Episode 158: Arkham Horror, Shadows:Amsterdam, Hail Hydra
Transcript
rolling dice and taking names is sponsored by the broken token creator of high-quality gaming accessories and storage solutions visit them online at the broken token da hey y'all it's time for another episode of rolling dice and taking names and this is not just Radio gaga the guys play the game Arkham Horror 3rd edition where we were not the champions don't stop me now plus they review shadows amsterdam's they are under pressure to deliver a good episode
welcome back to rolling dice and taking names this is episode number 1 5 8 that's 158 I'm going slightly mad I'm Tony and this is Marty and that of course for those who don't know is a song by the incredible band Queen who all have degrees high level degrees kind of like me and Marty and who who have also movie is just gonna come out Bohemian Rhapsody which there is a ton of trivia about for those of you who don't know it but more than portly this song is all about a recent game we got to play Arkham Horror and the fact that Marty went and saw Bohemian Rhapsody and I've yet to see it but what did you think I rarely if ever asked you to pick a group or song or whatever and this was one of those things that right after I saw the movie I reached out to you and said can you please pick a queen song for this one I didn't really care which one and when I saw the one you picked I thought oh that is so perfect with the fact that we're gonna be talking about Arkham har which is all about going insane I'm going slightly mad which is a song off their last album in 91 innuendo that is correct right before Freddie Mercury passed away so we went and saw the premiere of Bohemian Rhapsody made my entire family on Thursday night this is one of those movies that if you're a queen fan Tony I highly highly recommend going to see it is very well done you'll learn a lot about the band and the guy
who played federate Freddie Mercury was absolutely spot-on he did an incredible job I've been watching the trailers in the movies for I don't know I guess six months and when it first hit I said wait a minute that looks like really they did a movie I didn't even know this movie was coming out so I have been waiting patiently for this movie to hit the theatres and I am very excited I cannot wait to see it matter of fact I have to build up to this I've been watching a lot of YouTube and the video for I'm going slightly mad that is one weird video they did a lot of weird ones but even this one was kind of strange oh you know what I can't picture what that video was it's all black and white Freddy's dressed up it was just very strange I don't remember you know I don't I don't remember it when it originally came out I get this channel now on AT&T u-verse that's called axis do you get that channel I do not all right so I do not know I got this channel it plays various concerts and documentaries about various bands and they just recently had for an hour-long show they did where Queen went to Budapest it was amazing he freddie was incredible and I was in it oh man to have been at that concert after the Wall fell Oh amazing yeah it's one of those things that is as the Queen fan I was really sad when the movie is over basically it's not really spoiling anything it takes you through liveit oh okay and then does one of the things where it tells you kind of what happens the band through the years and
for those who don't know if Freddie Mercury died of a HIV related pneumonia and the thing was is he found out that he had AIDS in 87 but didn't publicly come out with it until 91 mm-hmm and in fact he didn't publicly announce it until 24 hours before he passed away right and I remember that year distinctively because I was working where you work now Tony I was working at what was then Duke power and I was in Pittsburgh for a month-long training session on the rod control system of a nuclear plant which could be a very exciting game on how to move rods up and down a crow and keep a reactor from blowing up just speculating exactly so I was stuck in Pittsburgh in February and then winter and this album came out and I had a rental car and I said I gotta have some music or something so I went and bought this album and it was a album it was a cassette because the rental car had a cassette player and everywhere I went I listened that album and it's one of those things that you know it doesn't get a lot of recognition as one of those it wasn't greatly critically acclaimed or anything like that but it's a solid solid albums kind of a throwback to their older stuff but I loved it and when he passed away in November it it really bothered me and then I went back and listened to innuendo and the last song that they did on that album the show must go on while it's like he knew that was probably his last album and the last song that he put on the album was the show must go on which is oh it's just
hard to listen to in fact on Friday last week after the movie I was started to listen to any window and it's just all this rushes of memories of 91 and and all this I couldn't even get to the album because it was just so flippin depressing there have been very few celebrities that when they passed away kind of affected me he was one whether you're a huge fan of coin or not I think everybody probably likes at least one Queen song right oh yeah they just want those bands that they have so many different types of songs probably every like everybody has like oh I do like that one oh yeah I completely agree everybody even if you don't know the words you pretend you know the words - we will rock you
everybody can can do at least a little bit of that song oh just and then the fact that Bohemian Rhapsody was brought back because of gentleman in the film Mike Myers doing it in Wayne's World and yeah you know my wife and I were discussing my wife's like I don't remember that I'm like I distinctly even when I was young remember listening to that so incredible man if you haven't listened to their music quick go out to YouTube just type in Queens start clicking on songs and well one of one of my favorite is from Highlander oh don't tell me it's um it's a it's it's a kind of magic no it would be oh my gosh what's the big one from Highlander tell me what is it no keep keep thinking I think you will come to you oh it's um oh my gosh I can't get this through must go on out of my head and it was from the album it's a kind of magic who wants to live forever that's it there's other things we grew up with Queen you know it was like they were there when we were born and then they're with us for decades and they never changed band members which was amazing which is which is unheard of so I'm sorry I know we've gone a lot about Queen but I was so torn up over that movie it's like please do a queen song as I just kind of want to give a tribute to them and and Brian May is an amazing musician and it was so funny as the guy who played Brian May and the movie looked more like Brian May than the guy who played Freddie Mercury real me and Adam were like holy crap could they couldn't have got a person that looked
any more like Brian May who is the guitarist you know I was talking about celebrities who affected me when they died the three other people that when they passed away I was I was like oh that hurt one I think was around 20 around 91 or 92 when Jimmy Valvano passed away okay it was like 92 93 he's the basketball coach for NC State Jim Henson mmm-hmm that's one that when he passed away who did the Muppets Sesame Street and all that kind of really bummed me out I didn't realize and the most recently of all people Harold Ramis Oh ghostbusters yes writers in so many movies from the 80s it was like all these people kind of affected my childhood in some sort of way and when they were gone it was just kind of sad for him to go and it's really interesting here you like your little travel stories I was in London when David Bowie passed away mm-hmm and you talking about a country going in the morning it was sad it was sad to be there and see all the memorials and the TV stations radio stations did nothing but play David Bowie songs all day long he was a big deal to me too but just just not to the effect that like Freddie Mercury was so that's enough depressing stuff right now but thank you for picking a queen song it's um they'll always be one of my favorite and all weekend long we've been playing we were saying hi Alexa play some queen for us there you go and you talk about the live aid in Wembley to be the band that followed Queen after that performance you're screwed you were so oh you know that was with my
crops had been invented back then boom that's it Bob legs over y'all I'll just send your money in later I mean Oh amazing I will say if you go see the movie go read articles that fact check the movie cuz there's stuff in there that they really changed even when the movie was over I looked at Vanessa ongoing something doesn't add up on the timeline in their story and I wouldn't looked it up myself and I yeah I knew they did they did us some they took some dramatic liberties well they should after you watch it go read good fact check it because it's not exactly accurate and I you really need to know what what really happened last tidbit because you brought it up when Michael Myers did the movie for Wayne's World originally the script had the scene in the car they were doing it to Guns & Roses welcome to welcome to the jungle mmm-hmm Mike Meyers said growing up he always had bang to Bohemian Rhapsody said no I've got to do my human rap ste and Lorne Michaels who was from the SNL who produced the movie said no no no it's gonna be Guns and Roses and Mike Myers said you know what it's either Bohemian Rhapsody or I'm walking off the set and Lauren Michael said let me get this straight you who've never done a movie and may never do another movie again is willing to walk off this movie over a song and Michael Myers went yep and Laura Michael said alright must mean that much to you so they made it but human Rhapsody in history was made yep boom there goes so let's let's liven things up if you're a member of the rolling dice and taking names pod pledge backers and you're ever
on our slack channel lighten your mood over there because our good buddy TR Knight who does a lot of editing on rulebooks has just recently posted a Jif of two squirrels doing push-ups wait a minute now for those of you oh my gosh that's hilarious so over in our Podge pledge backers Channel and slack Marty has dropped some bomb about having to do push-ups or a hundred push-up challenge or something I don't know what the devil they're talking about they've set up this tracking we've got a hashtag our DTN death by pushup miss fixing to happen I don't know what all that's about some other thing I'm trying to catch up on all this but Marty what the heck push it what it's the holidays Tony and during the holidays I put on weight every stinking year well duh who doesn't I know but after all after Halloween I got on the scales and I went no no no no no no no I need to do something physical to try to at least control the weight at least not try to gain and it's one of those things that when I years ago when I started running it's like a Ark I could never run a 5k well I found a program and guess what advence you ran a 5k Congrats thank you and then I thought to myself you know what there's no way I could ever do a hundred push-ups at a time I found a program over the weekend I said here's a six-week program to work towards doing a hundred push-ups so I made a little video and posted it and say hey would anybody like to join us
and a ton of people I have said you know what I'll take part of that challenge if nobody wants to look Ain weight over the holidays and so there's a website called 100 pushups com where there's a program that you can follow to work up towards over the course of six weeks of trying to get to a hundred push-ups in a row now it doesn't guarantee it but guaranteed you'll be able to do more push-ups then then then right now so today's the first day it started and in our and our PI pledge backer channel which people can join if they want to they can go to pot pledge comm /rd TN and there's a backer level for joining that channel which I highly recommend doing somebody came out the hash tag of hash tag Rd and death by push-ups today was the first day I've posted my picture use the hash tag and then I'm gonna be saving this squirrel gif and it will be on Twitter probably later on tonight okay well that's great y'all enjoy that there isn't I wish I could participate but not going to happen happy to wake up get my car drive to work do 20 minutes a walk you're a fit person don't you want to get more fit maybe back in my 20s and 30s I'm fifty years plus right now what's 100 pushups gonna gain me woman is that going to help me mow my grass better no is it going to help me lift my 11 cubic yards of mulch I had to move this weekend maybe probably can't tell
you 11 cubic yards of mulch is a lot of stinking mulch oh my gosh I'm trying to picture my head what 11 cubic yards would look like and that's a lot of mulch if there will be a picture as part of our splash page when we release the podcast of what 11 cubic yards of mulch basically you know a standard square in a driveway is 10 by 8 right so think of 4 of those covered in mulch about 5 feet huh I was like dönitz like why didn't you just get 15 I'm like cuz I'd probably die at 11 and a half so I'm good here at 11 so I got all my mulch down spreaded so but the good news is all that mulch it's keeping me from having to mow a little extra land and it was free oh well I had I had to pay 95 dollars in shipping and they delivered it for me but it was free because of all the hurricanes there's free mulch out there to be had if you lived in Charlotte they'd have the mulch centers and they post them for free my gosh yeah you can get up to 15 cubic yards it was for a week it was free normally it cost you I forget how much and I said sure hey send me my wake but I did play move the mulch pile it's a game that stuff goes one to ten you can easily get ten people around it it was at a co-op game well it would have been a co-op but unfortunately I was one I played solo which was sad nobody came to join me but that's alright I can deal with that my back was bothering me a little bit this morning but nothing like a good Aleve can't take care of or some push-ups
push-ups work on your biceps in your shoulders how does it help your lower back that's crunches and that's core oh my god okay so we've gone about 20 minutes and have yet to talk about a game we've talked about a lot about Queen some push ups some mulch nobody's listening anymore probably at this point in time everybody's gonna know click so the big-boob acute was this weekend where a lot of people came over to your house and ate some amazing food got some barbecue Thank You mr. Gibbs that was incredible as always plenty of desserts were to be had and I think I snacked on candy corn till I was going to puke it Vanessa put on and incredible unreadable then we have what 17 people showed up for the event and we just had a blast there's a ton of games going on one of the biggest ones was a designer Richard la Gnaeus who designed the original Arkham Horror was here to teach us Arkham Horror third edition which we'll be talking about later but Tony there's a lot of smaller games that we got on the table we kicked off the day by what I was told by our friend Joel Eddy of a drive-through review that here's there's a game out from Fantasy Flight are not fantasy flight but asthma day that is code names killer it's what he calls it mmm-hmm and that's shadows Amsterdam and we saw this at Gen Con it was being demonstrated in and when I walked over here and looked and I was like oh I could see where this could be a code names killer mm-hmm I could see that just kind of high level overview Tony wouldn't you say this game is pretty much a mixture of code names plus Dixit yes I would and also oh god
the one that ignosi showed us at bgg con that they picked up as well the ghost one where you're a ghost Mysterium mysterium thank you yes I would say all three of those combined it's split into two teams just like code names the board is really cool it's like a hex board laid out with a bunch of different tiles with different pictures on it the two people that are giving clues have a little card to indicate which of the tiles are the ones you're trying to get your team's to guess much like code names but the way that you give clues is you have a stack of cards they have pictures and your tray and you give your team a picture and you try to get them to associate the picture that's on the card you gave them with one of the tiles on the board to get them to move to it now if you give them one card they can move to one a Jace hex if you give them two cards they must move to adjacent hexes and hopefully to the one that you've got the cards kind of indicated towards if your team lands on the one that this one of yours hey sweet you got a clue and you market that hey you found one if you land on a X on the spot this is X that's the police they found you that's bad you get a X you get a police marker mark down first team to find all three clues and take it back to the headquarters we'll win that round or if the ephah team finds three Lance on three policeman places then they automatically lose and totally the thing is though this isn't like code names where its back and forth it's real
time unless I'm giving the clues then it's Toni time I mean real time so both teams are playing at once so the people giving Clues are constantly throwing out these cars of their team and everybody's moving around the board there's constant chatter so there's not a lot of down time except when maybe the person's trying to pick a clue to give so Toni what did you think I think I need to play it again because my after we played it you know three times I walked away thinking I'm not feeling the love I was I'm like old grumpy Tony's coming back we don't start off boo-boo Q and grumpy Tony mode so before everybody says how can you not like this game no no it's not that I didn't like the real-time aspect of it I didn't enjoy that I understand it but I guess I have been conditioned through mysterium and code names and Dixit and all these other games that I'm not ready for the real-time world I'm fine in these slow time world I'm good with a you know you like turn-based type games that's funny because one of the appeals to me was the real-time because when you're giving clues you have five is at five ten there's there's a certain number of cards in front of you that you that the clue givers can pick from to give that our teammates and if you pick one you replace it with another card there were several times during our game where both people wanted to use the same car as a clue and like one person to pick it up you know because now they got trying to find another card in its place in order
to try give the clue I do like the fact that actually some of the locations can be won by either team but as soon as one team claims it the other one then can no longer claim that spot for it for one two clues and see I kept losing where my clues were on the in the relationship of the board to the map I kept wanting to count go I've go put my finger over on the board got one two three four old there it is but I knew that would be wrong because that would indicate where it is so I kept checking and checking and checking and I'm like real-time I'm like I'll screw this here's a clue figure it out people and that's one of the things I thought that kind of was a negative to me is the person that's giving the clue with code names you can just kind of clearly see the words and don't have to stare too intently with this game as the clue giver I found that I was constantly looking at the board and pictures and stuff and I felt like I was gonna giveaway where I was looking mm-hmm and and likewise the team's constantly look at the board and you can almost get clues from where they're looking at the board that might can help you out right so with code names it was easier just kind of take a quick glance to the board and then play the game here you're constantly looking the board and to me it was hard to not give away certain places I was looking at which which kind of knocked it down a little bit for me I don't know if it's a code names killer for me Tony I think with a group of people are more ting to teach a game I think I could teach code names quicker mm-hmm I think it would move smoother now with a group of people that I know really well maybe shadows Amsterdam would be a more interesting game because of the whole real-time aspect and everything so to me I could play either
one but I'm not no I don't think I'm calling it a code names killer it's not a code names killer for me definitely it's one that I will I will play at any time but this is one where I would probably normally encode names or mysterium or any of those I am happy to be the clue giver here I would not be as excited or jump towards the opportunity to be a clue giver I would rather sit back and harass the clue giver than anything it was just one of those things where I was like I'm not quick enough and matter of fact one of the things I wanted to bring out is when I saw the other team that was against us get to X's knowing that their next one they were going be out and and how well they were playing I said I'm gonna go into four corners defense or offense here and stall because why do I need to jeopardize my opportunity to win I'm gonna let them screw up because they had the same amount of clues as we did and yet they had two strikes and I only had one so I'm like let's see how well they play this off if they get another one then I'll reenact give me the win people yeah actually and that worked for you didn't like a champ which we were nice way to throw out the obscure sports reference that only a handful of people are gonna get the four corners offense that's because people listen to us and I actually remember when Carolina and they could play four corners it didn't have a shot clock in basketball yeah so there you go that's kind of our quick look at shadows
Amsterdam again I'll play it again I I enjoyed it but after hanging codenames killer it's donek i codenames killer for me speaking of killers I got to teach a Kickstarter that is out right now from shoot forbidden game forbidden games thank you very much for bidding games I keep on to say Forbidden Island that's Matt Leacock game I know forbidden games extraordinary adventures pirates so they sent us that Glen drover sent us a copy of that Simon said hey we'd all like to look at this and I said sure it's a pirate gang next to train games join me some pirates Arg games and I introduce and say guys guess what I'm going to teach you a game and it's simple to learn and I screwed it up because in this Court it looks like it's looks like a racing game there's three tracks on the board where each of you have pirate ships right you're trying to race to the end along the way I guess you can raid merchant ships and collect some and then you can go into a port and convert that that booty just keep going man I'm loving this explanation to do some victory points away meant what I need to do what would my booty are you gonna convert your booty to some victory points so off to the side there's a there's a bunch of victory point tiles and the the resources you're collecting are different colors and the towels might say hey turn in a red blue
and yellow and you'll get three points so the course of the game you can you can run to a merchant ship but especially just cubes on a board collect those go into a port trade those in for one of the victory point cards but the thing is Tony when you go into a port you're going off the main line which means somebody can rush right past you in this race to rush to the end right and one of the things is as you move into the merchant ships or into the port you also pick up additional crew members so it is a quasi semi deck building game where you're drawing five cards on your turn in playing three I think it's a full deck building game I know that it's quasi okay it was fine I mean usually because it had calling so that makes it deck building and everybody starting out with the same decks right okay fine it's a deck building game thank you was it a worker placement game not at all okay cuz we're not placing powers to go collect the booty that we have to take into boards hey so yeah so you're enhancing your deck with the pirates and they give you thing now on the pirate cards of course you have special text that you can either use or the movement value for a ship rule number one that I screwed up I am so used to deck builders ascension just any deck builder where you total up the amount of resources you have to buy additional cards like in Clank from the pool right right and you can spin them however you want right here though when you play a movement card that ship must move that amount you can't total it up and like if you had three twos and say
okay that's six I'll spend three for this ship and three for that ship no can't do that nope that's wrong that's mid game rule correction number one yes it was and rule correction number two which was a big one could have been it might have been yes you score victory points depending on where your ship is on the three tracks that are taking you towards Trinidad which is the final booty port it's the finish line the finish line okay so anyway whoever is first on the of the red track gets sixteen it depends on the number of players gets X amount of victory points second gets another and gets another in the fourth player whoever's in last place get nada zip zero zilch so you add up all the victory points from your treasures and your where you finish on the three tracks and there is your winner the most victory points and I thought it was the first ship along it wasn't the three tracks I said no no no it's it's all three tracks whoever's the father song well how do we figure that out and then Lee Shelton who mr.
rules says hand me the rules and he's looking and says oh wait a minute well it's so funny because all of us were like so why even race on three tracks why not just pick one track and go as fast as you can Nate Bivens who's a designer going this can be much better if you had to race on all three tracks and that was about when Lee said hit me the rules and it was like yes you get points for all three tracks not just one or like oh that makes more sense that's why you don't want to leave two of your boats in last place on two of the tracks so that was an ass ring but overall it's a racing game where you have to balance you know your deck when to use special cards and you know it's a very light game there's there's some strategy in there don't don't take it as oh it's just a quick racing game no you've got to have some strategy on when you want use certain cards some of the special pirate cards have negative effects like I when I was playing with Donna and Rebecca there was one where I could if I land on their ship I could steal cargo that was kind of fun so I could take a cube I needed and rush into the booty port and get some victory points if I wanted to because I matched up you know all I know take a look at it it's out on Kickstarter now see what you think like I said forbidden games has put out railroad Raccoon railroad tycoon and now extraordinary Avengers pirates Ark but there's no argument I just had to throw that in five minutes initiative begins in three
two one all right another game we got to play at bubu cube which I was tricked on was hail Hydra by spit master limited and designed by Nick Metzler this is a social deduction game and I wasn't tricked it was fully explained to me that we were going to be playing a social deduction game and everybody knows my love for social reduction games but I will give any of them a try now this plays five to eight players in the overall objective is this for your Hydra operatives they are trying to destroy a city meanwhile the super heroes who all have a special power they can use once during the game are trying to defend the city by defeating the various villains and the big bad boss at the bottom of the deck Marty social deduction I was waiting for that big old punchline for me is when do I get eliminated but I think you lose that punchline actually the beginning of this yes you do you do not get eliminated everybody continues playing that's one of the neat things I will say about this game on hail Hydra that you couldn't be eliminated so either way I was in for the count on this and I was Hydra and I was I was I believe it or not I was kind of digging this game I don't know what did you think you are digging a social deduction game yeah because we were moving along we were playing pretty fast and I like the fact that you can say I'm Hydra and continue to do things I enjoyed that aspect I am surprised because you aren't a big resistance fan and to me this reminds me of resistance because at the beginning of the game you're either everybody has a secret you're on one of
the teams right you're either Hydra or you're you're the good guys and you're the heroes even though everybody has a hero card some of those heroes are Hydra agents or or whatever much like in resistance you're contributing power each round that can do damage to the boss you do enough damage to the boss you kill him and you move to the next round meanwhile the boss is trying to do damage to the city so obviously the Hydra agents can tank it right because there's negative cards that you can throw in much like BSG Battlestar Galactica game so there's positive numbers you can throw in to help or negative numbers and you just secretly put them in there and that the round goes around you shuffle them up in the revealer more than add up and if you exceed the value that you're trying to hit on the the villain the ball the villain he takes damage so to me is very resistance like even to the point to where after a certain number of rounds you can eliminate people from voting in that round mm-hmm you're not a big resistance fan right so what made you like this one over that one probably the theme and that's pretty much it that and who we were playing with I mean we had a great crew playing this game which helped it but I did see one thing come out from gentleman by the name of Peter re where he kept talking a lot and anytime you talk a lot in a rape of these social deduction games I immediately say hey you're bad because you're trying to throw everybody off and and I guess another thing about resistance games in freshman I was playing straight-up honest the whole time even though I was hail Hydra I never lied once everybody's like well
Tony's lying I'm like Tony I will give you this for a guy who doesn't like social deduction games you threw me at the end of the game when the heroes ended up winning we end up beating the boss and when the Hydra agents were revealed I knew two of the three the third one I thought was somebody else and when you flipped your card I was stunned you played a Hydra agent perfectly I had no clue and we got lucky because in the last round you can eliminate three people from being able to vote that round we had deduced two and picked you so we eliminated all the Hydra agents there's actually an easy win for us another thing that frustrates me about social addition is mark Cal from the scurry report well mark really gave me a bad one mark I had a card that said I had to eliminate all my positives of course I gave you a negative car you full and oh yeah and that's one of the cool things about it is each of the superheroes have a special ability and during your turn you can use that special ability one of them is like you know get rid of all your cards or do something special so every game you could play somebody different I kind of dug this game I'm like you Tony I'll play a social adduction game and I am but with the different card variabilities the way the mechanics work of the way you win the game of one trying to destroy the city and the other not and if you reveal yourself as Hydra you get special abilities then too you can like immediately damage the city so being found out and revealing yourself it can actually help your team win yeah and I mean having a timer helps a lot in this game requires a timer so I'm good
with that 2 minutes minutes you got to get it done you got a vote and all that so yeah for me believe it not you see me out of convention next year and you won't play a social deduction jump on hail Hydra I'll be right there for you go Hydra that's hail Hydra okay fine hail Hydra five minutes initiative is complete
we've been teasing about miniature market.com big Black Friday sale well they're doing what all other stores are doing that's right they're gonna have their Black Friday sales early that's right they're gonna put two thousand games on sale call them round one coming up quick I do believe it's the 13th of November right when this drop so if you haven't already been out to the site you might be a little late there cuz it's gonna be huge yeah biggest sale of the year lowest prices you've ever seen on board games but as always they're gonna come back with round 2 which is later it's all 1122 and you won't have some relief from the map restrictions that's right y'all be sure to check it out because around 1 you can definitely buy them and hold them for a shippi round who comes buy you some more get that free shipping once again be sure to check it out at miniature Market calm as we mentioned earlier in the show we had a chance to try out Arkham Horror 3rd edition from Fantasy Flight Games and we were thrilled to have Richard Lonnie as the original designer of the game to come to our house my house for booba q he came last year and he said come out with you guys and hang out again then we said hey Richard while you're here do you want to teach his third edition he said well yes I do so he sat down with us Tony and told us and ran the game of Arkham Horror third
edition with us how special is that Tony not many people can say Richard law Gnaeus taught them how to play that you know man is amazing his enthusiasm for the game continues you know but what's the beauty of this if you've played Arkham Horror if you've played eldritch are you've got the base concepts down shouldn't be a lot of questions about things thanks sir I hope so I mean there's a lot of text so there's a lot of flavor text going on here but it is fairly straightforward a lot of new things got that big old map that's now modular yeah and that's one of the big big differences in this game is the fact that with like eldritch are and Arkham Hart you had a static board Arkham har was based in like the city of Arkham and areas around it eldritch har was a world map pretty much here you got four scenarios that come in the base game and the scenario cards tell you how to layout the map and basically you you have these large tiles like each of them of neighborhoods with like locations around each of the areas like Miskatonic University East town uptown etc you join those together by streets and you build this map and over the course of the game you can move around between areas that right there is one of the big pluses for me is this the fact that with this modular map is much like mansions of madness and its tiles and or either the Arkham Horror card game and the cards you can have a different set up of the map every single time that you play screaming expansion isn't it just screaming it
oh you think there may be an expansion or 12 could be a few there but all I know is that we were rolling some dicing getting some monster names and then getting devoured is just cause it's a little more streamlined doesn't mean it's any easier and it wasn't meant to be now there was a natural progression of streamlined in business which made up a word from Arkham Horror second edition was Streamlight to a version elder charm and I remember talking to them at Gen Con they said yeah elder jar is kind of like your streamlined version of second edition they said we've even gone even further and streamlined from eldritch are kinda to this one so it's not a direct correlation between the second third edition they're drastically different maybe eldritch are in between those two much like those other games you're going to get an investigator you're gonna have Bill T's for each of those investigators you've got d6 dice that you're gonna roll to try to measure your successes just in basic mode if you're all five versus six you have a success you count the number of successes you had that may make a difference in the game on your turn you could take up to two actions I mean there's actions that you've seen in the past you can attack a monster if it's on you can evade a monster you can move you can gather resources you can try to remove doom from the board there's the there's a way to do that so each of these actions are going to be taking each each round of the game you could take turns in any order and then once you're done much like then like eldritch are we have encounters Tony where whatever location
that you're at you're gonna draw a card from that location and you're gonna have an encounter with it and I did this is what your flavor tax comes in Tony but it's gonna be a little thing of text Reds to you and you're gonna have to test your will your strength your investigation or your observation or whatever you're gonna have to test that roll a certain number of dice based on whatever your stats are and if you succeed usually something good happens and if you don't usually something bad happens let me get this straight I can move I can fight I can gather clues I can up this up that to help me guys focus which is it which is increased your base stat by basically adding another die that you can roll what every time you make a test with that skill check right and then the whole object of the game is to beat down the big baddie and he's sending out people to devour me up and the way I'm doing that is if certain tokens get on him doom tokens then the end of the world is coming if I gather enough clues I can beat him down for a final battle which we didn't see I guess that's how the game ends is that how the game ends yes somewhat here's the thing the beauty of this is with scenarios every scenario is different so obviously there's going to be clues involved every single Arkham game is about gathering clues and in this particular situation you went to a certain location they had clue tokens in the the middle you hope that the encounter card that you were going to have was one of the clue cards you gather that clue and then you could take an action a research action another one you can do to try to move that clue token maybe over to the scenario card
depending on the scenario those those clues can do two different things in the first game you're just trying to get enough cards on that clue to change your codex again here's something new in the game each scenario has a codex setup where you're going to start out with a couple cards in play that kind of tells you some of the things that you're going to be able to do during the game the thing I love about this Tony is you don't know how to win the game until you start playing it yes with some of the other games it's like oh well you need to achieve this objective and if you do you win here you just need to start walking around investigating gathering enough clues now it's the first scenario once you gather enough it's revealed to you oh by the way for you to win this scenario you need to do this I really like that because you didn't know what you're gonna have to do until you started playing so yes I agree with you now I mean for me Marty I'm looking at like Arkham is such you know classic people who enjoy Arkham they're saying everything should we go ahead and purchase number three but I I'll let you answer this because I personally do not own an Arkham game other than elder signs don't you old mansions a madness but never played it I've played it okay I forget I own it because I haven't seen it in a while I'm surprised the iPad can still run it the app that goes with it but either way if our said if I went up to you and if someone were to ask me which one because I have played the original I've played the original with you or two I forget which one we will play the second one second one edition
yeah I would say if you've never played Arkham I believe you should definitely invest in I mean I think it should be in your collection and but I don't think I ever want to play that game with six people I think that for it's got to be for it's got to be either three or four there's one negative about this game that I'm not that crazy about and it's a brand new thing is the mythos bag typically in like a eldritch are you doing the mythos phase there's a card that will be flipped up and there's like icons up at the top to resolve things maybe a gate opens maybe you add a doom to the track it's kind of a a quick thing you resolve it and you and you move on same thing with Arkham part of the card game when you go into the mythos phase each of you pick up an encounter card you resolve it you move on with this game you have a token bag now the token bag in the card game is used for skill checks there's no dice in that game this is a different type of bag the scenario tells you to put X amount of tokens in the bag and they all do different things during the mythos phase each player draws two tokens and resolves them maybe you open up and it's an anomaly we're doomed tokens are added to an entire neighborhood or there's one that says just add a doom token to the track there's a vent deck that's out in in play and you take the top card of that deck and you flip it over and it tells you where to put a doom token the good tokens are clues with the clues you pull a card from that same event deck and it tells you where in the neighborhood that clue is gonna go and
this is kind of neat that clue card then gets mixed in with the encounter deck of that neighborhood so let's say it's Miskatonic University you'll take that new clue card take the top two cards of the Miskatonic deck shuffle them a nut shuffling shuffle those three cards together then lay them back on top so you know one of those three cards on that area will give you that clue so it gives you incentive to go over there and get it there's other things to do it spawns monsters there's there's monster tokens and then there's like a token it just does nothing there's one called headline where you pull up a headline card and you read a headline usually takes a test so you see there's a lot of things that can happen right Tony so with every player resolving to tokens to me the game really slowed down at that point and you're right was six players that means you're drawing twelve tokens out of that bag each one of those has to be resolved before he can start playing again that was the thing I was not as big of a fan of and I mean even with Richard doing running the game for us he was short living and he was doing quick paraphrasing so that was telling me something right there I mean don't get me wrong here everyone it's fun I mean it's a challenge this is a hard cooperative game it is up there with Robinson hardness it is out there it is the next level for your pandemic co-op if you've never played it it is one of those games I think that if your group is ready to move on and you want a challenge plop this thing on the table because you know more goodness is coming so yeah I'm with
you there that mythos face I was getting up checking out other games talking to people during boo-boo cute while y'all resolved it I was like oh hey I want to do mythos first so I can get mine out of the way yeah and see that's the thing is it's just the mythos phase move quicker and elder spin it and then it doesn't this one and the game plays 1 to 6 players even Richard said you know what this game is really best with four or less players you get to do more things on your turn there's less downtime obviously oh and by the way with the token bag once you've emptied all the tokens out of the bag they just go back in the back so you can kind you also kind of know what's coming to you know that oh we've drawn this mini monster tokens out so you know there's like this mini monster tokens left in the back that's kind of good because you can plan for it but still that's the biggest negative me was the mythos token bag which is also one of the biggest changes but with everything else I think I do like this better no no I know I do like this better well do you want to have a discussion with yourself on whether you like it better or not oh no Marty what do you think what do you think with it compared to elder's Harwell more tasks a good question and even though I may like the mythos phase of eldritch horror better yeah going continue morning um I wasn't ever crazy about the setting of eldritch are I did like the idea of it being a world based game I like it kind of localized to our arkham marty i thought i kind of tinder if you I can like the Arkham based locations too so a third edition you've
gone back to it everything taking place in Arkham so with the modular map and it being placed in Arkham I will now play this one over eldritch are Martina those are good points and I can't I can't disagree with that I really think you could probably do the podcast without me so here's the thing Tony yeah Vanessa is a huge sheet of crafty and fan yeah she will play anything that has the Arkham Horror Lovecraftian theme in it I asked her what would you rather play she's oh no doubt leave eldritch are on the shelf give me Arkham and it's part of the same reason she just likes the setting better also she feels the narrative of this game is way better I know you don't like flavor text Tony but sometimes it really does help a game and I think it helped a game here the story is more engaging with those codec cards you have at the beginning of the game that kind of drives the story in those codex cards all are almost like the detective cards from Portal games where you read a card and then it says hey get this card and read this one it's kind of that same sort of effect hey when you flip this card over go grab this card read that card so the story is kind of driven like that which I appreciate but then I asked her the tough question I said Vanessa if you had a choice between mansions of madness and Arkham Horror 3rd edition which one then she had to pause and she had to think for quite a long time she finally decided I think at this point third edition she said maybe because it's newer but as much as people love at driven games she says I honestly like no app involved at all just I just like
cards on the table and tokens on the table and playing that way so then Tony I have to ask this I asked myself I said Marty which would you rather play and granted manages the madness is way easier to set up this game still has some setup time you're sorting card you're setting up the decks and blah blah blah I think it's quicker than eldritch by far but there's still some set-up time and it's longer than mansion's but after a while I get kind of tired of dealing with the app and I'm almost kind of clicking through app I'm not even reading the text anymore so I alright what's my test what's my test and also there's no prediction sometimes you'll go into a fight Tony on the mansions of madness and you don't know what's going to be testing maybe a strength maybe its agility here when you go into a fight it's much like the monsters in eldritch are you know exactly if I want to invade I'm going to be testing costs not it's not agility it's as where the other one was and if you're gonna be fighting girl to be testing your strength and it's you always know exactly what the fights gonna be with mansions you really don't know that so at this point Tom maybe because it is newer I think I like Arkham more no I can understand that I mean you know from my side of it I'm I will definitely put Arkham Horror on the table probably because my setup time is going to be the same between the two because I still have to reattach the monsters and mansions that is one some people may like matches because of the miniatures yeah you do have these super-sweet miniatures those are fun to play with and move around here it's us all card based all monsters or cards are your characters of cards so you don't have that it doesn't maybe look as good on the table so it is the thing if
you're a big Arkham Horror fan your big mansions fan I think you owe it to yourself to at least try third edition if you like Elder I definitely recommend trying it see which one you like better and you just have to sob on yourself which game do you prefer between mansions and Arkham or third so your point about the miniatures there's so many third party me I mean Richard had all the miniatures for the investigator you buy all that stuff but but you're not paying for the mentors on the upfront of this game so you can say hey I can't no I don't like it and then you know add to it as you want to Arkham Horror third edition I'm I'm glad it came out because rich was kind of ready for it to come out he said they've been planning on a third edition for a while and Richard said that Arkham Horror second edition has still made so much money year after year that they just kept pushing it off so they finally got to the point alright let's just go ahead and do it and they did it so Arkham Horror second editions gone you can't buy it anymore it's done so if you have it and you don't get rid of it unless you just think you'll never play it again for me there are some nitpicky things it doesn't really play that much shorter some people wanted to play short really doesn't I think it is easier to teach I'm not a big fan of the mythos phase but everything else I do like more than the other games Tony okay and for me if we're gonna play a game at Halloween I think I'm gonna lean towards Arkham Horror 3rd edition as well as the game for me to drive get on the table fairly straightforward to teach up a level from Elder Sign which my wife loves so I know she will enjoy that and it's fairly simple to understand the various tests that you're needed and I like the aspect of the
unknown on how to win at the end so definitely give Arkham Horror third edition to try and also look at it for any potential sales because it's something you should add to your collection and for the month of October Tony it was the number one selling game at miniature market no shock here Essen is over and Ignasi from Portal games had an incredible keynote where he announced portal games coming in 2019 that he would not really tease here on the show he who had to wait till he got the Essen sorry dumb Tony check this out 51 51 state oh my god did he first date I am I'm losing it 51st state expansion allies you and I are big 51st state fans so that's one will be definitely interested in alien artifacts has a brand new expansion coming out called a breakthrough Oh Tony this is one he did talk about with this robinson crusoe mystery tales yes very excited about that matter of fact i've been seeing on amazon a lot of low prices on robinson so definitely check that out if you're interested in picking up a good copy of robinson there at a cheap price and detective did super well Essen I know all the German copies were sold I'm not sure if all the English copies were sold out and to follow that up he has this first expansion called la crimes I'm excited about this because this is an 80s crime story so I'm expecting an all Miami Vice sort of
thing where everybody's wearing ray-bans and you got your collar flipped up with your Members Only jacket can't wait for that one and will you have your white jacket with the sleeves pushed up oh yeah we're going to the full Don Johnson okay very good then in that portal game stop PL slash Ian and also he announced that stronghold on dad I was almost in tears I was like oh my gosh there it is and here's the thing it's a standalone expansion that's right so for the longest time we thought this was going to be an add-on to the base game this is a game on its own with a brand new board how exciting is that so you don't even need to own the first version of the game if you want to play it you could just pick this one up I can't wait for this Tony this is still one of my favourite two-player asymmetric games I agree with you but I think we've gone along long enough with this portal games PL /e in commercial so let's end it there alright you mentioned it back in Arkham Horror thing goes number one Arkham Harr was number one on the sell this yeah go team what's November because you've already released that video haven't you yeah I think you would have wouldn't you huh huh huh no the video that's released in November where I count down the top 10 list is for the previous month so the one just releases for October because I don't know what the top-selling game is in November because it's not over yet I'm talking about when you release it in November what been in for October I understood that fact over at miniature market I understand that they sent you that and you did you're gone this since dedication which I'm sure that was another good story I'll give you that for October thank you thank you I didn't
write it but yes I know but I mean it was tugged at the hearts a little bit there yeah it was so if yeah if you didn't check it out be sure to go over to our YouTube channel where marty is releasing these videos about Halloween decorations with my favorite guy okay the ghosts I love it goes video some of the Halloween decorations that we had over over Halloween there are two gone Tony like the day next day poof Vanessa's like alright let's take all this stuff down Christmas is going up so we've already got Christmas and Thanksgiving up 20 plus trees getting ready to hit the floor no those aren't up yet but yeah so we had to get everything down on that so yeah if you want to check out our my top 10 videos from miniature market you can do so at our YouTube page roll dice take names and we also post all of our episodes there if you want to listen to the episode online at their YouTube and some day I'll post one for 2018 I don't think I've posted one yet it's up there with my Instagram account speaking of 2018 we're actually starting to wind down 2018 it's hard to imagine we have an annual tradition every year yes we do boo boo q and we've already talked about it not that one okay where we sit there and deliberate over our squirrely awards that will be happening soon but not that one it wouldn't be that survey I'm responsible for would it I think it is that survey you're responsible for Oh the annual survey where we go out toward listening audience and say what do you think can I just maybe I'll just do that one question what are you thinking because
we've eliminated a lot of them from last year look we don't really care how you listening we just will hope you're listening we don't care what US what was it are you doing it through this how are you getting notifications you wanted to do that doesn't matter yeah that stuff stays pretty much static year after year so we actually gonna make this a little bit easier from that standpoint but what do you think I'm liking it so the whole purpose of the survey is just get a little bit of feedback you know did we introduce in these segments this year I can't remember whether we did or not do you like to hear about lawn mowers you know just various things that we just kind of get some feedback from those who listen to the show what they like what they dislike and we take all that stuff to heart because we want to tailor a show that's fun for people to listen to it's also a great way for us to do a contest that's right people the survey will be out there will be on a Google Form located over on our website roll dice take names calm you'll go over there click on the link it'll take you to a Google Form where you will answer the questions it's it will be we're not kidding it is a short short survey and you'll need to enter your email address and we will contact you we are going to pick three count them three lucky winners this year two winners will each receive a $25 gift card from miniature Market congratulations to those winner and a special surprise and for a game that we'll be talking about in a future episode impact the brother of strike has finally arrived
that's right that's right and we finally have the dice game that I've been waiting for where a theme really matters I'm letting it buddy stop laughing we'll talk about on the next show but that's right you will have the opportunity to look when impact however I will say that this game will be cheaper than if we have to ship across seas so this is for our us audience so when I select I will make sure that US resident will get that game and then the $25 gift cards will go to anybody from miniature mitai ice in a bowl is no more it's nitro elements in the universe and I'm all into this theme Tony this is it this is the winner I can't see how dice are gladiators but I can see how dice are elements we won't swap roles here are you gonna stand out for elements in the universe and I'm going to be like well this makes total sense you got elements bouncing off against each other and they're colliding and they're disappearing and you have the Big Bang where stuff is created it just makes total sense okay I'll let you go ahead and believe that where it's simply you dropping dice in a small bowl I mean this is this is the perfect size for cereal this new stadium it's like a black hole you know it's like a black hole you know this is the star the center of the black holes is very small it's very small and dense that's what this is replicating that dense core of dark energy and dark matter where
elements are combating against each other all right we'll talk about this on a future episode we'll talk about this on episode number one five nine which is also our episode where we're gonna talk about Marnie's adventures at bgg con that's right I'll be heading out to be GG con when this episode releases I probably will have some stories to share maybe I know I won't be watching you there sleeping like I did for Gen Con thank goodness yep you and Rodney Smith just laying over there snoring it up meanwhile I'm up thinking hmm how can we silence those two yeah we understand that so big thang so be sure to check it out the survey will go on for the for about a month that's November and December we'll definitely have the final dates in our next show so be sure to enter that if you want a chance at those three items prizes contest by the way if you are a pop pledge backer you are automatically entered in that but we would still love your opinions about the show need to hear from you so we can make it better just whatever Marty have a great time at BG con if you see him there say hi yeah please do I probably have some moonpies if I remember to pack them I think we it's time for us to move on from the moon but people keep coming up to me and say do you have a moon pie I can't disappoint her now I know I sure will be sure to go and get you the mini moon pies those are easier to pack I'll
do that I'm jealous that you're going but while you're there be sure to keep your rolling dice and take your name thanks for listening there's only a few months left in this year's pod pledge campaign where you go out earned ice a t-shirt or a mason jar you can go check that out at pod pledge com /rd team in and don't forget to join our bgg guild one five eight nine
we will we will rock you we will we will rock you Tony have you been out to the broken token calm sight lately they've totally updated that thing yes I have morning it looks gorgeous it's easier to to navigate it looks good it's quicker and you can go there and see what their latest items are like you can pre-order the founders of gloom Haven organizer right now they made that gorgeous Jim Haven insert for gloom Haven which makes sense it's a great good reason to name it that and Tony you actually have that one yes I do and one of these days we'll go get that game back out relearning and play cuz we will do that it's one of those many games but if you're right I shouldn't really get that thing organized so be easy to set up teach okay broken hungers not let me teach games easier there let me set it up easier come on broken token what are you doing that's right and so now with their new fan founders of gloom Haven organizer come out you can now organize Isaac's next big game in the gloom Haven universe but not only that they have game components they have accessories for miniature gaming and just accessories in general like dice towers and paint holders and deck holders so make sure to go check out their website the brand new website at the broken
token calm Oh