Skip to main content
Loading video...

The Broken Meeple Show - Episode 53 - Outstaying Your Welcome

Transcript 1:00:42

you're listening to the broken meeple show a podcast that speaks passionately about board games for the benefit of those who play them my name's luke hector best known for the broken meeple youtube channel and i'm an everyday gamer just like you and i'll be talking about reviews top 10s and just about anything that connects me to board games as long as i have a tea or coffee in hand that is so grab a cup relax and enjoy and remember it's only a game

hi everybody this is luke hector here for episode 53 of the broken people show and it's hot oh my god it's hot i know you in the states have hotter weather and that's why i don't live in the states okay well actually some of you do some of you are in cold areas and i'd probably live there but oh man we've we've had heat waves a lot anybody who tells me that global warming doesn't exist seriously what are you on but lately we've had like the old spot heatwave now we've had one for a few days and it's going to last at least another week my house is a new build so it retains heat like you wouldn't believe curtains are closed this whole place is in vampire mode i am drinking drinks with ice in them i mean yeah you know the ice in there i am literally like i am dissolving the arctic you know so piece by piece with the amount of ice i'm having in my drinks i can't take it it's so hot and humid and horrible so i almost feel like i need a towel just to do this podcast but i'm gonna do my best because heat makes my brain shut down it makes me out of breath you know i have to go do swimming exercise to try and cool down in that i went yesterday which is really nice i might go again today actually but there's stuff to do on the blog so we know we'll get on with that anyway but in terms of what's been happening um the blog has been pretty busy actually the last couple of weeks because i've had a lot of little reviews to get done so most of those in fact all of those are now done so what have i done i've

done viticulture world expansion beyond the base game that's been pretty popular thank you very much uh you know some i'm i'm glad there was no uh so people were talking about the game and not anything else in relation to that one thankfully uh the sniper elite review for the solo and expansion uh that went up and that's done all right i thought it would do a bit better but it's not doing too bad uh the star wars outer rim beyond the base game review though that's doing very well very pleased with that um i recently put up the gutenberg review er wasn't the best of uh games for me it was a bit dull but you know glad that some people have watched the video and i've also put up a preview of almond ray which alicat games sponsored the video and asked me to do a preview for their kickstarter so by means check that out if you're interested in some classic kinicia as i call it and also literally last night i put up a kenner spiel uh wordy discussion video well that it's called kenyspiel wordy question mark but it's the living forest review so the kennishbill nominee living forest gets my express review in there and certainly i just want to quickly mention about that because i'm kind of wondering if i need to change the name express or decide that i only do one type of review and it's always in the format where i'm sat at the table i don't know because the thing is detailed reviews do take a long time for me to do i mean perseverance is one of those you know examples it took me forever to do that review but express reviews don't always end up as short reviews i mean the sniper elite review was over 20 minutes

that's normally detailed review length now granted i threw in the solo mode and the expansion in there which would have taken up a good five minutes in themselves so perhaps in hindsight i should have done the solo and the expansion of separate uh videos that probably would be something i'll do in the future but you know the gutenberg review was only a standard one and that's 20 minutes uh the kennespie the living forest one was about 20 minutes and bear in mind i am including the fact that i have a background uh intros and of course the kianda promo which takes 30 seconds in itself but yeah they don't seem very express anymore so i don't know if that word is the best one to use i don't like the idea necessarily of getting rid of the details format because i do like that structure but maybe i could just incorporate a little bit of that structure in the sat down at the table version because those ones don't take as long to edit so i'm kind of curious as to what to do about that i'm having thoughts i'll be interested to hear your comments on that but yeah it's just something that's kind of been bugging me at the moment not to say that i don't want to do stuff in the other room i mean you know i don't want i want to do less reviews and more top tens and added value content in fact i had a viewer suggest to me trying to do a if you like this dot dot dot series which um i don't want to do on the podcast i want to do this as a proper video series but it's like if you like this game you should check out these games that to me is what i consider to be value-added content it's something for a consumer that is not necessarily

you know not something you would necessarily get on a lot of other channels because a lot of other channels do not do this sort of thing they'll review the new hotness and then they'll forget about the old stuff whereas i want to sort of say to people look you know you're probably new to the hobby and you've seen this great game where do i go from here because there's so much choice it sounded like a good idea and i reckon i could do those videos fairly quick very little editing very little like no need to put a ton of clips and that in there you know keep them fairly simple and straightforward but yeah i feel like those would be good and i'm gonna try this theory i'm gonna do a ticket to ride one so if you like ticket to ride you'll like this and we'll go from there you know i'd be interested to get your feedback when i put that one out but i haven't recorded it yet so uh don't you know get too excited uh on top of that uh there's some more what am i thinking oh yes uh a live stream well i did do the top ten six player games with ninja geek games uh back in june 11th as you already know but since then i have also done the top 10 games we called on with solo play-throughs greg that was a very fun stream yeah we uh got into quite a few like heated discussions on uh that one with uh games because we had very different sort of opinions on there but yeah i thought that was really good fun i mean it's clearly doing a lot better i mean you know nothing against mark you know i really enjoyed that stream as well but you know a lot of people really liked that topic i think the top 10 games we called on uh in terms of collaborations i've only got one more on the cards at the moment um all aboard gamer uh wants to do something with me in the future uh top something we don't

know if it's gonna be five or ten because there are two of them on that stream but we want to do a heavy games list uh we haven't set a date uh we don't know what's um what's happening with that just yet but we are planning to do one and you know despite the fact that they've had some backlash on twitter lately because of some trolls going around it's like you know not gonna scare me off i want to do a collaboration with you guys so uh that would be cool to do uh but also very important one actually this 24-hour marathon i'm doing i want people to uh take note of this this is a it's a oh no i just i just realized that i'm not showing the tv screen for it but don't worry it's not that important um but this uh 24-hour marathon one i want people to take note of this because the 24-hour marathon is something i'm doing at the end of this month it's a special charity event hosted by a friend of mine called dan axey and basically i've done a live stream video last night which granted the first one had technical issues so i had to redo it which was really annoying but basically it's a charity let's let's get it on the screen here so that you can uh see it so hopefully that's going to load up any uh minute now but saturday the 30th of july from 9 00 a.m to 9 00 a.m so it's a 24 hour marathon i will be doing this challenge on behalf of a charity called cots for tots they are a british charity uh set in bristol that caters for like newborn babies neonatal disorders that

sort of thing you know families from others i'm sorry family some others you know accommodation for mothers that sort of thing they're a very nice little charity and this 24-hour marathon has been going on for four years now and they've raised over 11 000 pounds to this charity it's essentially just a convention where you come and play board games but you don't have to do the full 24 hours you can just turn up for part of it as also as part of this they do a big huge live twitch stream uh that goes to facebook live and youtube as well of various people playing games and i'm going to be on two of those streams so i'm there for the whole thing 24 hours i'm going to be on a stream at 11am i believe which will be for art nova so that's not a teaching game that will just be playing it but then later on at 2 30 i'll be teaching i think it's two fridges sorry four o'clock uh i will be teaching star wars out to rim with unfinished business to a couple of other players so i've got two three hour slots effectively that will be on that twitch stream so by all means check out this website that's on the screen here uh if you want the link uh go um check out the live stream video i did for cuts for tots all the links are in the description in that video you'll find them just fine but what i would certainly like to urge people to do is to pop onto this page give them a look give it a read and if you can visit this just giving link here all the proceeds from this convention go to the charities all the ticket sales and everything but they have a separate just giving page where you can just stick in the donation from anywhere in the world i mean american australian canadian dollars

euros and pounds will work just fine but you can basically just make a donation to the charity and you can be anonymous you can put your name down i mean somebody's already put in there saying thanks to the broken people for highlighting this you know if you want to say that i refer jude and by all means it will make dan's day but yeah i would like urge some people just to go on to that link and just give a little bit of cash and i know cash is tight for a lot of people at the moment with the whole economic climate but if you can spare anything for the charity it would make our world because you know i'm doing this 24 hour challenge for this charity you know i'm not just turning up to the convention and saying please donate i'm doing this 24-hour marathon and at the age of 38 marathons like this are not as easy as they once were so it's going to be an interesting one particularly as i've got to teach a game on stream and play and over on stream and if you know anything about streaming guys case in point it's a very draining process other than that in terms of news for the channel i've got some pretty good uh you know top tens on the way and i've been asking my patreons for you know by maine's if you can check out the patreon channel then that'd be fantastic you know i would certainly uh sorry patreon page you know and sign up to that i'd certainly be very appreciative but i'm definitely going to be i've already asked a bunch of questions to my local patreons for topics for the channel as well as top 10 ideas so the discussion point on this channel has been suggested uh by a patreon emily and yeah we're going to talk about that later but i've got some other really

good ideas for discussion for future podcast episodes so i've got some good stuff on the on the horizon for that but on top of that i've also put up a poll and some suggested ideas for future top 10 lists one of which apparently the dice tara is doing this thursday which is really annoying because i thought like oh this sounds different no one else has really done this and then i look on the dice tower top 10 website and they're doing it as their next top ten nature themed games which is a little irritating cause i'm expecting to get some backlash for that but uh you know but the thing is they'll do it first because it wasn't one of the higher voted ones on my patreon actually uh it it will get done i will do it but it was in the middle so it's not going to be a top 10 that i do soon i'm obviously going to do what the patreons want to do but they wanted me to talk about filler games particularly that was a big one so 30 minutes or less they wanted me to do a two-player game series so casual medium and advanced two-player game series so that will take a bit of time to do but there was also a list which i didn't expect to be very popular but i put it on there anyway which was uh i don't think i even suggested it i think uh yeah a different another patreon suggested it but it was a top 10 games i want to play that no one else does i don't think that would be an interesting topic but yeah not to go against the patreon vote but i thought i didn't think other people would want to see it i thought like yeah that sounds all right but let me put it on i don't know if it'll be popular enough but i've been proven wrong that it was the highest voted out of all of them so far so uh i think we'll be probably doing that one next i think

we'll put the top 10 20 2021 retrospective on hold for a little bit and try and get that list out so i need to do although will i survive in the heat is another story all right well that's it for channel news so you know some good stuff on the horizon um i'm thinking of doing play throughs as well just as a side thing uh solo play-throughs but i've got the c-stand that tom heath uses for sucker drips i've got a brio 4k webcam that i'm going to use as the overhead camera now i just need to figure out how to attach the camera to said c stand and then i need to actually play around trying to set up on stream yard and things like that i'm not going to do live stream live stream would be too much but i'm hoping i can find a way to do it but it's going to take some time yes this is going to be something for later in the year but i'm just getting the pieces ready now so that being said we'll move on to the next part of the show which is about what i played so just one game for this time and for this one uh i was gonna i was thinking of doing paydio but then i realized i think i talked about paydio a little while ago i put up an instagram post about my thoughts on it after playing it some more suffice to say i i want to like it but i don't like the fact that it's really hard like i think the difficulty curve is way too high so instead you know as i've already talked about that one i'm going to talk about a different game and that is long shot the dice game so finally i've got myself a wretched copy of this thing because unfortunately the publisher wasn't able to send me a review copy due

to the uh well from what they claim the postage costs from the us to uk which i can believe but the i finally got a copy of this because uh games quest had it for sale at the uk games expo which i couldn't attend so i had to ask them very nicely to reserve me a copy and then for two weeks it's been sitting at the dice cafe and i've been forgetting to go pick it up but finally i got it i learned it and i've played it not the solo mode i've only played the normal game uh several times but the normal game this is a roll and write technically i know it says the dice game although the fact that it's called the dice games is a bit weird actually because i think it has the same amount of dice if not less dice than the normal long shot game it only has two dice in it that's not really something i would call the dice game i think that's a bit of a weird title really you might as well call this long shot rolling right because that's basically what it is it's a roll and right game so why it's the dice game i have no idea but you're also probably thinking well luke you hate rolling rights i don't necessarily hate them i just think that they're overrated and sort of dull and tend to do the same thing all the time but this one intrigued me because i like these little betting racing games horse racing is a fun theme to do as a game and it looked very simple and it was just getting a lot of buzz like a lot of people were liking this and the original long shot took my fancy so what you do in this one is you have this pad in front of you it's all dry erase and you have a bit of money that you know in here this uh dollar bill to the right hand side of the board and then basically you roll two dice one corresponds to the number of the

horse one to eight another one corresponds to the movement of that horse but each of the horses has secondary movement on their cards which basically means that when a particular horse moves another horse might follow it and so you're playing this one lap race but you're betting on horses for first second and third you're buying horses to own them to get winnings if they do come first second or third but then you're also doing other things like like marking off concessions on your board and you know like putting off helmets and jerseys on your board for set bonuses and special abilities uh you when you buy a horse they'll have a special ability so nitro nelly here for example is when you do the jockey action you'll be able to move the horse on the die an extra point so it's got like a few little other bits you can do but primarily you are doing a horse race and you are bidding and betting as you would in the horse race i love the cartoony artwork i think it's like pretty funny it's definitely like highlighting the fact that this is not a serious game this is something that you would probably expect to see out of like a i would almost expect to see this out of a pixar animation or maybe like a looney tunes cartoon or something it definitely has that kind of a feel about it see if i can make the picture a little bit bigger for those it's kind of weird when i look on stream yard it basically puts the screen as white for a bit before it then appears on my view it's really annoying stream yard's starting to get a little bit of a pain but needs must it's the only way i can live stream but with this i have to say component quality top-notch dry

erase markers dry erase pads cool like plasticky cards that you know wouldn't need sleeving uh you know the decent well-written rule book these wonderful like chunky wooden pieces that are painted with the art on them and different weird shapes for the horses two dice the only really the only component blemish in here is that my dice has a bit of an etching issue or an ink blob or whatever on the free which means that it's very difficult to read the free die i don't know whether i should put in the claim to get a replacement one of those i don't know if that's the same with a lot of people but it's a little bit irritating but i it's not like it doesn't break the game it's just like it always gets noticed which is a bit of a problem but i think this is actually one of the better rolling rights in existence actually i think this is a really solid now if you find players who are going to ap this then send them to a different game because this is not a game you should be thinking hard about your turn you roll the dice and you move the horses and you do an action each and they're not complicated actions you should not be overthinking this really it's a we look at the look at the artwork of these horses what part of this game tells you you should be taking this super seriously like a euro gamer it's like come on have a bit of fun but it's great laughs it replicates i mean yeah there are some thematic weird disconnects like the horses going backwards and stuff like that at times but it's yeah at the end of the day it's it's a horse race it feels cool you you some horses do better nurse then you get

some that come from the back yeah you're rolling dice yeah it's going to be on the random side but it's great to have some of these like weird finishes where it's tight or one horse that you wrote off ages ago suddenly starts belting down the track it's there's a lot of cool really fun moments and the game comes with a lot of these different horses sets so you've got normally i think three sets of one to eight horses mine came with the mini expansions from the kickstarter which is kind of weird because i didn't expect it to have kickstarter content in there so there was two other sets in there so i think i got five sets of these horses and i can mix and match them to my heart's content so i'm gonna have some fun with like variety in this game and i haven't even tried the solo mode yet there's apparently a way to play the solo and i'm looking forward to it in fact i will try that later today i've got some spare time today after i'm doing the work because i'm not doing any online gaming tonight uh friends are on holiday so yeah i'm gonna take the solo mode and i'm gonna have to go with it uh it uses this board apparently looks a little on the complicated side but i don't know we'll see i i thought it looked complicated at first just from looking at the player sheet because it does look a little overwhelming at first and then you quickly get through the rules and you realize it's actually a pretty good reference sheet that you have in front of you and it's dirt simple so yeah i'm i'm definitely keen to play to some more i will say that i don't agree with the player count uh it says one to eight players now i don't think that this is a game i'd want to play with more than five players because yes you only have to do one simple action but waiting for somebody i mean the more players you have the more chance you have of some apnes and i'd rather not have to wait for six seven eight people

to do their turn before it gets around to me yes you can do it but just because you could doesn't mean it should i think five is the max i would do this game with i mean five is a weird player account anyway and you could get me to do six but i'd rather play something like downforce or mysterium or something like that you know or a party-ish game if i've got six players so i would probably cap this at five i think it works really great at 304 not tried it with two and i would certainly like to try the solo mode later but yeah you know not the cheapest uh roland right game out there but then for the components that are in it can you really blame it i think it's pretty good value for what you get in that box it's very well produced i mean kudos but yeah i was really interested by this i mean it replicates a horse racing game really well mad mad frantic like unless was it unpredictable races you know bidding buying horses you know quick decisions guessing and gambling you know you might put all your eggs in one basket or you might spread your winnings and that it's a great little game it's just like i say a good bit of fun it's not like mind-blowing or something i want to play over and over and over again it's just that if i've got the players and they fancy like a bit of a laugh or roll and right thing then this is perfect i mean i would rather play this than something like winner's circle because when a circle is not too dissimilar you know you play a lap race and you move the different horses at different times and you bet on different horses this gets that sort of thing done a lot quicker and for a cheaper cost and a more portable product so i would much rather play this

than winner circle but yeah one shot the dice game first impressions very good i'm not planning to do a full review on it but i won't rule it out you know we'll see maybe maybe this one warrants it i don't know let me know in the comments do you want me to do an express review for long shot the dice game i've already given you a pretty decent review so far but i could do a quick express review on this and i do mean quick because i shouldn't need to take 20 minutes to explain this game but at least by then i would have tried out the solo mode and i should be able to contain both in one video honestly because the game is small enough that seems to be the best thing for express videos actually they seem to be good for fillers and small games but they struggle when you have a false box size game but then i don't want to make it a detailed review i don't know like i say you're gonna have to give me some thoughts on that i really do need to sort this out at some point soon going forward because otherwise it's just gonna be in flux and it's gonna make everything seem a little bit unstructured and in my opinion not as professional as i would like okay right well after that we've got a fair bit of news so lots of different games that have caught my interest shall we say and uh yeah i'm we're going to go over some of those now so very first i don't know if i've mentioned this in the previous episode if i have i apologize i'm just so excited i'm so excited and i just can't hide my love spirit island oh yeah um spirit island has another chapter coming i might have mentioned this before but i think we've had an update on this because previously it was just hinted

that there was another chapter so a new proper expansion of spirit island the one that released recently was just reprinting promos that doesn't count i already had them anyway this is a new chapter so the next expansion is ready to be revealed a crowdfunding campaign will launch for nature incarnate this is essentially new spirits new aspects new frets and new powers await that's pretty much all the detail we've got for what's in the game and i'm hoping that the game is mostly just more of the good stuff you know just give me another jagged earth loads more variety maybe one or two extra little mechanics that you could throw in there but nothing too complicated the game's already complicated enough as it is it does not need to be bloated but i'm up for new spirits and new powers and stuff i mean give me that make that deck bigger give me new adversaries to fight give me new spirits i mean i mean the picture here or sorry it's got like little what look like flaming dogs or something you know that it's i can't i'm trying to think what describe them as but yeah they kind of look like flaming wolves also like blue flame rules if there's a spirit that has something like that that'd be quite fun or maybe that's just a power on a card i don't know but they could really do some good artwork now because it has been several years you know artwork's come a long way but here's the news thing it says crowdfunding exclusively through baka kit on october 18th i don't think i had a date last time when i mentioned this october 18th 2022 is the official launch date for this backer kit you can bet your bottom dollar i am going to ask

like so nicely if i can get a review copy of this when it's done failing that i'll just back it anyway because oh my god i want this expansion so much cannot cannot wait now we're going to talk about a game that i never really heard of before it's called precognition now i didn't know anything about this game didn't know it was coming out apparently this will be at sn22 and i need to actually have a look at the spiel preview that's released recently to see if there's anything that takes my fancy not to mention i need to get emailing publishers to actually set us up for interviews and stuff because last couple of years i have not done that and it's lost me out on some review copies by not emailing publishers ahead of time so i really must make certain that by the end of august at the latest probably during august i should really get on with emailing some publishers but maybe even look at the preview and just start now i don't know i'd be curious what other creators have done actually how early do you do it how late do you leave it but precognition use your power as a precognition to save what's left of humanity it's got a really cool cover already i mean that cover is really cool they're sort of like mystical eyes and then the the water sort of landscape the lake with the island the sort of desolate ship in the background it's a really cool title it's from ludanov games who did the living forest i mentioned and it says 60 minute playing time okay good two to four players good it's not trying to ham-fist a solo mode in here and frankly i don't know how you would fit a solo mode into this game considering what it is why am i talking about it on this news well because i

want to highlight a specific mechanic that was involved in this so this one says and i quote here all right so two to four player card drafting game giving you the opportunity to pass cards to yourself to plan for future happenings huh it's like i read that i thought what how does that work well listen more here all right so here you go so there we go uh going down to great river you explore the banks to rescue contaminated humans in a post-apocalyptic world you hire doctors to treat them or protectors to secure the boat from veins to come and try to collect batteries to achieve to activate the machine rooms of your boat or food to feed the new healthy humans so you know this sounds like an interesting theme but let's get to the poi i'm referring to here so here we go last 12 rounds in each round last three phases during the decision phase you have four cards available two in hand and two in your decision zone you will choose one of these four cards to play for yourself and one card in your decision zone to play for your left hand opponent the remaining two cards will go into the decision zone of the player to your right which means they'll play one of these cards for you next term that blew my brain that is something really cool i've not seen that done before this whole idea of passing cards and drafting has already been done and the whole idea of oh i've got to be careful what i pass you fine and we've had a couple of games like gigopolis and that where you passed cards and you're not necessarily certain

you're going to get the card background or dice theme park did that as well but this sounds like something truly unique i really don't know of any other game that does this and if there is let me know in the comments because i would like to check it out but that sounds cool sounds finky for a 60 minute game that sounds pretty thingy so these are going to have to be some pretty simplistic card effects and to be fair it doesn't look like a very difficult looking game i mean you've got your player board boats with all sorts of stuff on it hopefully not too complicated that's the river in the middle which just looks like a kind of racetrack with different terrain looks like it's got a decent amount of pieces but wow that just sounded great i mean during the action phase you activate the card you chose and the card chosen for you using powered machines as well as possible so that must be what your home board is to close the round here or contaminated humans manage any beans blah blah and move forward after three rounds you must feed the newly healed humans and at the end whoever has the greatest number of healthy humans win so it's got a cool theme but that card system sounds amazing i am very interested in this this has shot up very highly on my anticipated s and list now which i didn't have before but i can guarantee you this one is going on there as a top 10. that just sounds like a such a such a cool mechanic i want to check this out now i want to see how this works in practice now i could be setting myself up for disappointment here but uh come on does that not sound cool to you i think it sounds pretty cool honestly all right let's move on to another one so we have puerto rico

not a game i'm a massive fan of it's fine it does the job i much prefer san juan biggest problem with puerto rico is that the theme never really interested me although we'll get onto that in a minute and i never felt it really came out as i was playing it but also i hated these puerto rico sharks i kept finding when i played the conventions you find the people who have played this game so much that they will practically want to bid on the seating arrangement because they don't want to sit next to anybody who's new to the game because they think they'll play sub-optimally if you are like that and you're playing this game shame on you because frankly you should have more appreciation for the gamers but i hated that that put me off the game quite a bit now the game's okay i don't mind it mechanically but i much prefer sound one i think it just gets the same sort of thing it did much quicker and just much easier with the card deck but now we apparently have a new version uh being um i think it's been launched as part of the new relaunched aliyah games line which like you say wasn't the best looking of lines in terms of aesthetics but ramens burger of basically uh based on one or two little articles also ringing and i think there's been some work behind the scenes as well where they are releasing a reimagined version of the game so this is basically supposedly created in partnership with a culturally diverse and represented team set in post-independence puerto rico and doesn't include themes of colonialism you want to do that that's fine i mean honestly the theme of colonialism never really came out to me in the original version of this game i tend to be able to separate myself from these dark

themes pretty well i mean i played this war of mine let's face it you know and that doesn't trigger me you know no i did not get triggered by the conquistadors and viticulture world if that wasn't evident enough you know so certainly i tend to separate myself a lot from these dark themes i don't let them get to me even if some of them i might go whoa it's pretty dark and that might affect a few people but whatever it's a board game it's only a game that's what the the catchphrase you know it covers a lot of bases but you know this is fine a re-launching of a game that used to be number one on board game geek a lot of people like it and if the theme really did bother you then now you have this version i mean it doesn't sound like it's changing much in the way of mechanics so i think it will still be pretty much the same sort of game hence i probably won't be that desperate to grab a copy of it but uh yeah i mean i mean the fact of the matter is is that you can't really get the old copy anymore and i don't think it's going to be a case of well i refuse to get this copy because it's now changed the theme it's like whatever i mean the theme was never a big deal for me in the old one so it's not really going to be as massive a deal for me here but you know kudos i mean colonialism is something that some people do you know are not fans of seeing which is understandable so if it means that they can now play this game and not have a problem with it then you know who am i to argue with that that's fine you know let's make the games you know more appealing to more players and i just don't i don't see how this is going to cause any massive uh you know controversy or anything like that but you know it's what's done is done it's coming out puerto rico 1897 so october

2022 so i suspect this will come out probably around uh um essen as well but yeah by all means give it a go and see what you think you know i think the game's okay average but uh you know maybe there'll be some more fans of it now all right uh very quickly scrolling down actually funny enough i know a lot of this comes from bgg news but that's because uh you know my various sources haven't done any news updates for a while but where stonemars announced a quarter iv 2022 release for the asia expansion for wingspan so yes i love myself some wingspan i even took my dad recently a little short story to bird world it's a little avery place near where i live about 30 minutes up the road and i've never been there before my dad loves birds and i thought you know treat him out to a father's day birthday birthday gift and i treated him out to i bought him a ticket for this and we had to walk around it was sunny day and he had a great time we all had a great time i mean i learned a little bit about some birds i didn't know before laughing kookaburras are so fun they sound like they've got manic laughter it sounds like an evil villain out of a cartoon or something it's really cool but i put up a bunch of pictures on instagram if you want to see the photos but yeah i bet a good time and he really enjoyed it so yeah that's just a little side story of my life but yeah more birds i mean i it doesn't it doesn't sound like there's many details on what these birds will do but they're going to focus on asian birds more birds don't give me more mechanics i mean i still i'm in two minds about the uh oceania expansion for

practically changing half the game system with its new boards and that but yeah i am certainly up for just having more birds and more objectives and stuff so by all means wingspan is probably the last hurrah from stonemaier actually because yeah because everything else after wingspan has been mere or bad for me i'm not including the viticulture world expansion even then i only gave out a seven so yeah but like i say wingspan is still hotness for me okay uh it's quite a bit down there's a few bits on here that aren't desperate for me but i wanted to talk briefly about this one so sorry so the heavy restaurant act up there so french publisher dave wander has announced another standalone game finally i mean blimey days of wonder you know don't seem to publish many games these days although that's not necessarily a good thing because uh they produced ticket to ride in small world two very great games i mean a small world i'm burnt out on a bit but i love ticket to ride still and these ones are just ones that they keep expanding expanding and expanding and basically milking the cash cow you know they could probably give it a rest now um but when they released standalone games they didn't tend to do very well corinth and deep blue or 2019 when they released those two games does anybody give a monkeys about corinth i've never seen it since i i can't remember if i reviewed it if i did it was a very basic one and deep blue i liked it okay at first but that's basically i mean i've burned out on that

yeah i liked it at first but i think yeah after a while it did show some kinks in the armor and nobody talks about that game anymore and even dice tower put it on games what they were disappointed by so yeah uh not exactly the best release schedule so now the same designers of deep blue which is another worry have now brought out this new release heat pedal to the medal which is a very boring title i mean heat would have been fine pedal to the metal just i hate that phrase but it looks like a formula one racing game and you're basically uh in car races jockeying for position across the finish line first while managing the car speed if they don't want to overheat selecting the right upgrades will help their car manage the curbs and keep their engine cool to maintain top speeds so basically i don't know how many laps you do but you've got things like weather road conditions and events to spice up the challenge you have a solo mode automated drivers so you know i formula one is a bit of a boring race theme i mean i like it okay in downforce but it's not like the first thing i want to do in a racing game but you know days of wonder so this will be this will have good artwork in fact is it me or does this look like it was uh illustrated by vincent de trait this does look like vincent de traits artwork doesn't it i'm not sure they don't mention who it was uh who the arts done by but i'm curious because that does look remarkably like vincent detroit's artwork and if so seriously does this guy not rest but you know we'll see what

it's like i mean i think this is releasing later this year so i've got a feeling this will be another thing as well i bet money it's probably going to be on there yeah here we go we'll debut at spiel 22 in october with a worldwide release scheduled in q422 for a retail price of 65 euros though that's a lot of money i mean they're going to give you a decent amount of tracks but it looks a bit i mean two double-sided game boards a bunch of cards some player boards so i guess it can justify that price but yeah games are getting expensive these days so uh oh well i'll see if i can get a review copy of this i mean days of one don't tend to give out review copies so maybe i can get something for asthma day maybe i'll get in touch with kendra maybe they'd have something but um we'll have to see but i'll i'm certainly interested to try this because i like racing games and i'm certainly down for a thing that's like 30 to 60 minute racing game fun but yeah it's kind of like oh you know what's it going to be like we'll have to see and wait and see okay right fine let's move away from news then and get on to the discussion mainly because i'm running out of breath oh that ice drink is so gorgeous i could do it in iced coffee or something like that actually alrighty so a question that was suggested by our patreon early is what exactly makes a game too long for me so i talk a lot about games being too long i got such stick on perseverance about this people say no it's not that long it's like dude it's three to four hours for the second episode and two to three hours for the first one and you get barely 12 to 14

turns i'm sorry if that's not long i don't know what it is but you know i talk frequently about long games and people seem to think that i hate anything that's long not true new angelus over there is three hours long arcanova is frequently a good two after three hours possibly even more if you've got slow players i like the sort of games do any of these lasola games by my head sound like they're less you know short games no mind clash anachrony yeah good luck playing in a short time it's you know there are games i like that are long it's not just simply the arbitrary length that gets it so at the end of the day the question is what does actually make it too long and it's a concept that we use called i don't think non-gamers would have heard of this term but we phrase it as outstaying your welcome when a game out stays it's welcome so what that generally means is that the game is too long for what the game is providing so it's not just the case that it's three hours long it's the case that it's three hours long and it doesn't justify being three hours long now this could have multiple reasons for this but even a game that's 60 minutes long can still be too long for example uh parks uh parks is a game that a lot of people love and personally i'm kind of mad on it i mean it's basically well my opinion is basically just splendor with extra steps and i much prefer to play splendor so i only give parks a five i've not tried trails but i hear that's got the same problem that this one does but parks is a really beautiful game okay not gonna

deny it it's nice it's beautiful and like pleasant but the problem with parks is that again it's basically just splendor with a track that is all it is you collect cards in the exact same way you would do in splendor and you move along this track where you jump on the space grab a little token you trade them in to get the cards for points end of story but splendor i can play in 30 minutes with four players parks takes over an hour every single time particularly if you play with four or five players and i refuse to play this with five players ever again i mean this game just drags on and on for what is a fairly simple game and in that time you're frustrated because you never seem to be able to go on the landscape tile you want because there's too many people it's just too tight so i'll say that i'm not the biggest fan of parks but i think parks outstays its welcome because like i said i can play splendor in 30 minutes this one takes like over 60 to 75 minutes why would i want to play this game for that long i've seen it take 90 minutes for some people with five players that's too long i don't see why you would play a simple game like this for that long when there are shorter ones available but there's other ones like like polyamino games so i mentioned like baron park as uh one of my favorite polymer games it doesn't take too long but it still takes a good 45 odd minutes to uh play the game and it you know that's not too long but if it was any longer it would probably be too long for what it is just this nice simple build a park with some polyamino

tiles on it and get victory points but there are some polynomial games like the cottage garden and uh autumn summer or whatever they were called the ones that we rosenberg did which i think do outstay their welcome i think they are pretty simple games but they just go on a bit too long new york's zoo that ue rosenberg did i wasn't a big fan of that game i thought it was too fiddly you know putting those little creatures on was just such a pain and i didn't like uh actually six i'm dropping out to a five yeah i really didn't particularly like this game so um well it was average it was okay but but this one like claims 30 to 60 minutes yeah good luck playing this in 30 minutes ain't happening unless it's maybe the solo mode but i just didn't really get into this one and i felt again i'd rather play a quicker polyamino game then remember my review i did for alice garden alice's garden the surprise hit from kiender yeah this is a fantastic polyamino game for gateway gamers has great production real cheap and it is done in 30 minutes even with four players this game is done in 30 minutes and could be done in less with less players but you're talking about a 30 minute timer that's brilliant that it's like doesn't outstand it's welcome at all it's nice quick snappy it's a proper filler polyamino game and it gives me the same sort of feel so the idea of like games maybe being too long for what they are is part of the whole thing of what makes it too long so let's talk about some like heavy games for example i mentioned

perseverance right let's compare perseverance to something like uh let's see another heavy game that's pretty mechanical well actually why did we put why did we uh compare it to arc nova because i keep talking about that one so much and oh it's number seven on board game geek top ten not that i care but you know it's nice that summing goods in the top ten but the arc nova game so this game regularly can take a good two and a half to three hours i mean certainly three hours is possible with a four player game and some people might think that's too long now it's certainly as long and narco is kind of on the cusp of maybe going a little bit too long with four but in october not only am i considering like next turn and planning ahead but i'm frequently taking turns so i'll do my build now do me association now i'll do my sponsor and then i'll do sponsor again and then i'll do animals and you know you're frequently doing a lot of turns which keeps you engaged the turns may take a little while they may not but you are frequently doing turns you're constantly being brought back into the game and with the great theme that this game has it certainly helps to keep me engaged now compare this to something like perseverance when perseverance you are playing this game for it depends which episode you do i mean you're talking two to three hours for the first one at least three hours if not four hours for the uh second one and i know i got a bit of sticky on this one but i'm still defending my point here right this game goes on for that long and i know mine clash games typically go on

for that lob but then whereas in anachrony you are frequently taking turns because you're taking action action action action action and the action could be to put somebody out on the board it could be to do time travel it could be to use a worker it could be to wake up your workers i mean it's you know you're frequently taking a lot of turns perseverance has you drafting from a dice pool someone find a dice pool a decent picture of that and like i say the game wasn't horrible it was just the dice pool was a problem uh come on you know any more from the dice see i don't know well i'll talk i'll i'll mention it when i see it but essentially you draft from an action pool of dice and with these dice you take your actions now with these i'll just use this picture here so with these dice you only get so many turns in the game yeah because it works out that regardless of what player count you're doing it as or certainly with four players at least and three close enough you're barely getting 12 13 tops turns in this game possibly less uh it's suddenly around there it's like 12 is an average so 12 turns in a game that's three to four hours no the time ratio of turns to time is ridiculous now people will say well come on you are thinking really hard about your next term well as opposed to every other heavy euro game pretty certain i'm not just tweeting my thumbs when i'm playing any other heavy euro game you know i am thinking about my next turn it does not take as long as this one does this one

also has the big problem that some of those turns you take out the 12 may literally just be take two food that's it because the actions in this game are so fundamentally unbalanced in terms of their time length is ridiculous if you take the adventure uh action on episode two for like going out into the wild your turn can take a good several minutes to resolve because it is that long and a phrase to do and complex and fiddly but taking rations or scrap is literally just go to the spot take two food turn down five seconds you can have a turn that takes five seconds you could have a turn it takes five minutes in a four-player game it is feasibly possible for you to take a five-second turn and then have to wait 15 plus minutes before it gets back around to your turn again that's way too long this is what i'm talking about without staying it's welcome it's this game should not be one that takes three to four hours it should take less time because you're not getting as many turns if this game did take something like 90 minutes two hours tops i'd actually probably like it a bit more but at that kind of length it's kind of ridiculous it's kind of kind of ridiculous now part of this thing is now getting onto the idea of being engaged for a lot of the game and this is a key factor you can give me a long game but if i'm constantly engaged for those three hours then great and don't say it's the interaction between players that does not count that is a cop-out because you can interact with players in every game

yeah so don't use that but let's take another game that i like to play and no one else seems to that could be a contender of the list but new angelus so new angelus is a relatively underrated game in my opinion i think it's a really solid negotiating game uh for in fact negotiation games are a good one for this category because i'll talk about another one in a second but new angelus this game can frequently take you anywhere between two to three hours you are probably looking with six players that this takes nearly three hours to play so that may seem really really long but it's negotiation you are constantly negotiating with the other corporations with these different asset cards and action cards to try and build up this city so it's basically a blade runner style system it's the net running universe but you are constantly making deals with other players somebody puts up an offer you're considering whether the counter offer and then you're voting on which one you want to do you are chatting to different players you know you are doing so much in this game with other players that those three hours just fly by you don't notice the game is taking three hours because it's just so much engagement now you will feel dead at the end of three hours because it will drain you but it never feels like i'm bored i never feel like i'm just sitting there waiting for the next thing because i'm involved i'm interested in what's going on and negotiation games do a fantastic job of this the other one i was going to mention is a unexpected one that i like

is a sidereal influence so dear real oh for god's sake this stupid title suderial confluence isn't that it here we go oh oh this is the expansion but nevermind i just want to get this game on the title come on hurry up your stupid thing so saderio confluence uh this is uh yeah this is like an expansion to it but this game is like insane negotiation of cubes for cubes for cubes and then more cubes i mean yeah it's dry as a bone despite the alien theme that they put round it but i enjoyed this game i thought this was a good solid one i've given it an eight it's you know definitely requires like the same group of people to play with i think playing this with randoms doesn't work so this is definitely a niche title but in this game you are constantly negotiating with other players trying to make deals and you're thinking about your next phase you're trying to decide whether you can go for certain machines or certain objectives and it constantly keeps you engaged for the good you know two and a half to three hours that you'll be playing this game for it's a really solid game you know the only reason i don't own it is because a friend of mine owns it and frankly that's the person i'm going to play this game with otherwise i would probably get a copy of it because i think it is pretty solid but yeah you know negotiation game that takes three hours is not a problem for me because you're constantly negotiating now let's say you had this game with some negotiation but you only had negotiation for part of the game like you had like a phase every now and again where you did some trading and then the rest of it was you know mostly euro

mechanics and you didn't have many turns that would probably make it out stay it's welcome but this one doesn't do that for me you don't get some stupidly long games which i mean you don't even have to justify why they out stay they're welcome like mega civilization this is a game i give a one i hate this game with a passion and i was so excited about this game because it came in a huge box and i thought oh grandiose big group civilization game is going to be fantastic i'm going to love it i played it and sold it to my friend because i thought this game was terrible because what essentially this game boils down to is one giant game of pit that you play for about 12 hours it's insane this game is long you have a giant map of people around the world most of whom you don't even interact with because they're on the opposite side of the map to you so what do you care you collect these cards whoopee doo you don't collect many of them and then you go through this pit style trading phase where these people that you can see here basically go around going i got a free grade i want to give you two of these wood and then you lie about what's on some of the cards because they have calamities on them so you have in fact in fact this is the tag line i'm going to use for this point punishment punishment in a long game also can make it out stay it's welcome because if you're in a game that hurts you from time to time but it's a short game you haven't got to live with the consequences of that punishment for too long and in some games you expect it this game has you trading calamities calamities are basically things that affect your nation in a bad way so for

example i had one where i was playing i think i was playing this race actually down on the mediterranean and i grabbed a calamity at the start of a round bearing in mind minor calamities you can trade major ones you can't if you get one you're stuck with it and this major calamity was a typhoon that wiped out my entire coastal civilization and i couldn't trade it and it was entirely luck of the draw that i got the card this is a game that takes 12 plus hours well maybe 12 hours but you're talking like most of the day you're playing this for like six to twelve hours or so i've seen it go to extreme lengths right and you can be wiped out of the game by a card draw at any particular point screw you mega civilization dumb stupid game but that level of punishment is so bad for a game that takes that length of time you should not have stuff that could just completely neuter you out of the game that easily and not lucky or unlucky in this case be in a 12-hour game and i don't want any gamers like that food chain magnate another one that i hate with a massive passion if you do not play the first few turns of bouting magnate the exact way that you're meant to you will be out of the running from this game for the get-go and you will not be able to win it in the four hours it takes to play this wretched piece of tat and with this again it's so punishing because you're basically neutral out of

the game for you know a couple of mistakes max and new players will get caught out by this like crazy and you're supposed to just sit there and take it for the next four hours no you know if this game was maybe 30 minutes i'll take that kind of punishment but no not four hours you know you telling me that four hours is not outstanding it's welcome when you are literally taken out of the game yeah i'm sure you have fun just twiddling your you know twiddling your thumbs and not actually contributing to the course of the game oh god i hate this game so much i'm gonna get off it get off the find me another page find me another web page there you go i'll take the dashboard of bgg better oh i need some happy kittens that's what i need i need pictures of happy kittens but yeah so yeah that's kind of like a short case for it it's not is the game long that causes problems the game can be long but in summary you've got to bear in mind that you shouldn't have too much punishment in the game that is too long because it's just not a fun experience at that point to be like taken out as what i call pseudo knockout uh it needs a lot of engagement so a negotiation game that's long is fine but something like perseverance where you basically take 12 turns and don't do a lot isn't enough to justify a three to four hour game length and so number of turns is important i mean pulsar 2849 has i think 12 odd turns in the game as well which could be somewhere up it could be bumped up to about 20 with bonus actions but yeah you're not talking a lot of actions in

pulsar 2849 the game is done and dusted in 90 minutes that's an acceptable length considering how smooth that game is but if polestar 2849 took two and a half to three hours and it had that same number of turns i wouldn't like it much at all makes a big difference uh wonderland's war actually um i did the review recently and you know said that that one was too long for what it was well yeah because it's basically quacks of wittenberg with a with an aerial control system in it and i'd much rather probably put i mean i don't i'm not a massive fan of idler game and i gave wonderland's war seven i mean give me a break i'd give quacks at seven as well but i'd rather play quacks because i'll get that done in much less time as long as you haven't got the ap players so i don't want to play wonderland's war for the like two and a half hours that that game seems to take on occasion it's like ridiculous length of time a four or five player game of wonderland's war can take so again that one i made a big deal in that review that outstays its welcome and a lot of people agreed but a lot of the fanboys were willing to sort of jump on the high horses and go no this game is amazing 10 out of 10 there can't be anything possibly wrong with it you're wrong which seriously you can love a game but you got to accept when the consensus kind of says something else so it's yeah i sort of mentioned that but yeah engagement you know punishment number of turns you know how often are you actually doing something in the game rather than just sitting and twiddling your thumbs there's a lot of these little factors that go into outstaying its welcome and it can also be compared to other games as i

mentioned with parks and splendor you know parks is just splendor with a track so i'd rather play splendor gizmos splendor with added steps i've played gizmos i like it fine it's a lot more fiddly and takes a lot more time now than splendor does i'd rather play splendor and i say there's something to be said about short games being quick and snappy i mean the alice's garden it's gonna be a long time before anybody manages to top alice's garden for a polyamino game now in that jonber because it's so short quick and it's a good amount of fun that you're gonna have to work pretty hard to justify why you would make a polyamino game in a similar lineup that takes longer than that what uh codenames names actually i could uh say is outstays its welcome because a lot of that time you're not engaged you're sat there just going

as the clue give a gun yet is it it's boring it's like code games is just boring so you know while you're waiting for the clue giver to give a clue and then you're waiting on the other team for the other person oh you just hurry up and make a decision all right look you've been debating this for five minutes can you just pick a card it's all right drives me nuts so now first contact i get it done in about the same amount of time i get more engagement it's more interesting more fun i dare say that game nah that game can take a little bit longer than code names in terms of play time but i get so much more enjoyment out of it that i don't feel it's outstanding it's welcome so you know you can be longer than the competitor and still not outstay your welcome like i say engagement punishment you know how much are you physically engaged in the game is a big deal so we'll leave it at that anyway i'm out of breath and i am sweating this is horrible i hate this heat i hate this heat so much and this room has had the window shut the car and shutting the door shut so i didn't have outside noise so i'm just uh overheating a bit more so i'm going to take a break now and try my best to cool down with some more ice water and uh whatever i do i wish i could make iced coffees that'd be good but i would certainly go for an iced coffee right now but that's it for me i will see you on the next broken people show on the next episode remember what i said at the start there's some cool stuff on the way uh for those of you that are going to manacon i will be there this weekend friday to sunday not on the monday uh but yeah i'm gonna be there playing games i've got some booked ones some not i'm gonna be bringing a

lot of stuff on the bring and buy like well you know perseverance i'm selling versions of the dark road i'm thinking of getting rid of dwellings of eldervale as well so you know i got a lot of big stuff to sell on the bring and buy but then after that obviously there's the 24-hour gaming marathon so if you're going to that in um at the end of the month in britain then by all means i'd love to see you at it but i know some people have asked if i can go to gen con it's too expensive it costs tons of money for me to fly over there spending only a week there it doesn't really justify the length of time and cost that flight and then the hotel costs a bomb and then they'll be feeding me as well it's it's expensive i can't afford it i'd love to go to gen con i'd love to go to dice tower east you know on the east coast that would be fantastic i would love it but it's just really cost prohibitive when you've got to pay for everything yourself you know so it's a bit of a bit of a nightmare but maybe one day in the future we'll see but i will be at essen so if you're gonna be at essen i will certainly be there and even then that's quite a costly one for me but i kind of have to go to western i kind of not not go to esser so it's kind of a thing but anyway i'll see you in the next broken people show if you want to check out more content on the channel then you have got to recent stuff like my top 10 solo playthroughs uh games we called on by all means check out that live stream and of course you can check out the previous podcast episode as well you know i did debate what i was doing with the podcast episodes plenty of you still want me to carry on doing them so i'm going to carry on doing them take care and remember as always it's only a game bye

for now everybody

Progress saved