Do Board Game RULES Actually RULE? - Do's and Don'ts!
Transcript
someone who's a stickler for the rules or maybe you're someone who's been waiting for a board game simply to open up the rule book to see that it looks like it's been written in mumbo jumbo well you're not alone in this case I've played many board games and I've often still feel those same feelings that you do right to this very moment and often those can be really big hurdles for allowing us to enjoy enjoy a board game and fully immerse ourselves in the experience in this video we're going to be talking about my dos and don'ts for exploring rules to some of our favorite board games hi my name's Danny I'm an aid modern Australian board gamer who loves sharing my passion for this hobby with you my friends and my family let's get this video started hey Danny I think I'm going to head to bed now it's been a long day good night see you tomorrow don't let the board game bed bugs bite uh Danny I thought you said you were tired it really helps me to get to sleep the inspiration for this video actually came from my husband which is probably the person I play board games with the most I often try and reel him in on a Sunday morning to play two or three heavy Heroes and he kind of tries to convince me that you know what we should really only play one sometimes I try and get two out of him but you know life gets in the way we've got other things going on and sometimes we just
often sometimes there are weekends that go by where we don't even get to play a board game sad face but you know what one of the biggest hurdles I found is actually just doing the rules teach or getting through the rules or reading the rules there's a lot of videos and resources online and apps that help to teach you games but there's no denying the fact that reading a rule book isn't the most enjoyable experience it's kind of like reading like a a novel for school and you're kind of forced to learn it because if you don't learn it you can't really play the game sometimes games that have less rules but a lot of deep strategy to it are probably games I'm going to get to the table a lot more often because the rule teach can be minimized and the gameplay experience can be maximized there's a bit of a balance between having a rule book that's 36 pages long and a rule book that's simply on a double-sided card which one is better which one has the better game design does a thicker rule book mean that you're going to have a much more fun board game experience well that's in question one of my hubby's biggest pet peeves when it comes to playing board games is not the fact that okay maybe the games do take up a lot of space in our house that could be for another video but the fact that every time we sit down to play a new game he's got to sit through a big long rules teach uh while he's played a lot of games and is familiar with a lot of game Concepts you know just having to power through learning new rules each and every time we play a new game can be actually quite frustrating has actually
shared a lot of this uh frustration with me mainly because I think because we play a lot of new games and sometimes you don't get to revisit older games that we like and get them out to play again which I think I should he just finds uh the learning process of it really hard I often try and find lots of different ways to try and make the rules teach a lot easier we basically act out the game and then we play it or I just simply just say we do this and you've got these three options and that tends to make the rules a little bit more palatable there is a fine line between having a lot of rules and equating it to complexity you can have a game that is complex but has a simple rule set that's easy to grasp easy to dive into that makes logical sense and this is where I think sometimes games do fall at the sea because the first time someone plays your board game that's the probably the first and possibly the last time they may play that game and so that first initial game experience is so crucially important if you don't have an enjoyable game experience the first time you play a game you may not revisit that game again and if other people have that same shared feeling then that game which could be the most amazing game ever might not ever see you know another play and that's that saddens me quite a lot because I feel like oh well if there's a good game under there how will people know there's a good game under there if a lot of the rules clutter and Rule
exceptions uh get in the way and so sometimes I often give games the benefit of doubt if I don't like a game the first time I'll try and play it a couple more times but not everyone has the time to do that so making sure that the first game experience is a smooth and good one is so important so there are some games that literally have like a shortcut to getting your first game on the table here are the steps you follow set these pieces up now play and I love that one of the first board game don'ts I want to talk about is the fact that a lot of games have rule exceptions they'll say do step one resolve this action do step two get these resources do step three get these points except when you do this and except when you do that and except and that can often create a lot of confusions now I understand the need to have exceptions because an action might seem overpowered so if you don't have an exception then it doesn't really make the game feel balanced but remembering those exceptions can actually be challenging and a burden for players and without a player Aid that has those exceptions printed on it it can even make the game experience a little bit tougher to get through so I often feel like board game rule exceptions feel like Band-Aid solutions to you know some design mechanics the idea that okay we really want to do this particular mechanic but we haven't been able to flesh out how we get around the exceptions or balance issues and I feel
like that extra time invested in making sure that the balance is right and the actions make sense in your game without having to have rule exceptions means that your game is going to probably get played more I often find that if you can make the rules as easy to understand reduce the volume of rules but make the choices more complex and deeper then you're probably going to have a game that's going to be a lot more interesting and my prime example is basically for ex when a player takes an action if that action can Branch off into three or four different choices for that play that makes an impactful effect on their game then that's going to be a more well-designed game because not only do players only have to think about moving one or or two spaces or taking one or two actions they can then see how those actions lead to other things do this really well and that is Great Western Trail cuz all you do is move your little um worker along the trail and then you basically take the action of the building space that you land on so you're seeing two or three options in front of you on the trail but then you can kind of think on another play Stone which of those actions is going to best benefit what you want to do and so whilst the game is complex the choice and the rules are a lot simpler there is a fine line where account keeping can overshadow the actual fun and strategy of a game if your game is really fiddly or there's a lot of upkeeping and I'm talking about dinosaur world those
boredom tokens uh which are literally like this small and I think I've replaced my uh botm tokens with like d6s which help to track a little bit easier I often wonder whether there are solutions to different account keeping problems so when there's a game where you have to manage a lot of pieces if that management and physical management can be simplified by using a track with a single marker or maybe a group of resources then that's probably going to make the game feel more fun and i' like to use the Expression hide the broccoli in the spaghetti meatball and that's basically if there is account keeping in the game if you can disguise it thematically disguise in a way where it's part of the fun experience then you can kind of get away with a little bit of extra account keeping but if it's glaringly obv obvious that all you're doing is just moving things around and you're not getting any value from it I feel like that's something worth culling try and make the rules make sense thematically you're doing this action because it works with what that thing would do in real life if it is a zoo I'm placing this food in this enclosure because it's going to feed the animal and then the animal is going to reproduce and grow and get larger that Mak makes sense to me if you're doing rules that don't really fit in with the theme of the game it can feel a little bit jarring especially when you're trying to learn the game on the flip side there's sometimes when I've read some Rule books where they use a lot of thematic jargon where it's like um put
this amazing Little Flower in this spot with this weird name but then when you see this word do this and then when you see that word do that and then you're lost in the vocabulary um that's kind of swirling in this rule book and you're just simply trying to comprehend is it just you just want me to put this flower in this spot to do this action is that all you want I love thematic touches in Rule books in fact I actually prefer it when a rule book kind of outlines the rues simply but then they have little boxes that explains the Thematic reason behind it that separation actually makes it more interesting cuz it's like you do this action it's like oh this is why you do it because this is how it fits into the world of the game one thing I love to see in a rule book is plenty of pictures plenty of examples and scenarios that literally take you through how to actually um resolve an action for example there's pictures in a lot of rule books which literally say okay the red player has this many resources and does this action this is what happens to them the blue player does this and this is the result and this is how you resolve it I love Rule books that are sequential when they explain the steps and not just you know scattergun their way through um the rules of a game and I love it where there's pictures that literally clearly spell out what you actually do one thing that really sells me over when I look for a game is basically when a game just does one or two things really well and I think that's something that my hubby has often spoken to me about he often enjoys games that really just focus on one or two
mechanics that have been fleshed out in a different way uh if it might be a Twist in a worker placement mechanic that's linked to Resource Gathering or might be a creative use of cards and I think Forest Shuffle is probably one that comes to mind where the multi-functional use of cards is used in an interesting and unique way yet there's only really one kind of focus mechanic in the game I mean I actually like Point salad Gaines which are completely on the other end of the spectrum so games like Boku where you basically have you know eight different ways where you can get points and then at the end you kind of go o how did I get points throughout the game I did a bit of this a bit of that moved up the Boku track I like games like that and it doesn't bother me as much but it does mean it does take a lot more time to learn the games so when a game does come along that really Dives deep into one thing really well I think that actually is a bit bit of a selling point actually and I I think I'm more inclined to say that I'll probably get to play that more often I always like to think from a new place perspective when exploring a rule book I always like to imagine look if someone were to open the game for the first time what was the first thing that they will see what's the first thing they'll experience it's like walking into a brand new shop and seeing the display out the front of the shop and going ooh I love that jacket oh I love the that that set of shoes and then stepping into the shop and going ah I can see more of what I liked from outside the shop and no one likes walking to shop and going oh the inside of this shop is so different from the
outside of shop sometimes it's a good thing not saying that's bad but it can mean that the willingness to play a game uh can be diminished if it is is not something that makes sense so what did you think of this board game rules discussion do you think a lot of board games have too many rules do you think there could be some way we can change how easy it is to learn a new game all I know is that learning a new game requires a lot of time and the less hurdles Us game players have to jump through then the more more chances that we'll actually get to play more games and that's what we really want to do we don't want to sit there and wait for a loading screen or try and learn rules unless the rule experience is part of the game experience so what are your thoughts please leave your stories experiences um in the comment section below I'd love to hear and chat with you if you really like this video please consider liking and subscribing to my channel if you want to see more exclusive board game Sanctuary content please head over to my patreon page and you also get the power to influence what video topics come out on this channel in the future this is Danny S I hope your next game is an amazing one see you soon