How to playtest like a pro | Rob Daviau
Transcript
and quite honestly although the game in the Play test turned out fine once people realized there was a drawing tool in there the entire game board was covered with graffiti Doodles of genitals like typical yeah I mean like humans don't change you look at Roman ruins and Egyptian ruins you're like oh look pictures of genitals um it's like you're giving people a pencil and that's the first thing they draw tic-tac-toe boards or they keep flipping the tape or they like flip the yeah they flip the table and then you have to rewind it and stuff like that um so Rob really excited to chat with you again I think the last time you're on the show was 2017 so it's been a minute you've had a few things going on you had some really cool games come out I think I think the last time we actually chatted like in real life was when death may die was coming out if that gives you any perspective it's been a minute and we've had some really good email exchanges and you've been so gracious to help me with some of my books and answer some questions there and I really appreciate that but also before we get into this I want to just publicly thank you for helping me with this show and you probably didn't even realize it when it happened because in 2017 when you join me on the show it was a turning point uh for me as a conductor of interviews you might say and I don't know what it was man but something about that conversation it kind of oh it unlocked some things like going up until that point I was very much ask your question get an answer ask
a question get an answer but that conversation with you turned into just deeper me being I don't know feeling more comfortable to share stories and talk about sports and talk about you know the different things that make up my life and then apply it to game design so I don't know man I don't know what it was but I want to thank you publicly and let people know that uh you were yeah well a decent chunk of why the show is what it is well thank you very much yeah I I think it goes to like when someone new just starts with a um like a late night talk show or any sort of show where you're interviewing guests those first 100 or 200 things are very much ask a question get an answer and it takes a while before you start realizing oh this can go in different directions and where I expected it so whether I had anything to do with that or I was the right person at the right time but I'll just take the credit exactly either way I appreciate it thank you I'm great and so I'm excited to chat with you again we're talking about play testing we're just going to do a deep dive into the different Avenues different things different things to think about based on the kind of game you're you're trying to bring to life based on the maybe where it is in its development based on where where you're play testing are we is it real life is it digital is it unguided or guided that kind of thing and so I'm just excited to chat with you about all those things and let's start off with the basics somebody's just now getting into game design they're just trying to figure out okay what is play testing like how do I do that whatever what would be your advice to them to really get going almost like a just surface level how do I do this
effectively and then we can go deeper from there uh yeah well first advice is play testing sucks and you need to get used to that and I've used this analogy before but this whole you know you you come up with a game idea and you're all excited and 10 star if you're a newer game designer you spend a lot of time making a perfect game you have rules for second tie breaks at the end and all these things and it's precious and you keep it to yourself and then you invite people to play it and stuff doesn't work stuff's not going to work in it it just it hurts like I said it's like um inviting over uh strangers on your kids first day of kindergarten to evaluate their outfit what do they think you're a kid like I don't like the Hat I wouldn't go with blue and then other people like are you sure you ever wanted a kid how about a dog like it's just this type of thing you're like I worked hard on this um so that feeling never goes away especially when it's strangers especially when you've worked on it for a while so you trick is to learn to distance yourself a little bit from it I like to think of it as um they're evaluating some other game that I happen to be watching not a game that I spent time on so just try to get a little removed now maybe there I'm just a little fragile being um you know and other people handle it better but I don't think so from what I've heard I don't know that anyone creative handles it perfectly I mean I've met people that do handle it kinda okay allegedly like I don't know what's going on internally but like at least externally they're okay but I feel like anyone who has the creative mindset
probably also has some imposter syndrome they probably have these deep-seated insecurities which is probably where creativity maybe manifests right so it's like oh these things intersecting with each other and I feel like a lot of times that criticism kind of it calls into your deeper soul which is why it hurts because like people are maybe affirming kind of the negative things you already thought and you're like oh no yeah I mean a little bit I don't have much imposter syndrome finally I still don't get my success sometimes I'm like I do what I do and people seem to like it I don't you know I see other games I'm like I like those better like what you know like but it's not imposter syndrome I just learned to like okay that's that's the reality of things and if I keep doing what I'm doing it should be mostly good for many people um is that your every time I start a game there's two feelings I have one is maybe I get it on the first try and oh can I do this again because it's hard right and so there's these things that are competing with each other like it's gonna be hard but maybe this time I just do it and just nail it how does that happen and that it never never happens but you have to go into it thinking it because it's a long road to have a good game and if you walk in going oh I can't wait to spend the next two years improving this that's daunting so you always have this little optimistic feel that maybe this one will be faster I'll get it right or I'm really excited um and then play testing just confirms that no it probably isn't going to
happen quickly it's going to take the usual work it takes to make something good um and it's necessary uh I think one of the things going way back to your question because I have a tendency to just grab the reins of an interview and answer what I want um I think a tendency is to take when you're new designers to take too long designing the game before you test it and letting the play test go too long uh I like to say that early play tests I call them workshops all right we're going to Workshop a game and play a couple turns like go back let's start again you start here you do this grab an extra card go okay you did what okay what what what are you doing over here you're not like Okay so let's change this and let's do that and it's very disconcerting to players sometimes because they're having to keep track of the games I just want those first handful of turns to make sense or I'll be like okay you know what everyone's gonna forget this whole thing about this Market that I said on your just draw a card or just take three money or whatever you know I'm trying to test so it's it's really trying to figure out what people are resonating with and then as the game comes into Focus it's a lot more of at restoration we talked about we did it the plane took off it flew and it landed there was turbulence it was a rough Landing people spilled their drinks but it did it and that's like a big milestone for us but that doesn't happen often until about halfway through the design and development process and I think that new designers and I've seen people do this uh when I
taught I bought by and be like is this game working they're like oh no it's completely broken like why are you still playing like they're not done I'm like are you gonna get any more useful data out of this they're like no I'm like please stop and talk about what's not working you know play the first half three times rather than a broken game yeah I love that and that's actually something I think I got from you years ago with just giving your play testers permission to say I'm done like to be able to raise their hand or just ask them at periodic you know moments and go hey do I want to keep playing and if you say no that's totally fine I've got what I need and to not burn out these people who are doing you a massive favor unless you're paying them some substantial amount of money like they're doing you a huge service and so to not uh ruin their experience or waste their time yeah and I do say that to people say like okay I've got what I need out of this uh you can keep playing you can stop and sometimes we're like oh let's keep playing a little bit and then they realize oh wait no this isn't working usually it Peter's out or something and you can read body language more so in person than online and you say like hey uh how's this going you guys seem a little frustrated now they're like this isn't fun I'm like okay great just take it away yeah definitely at what point do you start Play testing a game with other people like do you do you play it by yourself and just do multi you know playing all the turns or like win tell me about that like you've got a game are you testing it alone or do you just go right into bringing other people on board well I've been doing a lot more with um my company restoration games and it's all my company notes
one of the owners where we have design meetings couple times a week so more and more I'm playing with people let's let's just try this thing where I give them homework and then let's try the thing you did and there are these workshops so it's more playing it with other members of the team which is not quite the same as play testing but I would not put a game in front of a play tester until I put it on the table if it's just me and walked around and Red's always the aggressive player in green is how I would play because I played green and blue is the the cautious player and then I pick like yellow or something or no yellows are cautious because your cowardice and blue is just the agent of cast they're not paying attention so they'll make weird moves and so I literally have to walk around the table from okay it's red Red's aggressive okay so they would do this then or they would throw caution to the wind and I just try to see if the pieces are working and I probably play a turn start over play a turn now start over and just keep going like that until I feel I got something yeah that's a really cool way to do it because like I know personally what I would have and I do a little bit more of that that you're talking about now where you kind of assign okay this is this type of player because for a long time I would test things by myself but it would be me playing all the players like it's just like how I would do it but then that's not reality because then you get in a real situation and people play totally different they have different styles they have different things they want out of an experience and then also if if I'm just playing it like me then I'm not pushing systems to their limits I'm not playing one action every single
turn just to see what happens because I'm I'm playing you know as the designer of the game and so I think that's a really cool takeaway is assign each color a different personality and then see what happens because that's a little bit more realistic yeah and you can see things like you know you want player interaction some level but like man this aggressive player is really ruining everyone else's game it's not an inconvenience it's like I can't play because of what you're doing so I'm like oh I I'm not usually uh take that sort of player so I wouldn't push that system so I may not have found it unless I put on that hat yeah makes a lot of sense all right let's talk about the difference between like the early play testing because I feel like play testing is like the the purifying fire that every creative work has to go through and the thing about fire it's gonna burn and it's gonna hurt and you're gonna need some Salve you know to rub on the wounds and stuff like that but tell me about like what changes between we'll call it the first but like the early Place testing and then like the next set of play tests so maybe you do a couple and you're like okay this is Burger whatever but tell me about that difference because I've seen games that are wildly different like the first play test it's a different game almost going into the second and so is that something that you do as well like you find in place that you're like okay the second set of play tests it's a whole new experience I don't know you can't understand what I'm saying like how much is it a game change between if I'm doing well it changes where it needs to change like I might walk into a play test and be like this game is
about X and I threw Y in because I needed something and then everyone loves Y and you have to go okay maybe the game is Y and X goes away um and that's hard to do here like but I wanted to design this game it's like well guess what you still can't just put that to the side you get something people are excited about design a new game based on what you thought was a secondary idea um I'm trying to get better about just not holding on to things and that was one thing 10 years ago 10 15 years ago I'd be like no no this is important and now I step back okay why is it important it's just important to me is important to the players um another thing I've done when Eric clang and I were designing death may die I would come up with some really cool idea convoluted sure to make other game designers excited and he would literally because we'd be working remotely would Pat me on the head you know you're a very clever board game designer you can tell that story now that other game desires let's make something for the players that want you know that they want to play and uh besides humiliating it was also funny and it really kind of changed the way that I focus because I have something clever and I go oh okay yay I can still think of clever things but that's not anything anyone would want to play that's just me proving I can think of a clever idea um so games can and I think should change a lot and what I'm constantly looking for is where's the fun and when does the fun uh
I'll say it's welcome another question I ask in play testing or even playing a new game for the first time as I say uh how much of this game does it feel like you're done half sixty percent a quarter and if people are like I don't know I feel like this is 60 80 percent done and in my head I'm like oh you're 25 done then I know I have a good game I just have too much of it right it wants to be shorter so there's all sorts of questions like that that I asked but yeah the next time it comes to the table it should be significant especially if it's the first time the second time it should be pretty different people are like let's just make this three or four on this card that's that's at the end yeah and I think this also Harkens back so something you said a minute ago with the speed at which you go through the design process and get it on the table to play test because if you if you take six months or a year designing quote unquote the game before you ever test it you're kind of pot committed like you you put a lot of effort into this thing and so you're maybe going to be a lot more reluctant to change things that need to be changed and so the faster you get it on the table and tested the less you're gonna hopefully the less you're gonna be holding on to it with a closed fist like hopefully you come in there open-handed you're like okay what's good about this what's bad let's let's like you're saying let's find the fun and then lean into that versus no this has to be the experience because I can't lose a year I can't lose eight months of what I've been doing yeah and that's the thing is you get emotionally invested and you can hold on to all sorts of things that you don't want to change um your game shouldn't look ugly
right you should be able to read numbers and read words and things like that but once you start downloading pictures and adding frames to cards and designing the board and stuff like that then you're like I don't want to redo all of that uh so you know and then the Counterpoint is sometimes you need it to show what the game's going to be because you know picture this elaborate map and here and then players like I can't see it and they don't have fun because there's not enough there so it's a balancing act between putting just enough in that players understand where you're going but not so much in that when it inevitably needs to change you're not like oh that took me like a week like four hours a day I don't want to redo that because then you're not you'll be like I should but I'm well maybe I can fix it another way yeah so speaking of that kind of quick change iteration process do you use any digital tools uh component Studio or nandec or there's something I've seen out there that makes it you know a lot easier to make cards and things like that online you print them off you do you do any of that uh yeah I use the Adobe suite mostly illustrator and InDesign and InDesign has a data merge function to make cards yeah data merge changed my life dude like it made everything so much easier if you don't know what data merge is basically you can set up almost a spreadsheet and it makes it so easy to update numbers and names and abilities and everything and then you just kind of you let it run and it like populates all the things for you and so man that sped up my process so much that is great it's a little fiddly and you need to get a subscription to Adobe but it helps me to
look at I got a second monitor over here that's what I'm gonna do uh to look at like a spreadsheet and be like okay I have four cards that do this and I can have notes and things that don't get imported rather than looking at a sheet of cards or a deck of cards although sometimes that's handy too to see what they're going to look like and then I'm like okay and then you know bring them into the card deck print them out and then you know good to go uh it was I'll just design game boards and non-data merge things in illustrator because I know it better um sometimes I just take a piece of paper and draw on it yeah yeah absolutely just as well and then another thing is to to feel free to take a piece of paper and draw on it in a play test like that's one thing to open it like I don't oh yeah I don't like I'm not locked into this and so if I see players not having fun and I think I have a way to maybe flip the fun real quick like you're saying earlier okay we're not gonna do this open market we're gonna make it this other thing instead to just do that and to go and as long as play Touch There's No Going In hey I might totally flip the script on you and rotate with it right and so that's something I learned as well so talk about that a little bit about just that confidence to feel free to make it a different game yeah that's that's why I call them workshops to people like it's gonna be somewhere between a play test and workshop we're gonna try a few things I try to set it up and then and I like to tell people like plea try to win but you're not going to win the play test you're going to win the play test by helping me so I'm going to change things if you come up with a killer strategy that's kind of broken I'm going to take it away from you you've won you've shown me that it's
broken and then you might lose the game if we finish but that's okay and some people don't like they're like I was winning and then you changed the game on me and I'm like you were winning you won the play test by breaking it um yeah and I I think by setting up the framing of it it helps people but it's hard to do we were play testing something for restoration a week ago and it wasn't just a design team that was a new member of our operations team and then our marketing person was in and we'd play and I go okay go back to start let's do this okay I don't like that that's a four now okay and they were like like you know it's hard enough to learn a game but to learn a game that's constantly changing was like a little tough but yeah draw on things I've taken cars to be like this card is great this card is broken I'm like you're right I take it and I give them another card and they're like oh so what you're saying is if I'm play testing for you don't reveal anything I should not say a word if I want to win the play test I should win the play test it's a joke we have at restoration it's like congratulations you you've won the plate like we'll be five turns away from the end and I'm like okay I've seen enough I want to be able to like spend the last 20 minutes of meeting talking about it and so I'm back oh I was gonna win I'm like you won the play test congratulations you won this game that's gonna attract a good change and now we're good yeah now we're gonna throw away 40 of the game oh that's awesome so let's talk about compensation as far as you know if they work in your company it's a little different because you're probably paying them bi-weekly anyway and maybe they get some benefits like
there's already that compensation built in but if you're just testing at a convention or people come over to your house what are some ways that you found that people really resonate with because I mean what I found is a lot of people don't like they don't want me to give them twenty dollars they don't want like money they want other things and so what are some ways you know money is a great way to compensate obviously but what are some things in general that you've used that you found work really well to say hey thanks for play testing my game uh first of all I just want to acknowledge that you just said that money is a good compensation for work I think that was I think that's going to catch on We're Gonna Change the World here man I know there's a new political movement I'm starting yeah um it's true they're they're games don't make enough money like if I was paying everyone money to the number of hours of testing unless I had a runaway success so I'd quickly be eating into the profits that I have um gratitude is nice Credit in a rule book for extensive play testing if someone play like 30 minutes at a Convention of an early prototype I'm probably not going to give them credit but if they play a whole bunch of versions and really give some insights if they're coming to my house they're going to be well fed they're going to be fed whether it's just taken or I'm a cook by a hobby so I'm like I'm gonna make you dinner you're gonna get a nice steak dinner I got a bottle of wine we're gonna and then I'm gonna take two hours of your time to play a game that sucks feed them first or feed them after feed them first or during there you go play a little bit let's have some food take a break I'll think
about it while I'm cooking then we'll come back we'll play again with some new ideas yeah maybe some dessert on the end yeah and then yeah exactly so I for me it's it's genuine gratitude credit copy of the game sometimes um take games that are on my hey I don't need these games anymore I don't play them you know please take them food all sorts of the things that I do yeah and that's that's something I found as well also it's kind of interesting I've also run into situations where people who especially one guy in particular who have play tested games especially if it's a game that's like a system like you have that unmatched system where the sky is the limit right I've had play testers come back to me and say hey I've got an idea and they've almost created a new game in the series and they're like hey because they play test it so much they get locked in now they're seeing it not only as a gamer but they're seeing it from the design level they're seeing how it changes they're seeing the different opportunities and things you can do and change and then it's like oh that's a great idea yeah let's co-design that let's work on that and then so I've gotten other games out of it and so have you had that happen like with unmatched or any of the other games well unmatched Adventures which is coming out later this month couple weeks sometime soon on the front of the train I can't remember when stuff comes out is it Cooperative game that came out of some people who really liked unmatch and they came up with a cooperative play way to play and they were they were play testers and fans in our Discord and they approached some members of the design team so we want to pitch you a new one match game
and we're like okay and I sort of got a meeting invite and I didn't know what it was it was like the name on the meeting invite was odd I forget what like it was and then I started playing uh watching on TTS and I'm like oh this is a co-op why didn't we think of a co-op oh this is pretty cool yeah I want to buy this right yeah so that's that's another potential opportunity um let's go so anything else you want to say as far as like service level people just getting into the hobby just getting into game design kind of basic level and then we'll dive maybe a little deeper in just a second um not really they're they're other than luck or some inane insane amount of talent that is rare to come by it just takes time and hard work there's no secret you'll learn your own ways to play tests that work for you things things to avoid are easier than things to do right like things to avoid are telling people they're playing it wrong no no it's it's a good game you're just not seeing what I'm trying to do here right that's a pretty common one like it's not the game it's you yeah uh if you just played better you would find it fun that's right uh it gets good in the second hour that's what everybody wants whether watching Netflix series or movie or something like that just give it another option well because people get emotional investing like they want it to be good they think it's good you have to go in and be like you thought it was good you tried
now listen to what's there now you you can have the wrong play testing group right if people are like uh we mostly play you know exploding kittens and then we play some games with the kids and you're like oh hey I got a three hour sort of deck building worker placement game with like variable scoring and like I threw the first two expansions into just so I could like it's not gonna go well the game might be fine you have the wrong audience so make sure that the people are the right people who are would potentially buy the game before you start Play testing or at least um have them say like oh I don't usually do co-ops I'll play it but I don't usually like it you've got a co-op game then know that they're gonna be like yeah I still don't like co-ops that's not your game what's that but but the thing is try not to make it personal and try not to become antagonistic with them because you're feeling like I worked hard on this like it and then you start like saying like dude you played wrong and you keep forgetting this cool rule and that that's not helping anyone yeah 100 and this actually reminds me something I heard Mike Tyson say you know the famous heavyweight champion of the world in boxing and he said because somebody asked him about like all the negative stuff people say about him online and like if you're a celebrity of any status you're going to have people who hate you people who love you that's just the way it goes and so online that can get kind of crazy sometimes and they asked him like how do you deal with people saying negative things about you online and he says well when I think I'm somebody it bothers me
but when I remember I'm nobody I don't worry about it I was like oh man what an interesting mind shift to just to look at negative feedback negative anything and go man I want to get upset about this but you know what especially in this context but you know what this game it's an it's a nobody it's not there yet I'm not gonna say this personal because like this is play test number three it's gonna take 100 plus more of these and to not get offended because like why it's not gonna help anybody to to get antagonistic to get offended by and so just kind of flip your brain or if you're gonna do it just stop the play test just say hey this isn't going well it's a little hard for me to watch because I thought I had it this time but clearly I don't let's just stop it before it starts you know I have enough to realize it's not working at this point it's just too much like just be honest with people and then you can be upset or you can take a walk or you can spend a couple days and be like Oh and then you deep breath and be like okay if this game was given to me and someone said fix it what would I do it's not my game I didn't spend months on it someone just walked in the door and said hey there was a play test it didn't go well what do I do next you would approach it with fresh eyes like do that to your own work yeah it reminds me also of what Eric Lang I heard him say one time sometimes he'll sit down at a play test especially at a convention or something like that and he'll say hey I've got a game that a friend of mine is working on and you don't mind play testing it and I can give him some feedback when it's his game right but it gives players that kind of openness to maybe be a little harsher on it because they don't think the designer's sitting at the table so
you might get a little more honest and critical feedback which can be super helpful but I think also flipping your brain like you're saying earlier it's like I'm just helping a friend and to detach yourself from it can also be helpful as a designer and so yeah anything you can do to I heard a phrase a while back notes you can't read the label from inside the bottle and so just realize as a designer of a game you're inside the bottle and so what can you do to find ways to get out right whether you have a really good play testing group that's going to tell you the honest truth or whether you can kind of detach and find a way to see things with new eyes and fresh eyes and come back to it anymore but anything you can do to kind of see reality as it is versus how you really wish it was is super helpful yeah and boy the more we talk the more I realize there's these little things that I do which is I think my tendency early on was I'm going to make a game it's going to be a complete game it's gonna have rules and I'll give it to people and they'll read the rules and I'll play it you know play it and I'll watch first of all I'm a bad guy at shutting up when people play so I've had to learn that or just have them video themselves or some other tricks but the way I look at it now is I'm going to put pieces of a game down and I'll sit down like this is not a rules test I'm going to explain how to play and if you forget just ask me or I may remind you and then if I change something like I'll change it in the middle and then I start getting to the I'm going to explain the rules but here are the printed rules so if you forget something check those see if it's in there if it's not in there I forgot and then I will tell you to eventually I'd like you to read the rules we're going to play test tomorrow and then you
teach it while with me there to I'm going to mail it to someone and have them video the whole thing like I start removing myself from the process it starts standing on its own two legs I as it goes yeah this is something you talked about a while back when you came on the show you know several years ago was how you were getting into filming the test and then you're almost just going back and watching the film and seeing where players made rules mistakes or seeing where the body language changed or seeing you know you can pick up on things when you're watching film that you maybe you wouldn't even notice if you were sitting in in the room because you can only look at one thing at a time versus the film you go back and all right this time I'm gonna watch this player all right now I'm gonna watch that like you can kind of focus on things I think that's a really cool way to do it and also remember uh from remember correctly at Hasbro y'all would set up play tests and then watch people from behind glass that they couldn't like the mirrored glass right those are painful yeah do they still do that I mean only because it was it was a kids game and so we're all like middle aged I was in Middle East and I was in my 30s you know game designers who were doing magic drafts in the basement and you know doing all these complicated things and we'd watch like a family try to play with a six-year-old and we want to be like it's so easy why are you confused right that's not understanding your audience and and things like that but yeah I got the video trick from Matt lecock he did it we did it on pandemic all of the pandemic legacies but starting with season one and watching the video and it's because he can't shut up either or he's better at it now he can sit there and just write a notebook and not
say anything but at the beginning he couldn't so he had to learn to for him to not be there and so that's what we did and it you know it worked out and uh I I use it on some stuff I don't use it on others how do you know when to use it or not it depends if you're looking for qualitative or quantitative data okay so we have our unmatched fine any deck fights any deck we want to know who won who lost how many rounds did it take what was the most powerful card how many hit points did this person have left what other questions we ask oh if you asked you it would the play test character do you think you could win the next game that was a big one because sometimes people are like I have no idea like I don't know how another feel like yeah I played it wrong so if we see like this character is only coming in at 40 we we look for 40 to 60 because the sample sizes are so small on the variance but it's like they're 40 oh let's look at yep most people feel like they could win next time and they were the person who beat them only had like two or three Health when they died which means those games could have gone the other way you know and so that's probably within the bound so you're looking for patterns that emerge from the data but even within then we say are there any things you didn't understand or any comments on the character and I in particular look at those as much as the numbers other members of my team will make pivot tables and crunch numbers and look at variations in the mean and all these sorts of things and I'll be like I see a lot of people saying it's not fun right they're like well it's coming in at 50 I'm like but it's not fun
right and so you have to kind of look at those things now where I will do qualitative game data is with a legacy game you can't get a hundred groups to play like 12 games of the Legacy game and get any meaningful data so that's when you get the group to video it and you watch you still get enough groups that you can get some cross data it's like okay this card was a problem in all three play tests so that's a problem but most of you just look at where people understanding how are they putting stickers book are they delighted when they open something are the games going too long and you look for sort of these subtle Trends between things but you know if you're doing a living card game you need more data yeah that makes a lot of sense especially like you're saying if you have a story based game and you you want a key moment to be surprising like that's really good to have that video of the group and like okay were they surprised or were they like that was it okay did they call it ahead of time do they have a better idea right oh you know what's going to be in here when we open this it's going to be X and you're like oh is better oh yeah it should be X yep right then they open and they're like it's pretty cool and they forget they said it and then you might say like hey you mentioned this thing we're going to switch is that okay they're like I don't remember saying that yep absolutely okay so these are more Advanced Techniques anything else that you're doing or that you've seen work that are kind of like that next level
like this you know filming play tests might be a little much if this is your kind of newbie getting into this thing but you know anything else that you would say is like a deeper dive once you kind of have figured out your system and the way that you like to take in data and like once you kind of established your process anything else is like on the deeper level no it's really just being okay of watching a test and saying okay I've seen enough um because what you're looking for is and it's hard since my brain just works this way after 25 years and I was playing a game yesterday with the design team and I'm like okay I've seen enough and we stopped and one person was like I was having fun I'm like it's not bad and then I pointed out like four or five things and people are like oh yeah I guess now that you say that I was missing this and then they say something and we're just looking for problems and where it was an interesting test because we're like mechanically it all works but I I wasn't engaged how do you describe engagement it's like I didn't feel that what the game was promising me thematically was coming through it felt like that if you didn't tell me the theme I'd be struggling to find it and I'm a theme guy and I'm like I want and you know it felt too safe it was an extension of another game we have at restoration I'm being vague on purpose and I'm like it feels like very much like the other like another game it feels like the parent game it's too much you didn't give me anything new I'd rather
you present something to me and I go that's insane I don't how is that gonna work that's not gonna work but I got excited and then I want to figure out how to make a word like everything worked but I it was so we just went back to the people who we had working on and we said can you just redo this and scare us show us something too much too weird too big and you know it's yeah those are hard that take that's the stuff that comes with experience because you're um another line I say and I may have said on your show because I've said it before is um well we start arguing about numbers we're almost done because they know how to win they know what to do on a turn they're engaged and now they're like oh is that a three or is that a four or five or should the market be four cards or five cards based on the size of the deck and how many should be I'm like we're in good shape when we're talking about this not should it have a market what does a card do why is the game six hours long like those are all settled now we're just making you know we're staying Within These parameters so once you if you're talking about numbers at the beginning you're either deluding yourself that you don't have deeper problems or you're brilliant or you're almost done yeah that's a really good point it's just understanding where in the process you are just based on the conversations that you're having because I think one one question a lot of people have in general it's like how many times should I play test a game and it's like as many as it takes I don't know there's not a magical number it's like a hundred like no yeah I've never it depends is it a three minute card game you can play it 100
times but assuming that the game takes an hour to play I don't know you're going to be maybe a few dozen play tests internally and externally I mean you're gonna need more data than that it may be longer if you're if you're not getting it right away maybe less if it's something that you know you get pretty good at or it's based on something you know how to work with but there's yeah I just uh finished up a game with a co-designer I'm like I think we're done right we're like anything else we do is just gonna move it around like it's got its little problems but we're gonna fix these problems and create other problems or group a will like it better now but Group B will like it worse like we're just the there's diminishing returns and you go yeah at this point I'd rather go do something new than try to get the last one percent of this because you'll never get there yeah that's a good point it reminds me of something I think and that gamer if you said or Matt leak out but it's like when you're 80 done you realize you've got 80 left to go as well yeah that was we probably both said it because I uh I think we were working on pandemic legacy two and I said man I got I don't know it's coming together I feel like we're you know 80 done and he said yeah the next 80 will be the hard part though and probably take just as long as the first you know first part yeah the last 20 is just the song and I got what he said I'm like yeah yeah and I've told either he says it or I say it that he told it to me so he probably both told the story and I think that's so important for new
designers especially to realize that even someone who's been doing this 25 years even someone who has tons of games on the market that do really well in retail that are ranked really highly on BGG like even still it takes a long time there's no substitute for testing there's no substitute for just getting the Reps in no substitute for the work there's no shortcuts really it's just a matter of putting the time and the effort in yeah I think the shortcuts that I can take is I can probably see the problems a little faster and if I'm not doing too many things at once like if I'm just focused on a game I can see them faster I can ask maybe better questions I'm more willing to throw stuff away and I can iterate faster but it's the same amount of work it's just less like playing guitar I'm not looking at the chords anymore right I'm just doing it faster just from experience but it's the same process and then the other thing is you're like okay this is another thing people like to do is I I play version five and it doesn't work so I make version six this is still has problems I make version seven and now it always somehow would get worse most people will be like well I gotta go back to version six but you might have to go back to version five you're like why do I have problems here why did this get worse and you're like well the market doesn't work anymore it's like why doesn't it work it was working great it's like well we changed it because we had a problem over here with the tile Lang and you're like oh so we tried to fix a tile egg with the market and we made the market worse so we need to go put the market back go back to the tile laying problem and find a different solution
for that so you need to be able to just not only throw away the work you've done but sometimes like the one two or three iterations where you're like this was the wrong direction pull it back let's go here and that that's hard yeah it's kind of like if you're gonna clean your house a lot of times it has to get dirtier like you have to pull everything out of your closet yeah in order to put it all back organized and so there's like a certain part of the process you're like wow this is way worse than what I started but that's the only way to get to that organized finished product and it reminds me of a quote from C.S Lewis who said the long way around is the short way home like you just you just gotta go the long way to get where you're trying to go and if you try to take a shortcut it's not even it's not even gonna work out and so I think it's something yeah I use a slightly different analogy with restoration like other members team like hey can we play test this thing you guys are talking about I'm like we've kind of taken the whole car apart and it's on the lawn in pieces like we it's this is not a time like we know we had a problem but we had to take the whole thing apart and we're looking at it and then we got to put it back together and see if we can make it work now like give us a week or two yeah and so that makes me wonder what are the notes you're taking if I remember correctly I think on the last last time you're here you talked about how make sure when you're watching a play test when you're taking in notes and figuring things out taking in feedback that you write down the problem not just the solution because sometimes we have a tendency to go oh I know how to fix that and you write down how to fix it but then that turns out to not be a way to fix it but then you can't remember what the problem was to begin with because you didn't write that down you haven't seen and you haven't you worked
on the game in two or three weeks and it's like wait what was that and so to write down the problem among any solutions that you have but whatever what else what there are notes what are you looking at and then writing down in your your notebook uh well that's what I do certainly when I'm working with Matt because he taught me that and he's very diligent and I don't want him to yell at me and uh I'm a little more from the shooting from the hip when it's just me like I see what's wrong and if I'm going to be the one working on it I'll write down like two or three things like eats more story this is bad too slow right just a couple things that need fixing when we're in the Restoration Team is mostly when we do a debrief and then I'll be like you can you work on this you can you work on that show them to me I'll approve them we'll put them back in we'll play again on Thursday so it's just really like I don't want to try to fix 40 things I'm like there's tons of other things wrong and this may not be replayable that that's a down the road problem right now I want to look at these four things that we found that we're just fixing those four things you know when those four things are fixed then we can start looking at the this is too long what happens in a two-player game what happens if someone gets eliminated early you know I just went into we were talking when we were doing Thunder Road a couple years ago these are the questions we asked so that's how I was framing it would you change a bunch of stuff play test to play test or would you only change like one or two things that way you could pinpoint what the real issues were I try to pinpoint I try to be like let's not change everything and then it still doesn't work and we don't know why it's
like okay at the beginning it's like real big stuff you know maybe this isn't even cards maybe this is Dice like you're looking at real big sorts of things but yeah usually it's like okay this wasn't fun though first turn was really boring second turn was okay so next time let's start on the third term I think it has a momentum problem and let's just double all the numbers on the cards and let's change this one rule which seems to be the thing that people were forgetting like you don't have to you know like there are other problems I'm just ignoring them for now let's see if it feels closer before we start dealing with the other problems yeah and I think there's another thing new designers maybe get too caught up in they're trying to fix everything it's like no just just fix one or two things right go into a go into the next play test knowing these other things are still broken right and maybe you tell play testers maybe you don't but just kind of have that back your mind that way you can get the next test to the table as fast as possible to find out the answers it's kind of like if you're a scientist you can't just sit around the lab pontificating right thinking oh I wonder this I was like oh eventually you have to sit down and do the experiment and find out get some data and then and then keep going and so I think that's another thing to to take away from this yeah I I think the analogy I I in my head is it's like building a house everyone's excited to do the final carpentry and paint the walls and put the couch in because it's the shiny stuff and it's great then you know the house is done but I'm like can we can we pour a foundation
mad Plumbing get ready for electrical stuff like and like let's just keep doing that do we make sure the basement doesn't leak and there's stairs that go in and you know then we'll start like we know there's gonna be a house and then you get real excited near the end you're looking at particular language and oh we use the word on a space here and in a space here and those need to be cleaned up and you start coming up with all those clever ideas that kind of tie everything together like wait wait what if this was also that and these could be the same thing and what if this wasn't a thing what if you weren't buying from a shop you were buying from a person because people relate to people more than they relate to things and then they could have a you know you start doing all those clever bits that tie together and those are those are more fun than the like guts of the game in a way yeah at least for me I think that's for for a lot of people like we get excited about these little like you're saying earlier the things that make you feel clever as a designer but it's like yeah but should it be dice or cards like we need to we need to figure out the foundations here first because you know if you build a house you can build a house on Sand or you could build it on rock you know like which one is is gonna it's gonna last longer yeah I mean I uh Suzanne Sheldon who is our marketing person we're a Gen Con and we're out back in the booth on Sunday and there was a box for pipe and drapes I don't know if you've ever done anything oh yeah that's the box where you put the pipe up in the drapery and she's a big Euro gamer I go this sounds like a Euro game pipe and drapes and then she's like I guess and then I just went into a one minute pitch I did a whole pitch she
goes I want to play that I go I kind of want to make it but the thing is all I've thought about is the pitch and the pitch is all the finishing stuff right and it works perfectly and it's like well what do you do on a tournament I don't know what you do on a turn like and it's like oh you're doing this and you're doing that and then I'm like and I'm like oh I I don't have the guts to this I just have the pitch and so it's great and it's exciting whether I'll do anything with it at any point I don't know and part of me wants to just give it to her I'm like here I made it but I also know like oh that would take six months of work it doesn't sound as much fun when you put that way yeah but it's the reality so all right let's switch gears a little bit let's talk about tabletop simulator something you know because of the pandemic because everybody was promoting online whatever I think at this point the majority of designers are at least familiar with it or at least aware of it where they weren't five years ago and so what are you looking at what notes are you taking when doing an online play test when you can't really see body language you can't really get the vibe of the room you can't you can't know that there was a distraction at the 14 minute Mark for Bob because you know like you don't know that because he's you know not in the same room with you so what are you looking at what are your takeaways your notes any of that kind of stuff I use TTS a lot of restoration because all four designers are in different places we're on the same time zone I guess we can say but I don't after trying it I don't use TTS for the most part with outside play testers for the reason
you said there's something we talk about inside that there's a TTS tax oh yeah well it does a few things better than the real world it does many things far worse including things it shouldn't like dice like you can roll the dice snake and land on their Edge oh and you're like or they rest on a deck of cards you're like you've this is made up make them not do that you know and then to rotate things to pick up cards I'm 53 years old I'm always like it's like playing a game with oven mitts on right and I'm better at it now than I was so we have to look at it and go man this game's taking a while like what do we think the TTS tax is on this or like pretty high because you're going with different cards and picking them up and we're zooming in and you've got to look and stuff that would be real clean on a table is not clean here so you have to kind of um adjust for that but I tried I tried to have and we're always on a zoom call as well so I can we can be talking and we can be looking and I can see people and I've done some limited play tests with that and quite honestly although the game and the play test turned out fine once people realized there was a drawing tool in there the entire game board was covered with graffiti Doodles of genitals typical yeah I mean like humans don't change you look at Roman ruins and Egyptian ruins you're like oh look pictures of genitals um it's like you give a people a pencil and
that's the first thing they draw tic-tac-toe boards or they keep flipping the tape or they like flip the yeah they flip the table and then you have to rewind it and stuff like that um right so it causes a distraction it's hard to play so I and ultimately we have we have almost gotten in trouble and I know other Publishers have gotten in trouble like at some point it has to be on the table and you need to see how big it is and how many these different piles are and what if there isn't a magic bag that sorts everything for you you have to actually Shuffle you have to actually organize some things get harder and some things get easier and what does this actually look like when you hold the card in your hand and you can't shove it up to be your whole screen yeah so I use it in those early stages when you're blocking it out and then at some point I go I need to print this and play this in the real world or we're going to be in trouble before we get much further because we get to the end and then we print you're like hey by the way do you know this is the size of a ping pong table we're like oh but it's done it's like no it's not done we thought it was done so um it's a necessary tool I I wish there was something I'm not a particular fan of the implementation it has a lot of features that I think no one wants and it's missing features that I think people would want um it's a physics Simulator for play test but it doesn't really do it because with Fireball Island we tried to make the island to roll marbles like oh hey now we're going to use it as a physics simulator and it didn't work as a physics simulator when we were trying
to do a physics game um and and so I just wish it didn't have a lot of these things that it has with things running into each other and cluttered things and stuff tipping over and you know falling off the board and stuff like that it just feels like that wasn't needed um but just know if you're play testing something in TTS you are playing a second cousin to a board game right and that everything is going to take maybe double the time like I've played games that should take take an hour and they take two it's like this is interesting yeah the the time tax in in TTS is great except for the things which does really quickly like Shuffle right right like if you're playing a deck builder and you know like I just add in my cards and I got a shuffle and you know it takes a while but you're just like okay Shuffle Shuffle put it in the bag that's randomized do this at all everything comes out face down right like all those like some things it gives you the illusion that it's easy when it's not and many things that are easy it somehow makes it seem tedious so you it's like you gotta translate it from TTS to the physical space yeah that's a great point it also brings up the importance of testing your game in its entirety not just the the gameplay right testing the rule book and that's one thing I love to do is just hand somebody a rule book and say teach me this game and now we're testing that aspect of the experience right because it's not just the between the numbers not just playing the games it's also setting it up does it take 30 minutes to set up okay well can we speed that up is there something we can do
um testing the insert I I can't tell you how many times I've seen unboxing videos where then they go to put the game back in the box and they're like how does this fit back in there and they're like they can't understand like how the things were wedged in there together and it's like it's almost like trying to put something back in the package that's been vacuum sealed it's like how does yeah how does this work and so like that's part of the testing make sure you're doing that because it's the full product not just the game by itself yeah uh my my title at Hasbro was product designer not game designer because it was the box it was the package it was everything in did it make money did it make sense what did the piece look like and how did it play like at some point I say like at some point this game becomes a product and you don't want to be surprised by that right right you don't want to be like this game is great and it's like it's got 700 cards and we wanted something for twenty dollars or this theme doesn't work or just a you know this only plays with nine players right like at some point it needs to be boxed it needs to be put away and needs to be set up and then these substrangers play it and needs to be sold and it needs to make a profit and all those things yeah don't get caught by surprise now if you're just designing games because you want to design a game and get better at it it's for you and your friends just forget all that but at some point if you're like I would like to sell this to someone it's a whole different set of thinking and I was really trained right from beginning at Hasbro that like you know I had to pitch it I had to have a piece of paper that said this makes money I had to do a bill of materials I needed to know the
box size I needed to talk to marketing to understand the audience so I can lean into it a little too much but I rather lean into it too much than be completely blindsided by what do you mean this doesn't make money what do you mean I have to take all of it out you know like all this section or half these cards or the batteries or whatever I put in there yeah that's a great Point all right Switching gears a little bit I want to ask you about Legacy games I saw recently you've got Ticket to Ride Legacy coming out here pretty soon which really goes to show that any game is legacy of fireable and so I'm looking forward to Uno Legacy at some point chess Legacy would be pretty cool like I'm I'm hoping that we can do both of those I don't know right the world doesn't want them but I think I could do it hey we could at least play test them and um but let me ask you about like tell me your your process is it different you mentioned like filming those games especially to see those moments and you know because it's hard to get a bunch of data when you're having to play a game 12 times to get the full experience anything else though that's just different with a legacy game as far as play testing it is like a fractal version of the play testing situation because first you have to get a game that works now if it's Ticket to Ride or pandemic you're kind of good because what you what you do is you say well what do we want to change or tweak to the base game so it feels a little different so that we've set ourselves up to change it so when you open it you go oh hey this isn't exactly Ticket to Ride we did here like there's no sport track and there's a couple different features
on there and you're like oh hey oh this plays a little different why you know you know we wanted a reason um so you need to play that game with all the play testing that you think before you even start going in a different direction and then when you go in a different direction now you play like the first four games a couple times and then you play the first get a different group to play the first eight games and then you know like what uh there's 12 I think in there so it was like play Four get a couple groups Play Fix those get the next group to play eight hopefully one through four are cleaner but they're not gonna be perfect but then five through eight are gonna be rough and then you do one through twelve and one through four should shine now and five through eight might be rough and then you know and so forth and then you sometimes people like to go back to people play the early games they're like hey we finished it let's play it and they'll play it again because they you know they just got this taste like I wanted to see where it was going like well congratulations it is there you go it went somewhere and you can now do it again and then they have to kind of forget what they played in the early games or it's worse where they go wait is this rule like this it's like no that was last year when we played um so it's kind of fractal in the sense that you have to do everything that you would do to design a game but then you have to also design a campaign which is like designing a game where you do a little and then a medium and then a lot and then refine it yeah that makes a lot of sense whenever you're designing a Cooperative versus a competitive what what changes in the play testing what feedback are you looking at because obviously it's not that much different
but it's different enough where you're going to have to look at different things so what are some of the things that you're you're noticing that's different well interestingly enough it is um the I don't call it the Fidelity the granularity of some of the rules if you are playing a um competitive game and there's a rule that's worded poorly or could be argued or could be abused it is a much bigger deal because people are like that's not what it means it's like yes but if you do that you win I know I've been playing my whole strategy about that and that's why I'm winning but I don't think it could be read that way and you and when you're playing a Cooperative game and you're like should this rule be like this or like that you're like well this will make it too easy and this seems like a challenge and the group can decide right even if they play it wrong to make it easier you wanted the harder one and they play it easier and they're having a great time it's like good for them like that there's some sort of forgiveness now I I just feel people will come into alignment about the vagaries and the rules with a Cooperative game and I also feel on a competitive game people get deflated earlier right you're playing a game you're like I'm not gonna win this we still have to keep playing right like is there a way that when do people check out and a lot of times in a Cooperative game again if they're like we are not gonna win this and it's almost this Esprit de corps of the ship going down together and they're like let's try something crazy and see if we can save it or they'll just go let's call this right this is this just not our night
and then that that's fine and you don't get that in competitive game so you have to work a little harder in a competitive game I think to keep people engaged the whole time so there's just but I don't know how much that affects play testing it just affects like some of the decisions you make when you're playing it if you make it shorter do you hide the score like are there rules that are particularly subject to confusion or abuse that you should be looking at a little earlier in the process for a competitive game yeah that makes sense and I can also see how it would change let's switch gears as we kind of come to a close in this conversation is feedback right if I'm testing a competitive game where what's kind of natural in a competitive game especially if there's like interaction where the players can kind of balance themselves if Bob is all of a sudden way out in front we all kind of have an agreement that we're going to work together against Bob so at least Bob doesn't destroy the rest like give somebody else a chance versus a Cooperative game it's like well we're all in this together so we're it's not quite as self-balancing from the players so the game itself has to self-balance in different ways so you're looking at different things in feedback yeah you're looking at different balancing mechanisms right because a lot of the things I thought about with um some Legacy games is like hey Bob's way out in front he's won like four games we've each won one let's Ally together and one of two things happened either Bob has a miserable next four games or they don't do that they go I don't need to finish the campaign you got it Bob I don't see the need to play like it's four to two to two to zero and I'm zero
and why am I going to keep showing up because even if we go against Bob you guys are too ahead of me so let's play something else so you'd think they would catch up as like there would be some ganging up on the person but sometimes people just feel like then they're just having a bad time right and if you look at it you're like okay I have to go undefeated in the next four games five games to have a chance at winning it's like like I said let's let's do something else yeah that makes sense it starts feedback what are some of the questions you like to ask what are some of the things maybe you don't ask maybe you're you just you found that this kind of a waste of time to ask these questions or travel down these roads what are your thoughts on feedback I'm not really caught up about different ways to get feedback from people I've had people be like this isn't working let me tell you why and kind of half redesign it in their right and the redesign is good I've had people who do that and it's horrible and I don't want that at that point um I have people where I say just play the game I'll watch I'll understand let me ask a few questions at the end I don't need anything else what I don't like when playtesters are like I wouldn't usually do this move but I'm play testing games so I'm going to try to break it for you I'm like don't do that just play the game doing you a favor like you want me to play yeah like I'm doing you a favor I'm gonna play really sub-optimally or bizarre or like look for I'm like don't don't do just play how you'd play I want to know how people are going to play not how they're not going to play um I know some people like don't want suggestions or don't want discussion in
the middle or don't want discussion at the end or only want to rent I'm pretty chill they're taking their time to play something bad they have the full right to tell me however I may say at one point like I'm not looking for that right now like I understand it that's a if you play this again in a couple months I'll be looking for that so if you can put it to the side like I know it's a problem you know the wording on the cards is all over the place because they're written by different people at different times and I'll try to clean that up for the next time but that's not my issue right now you know typos things like that yeah and I guess just being gracious you know always thanking people for their time thank you for that observation thank you for this or that yeah and just make people feel like they're part of the process even if you're in the back of your mind you're like wow that was the dumbest idea I've ever heard but hey externally you know that's something I'll take a look at I really appreciate you you giving me that feedback yeah and sometimes I can feel myself going like getting frustrated like I know I know like it's not what I'm look you know and I'm like hold on they're taking their time but what I'm frustrated is I'm looking for a and they're saying like I don't like BNC and I'm like I'm not I don't care yet right not that I don't care ever but I don't care right now and I need you to get back to what I need to focus on and it can be frustrating because how do they know what I'm focusing on they're just playing a game that's bad yeah exactly Rob there's been excellent anything else you want to add any kind of like closing thoughts or any anything you've noticed recently from these I mean you've got some cool games coming out dude unmatched Adventure really excited about that one ticket to ride Legacy I have no idea how you're pulling that off and so I'm just curious to just to see it let
you know and also play it uh Thunder Roads coming out you've got a lot of cool games very different as well so anything just kind of close things out that you've learned over the last year two years of working on these games you'd like to leave listeners with no I value being around company now after having to spend two years not around them uh but I think you were talking about game design um I know it's it's a gradual change right like if you compare this interview to one from six years ago I probably said a lot of things similarly because I'm me but I probably have a slightly different take on it I looked at my game seafall which I started 11 or 12 years ago um and then it came out and I finally pulled it out and looked at it I'm like oh why'd I make these decisions right like time does its thing it's still me I'm like this was pretty cool I forgot this part and I forgot this part but I don't know why I did that part I remember thinking this is important and that wasn't that important so I'm sure I have a lot of different perspective but it's like you said I'm inside the bottle of myself I can't read the label I tell you what though man I'd love to see a second edition of seafoam I would love to see you go back and I I figured out spend some time right before day before Gen Con so over a month ago now and I went through and redid the whole core system in a couple hours one night and like this is great and then I've been so busy I haven't looked at it again but I can see it working its way to the top of the pile yeah that'd be a cool thing and I guess it's it's kind of nice because you're not having to start completely over hopefully not starting from scratch and you've got a lot of it it's just I
mean the bottom line is I wanted this thing where you had four guilds each of them are equal and each one are path to Victory but my heart was I love exploration games so the game actually was an exploration game and if you picked Explorer's Guild and went into it you tended to do well but I was promising you that all four of them would work but that's not the game I wanted to make so my head and my heart weren't really talking yeah and it was my um was my wife put it when the Beatles broke up George Harrison who was always very limited to the number of songs you get on them came up with a triple album All Things Must Pass the next year was every song on that album good no but he had a backlog of stuff to get through I had just left Hasbro I had 12 or 14 years of ideas that I needed to put in one game yeah they didn't need all to be in that game they could have been in like five or six games so yeah the things you learned just as you should do it man but small taught me how to work small and cleaner right right absolutely that's nothing I want creative people in general especially game designers just anyone who's or just a business owner anyone that does anything really is to understand that it's not about success or failure like it's everything is a bridge everything is a bridge to something else and you can't even say oh I'm only here because of this like no you're here because of everything good bad ugly otherwise things you don't even remember like they all create who you are now in this moment and to just be okay with that and sometimes things don't go quite the way you hope but you learn from it and everything else will
hopefully get better you do I did Risk Legacy and I worked hard on it it came out and it was kind of it was a success and radical at the time and I remember starting with seafon I said I don't know what I did right right right from the first moment I was like I was working a little paralyzed and so this came and then see fall gamer like I don't know what I did wrong right like a lot of people do like it but it didn't find its audience and why didn't it why did his reputation not match what I thought it was going to do and so I I just needed a little time and more experience now I could be like oh I understand both of these games why people liked them why they didn't buy it worked why it didn't yeah right and I've got a second edition of a game coming out soon in my hunted series of solo games and more people played it you know in the first few weeks that it came out than I could have ever had play tested oh yeah you know you just you get so much data in the first month that you just just don't have access to and so all of a sudden these little things come out and you're like oh yeah I should have done that different oh yeah we wrote the way we wrote that rule makes sense to me but you know 15 of other people don't get it at all it's like okay how do we change that so yeah I always says if you get more play testing data the first week a game is out then no matter how much time you spend also you just look on BG do you know the things you go oh that's what people think that's what works that's what it doesn't and there's no other way to do it right it makes you want to design video games because like oh we'll just patch it we'll just figure like well no it doesn't work that way okay yeah 5 000 copies of this thing and they all have the same typo that's what it goes Rob this has been excellent dude really appreciate your time uh so we've been talking about these games you got coming out anything you want to say about any of those
already mentioned or any other games you want to plug until people where to find them uh no I know I should be plugging stuff but restoration games is where I'm spending a lot of my time and I still do stuff with some other people I had a stranger things game come out yeah earlier this Summer that did pretty well I had a DND game come out that I really liked didn't do that well what's that one called it's called Warriors of crin it was it was it was such a cool idea it was a little bit of a product the pandemic in terms of testing and marketing and stuff like that um how do you spell Korean k r y n n is a dragon Lance game they redid the dragon lands campaign and dragon Lance is all about war games and so what the idea was you'd be playing and it still it works is uh you're playing a d d game and then you're like oh and then this battle starts and then when you come back the next week instead of playing D you have the board game set up and you put the Miniatures on the board you play my game or I co-designed it with someone and you play out that battle and then depending on how well you do you it says in the DND book like if this battle went a b or c these things happen and then you go back and you play D and there's like 12 battles six of which are integral to the plot the other six are sort of pick up you know if the DM wants to put them in or you can just play it as a board game and play this 12 battle campaign um I I think there's some things that happen because again because of the pandemic because of just some of the likewise every game becomes a product I think some of the product things didn't work out as well as I had hoped
either because of cost or graphic design or I wrote the rules poorly like there's just some of those things where but I remember play testing the entire campaign during the Omicron wave I couldn't have any outside play testers by myself I was getting up at like five in the morning in Solo apply until nine like I know the game works but sometimes it doesn't find its audience for whatever reason yeah and just so much noise in the market as well who knows what's coming out yeah exactly like what other five games came out that did take all the oxygen out of the room and if if only four of them had come out and you had you could have fit that fist spot like there's so many things but I like the idea though like I like the idea I fell in love with the idea but maybe people don't want that maybe who play D D don't want to stop and play a board again because there's a hybrid it says hybrid and I thought this was such a really interesting hybrid and I started my my love of games with d d so I wanted and I have it now I have a dungeon dragons game with my name on the cover but maybe it was a promise that we were speaking to ourselves not to the the final people yeah or or just haven't quite found the right marketing message for the people for the game right because I know there's a lot of people that would find a lot of joint enjoyment in that structure of the board game system for that you know for that chunk of the game but then the freedom and the flexibility of the other parts of the game and just to be able to go back and forth because like I used to run d d for high school kids at this school I was teaching at and battle would take so long because it's all this talking and bickering and there's no structure in
this too free form it's like to just be able to pull out a board game and say hey guys here's the rules here's what you can do on the turn here are the options here's the you know go kill that go rescue this right yeah I I really love the structure I think it's cool and then you know as these things go I think that the dragon lands role-playing book did fine but they're not going to reprint it and the support game did okay at best and they're not going to reprint it so at some point it'll revert and be mine again there you go it might take longer than I want and then I'll be like okay let me see if I can redo this and you know why didn't it sell was it dragonlance was it marketing was it the design was it the graphics was it too much too little right you know do that sort of postmortem and then see if you can reboot it again yeah that's a great way to do it Rob again thank you so much for your time all right um really appreciate you just coming on the show and sharing so much wisdom and advice and I wish you the best man I'm again I'm really excited for some of the stuff you got coming out and I'm sure there's things you're working on you can't talk about that I'm probably going to be even more excited about so good luck with all those things I hope so yeah that's awesome too thank you all right thank you