Paint The Roses | Best Cooperative Game of 2022? All Time? |Overview & Review (Episode #63)
Transcript
actually leave me to make this very bold statement i think this hello everybody my name is ilya and my name is tyler together we make up coffrey a couple that loves to play board games and smelling roses and logic puzzles what do logic puzzles have to do with roses this game that we're going to be talking about today is paint the roses
check it out well welcome to our check it out series where we showcase various board games to you today we're talking about paint the roses now this one's designed by ben goldman illustrated by jackie davis and published by north star games yeah so what is paint the roses so basically in paint the roses you're trying not to get your head chopped off basically you're the queen's gardeners and you're going through the garden making sure that everything fits the way that she likes it too and you're doing this through placing tiles and once you place all the tiles and you haven't get got caught got your head chopped off you're doing well and you'll win the game but let's take a quick look at how to play you'll begin by setting up you'll place a garden board on the table with the gardeners on space zero queen on space 44 and the white rabbit on the icon between spaces 9 and 10. you will then place the starting shrub tiles on the corresponding spaces you'll shuffle and place the three wim decks above the player board and set up the greenhouse by drawing four random shrub tops from the bag now each player will get six clue tokens of the same color and have to choose one of the whim cards to start off with although only one player may have an easy whim at a time the starting player will get the greenhouse and now you're ready to play and beat the roses your goal is to fill the garden without getting your head chopped off by the queen of hearts you'll do this by placing tiles giving clues and solving the whims of each
other now let's go over the turns on your turn you'll go through these phases in order place the tile place clue tokens guess a wimp card move the queen and then replenish when you place the towel you'll take a shrup top from the greenhouse and place it in any of the unoccupied spaces in the garden this will allow clues to be revealed across all the player's wim cards which brings us to the second phase placing your clue tokens when that trup tile is placed every player checks their hidden wim card if a symbol on the new shrub towel and a sybil and adjacent shrub tile exactly match the player's wim card you'll put a clue token on this newly placed tile now multiple clue tokens can be placed for multiple matches on that tile you're also able to take notes on these provided note cards which can help you decipher some of the whims of your teammates the third phase is guessing of whim card the team must guess at least one player's wim card during this phase it can be any player's bum card including the active player players are free to discuss the whim cards of others but cannot discuss or contribute to your own a guess is only correct if the team has correctly identified both symbols on a wimp's card now if you guess correctly you'll advance the gardeners on the score track the number of spaces indicated on the bottom right of the whim card that was guessed you'll then return the clue tokens used for that whim card back to that player's supply place the wim card face up in the discard pile if the gardeners then pass the white rabbit you'll add a flower token to the queen and move the white rabbit to the next
icon you'll remove the white rabbit from the game once the queen has all four flower tokens the team also has now the option to guess another player's whim card after each successful guess but if a whim card is guessed incorrectly the space ends immediately do not reveal the wim card that was guessing correctly as this is kept secret until accurately guessed the fourth phase is moving the queen after players have finished guessing the queen moves clockwise around the board according to her speed her if the team gets incorrectly the queen doubles her speed now the queen's speed initially is 1 but as she obtains flowers her speed increases by 1 for each flower now if the queen ever catches the gardeners you lose the game immediately the last phase is the replenished phase if you're still ahead of the queen you'll take the following steps everyone who needs a new wim card takes one everyone must have at least one at all times and only one player may have an easy one card as a reminder you'll then draw a random shrup tile and add to the greenhouse and pass the greenhouse to the next player they'll continue playing until you're either caught and lose the game or you fill the garden and the queen has not caught you at which point you will win will your team of gardeners be the absolute best and will your heads remain intact no it's not a schnip it's a coo i guess it's the ship in the cover in there yeah you're trying to like trim that yeah yeah that's true
so overall what do we think of paint the roses i really like this game it's a cooperative game it's a lot of fun and it's social deduction so like i i don't know what more you want from a cooperative game we really like i think so the mix of social deduction cooperative tile placement all the mechanics in this game actually leave me to make this very bold statement i think this may be my favorite cooperative game i think it just does it so like it's one of the best cooperative games i've played it's extremely smooth uh it keeps you at the edge of your seat all the games are close there's moments of excitement is that too bold no that's i can't think of another cooperative game that i that i guess is comparable to it but like i just like cooperative games and this particularly i like logic puzzles so it combines two good two things that i really really like yeah so well speaking of games you can't compare it to that you can't really think of let's actually think of some comparables for paint the roses you want me to go first yeah okay well the first one and i think it also rivals kind of the best kind of cooperative game out there for now all right is the crew yeah and the reason i'm comparing it to the crew i think a lot of the times when i do the comparable section i actually focus a lot on like the feels they give the game the vibes and the feels because i'm very much a vibes and feels type of person and with the crew it's very similar
where everyone has kind of hidden or not maybe not hidden goals because you know what the goals are but you don't know what's in the hand and it's hard to get to them yeah so you're trying to figure out what's in hand and kind of trying to deduce information between you by giving various sorts of clues and playing different cards uh in order to fulfill those goals and here it's very similar your goal is to fill the garden but and you have like a whim cards in your hand that really allow you to get to the inside of the queen but by playing various styles in various spots you give everyone a little bit of information you give yourself a little bit information about everybody else so it's kind of that cooperative experience of let's discover the beauty of the garden together and the crew gives me the vibes of let's discover space together so that's fair yeah because that's instead of actually like going for yeah i like that you like it yeah like it's almost like the opposite but it also like you said gives the same box it's the same vibe so what about you let's see your comparable i went more on the logic side of the games and i'd say a search for planet x i love that game and the reason why i'm gonna say search of planet x is basically those logic puzzles where you have to try and like you get these clues from different uh areas sometimes from the other people that you're playing with it's not a cooperative game but you're using the information that you're given to try and deduce where planet x is and i think that that's what is happening a lot in paint the roses which i really appreciate because it's fun and what paint the roses does
well not better than searcher planet x but it does well is that it involves that cooperative environment so that everybody can get involved and then also be able to like still solve the puzzle in a fast-paced manner whereas like social planet x you're kind of doing it on your well you are doing it on your own i like that that's basically like a good recommendation if you like the competitive or like the game but you want something cooperative you can check out peter rose's yeah and if fifth rows is too cooperative if you want something competitive check that out yeah yeah so now in our beloved segment where we tell you why should you check this game out we go into the depth of paint the roses we're just gonna tell you why you should check it out exactly we kind of mentioned these things but we'll talk about them a little bit more and the first one that i want to say is again it's a cooperative and social deduction game or logic puzzle game and there's tile placement in it yeah so it combines um three pretty unique mechanics together in this great way that i think is really enjoyable and it has like a big presence on the table so it's a lot of fun to get involved with your friends who are particularly interested in logic puzzles in general i think that this is a great game to like segue them into the board game space for those of those people who are like not always there for competitive games this is perfect because there are ways to play this game that makes it feel more competitive as like a group absolutely but
then you're playing against the game instead of against other people and it feels really great and there's no like alpha player where somebody really takes over here because of that deduction element but what i also really like is the fact that there's various difficulties of whims so if you're not feeling very confident and giving a clue and maybe you're just not on par with what everybody else is like the mega meta thinking yeah you can just grab an easier whim or like a medium one to kind of challenge yourself but you pick your own pace of what you want how you want to contribute to this team effort yeah and like of course you've got like the game itself comes with these notepads that can help you like kind of write down your thoughts as you go obviously some the way that some of the tiles are placed like you don't get full information based on like new tiles that are placed against tiles that already have clues on them memory foam yeah so you have to try and remember things and that can get kind of complicated when there's a lot going on the board so these notepads are actually quite fantastic comedies different types of thinking and learning yeah as well so that's really cool yeah so i think the other thing the game does really well is it provides a little bit of a rush yeah because it feels so the queen is behind you this whole time yeah and if she catches up to you game over you lose and it can be very stressful because if you get the car the whim wrong the queen moves double the speed and in the beginning you know it's not a huge deal she's only moving two instead of one but when she moves ten instead of five yeah it can get a little bit
stressful because she hits milestones and her speed increases and it gets scary and then you are like almost forced to like try and make sure you don't get anything wrong or try harder whims and then it gets more and more intense it does and i think you're at the edge of your seat the whole time because then tyler plays a card and i'm like oh there's only two options it could be but if i get like what do i do we have to guess yes and you kind of like take that bold push your luck almost where you're trying to figure out what the odds are and maybe he took this specific tile so there's something like that yeah so that's the one i'm the worst at is like paying attention to what the players like took and what they could have taken because maybe there's not a better option out there so you're just trying to make do i think the last thing that i would touch on is the modules that it comes with so that's expansion expansions yeah i guess they're not modules but they're just like you can play the game with um queen cards and then a character card that you pick from essentially and that's a lot of fun because they add new elements to the game and you're basically trying to collect five keys right to basically get freedom so you don't have to always serve the queen yeah but i think what it does really need is it once you've played the game a lot of times you kind of get used to the strategy and it's very similar so this kind of flips the game on its head so now it gives the queen certain abilities like if you play a purple or a yellow flower she'll move more so you're trying to avoid giving those hands but also the various helper cards allow you to kind of help out as well and they're
different characters from the wonderland world and yeah i think it definitely elevates the game quite a bit yeah and it's like a different way to win the game right like the rabbit for example is a timed one so you have to do it as fast as you possibly can 20 minutes that's stressful but there are other ones that are not so stressful you should have to create patterns within the garden or something along those lines and it's really really fun so it throws different kicks and mechanics into this already great game exactly so now that we've told people why they should check it out why should they not check it out they should well in all seriousness i think a reason that you shouldn't check the game out is uh if you don't like those if you fall off once you attach your seat and don't like those types of experiences this game can be very stressful because a lot of the time a lot of the pressure can be put on you as the clue giver because maybe just the way the circumstance works all of a sudden whatever tyler does we win or lose the game and sometimes in some friend groups and sometimes in some scenarios that can be tension that can be pressure that can be pressure you don't want on yourself so if you're not inclined to have that maybe this game isn't for you yeah that's a good point i think um there are definitely moments where you can get absorbed as like the center of attention and it can be kind of uncomfortable to have to make those decisions and calls so but hopefully you have supportive friends to help you and i mean also remember that it's a game because like i know that there's been some some times where none of the tiles
have come up and worked for me and it just feels really bad so i guess like if that's something you want to avoid don't check this one out so i actually want to talk about a point that you brought out in why people should check it out okay it's kind of that alpha gaming thing and i think this kind of is in the same vein maybe slightly different okay but i think like if you're playing in a certain group and there are two or three people that really dr jive well like they're on the same wavelength and then you just for some reason cannot get on to that wavelength the game feels like you feel pretty left out and then you can't you feel as if like you can't provide enough information for these people you're kind of just like sitting there knowing that they're going to figure it out and i think like it isn't alpha gaming it isn't but it almost feels like a sub category yeah i hear you saying so i think like to me it sounds like if people are very experienced in this game and already have set like a culture of how they play some like maybe like it is a known fact you have to not consider what they're not taking and that's a clue in itself and you're coming in and you've never played this game and all of a sudden you see people doing this and you play a towel and someone's like oh it can't be this because she did that yeah and then all of a sudden it is yeah and you're like oh he just said it can't beat that but it is no so i think yeah there's there's almost like a culture this game creates although i think it is it isn't as
exclusionary because i think you can catch on uh and it provides a lot of opportunities but it can't create those moments for sure yeah yeah it's just something to be aware of it yeah it does suck when there's like four people around the table and you're just like i don't know what to say i want survive yeah it's here somewhere else i think the last thing i will say is the paralysis by analysis piece because you have so many options of where to put your tile the your tile placement affects everybody else's clues the way that you put it could potentially lead to a situation where like oh why didn't you put it there she must have put it there for this specific reason so i think because of all of those elements combined uh sometimes it's hard to make a decision so sometimes you will have paralysis by analysis and if you're prone to that where you have friends that are prone to that this could be a very long game yeah that's true so that's another reason if you but that's a good point yeah but i think it also is a great way and on the other side of it i guess it helps you make those decisions faster and builds that skill set as well yeah i just imagine like in my situation like i like will watch somebody place a tile and then i'll over think about it and then i'll be like oh they they could have done this they could have done that but on the other side of it that person is just like no i didn't even think about that i was just putting it here because that's always because i just go here and everyone's like well he couldn't have meant that yeah yeah so so like it's just something to be aware of yeah absolutely and me and that's part of the game right like it it's just how those logic puzzles
kind of work and if that's not how you vibe with games or want to play a game that's like that then paint the roses probably might not be a game for you you might want to sniff the roses instead so overall what do you think really fun game i like it it's fast it's quick it's easy to teach there's a lot going on and it's fun i like solving logic puzzles i can't wait to keep introducing this game to everybody i think it definitely has a huge place in my heart and if you're a cooperative game lover this is i want to even say definitely try it out because yeah it will win you over as it hasn't won my heart queen of hearts off with your heads off off your hands so for our question of the day we have if you could be royalty in any of the suits in a card game what suit would you pick and and why i guess i would pick clubs i feel like clubs are often misunderstood i guess yeah you could say the same it for diamonds too no diamonds are very understood they're almost square forever nailed it nailed it is that what you would be no i would i don't think i would be diamonds i think i'd probably just be spades why um space is upside down heart do you have upside down heart yeah i just like i used to play hearts all the time and keeping the queen of spades is just like not not something you're supposed to do and if you win it it's like if you win the trick with the queen of spades it's like not good so but did you play spades
all the time no i didn't play space all the time so i don't have as much of an appreciation for spades i guess so that's why i would pick the royalty so you'd want to be something you don't appreciate that i don't understand it's not that i don't appreciate them okay well let us know your answer down in the comments below and you know what to do hit that subscribe button hit that thumb up help us by commenting on the video and engaging with our content because it helps all those magical algorithms bring more people into our fold exactly we love having chats with you folks about board games and we always enjoy chatting with you no matter what it is yeah and if you played paint the roses let us know tell us what you think is it your favorite cooperative game is that the best cooperative game is there one out there that rivals it i must play who knows but until then good boy this is us checking out we already said goodbye you