Mariposas, Blue Moon Legends, R-Eco, Kodama Forest, Lusitania Ranked and Reviewed
Transcript
hey everybody and welcome to another chairman of the board ranking video this is where I take a look at the last five new toi board games that I played and I rank and review them in order of preference now before I get started on these five games I want to give a shout out to the show's sponsor kenderc who are my go-to online retailer and if you use the link in the show notes or the QR code then you can get 5% off your first order and number five I have Lucitania now this is a small boox card game where you are trying to build up this Army of soldiers and try to equip them with their relevant know Shields and swords and horses um and race to get to a certain amount of points before your opponent reaches that Target now essentially it is a drafting Style game where you're managing this hand of cards um you know swapping them with ones in this communal par you wiping them off using some special abilities that are fairly basic and play cards of a certain suit down once you're committed to a certain suit or color of soldier then you're committed to that you're going to look out all the other players to play that certain suit of cards um but obviously you are on the search for those particular cards your opponents know that you know what your opponent wants and so on um it's very luck dependent and to be honest I was very disappointed by this game I thought it was a bit of a mess I thought it was very it could constantly uh just leave you in stalemate situations where you do
not want any of the cards you just swapping card that you don't want with a card that you don't want until you get a particular card that let you wipe the display and it was very poorly put together I think um and ultimately I just um by the time it got to halfway through the game I just thought you know let's just let's just get this over with just say that we've played it so I definitely would not recommend this one to anybody it's just a pure luck Fest and I doesn't really have any interesting mechanisms at all and um yeah definitely a big big dud for me so um let's call it there that is litania at number five at number four I have blue moon Legends and it was very difficult to put this one in a kind of a ranking order because this is a very well-designed and clever game um but the reason it's low on the list is because I'm pretty sure this game isn't right for me uh so this is a rinus take on a kind of a a fantasy jeweling system uh where you have preset decks of cards which I do like you know I love having these preset arrang decks of cards rather than having to deck build myself and then you are basically playing these cards out these cards have two strength values on them either fire or Earth and you can also kind of bolster your strength by playing these additional booster or support cars to try manipulate the board state to keep kind of head to-head or eye to eye with your opponent because you always want to be playing cards to at least match the
level of your opponent and if you can't you're going to lose the round and then gain access over these dragons which work in this kind of tug of war system and you're trying to get access over all three of these dragons and then score another Point as if you were to gain a fourth so um actually it's very simple mechanically um it is broken down into quite a few phases which to be honest most of the time you could ignore those phases um and there are certainly nuances in the way that these cards interact with each other some of them are a bit more obvious on how you should play them at face value and some of them are a little bit more sneaky a little bit more you know have a few more tricks up their sleeve and a bit more difficult to play and to master now I did play through quite a few decks of these cards to see the differences and yeah I can safely say that while I while I like the way the game works and I like that potential of how the cards interact with each other um I just found that the game play wasn't right for me because um I think this is one of those games that's going to favor a player who prefers to Deep dive into games to get the most out of these cards and to really find those again those synergies between those cards where for me if I'm going to play a game like this I'm going to dip in and out you know maybe some sometimes leaving months in the spaces between playing it and I don't think that's going to be the way you're going to get the most from this game so I can certainly see why players who like these jeweling style games would get a lot from this but still it's not right for my collection at all I just know I'm not
going to go back and revisit it and try all of that content in the box so still objectively a very good game but personally certainly not right for me so that is blue moon Legends at number four at number three I have Kodama Forest this is a polyomino Style game where you are working with each of your neighbors so it has that between two cities mechanism where you are going to score for Your Right board and your left board um and you're trying to score as few points as possible because each round you are drawing um a certain amount of tiles and you're going to place one of these tiles on the right board and one on the left board but you can discuss with your neighbors how to optimally place these so on these boards there are um spaces that have five and T written on them which are positive points which you don't want of course you want to cover up as many fives and tens as you possibly can and there's also kind of preset Kodama space what you cannot overlap and there are also on the tiles kind of halves of these different features so for example there are these like Bamboo Gardens and if you and your opponent combine them with each other or you and yourself on future turns then you get to place additional pieces such as these big pandas that can cover up a lot of space so it's all about trying to keep both sides balance balanced so that you don't fall too far behind and you know make one of your boards drag down the other one um but of course all the other players are trying to do that and try to keep a passive view on what on
what the other players are doing so that they have the lead in terms of scoring the the fewest amount of points now after reading the rule book I thought this game would be far too basic and I thought the placement rules would be far too lenient where in reality that board quickly does fill up because the tiles are fairly big and those Kodamas are placed in very um inconvenient places to stop you placing on top of them but as a Twist on the simple polyomino mechanism this one worked well you know the idea of um you know communicating with your neighbors to optimally place them was was really quite interesting and as a concept you know I've seen that between two cities mechanism work really well and I've seen it fall completely flat and this one I would say it worked pretty damn well so that is Kodama Forest at number three at number two I have marap posis so this is a pretty interesting game about these butterflies and trying to move around this large map collecting resources in order to breed more butterflies I'm trying to achieve goals as you go through the game through these objective cards and but the feature I did like the most is the is that kind of um busting of the heads between those in-game goals with that end game goal of trying to fully upgrade your butterflies and make it back to the start point in order to score obious like a set collection bonus you know the more you get back home the more points you will get uh the card so the game is card driven where all times in the game
you'll have two cards in your hand with the potential to get some bonus booster cards and these cards will dictate how far you can move your butterflies and also how many resources you can collect now actually I think the game works very well mechanically it's a pretty smooth game I think some things are somewhat tacked on through this kind of card set collection but I really did like Simplicity and Elegance of the game I suppose my only nitpick would be that I think the card draw is a little bit too restrictive you know only having two cars in your hand didn't feel like you had enough options at all times I would have liked to seen maybe three cars in your hand just to slightly alleviate that I suppose you could house rule that um but all in all I thought it worked very well again I love that that kind of conflict of how far do I venture out and am I going to leave myself enough time to make it back to the beginning how am I going to most efficiently play these cars to get the exact right resources I need not only to upgrade my butterflies but also to match those with the objectives do I hold on to these resources score the objective and then cash them in or do I get my butterflies upgraded now because they need to be in very particular um specific places in order to upgrade them or to to breed new ones so yeah all of these different moving Parts but heads with each other which creates interesting choices and I really do like that and despite having a lot of options at all times the game didn't feel overwhelming and it still
felt pretty pretty chilled and pretty smooth and a relaxing experience in spite of having all those options so a very nice looking game you know a nice approachable theme and um all in all I can see why this one did quite well so um yeah I've not really got anything negative to say about it apart from maybe again that having an extra card in your hand would be useful but other than that it was certainly a pleasant experience so that is mariposas at number two and finally at number one I have R Eco now this is a Japanese card game that was printed in English a long time ago I believe but it's it's long out of print now um and this one has some really cool uh features that I could see being hugely successful if this game was only more widely accessible so it's kind of a hand management style game where you have uh hand of cars made up of these different kind of um you know uh rubbish essentially or you know trash and you are trying to recycle these trash cards by playing them on these different kind of um columns and then once one of these columns has at least four cards of the same trash type on it then you will pick up the next kind of scoring card the scoring is quite interesting because each time you play a set of the uh of the cards going above the four of the same trash type then the points you get will increase as you go so you don't want to leave your opponents too many opportunities but kind of halfway
through the game one of the cards is negative so you want to try avoid taking that one but the interesting Twist on this game is that when you play any amount of cards on one of these Stacks then you will pick up kind of one of these random cards that have been deposited there from the deck and add that into your hand and if you ever go above five cards I believe in your hand then you will be giving those cards or playing those cards in front of you as negative points so it's all about trying to very finely balance how many cards you playing with how many cards you're picking up and the more cards that are played in front of these um you know recycling plants or these these columns um without scoring the more cards are going to build up in the in the collection Zone where you're going to be adding more cards into your hand so um it can become very painful at times when you're forced to pick up these cards that you definitely do not want um sometimes you're going to be overplaying cars so that you don't have or so you can th out your hand essentially um and just those extra little twists you know trying to manage your hand of cars to keep it below five or five or below know um knowing when to um hold on to cars when to play them and so on it's just a very interesting smooth little card game that's a lot of fun to play u sometimes can be a little bit frustrating but in a good way and yeah all in all this has a lot of kind of Hallmarks of what would be a widely successful game in my opinion because anyone could pick this up and play it and have fun with it um but it still has some interesting decisions to be made
now the version I have is called Aro plus it does come with two variants on the game um I played the one I've just explained which I believe is the original I've not played the new one yet so um you know I've not I've not made up my mind on that one but based purely on the original Aro game this is right at my alley in terms of the card games that I enjoy and this is certainly going to be staying in my collection for um for the foreseeable so I put this just below a recommendation for now only because I've not played it very much at all um and I'm pretty sure with repeated plays this is going to go up into um accommodation so uh I'm pretty sure of that so that is our EO definitely and pick this one up if you have access to um you know Japanese games and you like your card games hand management games this one's quirky but still quite familiar so that's AR EO at number one so there we have it that concludes the video definitely a mixed bag of games here now if you have enjoyed the video please be sure to hit like And subscribe to my channel and check out my other content too but for everybody else I'll see you next time on chairman of the board bye-bye