Skip to main content
Loading video...

TCbH Podcast - Golden Geek Awards

Transcript 1:41:17

Hello and welcome to the Cardboard Herald podcast. I am Eric, your host, joined uh as most of the time usual by my lovely aquatic co-host Jack. Yeah, I'm I guess under a deluge right now. I don't know if you're aware of that. I guess you can just guess when it comes to Juno, but uh maybe that's what you were going for or maybe there's some other aquatic reason. It was more to do with the fact that you live in a rainforest. I was telling somebody about uh the rainforest in Juno today and they were very surprised uh that we Juno is in the world's largest temperate rainforest. Yeah. Uh I guess I'm a bit like Kevin Cosner in Water World. I'm starting to like develop gills and stuff. Well, thankfully you you don't have anything like here blocking it, so your gills can breathe free. I get weird hair growing there. I don't like it very much. Um, yeah. Well, welcome in to our audience.

Thank you for uh letting us have our silly little I come up with an adjective and Jack tries to improv his way out of it uh thing we like to do at the start of the podcast. Um, Jack, what have you played this week? Hey, I have played uh a really cool game this week. I actually have a visual for those who are watching this. Uh I got Lord of the Rings Fate of the Fellowship. Um and I'm not so much of a like hold up a board game type of guy. Uh, in fact, uh, for some behind the scenes type of stuff, uh, I was giving some criticism to Eric recently where I was like, don't just I mean, just like holding up the game, the entire review, doesn't that feel like amateur hour? And then I realized like the next review I did, I was holding up a game and I was like, man, I kind of seem like a jerk when I say that. But uh um you know like use it for emphasis, you know, make it a distinctive. If you're going to hold it, you know, make that part of what you're doing or the environment. Uh anyway, uh Fate of the Fellowship is the new Matt Leok uh pandemic system game. It's not pandemic Lord of the Rings in the way that you might think of like Monopoly, Lord of the Rings Monopoly or something like that. Uh, but it definitely has the lineage, the heritage, the DNA of

Pandemic in it. I don't know. I I think Zman just wants to, you know, slap something on there. When I think about it, if Zman were responsible for say Forbidden Island, they would call Forbidden Island a pandemic system game. It's about that connected. You know what I mean? Gotcha. Yeah, that's and I kind of get it in terms of like I don't know for me with like my film background. It's always there's so much discussion of like you you want to make a prop even if it has nothing to do with the original property like 19 Cloverfield Lane or whatever it was that has nothing to do with real Cloverfield, but they want to just slap on the Cloverfield branding because it helps sell games and it makes it so much easier to very confidently put that product out there. Um Yeah. Yeah. And I I kind of get it. Yeah. And I I think it's going to peique the interest a lot of people who maybe are uh like pandemic dieards uh like uh my friend Sarah and Nico are pandemic obsessed. But at the same time, I think there's a lot of people who would be hesitant to play a game if they thought it was just like a uh licensed IP pasted on top of or, you know, loosely pasted on top of a pre-existing game. Um, and so I I think

they did a really smart thing here. It's not in the same shape as a typical pandemic box. uh the pandemic system is very minimalized here and they really wanted to emphasize this like fate of the fellowship as the name. Uh and yeah, it it really is a game that feels completely unique, like it's an original idea, an original concept that has some of the elements that you might expect from Pandemic. uh particularly in the the character-based action system, some familiarity with the like draw two cards and you might have to reshuffle the bad stuff deck and put it on top so you have recurring elements coming up. Yeah. But the the implications and the carrying out of that is completely different. Uh how you structure objectives is completely different. Um, I've played it a couple times already and it's it has been impressive uh each time that it's hit the table. Um, it's not without flaws. Uh, yeah, totally. My god. My god, the pieces uh the the little army pieces are so tiny. They're they're so tiny. Not even the Naz Ghoul. Just just the little soldiers that you're moving around. It's like they took a pandemic cube and then shaved away about 50% of

the material in order to put in the shape of a dude. Um, so it's already small. Yeah. So it's really cool looking. Very small sword. It's very small sword. Um, I think the most intriguing thing I can say about this game, uh, is that as a huge Lord of the Rings fan, um, this seems to capture the kind of like grandeur, the, uh, epic, uh, intent of a lot of Middleear games like say War of the Ring, uh, having a very large scope, um, having uh a lot of moving parts uh and this like epic journey and thematic storytelling um and this combative war element but automates a lot of the war. And it's like there's a a clockwork war game that's happening amidst you doing the heroic navigation and positioning um that uh happens at a character level. uh has some really interesting implications. Uh I was kind of dubious on it to be honest. Like when it was announced I was like I don't know there's a lot of crap that's getting Lord of the Rings paces on it these days. There is so much I it Middle Earth is hot again. Middle Earth

Middle Earth is is in its glow up phase. And by glow up phase I mean that it was it's been glown up but people are now coming to terms with how cool it is for board games. Well, what people might not realize is that Asadday uh the like company is owned by the same investment company that owns Middleear Entertainment that holds the rights to a lot of the Tolken IP that can be published that this is separate from the Tolken estate itself. Um but the rights holders through large investment company means uh are under the same umbrella just by happen stance. So it's not like Asthma North America had to get licensed to do this. They just happen to be owned by the same mega corporation that already was like yeah we're the people who get to control who make board games of this.

Um, that's brand synergy in latestage c capitalism. Um, synergy. Yes. Uh, it's it's a cool game. I I'm very excited by it. Uh, and it blends some of the elements of my favorite Middleear games of yore. Um, there there's DNA to me of Middleear Quest in there. uh the Kitia Lord of the Rings and the um uh and War of the Ring in there. Uh and uh it has a a cartoony uh but still at the same time very impressive, nuanced art style uh that feels kind of like the Ralph Boxy movie uh from the '7s, which is also really cool. Yeah. I don't know. It it's it's it's interesting. We'll have a review up. I think next week is when we're going to push that. Um and man, for the for the audience at home, let me tell you is a good review. You're going to want to tune in.

Um yeah. Well, I got to to pull that clip of uh Matt Lecock. That was I was like, man, what a what did I interview him like three or four years ago? I'm like it's seven eight years ago. Uh it was 2017. Yeah. So, you know, like it was ages ago to Oh, it hurts for you to say that's eight years ago. Oh, that's right. That's a painful one that you just dropped on me. Yeah. And while I've played some other uh stuff, uh the the only other thing that I wanted to mention uh is a shout out to Jared Carmichael of Three Minute Board Games. I just got a promotional copy um of his uh new book 101 Board Games to try before you die of boredom. Um and uh he's been a great ambassador for the hobby. uh his uh format is really amazing and deserves the accolades that it gets. Uh and I just started uh reading through this book uh since I received it earlier today. Um has some poll quotes on the back from Jamie Stakemire and Jeff Engelstein. So, um it it's at least worth, uh giving a look into if you're someone who likes reading some board game material, like if you like Senate magazine or something like that. Um I have huge amounts of respect for uh Jared. He's been a guest on the

podcast before and um yeah, shout out to him for making a cool book about board games. Rad. That's cool. I'm glad that that's first of all cool that you got the review copy. I'm interested to see I would be interested to see what 101 games made made the cut. Is is it like primarily games that he thinks are like the best of all time or games that he think are the most interesting or the most important in board game history? Like where is he going there? According to the forward uh which I I read uh it is uh largely games that have made an impact to him. Um they also have to be somewhat visually distinctive. Uh they can't be games that he's published.

Uh Red Dust Rebellion I think has come out by now. Um, I think as of writing the book, it hadn't come out and he has another uh design that he's working on. Um, but uh it really seems to be like if he was trying to categorize truly 101 board games that he'd recommend other people try um possibly as an entry point into gaming or as an entry point into a type of gaming. Uh he separates it into subsections uh based off of uh quick and fun games, family-friendly games, low conflict games that need cooperation. Your favorite show is now a game. So that's like licensed games and stuff. Uh games that tell stories, educational games, high conflict, games for one, and games that hurt your brain. Um, okay. So, yeah, my brain my brain's had it too good for too long, right? And there's uh some deep poles in here which I I think is really cool.

Like uh I I know that uh Jared is very um politically oriented. He's uh someone who seems very principled and very progressive. Uh and so you know like things that make you question uh or maybe challenge your assumptions are something that uh matters to him. So like I I was uh pleased to see that Blockbyblock Uprising was in here for example um which is you know a small little indie game but does some challenging and interesting things uh in this space that isn't typically uh done. Um, but at the same time, there's new stuff in here. Like there's a page that's on arcs, you know, they're they're keeping up with relatively new stuff.

When I'm done, I I hope to do some sort of review for the channel. Um, it's always hard with print media like this to see what, you know, it really comes down to the the writing and the entries. Um, how soon will this be dated, right? You know, like if someone got this book 10 years from now, is it still going to be of value? If it's merely recommendations, uh, then that's not that great. But if it's essays, you know, like why these games were an impact to him or to other contributors, then that becomes timeless, right? You know, like kind of like reading a Pauline Kale review of a movie that came out in 1972 or something. Sure, there's been other uh analysis of that movie that has come out since, but having that person's perspective, thinking about what the society was like, what the culture of film was like at the time, um and uh and going deeper into, you know, what is the the impact and purpose uh of this film, not just as a consumer, but on the the the the landscape itself um makes it much more interesting. But yeah, uh I I'll dive into it more later and I'm

hoping that I'm going to have this done by the time that you're up here in Juno, which is going to be relatively soon, and I can hand it off to you because you're a big geek who likes to read board game related stuff. I read those things frequently. Uh which brings me to what I've played this week. I actually have not played like a published board game this week. I've played a couple other things though. Uh, first of all, I've started a Mythic Odyssey of Theos campaign. And by that, I've taken it's a D&D campaign. I've taken the Wizards of the Coast, Magic the Gathering World of Theos, which is Greek mythology, but but changed a little bit to make it non-copyright and then taken it back to Greek mythology. Um, so I fight I I have played a Wait, wait, wait, wait. to make it non-copyright on Greek mythology. I don't think that like that is what that Homer is coming after you. They've made it into copyright.

They they've taken Greek mythology and then said we're going to change it enough so we can copyright it. Exactly. Well, that is true. And that is that is probably what ended up happening. And they also probably wanted to not be beholdened to like being incredibly lore accurate to Greek mythology uh as well because but also this is like this is a Magic the Gathering card set that they have then turned into a campaign setting for Dungeons and Dragons. It started off as just this is this is the world for a card set for Magic the Gathering which then became Mythic Odysseies of Theos and you have campaign things for Theos, the land of Theos. And then I have undone all of the work they did to make it non-copyright because I'm playing with people who are new to Dn D. And I figured having them also learn on top of the game system all of the different just new names for different gods. Uh right was maybe one step too far. So now we're just going to go back to ancient Greece.

We're back to Greek mythology. Um, but I have gotten my first I got a session zero in and we are planning out our next session. Uh, I also ran a oneshot recently in not in that campaign setting but just uh generic D&D campaign setting. So, what are the things that you prioritize as part of a session zero? because this is a relatively new thing to me, you know, like I I grew up in the periphery of RPGs and now a session zero is like expected as like a de facto. You need to have this because this is part of what's going to make like a cohesive campaign. It sets expectations. It allows people to get questions out of the way. And I think it's fantastic. But when I was first getting introduced to role playing games, um particularly say in the '9s, uh maybe some groups would have session zeros, uh but the the terminology wasn't necessarily set, nor I think uh was there an expectation of everyone's going to get together and and you know, hash out some elements about the game before actually playing the game. So for those in the audience who don't know what a session zero is, uh what is it and like what are the things that you're really trying to prioritize during Yeah, totally. So for me at least, a session zero is just like something you should do to just make

sure everybody's on the same page before the campaign starts. Now what that page is to you, there's a lot of different things to discuss. I think the one that is like most frequently discussed is like what is the setting we're playing in? What should the players expect from this campaign? Just making sure that expectations are set of like like for me I told my players I'm going to do a kind of like whimsical silly campaign. There going to be some moments of seriousness like we are going to have like a oh no this is like a terrible thing that's happening to the world. But all in all, it it's going to be a kind of bit of a silly fun campaign. Just make sure everybody knows that is baseline what we're doing. Um, I actually my session zeros used to be a lot different before I read the rule book for kids on brooms, which is just they compile a lot of different things, but uh, one of the things that they I I am I used since they since reading it is start off the discussion with like any boundaries players have. Um, so like what I like to say is I've had a player in a campaign who requested that I not bring up any head trauma like specifically or graphically for for reasons that I'm I don't know cuz I didn't ask. I don't ask my players to

like give like justifications cuz that seems maybe not fun for anybody involved to hear why you don't want to hear this thing. Um, but like making sure that everybody is having a good time, I feel like kind of requires you just knowing like, oh, this is a topic that you don't want involved. Uh, and then also just being like, as a DM, these are the things that I'm going to be bringing up more frequently. Uh, making sure that everybody's on top of like what the scheduling is going to be. So like every other Tuesday, does that work for everybody? Okay, great. So, we're going to plan on that. And here's just making sure you go over situations as much as possible before they happen. So, right, another thing is like what if a player can't make it? Do we can do we just play a session without them? And I think that kind of depends on how many players you have, but just making sure you like talk about these situations that are almost certainly going to come up during the campaign.

Um, you know, it it reminds me a lot of like leadership training that, you know, I've taken and and hopefully uh utilize some of the best aspects of that in my own leadership in professional settings. You know, like people should know expectations and you as you know, the the leader should know uh the preferences and needs of the people that you're working with. So that way you know you can find the best ways of collaboration, of motivation, of making sure they feel fulfilled while at the same time they know what their obligations are. What happens when you know the the expectations fall apart? Those kinds of things. It's such a smart way to start off a a campaign because there's such a level of investment and the last thing that you want is one for someone to get their feelings hurt or or to feel like they're in an unsafe space. Uh but also kind of like the the schism that can come out of misunderstood or misaligned expectations. You know, some people want very different things out of a role playing game. Um, do you discuss things like level of uh severity in or or adherence to rules?

Like for example, um something that I think about a lot is I one time heard a DM talk about how they always try to explain how tightly monitored resources are going to be. Yeah. You know, like I'm just going to assume you have unlimited arrows. You never have to tell me how many arrows that you have. You don't have to keep track of how many arrows that you have. The only time in which the number of arrows that you have is going to be of any relevance whatsoever is if I specifically tell you in this situation, you know, like you tumbled down uh a a crevice and much of your gear was destroyed upon the fall and inspecting what you have, you realize you have two good arrows and, you know, like 30 ft of rope and that's all you have available to you. that's the only time in which a limitation on common materials is actually going to be applied. Like do you talk about that stuff in session zero? Yeah, definitely. So that is that is something that I brought up and it was more to do with spellcasters just because in D and D spellcasters have like specific components that they need to use essentially um to cast a spell.

Uh, and there's a few different ways to rule it where you can de like make them like use that as a limitation against spellcasters because spellcasters in D and D are typically more powerful than their melee counterparts. Um, but how I run it and what I told my players is in very similarly is unless there's a reason for you to not have access to these things, I'm going to assume that you have done your due diligence and purchased the things you need from the market to cast the spells that you have. Um, another thing that I discuss with them, just going back to like how tight we're going to be on the rules, is I I I let them know any homebrew rules that I have. So, I have a couple that I just like always use in every campaign just because I think they're fun. Um, and just making sure the players know that that is a deviation from the normal rule set, especially if they're new players, so that they don't just expect that with every DM. Like just letting them know, hey, this is a home rule rule that I have in place for this situation. That's not how the game tells you to rule it necessarily, but that is how I like to rule it, and that's what we're doing. I typically always homebrew in favor of the players as a DM. Uh, so like one homebrew rule is listen, the goal of the game is to tell a good story. That is what everybody is at the table to do. That is

everybody everybody's at the table to tell a good story. And I think giving players more things that make them feel more powerful, even if it's a niche situation, makes them feel more powerful and therefore makes them feel better. And you can then use that to tell a better story where it's like, so one of the rules I have is for critical hits in Dn D, the way it's supposed to work is if you roll in that 20, you roll the damage die that you have twice and then apply the bonus once. Mhm. What I choose to do instead is okay roll the damage die once, add the bonus, and then assume that on the second damage I roll, they rolled whatever the max is. So if they like to make sure that critical hits are actually something that is powerful, like this is a thing that you have done which is really stellar. So if you have like a d12 plus three damage on like a normal hit, we're just assuming the 12 then you would get Yep.

So you're getting 12 and a four and then the three cuz I have had times where I've gotten a critical hit, rolled damage dice twice and gotten three damage total from the rolled dice and then three damage and it's like I just got a six. That's just a normal That's just a normal hit. It feels a critical hit and a glance at the same time. I mean, if that character weren't such a weakling, then maybe you could have done better. Um, okay. Well, uh, one more question about uh, this setting uh, both as the setting itself and the retrofit back into Greek mythology. Greek mythology is one of the sexiest of mythologies. How sexy is this setting and your retrofit campaign? Let me tell you, it is probably not that sexy all things considered. Uh, okay. Sounds good. I mean, let's just say I played Hades and that's like the level of expectation that I have for uh any Greekbased uh mythological fantasy right now. So, this is another thing that you had probably discussed in session zero, which is how do you deal with intimate relationships? And my ruling as a DM is I don't want to narrate them. You can absolutely have them, but we're just gonna fade to black.

Good call. I think that's a decent thing to do for video games as well, you know, like especially because video games like I I don't mind adult stuff being in uh my books or in movies or even video games or anything like that. Uh but um there is some sort of crossover in video games where you're playing as a character uh that like crosses this threshold um that feels more forced upon you. Uh I I don't know like in video games I tend to prefer that if there's romantic relations even if there's something that you pursue and have to consent to and attain. I like the much more fade to black and then, you know, come back to it and everything is just dialogue. Uh maybe I'm just not man enough to uh to really hang with uh with Will in Balders's Gate. Uh oh, man. You kind of look like Kratos. How do you feel about the quicktime events in God of War?

Those scenes. Yeah, you know. Yeah. What? Okay. He's your effigy. Greek mythology. Yeah, I actually have the uh his axe from the recent Dad of War games hanging up on my wall over there. Um H Yeah. Well, anyway, so uh I I may be representing a golden god, but there's the Golden Geeks, which were just announced this week. You typically, if you have a really good uh transition, you typically do jazz hands. So, if you could just Yeah, there we go. Okay, that's the topic for this week. Uh this week we are chatting about the Golden Geeks. Uh the winners were just announced uh yesterday or two days ago. Uh two days ago. And we, you know, it's important to our hobby to discuss these. I think I mean it's it's a really interesting just pulse of the nation almost of how are we feeling about these uh games that have come out this year and I think that there are in my mind some interesting takes from from from the people. Um, yeah. So, I I think there are two I mean, of course, there there are many awards that matter for a lot of reasons, but the ones that I would have the most interest in talking about uh

here um are uh I guess really three. Um I think the Zenobia Awards uh is a very awesome project in general and that's trying to recognize game designs in their uh nason stages uh underrepresented game designers and you know a lot of people who are experienced veterans in the hobby are involved in kind of shephering these along. So the Zenobia awards are kind of its own thing. When we're talking about published games, the two award ceremonies outside of our own uh which you know every channel and their their brother and mother have a have their own re awards ceremonies, but the the two that matter the most to me are uh the spiel diaris uh which the reason why that's so important is because it is the Oscars of board games. uh it's slanted for a lot of uh specific things and there's a level of predictability that you could find in that. But there are a lot of people on this planet who will just buy the winners of those games.

Like whatever games get recognition for that, that is a huge prestigious thing that will be a footnote in gaming history for them. Um, then the Golden Geek Awards are so cool because Board Game Geek is the de facto hub of our hobby. All things board games currently and for the last 20 years have ebbed and flowed through board gamegeeek uh in a way that I don't really see that sort of centralization uh in many other hobbies. And because of that, the user base uh is uh I think uh a very good representation of enthusiasts within our hobby. And the Golden Geek Awards are a uservoted uh for series of awards. Exactly. Yeah.

For the people. For the people. So, how how do we want to tackle this? What do you want to start on here? I they have it listed. I think that there's uh we'll we'll change up the order they have it listed, but I think go through the nominees for each category. Uh talk about the winner and then kind of discuss our opinions of what we would have voted for or what we did vote for. I don't know if you voted in it. I can't vote in it. I was not I was not at the point where I had the reputation to vote for it. Uh so I did not vote, but I have my thoughts. Yep. Well, let's let's lead into it. here.

So, uh, the first one for two player games, uh, the nominees were Agent Avenue, Compile Main One, Dune War for Arachus, Flat Iron, Aest of Robin Hood, Ironwood, Kelp, Shark Versus Octopus, King of Tokyo Duel, Lord of the Rings Duel for Middle Earth, and Star Wars Unlimited. Um, I was actually surprised by the winner of this. And I'm not necessarily surprised because I don't think it should have won. I just don't think it was go if reading this. I didn't think it was going to win. Um, yeah. Well, I mean, I guess this is kind of one of those like lowest common denominator type of things because the the winner was the Lord of the Rings duel for Middle Earth. Um, why were you skeptical of it? So Lord of the Rings stole from Middle Earth I think makes sense especially with like how popular Lord of the Rings is. Um I just feel like in terms of the buzz I heard about the game's release Kelp just of Robin Hood and Compile main one were were the ones that I immediately picked up as these are the games that I've heard the most buzz about from this list. So, I would have bet dollars to donuts that one of those three would have won. Um, the I agree with you and you know, like I I'm a huge fan of Kelp, uh, and Jess of Robin Hood

and Ironwood, uh, I think is one of the best games of last year, period. Uh, and I've played it a few more times. I played it last year and it was still kind of just it wasn't quite making it for our end of the year list. uh but uh it's it's growing and and I think that one's going to continue to cement. But the thing is is that Kelp is I think an availability issue. Uh and there's there's a level of specificity to that. Just of Robin Hood is really good, but it's uh it has a look uh of being a GMT game, and it is a GMT game. you know, that's not a bad thing. Uh, but you know, like there there's a level of war gaminess to it that I think limits the broad audience. Whereas Lord of the Rings Duel for Middle Earth, I think a lot of people went into that expecting it to be just a reskin of Seven Wonders Duel. And it really more than anything feels like Seven Wonders Duel second edition that happened to have a Middle Earth theme. Yeah. And because of the beloved uh uh place that Seven Wonders Duel has in the hobby, you know, I think Seven Wonders is a fine game. Seven Wonders Duel is one of the best games ever made. Yeah. And Duel for Middle

Earth is even a little bit better than that. And so it's affordable. It has a really appealing theme. I don't know. I I totally buy it. I I see why it is uh why it's hanging at the top of this list. Yeah. I I think o of the nominees, I probably would have chosen definitely not King of Tokyo Duel. I don't know. Just Robin Hood was fun. I I would not be upset about that one winning, but Kelp would have really have been the one that I I thought would have won. Um, but Lord of the Rings, Duel from Middle Earth, I haven't played. You have, so I'll The Cardboard Herald is a okay with that winning. Um, the next category is artwork and presentation. This one feels the most loosey goosey. I couldn't really feel I mean, not necessarily.

There's all there are some other categories that I feel like are not particularly well defined what you're judging them based on. Um I have not been able to figure out what the voting criteria was and maybe that was in the actual voting block. Um but the next one is artwork presentation. Uh nominees are Arcs, Fellowship of the Ring, Tricktaking Game, uh Formage, Harmonies, Kelp, Let's Go to Japan, uh Duel for Middle Earth, SETI, Unconscious Mind, Wondrous Creatures, and Worms with the winner being Unconcious Mind. Um, sure. Sure. Uh, no. No, I No, it ain't it to me. I mean, okay, so first off, I'm getting this out of the way. I shouldn't be picking on someone who's not the winner, but uh Formage, I don't even know why it's in this category. I do not like the way that Formage looks visually, aesthetically, I'm surprised that it's nominated in this category. Now, unconscious mind, I get it. Um there's a lot of art assets and the the artists are Andrew Bosley and Vincent Dutra who are two of the most well-known and celebrated artists in this uh in this industry. Uh if you want a really damn good artist for your

board game, those are two of the you know like 10 names that are going to come up to the top along with Tul and Bethel and Quanch Moria. Um you know like those are all uh names that you might turn to. Kyle Faren is another uh name with a lot of accolades in there, but of course Kyle is the house illustrator for Leer Games, but unconscious mind, you know, like I love Vincent Dutri and Andrew Bosley's artwork. I just don't see the originality in this. Uh, and I I would love to have highlighted something like, for example, Harmonies, which was a runner up, which I think has a very arresting and catching visual style that doesn't look like other board games. Um, and it was an opportunity to maybe recognize uh something that's more innovative uh as opposed to just best representation of things that we already see in the hobby. Yeah, I I think that's fair. And I would also like if harmonies won, I would also be sure. Yeah, totally. Uh because I think Harmonies is like super cohesive. Artwork fits the theme. Theme fits the artwork. really good mar marriage there. Um I also and this is a little bit more to do with just I guess it depends on what you are meant to be judging it on. But

Kelp Shark versus Octopus is a gorgeous game, especially if you have like the miniatures that are on there. That's a gorgeous game. And I think the artwork and presentation, which I in my mind like the presentation would include the like ma jang style tiles that you're playing as with the octopus, like that's a really satisfying thing to touch. Are you judging based on that or is it just the artwork and graphic design? I guess I don't really know. But yeah, production does go a long way for how a game actually feels apart from the mechanics of the game. And I could totally see what you're saying. Like if this were the year that PAX Premiere came out, would the fact that the the totems are like clay pieces um that have these really deep inlays on them, would that impact the artwork presentation? I I don't cuz my thing is I don't even know if it's meant to impact, but if it is, sure. But yeah, I guess that's the part where I'm like a little squishy. I guess a little squishy. The the fact that it's a user voted thing kind of leaves it in the hands of whoever feels that, you know, the one versus the other. Yeah. Um, and I meant to bring this up. Uh, I did, uh, pull up the original 2006 Golden Geeks

and the 2023s. Um, you know, I I was giving GMT a little bit of a hard time for being a niche audience. The very first Golden Geek winner for two-player board game was Twilight Struggle, a GMT game, like the GMT game. Um, which uh is uh funny. Um, but at the same time, the last year's Golden Geek winner uh or I guess the 2023 winner uh for a two-player game was Sky Team. So I think that's the spectrum when we started this hobby was the the people who were very into these um heavy simulation war games uh that could be very dry and niche whereas we're seeing seven wonders dual duel for Middleear Sky Team these you know more appealing smaller poppier bite-size games as the two-player winners now. Yeah. Well, and I think that also is just like we've I feel like we mentioned this on the podcast before, but just two-player games are in their they're they are peaking right now in some ways. I mean, maybe they're not peaking, but like they are there's a ton of them coming out and there's a ton of really good ones coming out. Um, so yeah. Um, the next category we have is cooperative game.

Uh, the nominees are Seventh Citadel, uh, Aimonia, which is maybe how that's pronounced. Your thoughts on how that's pronounced. Uh, I I I I'm guessing Hegeimonia. Yeah, but it's a But it's an A. Aimmonia. Uh, Bomb Busters, Dead Cells, Fate Forge, Chronicles of Khan, uh, Fellowship of the Rim, Tricktaking, The Gang, Leviathan Wilds, Primal, the Awakening, Slay, the Spire, Tidal Blades 2, and Wilmont's Warehouse. Now, I have not played most of these.

These are a lot of these are new to me. I've heard of I most of them. There are a couple that I have not such as Aimonia. I don't know if I've just been living under a rock, but that is I have not heard of that. Uh Primal the Awakening I hadn't heard of and I don't know if I should have. It's funny because I consider cooperative games to be one of my favorite game types. Uh, and I even went out of my way to look for cooperative games last year uh to to play some more. Not necessarily ones that came out that year, but I've been thinking a lot about like how much I love um Spirit Island and wanting things in that vein. Uh, and there were so many on here that I hadn't played. This is the category that I have played the least of. Um, the winner I've played, uh, the Fellowship of the Ring Trick Taking Game, which I think is a very good game. Uh, and sorry, and this is a thing. This is a thing that I need to clear up cuz I was going through it today. And I when we were making our 2024 best of video put this game as a nomine as an honorable mention and then took it out because it's a 2025 release. I thought yeah we received a copy of it uh as an early thing in 2024 but we removed it

because the actual retail release was 2025 and now I'm seeing it here 2024. You look up the boardamege geek 2024. What is this nonsense, Jack? What did you do? It's It's so squishy and it's so squishy when it comes to board games because, you know, like some things roll out in certain regions or, you know, have an early release at a convention and like what do you actually call the release date and then you compound that with like crowdfunding and that becomes a whole nightmare. um you know like if this is the year in which they want to say that it's eligible for consideration great. Uh I do find it kind of crazy that a game that even if it came out at the tail end of 2024 that this is one that um had so much attention because it doesn't have that much opportunity to come to the forefront. Um, well, it makes me wonder if there's like a recency bias with this. I was going to say I it kind of it doesn't it doesn't matter especially when the voting doesn't take place until April like I mean and that's kind of similar to the Oscars where it is like you know things the Oscars the voting happens in like February.

Mhm. So, you know, I think it's is what it is, but that was just a thing that I need to clear up. I don't think that I am actually in terms of cooperative game, I'm here for it because I think that game was one of the one of my favorite cooperative games I played last year. But, uh, the big thing for me was just I wasn't I had it written off as a 2025 release. Uh, so I'm kind of surprised that it was even in the running here. At the same time, it's a great cooperative game. I'm a little surprised, and this probably goes back to what you were mentioning earlier of just availability, but Slay the Spire, the board game, had such hype to it that I'm kind of surprised. It had a lot of hype, but it was uh also a later release that happened in the year. Um, what I think is really telling about this category and the winner, uh, because personally I would absolutely put Leviathan Wilds as the top of this, but Leviathan Wilds was a niche debut game by a small studio and came out towards the beginning of 2024.

So, I I think that I I guess it's kind of like the Oscars, you know, those January and February releases that completely get ignored uh during the next year's Oscar campaigning. But, um I I think it just wasn't a year for really hot uh cooperative games that were particularly unifying. Sure, Lord of the Rings, the trick- taking game is popular, but I don't think it is like making giant waves in the hobby in the way that the prior year uh Golden Geek winner uh being um uh being Sky Team once again uh really won the hearts and minds of everyone. And I started doing some research uh because uh cooperative games have been on my mind a lot recently, right? I got Fate of the Fellowship here. Uh and an angle that I took with that review was almost like a retrospective, like a historic lens. Um, and it made me think about the development of cooperative games. And it wasn't a like whole genre or, you know, like type of gaming uh, in the way that it is now. And it wasn't until 2016 that there was even a category in the Golden Geeks for a cooperative game. Um, the first winner was uh, 2016's uh, best cooperative

game, Mechs Versus Minions, which is cool. And that did definitely make a big headway. It was a League of Legends uh IP. Um massive game. Uh like absolutely massive. I have it on my shelf over there. It takes up so much space. Uh, but you know, beautiful minis, cool system, but at the same time, I'm surprised that even though Pandemic came out like a decade earlier, um, that it took until 2016 to have a dedicated cooperative uh, category. Yeah. So, I don't know. I think Fellowship of the Ring to me makes sense. Leviathan Wilds. Also, I think I'm kind of surprised it isn't a runner up, but you know, I think that's kind of what you get with a popular vote. That's that's how it is cuz this is also I mean, it's not quite rank choice voting.

I have pulled up the the voting method, but it is it is a style of rank choice voting where it is Yeah. Unless until there is a plural until there is a plurality or a sorry a majority vote. You take all the votes. You take everybody who voted like this thing as their number 10 or as their number one and take it out and then go to the number two. It's like the rank choice voting in in Alaska. Whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa, whoa. Okay. Okay. All right. Uh I was having like a panic attack. I still think this is a little bit weird, but I uh was looking again at the uh historic winners here. Uh Mech versus Minions was the first one. And then we have Gloom Haven, The Mind, The Crew, Gloom Haven, Jaws of the Lion, The Crew again, Mission Deep Sea. So, I guess we got a lot of cooperative trick taking going on here, Return to the Dark Tower, Sky Team, and then finally, Fellowship of the Ring.

What's missing from there is Pandemic Legacy, uh, which Pandemic Legacy did come out 2015, so that explains why it's not on here. They didn't have a dedicated um a dedicated genre for it. Uh, and also, I find it kind of weird that Sorry, hold on. Uh, Pandemic Legacy, who won in 2017? Gloom Haven. Oh yeah, heard. I was surprised I forgot that that was I forgot that was 2017. I was about to be upset that Spirit Island didn't win. Yeah, Gloom Haven. Gloom Haven. Gloom Haven. Yeah, that Gloom Haven. Okay, that changed the game. Okay. All right. Um Um but still Surprise Pandemic Legacy season 2 or season zero didn't uh get it kind of as like an honorary nod. Uh but uh you know it is what it is. Uh what what's our next category? Next category expansions.

So we have arcs blighted reach expedition gears of corruption. Two different forest shuffle uh forest shuffle alpine and forest shuffle woodland edge. Uh, Gaia Project, The Lost Feed, Heat, Heavy Rain, Obsession, Characters Expansion, Sky Team, Turbulence, Terraforming Mars, Prelude 2, and The White Castle Matcha, which you have just released a review on. You should all go check that out, listeners and viewers of this podcast. Um, if you haven't already, I assume you probably have if you're listening to this podcast. Feel like we're probably in a good spot there. Um, with the winner being Arcs the Blighted Reach expansion. Um, how you feeling about that, Eric? How you feeling about this? Sure. I listen, we were talking about expansions recently and I said that Arc the Blighted Reach expansion is one of my favorite expansions. I think it does so much to open up open up that world. At the same time, um, I'll be perfectly honest, I haven't played many of these expansions, so I'm not going to really comment on many of these things, but Sky Team Turbulence I have played.

Yeah, I've played a good amount of these. Uh, I've played a good amount of these. Uh, the Listen, I love arcs. Uh, I actually like arcs better without the bladed reach, but even still, I like arcs with the bladed reach. And I I could totally see this, but there is something in my bones that feels weird about a simultaneously released expansion taking the best expansion uh category. I don't know how else to do it, you know, like I I don't I don't know either. You can't entirely disqualify it either, but it feels so weird that, you know, like an add-on at the time that a game is released to be taking the the best expansion. Um, I don't know, like there's not a better way to do it. Uh, and in a lot of ways, arcs, it was originally developed with the content of the blight of breach in mind. So, when someone is saying the most innovative game, are they talking about arcs with the Blighted Reach expansion or are they talking about arcs on its own? I I recognize that's a different category, but having it here is just it's weird. It's squishy. I don't love it. I would much rather this go to uh another It could it could go to the runner

upgra was the runner up. I kind of agree especially with the fact that Arcs the Blinder Reach was like what Arcs originally was intended to be and then they took it and separated out. I can see that being a little bit flimsy of it being like this is a expansion when it was originally intended to be part of the base game that they then separated off. With that though, it is a popularity contest and it makes total sense to me that arcs is is going to win that. Um, I'm actually kind of surprised that some of the categories that arcs didn't win that it was up for excl, but just because I think that it is interesting with it being such a the like I will say the most popular game of last year. Like there are definitely other games in contention, but just in terms of popularity, Arcs had the most hype around it. Arcs was definitely like one of the most talked about games. Um yeah, and that leads me to our next category after you you go ahead and say yours, but I have some thoughts about arcs in the next category.

Yeah. So, uh you know, innovative the the winner for innovative was ARCs with runners up forage and STI. Um, and I I I disagree as far as being an innovative game. If we are talking about arcs with blighted Reach, I I'm here for it. Uh, if we're talking about arcs on its own, I don't know that I would necessarily call that a super innovative game. Like like what do you think? Uh, I disagree or I disagree with Arcs winning the category. I yeah I think that arcs so if we're gonna say arcs the bloody reach expansion is an expansion like we're we're we're we're saying that arcs the base game is you're not considering that when you're considering it just saying arcs in terms of the game now like in theory if you had changed it to be like arcs the blighted reach expansion in terms of innovative I could see that argument much more but like city of six moons is a game that's in completely alien language that you have to decipher while playing the game to figure out the rules of the game that you're playing.

Yeah. Like I'm and I haven't even played City of Six Moons. I don't even know if I would have voted for it in this category, but like Arcs I think is is an amazing game. I had it as my favorite game of last year. Like I clearly enjoy Arcs. I don't know that I would see like if we're voting on just the term innovative. I don't know that arcs gets my vote in this category. Again, it goes back to it's a popularity contest. I mean, it does have some novel things. It's got the the uh tricktaking action system. Um the declarative point system uh that happens uh you know, like that. That's really cool. It does some new things. Um, but I think even uh Kelp would be a good example of something that uh I don't think I've ever played a hidden movement game that looks or feels like Kelp and blends disperate systems in the way that it does. So, like, you know, uh I think we as a community should be thinking about not just what our favorite game is that's possible to vote in each uh category, but think about like what it is that we are that we're recognizing within the concept of each category because this is, you know, one of those things where your vote is manifesting things in the

industry by recognizing ing certain things as worthwhile endeavors for being uh innovative, then that's that's going to shape the minds of publishers who, you know, don't want to take too many risks in putting something out there. Now, again, arcs, we love arcs, right? You know, we have nothing against arcs that there's an opportunity for many games to shine in different ways. Um, but uh yeah, let let's uh let's carry on. Uh we got a lot of categories to go. I'm going to skip the next few categories. I'm actually Let's just I'm going to swap to just saying the the runners up and the winner for each category. Uh for party game, which is what I'm going to jump to next. Uh the runners up were Things and Rings, The Gang, and Flip Seven. I'm going to go ahead and say it. I don't see The Gang as a party game, but sure it's still a solid game from from what we played at PAX. I think it's a totally reasonable game. Um I haven't played Flip 7, so I'm not going to disparage it. I will say Things in Ring Things and Rings is is so much fun.

Yes, it's I feel like it's difficult for me to like I don't think I would have voted for any of these other games even having played them. But again, this goes back to I haven't played Flip 7, so I don't know. Flip 7 might be might be very fun. I think uh Things and Rings to me is the best uh in this category. I I have played Flip 7. Um I I've played all of these games at this point. I agree with you. I don't think the gang is really a party game. very confused about it being in this category. Things and rings would have been a great contender for the best innovative game. Like uh and it's man like it's such a cool concept. It does what you want out of a party game in getting people talking. like the the rule system is squishy or or subjective in just the right way where you get people talking about like what is allowable or not allowable or how did you think about this like in the way that um bananagrams or not bananagrams uh apples to apples the other fruitbased game you know like brings a level of personal subjectivity and interpretation but then causes you to discuss why you did or did not think something applied there. Um it it has a degree of that, but using ven diagrams is such a smart system. Um it is inviting. It's

quirky. It's weird. And that art aesthetic as a direct nod to uh Dr. Seuss's illustrations. Like man, talk about something that is inviting people to the table. Uh the total miss in not having this as the winner of the category. Uh I'm going to go on a very small tangent just because I feel like it is related. Bananagrams uh a friend of mine uh plays it with her wife and doesn't she's not the best speller and she openly admits that. So whenever they play Bananagrams, they do uh thematic bananagrams. And what that means is they when they play they care less about spelling, but all of your words have to be based on a specific category. Uh, which the best one so far has been ginzy baby names where you have to like you get you take your letters, you play bananagrams as normal, but you don't have to care about spelling. You just have to put out words that you can you can argue fits the theme. and everybody at the end of the round goes around explaining how their words possibly fit the theme.

That's very fun. Would recommend people try that out. The next category is print and play. Um I'll say I've only played one of these games. I despite print and play being like something that I I feel like I did a ton when I started out the hobby, I I I missed I missed this year. And I'll I'll I'll wear that on on my sleeve. I listen audience, are we outing ourselves right here? Like are you listening to this and going like, "Are these guys really board gamer reviewers?" Like, we try to play so many new games. We're publishing games, often multiple reviews every week. Like at least one new review every week, sometimes multiple. and yet the there are so many games that uh you know don't come to the forefront. Um but yeah, I I wonder like it would be interesting to see how many like what percentage of each category the average voter has logged a play in. Like I think that would be really cool data, you know, like of the people who log plays with regularity, what percentage of those people who have logged plays have played, you know, 50% of the games in each category. Well, and that's something that Board Game Arena did for theirs.

Just hold on. I'm trying to pull up their rules, but they did uh because it's all within their own uh within their system. They were able to be like unless you have played a game, you cannot vote on a game. You can you cannot vote in this category unless you have logged a play in every game that is that is currently up for up for voting. And I there's speaking of did did did you see the recent news that the academy the motion picture academy was going to begin requiring that voting members have seen all movies and like the the major shock that everyone has is like wait a second the people who are voting on these haven't seen all movies it is a lower barrier to entry to watch a movie like playing a game you get sent them all the time. I listen, I know a ton of people who used to be in the uh used to be in the academy in some way and they got sent so many movies all the time nonstop.

Yeah. And DVDs, you you have uh obligations and other things to do. Same thing here. We haven't played all these games, but I would argue watching a 2-hour movie is so much less of an investment than playing a game, often multiple times, to form an opinion because the first time that you're playing, you're just learning that game. And you have to also arrange for someone else to be there to learn the game with you. and you have to go through the process of like reading the rule book, learning to play a game and like getting it played is so much more of an investment than like uh uh watching a movie or watching a show or anything. But, and I think that goes back to games are much more of a time commitment than than a lot of other media where it's like just to get an opinion on a game, you have to read the rule book and learn how to play it and then play it a couple times. With the print and plays, the runners up were forage, a nine card solitire, Rome, fave empire, and the winner being 52 Realms Adventures. I am going to go ahead and say I don't know enough to have a strong opinion on this category. Uh this is one that they're just I I had played Grim World. That was the one I had played. I had fun with it. I don't know that I would say it's necessarily the best print game of the year. With that

said, I haven't played other printandplay games this year. Like I have, but not not of the ones nominated. I've played other print andplay games, but not ones that were up for consideration. And I pretty much don't play any print and play games. I play uh print and play games that my buddy Mike Heyman designs, you know, like those are the only print and play games that I play. Uh so not a good category. Not a good category personally. Next one. Solo games is my category. Uh I say not having played the winner. The runners up are But you really want to play the winner. Really want to play the winner. It is so tough to get a hold of this game. The runners up are Imperium Horizons. Good job. Gloom Haven: Buttons and Bugs, which Jack has a review on. Uh, and the winner is Slay the Spire, the board game. I have not been able to feasibly get a copy of Slay the Spire, the board game.

Uh it's just it is it I got a budget for board games and I cannot spend $100 on Slay the Spire the board game. Mhm. Uh yeah, sure. This one again makes sense to me because it just it had so much hype and the other solo games I just don't think came into this with enough hype other than maybe Civolution. Um, Imperium Horizons definitely had hype, but not to the level Slay the Spire did. Uh, I would be surprised I would have been surprised if any other game won other than Slay the Spire. Not because it it should have or shouldn't have won, but more so it just is it's it is such a wide widely known and revered game so far. I am surprised that Buttons and Bugs didn't take it here because of the uh beloved nature of Gloom Haven. Um, and I honestly think that the reason is that there is a smaller percentage of people who will buy a 100% dedicated solo game like Buttons and Bugs. Yeah.

As opposed to people who would get Slay the Spire because they really love Slay the Spire. They want to play Slay of the Spire and they happen to play the solo version of it as well, which I bet is the reason why Slay the Spire is at the top of this. Looking at the previous winners uh of this category, the majority of the winners have been multiplayer games that have uh a a solo component as opposed to fully dedicated uh solo games. Um, that said, there recently has been more of those. Uh, Under Falling Skies, one in 2020. Uh, Final Girl 2021. Uh, Legacy of You was 2023. Um, so like those are all dedicated solo games. But outside of that, which surprisingly there was a solo category before there was a cooperative category.

um since 2014 is when uh solo games have been voted on. Um you know like Scythe is one of the winners here. Honestly, I I never really liked Scythe as a solo game. It's not a good solo game. Um I have a question and this goes back this goes back to a different year. Did Gloom Holden win best print and play in 2021? If if you have that in front of you. I don't have all the years in front of me. I just have like the current year and I just it sounds like you might have them. Yeah. Uh so if you just Google Golden Geek Awards, this is good for audience to know because it's important to know about our history. Um you'll come to a page that uh has uh both the award sets which you can look at the years but then there's also a categories feature which is really nice. So I'm just clicking on the print and play. Holden did win that year. Yep. So, yep. Okay. The interesting My Little Scythe won as the best print and play before it became a uh official title that Stonemire released. Yeah. Um, okay. So, Solo Games, Slay the Spire one, sure. Makes sense. To me, it makes sense to you. It sounds like you were expecting Gloom Haven to win, but I kind of agree with the thought that a non solo only game might have a better chance to win this just because more

people will own it and therefore have played it. Uh, I'm going to go out on a limb and say I think people who love solo games. If if people who viewed themselves as a solo gamer exclusively voted for this, I think Imperium Horizons would win. Probably solo players love that freaking game. I bet you there's a lot of people who are voting for Golden Geeks who don't really care about solo games who voted for Slay the Spire. That's why I'm going out on a limb here. It may be absolutely excellent, but uh that might also be the case. I think what I will point out is through the voting system, if you vote on any game and then just choose in a as in you didn't play it for the other games, it ranks those games as your lowest ranked game. So like if you have all like if you only have played seven of the games, the other three games will all be your eighth ranked game. Uh, right. So, I can definitely see it being like, oh, I've played Slay the Spire. It was my I'll put it at like number four, but I haven't played the rest of these, so I'm gonna put NA as all of those.

That makes sire your number one. Uh, right. Is what it is. Uh, I think solo game is so like what a person's favorite solo game is t tends to be more subjective than I think a lot of other categories just because it really is one person's sole opinion. Uh, yeah, so is what it is. Um, thematic game is the next category. This is another one that the definition for it is squishy. Uh, the runners up are the Lord of the Rings Duel for Middle Earth, uh, Let's Go to Japan with the winner being STI: Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence. Jack Boo, I disagree with this. I mean, I I I disagree with this as well.

I like STI. Uh, I had a conflicting opinion on SEI. As I've played more SETI, I've enjoyed SETI more. But nonetheless, I think there are many more thematic games that could be recognized in this category where the theme is better integrated into the game system itself. SETI has a lot of theme, but I do not think that there are a ton of decisions that you're making that correlate to that theme in the same way that again Kelp I think would be a great example of utilization of theme. Pagan uh would have been a great uh utilization of theme. What's that? Yeah, it's a 2022 release.

Pagan is Pagan. Yeah, I I looked it up too cuz I was going to bring it up in two-player game, but then I I saw that it is a 2022 release. Pagan Fate of Ro is crazy. It is very kickstarted. Or maybe it was a European release and it was just getting an American uh release uh when we were uh recently doing it. Yeah. Um, but yes, uh, I think I I I I agree with your disagreement. Uh, SEI to me, and this is nothing to do with the game itself. I just feel like the theme didn't really fit the gameplay in a way that I felt was like, oh, this theme works great with this game. Yeah. Uh in a similar way that I think I am glad that arcs didn't win this category because I really love arcs. I think the theme is really great and I think the gameplay is really great. I don't know that I necessarily think of those things as being like Arcs is a really great thematic game in the way that I would agree that Kelp feels really thematic in terms of like the octopus is like pushing and pulling like an octopus while the shark is like hunting for prey. Um yeah, honestly I think a jest of Robin Hood would be really great here as well. Uh, I think that even though just feels more abstract, it still I I

think has this essence where, you know, like I if if you're the Merry Men player, you're feeling, you know, cheeky and, you know, subversive and playing as the sheriff, you you have to rule with an iron fist and entrap Robin Hood. like it it's tapping into the theme in ways where you can correlate what you're doing to what it's supposed to represent in um in a way that I don't think Sadi does or even for that matter the runners up in this, you know, like I I I think this is a missed opportunity or a misunderstanding of what what we're trying to Another one that I would just put up for it and I know that it's it's a much smaller release. I wouldn't expect it to be on this list. I'm not like really I I do not consider myself surprised, but uh We're Syncing to me was like one of the most thematic games I played last year just in terms of like I was really like I am a pirate trying to kill a monster and also like be mean to the crew that I'm working with and like try to get as much like I felt like there was such a beautiful that to me was like one of the best marrying themes to mechanics uh in a game that I played.

That would probably be my winner. But Si said he ain't it. Saidi ain't it. In this category, uh the next category is War Game. We have two runners up, which is Dune, War for Arachus and Aest of Robin Hood with the winner being Arcs. I agreed. I I guess I disagree. depends on what you're looking for in war game. But yeah, I disagree only for the sake of I I don't mentally consider Arcs a war game. Like it it is I get that cuz it's a confl it. It's a conflict and collapse in the reach. It is conflict. It is a conflict game. And I can see in the same way that there's a lot of deliberation on something like Blood Rage. You know, Blood Rage has a conflict heavy theme. It is a conflict heavy game, but you know, like you're you're trying to obtain points and conflict is only one of the mechanisms to do that. Yeah. Like in in a way like I would totally Root Root is a war game.

Totally consider Root being a war game. Arcs there just are so many other ways to succeed in that game. Like you can in theory it's probably not the most optimal way of playing. In theory, you can win never having entered a battle willingly. Um, especially if we're talking about the with the Bladed Reach expansion. Yes, I think if you are playing arcs well um basically it does require you to I either you are going to enter a battle uh because you chose to or because someone else did. you know, like I if other players are doing what they are needing to do uh to remain competitive, they're putting pressure on you. Um that so like if you're just kind of hovering outside of battle, it is up to the other players at that table to gang up on you to make sure that you don't become too entrenched and and too uh expansive. Um, and I think that's something that the game recognizes as part of its design. But when we're talking about The Blight of Reach, I think there are too many competing priorities to really say that it is going to be a war game because there are a lot of, you know, like what you're doing might have nothing to do with battle. And what I'm doing might have nothing to do with battle. So, we don't really have an incentive to combat one another except for when it's either

interacting with NPCs or we're competing over say the the same resource um or or you know certain things on the table. Um, one game that didn't get a runner up or the winner that I do just want to point out because we mentioned it earlier in this podcast, Red Dust Rebellion, which has come out. We just mentioned it earlier and we were talking about we weren't sure if it came out or not. It did come out. In fact, it was nominated. So, it came out last year at some point. Um, yeah, I am kind of surprised in this category that arcs winning again, if we're thinking of it as a popularity contest, AR20 makes sense. Like even even like completely ignoring the hesitation I would have to vote for it as a war game.

Like even if it we're taking it as it is a war game, Arcs makes sense is winning its popularity contest. Arcs is one of the most popular games and especially from this list the most popular game that was on this list. I'm right based on that reasoning kind of surprised that Undaunted 2200 Kalisto which was a nominee wasn't a runnerup but a Robin Hood makes sense to me like that is a two-player war game uh in so much as the conflict that you have in that game is a very central focus of it. Um, I'm kind of surprised that uh Oh, now I forget what I was going to say. I was in the middle of saying it. I have to go back up to where I was thinking. Ironwood. I'm surprised Ironwood wasn't nominated here. Actually, that that's the one that I was thinking of as would be a very good uh contender in here. Um, so Undaunted. Uh yeah, I I think Undaunted uh always deserves uh more recognition because it's amazing. Um and Ironwood is interesting because that's another one of those games where what you're doing isn't necessarily uh combat related. Um, combat informs the game, but one player is kind of

doing like a capture the flag type thing and the other player is doing kind of like a base building thing and the twain does not need to meet. Um, unless you are playing well and you're trying to interfere with your opponent or your opponent just happens to be where you need to uh capture your flag from or you are uh trying to capture a flag and someone else is already in the middle of building a fortification there. Um, Ironwood has a level of specificity. I think that uh will put it at a disadvantage here in that it's a high price two-player game. Um the components are really amazing. Uh and the illustrations are incredible and probably could have been in that illustrations category. um and presentation like holy cow, you know, the the metal pieces in that that that really should have been uh uh one of the top runners. But at the same time, um it kind of has this conflict heavy war game feel. It's more expensive than a typical two-player game as we think of them as more dimunive games for the most part now. Uh and yeah, so I I don't know. Uh, I think it should have been in here, but it it wasn't. Congratulations, Arcs.

Great job being a War Game. Congratulations. Uh, the next category is best podcast, which uh we got to get ourselves on this one of these years, Jack. You and I. Wait, I can't nominate because I don't have enough things. Uh, I don't have enough key gold. But, uh, the winner, so, let me this one. Um, I I think this is a great one to end on. Uh because this is uh well we're pretty much at the end of this list. There's a best board game app. Yeah, that is what I don't know. I don't know that that's really that important for for this discussion. Uh but uh ending here uh there are so many amazing voices in the board game hobby. Uh and uh of course we love that our audience supports us, but I am just I I totally recognize uh these um uh other podcasts that are here uh and I like all the people involved in them.

So, the runners up, Space Biff. If you don't listen to this podcast, or even more so, if you don't read Space Biff's reviews, those are the types of written reviews that I wished I could write when I got into covering board games. um incredibly inspirational as a writer, as a critic, as a thoughtful person thinking about uh a hobby and a medium and having a degree of self-awareness and uh levity, but at the same time um balancing that with gravitas and depth uh and and critical analysis. I think Space Biff is the best writer in the board game space, period. Um, Board Game Hot Takes. Uh, Tim has been on our podcast. Uh, I've loved to see, uh, that, um, Board Game Hot Takes has grown, uh, and is such a great format for, uh, a, uh, podcast. It's something that I wish I had thought about.

Um, we actually have a category on this channel called uh TCBH hot takes that predates board game hot takes, but it was nowhere near as smart as what they do of some friends getting together, playing one session of a game, and then talking about it. Just talking about what their opinion is, and pulling it apart. That's so smart. And it I I I've only uh interacted with Tim, who kind of handles most of the social media, their stuff, does the most outreach, goes on other podcasts, that kind of stuff. Um I I'm just a huge fan of what they do. Uh and then Beyond Solitire, the winner. Yes, Beyond Solitaire is the winner. And Liz is just one of the best people in the hobby. And I I've met with her in person a few times. uh her involvement uh in the um Zenobia Awards is really great and she along with uh a few other people including Kirley uh came on to the Cardboard Herald podcast to uh talk about that when Zenobia was in its inception and she's now the solo arm of Leader Games which is so cool and such wonderful recognition. um just an amazing podcast, an amazing presence and someone who has put in the time in this hobby uh really giving thorough

thoughtful analysis and perspective for years. So totally deserved. Yeah, totally. I uh very happy with both the winner and the runners up here in terms of like where for the hobby. These are just super influential podcasts and I think that they are great to represent the hobby. Uh we do have three more categories. I skipped them over. Three more. We got light game of the year, medium game of the year, and heavy game of the year. We've talked about all of these games frequently, so I'm not going to like really go too deep into it. Um, the winner of light game of the year voted on by the Golden Geek Awards is Castle Combo. The winner of medium game of the year is Harmonies. And the winner of heavy game of the year is SETI: Search for Extraterrestrial Intelligence.

I'm going to go ahead and put my flag in the ground here saying harmonies probably should have been a light game of the year. Like it's it's it's weird. It's they've bracketed it off in weird ways where it feels like like harmonies and worms being in the same category feels like it shouldn't be the case. like Harmonies just is so much lighter rules explanation than some of these other games. It harmonies being in the same category slay the spire doesn't feel right and I it's still one. Uhhuh. But I'm surprised especially considering some of the things that are in light game of the year that harmonies was bumped up to this range. Um good for castle combo. I guess I'm back to being confused, the voters of this situation where it's like they've had other games in light game of the year like Flip 7 won one best party game like it flip 7 was like one of the only games nominated for other things. Same with uh like the gang was also nominated for a few other things but then it didn't win. So, I'm a little bit confused with the voters. Um, I I think really they're going for like time frame on the the light versus medium. You know, less complexity and more to do with the amount of time that it takes. Um, what

really jumps out to me, uh, one, heavy game of the year. I am so surprised that arcs didn't win this. So, didn't win this. STI is very wellliked. I wonder if um you know with SETI being a a CGE game uh uh Czech games um release I wonder if there's a more diehard European fan base uh for that that isn't necessarily as strong uh in arcs but from what I can see in the uh Englishspeaking discourse of course, um, arcs seemed to be the darling, uh, for everyone, uh, and STI definitely was beloved, but I I just do not see the kind of fervor, uh, in online discourse for it. So, this was really shocking to me.

Um, what was also very shocking is one of our favorite games, um, Harvest nowhere on any of these. And I wonder if it wasn't available for consideration because it is a uh, remake of a pre-existing game. But if that's the case, I would argue that Harvest has as many thematic and mechanical changes to it uh as the Lord of the Rings duel for Middle Earth does. Um shipthesis Jack. Ship Athesus. Yeah. I don't know. It's crazy. Um so, you know, like anytime that there's award ceremonies, you could pick apart the the semantics. And I do have to have a degree of sympathy for the people who are always putting these things together because you have to draw the line somewhere and sometimes that doesn't mesh with other decisions. But if you fiddle with it in one place, then you start overanalyzing everything else and there there's no way that you're going to be able to perfectly satisfy all of those disperate elements. So I imagine even the people who were putting this together were like, man, I don't know. is kind of bunk, but we got to make a decision somewhere. So, let let's settle with this. Yeah. And I mean, I think the fact that it is community voted kind of lets them go.

Hands are clean. Let them make this decision. They did. Uh the nominee situation I also I'm I'm not perfectly clear on where it's like h how do things get nominated necessarily, but I think that it it because I also know that the community put up things for nomination. So I wonder if it is just like another they've put things up for nomination. Maybe Harvest just wasn't on the list for people. Uh I don't really know. But that is the Golden Geek Awards. If you're wondering who won best board game app, it was Dune Imperium. I liked that app. Sure. Right. Go right ahead. Dire Direwolf Digital had like a couple games in that nomination. Sure. Great. That sounds good. If nothing else, if nothing else, uh, this brought to my attention that Code Names had a 2024 app and made me go like, whoa. Yeah, that was Code Names.

It was big at uh, PAX. There was a real heavy push by CG. Yeah, when we went to our CGE uh, event, they had like separate boots to enter the CGE room. That That's how on the periphery board game apps are for me. Um I I really need to get with the times. You do. Um cool. Well, uh were there any other notable um uh snubs here for you or particular games that uh you really wanted to see or uh categories, you know, in the way that we discussed uh solo games were a new addition to the Golden Gates throughout its lineage. Um cooperative games become became a new category. The next year is going to be the 20th annual Golden Geeks. Is there a category that you would like to see next year? I have I have two categories that I would like to pitch. One would be small publisher.

I think that could be a really fun way to just the there are so many smaller publishers that could really benefit from being nominated and just having more people see them. And I also think that that just is super healthy for the hobby to have that be something that gets recognized of here's the best game from a small publisher. Um, and then the other one would be like best under represented community. We kind of already have the Zenobia Awards, so I don't know if we need this, but this game would be more about the finished product. Uh, and it feels kind of tough. Well, especially because next year I feel like there's just going to be it will be tough for any game to I feel like beat Molly House in that category if it comes out, right? Just because of where Molly House stands. Uh I I this is saying less about any games that have come out this year that fit that category, but more so just the hype that Molly House has uh is definitely going to carry it into into the win if that were a category. But I the the small publisher would be the one that I would more want to see.

I think I I would like to see um maybe as a better way to handle small publisher, which I think these could coexist. Um but uh debut uh either debut by a designer or a debut by a publisher. Um maybe those could both exist. Maybe they could uh be one category, you know, uh either uh debut by a designer or a publisher. Or maybe uh these exists in parallel to um small uh publisher because small publisher feels like there are so many small publishers in this hobby. What what does constitute a small publisher? Is Stonem Games a small publisher? They don't have a very big team, but at the same time, they're like the biggest most mainstream within the the hobby gaming side of this hobby. You know, they're they're not Milton Bradley. They're not Asthma Day, but as far as a hobby gamer, you know what? Wingspan, it's Wingspan, baby. You know what Wingspan is. Uh, one other one that I or just this is less like a new category, but just I would love a definition of what is light game of the year, what is medium game of the year.

Yeah. Well, and I I saw some comments talking about how it's broken down by the board game weight ranking, but I don't know, maybe switch to like playtime. Like playtime could be an interesting one. Instead of going light game of the year, mediumheavy, playtime feels like that would be a natural these are the games that are competing with one another or these are the games that are meant to be competing with one another. But those are my thoughts. Uh do you have any closing thoughts on the Golden Geeks? Uh just once again, you know, like it's great that uh we have a community that's uh so participatory. Uh and we have, you know, like a a cool centralized place.

This matters, you know, like this matters a lot for publishers. It matters a lot for designers, artists, and all the people who work in this industry and you as the gamer. Like these are the games that surface to the top. Even if you never go to the uh Golden Geek page, the the amount of traffic that it brings to these games ends up making this recursive uh interest, you know, this compounding uh effect where uh it brings traffic which then brings it to the top of the hotness which if it's at the top of the hotness is going to get more people who are just clicking on it because they're like, "Wait, why is flip seven, you know, number one, two, three, four down on the hotness. Uh, and then they click on that, which then confirms its position at the hotness and then they're looking at the Golden Geek Awards, you know, like these things really impact uh how people view these games. Uh, so it's great that people uh participate in it and it's great that it exists. So those are those are my closing thoughts. Yeah, thank you for your thoughts. Thank you to the audience for tuning in. Thank you for listening to our podcast. Uh if you have any thoughts you want to share, feel free to comment on this episode on YouTube or Spotify. Uh or email them in to uh cardboard herald@gmail.com. Uh we are so happy that you have taken this time to listen

to us chat about uh the big awards of the year. Uh and give us your spicy takes. I want to hear your spicy takes on these. Spiciest takes spiciest takes possible down in the comments below. Uh, thanks for tuning in. I have been Eric along with a Jack for the Cardboard Herald podcast. Bye.

Progress saved