Did I Just Change My Mind About Historic War Board Games?
Transcript
are historic War Games a hobby worth exploring I set out on a mission to find out if you haven't been following this channel you might not know that there's this inside joke of me not enjoying war games hello I'm Yiannis I just played the war game and I'm going to talk about it for three hours and this Yannis is going to edit the video and listen to it twice oh no this sucks and there's definitely something truth to it as the experience I have with historic War Games hasn't been the greatest but I haven't played nearly enough War Games to have my final sa as well as the ones that I have played is a very random crop so maybe a war gaming expert could give me five War Games to try out so I can finally decide are they for me or are they not so here's the deal today is janis's birthday and it's the perfect time to start this challenge Janis is the war gaming expert here and if he can find the right games for me to try out well than just historic war games are not for me how you doing uh great got my son from school happy birthday oh thank you you didn't have I have a small gift for you and it's kind of a challenge thing at my age everything's challenging so you really like war games but you usually are uh saying that you don't have friends that play war games with maybe I'll give you two months time all right two months and five board games five
historic board games that I will play with you all right you can pick whichever ones and you have to change my mind about historic war games so here's the thing you said it's a challenge for me seems like you're going to be the one who's going to have a big challenge well it is kind of your birthday gift you know so it's still going to be a task for you to make sure I change my mind so the viewers will know which five games are really good to try to get into historic war games have fun with buddy the time starts now oh I will oh I will so much have fun so it begins I'm going to janis's place uh and we're going to play two war games today he's going to teach your rules I'm always excited to try out new war games so excited about today but also I don't have too high hopes if I do not change my mind on war games then it might not be the war game's fault it might be giannis's so you know the board games that I have played always felt like they are sacrificing things for it to be historically accurate and it's for me not fun that's why there is this challenge that's why I want to try this genre with the best games Yannis can uh teach me or provide so fingers crossed Yannis changed my opinion with these games
we recently played two War Games didn't we H yes from which only one counts why doesn't the other count because it's not a historic war game and this whole challenge was about historic war games these fantasy deniers the first game we played and that actually counts seara SE gahara the unification of Japan yeah it's actually pretty good thank you uh let's leave it at that it has three really good things right you never have to Play It Again first one I really enjoy the uh pieces your armies are hidden and then turn around these blocks for all you War gamer nerds right there it's called a block war game they're like ah why didn't he say so you are here to be the war gaming expert on me enjoyed the winning condition that you need to kill my general and you never know where he is I was very tactical and was hiding him in the front lines that's ridiculous how did I not so you missed out on him and didn't kill him I didn't hide my general you always knew that it's he's way way way back there running General was a coward just hiding in a corner and not doing anything no no no he was in attack mine was in the front lines fighting winning by the way barely I mean the combat was pretty interesting where you can play these cards which is fine but I think the most interesting part which also brings out the flavor was the Loyalty cards when a battle starts I can take your troops suddenly or maybe you could take mine if I don't I haven't prepared for it it was 3 hours with the rules so 2 and 1 half hours I think I think you can squeeze this into 2 hours for what it is it's a
tiny bit too long this covers whole unification of Japan would you want to unify Japan in 20 minutes would be great that would be a great game this in 20 minutes would be 10 out of 10 and uh this was uh his way how to make sure I play more bad games because he set it up we played it and it turned out it's not a history game so that's a way how he made me play more war games which uh I won't forgive you that's your point of view that it's not a history game you weren't there I hope you will do better next time no you need to do better how disappointed will you be if I win all five games that's the new challenge we have three categories number one is I want to play this again all right you going to say hey Yiannis do you want to play the other one is all right I play it because you want it and the third one is it's not for me this one goes to the middle one right I would definitely play it if you want to it's a really good game I thought but also I think once was enough I'm on my way to the second game night game day rather we're going to play a game that even yanis hasn't played but he's confident that that's going to change my mind vangar a symmetric game where each player plays a faction and you have your own ways to score points and the basic system is that we flip a card and just it tells who goes first and you can decide to to do either an action or the event on the card yeah but if you do stronger actions or the event then next time you kind of skip your turn yeah so
you pretty much will go every other turn again didn't blow my mind but it was definitely fun and what I enjoyed here was the event deck because there were like super strong cool events uh with this historic flavor as well you were playing the uh Del alterate that start out in a super great position and slowly chipped away and I lost miserably cool we were three players and each playing for uh our own good but uh from time to time uh there were some events or something that kind of made us want to work together against you for example yeah the Mongol invasion if in shagi kakara I learned a little bit about the history then in this one I learned a lot also it will go in the middle you scared me there for a second cuz you're like also and I thought it's going to go no no definitely if you would suggest i' definitely would I already did once didn't I are in a board game Camp uh with million people million 35 but million people 35 million people and most importantly amazing people that all are here to play board games and we're taking the time to play one of the board games for the video memo 44 you said it's going to be an amazing game huh stop saying that on camera never said that never said I said it's going to be great game it's number three on our list yeah and you said it's going to be the easiest one this is going to be a Brie cuz I going to be so Snappy so would you say if you haven't ever played any war games then this would be the first one yeah yeah why didn't we start with this
one anyway that's it for the intro in this let's see janis's thoughts after the video jannis doesn't know what's coming I don't oh no I do I do sorry I do his defeat he's defeat oh man on this was the role of the game okay this is it right I have to yes for a second there I thought it's not going and then then that's it that's it all right well that's Memoir 44 uh I loved it I'll be honest I really really loved it it's very simple I'm taking a little pause from board games played tons of them already and most importantly we just played memor 44 and I thought it's really really cool it's really quick Snappy I think it's the best and most polished user experiences if I could say that maybe it's not as epic as Vin Haron or others but uh it's a good starting point I think yeah and then I think you could build up on that this one is the one that's starting to maybe turn my thought so this is where borium Camp takes place absolutely nowhere it's a really cool place to get away from people things and just have time for your friends and play a lot of board games I'd really recommend hosting one of these events if there's none in in your area then you know do it yourself will I ever play a war game after this video you don't know just yet but uh starting to feel like it so this
one's the lightest one of them all but like by a mile I had the blast playing this one was that pun intended cuz you know you're blowing stuff up and you said you had a blast this one I definitely will put uh in this category where I would even suggest you hey could we play this one a bit anyways two more to go and the GR finale will be here I stand the biggest war game you have played as well in but before that the most thematic and thematic war game at least that's what he said comic Commander comic Commander comic Commander comic Commander we played uh Germans and Russians fighting each other this time in the second world war and first thing we noticed that all the people that passed us just saw this paper and thought is this yeah their faces were like one really cool part in this game is that you have this deck of cards and this deck of cards do everything events there it has actions there it has random hex if you need it and it also rolls dice for you so whenever you have to shoot you have to turn over a card well the little caveat is that you taught me the wrong rules yeah I messed one rule up so when you shoot like ordinance weapons like big cannons or mortars what he's trying to say is that you don't have to aim every time so it's uh half as much of rolling we we were very careful with aiming just I didn't I guess get the right taste and for me the taste that I got was uh just too much rolling that's okay we can always try
again we can always try again I totally agree with you about the Thematic feel cuz you definitely can feel you're stuck in a house and then desperately trying to shoot or people are shooting at you and you feel closed in and you definitely have the like feel of a war going on I don't know if you want to feel bad all the time if I run out of the house he can play a card and start shooting at me so you never know it's like should I take the risk should I try to get out of the field the answer is no cuz he shot me all the time oh no I did get once over to the to those woods for me this is a super exciting uh narrative game yes with a lot of random but that adds to the narrative but I agree that it's not the prettiest kid on the Block I guess in the middle I actually actually the fact that you taught me it wrong so makes me think here's a tip for you guys if you play a war game with someone make up a new house Rule and tell you tell them that you didn't play correctly the previous time that's how you can get them to play again all right and now we're down to my number one game of all time not like a war game just period war game game so it's the day it's the day Jan is setting up here I stand and we're going to have a good time the best time he's going to have the best time playing it and we'll see this is the final Judgment Day are war games for me Hest I'm not sure anyways I'm going to play England Henry the 8th yep and we'll try to get
women pregnant yeah uh get through those wives and you think we're joking no we're not see I'm playing the Protestants going to have some religious debates going on freeze let's freeze this moment in time your face and how you look before starting this okay beginning of the day it's actually uh almost 9 uh a.m. let's see how you feel in like 10 hours he's so happy with himself I am I am very happy we had a simpler game we had midlevel games and then we had to go all in in this one this game takes longer than all of these combined to play and also it feels more of a diplomatic game than it does as a war game which I really enjoyed each of you will play as magic powers automans won right England did not win I play that one 16th century Europe where everyone does their own thing pretty much so and a lot of people things like cross over and you're always in somebody else's face and sometimes actually two people can stand up and go outside the room there is a separate phase for that yeah and then they come back smiling you're like oh this is not going to go for well for me both of them are your neighbors so you know that uh things are going to go down if you're playing this one I'll be sad if you don't invite me cuz wow it's an experience definitely it's it's a game that is not that much about hey how you will win or move your armies it's an experience what's going to happen how history is going to change and it's going to be random it is going
to be random I think this one is the most random of them all and also getting through the little book took as much time as almost playing it so it's a difficult one but definitely going in this collection which I would even suggest uh hey you know what let's play this is by far the lightest and shortest yeah and this is by far the longest and heaviest these two surprised me cool history I learned a lot but this I already have played this with different events but I'm super happy that you got finally oh I did I'm like I hadn't played this for 10 years they still hold up I still love them and can't wait to play them again if we do another video which game should have given to Yiannis to try to convert him to this side of the hobby maybe I picked the wrong ones maybe I should have picked something else so what are the end results are historic War Games a hobby worth exploring definitely yes in these five months I learned about the history of India I learned about history of Japan I learned about 16th century as well as the second world war all of this in just five plays and I'm definitely much smarter than I was before I do enjoy some mechanisms more than others and not all games will be hits and not all games I will play this for the second time but I definitely feel like it was worth playing all of them at least once thank you for coming on the journey with me we'll see you next week all right thank you for watching consider supporting us you guys are great see you next time bye