Skip to main content
Loading video...

Which Fallout Board Game Should You Buy for Solitaire Play? A Comparison

Transcript 19:07

hello everyone welcome I'm Robert and today I want to help you decide which fallout board game is best for you for soliter play I'm going to compare Fantasy Flight games Fallout versus modus Fallout wasand Warfare Miniatures game and just so you know made uh videos individually discussing these uh two board games uh extensively so I'll link those in the description so you can watch those individually if you want to hear my extended thoughts on each but now for this video I'm going to compare both titles in different categories let's get started okay so first thing I want to discuss is what you get for the money okay so uh The Fallout board game with the two expansions is going to set you back at the very least $100 depending on where you are uh there's some um stock stock issues with the new California expansion for the Fallout board game uh but if you're going to play it solo at the very least you have to get the um Atomic bonds expansion okay uh and uh when you add both expansions at least $100 uh I don't recommend that you get the Fallout board game just uh for the base game uh the solo experience is not very satisfying there uh so that's the Fallout board game now for Wasteland Warfare for Wast Warfare uh for the core set you're looking at at least $80 depending on where you get it but it msrps for around $80 as of the recording of this uh now uh for Wasteland Warfare you're going to have to spend a nonzero amount of money

on terrain uh which I discussed on the my video overview uh so you know you could just use whatever you have around you or just make paper terrain or just use whatever you have at home already but for the best experience for uh fallout Wasteland Warfare you have to SP you should spend at least 20 to $30 on a bare minimum amount of terrain okay so you're looking at about $100 for both games minimum right if you want all the expansions for the base game and um uh waste and warfare now uh for the money if you're going to spend this amount of money I would say that the Fallout board game from Fantasy Flight games gets you the most bang for your buck uh Wasteland Warfare does offer a very neat experience and it does have plenty of uh uh you know content that you can uh play in that uh starter set but uh if we if we're talk if we're talking longevity uh definitely you're going to get a lot more uh out of the Fantasy Flight game board game with expansions uh versus modif Wasteland Warfare so on the value category I'm going to give it two uh Fantasy Flight games um for their board game version now keep in mind little side note for um for Wasteland Warfare there's a vast amount of expansion so it is a system in which you can get a lot out of it if you want the more you invest in it okay but it's not cheap and Beyond the starter set at the very least you're going to need some terrain uh but

that's a value category uh I'm going to give that to Fantasy Flight games uh version of the board game and let's move on to the next category okay so which game has the more approachable rules so the Fantasy Flight game uh fallout board game has a what in theory should be an easy straightforward rule set but it's uh marred by the fact that uh because you have to add the expansions to get the best solo experience you're going to be joggling between different Rule books you're going to have the base set uh learn to play guide then the extended rules reference then each expansion has their own rule book so you're going to be juggling between four different rule books and it was a bit of a miser learning experience for me okay so I just did not have a good time learning this game it's not intuitive at all uh and there were many rules that were kind of um uh prone to being misinterpreted or uh just easy just or just rules that were very easy to miss there's very very important rules that are almost like hidden that and this will just warrant a very careful studying of the rules across all four different documents especially if you add the expansions it just becomes a bit of a pain uh so I had a horrible experience learning uh The Fallout uh Fantasy Flight games uh version of the board game now on the other side with Wasteland Warfare uh it is a long rule book uh but so it is a

bit more complex than fantas the Fantasy Flight games board game which uh it again in theory the other one should be uh easy uh you know you just pick two actions and that's it in theory it should be u a bit less complex but for with Wasteland Warfare uh although it has a long rule book it has a nearly 60-page rule book uh it is a master class rule book and everything is very clear easy to find everything is indexed you're not going to have to juggle between different Rule books uh well uh except when you do play solo you you're going to look at the scenario rule book that that really is it for the most part uh it does even have a little tutorial rule book that you can start with but but the main rule book if you just take your time and study that you're going to be prepared and everything is easy to find it's very clear U so Master Class rule book and uh hands down I'm going to give the in the rules category uh I'm going to give it to Wast not Warfare just I had a much better experience although uh the ru book being longer took me a bit more time to go through it but just such a such a much more Crystal Clear uh uh rule Set uh that you know didn't get in the way of me enjoying the the game uh so the rules category goes to uh Wasteland Warfare all right so now I want to discuss the game play uh so Fantasy Flight games Fallout is a adventuring game uh where you're allowed to just control one character up to four characters and you're going to explore the land and uh you know this discover locations go on quests and there's um a

very cool mechanism where there's this numbered Quest cards where when you finish a quest then it prompts you to bring out another specific numbered card and put it on the table also known as staging the card and uh it'll basically give you these Quest chains okay that go on for a while and it'll motivate you to move around the map and explore and go to different locations okay uh now uh on the solo uh version of the game there is a bit of a timer element which unfortunately doesn't allow you to just explore indefinitely like you would in the video game uh you do have to make sure you tackle the main quest uh because you're going to run out of time eventually if you don't make sure that you tackle the main quest okay so you can't just uh put the main quest uh and put it on the side like you would in the video game you have to also um you can explore a bit but you do have to tackle the main quest eventually so it's it can feel like a bit of a race sometimes U and now uh so and some scenarios uh do uh call for controlling multiple characters okay uh it can be a bit tough doing everything with one character it can beit it can feel a bit unfair it can feel like you don't have enough time uh the interesting thing is that it's very mod able so you can just give yourself more actions uh or make the scenario last a couple extra rounds I didn't mod it in any way I didn't house rule it in any way I don't do that uh but many people just house rule the game until it has the parameters that you want but I don't personally do that so if just playing straight out the out of the box the uh the experience can feel like a bit of a rush uh instead of just exploring at your own pace uh but it

does have very cool narrative elements it does a great job of creating uh crafting um emerging stories on the go it has a it's one of the best experiences I've had from many of the adventuring games that I've played uh where Fallout does it such a good job creating these emerging stories and funny interesting situations so very cool job at creating emerging stories through the engine uh that it has with the items or character uh the leveling up the RPG elements the exploration the quest cards it it it uh it's a great system that uh uh it's allows it's PR to creating these emerging stories that are very cool now on the other hand we have waste and warfare where it's a skirmishing game where it does offer some uh RPG uh campaign elements okay but I mostly experience just the skure machine part where you pick a faction uh so you have two factions you pick one to play against and then you play against the other faction using AI cards uh so the actions of the uh opposing faction are driven by AI cards that are very intuitive very well made and uh will um it'll make sure that you're not making decisions for the AI there might be a couple edge cases where you kind of have to push the AI in a certain direction but the AI cards make a really good job of uh they make a really good job of uh making the anime do in general intell intelligent actions that adapt to the situation okay uh some scenarios are just you know kill each other versus uh just completing objectives uh so uh

there's various scenarios that are uh that have different parameters um it's pretty much every scenario soloable if you really want to make it soloable but there's some solo specific scenarios that come in wasand Warfare um I mostly experienced it for the skir maching part it is a uh even if you remove the Fallout skin from the game it is just a great scare machine game in its own right rolling all the colorful dice is very fun uh so I loved it as is skir machine game uh gameplay wise okay so uh I have to say that I have the most fun with Wasteland Warfare uh with the uh the skirmishing it's just that there's not a lot of solo skirmishing games folks it's it's a bit of a category category that um uh there's not a lot of pickings in that category and uh Wasteland Warfare just provides a great uh solo skirmishing experience if you if you don't have a Warhammer like if you don't have anybody to play Warhammer with and you want a solo skir machine Miniatures game at home for Wasteland Warfare offers that and it does a great job and it's there's like an infinite amount of content if you really want to uh invest yourself into that system uh I think that a Fallout Wast night Warfare was a more fun experience for me uh great uh don't get me wrong the Fantasy Flight games uh fallout uh is a great adventuring game uh cool narrative experience uh but I the game play just from a pure gameplay perspective I had the most fun with um um with Fallout

Wasteland Warfare and little bonus if you enjoy painting terrain Wasteland Warfare offers that outlet for you to paint terrain uh and be creative with the terrain and setting up the maps which is part of the setup uh uh I I I love creating this maps with the the terrain that I have and just you know creating cool Dynamic um terrain maps for me uh you know for for the combat to take place so that part is super fun um and if you do one narrative elements Wasteland War also offers it but you're going to there's an additional rules element that you have to um um invest yourself like if you want like a legacy or like a between missions element uh was and warfare does offer that so at the end of a skirmish there's this settlement phase uh you know you can just Place scare missions individually but uh Wasteland Warfare offers a settlement phase where you have a persistent element between missions where you can level up your settlement so you can acquire gear uh there's some there's a narrative element that you can even expand upon with expansions or if you want to add more RPG elements or create your own scenarios so was n Warfare is definitely offers the most um amount of content if you want to expand upon it not just with the Miniatures but with modules uh so uh I I'm going to have to give the game gameplay category to uh Wasteland Warfare uh 100% in my opinion I had the most fun with it and if you wanted to have a lifestyle game um was on warfare is it uh you know it'll it'll take that uh War gaming um

that wargaming uh scare missing um miniature game box and also if you want the Fallout flavor uh that that's thrown in there as well okay so for this category I'll give it to uh Wasteland Warfare okay now moving on to ease of play and by that I mean setup tear down and table footprint so uh the Fantasy Flight games Fallout board game uh will fit in a smaller table compared to Wasteland Warfare so uh you can expect to be able to fit it in a 2x3 area conceivably uh maybe even less if you use certain uh add-ons like a business card holder or something like that to uh try to keep the elements organized so that uh like the cards especially so they don't occupy so much table room um uh but it's very modular you can uh you know you can move the parts of the game around so that you can try to fit it in a smaller space so uh you're not going to have much issues with that and setting up once you know what you're doing it's takes a about 10 minutes to set up between picking a character building the scenario map and all of that um now compare that to a wasand Warfare where you're going to need uh you're going to need at least a 3X3 feet area as many uh miniature games do uh you need a bigger area uh so not everybody might have I know I didn't I had to actually buy a table so that uh you know a foldable table so that I could play Wasteland Warfare so you're going to need a 3X3 area at the very least because it's not just the map area where the action will take place you're going to need to place the components

nearby like the cards the tokens and all of that so uh you're going to need uh ideally a four or 5 by3 feet table okay so you're going to need a much bigger table uh and you're not going to really be able to sit down that's un little detail but it's kind of important so uh with the Fallout board game you're going to be able to just sit down on a smaller area and just you know look at you're going to have everything within Arms Reach with Wasteland Warfare you're going to have to stand up move around because you're going to have to control the enemy Ai and you are going to have to walk to the other side of the table and move their Miniatures so you're going to be moving around a lot and you're going to need a bigger area uh so uh not to mention during setup uh you're going to have to build a map which takes longer I do enjoy building the map and with the terrain but that makes it take longer okay uh it does set up relatively quick All Things Considered for the cool experience that you get with Wasteland Warfare but it does take longer than the uh and more space than the um uh the Fantasy Flight games Fallout uh so um without a doubt I'm going to have to give the ease of play category to a Fallout by fantasy fight Fantasy Flight games uh because it's just uh you're it's just much more flexible for where you can play uh and you know not having to stand uh and with the footprint and all and even the setup time is faster once you know what you're doing so hands down ease of play goes to Fantasy Flight games uh board game and finally I want to discuss which game is the most faithful adaptation

from the video game and uh I have to say that by far that would be Fantasy Flight games Fallout board game um The Fallout Wasteland Warfare even though I had the most fun with it and even though it's a great skirmishing game in its own right I really do feel that if you removed anything Fallout related from it if you removed the Fallout skin from it uh and just applied another skin to to it from another IP you really would not be able to tell that it is a Fallout game there are a couple things like radiation damage and the special stats but you know those special stats you could just rename them to anything else really uh and so that only leaves you with the faction names and the uh you know like the the IP flavor but the game play it really didn't scream fall out for me even though it was really fun and I was having a blast now now on the other hand um The Fallout uh board game by Fantasy Flight games it just does such a much better job translating the uh the feeling of exploration and the emerging uh stories that come up randomly like the random Quest that you find and uh finding Loot and all of that uh it does translate that just so much better now if you want a narrative uh experience uh you can definitely get it from The Fallout Wasteland Warfare version but it will require a lot more work uh versus all the the engine and all the elements that you need are already offered if you

buy Fallout board game plus expansions with Fantasy Flight Games version versus with Wasteland Warfare you're going to have to buy modules like uh to expand upon the RPG elements you're going to have to kind of fill in the gaps yourself with the narrative elements it doesn't have any much of a handcrafted campaign or Quest much to speak of honestly uh and it it'll just require more work uh for you to do the element and the bookkeeping and the in between Miss missions for you to have that persistent element between the missions versus the Fantasy Flight Gams version you just play a session and in that couple hours session you just get a a whole fallout Fallout experience from beginning to end from being a a weak wastelander to being a powerful wastelander at the end and having had all of these Adventures uh you know from the start until the end okay uh so uh just hands down I have to give the most faithful adaptation uh aspect uh I awarded to uh the Fantasy Flight Games version but again don't get me wrong I I think that the Wast and warfare is a just a great scare machine game on its own right and I would prefer playing it if I had to pick a game that I wanted to play in general for mechanical for just for the mechanical aspect I much prefer um Wasteland Warfare but just being being real the fantasy fly Games version is a much more faithful adaptation to the video game and I hope that this helped you figure out which game is best for you if you

have any comments questions feedback go ahead and leave them in the comment section and make sure to like And subscribe if you enjoy this content and don't forget to check out my more in-depth videos that I made individually for uh fallout and Wast and warfare and again thank you so much for watching see you in the next one oh

Progress saved