopify you add on distribution distribution is hard though because you got there's a lot of games and you got to fight for attention well the easiest thing to do is go find a partner who helps you we use Golden Goose Golden Goose knows a lot of the buyers they have pitches they go out they do stuff for us and so that adds another pillar to our business and then the fourth one is um just local game stores and again this is very different from you know Distributors do sell to local game stores but if you call a local game store and you're like hey I saw you were interested in botney can let me tell you about it let me tell you how to sell it you know let me tell you the key points we think so that when people walk in the store and they're like I'm looking for something interesting and light that my that my mother would play with me or something like that right um we also have lots of like florist and Botanical Gardens and we're the only game in their stores I mean you want to talk about a lack of competition somebody walks into the store they see they see flowers wall to wall and they they only going to pick like one or two flowers but they see one board game and nothing else like what is that right it's the same thing we're talking about with finding other audiences and if you build those like I
find a lot of people are afraid of that road map after Kickstarter like what am I going to do with my business I don't know where to sell those are the four things you need to do and Shopify you can have a Shopify site in a half hour right you can be a business in a half hour and if you don't know how to advertise on Facebook Shopify even has a button that says let us advertise this on Facebook and you click it and you click a few more times and you connect it to and you're on you're on the way is it as efficient as it could be maybe not but but the barrier to entry is so low you are 100% in control of your own destiny there and then when you start doing that stuff the the the rest of the success begins to follow as you build on top of that we also advertise on Amazon too yeah but yeah sponsored ads on Amazon but even that that's you know okay but then here boy we're going back to math again you got to be careful about the percentage you spend of your you know because you're always making sure you have that margin right and so like we're when we're when we're advertising for Shopify sales we're looking at a blended row as of like two to 4X depending on what time of year it is but and then that's a blended row as compared to all our sales of maybe like like uh 20x right and so again it's all about that budgeting making sure you're not spending too much if you spend any time on board game wire or icv2 or you know any other of the board game news sites once a month you're going to see this business is going under this business is going under these these problems that's happening because because they got ahead of their skis and they're spending more money than they're making so if you take away one thing from this whole podcast today if you made
$10 spend spend less than $10 yes there you go Dusty's wisdom in your nutshell what's something I hear you say all the time and it's just I don't know if it's like tattooed on your your shoulder blades or if it's like in a big mural on your house wall there but it's you're not allowed to lose money you yeah if I blink fast enough it's on the back of my eyelids yeah yeah that's it man you're not allowed to lose money and when you're not allowed to lose money you change your behavior you know like yeah you do not have permission to lose money period exactly if I finally have $5 to my name I can't go get $6 worth of gas they won't sell it to me they like no you have $5 in cash we'll give you $5 a gas that's how it works but unfortunately with crowdfunding you get so much money upfront that it's easy to get ahead of yourself and not understand the math not even do the math and lose sight of how much you're spending and then all of a sudden you can't pay the Fulfillment company and now they're just going to hold on to your games until you can pay and then backers are just waiting you know indefinitely worse not that that's ever happened we we haven't we have known of people who cannot pay their taxes when you cannot pay your Fulfillment company that makes board game wire and it makes a lot of noise and it hurts your business when you cannot pay your taxes the government does worse things than complain about you on Reddit right yeah they'll reach into your bank account man yeah I had a had a friend he wasn't let's he was behind on his student loan payments or something and he you know went and did his taxes H&R Block and they're like oh yeah you're going to get $2,000 back for your taxes he's like cool and got so excited and then
whenever the tax money came in the government was like thank you very much and they just took that tax check right into their system they said that's gonna go towards the loans that you owe us it's like he was like I didn't know the government could do that I'm like I didn't know it either but I'm not surprised they're gonna get their money oh yeah they yeah we uh the way we look at it this is a good life after Kickstarter thing when the kickstarter ends we do not spend any of that Kickstarter money that is not related to making the game like finish your yeah completed and delivered to backers once it's delivered to backers that money's free you can go buy all the Warhammer you want I mean okay let's let me play devil's advocate here and say if you have a great Kickstarter campaign treat yourself for a little you may go and buy yourself one $200 box of Warhammer okay you can do that you did a good job you treat yourself and and some ice cream you know get Amy some ice cream okay we're good let Amy buy something some nice jewelry or something like a fun little book or something yeah good but then don't touch it the rest of it does not get touched until it's like super wanted a swimming pool after boty and we're like that's not happening yeah we do not have a pool right because because the ship has to go around Africa because I was off by 50 Cents on shipping rates for 15,000 people that's $7,500 all those little things are where people get in trouble we didn't you know we do not have any employees we're about to bring Amy's sister on part-time right at the at the size we're operating we
use contractors the burn rate is low if next month I find out that all of my games spontaneously combusted and I have nothing to sell I email my contractors hey guys we're GNA need pause for a few months I don't have anything to sell right and we also have to um save money for the next print run we we don't want to be on the kickstarter treadmill yeah don't run that next Kickstarter to fund your last Kickstarter or to fund the next you know print run we're actually using Kickstarter now more as like a forecasting how well does this product sell how many should we print next time yeah all the problems are the same all the problems about like where does food come from like you got you still got to have money to buy food don't spend all your money until once the product's in the consumer's hands then you're safe because you know you did it right they got it you can spend some money and going back to the whole you know if it takes you a long long time to deliver and you start increasing your overhead you know that's what happened to a lot of these companies have gone under that they rented they started renting office space and they started hiring all these other people and they right they did all sorts of stuff and you're like wait a minute are you really doing the math and are you doing the math with some buffer in there in case you do have to go around Africa in case you did make a mistake that's 50 cents per backer like is that buffer zone big enough to cover the potential losses that anyway you start having some interesting kind of math problems there and because it took you a long time to deliver you didn't the the failure is a lagging
indicator right like you actually failed six months ago but you don't realize it until oh crap we can't pay the Fulfillment company and now they're just holding on to our games and our backers are giving us you know negative comments on a daily basis about where's my stuff and now what do we do well you actually are you figuring out taxes for for 26 and 27 it is 25 and and we are paying our taxes for botney in 23 next month because of theer yeah because of cruel based accounting and deferred deferred revenue and expenditure and because we didn't deliver until the next calendar year yeah danger zone for sure yeah absolutely absolutely and especially you know if that's a big number a million dollars now you know you didn't make a full m you know it's not like you get all of that money Kickstarter takes their like there's lots of cuts that come out of that percent yeah yeah still a large number yeah right there's still a large number that the government's looking at and they're like hey you owe us a big chunk of that and now we you know got to figure that out and so yeah just being smart and just doing math and unfortunately a lot of people that get into game publishing are creative types and not necessarily business types they don't necessarily have the math Wizardry and they got to work a little harder or hire it out or talk to their friend Dusty that's you know and that's okay if you have a friend who does do math pay him 20 bucks an hour take him you know to get some pizza find somebody um I I can't remember if we talked about this last time we were on or not but we ascribed to this theory of what's called wealth Dynamics and it's know what you're good at you do that find everybody else to do other things for you Amy's good at creating I'm good at
running this giant system this engine right not good at sales we find people to help us do sales not good at marketing we find people to help us do marketing um if and and but number one is are you good at math if you are not good at math find a way to find someone who is good at math because yeah like I know I couldn't run the business she could do it I make the pr no I make the pretty things Dusty runs the business yeah right which is such a a amazing thing to have in the same house and not have to worry about you know paying a salary for something like it's great to be in that together but if you don't have you know if you haven't married uh as well we'll say then you're gonna have to go out and find somebody else and that's okay too and just kind of work your way into that and unfortunately a lot of times companies get too much too fast and it's the kiss of death it is catastrophic success where you know they didn't they really didn't need to make a million dollars like that's not a good thing they really needed this first campaign to make $30,000 but they made a million uh oh like that's not good because they didn't have the infu they didn't have the foundation and understanding and now they and now instead of failing on a campaign with 500 backers they're going to make mistakes and fail on a campaign with 15,000 backers oh that's a different thing now luckily you had a lot of business understanding from previously running businesses and being an entrepreneur and making mistakes and other businesses and other industries that you were able to take all that knowledge forward into the board game space and hopefully not make nearly as many as You' made in the past as you were kind of you know falling in those holes so I think that's another thing is people just don't necessar realize the
the foundation that somebody has going into something yeah and you make a really good point there that so one thing we do is our plans are scalable 100% scalable somebody asked me the other day what's my goal for Artistry I said my goal is $188,000 they're like but you already made $150,000 this was yesterday and I said yes my goal is $118,000 maybe I'll be pleasantly surprised at the end of this campaign right the plan is the same and I think one place that people get into trouble is they see they made a ton of money but they don't treat it like it's because the math is more or less the same now you got mqs you got you know the the your your total investment as a percentage of as percentage of the of the revenue begins to decrease if you spent $10,000 on Art and you made $10,000 ver you made $100,000 but effectively the math does not change because a lot of it is must deliver product must Freight product must ship to backer and that stuff is the same whether you have a 100 backers I mean again there's some levels of efficiency here but effectively it is the same whether you have a 100 backers or 15,000 backers and so luckily we had already been thinking that way for botney and if Artistry has if Artistry stops today we're golden if Artistry does 10 times what it's going to do today we're still golden if Artistry does 200 times what it does today will not matter we are still golden because take panda a little longer to manufacture yeah it might take a little longer to manufacture and it might take a little longer we might have to use multiple fulfillment centers okay but that's the the argument is still the
same that the scale the math the way I treat the math you know when it comes to budgeting the budgets are the same it takes you know Ford has the same problem that your local store your local grocery store has you just add a bunch of zeros but the zeros are added to everything and so the scale stays the same and the reason that Ford is still in business is because they don't spend more than they make and your local grocery store doesn't spend more than it makes and if you walk downtown in your local town and there's somebody with a small business there selling purses and shoes they do not spend more money than they make and it's the same for us even though we're kind of in this crazy industry where it's a bunch of small businesses romping around Target and playing big business if you think about pro athletes and how many of them have made multi multi multi-millions of dollars and then I think on average I think it's the NFL and on average NFL player is bankrupt in seven years insane right well to your point this because people are people and if someone comes out of a a poor background like me personally I came out of you know my parents were divorced and it was my mom and I and you know we were on food stamps and like I didn't learn how to budget like we were living paycheck to paycheck and I was working uh part-time and like all the money I was making went right into rent and groceries and so like I never learned how to save how to invest how to budget I didn't learn any of that because my parents didn't have that information either nobody taught them and their parents didn't know like everybody was just kind of living paycheck to paycheck because that's what you did and so if
you were to give me a million dollars you know back then it would have been gone in a fairly short amount of time because I couldn't handle yeah right I couldn't handle a100 so what in the world makes me think I could have handled a million like it would just it made would have taken me a little longer to go broke but it still would have happened just because I didn't have that skill set and it wasn't until I was working at a church and that we had this guy that had retired from AT&T is like a vice president AT&T he came in and he became my boss at the church and he was like hey do you know anything about investing I was like no he goes okay let me show you and because of him right I started investing in mutual funds I started understanding budgeting I got out of debt completely I paid off everything because I because now I had somebody to kind of show me the way and thank God for him um because who knows you know it would have take I like to think YouTube and and I would have be able to learn it and kind of read some books and figure it out but it was having somebody come along beside me and go here's a here's B here's C here's D here's how to go from a to d and it's not sexy it's a lot of small stuff and it's a lot of really basic ad like addition and subtraction you know with my kids my my son came to me yesterday and um he wanted this glow-in-the-dark football and it's a really cool football but it's like $29 on Amazon he's like I want to buy this I was like that's great man how much money you got he goes well none I was like well that's that's a problem see when you have none that's not 29 and he's like yeah but I want it I go I understand that and going to have to work out a plan for you to you know go out here and pick some weeds and do some work around the house and you know we can earn $3 here and $5 there and you know maybe here in a week or two you'll have 29 and then you can go on Amazon
and we can buy it he's like oh man and we're gonna see we're gonna see how much he wants that football because I'm not just gonna buy it you the market yeah the market your own home Market will tell you if the football is in demand right our kids when Ronan was about two I I got on Amazon and I bought a like a whole spindle of uh Carnival tickets and whenever you do something like good like a chore or you know hold still while when he was that young it was like a fight to get him to brush his teeth right he would earn a ticket and then then he comes to Mommy and Daddy and we and the store is open and you know we we have a few things that we maybe snagged on Amazon when they're on sale and he buys them and the kids buy them and today I bought they it's educational toy it's snap circuits that we have I bought some of those they're not expensive and he's coming to me he's like hey so I've saved up 300 tickets well 300 tickets is like $150 this kid has saved up and I'm like well okay well I got like $140 or 140 tickets were the snap circuits here and it's like a two to1 exchange rate so it's like 70 bucks were the snap circuits and it took him months to earn that many tickets and I'm like they just got here you want them and he goes how many tickets are they he doesn't even say can I have it he says how many tickets are they and he knows what he did to earn those tickets poppy is Poppy's five she knows what she did to earn those tickets and I'm like if if nothing else I mean we have no cash like hardly any cash in this house in the in the world of credit cards and digital whatever they understand the act of I did thing I got thing I trade thing for thing right and that's all I have I
can't pay more than I have well there's no loans yeah yeah exactly is closed yeah ain't no credit card you know around here that's come on now um I'm like go pick some more weeds outside yeah they they yeah there's too much weeds in the gravel go pick them out um when I was I think I was 13 I wanted to I really wanted to be a skater like so bad well the problem with that is I live in the country there is nowhere it's Chip seal roads at best and gravel for most of them you there's nowhere to skate within six miles of my house and so I bought a skateboard and I sort of Rod it around the inside of the barn which is not an easy thing to do when a Barn's full of hay and I was like huh and then one of my friends who did live in town was like oh I really want to buy a skateboard and I'm like well I have one for sale and he goes how much and I had paid $99 for the skateboard and I sold it to him for 110 and that from that moment on I was like I get this I understand how this works you provide a a product or a service and you sell it for more than you paid for it and now you're in business right like so yeah I think it's just if we're you know condensing all that down it's whatever you have you know be so this is a quote from Dave Ramsey Dave Ramsey runs his business and he does all kinds of stuff about finance and getting out of debt but be humble and afraid right so I'm I'm looking at the numbers and I'm like okay Artistry is at 220,000 um great my goal was 18,000 great I have X amount of dollars to work with I will
do X number of things okay I'm looking far into the future how do I reprint this again when it sells out right and it's going to sell out because I'm going to make it sell out I'm G to find the people who want to buy it and make it and so everything I do it's never like oh yea it's like okay where can this go wrong today like where can this go wrong a month from now a year from now where you know how do I make sure we have enough money to handle whatever comes next so I'm reminded like people talk about murph's law anything that can go wrong will go wrong but they missed the other half of that actual quote and it's basically so plan accordingly yes he's not saying oh bad things are going to happen be depressed about it he's saying bad things are probably going to happen so make sure you plan ahead and are prepared for when it does and with shipping internationally with political craziness with 2020 Dusty I don't know if you know this John Cena just became a bad guy in 202 20 years later right he turns heel nope yeah he he denounced make a wish you know um Kathleen Kennedy also just resigned at at Star Wars so like 2025 is just like wild right now where things are happening and so you know plan ahead plan accordingly U be prepared for what could happen don't Doom and Gloom it you don't don't be like oh life sucks and like no have a plan and have ideas in place oh I was gonna say I have a very short story that probably not relatable to most people listening but Amy and I wouldn't you wouldn't know it given our story about living the country making pretty things but Amy and I listen to metal and one of my favorite bands is Code Orange and code orange has a song
where you don't need to care about the rest of the song but the point of this song is that the obstacle is the only way and I remember listening to that and like a week later we're driving up the highway to my dad's house and the and the truck breaks and I look at Amy and I go the obstacle is the only way like it was the most Zen moment of my entire life when I realized you know I could be really angry and screaming and have the hood open and and there's smoke and I'm like really angry that my truck is broken or I can call my dad have him come pick me up get a tow truck and go eat dinner at my dad's house and move on with my life right and that's business right there you know you can kick and scream but the thing that is happening to you is going to happen to you no matter how much you kick and scream right everybody is going to have a certain amount of bad luck happen to them every single year and you can just chalk it up like hey here's one of my bad luck opportunities for this year and look at it as a problem to be solved as opposed to something to lose your mind about like no this is just a problem that has a solution it is solvable and we just got to figure it out and it maybe it might be expensive it might take a lot of time effort energy whatever but we're going to figure it out we're going to get through it and yeah that's just a better way to go but let's let's keep talking about the whole like planning ahead you mentioned forcasting earlier tell me your formula tell me your process for kind of figuring out how many games to print how many like what's our run rate how many we're selling per month and when do I need to do a reprint give me your whole like system for knowing the forecast of Any Given title okay so this is going to be this is some this is deep math also it's hard to forecast when you don't have when you have no sales that's
also really tough yeah how do I distill this easily okay whoever's listening I'm just going to start I'm GNA start rambling math and just know that you might have you know don't be afraid to email me info doom.com I'm happy to write these formulas down for you it's Dux D not DS D yeah quack there's a there's an outtake from Good Time Society where they're working on the game and they're like the newest from ducks ducks quack like so we're walking around the office going quack quack quack um okay so forecasting is like looking in a crystal ball and the lady that's running the tarot shop down the road is going to be just as good at it as you are and so it's more about looking at everything that happened before and trying to come up with as many ways to use that to guess what might happen in the future and you're creating a projection cone for yourself when you do and so we you can do this in spreadsheets you can do this on a napkin I I have one of our other businesses actually writes like a whole uh Marketing System for travel organizations I took that and started sort of cutting it to pieces for my own use but basically what you do is you look at what happened and guess what's going to happen so the ways to do that that we use are we look at our sales for the last four months and we look at them by Channel or we look at them just in general and we look at them by product and we look at them across all products big old spreadsheet and we say and so the simple version is I sold 100 units a month for the last four months so 400
units cross the First full month let's say that you sold 200 the first month 50 the next month 50 the month after that and 100 what did I just get to I got to 400 okay good I'm doing math live not a great planer dangerous but it averages out to 400 over the last four months 100 a month and you say to yourself okay what's it going to look like if everything stays the same over the last four months now was the last four months Q4 was the last four months did it include February you know things are going to change but just what if and you say well then if I sell 100 units a month in the next 12 months I'll sell 1,200 units and if you look at your stock and you're like I only have a th000 units then you can use that model to say I'm going to run out in 10 months okay how long does it take you to get stock well it takes about four and a half to six months to get my stock well then you should probably think about placing a reorder at your manufacturer in the next three months OKAY model one model two we do the exact same thing but on a 12month basis how do I do this over 12 months now like Amy said this is hard if you're two months out of Kickstarter and you've only seen two months worth of sales and you got launch data but it's in exact science anyway so it it might seem like it's bad but it's you know it's not any better with years of data because you never know do the same thing for 12 months okay for the sake of Simplicity of the example I sold 1,200 units over the last 12 months again 100 units a month let's say that over the last 12 months I only sold 600 units so my four-month sell rate is 100 units a month and my 12 month sell rate is 50 units a month well now I have a
projection cone because if I have a thousand units of stock one of them says I'm going to run out in 10 months and one of them says I'm going to run out in 20 months and you can kind of look at that cone and say okay I have these two models and I'm probably going to run out somewhere in the next 10 to 20 months then we add a third model in here because two wasn't enough those two were simple the third one I look at what have lifetime our average sales been in January and what percentage of our total sales is that let's say that's 10% of my total sales and I do the same for every other month and I see that my total sales are only 5% in February I'm I'm totally making these numbers up by the way and that and that for November and ooc and December it's 20% of my total sales in any of year so 40% of my sales are in those months and then I say okay cool what did I do last month well last month with January you sold 100 units those 100 units are 10% of your sales and I can extrapolate forward okay in the next year I'm going to sell a th units and 400 of those units are going to be in November and December and then you can say okay well if that's going to happen and I look at each month then I'm going to run out 11 months from now well now we have a projection cone that has something saying we're running out of 10 something saying we're running out 11 something saying we're going to run out of 20 the crystal ball is slightly less murky than it was before and that in a nutshell is what we're doing right and similar with weather forecasting you're using models to make your best guess you're GNA be off one way or another like the odds of you being exact basically 0% and so I think that's another thing is is people get too caught up with wanting to know and
you're guessing it is an educated guess hopefully but you're still making a guess making a projection and then just Just go with it you know big companies make mistakes Jamie STM printed 10,000 copies of wingspan the firsts 10,000 and then he sold out about 42 seconds to the point where people were bashing him online saying he did it on purpose he's like you did this just to create you know a fomo type deal and to kind of up the it's like yes yes the the publisher intentionally only printed 10,000 even though there was demand for 100,000 because he didn't want to sell 990,000 more games like that I've never met a person in my life that intentionally didn't sell the exact right number of copies that they could have sold well and it's also e it's better to have too few than more like stock is dangerous yeah stock is dangerous so in if if Jamie had two scenarios there that Poss because you're never Andre our friend uh from Golden Goose always likes to say you're never just right you're always too hot or too cold which do you want to be well if I had a choice between be and Jamie stegmar with an extra 100,000 copies of unsellable wingspan or Jamie stemm with 10,000 copies that sold instantly I know which scenario I want I want the one where I didn't waste 100,000 copies right you can always like if your game's going hot you can always Place Another reorder I mean we yeah we reorder two three times a year for botney no problem and so yeah the thing it you can always reprint you can't unprint no you can you can throw them in a landfill so you
don't have to pay ship or storage fees over and over over again every month you can liquidate them even worse because then nobody ever buys your game at full price again yeah exactly kind of strow the value of it Funko with those pops like just throw them in the landfill there's a landfill out there with the most amazing Funko collection you've ever seen in your entire life because the way business is so silly it was more cost- effective for them to take it as a loss and throw it all away as opposed to liquidate it and try to sell it you know for a dollar or five dollar whatever 90% off it was and there's something to be said for our our interesting structure as far as our financial system there where it made more sense to create a million pounds of trash than to try to sell everything at a huge discount yeah anyway that's not for us to solve but yeah I mean you're just you're just guessing and good thing about crowdfunding is it gives you at least a jumping off point to say okay I sold 5,000 copies or 500 copies in crowdfunding and therefore I'm only going to print X now let me get your thoughts on this I am one of those weird Publishers that doesn't concern myself with retail distribution I don't really care at the moment although you and I have had long conversations about how I need to start figuring out how to get you know Amazon and Retail what I'm working on that for later this hopefully but I only print effectively what I sell so if I have a th backers I'm going to print roughly 11 to 1200 copies that way I have extras for anything that gets lost or damaged whatever I can replace I don't worry about printing a whole bunch of extra now in general most people are going to want to you know they had a thousand backers they're going to want to print X number more to be able to
sell those post campaign tell me your system your form yeah for base games we do like 50% more and for expansions is it 20 it's like 20 so there's a couple things here uh Kickstarter is not a representative audience for regular retail it is an audience and it is a crystal ball to look into but I have met people that that they're like hey uh how many do you think I should order I sold a thousand copies on Kickstarter I think I'm GNA order 10,000 copies and I'm like whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa whoa that's not bad that they only sold a thousand that's a thousand people that wanted their game that's amazing if one person wants one of my games I am thrilled right but if only a thousand wanted it either you didn't find your market yet or it's telling you that your Market Niche not kick your Market Niche is not Kickstarter or your Market Niche is smaller than you anticipated right and that's okay there are a very limited number of people on the planet who play insect glaive in Monster Hunter I'm one of them right but that doesn't mean everybody does and that doesn't mean it's bad okay now the what you what we do is we look at Kickstarter and we say and we have a very good example of this we say we're going to order 50% more than what we made as a rule of thumb and the other thing to understand is that people look at when you when you look at expansions you need to be even more conservative when it comes to stock risk because Kickstarter also buys a disproportionately high number of expansions there's and deluxes and deluxes and deluxes both very dangerous
are dangerous yep so what you do is you look at it and you look at the attach rate the attach rate is what percentage of people who own the base game will buy the expansion and mathematically speaking it will never be 100% Ticket to Ride has expansions people love Ticket to Ride has sold what 18 million I can't even remember the number millions of copies right any given one of their expansions has not sold that many because only a percentage of people are going to buy it so with our expansions depending on where the break point is maybe we'll order 20 30% more something like that we'll see how it goes because they sell slower than the base game if you if you run out of expansions you will still sell copies of your base game if you sell out of Base game you will not be selling copies of your expansion and so look at botney and the flo botney we sold 16,000 copies on am or on Kickstarter so we ordered 25 a little aggressive but there was a break point for us at 25 so we jumped up lefl we sold 7,000 copies that's not 16 we bought an extra 3500 copies we just did 50% again now turns out Le floor it looks like it's going to sell out way faster than we thought but that a good problem as opposed to what if we had what if we had just decided we're going to buy 25,000 copies of Le Flo because we sold 25,000 copies of botney we'd be still sitting on copies of the floor they would sell eventually but they'd also be taking up space in a warehouse charging me money every month and so that's the rule of thumb and then when we see how things hit then we see how they sell and then we can do our forecast models that I rattle off to
determine like okay how are we selling when should we buy more how much more should we buy because we only want like 10 to 12 months of stock at any given time what for deluxes are we only going to do like 10 20% more 10 yeah 10 or 20% more for deluxes too because those are also the kind like that jewelry box Edition like I have a chance of getting Artistry in Barnes & Noble I have no chance of getting art that jewelry box Edition at $300 into Barnes & Noble it's not happening right so you gotta be more careful with that stuff too or in Dro or retail in general like game stores probably don't want to try to sell $300 games that's a lot of yeah that's a lot of money stock yeah exactly put 150 into a game that's gonna sit on the shelf that maybe sells maybe doesn't like that's just that's a big ask so you know more than likely you're going to be selling that only through your website and you know hopefully getting ads to people there now if you sell one cool the margin on that probably pretty good but you're just making you know you're making again educated guesses and forecasts based on all the information at hand let's um let's keep talking about this kind of stuff as far as fulfillment you and I have run into some fun challenges recently lots of customer service opportunities lots of uh International fun and games uh lots of oh that company is now bankrupt what does that mean for us uh so tell me what you've been learning fulfillment wise kind of why you're doing what you're doing now right maybe some of the bumps along the road to get here just kind of give me the full picture as far as far as you know botney you delivered how many Bot games of botney have been delivered like by you like you've been the one that have you know submitted the addresses and stuff like that 20,000 okay so 20,000 is
games of like data to figure this out and I've done in the last year 10 to 12,000 14,000 something like that right doing the game every month all of all of my games are international shipments because I ship directly out of China worldwide takes about two weeks to get anywhere you know shipping is very reasonable I the games I do are very small and lightweight so versus botney which you're shipping you know at different fulfillment hubs around you know you got uh one in the UK I believe you've got one well we'll get to one versus how many you've been using uh in the US yeah we multiple in the US now yes right and so you know you and I both have very different perspectives on this but tell me what you're doing now and kind of why you ended up with that model so everything we set up to this point about math and fear and forecasting all of it culminates in shipping shipping is the shipping is the business killer like if I was going to pick one thing that could destroy this business the first thing you know you live on the side of Mount Mount vvus you know volcano is probably probably you know probably the danger point right shipping is the volcano and also people don't understand shipping is expensive like Amazon has like Amazon has yeah ruined everybody ruined the consumer base in general shipping for both price yesing does not take two days like I don't know like that just is ridiculous you know it normally takes three to five depending on how far away and so yeah Amazon is there a reason
there a reason Jeff Bezos is like the second richest man in the world and we're not complaining about it because we do a lot sales on Amazon like as we have been talking I know we have sold stuff on Amazon and we buy a lot of stuff we buy a lot of stuff on Amazon so we have also ruined ourselves so the the key with shipping is to first off you got to find a partner that you really trust and we have had to move through multiple partners where we learned you know we learned okay what are the things we should be asking what are the things we're missing because again like I said I was 50 cents off on botney for how much it was going to cost me and that was $7,500 by the time I was done with 15,000 backers right so you find somebody who will who will Who who you know that you can email and say Here's the numbers I think I'm working with am I right or am I wrong and they will tell you real fast super duper wrong well here where you should be they're kind of guessing too they're guessing too but at least you know what they're going to charge you yeah mostly unless there's a fuel search charger all kinds of stuff this is this is the big place where you know okay you made a game when you made the game it was going to cost you $5,000 to get a 40 foot container from China to Long Beach well now it's going to cost you $112,000 and we had that happen last year with botney our March shipment was $5,000 a container and our September shipment was $112,000 a container and when we shipped leflour in December it was $8,500 a container and so you're dealing with variation variables there's just so much danger if you read all the articles about different companies that have gone
under 90% of them like the place where it all went wrong or started to was shipping now the reason they didn't have money for shipping was other mistakes they made but the straw that broke the camels back was shipping right and so step one find a partner you trust who and go to them and just say here's a box of botney it weighs 5 pound 6 ounces what will it cost me out the door to send this to somebody in California right we ship from Mississippi California is it's a lot of people live in California so it's pretty representative of how far away can I get in the mainland United States for a large amount of my populace and they will come back to you and they will say that's going to cost you $18 and you're like whoa I was going to charge $10 to my backers that's fine but that's 8 that you're subsidizing out of your profit so you got to know that stuff in advance beforehand then the next step is everybody wants to have internet you know Customs friendly shipping in the UK and the EU and Canada and Australia and Namibia and Antarctica right and every one of those hubs you open that costs money like they're not just doing this out of the goodness of their heart they got storage fees it cost you money to get things there it cost more to ship things in a 20- foot container than it does in a 40 foot container just by volume uh if you're shipping to Australia and you're only shipping five pallets of stuff that's less than truckload less than container load LCL is the abbreviation for that they will now you're paying $4 a unit to land it instead of $2 a unit to land it so every one of these shipping locations that we
open I mean we launched Artistry and I am just now like yeah I think we've got enough backers in East Asia that we're going to open an Asian Hub maybe a vfi maybe China division maybe send from China you know I got to start talking to people about that didn't even jump into that until I was sure that we were GNA have enough to support it so this is if you're G to be afraid of something this is it this is this is the place to be afraid because it gets out of hand so fast find someone to help you find someone to check your math do your math 40 times and the biggest advice we can give on this one is charge shipping later if you ever run if you're back a Kickstarter and they sent out the pledge manager a month after the campaign ends and they're not planning to deliver for a year and a half and you pay them they have guessed at best what it's going to cost and whatever they charge you will not be enough like prices go up period death taxes and prices will increase are the only certain things in life right and so that I mean that's that's shipping in a nutshell yes I mean that's it again we're back to math we're back to making the best educated guests that you can um there's a little bit of nuance in there because you know people don't want to pay $20 for a game and $15 for shipping again we can blame Amazon but I mean that's just kind of human nature when it it just doesn't feel right that's kind of like when you go to a game store and you pick up a box and you feel how heavy it is like literal weight you're like hm does this line up to the MSRP is this and it has nothing to do with the game or the gameplay it's just like a a caveman brain thing well the same thing with shipping prices versus like the ratio of of shipping price to cost of the game
and so some of that you know you might need to just kind of put inside of the game costs you know instead of charging 19 you charge 24 and you're just know going in that five of that is actually just part of the shipping right that's just you're building the math all in there together it's just more of a a a perspective thing when it comes to backers but yeah definitely something just to again do a lot a lot of math on and get somebody help you um you know before we hit record you were mentioning you ran into an issue with I think it was a Fulfillment company that they ended up taking a massive percentage of the sales that they did for you and so you sold a whole bunch of games but still lost money so tell me kind of what happened with that you know we didn't got to mention anybody by name necessarily I'm not trying to drag anybody online or anything but um tell me what happened and maybe some things that other people should should just be aware of when it comes to this kind of thing so they don't run into the same situation I'm going to spoil the moral of the story before I tell the story but again it's always the it's in the math and it's in the fine details and this was fine print this was a this was a missed sentence on my part in an email that was one of 50 and if I had caught this so sh shame on them for not having made sure that I understood this shame on me for having been busy that day and and shot through the email as fast as I could we had a company that was handling that was make was going to have a presence for botney at ukge I sent a 100 copies there and I paid the company all of what I thought was going to be paid to them which was to run the booth
handle the sales and run a demo for me and that the rest of it and that that was and that was a and I went through and I said okay that's X if I sell all these copies 100 copies of these it'll be $6,000 and the $2,400 I'm paying for this minus the landed cost you know I was walking away with like a like a 30 40% margin on the show at that and I thought actually I think it was it was 39% was the exact number of margin I was having we like to aim for 40% margin shows are expensive shows are ridiculously expensive and very few people ever walk away breaking even all the rest of them lose money if you find out somebody made money on a show boy put them on this podcast right because it's just not a lucrative thing to do so we wanted a presence there we wanted to do some use it for advertising and I wanted what and I was going to walk away with 40% profit and I'm like great that's really cool well I missed in the email that in addition to all those things in addition to paying for the booth and in addition to paying for the other stuff and paying for the demo and paying for the shipping and having paid the landed cost just to get the stuff into the UK they were also taking a 40% Consignment of the sale which now I look back on it makes absolutely no sense to me because I also paid them to do all the other stuff to just have it there and so by the time I was done I had lost $90 on what should have been if I had just sold it in regular retail a profit of $3,600 and that's a big difference from one number from one little error and and
I even sent them and I you know I'm pretty pretty nice guy I even fired off a nastygram with a pile of math that said that ended with why wasn't this in the contract and if I had known this do you think I would have made this decision to lose $90 on ukge and what I got back was here's your invoice okay time for a new shipping partner yep exactly what that meant man it sounds like you and I are in the wrong business like we need to be selling shovels like the the California Gold Rush like the only people that made money where people selling shovels and buckets the bars all this all the saloons yeah and all the gold rush towns here yes it sounds like that kind of situation where they're the ones selling the shovels and making and you're just losing you know like 40% on top of everything else it seems like it should be an either or thing we're either going to charge you 40% and you don't have to pay anything else just send us stuff or you're going to pay all these extra costs and then you're going to make what what you make like it's almost it's almost like a salesperson making a big salary and commission it's like hold on like those things usually kind of offset each other and taking a yeah and not just the commission but also taking a percentage of your earnings yeah exactly this just seems like you're double triple dipping here and like maybe that shouldn't be the case and so while that individual story might be like very specific to that scenario the key is that again we're working in a we're working in an environment here most the funny thing is most game companies in this industry are not any different from most of the companies we
work with in the wedding industry as wedding photographers small businesses doing their small business thing the difference is if if the DJ screws up the wedding there's like a hundred people that know about it right and but if you screw up your Kickstarter there are thousands upon thousands of people who know about that and it will live with you all the way through to the next Kickstarter to the point where some people start a new company name because all they did was mess up shipping and their company is so irreparably damaged that it cannot continue on the the consequences get out of hand fast right but even those people that you know come back with a different company name backers find out and they post in the comments hey this is just that I mean it still follows you around and you know sometimes that that's a good thing because people you know companies screwed backers over like they did really did take the money that that does happen um but not always and it's just kind of unfortunate sometimes you know bankrupted a lot of people just because the containers went from like you said 5,000 all of a sudden to 40,000 a container and like they you know sometimes no matter how much you plan and project and forecast sometimes life just is what it is and there nothing you could do about it like it's just you're going to go down unless you had reserves of substantial amounts or you just delayed like I I just delayed stuff I I went to backers I was like look I could ship it now I can ship a game now and I will bankrupt my company and no longer exist or I can wait a little while until these prices come back down and I'll ship it as soon as I can and some people were annoyed by that and I I I don't I don't
mean this disrespectfully I didn't care because the my company and its existence was more important than getting a game to you a couple months earlier it just you know and so you just have to make those decisions sometimes and something you can do in those scenarios too is if if you so there's a fine line to walk here because one of the things that drives me nuts is when and I'm sure everybody listening has backed to Kickstarter that has done this where they have like basically like a like like a sit down by the fire and really come clean kind of moment and they want to tell you all the details of every little thing that's going wrong we don't tell I mean we have had so with laflor we had a lot of shipping errors I mean a lot of shipping errors and by sheer force of customer service we have got we're still making sure everybody gets their stuff and the funny thing is is when somebody has a shipping error even though it's your fault if you fix it for them they are a customer for life right you provided them a subpar service and they are more loyal to you because you took care of them than if you had just done it right the first time right but we had some problems with our fulfillment center they got some things going on related to bankruptcy you know time and date this you'll figure out what I'm talking about and it's not the people's fault there's a whole lot of different forces that are pushing here but it was still somebody asked me how am I doing the other day with all this stuff and I sent them a picture I don't know if you've ever seen Never Ending Story But when a Trey is pulling R taac out of the mud and he goes are you the horse or are you the kid I am I'm like I am the kid and this shipping scenario is the horse in the mud and I am pulling that thing out of this mud right that's just a thing that happens but you got to watch out for that stuff
and get through it and be careful and make sure and and and again if we had come to a scenario but okay so where I was going with this actually let me let me I got stuck on a Never Ending Story when you get into a scenario like that sometimes you just have to go to the backer and say and and I don't mean post poting on Kickstarter because we had you know we had 750 shipping errors we had 5,750 shippings that went fine I don't need to tell those 5,750 people that something went wrong for 750 other people right but each of 750 other people some of them I went to and I'm like hey here's what we're dealing with we came up short on coins in Australia on the metal coins if you'd like to wait a few weeks I can ship them to you there or I can ship them there and have them shipped to you and it'll come through your local post office but if you don't mind I would like to just ship them to you from the US free of charge you might have to sign a customs document when it gets to you just want you know which would you prefer I'll make either of those things happen for you and 100% of I'm like oh you can ship for the us we'll take care of it when it gets here no big deal and I'm like hey if you have to pay $2 on Customs or whatever let me know I'll refund that two bucks to you and they're like neat sometimes if you just give them the choice you know and so let's say that Kickstarter that for Artistry all of a sudden shipping containers cost $50,000 well the good news is hopefully I'll have enough margin to cover that if I have to but I could go to backers and say okay guys here's the deal containers got weird I can air freight this to to you from China for x amount of dollars or if you don't mind waiting six months we can get it to you at the regular shipping rate we charge you there and that's enough just just
putting them in control and giving them options and saying I will make if I have to drive it to you myself right if Gabe orders a product and I got to drive to Alabama to get it to him I will get it there one way I will lose money on that I will not enjoy that drive across the country but I will get it there absolutely and to your point earlier more than likely that customer was gonna is gonna come back and back again oh for sure I have somebody that I'm dealing with and I was telling you before I don't know what what's going on with where he lives but at all points in the shipping process I have lost eight packages to this guy from three different fulfillment centers companies not just same centers in I don't know what what the deal is Gremlins like Gremlin see his stuff they're like that's my lunch I'm eating that right and this but at this point I cannot believe that the guy doesn't hate us keeps on coming back and he keeps coming back and he's like you guys are the best company I work with and I'm like all we do is screw up your order all the other orders to Italy go fine but his specifically never makes it to him and it's not like it's not like I have a picture of it delivered to his doorstep his current package didn't make it out of England I know he's not in England stealing that package right and he loves us because every time we solve it for him right right any little bumps in the road I'm trying to think of of anything I've run into lately uh I mean going back to the customer service stuff sometimes Ace Ventura delivers the package and there's damages and like that's just the nature
of it you're going to have to replace a certain number of lost and damaged items make sure you're forecasting that into your your numbers as well uh whenever you're sending games to a certain filment center send more than you need you know hopefully you can sell them later but if not you can always just reach out to the Fulfillment company and be like hey if any of your employees want this game give it to them for free you know get rid of the rest and I don't care about that extra 17 copies I'm not trying to you know I'm not going to worry about the loss of 10 15 games or something like that like there's all sorts of things that you just kind of sometimes you just have to eat the cost but you know again just being smart with with how many you're printing how many you're sending other places you talk about losing you know go back to the metal coins thing for a second is that just you made an error on how many metal coin packages needed to go there or did the company added yeah so we we have to make a decision at some point how many coins are we going to send to Australia the Counterpoint to um are we going to ship to us or sorry the the Counterpoint is like okay do I charge shipping right away because some one part of the reason that people charge right after the campaign is because they want to know how many to produce and what to send where right well for us not that many people late pledge not that many people add more stuff I mean people do maybe 20% on on on uh on LEF flor's campaign lots of people added lots of stuff but I was overprinting anyways and I don't mind selling that stock um but at some point I had to make a call I'm sending X number of units to Australia for these coins and people hadn't filled out their pledge manager all the way or they had
and they added based on percentages and then like you know and then like the 50 people in Australia who filled out their pledge manager late who I had accounted for disproportionately large all bought coins and and our fulfillment Center's VR distribution down they're great they they do a very nice job um they just email me they're like hey we have these 17 orders that don't have coins what would you like to do would you like to send more I'm like well I don't really have a market you know for the coins down there I wouldn't mind if we had to send more base games but let me just email the backers and tell them I'll ship it to him from the US and I looked at Amy and I was like that's going to cost us about $400 that we weren't going to have to spend but we knew that there would be costs somewhere in here to do that right that that it's just shipping all over the world we ship botney to 87 countries we ship uh uh laf FL to 69 countries and I think Artistry has already sold in that many countries something is going to happen somewhere and this was the case and so I'm like we're at the point at the end here let's ship them from the US let's take care of our backers okay yeah I lost a little bit of margin on these guys because I had to ship coins from the US but there's just a point where you need to like dig your heels in spend a little bit of the money off your margin and just get everything cleaned up and right because you're never going to guess correctly like all the way through yeah ultimately just do the best you can and again that's the difference between selling a game and building a company when you're building a company these are just the things you do because you're trying to build a community you know a customer base around your company not just around one single product Amy Dusty this has been excellent I think this is a a 90 minute
you know packed full episode and I think a lot of people are going to get a lot of really good information out of this and so anyone listen to this if you're you know trying to get into game publishing or just trying to figure out how to make your Publishing Company bigger and better hopefully hopefully you've gotten a lot of value out of this um this wasn't the plan I didn't ask youall to be on the show because you had a game one kickstar it literally just kind of happened to time up just right but tell me about Artistry tell you know people about the game where they can find it just real real brief you know two-minute overview of that sure uh the Artistry story is the funniest part uh we're working we have another game that we're planning to launch this fall Artistry will be delivered by then but we thought that was going to be the one we launch now and I and I look over my shoulder one day when we we were kind of stuck we weren't really working on it we're trying to get other stuff done for the floor and Amy's working on this game and I'm like what are you doing we are not working on that game she goes just leave me alone I'm just having fun I just wanted give me a minute I I just want to think about something and work on this probably met I bet he was playing Magic and I was like for lunchtime I'll just do the Box yeah it's lunch I'm playing Magic she's working on the box I'm like what are you working on go do something else we're not doing that game next day I look over my shoulder she's working on that game again I'm like what are you doing we are not working on that game we're working on this other one she goes just leave me alone I'm just doing my thing whatever next the next night I walk into the kitchen after we cleaned up dinner and the dining room table she's got parts from all different gra games like spread across the table and I go what are we doing and she goes hear me out I want to tell you about this game idea I have and I'm like well okay oh that's cool oh yeah what if we did this instead of this like 20 minutes later the game was like 90 90 95% done and I said we are working
on this game aren't we she goes we're working on this game well and kind of what's funny is during bot the creation of botony I also had this idea for like making a workshop like they used to do um for for like the Arts and Crafts movement or art newvo he like that's a dumb idea nobody's going to want to do that yeah that sounds really dumb and now I'm like super proud of this game it's super fun I need just to listen to her you want you know about your Super Fan like of course the moment she showed me the art I said oh yeah and the other day she showed me some art she's like what do you think about this art and I was like I could sell that to anybody she's like what about the gameplay I'm like it doesn't matter yet we'll figure that out like it'll be good but but this art I could sell to anybody like let's do it let's make a game about this yeah so Artistry is about having your own art newo studio um getting more Artisans so that's that's one of the big fun parts of it is that as you're as you're going through and you're collecting these tiles and you're building the patterns The Artisans get so you're picking up things in different patterns and each Artisan so like a metal Smith like pulls the different shape and all these different shapes the funny thing is is this is not how we describe it to our backers for our backers we say You're Building your art newo studio and you get all these pretty stuff and you're making jewelry and you're making things and you're Gathering materials right we're telling the story but yeah uh it's a fun one I I mean I mean I'm biased I would never sell a game I didn't think was fun but like it's a really good one yeah that's awesome people can find it right now on Kickstarter wins a campaign close uh it closes on April 3 April 4th something like that that week okay awesome so if you're listening to this right after it comes out you'll have probably a couple weeks to still go check it out and then get it later on
the pledge manager as well well Amy Dusty thank y'all so much for your time really appreciate having you on good luck with the kickstarter good luck with the company just continuing to grow and scale and and do some really cool things I'm excited to continue to watch it and learn from y'all and figure out ways that I can Implement things you're you're doing into my own I have ideas for you yes oh let's keep talking after I turn off this recording because I got some things on but anyway good luck with the campaign and everything else you got going on right now thank you yeah and yep and thank you everyone who's listening to we really appreciate all of you