The Crew: Journey to the Ends of the Earth play and review - One Stop Co-Op Shop
Transcript
Hey everybody, this is Mike with the OneStop Co-op Shop and today I'm showing you the third version of The Crew. The crew journey to the ends of the earth. I was about to say the center of the earth, but nope, they're not doing that. This is more of an Indiana Jones style traveling around the world sort of thing. And a disclaimer that I got a review copy of this one. And if you like the content on the OneTop Co-op shop, consider supporting us through Patreon. You get early access to our videos and exclusive videos every month you can't see anywhere else. You can also listen to our weekly podcast for reviews and design discussions or join the conversation and say hi on our Discord. So, what I'll be doing in this video is doing a little bit of playing of the game. Now, to be very clear, there is no solo mode for the crew. What I'm going to do is I'm going to steal the solo play option from the Lord of the Rings tricktaking game and apply it to the crew. And that has kind of worked for the original crew and even Mission Deep Sea. I don't find it really works with this one much at all, but I'm still going to do it because I thought it might show kind of how the game works a little bit better than just a review, but then I will do a review at the end for my thoughts on the game overall. But again, don't think that the crew has a solo mode. This is not official. I'm just using the rules from Lord of the Rings, and you'll see they don't really work that well for this. Yeah, this time we've got a very small amount of narrative, a huge change from the old ones where they just tell you you're searching for the treasure of Charlemagne, and then you're pretty much just flipping from sheet to sheet uh to see where you go. Additionally, each of these little pages in the book is one stage, but each stage is going to encompass multiple rounds of playing the game. Whereas in the original crew in Deep Sea, each uh stage that you would
go through, each mission could be completed with one play of the cards generally, although if you failed, you might have to repeat it. And how it works, and this is a bit like Jackal and Hyde versus Scotland Yard that I covered before. Uh each turn, the players are going to pick one of the cards on top of one of these task decks, and the card is going to tell them how far it'll move them based on player count. So here, if I had three characters, that card would move my token three spaces. And then this little clock token, I guess I have it upside down. This clock token will move one space after each task. If you don't complete a task, you don't move at all, but the clock will keep moving. And you're trying to get to this little plain space before the clock does. And you're supposed to keep score. The farther ahead you are of the clock. When you finish, you get uh more points. And if the clock gets there before you do, you get points in the wrong direction.
And theoretically, at the end, you're looking at your score. But yes, losing a hand, uh, losing to the clock does not technically derail anything or force you to repeat yourself. You also still have communication tokens to show cards from your hand, but now they can be used by any players. So, if I'm playing three player and we have three communication tokens, one of us could use all three of them if it helped to solve the task. Also, the spaces on the map will sometimes have effects on the hands of cards. Not on this first map, but on other ones that I'll show you. And most importantly, you only have one task card active per round of play. So, it's not like each character is doing their own things or trying to get specific cards. Instead, the task card itself will kind of control everything. Although, again, complications could arise from these. But, like I said, I'm going to be playing the Lord of the Rings solo mode. So, if you haven't seen that game before, how it works is you take the big trump card and you shuffle that in with 15 other cards to form four hands of four cards. So, it's like I'm playing four player, but after each trick is played, each player draws another card from the deck. So, the colors you have and which suits you're out of and not out of is going to change drastically.
Again, this is not really the best way to play. I just wanted to show how the stuff works. But that's what you'll be seeing in this video. But first, we have to pick which task we want to do. We can uh per stage once for each pile take the top card and put it to the side and then it goes to the bottom afterwards if we don't like the values represented. Uh, by the way, this compass one with a three means that it could move us more or less than three because it'll have some sort of condition that we can fulfill multiple times. And those tend to actually be pretty powerful. So, let's start with this one. So, at the top, we've got some negative values. That's going to be our starting score. So, at three player be with us playing solo, four player it's ne5. And then the rest of the task is going to give us a way to add to that score. If we don't get above zero, then we just don't move. It's not like you move backwards. But if you get above zero for each spot you get above, you get to move one. In this one, it says the first trick must contain a one. Oh, this is going to be like impossible with this solo mode unless we get lucky. The second must contain a two. The third must contain a three, etc. The mission ends with the first mistake or after nine tricks plus one for each correct trick. So, with perfect play here at four players, we could get uh what is it? Nine tricks minus five. Four points, four moves. We'll see how it goes. But yeah, with the solo mode and us not having all the cards, this might be just impossible. Oh, never mind. We're off to a pretty good start. This is supposed to show who the guide is that has the four of trumps, which is helicopters, by the way, but it's all the same stuff if you've played The Crew before. There's four colors, one through nine of each suit. There's also the Trump suit, helicopters, one through four of that.
You have to follow if you can. A highest card of the lead color, the lead suit wins. Unless a Trump is in there, then the highest trump wins. All right, so we've got a bunch of ones. We've got a single two, and the two is the sticking point because we only have one of them. We want to be able to lead green or I guess have this player throw off. Now again, this is very different than real play. But sure, they'll play a one and I guess you might as well ditch some ones cuz we know we won't need them. These people can't follow green, so they can kind of do whatever they want. But this player wins with the seven. Okay, now we got to do two. Oh, it just got easier because they got a pink, too. Although they can throw off But let's try to use numbers that we don't need or won't need anymore. So, the pink will let them throw off the one. That's good. And they have to play the six. All right. So, they're in the lead. We're still in the negative. Oh, they they got a three. The luck here is kind of funny. Of course, we also have a three and four trumps, but sure, we can have them play a three of green. They can throw off a three of yellow. Hey, they can throw off a three of blue. And what the hey, this person can trump with a three of helicopters.
That's threes for everybody. All right, the person who trumped, we need to get fours next. So, blue or yellow would be fine. Let's do blue though. Okay. Although, hm. Well, we have more nines. I guess that'll be okay. So, a nine from them. Ditch the two. They got to play the seven. That's not great. But we get the four in. Okay. And tons of fives. But again, I don't want to drain options we might need later. Nobody's got a green. That'll make it easy. So, let's do the five. Uh, they should be safe to trump. Oh, do we have any sixes yet? I don't think we have any sixes. That's worrying. But they can throw off their two. And they can throw off their four. Sure. And they trump. Sorry, I should have kept track of that. Okay, we did get a six of yellow. So, I don't want to play the yellows, though. Here. Oh, we got a six of green as well. So, sure.
Green there. They can throw off a five. All of theirs are low and kind of out of contention now. And they can win with the six. All right. And the last cards have been dealt. They want the six, right? So, seven. We don't want to drain the eights or the nines. They've got eight nine if we lead into pink. So, let's do a seven yellow. They'll win with the eight. Oh, they've got a nine as well. I guess it doesn't really matter. They'll win with a nine. Oh, we might want to get rid of the trump. So, sure. We'll do that. So, we got a seven. And then they'll uh we don't want to lead off with the eight cuz then it would be Well, I guess they could play it off anyway. They'll do the pink. Okay. So, everybody does that. And we get our eight. Then we get our nine. Yes, there's one trick left, but for many of these tasks, you don't have to finish the entire thing. So there, we would have advanced the maximum for that card of four spaces, and the clock would have gone forward one. We would have been able to go again. If we could move three, we'd finish with the clock one, two, three spaces behind us, cuz it still always moves one after you go, which would be a great score to start out.
Now, for special stages, which pop up every three, four, or five stages, you've got very different things going on, and you don't use the tasks at all. In this one, you have to beat three different challenges. And each one has its own special rules. I'll show you the first one. So, for the first challenge, we take the first card, the lead card for each of the first nine tricks, and we put it in this configuration. So, here, then here, third trick, fourth trick, fifth trick, sixth trick, seventh trick, eighth trick, ninth trick. And the key thing is a card must never be played next to the same card type, horizontally or vertically. Card type meaning either their color or the Trump helicopter. See, I'm sure we can do this easily enough. We'll play a pink first and no. Let's throw off like a middling green here. So that lead card, the pink eight goes over here to the first spot.
Now there can't be a pink here or here. All right. So they're still in the lead. Although I'm a little bit worried because all they have is pinks and green. So let's somebody else take the lead here. So we'll play a green and they can win. They got that. And I don't know. Let's throw off blue. Maybe. Now the green three pops over here. Next we're going to this spot. So, we can't have a green. So, sure. We got a bunch of yellows. Um, and actually, I don't mind another pink coming out. So, let's go ahead and do a yellow trick that they'll win. Throw off a green up there. Okay. So, now we've got these. We're going to go down here. So, can't be a yellow. And importantly, if you thought about it, well, you probably figured out is that the final card that goes here will have to be the fifth and final color because you're going to have one, two, three, four there. So, you got to get like a blue here, a pink here, a yellow there, and then a wild there, for example. But that's a lot easier when you can see all the cards. You know what? Let's just get pink out of the way. It's okay that we already had one.
Let's throw off a mix of colors so we have access to a lot of them. So, now we got pink and green. Oh jeez. I guess we got to go with green again, don't we? Cuz I put myself in a bad hand here. So, we'll throw off a green. We really don't need pinks anymore. So, when anybody can throw off in this case, I think we should get rid of those. They've already been in two spots in the grids. We don't really need them. And there we go. And shoot, I'm totally not keeping track of who is in the lead. Uh, did they win? I think they won it with the green nine. By the way, now we're safe. Uh, we could play. No, we can't have another pink because then the center would be impossible. So, let's do a blue and let's have this one win this time to get the uh lead somewhere else. Okay, so now this or this needs to be a yellow and the other one needs to be a wild. So, this can be anything except a blue, but it probably shouldn't be a yellow or wild either. So, a pink or green would be great. Oh, and that would work. Let's go for the green. So, they're going to win it unless they trump. But now, their their colors are pretty terrible. Well, I guess not really terrible. They've got a lot of yellows. Oh, in fact, yeah, they got a lot of yellows and they got a lot of trumps. So, what if they trump this? I'm just trying to think of who's going to lead what. So, they're winning it and they can just throw off a blue or something. Okay, so now they'll lead a yellow. And this last one's going to be pretty easy because really doesn't matter. They can play whatever, they can play whatever, and they're going to trump because then they can lead another trump. And we lock in for that one. So that's an example of the special stages.
The first one is Pompei with five, and it would have two more challenges with different rules, but with the same kind of idea of building these shapes, but there are a bunch of these, and they come in lots of different varieties. And finally, let's jump all the way to stage 10 to show you an example of the more complicated icons. So, some of them are helpful, like these jeeps after the third trick. Each crew member secretly places two of their cards in the middle of the table. They all get shuffled together and then everybody gets two cards back, which I guess actually could be helpful or not. It could just add a little chaos to stuff. You also in a lot of stages have these little broken lines. That means no matter how far you move before you get to the space in front of the broken line, you have to stop right there. So like if here I completed a task that would give me six movement. I would go one, two, and waste the other four, then you could move normally after that. But once you're on these machete spaces, you have to be on the lookout for little machete icons on the cards. And this happens a lot of the time. You'll see like there's a bicycle there, which affects communication during bicycle stages, or the one blue has a little scooter on it. And during scooter stages, whoever has the one blue can trade a card with somebody else. But the machetes are more complicated.
That's why they're on a later stage. In any trick where at least one machete is present, you immediately fail the task if the total value of the trick adds up to a pretty high value. 15 or 16 for three players, 20 or 21 for four, and 25 or 26 for five. So, right now, our danger number is 20 or 21. All right, we've got a six and a three. Let me show you both of them. The three is an interesting one because it has that little one person icon with a question mark in the upper right. And that means kind of like in the old crew editions, only one character, one player is focused on completing this. In this case, they could only win tricks that contain at least one number that's repeated, and they get plus one for each trick without a mistake, but it ends the first time they make a mistake. And then the sixth one, the one I'm going to actually try is no trick may be open with a pink or yellow card. We'll see if we can do that. Probably going to be a bit harder with this fake solo mode.
What was it? Pink or yellow, huh? Yeah, we got a few of those. And we also remember if we have a machete in the trick, one or more. And if the total is 20 or 21. All right, so we got to get a green lead here. Otherwise, we'd have to lead the helicopter or lose immediately. That is a machete they got to follow. So that's seven. And I wanted to throw off some pinks and yellows. Well, if they throw off the eight yellow and they throw off the two pink, that's 17 total. Oh, and that's three out of the seven machetes. There's seven total. So that's good. Ah, crud. They have to leave their uh their four helicopter now. Really, man? All you got is yellows. Yeah, and if they draw another pink or yellow for the next one, we're already done. But again, this is not how you're supposed to play, so don't worry too much about it. All right, so we want to throw away pinks and yellows as much as we can. Let's get rid of another machete. Although that's 15, but then a yellow. Oh, that would make us 21. So, let's do this one. Oh, wait. Never mind. They have to play another uh helicopter anyway. Yes, that's 15. That's fine. But this could No, it's not the end. We have a chance to lead something else. See how they'll play a two. We have no machetes at the moment whatsoever. Let's get them into the lead cuz their blues are certainly a lot safer. Okay, then we can throw off some pinks and yellow for them at least.
Oh, never mind. They're getting into the lead. All right, there is a new machete, so they are pretty safe. I mean, they could lead off their helicopter just to throw even more things. Yeah, honestly, I kind of like that. So, let's get rid of pinks and yellows and no machete, so we don't have to worry about numbers. Okay, there's another helicopter. So, I'd love them to get in the lead, although that's probably not going to happen. Uh, so we got to lead a green or a blue. Let's go for the blue cuz fewer people have it right now. So, they can get rid of more things. Okay. And then the blue was lead and they're winning it, right? See, let's get rid of another yellow, I guess. Okay, it's going to be green. I'd like uh who's a good one to get in the lead after the second green trick. Well, I guess we can see uh in a moment. So, we'll do Well, no, I kind of do have to decide now, don't I? I mean, definitely not them. That's the key thing. I guess them having a helicopter makes them seem like the best option.
So, let's throw off all of our super high ones. And the value should be fine here, right? Uh 17. Yeah, 23. We're already too high. And that's where we end up. Oh, and actually a green unless I use the helicopter. We'll end with them. Then they can lead a blue, which would not work out well for us. What if I lead a blue now and then a green? Ah, it's going to be tough, too. Yeah, this final trick is going to be a challenge, which makes sense cuz again, you're not supposed to play totally randomly like this. I think there's too many of them. I don't think there's any way to do this cuz everybody has two yellows or pinks left. Yeah. All right, we're done. I'll just do one variation of them. I could trump with them. then they could lead their blue, but no matter who it goes to, they have to leave the pink or yellow. So, we would lose. But, of course, if we were playing real style with four actual players, they could have like played a long blue suit early to let people throw off a lot of cards.
It would have been a lot easier to figure out. But that's a taste of how the later stages can affect your card play even while you're dealing with potentially tough tasks. So, with all that out there, how do I feel about this latest version of The Crew? This is kind of a complicated one. When I first played it, I'll be honest, I was kind of thrown off by the new tasks only having one task, the board. As I've played more, I have enjoyed it more, but I'm still a little bit mixed. So, let me try to go through things one by one. Being able to use communication tokens with more than one per player. I think that's fine. The core mechanic of communicating has always been good in the crew. Being able to tell somebody what your highest, lowest, or only card is. And here, I think it works well, too. The core trick taking card play is still interesting. I mean, it's pretty basic stuff, but the tasks do change it up in fun ways. All that stuff is basic crew and it works well here. The two-player mode is also the same where you're dealing out 14 cards with some cards being face up on top of others and as you use those cards, you get to see what's underneath. I've actually played it quite a bit two-player and it still works quite well. It's definitely random. It's definitely swingy because sometimes cards that were key come up or you didn't know that the other player had those cards. But besides that, two-player definitely functions even with the weird tasks and can be a lot of fun. But the new stuff, the new stuff is kind of the sticking point here. First of all, I never thought I would say it, but I kind of missed the narrative. Is that weird? I've said in many reviews of the crew in the past, including in the podcast we've done, that we would often just like kind of skip through the narrative and not read it at all before
each mission. But funnily enough, I've been playing the second crew, Mission Deep Sea, with my kids recently. And there I have been reading the stories and they've enjoyed them and I've kind of learned to enjoy them, too. So having it suddenly go away kind of makes me a little bit sad, which is super unfair because I said for years, ah, the crew shouldn't have the stupid story stuff. And now that they don't have it, I'm like, "Oh, where' the story go?" So yeah, they can win with me apparently. As for the maps, I think they're fun. The first ones don't really feel like they matter very much, but some of the later ones are pretty interesting. Like for the skis, when one card gets played, the seven of blue, two players have to switch hands. So that's pretty exciting and weird. And there are limits on communication. Actually, the fog stages play kind of like the solo mode I was just doing where each player only has a subset of cards in their hand, six or seven here, and they draw one more after each trick. So the board stuff is kind of interesting. It does change things up. I definitely like these little stages in between. I find them to be the most interesting, honestly, even beyond the regular task play. Now, what I don't love about the special stages is that they often require you to pay attention to these icons on the cards because I miss them all the time. I don't see that there's a machete or I'll play the seven of blue, the one that makes a hands switch, and I'll totally miss that there was an icon there. It might just be my own fault, not paying attention enough or my eyesight going bad, but the fact that they are not important in the vast majority of games makes it easy, I think, to ignore them. So, when they suddenly become necessary to pay attention to, it's easy to forget. The actual chase mechanic is fine. It does sometimes have you going for harder or easier tasks. I like all of that because
in later stages there are even like negative terrain places you want to avoid. So you might want to like go farther or less far. As for the actual scoring of who gets there, I mean, it's fine. The one big thing I like about it is that it's a fail forward system because in the original crew, if you failed a task, you would just play it again and play it again until you got bored with the task and just cheated and moved on or until you eventually got it. Here though, you're always going to be doing a new task whether you succeed or fail at it. Even if you fail in one stage, your score justice goes down, you move on to the next one, which at least for my taste, I prefer. I don't really like repeating the same thing over and over. Now, it's definitely not as exciting as Jackekal and Hyde versus Scotland Yard, which again, it's kind of similar to, but that one had much more interesting mechanics with the actual race and how the cards kind of interacted with that. This feels like a bit of an imitation to me and not as good, but you know, at least it's something different. Now, the biggest change are the task cards themselves.
Because in the original Crew, each player would get different task cards and it would tell them different cards they had to grab. In Mission Deep Sea, they went even crazier. You were still picking different task cards, but the combinations were ridiculous. Now, sometimes in a bad way, to be fair. Deep Sea especially could have games where it was just impossible to win or where the tasks kind of comboed together in really odd ways. So, there is a beauty to these tests just being one thing, even if it is a really complicated thing with maybe some extra considerations from the stage you're on. And they did do a good job of making these highly highly different like the ones that can earn you extra points and just I mean you can see there's tons of them and they sometimes have lots of text. I mean, that is a little bit of a negative. They're a bit more confusing than regular tasks, but the variety is good. It's just that it feels like once you've seen a task, you kind of know how to solve it. Some of them are very like straightforward in their tactical thinking. So, while the deck is large, I feel like the replay of this one might not be so great. Whereas, again, in Mission Dec once you get into the later missions, you know, you can have those crazy combos and it's going to be fun no matter what. Also, a big thing is that in the original crew in Mission Dec, you would sometimes in the first, I don't know, four or five missions have hands where it was like super obvious you had already won. You got the stuff really quickly. Hey, everybody, stop playing. Let's shuffle and deal again. here. That can happen way later in the campaign because while yes, things like the machetes and fog and all of that can change up the feel of a hand, still if you get a challenge like this one, the two helicopter must win a trick. Like, okay, who cares? And
unlike the original crew in Mission Deep Sea, you could have this kind of hand come out and just be like a total waste and why do we even spend the time shuffling near the final mission of the entire campaign? So, the pacing and sort of swinginess of the challenge is a little bit weird. Also, while they can be kind of cool, there are a lot of tasks in here that have memory elements, like each player has to draw a card and they have to take that specific card, but there's nothing to kind of show them or you have to secretly select how many tricks you'll take or how many yellow cards you'll take, which can lead to interesting play cuz you're trying to sort of feel out what everybody else is going for. But, I don't love the memory element. I don't love the secret element. You have to like write things down or put it in your phone or take a picture of your cards. so you actually know what you're doing. So yeah, this one is very much a mixed bag for me. It's kind of awkward. There are some cool new ideas. There are some really interesting and unique tasks in here, but it also feels swingier. It feels like the pacing is off a little bit. But I do love that it's fail forward, so it's still fun for me. I mean, I love tricktaking games. It's still The crew, so it is inherently a good time for me and my family. But I would probably rank it third. Mission Deep Sea, I think, is still far and away my favorite one. But honestly, with like kind of the awkward bits of this one, I think I would rather play the original Crew before I would play this one, but it's still going to be in my rotation. I'm not saying I'll get rid of it. Well, I might get rid of it. I'll have to see. So, yeah, I can see this one maybe being a bit more polarizing, but what do I know? Maybe it'll be the favorite game of everyone this year, and I'll just be the outlier.
But anyway, that is The Crew: Journey to the Ends of the Earth. Thanks for watching everybody, and a special thank you to our biggest Patreon supporters, Matt G, Dan, J William F, Steve Ren, Andrew R, and Chris C. We'll see you at the next