Brass: Pittsburgh (B+) Final Grade - Kickstarter Critique Clip
Transcript
Overall, I think it's solid, right? I feel like that video I'm not a fan of how long it was and how redundant it was at certain parts, but I understand. And they have one of the few board games in the world where I'd be like, "Yeah, sure. Go with a fancy summertime movie Kickstarter video." Which is like more substance more fla- more sizzle than steak, but they showed the steak really well, too. They spotlighted the components. They showed the basic game play. They did a lot of great stuff on there. They did. I like the video. It's just a bit lengthy. Uh how we push the limits of the metal coins. Watch the iron coin trailer. Iron coins game counter stuff things. Woah! These metal swords for our recent X.
Yeah, that's what I'm talking about. That looks hot. That gets me excited for your 125 bucks. Wow. Yeah. I feel like the organization of the page just shotgun why I should give you 125 dollars component wise about me quickly. Will there be 500 denominations? Sounds like an overkill. I'm assuming there will be an optional add-on. Can these purchase without the game? Oh, this is the the updates about the the coins and whatnot. Cool. Which once again, that's a that's a great thing for a company to have in its back pocket. It's like, "Yeah, we also make we also make coins or dice or pouches or something like that." So, even if a game doesn't go so well, it's like, "Oh yeah, coins always go well." Uh there's this big shift like, I don't know, 6 to 10 years ago it feels like to like try and really make a money on other things aside from board games I feel like in the hobby.
That's what a lot of companies like started to do like those boxes of leftover games. It's like, "Yeah, 60 bucks for the mystery box." Or they started to lean more into dice or pouches or sleeves. That's why. Uh cuz it's just those you know, it's not hard to get an evergreen on a product people actually need or think they need. All right. Uh let's give these comments give this one a grade. By the way, if you enjoy Kickstarter game found coverage, be sure to sign up down below cuz I'm launching a Kickstarter later this year trying to raise $3,000 to cover Gen Con Origins and shoot some stuff there. And if you want to sponsor my channel for a whole year, 3,000 bucks, go for it. That'd be amazing. Uh how Here comes the first stretch goal that I've been locked. It is past 1.5. I assume they'll mainly unlock it. Uh I'm Yeah, honestly, and here's the other thing.
I like how they handled the stretch goals for a couple reasons. First, it makes me want to come back tomorrow. As someone who's not even backing this, I'm curious because their first stretch goal was so good that I really want to see what else you're going to be deluxifying or changing or making nicer. And if you get me 2 days in a row, well, you dang well better bet I'm going to keep going, right? I'm going to keep coming back. And then eventually it's like, "All right, fine. Maybe I'll just Maybe I'll do it. Maybe I'll pull the trigger on this one." And I feel like they've potentially set themselves up with that with how they ran their stretch goals here. I'm going to give them a Make it a third of a point grade bump up on that stretch goal system. I really like how they did that. I think that was really clever because a lot of times we've seen it so many times when companies come out and they hit all their stretch goals really really really really early and they're like, "Yeah, we don't got a lot else going on. It was just way more popular than we expected."
Or people who don't hit them and then it's like, "Oh, we're really really far away from our stretch goals." Yeah, and those are actually going to be in the game no matter what. We were kind of just lying. And so I I really like how they handled this. But, Final Grade Brass Birmingham by Roxley Games. Do I want it? Yes, I do. You told me it was the best board game of all time and this is the spiritual successor. And you showcased your components, you showcased the game, and it looks fun, and you spotlighted all your awards. Main image sucks. I definitely feel like this main image is trash, but do I want it? Yes. Can you do it? Yep, not worried about that. You told me quite frequently about how this is a sequel to the much beloved thing. You showcased all your awards. It's number one game. You led off with that. Great. Good job. Good job. And great job for Gamefound for getting another company come their way. Because they're inevitably going to lose some companies. Like I saw Lucky Duck Games going back to Kickstarter at least at least for this a project that I saw they were launching. It's got like 4,000 people already pre-launch.
Um and then how much is it? It feels bad. Well, it does. Like you're just you like Euro deluxified. I'm just in that 80 80 to 100 range and you're like, "Yeah, it's 125." But it's not 125 cuz you're going to want these coins. You got to have these coins. Uh cuz the coins are not included with this one, right? No. No coins. So, all of a sudden that 125 is now a 185 or 225 if you want to get the coins, which they're really selling hard. But you don't need the coins. Yeah. Okay. So, how much is it? It doesn't feel good. It feels top end Kickstarter reasonable. It feels, yeah, if you're not a huge like brass person, just just wait for Amazon kind of dealio.
Um that being said, this is day one. And with those stretch goals, if they keep banging out spectacular stretch goals like like those look just so good. They could change it. But how much is it doesn't feel good. So, final grade, I'm going to go with a B plus. Lots of quotes, lots of videos, no rule booklet. Yeah, I'm I'm leaning towards a B, but I think I'm going to go a B plus. No, A minus. I think I'm going to go A minus, actually. Cuz you did eventually like yeah, like once you got to actually showcasing the trays and the deluxifications and the cuz yeah, like like those like all these cubes are probably getting deluxeified. Those Those you think those aren't getting deluxeified? And then obviously the cool the coup de gras, I don't know how you say it, is is if you can get the coins deluxeified that'd be hot. Um probably not feasible considering they're 100 bucks unless of course that's all part of their master plan. I'm not insinuating that would be but that would be like a banger. Imagine last 48 hours like oh yeah we hit the stretch goal everybody gets these $100 coins mixed in or the $60 ones and if we can hit another 3 million we get everybody gets the 100 or something crazy like that.
I'm actually excited to see how this campaign goes. I feel like they did a good job max like A minus. Mhm A minus B plus that's where I'm going. No rule booklet pushes me to be plus but I gave them a third of a point to bump up. I'll go to A minus. I'm feeling good today and I do like the first two games. Brass Pittsburgh No I'm going to B plus that probably sucks. Uh let me know in the comments below what's your final grade for Brass Pittsburgh from Roxley Games and if you have a suggestion for an upcoming Kickstarter Game Found project that you'd like me to check out please be sure to drop it in the comments below. Also if you're heading to Origins Game Fair this year be sure to sign up for the math trade cuz it's awesome and they just launched it today. You can sign up and it's it's a lot of fun and I want your games. I'm going to try and get this this is this is this is this is this is There was uh it was it was a good one. Yeah Rails and Sails. This this old Ticket to Ride Rails and Sails like a big deal when it came out and then it just kind of didn't do anything. It was like 100 bucks. No it's still top 100. Yeah I want to get that one. I'll get that one hopefully.
But let me know in the comments below uh something. I don't something or other.